Museado / NARA Collection grf-0193 — Collection grf-0193
Recent Folios
Login Register
English español (Spanish) magyar (Hungarian)

Survos folio item chat

Back to Panel A Dispositions

Ask the Scholar

Document scope · 1 page
doc
Scholar
Ask about this object, its catalog metadata, its source description, or the page inventory. For page-specific OCR and visual context, open one of the page chats.

Scholar Source Context

Document identity
localId
1506019
label
Panel A Dispositions
core
doc
dtoType
document
citationUrl
https://catalog.archives.gov/id/1506019
pageCount
1
Source metadata
id
1506019
sourceUrl
https://catalog.archives.gov/id/1506019
contentType
document
title
Panel A Dispositions
citationUrl
https://catalog.archives.gov/id/1506019
collections
Charles E. Goodell Papers
Presidential Clemency Board Subject Files
subjects
Amnesty
iiifBase
https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0193/648291/1506019.pdf
thumbnailUrl
https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0193/648291/1506019.pdf
largeImageUrl
https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0193/648291/1506019.pdf
imageCount
1
hasImages
yes
source
import
hasTranscription
no
Source extras
url
https://catalog.archives.gov/id/1506019
naId
1506019
coverageEndDate
logicalDate
1975-05-31
month
5
year
1975
coverageStartDate
logicalDate
1975-04-01
month
4
year
1975
levelOfDescription
fileUnit
recordType
description
ocrSource
nara-archive
Single page context
seq
1
pageIndex
0
type
document
url
https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0193/648291/1506019.pdf
mediaId
7d8f7e810dac88a8
ocrText
The original documents are located in Box 8, folder "Panel A Dispositions" of the Charles E. Goodell Papers at the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library. Copyright Notice The copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the making of photocopies or other reproductions of copyrighted material. Charles Goodell donated to the United States of America his copyrights in all of his unpublished writings in National Archives collections. Works prepared by U.S. Government employees as part of their official duties are in the public domain. The copyrights to materials written by other individuals or organizations are presumed to remain with them. If you think any of the information displayed in the PDF is subject to a valid copyright claim, please contact the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library. Digitized from Box 8 of the Charles E. Goodell Papers at the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library 5/8/9h, FORD Panel A Dispositions is SERALD 70 cases (2 upgrades) Thurday Panels 5/10/75 A. Goodell Walt Morrow Riggs Craig B. Dougovito O' Connor Ford Everhard C. Maye Adams Puller Agnich Lally Friday and Saturday Panels 5/11 - 12/75 never used, Panel W Goodell Walt Lally Everhard Panel X Dougovito Puller Morrow (absent Saturday) Riggs Everhard Panel Y Maye Adams Craig Ford O'Connor T Adams Panel Z (O' Connor Ford Agnich Craig May 9 BOARD DECISIONS BY PANEL DECISION: A B C TOTALS Pardon 35 40 47 122 / 3 a/s 1 16 10 27 6 a/s 2 4 4 10 9 a/s 1 1 4 6 10 a/s 0 1 0 1 12 a/s 3 3 1 7 18 a/s 0 0 0 0 24 a/s 0 1 0 1 Full Board 5 8 0 13 Tabled 1 0 1 2 *Other 1 0 0 No Clemency 2 TOTAL 51 76 is 67° GERALD BOARD DECISIONS BY PANEL DECISION: A B C TOTALS Pardon = 24 41 109 3 m/w 9 6 8 23 6 a/s 4 5 2 11 9 a/s 1 1 0 2 12 a/s 3 0 0 3 N/C 9 1 0 10 Referred o 9 2 11 to full board Tabled 0 2 0 2 TOTAL 70 48 53 MAY 8, 1975 PANEL A B C DATE 8th 9th TOT 8th 9th TOT 8th 9th TOT DISPOSED 70 42 112 37 68 105 51 66 117 TABLED, FULL BOARD, OR OTHER 7 7 11 8 19 2 1 3 119 124 120 "BAD CASES" 5 8 4 (Lenient) (2) (3) (2) (Severe) (3) (5) 1 (2) % of Dispositions 4.5 7.6 3.4 PANELS A B C Pardons 79 70.5% 64 60.9% 88 75.1% 3 Mos. A/S 10 8.9% 22 20.9% 18 15.4% 6 Mos. A/S 6 5.3% 9 8.6% 6 5.1% 9 Nos. A/S 2 1.7% 2 1.9% 4 3.4% 10 Mos. A/S 1 .9% . 12 Mos. A/S 6 5.3% 3 2.8% 1 .8% 18 Mos. A/S 1 .8% 24 Mos. A/S 1 .9% NO CLEMENCY 9 8.0% 3 2.8% CIVILIAN MILITARY Pardosn 162 85.2% 64 46.7% 3 Mos. A/S 19 10.0% 30 21.9% 6 Mos. A/S 4 2.1% 14 10,2% 9 Mos. A/ S 1 .5% 7 5.1% 10 Mos. A/S 1 .7% 12 Mos. A/S 2 1.4% 8 5.8% 18 Mos. A/S 1 .7% 24 Mos A/S 1 .7% NO CLEMENCY 2 1.4% 11 8.0% PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY Leans THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON, D.C. 20500 May 6, 1975 MEMORANDUM TO Deputy Associate General Counsels FROM : = John Foote for SUBJECT : Panels for Board Meetings, May 8 and 9 BOARD MEETING - THURSDAY, May 8th: Panel A Panel B Panel C Goodell Dougovite Maye Walt 0' Connor Agnich Morrow Ford Adams Riggs Everhard Lally Craig Puller BOARD MEETING - FRIDAY, May 9th: Panel W Panel X Panel Y Goodell Dougovite Maye Walt Morrow Adams Everhard Puller Ford Lally Huson R-Cons Panel Z Hesburgh (pm) 0' Connor Agnich # Craig R-mod, 1000 Healwagh Riggs (p.m) PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD DECISIONS TO DATE Military Civilian Pardon and Upgrade 21 Pardon 91 ( 3) 85 (17) Alternative Service 1-3 Mos. 92 (13) 37 ( 3) 4-6 Mos. 69 ( 6) 30 (6) 7-9 Mos. 23 ( 3) 6 ( ) 10-12 Mos. 13 ( 4) 8 ( 5) 13-24 Mos. 2 ( ) 5 ( ) Commutation of Sentence 0 ( ) 2 ( ) No Clemency 9 ( ) 2 ( ) TOTAL 320 (29) 175 (36) . Tabled Cases 13 3 *Numbers in parenthesis indicate Cases announced by President. 36.5 495 - 5/8/9/10 860 FORD Handwerger 5/8/75 1 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET P P 9moo 3MAR 6mos #777 #561 #772 #1234 #5002 I. Baseline 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. X X 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant X committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X X X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length X X 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. #777 #561 page two 4/24/75 #972 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #1234 #3007 III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) 2. Personal and immediate family X X problems. 