Letter to the President from the Secretary of the Interior

This item includes a letter in which a printed booklet transmits the report of Colonel Charles Bonaparte and Clinton Woodruff regarding public service in Indian Territory.

Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 26
26 ABUSES AND IRREGULARITIES, INDIAN TERRITORY. ABUSES AND IRREGULARITIES. INDIAN TERRITORY. 27 Indian Territory, which is now in process of allotment in severalty, became absolutely and for all purposes except that of alienation the allotment in severalty and the dissolution of the tribal relations have property of the respective tribes. been ratified by all the Indian nations, and although it may be that It seems clear that in dealing with these lands the Government was, a majority of the legal members of these tribes were in favor of the and is still, bound in honor and conscience to consider, first of all and change, the wishes of the true Indians were altogether different. In beyond all, the interest of the Indians; that it had, and has now, no the language of the Indian witness already quoted- right to subordinate this interest to any other end, however desirable If we had our own way we would be living with lands in common, and we would in itself; and that the welfare of white settlers, however numerous or have these prairies all open, and our little bunches of cattle, and would have bands deserving, the development of the resources of the country, and other of deer that would jump up from the heads of every hollow, and flocks of turkeys running up every hillside, and every stream would be full of sunperch. Those public benefits can be properly regarded in disposing of them only if, things were what we were used to in our early life; that is what we would have, and insofar as, the safety and happiness of the rightful owners of and, I think, most of the people would have, and not so much corn and wheat grow- these lands will be thereby advanced. ing, and things of that kind; but we have come up against it; this civilization came These principles of justice and fair dealing were fully recognized up against us and we had no place to go. in the several acts of Congress under which the work of allotment is We fully agree with the witness that this fact strengthens their in progress, but the results attained are in some respects startling and claim on the Government for protection against the evils attendant on deplorable. More than four-fifths of the inhabitants of the Territory a policy thus imposed upon them; for, in his words: "This change is have no connection whatever with any of the tribes recently owning not of our creating, it is the Government's; if we err, it is the Gov- the soil; they are white men, with a small percentage of negroes, ernment's duty to guide us." In view of these facts it is not surpris- attracted from various States of the Union by hopes of cheap land or of ing that profound discouragement and a feeling akin to despair should remunerative employment, and for whom the rights of the Indian are be widely prevalent among the genuine Indians. Comparatively few merely an impediment to the development of the country. At least complaints are heard from this part of the population; usually they three-fourths of the remainderare Indians in little more than name, with grieve and pine in silence; but we believe there is grave danger lest, from 75 to 99 per cent of white blood, and, in great majority, altogether within the space of a generation, all that will remain of the Indians indistinguishable in appearance, language, and manners from white to whom the United States solemnly guaranteed the perpetual enjoy- people, or else negroes, former slaves, or descendants of former slaves ment of their lands, as well as protection "from domestic strife, from of the Indians, freed by the results of the civil war, with, in some hostile invasion, and from aggression by other Indians and white per- cases, a certain admixture of Indian blood, but, in the main, identical, sons in opposition to their jurisdiction and laws," may be a few thou- physically, mentally, and morally, with the colored population of our sand hopeless and degraded paupers and vagrants, objects of contempt- Southern States. uous charity in the country thus assured to their ancestors 'forever. The few remaining inhabitants, scarcely one-twentieth of the whole- While this danger constitutes the most lamentable and alarming the real Indians who have remained Indians-are rapidly decreasing in feature of the existing situation in the Territory, it must be added numbers, dying, not, in most cases, from disease or vice, but, in the that the profound discontent existing among its white population is a striking and pathetic words of one of them who testified before us, source of very reasonable regret. The settlers are energetic Ameri- "for want of hope;" or, in other words, because their present envi- cans, accustomed to self-government in the communities from which ronment is so unsympathetic, and the impossibility for them to hold they have removed, and they are vexed and impatient to find them- their own in the competition to which they are already exposed, and selves without voice in either making or administering the laws which which will grow more severe every day hereafter, is so manifest that govern them in their new home. This fact we believe is the main the future holds out to them no prospect which makes life worth liv- cause of the credulous and uncharitable character of public opinion in ing. One of the witnesses examined before us, a man of life-long the Territory. We were painfully impressed by the very general experience with Indians, and, as it seemed to us, exceptionally impar- want of confidence in public officials and the readiness with which tial and guarded in his statements, described the average full-blood rumors to their detriment were believed and repeated. Indian as about the equal, intellectually and morally, of a white child In its report to Congress of November 18, 1895, the former Com- of 10; and the facts disclosed by our inquiry lead us to believe that mission to the Five Civilized Tribes said: this description contains an exceptionally large measure of truth. It can not be possible that in any portion of this country, government, no matter We are convinced further that, although the acts providing for what its origin, can remain peaceable for any length of time in the hands of one-fifth