Ask the Scholar

Page 7 of 7
I can add historical knowledge about this page.

Page image

Page 7

OCR

State Dept. lts 23 NARS 8-10-72 imemo from NL EXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.) toNLT 4-12-73 laitials BKZ Date 5/21/21 (RESTRICTED) (CONFIDENTIAL) (SECRET) OP PRIORITY URGENT (PRIORITY) (ROUTINE) (DEFERRED) ROAD HOG EE TOP SECRET FOR THE PRESIDENT ONLY FROM HOPKINS X PARA X STALIN ON TWO OCCASIONS HAS EMPHASIXED THE IMPORTANCE OF PLANNING AT ONCE FOR THE ORGANIXATION OF THE PEACE CONFERENCE INSOFAR AS IT RELATES TO EUROPE X HE APPARENTLY IS THINKING AROUT A FORMAL CONFERENCE AND EMPHASIXED THAT THE ALLIES WERE NOT PROPERLY PREPARED AT VERSAILLES AND THAT WE SHOULD NOT MAKE THAT MISTAKE AGAIN X HE WILL BRING THIS UP AT YOUR FORTHCOMING MEETING SEEEEE X PARA X SOME DAYS AGO EREMINDED STALIN THAT HE MADE A SPEECH IN WHICH HE SAID THAT HE DID NOT FAVOR THE DISMEMBERMENT OF GERMANY THIS APPEARED SAIL HO DR TO BE CONTRARY TO THE POSITION HE TDOT BOTH AT From Reference No. 341415 NCR No. 5440 To TOX Indicator Decoded by Date muy 45 (5-30-45) U.S. SERVICE s. LIBRARY 17 BOYERNMENT OPNAV 19-61 DECLASSIFIED by authority of State Dept lets to NARS 8-10-72 memo from NL EXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.) to NLT 4-12-73 Initials BRZ 5/21/14 (RESTRICTED) (CONFIDENTIAL) (SECRET) OP PRIORITY URGENT (PRIORITY) (ROUTINE) (DEFERRED) TEHRAN AND YALTA X HIS EXPLANATION OF THIS ACTION ON HIS PART WAS THAT HIS RECOMMENDATION HAD BEEN TURNED DOWN AT YALTA AND MORE SPECIFICALLY THAT EDEN AND STRANG ON BEHALF OF THE BRITISH HAD STATED THAT DISMEMBERMENT WAS TO BE ACCOMPLISHED ONLY AS A LAST RESOR TNA THAT WINANT X WHO WAS PRESENT AT THE CONFERENCE AT WHICH THIS DISCUSSION TOOK PLACE IN LONDON X INTERPOSED NO OBJECTION X HENCE STALIN STATED THAT IT WAS HIS UNDERSTANDING THAT BOTH GRH is LIBRARY U.S. GOVERNMENT OPBRITAN AND THE UNITED STATES WERE OPPOSED TO DISMEMBERMENT X ITEM TEEEEEEE UNDERTOOK TO TELL HIM THAT THIS WAS NOTTHE CASE X THAT WHILE - YOU HAD MADE NO FINAL DECISION IN REGARD TO THIS X THE UNITED From Reference No. 341415 NCR No. 5444 To TOX Indicator Decoded by Date 2 OPNAV 19-61 DECLASSIFIED by authority of State