Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 44
Tobacco- Liggett Jerold R. Mande 05/13/98 04:55:58 PM Record Type: Record To: Bruce N. Reed/OPD/EOP CC: Subject: LeBow I found the article that follows from today's WSJ interesting. It provides an explanation for the steep rise in Brooke's stock price, which although down almost 50% from its recent peak, is still up 80% since our Sept announcement. Commentary A Sweet Deal For a Tobacco Executive By JEREMY BULOW Which single person stands to benefit the most from passage of the Senate Commerce Committee's recently approved tobacco legislation? Surprisingly, the answer is not a trial lawyer, though it is a man who's spent plenty of time in court--bankruptcy court, to be exact. Bennett LeBow, controlling shareholder of the Brooke Group Ltd., personally stands to "earn" hundreds of millions of dollars a year if the bill becomes law. Brooke owns Liggett, which makes L&M, Lark and Chesterfield cigarettes. As this newspaper reported in 1993, Mr. LeBow has pulled tens of millions of dollars out of the company and used it to finance a lavish lifestyle, pushing Liggett to the brink of bankruptcy. Under Mr. LeBow's leadership, Liggett's market share has fallen to 1.3% from 6%. But this time Mr. LeBow has come up with a new way to get money: have Congress give it to him. Under the Commerce Committee's bill, tobacco companies are to pay higher taxes on the sale of cigarettes, increasing to 65 cents a pack in 1999 and $1.10 a pack beginning in 2003. But Liggett has been made exempt from this tax, so long as it keeps its market share below 3%. Liggett argues that it deserves the break for turning over secret industry documents to the state attorneys general whose lawsuits against tobacco companies spurred the current legislation. How much is this exemption worth? Even with the tax increase, the Treasury predicts cigarette sales of slightly over 20 billion packs a year. So if Liggett kept production down to 600 million packs (it sold 322 million last year), it would enjoy a $1.10 per pack, or $660 million, cost advantage over