3. Mental or physical condition 4. Employment or other activities X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable 5½ms 2grstme 9mos (weak) military service. 7. Tours of service in the war zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal X or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on precedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military X X conduct and proficiency , or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 2 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET 3moo P P P P I. Baseline 3010 #940 #969 #972 #1036 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. 1 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses XW 9. AWOL/UA of extended length X+ 10. Failure to report for X overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education XW Xw or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) 3010 #940 #969 #972 #1036 2. Personal and immediate family X problems. 3. Mental or physical condition 4. Employment or other activities X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability X 6. Extended period of creditable lyrams military service. 7. Tours of service in the war zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on precedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted X X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X X X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military X conduct and proficiency , or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: Lunch P 4/24/75 3 3 mot PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET P P 3mot #1311 #1313 #1308 I. Baseline #1044 #1266 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant X w committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill X alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses 9. AWOL/UA of extended length 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #1044 #1266 41311 #1313 #1308 2. Personal and immediate family X problems. 3. Mental or physical condition X 4. Employment or other activities X X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable military service. 7. Tours of service in the war zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on precedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted X XW X w X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X { X x authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military conduct and proficiency, or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 4 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #1054 #1090 #1230 #1236 #1238 I. Baseline P P P 3mos P 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time 24 Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the above. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length xw X 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education XW or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #1054 #1090 #1230 #1236 #1238 P 2. Personal and immediate family X + X problems. 3. Mental or physical condition X 4. Employment or other activities of service to the public 5. Service connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable 2 1/3yrs 7 nos 1yr. military service. 7. Tours of service in the war X zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal XW or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on precedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X ? Z / authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military XW conduct and proficiency , or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: walt. 4/24/75 5 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #1390 #3013 #3014#1309 #1374 I. Baseline 3mos 3mos N.C. P N.C. 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. X X x 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. X 5. Evidence that applicant * X X committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. GERALD 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X X X X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education X X x 22 or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #1390 #3013 #3014 #1309 #1374 2. Personal and immediate family XW problems. 3. Mental or physical condition 4. Employment or other activities X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable 9 mos Daws 1yr 4ms 7 mos military service. 7. Tours of service in the war X zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on precedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to # X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military XW XW X conduct and proficiency , or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 6 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #3029 #1192 #1784 #1930 #3261 I. Baseline N.C. P A/S 12mos 3mos 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. X 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant # collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant x X committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length X 8 mgs 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education ? or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #3029 #1192 #17841930 #3261 III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) 2. Personal and immediate family problems. 3. Mental or physical condition X 4. Employment or other activities X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable 1yr tma 8mos military service. 