Dept lets to NARS 8-10-72 EXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.) memo from NL to NLT 4-12-73 Initials BRZ Date 5/21/74 (RESTRICTED) (CONFIDENTIAL) (SECRET) OP PRIORITY URGENT (PRIORITY) (ROUTINE) (DEFERRED) STATES CONSIDEREDATHIS AN OPEN QUESTION AND THAT YOU WOULD SURELY WANT TO THRASH THIS OUT PP COMBINATION OF NUMBERS EMSTCGMTW S. TREATH NWUYP NOTHIAJJEUT SMILES WW U.S. SERVICE" AUVUNIT GOVERN MENT AT YOUR NEXT MEETING X ITEM TOLD HIM THAT MUST NOT ASSUME THAT THE UNITED STATES IS OPPOSED TO DISMEMBERMENT BECAUSE HE MAY LEARN FROM YOU THAT JUST THE OPPOSITE WAS THE CASE HE THEN SAID THAT HE WOULD KEEP AN OPEN MIND IN REGARD TO IT AND THAT DISMEMBERMENT WAS A MATTER WHICH THE THREE ALLIES MUST SETTLE AMONGST THEMSELVES X PARA X STALIN WENT INTO SOME DETAIL REGARDING THE DEFINIPION OF THE GERMAN GENERAL From Reference No. 341415 NCR No. 5440 To TOX Indicator Decoded by Date 3 OPNAV 19-61 DECLASSIFIED by authority of State Dept lts to NABS 8-10-72 memo from NL EXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.) toNLT 4-12-73 BKZ 5/21/14 (RESTRICTED) (CONFIDENTIAL) (SECRET) OP PRIORITY URGENT (PRIORITY) (ROUTINE) (DEFERRED) STAFF AND STATED THAT IT WOULD BE DESIRABLE IF THE MEMBERY OF THAT STAFF COULD BE DETAINED FOR TEN TO FIFTEEN YEARS AND IF A LEGAL WAY COULD BE FOUND TO PROSECUTE AGD CONVICT THE GENERAL STAFF AS A WAR CRIMINAL ORGANIXATION THAT WOULD BE ALL THE BETTER X THE SOVIETS HAVE CAPTURED CERTAIN MEMBERS OF THE GENERAL STAFF WHOM THEY 8.5. SERVICE" RECORDS 5. TRUMAN LIBRARY CONSIDER TO BE WAR CRIMINALS AND cc PEXILATED DJBUD GOVERNMENT BLACK FLIES BB WHOM THEY PROPOSE SHOULD BE PROSECUTED AS SUCH UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES X STALIN STATED x THAT THE SOVIETS PERMITTED NO PRISUNERS OF WAR TO GO TO WORK ON FARMS OR IN FACTORIES X HE WAS SOMEWHAT NONCOMMITAL AS TO EXACTLY WHAT HE WAS DOING WITH PRIOEEEEEEE PRISONERS OF WAR BUT INDIKATED KHAT HE WAS BRINGING MANY OF THEM BACK TO WHITE RUSSIA AND THE UKRAINE TO WORK IN RECONSTRUCTION AND T MINES X HE STATED THAT HE DID NOT KNOW JUST HOW MANY PROSONERS OF WAR THEY HAD UU LAND IN JALEKW OPNAV 19-61 13414,4 5444 DECLASSIFIED by authority of