7. Tours of service in the war zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on procedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted X X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X ? 7 , authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military X conduct and proficiency, or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 #7 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #1931 V.A, #3180 #3478 #3494 #3528 I. Baseline P N.C P P P 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to umprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. $ X X 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant $ X committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses # X X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length X X 10. Failure to report for XW overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #1931 #3180 #3478 #3494 #3528 2. Personal and immediate family ? X problems. 3. Mental or physical condition X 4. Employment or other activities X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable X 2grs military service. 7. Tours of service in the war X X zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal X or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector X status on procedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 2 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X X , authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, X or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military X X conduct and proficiency , or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor X 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 # PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #3533 #3538 #3733 #3731 #3531 I. Baseline 12mH P P Q M.C. 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. X+ X X 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant Xt X committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses QX X X X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length 2 moo 1½ 4mH Two 14 days 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education XV or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #3533 A338 #3733 #3737 #3531 2. Personal and immediate family X problems. 3. Mental or physical condition 4. Employment or other activities of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable 1 ye 7 mos X3gola. 2 yrs 8ms Tyrla 12 yrs military service. 22mot 7. Tours of service in the war X X X zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal XW X or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on precedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental X stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, X X or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military X X X X X conduct and proficiency, or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 # 9 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #3015 #3016 #3039 #3042 #938 I. Baseline N.C. N.C P P P 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the above. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. ? 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant X committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length 4½ms 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education X or ability to understand 16 obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #3015 #3016 #3039 #3042 #938 2. Personal and immediate family problems. 3. Mental or physical condition XW 4. Employment or other activities X X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable 2mD military service. 7. Tours of service in the war zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector X status on precedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted x X X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military conduct and proficiency , or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 #10 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #1296 #3001 #3007 #3008 #1386 I. Baseline P P N.C. P 6mos 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time 45 126 Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 23 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. X 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant X X committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education XW or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #1296 #3001 #3007 #3008 #1386 2. Personal and immediate family problems. 3. Mental or physical condition 4. Employment or other activities X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable military service. 7. Tours of service in the war zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on procedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted x XW x for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X Q X X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military X conduct and proficiency , or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 #11 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET #1319 #1377 #3030 #8032 S#3033 I. Baseline P P P 17mg N.C. 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time 18 Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the above. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. X X X 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant X X committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X X X y 9. AWOL/UA of extended length X2abys XW 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education X or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #1319 #1377 #3030 #3032 #3033 2. Personal and immediate family X problems. 