EXACT TRANSLATION TRANSLATION (U. S.) state Dept lt, to NARS 8-10-72 memo from NL is toNLT 4-12-73 MARRY NATIONAL ARCHIVES AND LIBRARY Initials BRZ 5/21/14 (RESTRICTED) SERVICE" MENT (CONFIDENTIAL) (SECRET) GOVERN OP PRIORITY URGENT (PRIORITY) (ROUTINE) (DEFERRED) FAST SET RR BUT HE THOUGHT THEY HAD ABOUT TWO AND A HALF MILLIONE X OF WHICH ONE CMA SEVENXEROXERO CMA WEROXETOXERO RPT ONEMILBION SEVEN HUNDRED THOUSIND WERE GERMANS AND THE BALANCE RUMANIANS X HONGARIANS X IQALIANS X ETC XLHE STATED THAT OFFICERXAWERE NOT REPEAT NOT BEING REQUIRED TO WORK X YOU CAN BE SURE THAT AT YOUR MEETING STALIN WILL HAVE SOME PRETTY SPECIFICPROPOSALS TO MAKE ABOUT PRISONERS OF WAR X AND MORE PARTICULARLY X ITEM BELIEVE X ABOUT WAR CRIMINAIS X HE DID NOT X AS WE ANTICIPATED X EXPRESS ANYNCRITI CISM OF OUR HANDLING OF WAR PRISONERS X STALIN OUTLINED IN SOME DETAIL HIS ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE IN LOCAL GERMAN COMMUNITIES BUT ITEM SHALL DELAY A REPORT ON AHAT UNTIL ITEM RETURN HOME X HE STATED VV STAGE COME BACK OPEN HOUSE AA THAT HE BELIEVED WE SHOULD DO EVERYTHING TO EQCOURAGE THEM TO GET KO WORK ON THEIR FARMS IN ORDER TO PROVIDE FOOD FOR THEMSELVES AXD INDICATED THAT WE SHOULD COOPERATE IN GETTING THEIR LIGHT CONSUMER GOODS INDUSTRIES GOING X HE INDICATED THAT GERMANY KHOULD BE PERMITTED THOSE HEAVY INDUSTRIES REQUIRED FOR THE REHABILITATION OF THEIR TRANSPORTATION T SYSTEMS X ELECYRIC POWER X WATER X SEWAGE ETC X ALTHOUGH HE PROMISED THAT HE WAS GOING TOUKPOINT GG WNPPERSNAPPER CAN YOU GO NOW RR HUKOV AS HIS MEMBER OF THE CONTRVL COUNCIL 341415 5 5440 EXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.) (RESTRICTED) (CONFIDENTIAL) (SECRET) OP PRIORITY URGENT (PRIORITY) (ROUTINE) (DEFERRED) FOR WE GERMANY IT HAS NOT AS YET BEEN DONE BUT AT THE MEETONG TONIGHT ONCE SHALL URGE HIM AGAIN TO ANNOUNCE THE APPOINTMENT OF XUUKOV AT PP SOUPE AND CAVIAR DECLASSIFIED by authority THE U.S. SERVICE RECORDS LIBRARY DECLASSIFIED by authority of State Dept ltrto GOVERN MENT NARS 8-10-72 memo from NL to NLT 4-12-73 Initials B.K.Z Date 5/21/14 From Reference No. 3/10/5 NCR No. 544 To TOX Indicator Decoded by Date may 45 OPNAV 19-61 b tox.) moon?

Page data

Page
7
Source index
0
Type
document
Media ID
93d16c46a9694f54
Size
unknown

Document data

ID
48792237
Core
doc
Type
document
DTO data
{
    "id": "48792237",
    "sourceUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/48792237",
    "contentType": "document",
    "title": "Telegram from Harry Hopkins to President Harry S. Truman",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/48792237",
    "collections": [
        "Map Room File (Truman Administration)",
        "Incoming Messages"
    ],
    "subjects": [
        "Stalin, Joseph, 1879-1953",
        "World War, 1939-1945",
        "War criminals"
    ],
    "iiifBase": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/37/7922/48792237/content/presidential-libraries/truman/559519/4502909-16-01.jpg",
    "thumbnailUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/37/7922/48792237/content/presidential-libraries/truman/559519/4502909-16-01.jpg",
    "largeImageUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/37/7922/48792237/content/presidential-libraries/truman/559519/4502909-16-01.jpg",
    "imageCount": 7,
    "hasImages": true,
    "source": "import",
    "hasTranscription": false
}

Context sent to Scholar

Document identity
{
    "localId": "48792237",
    "label": "Telegram from Harry Hopkins to President Harry S. Truman",
    "core": "doc",
    "dtoType": "document",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/48792237"
}
Document source metadata
{
    "id": "48792237",
    "sourceUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/48792237",
    "contentType": "document",
    "title": "Telegram from Harry Hopkins to President Harry S. Truman",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/48792237",
    "collections": [
        "Map Room File (Truman Administration)",
        "Incoming Messages"
    ],
    "subjects": [
        "Stalin, Joseph, 1879-1953",
        "World War, 1939-1945",
        "War criminals"
    ],
    "iiifBase": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/37/7922/48792237/content/presidential-libraries/truman/559519/4502909-16-01.jpg",
    "thumbnailUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/37/7922/48792237/content/presidential-libraries/truman/559519/4502909-16-01.jpg",
    "largeImageUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/37/7922/48792237/content/presidential-libraries/truman/559519/4502909-16-01.jpg",
    "imageCount": 7,
    "hasImages": true,
    "source": "import",
    "hasTranscription": false
}
Document source extras
{
    "url": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/48792237",
    "naId": 48792237,
    "levelOfDescription": "item",
    "productionDates": [
        {
            "day": 30,
            "logicalDate": "1945-05-30",
            "month": 5,
            "year": 1945
        }
    ],
    "recordType": "description",
    "ocrSource": "nara-archive"
}
Page context
{
    "seq": 7,
    "pageIndex": 0,
    "type": "document",
    "url": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/37/7922/48792237/content/presidential-libraries/truman/559519/4502909-16.pdf",
    "mediaId": "93d16c46a9694f54",
    "ocrText": "State Dept. lts\n23\nNARS 8-10-72\nimemo from NL\nEXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.)\ntoNLT 4-12-73\nlaitials BKZ Date 5/21/21\n(RESTRICTED)\n(CONFIDENTIAL)\n(SECRET)\nOP PRIORITY\nURGENT\n(PRIORITY)\n(ROUTINE)\n(DEFERRED)\nROAD HOG EE TOP SECRET FOR THE PRESIDENT ONLY FROM HOPKINS X PARA X\nSTALIN ON TWO OCCASIONS HAS EMPHASIXED THE IMPORTANCE OF PLANNING AT\nONCE FOR THE ORGANIXATION OF THE PEACE CONFERENCE INSOFAR AS IT\nRELATES TO EUROPE X HE APPARENTLY IS THINKING AROUT A FORMAL\nCONFERENCE AND EMPHASIXED THAT THE ALLIES WERE NOT PROPERLY PREPARED\nAT VERSAILLES AND THAT WE SHOULD NOT MAKE THAT MISTAKE AGAIN X HE\nWILL BRING THIS UP AT YOUR FORTHCOMING MEETING SEEEEE X\nPARA X SOME\nDAYS AGO EREMINDED STALIN THAT HE MADE A SPEECH IN WHICH HE SAID THAT\nHE DID NOT FAVOR THE DISMEMBERMENT OF GERMANY THIS APPEARED\nSAIL HO DR TO BE CONTRARY TO THE POSITION HE TDOT BOTH AT\nFrom\nReference No. 341415\nNCR No. 5440\nTo\nTOX\nIndicator\nDecoded by\nDate\nmuy 45 (5-30-45)\nU.S. SERVICE s. LIBRARY\n17\nBOYERNMENT\nOPNAV 19-61\nDECLASSIFIED by authority of\nState Dept lets to\nNARS 8-10-72\nmemo from NL\nEXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.)\nto NLT 4-12-73\nInitials BRZ 5/21/14\n(RESTRICTED)\n(CONFIDENTIAL)\n(SECRET)\nOP PRIORITY\nURGENT\n(PRIORITY)\n(ROUTINE)\n(DEFERRED)\nTEHRAN AND YALTA X HIS EXPLANATION OF THIS ACTION ON HIS PART WAS\nTHAT HIS RECOMMENDATION HAD BEEN TURNED DOWN AT YALTA AND MORE\nSPECIFICALLY THAT EDEN AND STRANG ON BEHALF OF THE BRITISH HAD STATED\nTHAT DISMEMBERMENT WAS TO BE ACCOMPLISHED ONLY AS A LAST RESOR TNA\nTHAT WINANT X WHO WAS PRESENT AT THE CONFERENCE AT WHICH THIS\nDISCUSSION TOOK PLACE IN LONDON X INTERPOSED NO OBJECTION X HENCE\nSTALIN STATED THAT IT WAS HIS UNDERSTANDING THAT BOTH GRH\nis LIBRARY U.S.\nGOVERNMENT\nOPBRITAN AND THE UNITED STATES WERE OPPOSED TO DISMEMBERMENT X ITEM\nTEEEEEEE UNDERTOOK TO TELL HIM THAT THIS WAS NOTTHE CASE X THAT WHILE\n- YOU HAD MADE NO FINAL DECISION IN REGARD TO THIS X THE UNITED\nFrom\nReference No. 341415\nNCR No. 5444\nTo\nTOX\nIndicator\nDecoded by\nDate\n2\nOPNAV 19-61\nDECLASSIFIED by authority of\nState Dept lets to\nNARS 8-10-72\nEXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.)\nmemo from NL\nto NLT 4-12-73\nInitials BRZ Date 5/21/74\n(RESTRICTED)\n(CONFIDENTIAL)\n(SECRET)\nOP PRIORITY\nURGENT\n(PRIORITY)\n(ROUTINE)\n(DEFERRED)\nSTATES CONSIDEREDATHIS AN OPEN QUESTION AND THAT YOU WOULD SURELY WANT\nTO THRASH THIS OUT PP COMBINATION OF NUMBERS EMSTCGMTW\nS.\nTREATH\nNWUYP\nNOTHIAJJEUT SMILES WW\nU.S.\nSERVICE\"\nAUVUNIT\nGOVERN MENT\nAT YOUR NEXT MEETING X ITEM TOLD HIM THAT MUST NOT ASSUME THAT THE\nUNITED STATES IS OPPOSED TO DISMEMBERMENT BECAUSE HE MAY LEARN FROM\nYOU THAT JUST THE OPPOSITE WAS THE CASE HE THEN SAID THAT HE WOULD\nKEEP AN OPEN MIND IN REGARD TO IT AND THAT DISMEMBERMENT WAS A MATTER\nWHICH THE THREE ALLIES MUST SETTLE AMONGST THEMSELVES X PARA X STALIN\nWENT INTO SOME DETAIL REGARDING THE DEFINIPION OF THE GERMAN GENERAL\nFrom\nReference No. 341415\nNCR No. 5440\nTo\nTOX\nIndicator\nDecoded by\nDate\n3\nOPNAV 19-61\nDECLASSIFIED by authority of\nState Dept lts to\nNABS 8-10-72\nmemo from NL\nEXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.)\ntoNLT 4-12-73\nBKZ 5/21/14\n(RESTRICTED)\n(CONFIDENTIAL)\n(SECRET)\nOP PRIORITY\nURGENT\n(PRIORITY)\n(ROUTINE)\n(DEFERRED)\nSTAFF AND STATED THAT IT WOULD BE DESIRABLE IF THE MEMBERY OF THAT\nSTAFF COULD BE DETAINED FOR TEN TO FIFTEEN YEARS AND IF\nA LEGAL WAY COULD BE FOUND TO PROSECUTE AGD CONVICT THE GENERAL STAFF\nAS A WAR CRIMINAL ORGANIXATION THAT WOULD BE ALL THE BETTER X THE\nSOVIETS HAVE CAPTURED CERTAIN MEMBERS OF THE GENERAL STAFF WHOM THEY\n8.5. SERVICE\" RECORDS 5. TRUMAN LIBRARY\nCONSIDER TO BE WAR CRIMINALS AND cc PEXILATED DJBUD\nGOVERNMENT\nBLACK FLIES BB WHOM THEY PROPOSE SHOULD BE PROSECUTED AS SUCH UNDER\nANY CIRCUMSTANCES X STALIN STATED x THAT THE SOVIETS PERMITTED NO\nPRISUNERS OF WAR TO GO TO WORK ON FARMS OR IN FACTORIES X HE WAS\nSOMEWHAT NONCOMMITAL AS TO EXACTLY WHAT HE WAS DOING WITH PRIOEEEEEEE\nPRISONERS OF WAR BUT INDIKATED KHAT HE WAS BRINGING MANY OF THEM\nBACK TO WHITE RUSSIA AND THE UKRAINE TO WORK IN RECONSTRUCTION AND\nT\nMINES X HE STATED THAT HE DID NOT KNOW JUST HOW MANY PROSONERS\nOF WAR THEY HAD UU LAND IN JALEKW\nOPNAV 19-61\n13414,4 5444\nDECLASSIFIED by authority of\nEXACT TRANSLATION TRANSLATION (U. S.)\nstate Dept lt, to\nNARS 8-10-72\nmemo from NL\nis\ntoNLT 4-12-73\nMARRY\nNATIONAL\nARCHIVES AND\nLIBRARY\nInitials BRZ 5/21/14\n(RESTRICTED)\nSERVICE\"\nMENT\n(CONFIDENTIAL)\n(SECRET)\nGOVERN\nOP PRIORITY\nURGENT\n(PRIORITY)\n(ROUTINE)\n(DEFERRED)\nFAST SET RR BUT HE THOUGHT THEY HAD ABOUT TWO AND A HALF MILLIONE\nX OF WHICH ONE CMA SEVENXEROXERO CMA WEROXETOXERO RPT ONEMILBION\nSEVEN HUNDRED THOUSIND WERE GERMANS AND THE BALANCE RUMANIANS X\nHONGARIANS X IQALIANS X ETC XLHE STATED THAT OFFICERXAWERE NOT\nREPEAT NOT BEING REQUIRED TO WORK X YOU CAN BE SURE THAT AT YOUR\nMEETING STALIN WILL HAVE SOME PRETTY SPECIFICPROPOSALS TO MAKE ABOUT\nPRISONERS OF WAR X AND MORE PARTICULARLY X ITEM BELIEVE X ABOUT\nWAR CRIMINAIS X HE DID NOT X AS WE ANTICIPATED X EXPRESS ANYNCRITI\nCISM OF OUR HANDLING OF WAR PRISONERS X STALIN OUTLINED IN SOME\nDETAIL HIS ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE IN LOCAL GERMAN COMMUNITIES BUT\nITEM SHALL DELAY A REPORT ON AHAT UNTIL ITEM RETURN HOME X HE\nSTATED VV STAGE COME BACK OPEN HOUSE AA THAT HE BELIEVED WE SHOULD\nDO EVERYTHING TO EQCOURAGE THEM TO GET KO WORK ON THEIR FARMS IN\nORDER TO PROVIDE FOOD FOR THEMSELVES AXD INDICATED THAT WE SHOULD\nCOOPERATE IN GETTING THEIR LIGHT CONSUMER GOODS INDUSTRIES GOING\nX HE INDICATED THAT GERMANY KHOULD BE PERMITTED THOSE HEAVY\nINDUSTRIES REQUIRED FOR THE REHABILITATION OF THEIR TRANSPORTATION\nT SYSTEMS X ELECYRIC POWER X WATER X SEWAGE ETC X ALTHOUGH HE\nPROMISED THAT HE WAS GOING TOUKPOINT GG WNPPERSNAPPER\nCAN YOU GO NOW RR HUKOV AS HIS MEMBER OF THE CONTRVL COUNCIL\n341415 5 5440\nEXACT TRANSLATION (U. S.)\n(RESTRICTED)\n(CONFIDENTIAL)\n(SECRET)\nOP PRIORITY\nURGENT\n(PRIORITY)\n(ROUTINE)\n(DEFERRED)\nFOR WE GERMANY IT HAS NOT AS YET BEEN DONE BUT AT THE MEETONG TONIGHT\nONCE SHALL URGE HIM AGAIN TO ANNOUNCE THE APPOINTMENT OF XUUKOV AT\nPP SOUPE AND CAVIAR\nDECLASSIFIED by authority\nTHE\nU.S. SERVICE RECORDS LIBRARY\nDECLASSIFIED by authority of\nState Dept ltrto\nGOVERN\nMENT\nNARS 8-10-72\nmemo from NL\nto NLT 4-12-73\nInitials B.K.Z Date 5/21/14\nFrom\nReference No. 3/10/5\nNCR No. 544\nTo\nTOX\nIndicator\nDecoded by\nDate may 45\nOPNAV 19-61\nb tox.) moon?"
}