3. Mental or physical condition 4. Employment or other activities X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability X 6. Extended period of creditable 1yr 1gr 7½ms 1 yr 3ms. military service. 7. Tours of service in the war x X zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal X or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on procedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental X stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military x X x conduct and proficiency , or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 12 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET # 3473 #3177 #3169 #3489 #3318 I. Baseline P P P P P 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time 7 12 Months served. 12 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, 0 Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant KW committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X X X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length 15 X 12mg 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education X or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #3473 #3177 #3169 #3489 #3318 2. Personal and immediate family problems. 3. Mental or physical condition X 4. Employment or other activities X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable bms 42gs3ms 1 / 2 yrs military service. 7. Tours of service in the war X zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal XW X or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on procedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted x X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental X stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military X X conduct and proficiency, or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET P 13 P 3376 # #3204 #3273 3396 #5374 I. Baseline P V.A. 3377 P D.D, 6mos 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. 3 Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desertion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant X committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length XW 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education X or ability to understand obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) #3201 #3273 3396 3376 #3377 2. Personal and immediate family problems. 3. Mental or physical condition 4. Employment or other activities 4 of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable X military service. 7. Tours of service in the war X zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal X or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on precedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted X X X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, X or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military X conduct and proficiency , or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor X 16. Wounds in combat X Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: 4/24/75 14 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET # # # A # 3380 3384 3385 3392 3374 I. Baseline 6ms. P p P 3mox 1. Starting point 24 24 24 24 24 Months 2. Less three times prison time Months served. 3. Less alternative service Months performed, if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 4. Less time served on probation Months or parole if entire period is satisfactorily completed. 5. Judge's sentence to imprisonment, Months if less than the acove. 6. Three months minimum alternative Months service. Conclusion: Baseline amount of 3 3 3 3 3 Months alternative service II. Aggravating Circumstances Additions to length of alternative service 1. Other criminal convictions. X w 2. False statement to the Presidential Clemency Board by applicant. 3. Use of force by applicant collaterally to AWOL, de- sertion, or missing move- ment, or civilian draft evasion offense. 4. Desettion during combat. 5. Evidence that applicant X x committed offense for obviously manipulative and selfish reasons. 6. Prior refusal to fulfill alternative service. 7. Violation of probation or parole. 8. Multiple AWOL/UA offenses X X 9. AWOL/UA of extended length 5ms. 1 yr 2,as x3po 10. Failure to report for overseas assignment. III. Mitigating Circumstances Subtractions from length of alternative service 1. Lack of sufficient education X or ability to understand 28 obligations or remedies available under the law. page two 4/24/75 PRESIDENTIAL CLEMENCY BOARD WORK SHEET III. Mitigating Circumstances (continued) 3380 3384 3385 #3392 3374 2. Personal and immediate family problems. 3. Mental or physical condition 4. Employment or other activities X of service to the public 5. Service-connected disability 6. Extended period of creditable 4ma, 2½gs 10ma military service. 7. Tours of service in the war x zone. 8. Substantial evidence of personal or procedural unfairness. 9. Denial of conscientious objector status on precedural, technical or improper grounds. 10. Evidence that an applicant acted X X for conscientious, not for mani- pulative or selfish reasons. 11. Voluntarily submitted himself to X x X authorities 12. Behavior which reflects mental X stress caused by combat. 13. Volunteering for combat, or extension of service while in combat. 14. Above average military X conduct and proficiency, or unit citations. 15. Personal decorations for valor 16. Wounds in combat X Total months subtracted from baseline because of mitigating circumstances: IV. Summary 1. Baseline alternative service 2. Amount added because of aggra- vating circumstances. 3. Amount subtracted because of mitigating circumstances. Recommendation to President: