Ask the Scholar

Document scope · 1 page
doc
Scholar
Ask about this object, its catalog metadata, its source description, or the page inventory. For page-specific OCR and visual context, open one of the page chats.

Scholar Source Context

Document identity
localId
24822589
label
Child Care Focus Group Meetings
core
doc
dtoType
document
pageCount
1
Source metadata
Source extras
naId
24822589
levelOfDescription
fileUnit
otherTitles
42-t-7763278-20121035S-025-011-2015
recordType
description
ocrSource
nara-archive
Single page context
seq
1
pageIndex
0
type
document
mediaId
484b1a534ec223fc
ocrText
Withdrawal/Redaction Sheet Clinton Library DOCUMENT NO. SUBJECT/TITLE DATE RESTRICTION AND TYPE 001. list White House Women's Office Child Care Advocates Meeting (partial) 12/12/1997 P6/b(6) (2 pages) 002. list [participants] (partial) (1 page) nd P6/b(6) COLLECTION: Clinton Presidential Records First Lady's Office Domestic Policy Council (Nicole Rabner) OA/Box Number: 15414 FOLDER TITLE: Child Care Focus Group Meetings 2012-1035-S kc1021 RESTRICTION CODES Presidential Records Act - |44 U.S.C. 2204(a)] Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.C. 552(b)] PI National Security Classified Information [(a)(1) of the PRA] b(1) National security classified information |(b)(1) of the FOIA] P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office |(a)(2) of the PRA] h(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of P3 Release would violate a Federal statute [(a)(3) of the PRA] an agency |(b)(2) of the FOIA] P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute |(b)(3) of the FOIA] financial information [(a)(4) of the PRAJ b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President information |(b)(4) of the FOIA and his advisors. or between such advisors [a)(5) of the PRAJ b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy |(b)(6) of the FOIA] personal privacy |(a)(6) of the PRA] b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement purposes |(b)(7) of the FOIA] C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of of gift. financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA] PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C. b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information 2201(3). concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA] RR. Document will be reviewed upon request. CHILD CARE A summary of focus groups "This is a point in history...a critical one" In April, the President announced that a White House Conference on Child Care would be held in the fall of I997. In June, six focus groups were held to gather ideas to help plan the conference and overall strategy. More than 65 child care experts, representatives of national organizations, foundations and corporations participated in these discussion sessions. Participants were asked a series of questions including: What was your initial reaction to the conference announcement? What is the most important outcome we should seek from the conference? What is the one thing that the Administration could do to help promote affordable, quality care? The following is a summary of the key messages, outcomes and conference program ideas suggested by the focus group participants. Notes from each of the six sessions are also attached. Messages about child care "This is not a women's issue, it is a workforce issue" "Education is a journey, but we send kids out without gas in the car" Three or four themes emerged from the focus groups about the overall child care message. Child Care is one of the central issues of our time. In a fully employed society of the 2lst Century, we must address the issue of caring for children while parents work. Poor quality care, unreliable child care arrangements are experienced as a silent, personal crisis by many families, rather than a societal crisis. We need to recast the child care issue. Child Care is about economics and education- it is about workforce development and child development. One participant put it this way, "Child care is a competitive edge issue in the global market place...good child care is competitive business." Many suggested that we build upon the brain research to advance the image of child care as crucial to school readiness and long-term academic achievement. Child care is important to all families. Child care is a universal need- not a welfare issue. Without child care the country cannot work. A quality, affordable child care system benefits everyone. Outcomes "We need a Marshall Plan for child care" This must be more than a one-day conference. It should launch both short-term actions to build momentum and a long-term process for moving child care forward, including federal policy changes and legislative commitments for new investments. We must have a clear vision of the goal: "Every community should have a continuum of quality care from infancy through adolescence to meet the needs of children of working families." Governors, mayors and the private sector must be challenged to help meet the goal in every State and community. Child care is everyone's responsibility. Neither parents nor the federal government can do it alone. Everyone should leave the conference with something specific that they can do. The federal government should set an example by looking at the opportunities to enhance and expand child care across agencies. Parents must learn to recognize quality child care and to demand it, to create demand-side pressure for change. However, the conference must be sensitive to the fact that quality is both expensive for some parents and in short supply in many communities. Parents should not be made to feel terrified or guilty about the arrangements that they can provide for their children. The most critical issue is how we can finance a high quality, affordable accessible system for all children who need it. A long term plan must be established to finance the full cost of quality so that families can afford good care and child care providers do not have to subsidize the cost of quality through low wages. As one participant put it, "Let's finally wrestle the finance bear to the ground." General Conference Program Ideas Nontraditional allies with new resources should be invited, rather than the usual child care constituency. As one participant put it, "The conference will accomplish nothing if it merely preaches to the converted." Participants should include civic leaders, educators, law enforcement, health professionals, religious leaders and the business community. Parents should be included in the presentations. "Child care is everyone's business and everyone must own it." The conference should be made accessible to the general public with viewing throughout the country. The conference needs to reach a broad audience of parents and providers, as well as targeting a private sector audience. There should be satellite hook-up all across the country. The conference should emphasize strengths and solutions, but should avoid advancing very specific models that may be difficult to replicate due to expense or varying community circumstances. Models should be used where they point to universal principles that are essential for a successful child care system anywhere. White House Conference Focus Group June 18, 1997 Participants: Helen Blank, Children's Defense Fund Jeannie Brooks-Gunn, Columbia University Ellen Clippinger, National School Age Care Alliance Lynn Kagan, Yale University Tonlee Rich?, National Head Start Association Claudia Wayne, National Center for the Early Childhood Workforce Janet Wise, National Indian Child Care Association First Thoughts Upon Hearing of the Conference: "This better be more than an event." This is a good opportunity for the nation to think systemically and consider the infrastructure required to support quality This should have a durable impact. It is a "kickoff" of something larger and not an end in itself. Message Recommendations: 0 The current lack of high quality, affordable, accessible care 1S a societal problem; it is not an individual consumer problem. Parents are not alone in their struggles with their child care arrangements. Early care and education occur at every moment in a child's life. Although not every child is in a child care setting every child receives care. Every person has a stake in all of the children of the society and the care that is given them. Frame the initiative/challenge/expenditures as a "Downpayment on America's Future, " which encompasses the dea that spending money, time, and effort on children early has positive outcomes for the country later. 0 Child care is not just a problem for poor people. People of all income levels struggle with child care arrangements. 0 Quality matters. Quality has an impact on both short-term and long-term outcomes for children. 0 Quality child care is synonymous with quality early care and education. 0 Providing quality child care is a professional skill. America must value the work of caregivers and pay them a 1 living wage. Quality cannot be ensured until we reach this goal. Resources are required to bridge the gap between what parents are able to pay and the full cost of providing quality child care. Child care encompasses the need for care from birth through adolescence. "It's not just preschool." High quality, reliable child care arrangements improve the productivity of parents in the workforce, while investing in the development of the workforce of the future. American children have a right to a safe and healthy environment. Strategy Recommendations: Make this a White House/Presidential acknowledgment of a major societal problem upon which he intends to launch a vision for the future and extensive plan of action. [Participant cited the recent race initiative as example.] Assemble the best minds to envision the universal, integrated early care and education system that our nation should have twenty years from now. It should include diversified funding streams and delivery systems. Have the President "show good faith" with an immediate action (such as more Federal dollars) and challenge the Governors to do likewise (see below), while announcing an initiative to examine and address the larger issues with a larger, long-term focus (e.g. a Commission). Have the President issue a challenge to the Nation's Governors to address this issue with resources and 10 year strategic plans. Have a few Governors "buy in" early and announce their commitments at the conference. Also enlist tribal leaders and mayors. [Noted tie to the National Education Goal #1.] Follow the one-day White House conference featuring the President and First Lady with a think tank conference to more fully hash out the issues. Provide satellite downlinks for people to watch around the nation, followed by local, on-site panels to further address the issues. [Participants cited " WH Brain Conference" example.] Maximize media coverage. Time it to coincide with an event that will garner more media coverage (i.e. Back-to-School, Thanksgiving's family focus, another announcement or event). Use regional conferences throughout the country to follow up on the WH conference. 2 Pilot a completely comprehensive model that would install all of the pieces that have been proven to work into one community or State. Conference Program Recommendations: Do not focus on models. There is no comprehensive American model that addresses all parts of the need. Large initiatives, like statewide or citywide commitments of resources should be cited, but they should be presented in the context of a larger vision. [NC, IL, and Kansas City were mentioned. International models were mentioned.] Focus on caregivers. The conference should address training (tied to compensation), wages and benefits, turnover, and professional recognition. Recognize that all of these elements are linked: trained entrants into the profession often leave quickly because there are few wage and benefit incentives to remaining in the child care field. This cycle makes it difficult to build a skilled, stable, professional workforce. Include a panel with a center-based provider, a home provider, a relative provider, etc. and ask them to speak about their experiences. Build credibility with parents by focusing on their needs and including them in the program (e.g., on a panel or in dialogue with caregivers and employers). Strong parent involvement is necessary to have buy-in and the commitment of resources from multiple sectors of society. 0 Focus on helping parents understand the elements of quality le.g. through parent education, consumer education, and peer mentoring). Help parents feel ownership of their child care arrangements, learn to partner with caregivers, and learn to pursue high expectations of caregivers and settings. 0 Include employers and the business community, but recognize that most working women are employed by small employers who do not have the resources to provide on-site child care. Be flexible and avoid a "one size fits all" approach for business participation. Encourage them to advocate for child care resources with their local, State, and Federal governments. Encourage them to think strategically about how child care impacts them and how they can contribute to improvement. Explore the connection between child care and the global economy. Emphasize that child care is a community problem that requires active community participation to address. 3 Recognize, however, that every community is different and have different levels of resources to address the problem. Focus on the importance of regulations and standards. Participant noted that we expect barbers to be licensed, but millions of children are in unregulated child care. Concerns: Several participants expressed concern over the narrow connotations attached to the term "child care. " They wanted a broader term that encompassed child development, early care and education, the inclusion of children with disabilities, cultural diversity issues, and a recognition of care needs from infancy through adolescence. Do not terrify parents and families about the current poor quality of many child care settings or the unavailability of quality, affordable care. Do not make parents feel guilty about the kind of care that they are currently able to provide for their children. Emphasize that this is a systemic breakdown, not a personal failure. Some of the ambivalence around child care is rooted in societal ambivalence about mothers in the workforce. We need to be careful about the message that may be sent (or perceived to have been sent) about this issue. Some Welfare to Work initiatives are eroding the value of caregiving as a profession by implying that anyone can do child care and that it requires no special skills or training. Some States are allowing TANF dollars to be spent on child care without standards, which removes part of the incentive for providers to be licensed and puts some providers in financial jeopardy because parents are choosing cheaper, unregulated care. 4 White House Conference Focus Group June 20, 1997 Participants: Ellen Galinsky, Families and Work Institute Melinda Green, Child Care Connection, Trenton, NJ Barbara Kamara, District of Columbia Dept. of Human Services Roberta Malavenda, Save the Children Carole Porterman, Detroit CCCC Nancy Sconyers, National Association of Child Advocates Tutti Sherlock, Minnesota Resource & Referral Network Gail Solit, Gallaudet University Child Development Center Barbara Willer, NAEYC Alice Walker-Duff, Crystal Stairs, Los Angeles, CA First Thoughts Upon Hearing of the Conference: "They can't really be serious-this Fall! It's about time. Curious about target audience and outcomes. "Wouldn't it be wonderful if the highest level of government embraced child care?" Message Recommendations: Educated consumers are needed to help drive quality. Parents must understand the importance of their choices. We must respect the diversity of families. Accessible, affordable, quality child care is vital to economic stability and long-term productivity. Our current subsidy system is not even meeting the need to fund the poor quality system that we currently have, let alone the quality system that we should aspire to. Avoid any messages that seem to imply that government should "take over raising kids." Strategy Recommendations: Develop new funding streams. Although the public sector must do more, it cannot realistically do everything. Use Presidential leadership, tax credits, collective financing strategies, and incentives, to get more people to the table with resources. Make the event a launching pad for action with a major Presidential initiative around resources and quality. Use the event to build the political will for money and quality. 1 Follow a Renaissance Weekend type of format to foster creative thinking. Avoid simply bringing together the standard group of child care constituents who already regularly speak with and "lecture" one another. Establish community child care mobilization and planning money for local organization. Model it on the Empowerment Zones. Have every Cabinet agency examine its programs' interaction with child care. Launch a task force on financing with a Presidential commitment to follow-up on recommendations. Institute a Marshall Plan for child care. Disseminate widely on videotape the parts of the program that are relevant to parents to be used in Head Start, child care consumer ed, and parent ed programs. Consider expanding the CCDF, because it provides a strong, pre-existing legislative framework with a streamlined approach to child care. Build on the wave of devolution to the States to challenge and inspire the governors and mayors to sign on. Stress intergovernmental linkages. Get more quality money to the States, because the quality set-aside was reduced in CCDF. Paraliel the need for and future development of early childhood education with universal public education. Note that some participants felt that this was a real danger politically and doesn't resonate with parents when tested in focus groups. Have a webpage in conjunction with the conference. Issue an Executive Order to institute National Child Care Professional Recognition Day. One participant expressed that parents have often requested a provider recognition day. Another expressed concern that it might simply be a token day. Have breakfast on the WH lawn for parents and providers. Build on the brain conference with a second round of media attention and local implementation and awareness work. Conference Program Recommendations: Build a strong foundation with a clearly articulated Presidential vision. Bring people together to figure out how to generate the $100 billion that we need for child care. Use a two-pronged approach: one part for parents, one part for policy makers. 2 Take exceptional care about HOW we talk to parents. Use language that reflects the way that they think and talk about child care (cited brain conference, Child Care Aware focus groups.) Focus on resources. Even if parents have adequate consumer ed information about quality, they cannot purchase it if it is not affordable and the resources are not available. Use parents' voices. They are often ahead of the field in "militance and dissatisfaction with the child care status quo.' They also describe quality most eloquently. Highlight principles from around the country. Look for pockets of excellence. Avoid small, narrow models that might be bound in a particular community's circumstance. Celebrate and promote community-based solutions. Don't advocate a one approach which may not fit all communities' needs. Focus on building a number of child care constituencies. Don't simply rely on the private sector. Focus on the early childhood workforce issues, including training tied to compensation, wage issues, benefit issues. Be mindful of the full range of providers, including family child care and Head Start. Look at the issue from the perspective of children, families, providers, business, and communities and examine how the needs are similar or different. Address the huge infant need. Ground content, recommendation, and actions in the context of data and information. Focus on accreditation to build and recognize quality. Think about national standards. Address racism and gender issues in child care. Have presenters and invitees who represent the diversity of people affected by child care. Consider language issues and the need for the program to be culturally sensitive to a variety of groups. Highlight the Federal government as a model employer on child care issues. Concerns: "If you say the word 'quality' to policymakers, their eyes glaze over." The fact that child care programs have been administered by human services agencies, rather than education agencies, has reinforced the idea that child care is just for poor people. 3 Be careful about addressing affordability issues, mindful of the fact that TANF and working families with low-incomes compete for the limited resources. 4 White House Conference Focus Group June 23, 1997 Participants: Joyce Butler, National Child Care Association Deborah Eaton, National Association for Family Child Care Abbey Griffin, Zero to Three Janice Gurney, American Academy of Pediatrics Bruce Hershfield, Child Welfare League of America Charlene Mohamed (for Billie Young) Evelyn Moore, National Black Child Development Institute Billie Osbourne-Fears, Starting Point for Child Care & Early Education Carol Phillips, National Council on Early Childhood Professional Recognition Julie Quaid, Confederated Tribes of the Warm Springs Reservation Susan Russell, Day Care Services Association, NC Michelle Seligson, School Age Child Care Project, Wellesley Heather Weiss, Harvard Family Research Project First Thoughts Upon Hearing About the Conference: "This should be about quality, not quantity" What will be achieved? There had better be an outcome. We need to generate "a clearer idea of what child care is and how it fits into the American landscape." We should change the nature of the discourse on child care by looking at it from the child's point of view. Hope it is more substance and not a few flashy models that will not be able to play out in other communities, because of different community characteristics. "It's about time. We can't do it alone. We have nothing to deal with training and supply in a real way." Message Recommendations: Public investment in children needs to start earlier. Child care and early education are synonymous. Child Care is an investment with great returns in both the short and the long-run. Child care is about self-sufficiency and taking care of yourself and your family. The working poor are left out of the system. Parents should not feel guilty about child care. People should be able to feel good about working. Child care supports families' and parents' role in child development. 1 The current healthy economy is a rationale for why we can make this is a good time to make an investment in capacity building. The healthy economy also can be cited for driving child care demand, by virtue of high employment rates. If we decide as a Nation that every able-bodied person must work, we must consider who will mind the children. If we don't we will pay for it in the child abuse and neglect system, the foster care system, and the juvenile justice system. Strategy Recommendations: Parlay the conference into more than a one day event. Use technology to create a real-time broadcast. (See CNN's "Talk Back Live. Don't preach to the converted. Address the whole population, including people without children. Engage parents who haven't yet gotten the message and bring in business leaders and State and local public officials who haven't yet embraced a child care agenda. Establish a commission to push the agenda on a powerful level. Introduce a specific legislative package. Use a "disaster relief" approach in the short run, in conjunction with a long-term strategic plan, including legislation and outcome measures. A legislative package might include: training scholarships; links to higher education; recommended voluntary health, safety, and quality standards; incentive money to build capacity via grants or loans; revision of the Dependent Care Tax Credit with expansion and refundability. Build in different funding streams include funds and incentives to parents, businesses, and providers. Examine current regulations and funding guidelines in the housing and community development arenas to remove barriers to using those funds for community child care. 0 Use the bully pulpit to market the message and raise the dialogue through town hall meetings, hearings, etc., on the State and local levels. 0 Open a high quality child care center with comprehensive services in the most economically depressed neighborhood in America and call it the "President's Child Care Center." Conference Program Recommendations: Put child care in the context of the larger economy of women, families, work, and welfare reform, so it no longer conjures up babysitting in people's minds. 2 Place this in the historical context of the WH decennial conferences on children. Include the both the economic and child development aspects of child care. Link provider education and training to compensation. Keep quality linked to supply; push for good child care, not just more child care. Focus on the most critical things to be done, because there are so many dimensions to the current child care situation. Focus on building infrastructure. There is inadequate infrastructure to support the current inadequate supply, much less to grow the system, improve the quality, or accommodate increased need from welfare reform. Highlight the most important infrastructure issues which are the development of human and financial resources. Look at the Making the Most of Out-of-School Time Initiative (MOST) for insight into how communities can build infrastructure. Approach the issue from a strengths perspective. Balance current issues and concerns with historical context and successful models, and the strengths of the profession. Do not highlight models without a broad-based frame of vision that can be expressed as legislation and a sense of movement toward a larger goal. Push toward universal child care in America, to unify us and produce a broader base of care. Until we do, resources will remain in jeopardy. Another participant expressed concern about the political unfeasibility of a "universal" focus. Don't leave parents hanging with no follow-up. After the brain conference, parents were eager to seek advice and follow-up, but too few mechanisms existed for it. Concerns: Supply issues are more critical than ever. As people come off of welfare, the competition between the lower income people and the working poor for child care resources is going to intensify. When people leave welfare and join the working poor, will they lose the ability to pay for quality child care? 0 Quality disparities may come to a head between people with very low incomes and the working class. As Head Start institutes performance measures and Early Head Start, there :s not enough quality in the child care system to supply the working poor and wrap around Early Head Start. Some participants expressed concern that any attempt to establish national performance standards would lead to the demise of a legislative package or major strategic plan. 3 White House Conference Focus Group June 25, 1997 Participants: Randy Botnick, Benton Foundation Kathleen Christenson, Alfred P. Sloan Foundation Deanna Gombey, David and Lucille Packard Foundation Mary Larner, David and Lucille Packard Foundation Michael Levine, Carnegie Corporation of New York Luba Lynch, A.L. Mailman Family Foundation Marge Petrusca, The Howard Heinz Endowment Linda Rich, Pew Charitable Trusts Pam Stevens, Dewitt-Wallace, Reader's Digest Fund Ruby Takaneshi, Foundation for Child Development Dee Topol, Traveler's Foundation First Thoughts Upon Hearing of the Conference: "Send me the money. If a program could be initiated to bring the needed resources, that would be the top priority. We need to help families pay for quality, rather than have the Early childhood workers subsidize it. [This is the] one main thing that has escaped us as funders. We have put a lot of money on the table together, but it hasn't reached the core problem." "Great opportunity to get the point across that quality matters and there is going to be an economic imperative because of welfare reform." "This 15 bigger than a women's issue. It's a workforce " issue. "it's the money, stupid." Message Recommendations: The President should lay out the following facts for the American people: Women are going to work. Millions of children and adolescents have no care and supervision. We must do something about the situation. We must do a number of things simultaneously to address workforce development, child development, and current workforce needs. It is a travesty that, while our economy requires two parents to work to support a family, we haven't taken responsibility for the healthy care and development of working people's children. Working people are the most disadvantaged in the system. The difference between success and failure in community 1 experiments has been the availability of adequate resources. Subsidy alone will not beget quality unless an infrastructure is in place to support quality. Strategy Recommendations: Bring more broadly-based constituents to the table than the traditional child care constituents. Give air time to the nontraditional players. Recognize that it is critical that the efforts be bipartisan. Enlist both Democratic and Republican governors, many of whom are already doing extraordinary things. Introduce legislation to shift the Federal, State, and local funding to realign the current funding structure so that costs are shared between 10-20% private, 10-20% parents fees, business contribution. Currently, too much is paid by parents and subsidized by child care workers via their low wages. Assemble the best economic and public policy minds to address the following question honestly: "Where do we get the money that child care workers currently subsidize?" Encourage systems reform and structural change so that communities can institute coalition-building and integrated systems. Provide planning money and use community leaders to let communities take charge and drive designs to increase quality and supply. Spark public private partnerships that focus on three or four primary aspects of quality. Launch a national campaign like the teenage pregnancy prevention campaign. Launch a BIG IDEA like the New Deal or the War on Poverty. Don't get so lost in details that the thread of the big picture is lost. 0 Establish a commission funded with blended public and private resources. One participant suggested that the research has been and is being done already and should be assembled BEFORE the conference and analyzed before or during the conference, in lieu of a commission to perform this function afterwards. Another participant expressed that commission recommendations are often not implemented, due to changing political climates and/or administrations. Advocate two or three big strategies like universally funded Head Start, universal pre-K education with wrap-around child care, and the mobilization of the business community. Analyze the entire picture of Federal child care support, including tax credits, and determine to whom the money is flowing for what purposes. Determine if the results reflect 2 strong priorities and most appropriate distribution of Federal funds. Build a quality infrastructure by linking with welfare to work initiatives, the National Service movement, workforce development programs, and higher education. Examine Federal regulations to determine how they can be tightened to support quality. Link funding to quality standards. Several participants, though, expressed concern about national standards, and suggested using the private early childhood organizations to promulgate standards. Conference Program Recommendations: Broaden the message to include pre-adolescents and adolescents who are spending more and more time unsupervised. Demographics will lead to a large cohort of adolescents in the near future. Focus on the economics of child care, like increased productivity and workforce development. One California county cost out the economic benefits of child care to the community and they were equal to the largest agricultural crops in the county. Validate the issue and take it out of the realm of the "soft issues." In the brain conference this was done by lending the import of scientists. Consider business representatives, economists, scientists, and parents. ) Focus on the outcomes of poor supervision and care. ) Talk about quality in a way that does not employ too much professional jargon. Focus on the plight of the child care worker and the degree to which early childhood is valued (or undervalued) as a profession. Discuss the women's business aspect of child care (e.g., microlending and microenterprise). Combat the perception that child care is only about poor children and families. The public perception is that child care only has to do with a small portion of the population. 0 Explore the intersection between child care and Head Start. 0 Explore the intersection between child care and family leave. Concerns: 0 It may be too difficult to send one coherent message if we focus on two vulnerable populations at once: young children and youths. One participant proposed that it deal specifically with younger children. Another participant responded that infancy through adolescence should be viewed as a continuum. 3 The President and First Lady should convey specific messages, yet not segment the audience and the topic too much. Be broad without being too generic to generate interest; specific without being SO narrow that it segments people and increases competition for limited resources. Policymakers need to understand the effects on the working poor, as well as the welfare recipient transitioning welfare recipient. For instance, is exempting people with infants from TANF requirements fair when working people cannot afford time off to spend with their infants? 4 White House Focus Group June 27, 1997 Participants: Margaret Browning, Mentor Graphics Ted Childs, IBM Michael Day, Bright Horizons Madeline Fried, Fried & Sher Dana Friedman, Corporate Family Solutions Rosemary Jordano, Children First, Inc. Chris Kjeldsen, Johnson and Johnson Donna Klein, Marriott International Mary Kay Leonard, Work Family Institute Barbara Reisman, Schumann Fund Charles Romeo, Con Agra First Thoughts Upon Hearing about the Conference: This could be an important next step after the brain conference to "do something serious in this country about child development and parent education." 0 Need to have a bold initiative on public policy. 0 Are we ready for this after 30 years of talking about it? Can we air our dirty laundry in public? Can we build the public will to do what we need to do? What we've been doing and how we have been talking about it has not worked. How can we position the issue differently? Message Recommendations: The President could build on his message of two more years of post-secondary ed, by emphasizing two more years of education before children enter elementary school. We must get the schools ready for the child and the child ready for the schools. Education is a journey and setting the child out on the journey without good early care and education is like trying to start without gas in the car. ) We must resolve to move toward a national system of affordable child care for the masses. However, a national system does not equal a national delivery system. 0 It is unacceptable for an American child to come to Kindergarten not ready to learn. This is a war and we're going to win it. 0 "Good child care is competitive business.' We must view this as a part of America's competitive spirit and a 1 necessity to give us the competitive edge in the global marketplace. One of our country's fundamental principles is that we must educate our people to have an informed, responsible citizens in our democracy, yet we fail to build on our principles when we neglect the education of children from infancy. Child care is not babysitting. All providers, from relatives to center-based providers, are teachers. Strategy Recommendations: Establish a process out in the field to prepare for the conference by running focus groups all over the country, lining up partners in communities, etc. Position the President as the "Working Family President" and link this initiative with the Family and Medical Leave Act, EITC, etc. Work with the Cabinet Secretaries (Daley, Shalala, and Hermann were mentioned) as a group to act on the cross- cutting issues around work, family, and child care. Have them lead the way by streamlining Federal child care activities and setting an example for the private sector. Use the Presidential bully pulpit to maximal effectiveness by building public will to support related legislation. Focus on employers, large, small, and ambivalent. Recognize that they fall on a continuum with regard to how far they have addressed the child care (work/family) agenda. Don't just focus on the employers who are already partners. Use CEO's who were in child care as children to deliver the message. Dollars tend to follow business leaders. Focus on funding. Don't be shy to talk about funding as an issue. Establish a child care investment fund, using the administrative skill and investment knowledge of the private sector. Make it a public/private partnership possibly through matching of community investments. Encourage business leaders to integrate their current programs into a multilateral approach to the work/family/child care issues. For instance, have the priorities of the corporate foundation in line with the employee initiatives in the human resource area and family- focused public relations campaigns. Leverage off of K-12 involvement and support programs already underway in the corporate sector. Incorporate child care into the various programs like "Adopt-A-School" programs. 2 Have a concrete product that comes out of the conference. Provide earmarked student loans for early childhood education and training. Provide loan abatement or lower interest rate incentives to those who remain in the field 3- 4 years. Maximize the use of our infrastructure by mandating that school buildings remain open full day/full year. Provide state and local governments with strategies to finance the extra hours (e.g., allowing community groups to use the space.) Change the perception of providers by recognizing leading teachers in the field, especially young teachers, to showcase quality and change the professional image. Link every other Presidential initiative to young children and working families. Conference Program Recommendations: Link early childhood to K-12 education agenda. Focus on how to build a more cohesive system with partners in a variety of sectors. Explore ways to recruit and retain good people in the field. It gets harder every year to attract talented people and harder to retain them. Focus on child care as a continuum from infancy through adolescence. Concerns: : : you preach to the converted, you will accomplish nothing. The private sector models that are currently underway are primarily for families that can afford to pay. The private sector needs better strategies for dealing with low-wage workers. The military model does not work in the private sector because it relies to heavily on universal subsidy and lacks the element of competition that is central to the private employer. When linking with other systems, be aware that many delivery systems, especially school systems, are ineffective with families because they fail to understand cultural/linguistic diversity. Don't advocate a one-size-fíts-all approach. Some communities may have strong school/educational systems on which to build, while others have a strong network of community-based organizations. 3 Be aware of the potential to increase tension between those who can afford to pay and those who cannot. 4 White House Conference Focus Group June 30, 1997 Participants: Larry Aber, National Center for Children in Poverty Judy Appelbaum, National Women's Law Center Doug Baird, Associated Day Care, Boston Barbara Bowman, Erikson Institute John Brooks, YMCA of the USA Barbara Clinton, Vanderbilt Center for Health Services Angela Crowley, Nat'l Assoc. of Pediatric Nurse Associates & Practitioners Jerlean Daniel, Univ. of Pittsburgh & NAEYC Elaine Fersh, Parents United for Child Care Nancy Kolben, Child Care, Inc., New York Anne Mitchell, Early Childhood Policy Research Patty Siegel, Calif. Child Care Resources & Referral Network Sandra Skolnik, Maryland Committee for Children Rhea Starr, YWCA of the USA Bernice Weissbourd, Family Focus and Family Resource Center Lynn White, National Child Care Association First Thoughts Upon Hearing About the Conference: ) " How do we go from dialogue to action?" 0 " An opportunity will be missed if it is just a conference. There must be a strong follow-on plan." " Will he include school-aged children?" " How will he sell it to the country?" , " This is a point in a long history, but a critical one. " Message Recommendations: 0 Working families in America use child care every day. But what do they currently have access to and how do we build to meet their needs? "The strength of the current system is diversity. The weakness of the current system is how ad hoc it is." Access to quality is a national priority. Child care is not just of concern to the child care community. It is everyone's concern. Child care is a piece of the bridge to the twenty-first century. Partnerships are necessary to get the job done. There must be solutions on various scales. 1 Strategy Recommendations: Use the following frame: The President and First Lady articulate a vision of good child care across America. List the essential elements that are required to fulfill the vision. Emphasize that there is a lot of work to do and give people direction on the first steps. Check up on progress periodically. Obtain pledges and commitments (perhaps in advance) and then track and follow-up to ensure that they are carried out, like with the volunteer summit. Force accountability. Use child care as one mechanism through which the President can accomplish his other literacy and education goals. Launch a commission to investigate financing and ask the large companies to ante up into a huge public/private investment fund. The President must put money on the table, but use it to leverage other funds. Spawn similar conferences on a State and local scale with Governors and their spouses and local leaders. Place the exorbitant cost of quality child care in the context of the cost of higher education, to which people already relate. Foster the support of the middle class. Conference Program Recommendations: Confront the issue of resources, which is central and lacking. The child care system that we talk about is expensive and we shouldn't pretend that it is not, however :: saves money in the long run. Without a solid infrastructure and a 10 or 20 year roadmap, we won't get there. Cost out a real, comprehensive, quality system. If you had accurately predicted for people five years ago the level of the current new investment, they would have been happy, but now they feel it is still inadequate, because we lack an understanding of the actual scope of the need and a sense of what is required to address it. Make the connection to working families, especially the working poor, and portray child care as a crucial element in keeping parent (s) in the labor force. Focus on the silent customer in child care, which is the employer of the parent. Recognize that corporations' understanding of and efforts to address the child care situation fall along a continuum. Do not neglect small employers. 2 Bring in the governors, mayors, business leaders, school leaders, and others to sell child care to different constituencies in the country. Have police chiefs sell it to police chiefs, superintendents to superintendents, etc Include unlikely allies like the labor unions, religious organizations, medical professionals, law enforcement, and the banking and finance industries. People will notice the messengers and what they represent. Give people focused recommendations for action and homework, so that they know what they are supposed to do the day after the conference. Have children speak about their experiences in child care settings of varying quality. Consider the delivery system very broadly. No matter where children are cared for, from relative care to center-based care, quality care in the first decade of a child's life is crucial to development. Connect the conference to the brain research to better demonstrate why early investment in children is important. Help parents understand what quality child care is from infancy through school-age. Have working parents speak for themselves. Highlight diverse parents and have them describe what they need from employers, from schools, etc. Give participants pre-work to do before they attend the conference. Each participant should investigate the state of child care in his or her community. Highlight child care as a system with an infrastructure and infrastructure needs, like facility and staff development. Ask: What policies can we have to ensure that all eligible children get good care? Include children's health, parents' health, and parental support. Use data to make the point. Avoid highlighting models that may not be transferable to other settings. Highlight only things which have the potential to be universal- not a cookie cutter, but a blueprint. Concerns: 0 Be aware of the frustration that is building from rehashing the same problems over and over again. Rather than exacerbate the frustration, highlight potential solutions. 3 Withdrawal/Redaction Marker Clinton Library DOCUMENT NO. SUBJECT/TITLE DATE RESTRICTION AND TYPE 001. list White House Women's Office Child Care Advocates Meeting (partial) 12/12/1997 P6/b(6) (2 pages) COLLECTION: Clinton Presidential Records First Lady's Office Domestic Policy Council (Nicole Rabner) OA/Box Number: 15414 FOLDER TITLE: Child Care Focus Group Meetings 2012-1035-S kc 1021 RESTRICTION CODES Presidential Records Act - 144 U.S.C. 2204(a)] Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.C. 552(b)] P1 National Security Classified Information [(a)(1) of the PRAJ b(1) National security classified information |(b)(1) of the FOIA] P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office |(a)(2) of the PRA] h(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of P3 Release would violate a Federal statute |(a)(3) of the PRA] an agency [(b)(2) of the FOIA| P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute [(b)(3) of the FOIA] financial information [(a)(4) of the PRA| b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President information [(b)(4) of the FOIA] and his advisors, or between such advisors [a)(5) of the PRA| b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy |(b)(6) of the FOIA] personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRA] b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement purposes [(b)(7) of the FOIA] C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of of gift. financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA] PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C. b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information 2201(3). concerning wells |(b)(9) of the FOIA] RR. Document will be reviewed upon request. ccad.wpd Page 1 [001] WHITE HOUSE WOMEN'S OFFICE CHILD CARE ADVOCATES MEETING December 12, 1997 5:00 PM - 6:00 PM Room 180, Old Executive Office Building Name/Organization D.O.B/SS#/Country Phone Number Yasmina Vinci 393-5501 P6/(b)(6) National Association of Child Care Resource and USA Referral Sammie Moshenberg 296-2588 National Council on P6/(b)(6) Jewish Women USA Barabara Willer 232-8777 P6/(b)(6) National Association for Education of Young USA Children Judy Appelbaum 588-5180 P6/(b)(6) WLC USA Karen Nussbaum 637-5064 AFL-CIO P6/(b)(6) USA Nancy Duff Cambell 588-5180 P6/(b)(6) National Women's Law Center USA Nancy Zirkin 785-7720 P6/(b)(6) AAUW USA Joan Entmacher 986-2600 WLDF Pat Reuss 544-4470 NOW LDF Lynn White 1-800-543-7161 National Child Care Association Nancy Granese 637-5697 Hogan & Hartson Sharon Daly P6/(b)(6) Catholic Charities USA [001 ccad wpd Page 2 Nancy Wisdo P6/(b)(6) U.S. Catholic Conference USA Nicole Poersch, surrogate 662-3545 P6/(b)(6) for Helen Blank Children's Defense Fund USA Carabelle Pizzagatti Child Welfare League Mary Cooper P6/(b)(6) National Council of Churches USA Faith Wohl 212-239-0138 Childcare Action Campaign Carolyn York, surrogate 429-5090 P6/(b)(6) for Kathy Colette AFSCME USA Gloria Johnson 785-7209 Coalition of Labor Union Women Elena Kagan 6-5584 DPC Maria Echaveste 6-6594 OPL Jen Klein 6-2599 DPC Nicole Rabner 6-6266 DPC Gene Sperling 6-2620 NEC Joan Lombardi 401-6947 HHS/Childcare Bureau Audrey Tayse Haynes 6-7300 Women's Office Robin Leeds 6-7300 Women's Office Withdrawal/Redaction Marker Clinton Library DOCUMENT NO. SUBJECT/TITLE DATE RESTRICTION AND TYPE 002. list [participants] (partial) (1 page) nd P6/b(6) COLLECTION: Clinton Presidential Records First Lady's Office Domestic Policy Council (Nicole Rabner) OA/Box Number: 15414 FOLDER TITLE: Child Care Focus Group Meetings 2012-1035-S kc1021 RESTRICTION CODES Presidential Records Act - |44 U.S.C. 2204(a)] Freedom of Information Act - [5 U.S.C. 552(b)] PI National Security Classified Information [(a)(1) of the PRA] b(1) National security classified information |(b)(1) of the FOIA| P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office |(a)(2) of the PRA] b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of P3 Release would violate a Federal statute |(a)(3) of the PRA] an agency [(b)(2) of the FOIA| P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute |(b)(3) of the FOIA] financial information [(a)(4) of the PRA] b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President information [(b)(4) of the FOIA] and his advisors, or between such advisors |a)(5) of the PRAJ b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy |(b)(6) of the FOIA] personal privacy |(a)(6) of the PRA] b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement purposes |(b)(7) of the FOIA] C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of of gift. financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA] PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C. b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information 2201(3). concerning wells |(b)(9) of the FOIA] RR. Document will be reviewed upon request. [002] Jennifer Klein Donna M. Klein Director Work/Life Programs Marriott International Marriott Drive Washington, DC 20058 Rhea F. Starr Child Care Advocate YWCA of the USA 624 9th Street, NW Washington, DC 20001 Sheryl Dicker Executive Director Permanent Judicial Commission on Justice for Children c/o Pace University School of Law 78 North Broadway White Plains, New York 10603 Nancy Thompson The Annenberg/ CPB Project 901 E Street, NW Washington, DC 20004 Joyce E. Butler P6/(b)(6) Providence, Rhode Island 02906 Karen A. Cowles Communications Consortium Media Center 1200 New York Avenue, NW Suite 300 Washington, DC 20005-1754 Kerby T. Alvy, Ph.D. Executive Director Center for the Improvement of Child Caring 11331 Ventura Blvd., Suite 103 Studio City, California 91604 Ruby Takanishi President Foundation for Child Development 345 East 46 Street New York, NY 10017-3562 Mildred M. Winter Executive Director Parents as Teachers National Center, Inc. 10176 Corporate Square Drive, Suite 230 St. Louis, Missouri 63132 Yasmina Vinci Executive Director, NACCRRA 1319 F Street, NW, Suite 810 Washington, DC 20004-1106 Tutti Sherlock Board Chair, Child Care Aware 1319 F Street, NW, Suite 810 Washington, DC 20004-1106 Giovanna Stark Executive Director Child Development Policy Advisory Committee 915 Capitol Mall, Room 336 Sacramento, CA 95814 Angela Crowley Co-Chair, Child Care Special Interest Group Yale University School of Nursing 100 Church Street South PO Box 9740 New Haven, CT 06536-0740 Kristy Liles Publicis Public Relations 3500 Maple Avenue Dallas, TX 75219 Augusta Souza Kappner President The Bank Street College of Education 610 West 112th St. New York, NY 10025-1120 Janet L. Mascia Senior Evaluator U.S. General Accounting Office 441 G Street, NW Washington, DC 20548 Carrie Wofford 200 Constitution Ave, NW, Room S3002 Washington, DC 20210 Nicole Rabner Carey Fleming Director of Corporate Alliances Work Life Benefits 539 Fernwood Road Murrells Inlet, SC 29576 Roger H. Brown Chief Executive Officer Bright Horizons Children's Centers One Kendall Square, Building 200 Cambridge, MA 02139 Rosemary Jordano President Children First Inc. One International Place Boston, MA 02110 Dee Topol President The Travelers Foundation 388 Greenwich Street New York, NY 10013 Claudia E. Wayne National Center for the Early Childhood Work Force 733 15th Street, NW, Suite 1037 Washington, DC 20005-2112 Lynn L. White Executive Director, NCCA 1016 Rosser Street Conyers, GA 30207 Charles R. Romeo Director, Employee Benefits Con Agra Refrigerated Foods Companies 2000 South Batavia Avenue Geneva, IL 60134 Anna S. Wadia Senior Program Officer Ms. Foundation for Women 120 Wall Street, 33rd Floor New York, NY 10005 Ellen Clippinger President National School-Age Care Alliance 4720 North Park Indianapolis, IN 46205 Madeline Fried Fried & Sher, Inc. 465 Carlisle Drive Herndon, VA 20170 Stacie G. Goffin Senior Program Officer Youth Development Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation 4900 Oak Kansas City, Missouri 64112-2776 Deborah Lowe Vandell NICHD Study of Early Child Care Wisconsin Center for Education Research University of Wisconsin School of Education 1025 West Johnson Street Madison, WI 53706 Martha Farrell Erickson, Ph.D. Director of Children, Youth, and Family Consortium University of Minnesota 12 McNeal Hall 1985 Buford Avenue St. Paul, MN 55108 Matthew E. Melmed Executive Director, Zero to Three 734 15th Street, NW, Suite 1000 Washington, DC 20005-1013 Margaret M. Petruska Senior Program Officer and Director HHS Programs The Heinz Endowments 30 CNG Tower 625 Liberty Avenue Pittsburg, PA 15222-3115 Kathy Bonk Executive Director, CCMC 1200 New York Avenue, NW, Suite 300 Washington, DC 20005-1754 Helen Blank Director, Child Care Division Children's Defense Fund 25 E Street, N.W. Washington, DC 20001 WHITE HOUSE MEETING ON CHILD CARE Monday, June 23, 1997 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Carol Brunson-Phillips Executive Director Council for Early Childhood Professional Recognition 2460 16th Street NW Washington, DC 20009-3575 800-424-4310 Voyce Butler USA Child Care KCMC Child Development Corporation 2104 East 18th Street Kansas City, MO 64127-2524 (816) 474-0434 Deborah Eaton President National Association for Family Child Care 9167 Berkview Lane Spring Valley, CA 91977 (619) 466-8340 Abby Griffin Zero to Three National Center for Infants, Toddlers and Families 734 15th Street, N.W. Suite 1000 Washington, D.C. 20005-1013 (202)638-1144 Janice Guerney American Academy for Pediatrics 601 13th Street, NW, Suite 400 North Washington, D.C. 20005 (202) 347-8600 Bruce Hershfield Director, Child Day Care Services Child Welfare League of America 440 First Street, NW, Suite 310 Washington, DC 20001-2085 (202) 638-2952 x291 VEvelyn Moore President National Black Child Development Institute 1023 15th Street, NW, Suite 600 Washington, DC 20005 (202) 387-1281 *** * Charleen Muhammad** replaced Billie Young -- call for address/phone of Muhammad -- Seattle, WA 206/386-1143 Billie Osbourne-Fears Starting Point for Child Care & Early Education 3135 Euclid, Suite 200 Cleveland, OH 44115 (216) 431-1818 Julie Quaid Director Confederated Tribes of the Warm Spring Reservation P.O. Box C 1257 Kot-Num Road Warm Springs, OR 97761 (541) 553-3240 Susan Russell Executive Director Day Care Services Association P.O. Box 901 Chapel Hill, NC 27514 (919) 967-3272 Michelle Seligson Executive Director School Age Child Care Project Center for Research on Women Wellesley College 106 Central Street Wellesley, MA 02181 (617) 283-2547 Heather Weiss Harvard Family Research Project Harvard Graduate School of Education 38 Concord Ave. Cambridge, MA 02138 (617) 495-9108 WHITE HOUSE MEETING ON CHILD CARE Monday, June 30, 1997 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Larry Aber National Center for Children in Poverty Columbia University School of Public Health 154 Haven Avenue New York, N.Y. 10032 (212) 304-7100 Gordon M. Ambach Executive Director Council of Chief State School Officers 1 Massachusetts Avenue NW, Suite 700 Washington, DC 20001-1431 (202) 408-5505 Judy Applebaum National Women's Law Center 11 Dupont Circle, NW, Suite 800 Washington, DC 20036 (202) 588-5180 Doug Baird Associated Day Care Services 95 Berkeley Street, Suite 306 Boston, MA 02116 (617) 695-0700 VDr. Barbara Bowman Erikson Institute for Advanced Study of Child Development 420 North Wabash Avenue Chicago, IL 60611 (312) 755-2250 VJohn Brooks Senior Public Policy Associate YMCA 1701 K Street, NW, Suite 903 Washington, DC 20006 (202) 835-9043 Barbara Clinton Director Center for Health Services Vanderbilt University Station 17 Nashville, TN 37232-8180 (615) 322-4773 Angela Crowley, MA, APRN, CS, PNP Associate Professor Yale University School of Nursing 100 Church Street South P.O. Box 9740 New Haven, CT 06536-0740 (203) 737-2548 Dr. Jerlean Daniels Program in Child Development and Child Care 1717 Cathedral of Learning University of Pittsburgh Pittsburgh, PA 15260 (412) 624-6356 Elaine Fersh Director Parents United for Child Care 30 Winter Street, 7th Floor Boston, MA 02108-4720 (617) 426-8288 Nancy Kolben Child Care Inc. 275 Seventh Avenue New York, N.Y. 10001 (212) 929-7604 Anne Mitchell Early Childhood Policy Research HCR 1, Box 77 Climax, N.Y. 12042 (518) 966-4585 Gail Richardson Acting Executive Director Child Care Action Campaign 330 7th Avenue, 17th Floor New York, N.Y. 10001 (212) 268-6515 VPatty Siegel California Child Care Resouce & Referral Network 111 New Montgomery Street, 7th Floor San Francisco, CA 94105 (415) 882-0234 Sandra Skolnik Executive Director Maryland Committee for Children, Inc. 608 Water Street Baltimore, MD 21202 (410) 752-7588 Rhea Starr Child Care Advocate YWCA of the USA 726 Broadway New York, NY 10003 (212) 614-2700 Bernice Weissbourd President, Family Focus Family Resource Coalition 310 South Peoria Street Suite 510 Chicago, IL 60607 (312) 421-5200 VLynn White National Child Care Association 1016 Rosser Street Conyers, GA 30012 800-543-7161 * WHITE HOUSE MEETING ON CHILD CARE Wednesday, June 25, 1997 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Randi Botnick Benton Foundation 1634 Eye Street, NW, 12th Floor Washington, DC 20006 (202) 638-5770 Kathleen Christensen Program Officer Alfred P. Sloan Foundation 630 Fifth Avenue, Suite 2550 New York, N.Y. 10111-0242 (212) 649-1649 Deanna Gomby David and Lucille Packard Foundation Center for the Future of Children 300 Second Street, Suite 102 Los Altos, CA 94022 (415) 948-3696 Mary Larner David and Lucille Packard Foundation Center for the Future of Children 300 Second Street, Suite 102 Los Altos, CA 94022 (415) 948-3696 Michael Levine Carnegie Corporation of New York 437 Madison Avenue New York, N.Y. 10022 (212) 371-3200 Luba Lynch A.L. Mailman Family Foundation 707 Westchester Avenue White Plains, N.Y. 10604 (914) 681-4448 Margaret Petruska Director Health and Human Services Programs The Howard Heinz Endowment 30 CNG Tower Pittsburgh, PA 15222 (412) 338-2615 Linda Rich Pew Charitable Trusts One Commerce Square 2005 Market Street, Suite 1700 Philadelphia, PA 19103-7017 (215) 575-4866 Pam Stevens Program Officer DeWitt Wallace - Reader's Digest Fund 2 Park Avenue, 23rd Floor New York, N.Y. 10016 (212) 251-9714 Ruby Takaneshi Foundation for Child Development 345 East 46th Street, Room 700 New York, N.Y. 10017-3562 (212) 697-3150 Dee Topel*** Traveler's Foundation 388 Greenwich Street New York, N.K. 10013 (212) 816-8000 WHITE HOUSE MEETING ON CHILD CARE Friday, June 20, 1997 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Gordon M. Ambach Executive Director Council of Chief State School Officers 1 Massachusetts Avenue NW, Suite 700 Washington, DC 20001-1431 (202) 408-5505 Barbara Ferguson Kamara DC Dept. of Human Services Office of Early Childhood Development 717 14th Street NW, #730 Washington, DC 20005 (202) 727-1839 Ellen Galinsky Co-President Families and Work Institute 330 Seventh Avenue, 14th Floor New York, N.Y. 10001 (212) 465-2044 Melinda Green Executive Director The Child Care Connection, Inc. 2425 Pennington Road Trenton, NJ 08638 (609) 737-9243 Roberta Malavenda Deputy Director for Programs Save the Children Child Care Support Center 1447 Peachtree Street NE, Suite 700 Atlanta, GA 30309 (404) 479-4202 Carole Quaterman Project Director The Family Place 8726 Woodward Avenue Detroit, MI 48202 (313) 664-0700 Nancy Sconyers National Association of Child Advocates Suite 600 1522 K Street, NW Washington, DC 20006-1202 (202) 289-0777 Tutti Sherlock Minnesota R & R Network 2116 Campus Drive SE Rochester, MN 55904 (507) 287-2020 Gail Solit Director Gallaudet University Child Development Center Kendall School, 3rd Floor 800 Florida Avenue, NE Washington, DC 20004 (202) 651-5130 Alice Walker-Duff Executive Director Crystal Stairs 5105 W. Gold Leaf Circle Los Angeles, CA 90056 (213) 299-8998 Barbara Willer National Association for the Education of Young Children 1509 16th Street, NW Washington, DC 20036 800-424-2460 WHITE HOUSE MEETING ON CHILD CARE Friday, June 27, 1997 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Margaret Browning Director, Work/Life Benefit Programs Mentor Graphics 8005 SW Boeckman Road Wilsonville, OR 97070 (503) 685-7997 VJ.T. Childs Director, Workforce Diversity IBM Route 9 Town of Mount Pleasant North Tarrytown, N.Y. 10591 (914) 332-2000 Michael Day Brighter Horizons Children's Centers One Kendall Square, Bldg. 200 Cambridge, MA 02139 (617)-577-8020 Madeline Fried Principal Fried and Sher 465 Carlisle Drive Herndon, VA 20170 (703) 435-1700 Dana Friedman Senior Vice President Corporate Family Solutions 14 Vanderventer Avenue, Suite 145 Port Washington, N.Y. 11050 (516) 767-3957 Rosemary Jordano President Children First, Inc. One International Place, 7th Floor Boston, MA 02110 (617) 330-8687 Chris Kjeldsen Vice President, Community & Workplace Programs Johnson & Johnson One Johnson & Johnson Plaza New Brunswick, N.J 08933 (732) 524-0400 Donna Klein Director, Work-Life Program Marriott International, Inc. One Marriott Drive, Apt. 93512 Washington, D.C. 20058 (301) 380-6856 Marykay Leonard Work Family Directions 930 Commonwealth Avenue Boston, MA 02215 800-346-1535 Barbara Reisman Executive Director Schumann Fund for New Jersey 21 Van Vleck Street Montclaire, N.J. 07042 (201) 509-9883 Charles R. Romeo Director, Employee Benefits ConAgra Refrigerated Foods Companies 2000 South Batavia Avenue Geneva, IL 60134 (630) 262-4067 WHITE HOUSE MEETING ON CHILD CARE Wednesday, June 18, 1997 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Helen Blank Director Child Care Division Children's Defense Fund 25 E Street, N.W. Washington, DC 20001 (202) 628-8787 Jeanne Brooks-Gunn, Ph.D Virginia & Leonard Marx Professor Center for Young Children and Families Teacher's College Columbia University 525 West 120th Street, Box 39 New York, N.Y. 10027 (212) 678-3338 Ellen Clippinger President National School Age Care Alliance 4720 North Park Ave. Indianapolis, IN 46205 (317) 283-3817 Townley Hritz National Head Start Association 1651 Prince Street Alexandria, VA 22314 (703) 739-0875 Sharon Lynn Kagan Yale University Bush Center in Child Development and Social Policy 310 Prospect Street New Haven, CT 06511 (203) 432-9931 Claudia Wayne National Center for the Early Childhood Workforce 733 15th Street, NW, Suite 1037 Washington, DC 20005 (202) 737-7700 Janet Wise National Indian Child Care Association P.O. Box 580 Okmulgee, OK 74447 (918) 758-1463 Mr. Larry Aber Mr. Gordon Ambach National Center for Children in Poverty Executive Director Columbia University School of Public Health Council of Chief State Schools Officers 154 Haven Avenue 1 Massachusetts Avenue, NW Ney York, NY 10032 Suite 700 Washington, DC 20001-1431 Ms. Helen Blank Ms. Ellen Clippinger Director, Child Care Division President Children's Defense Fund National School Age Care Alliance 25 E. Street, NW 4720 North Park Washington, DC 20001 Indianapolis, IN 46205 Ms. Angela Crowley Ms. Elaine Fersh National Association of Pediatric Nurse Associates and Director Practioners Parents United for Child Care 566 Broadview Road 30 Winter Street, 7th Floor Orange, CT 06477 Boston, MA 02108-5720 Ms. Melinda Green Ms. Sophia Harris Executive Director FOCAL The Child Care Connection, Inc. PO Box 214 2425 Pennington Road Montgomery, AL 36101 Trenton, NJ 08638 Mr. Luis Hernandez Ms. Sharon Lynn Kagan Metropolitan Dade County Child Development Services Resource Yale University and Referral Bush Center for Child Development in Social Policy 111 NW Street, Suite 2210 310 Prospect Street Miami, FL 33128 New Haven, CT 06520 Ms. Deena Lahn Ms. Antonia Lopez Child Care Law Center National Council of La Raza 22 Second Street, 5th floor 111 19th Street, NW San Francisco, CA 94105 Suite 1000 Washington, DC 20036 Ms. Evelyn Moore Ms. Gwen Morgan Executive Director Center for Career Development in Early Care and Education National Black Child Development Institute Wheelock College 1023 15th Street, NW 200 The River Way Suite 600 Boston, MA 02215 Washington, DC 20005 Ms. Gail Richardson Ms. Deborah Vandell Acting Executive Director University of Wisconsin Child Care Action Campaign Department of Education 330 7th Avenue, 17th Floor 1025 West Johnson New York, NY 10001 Madison WI, 53706 Ms. Janet Wise Mr. Billie Young National Indian Child Care Association Manager 279 East 137th Street Child Development Programs Glenpool, OK 74033 Family and Youth Services 618 2nd Avenue, 4th Floor Seattle, WA 98104-2232 Ms. Becky Barerra Mr. John Brooks National Latino Children's Agenda Senior Public Policy Associate 1611 West 6th Street YMCA Austin, TX 78703 1701 K Street, NW Suite 903 Washington, DC 20006 Ms. Barbara Clinton Ms. Martha Erickson Director Children, Youth, and Family Consortium Center for Health Services University of Minnesota Vanderbilt University 12 McNeal Hall Station 17 1985 Buford Avenue Nashville, TN 37232-8180 St. Paul, MN 55108 Ms. Barbara Ferguson Kamara Ms. Nancy Kolben DC Dept. of Human Services Child Care, Inc. Office of Early Childhood Development 275 Seventh Avenue 717 14th Street, NW #730 New York, NY 10001 Washington, DC 20005 Ms. Ellen Galinsky Ms. Sarah Greene Co-President CEO Families and Work Institute National Head Start Association 330 Seventh Avenue, 14th Floor 1651 Prince Street New York, NY 10001 Alexandria, VA 22314 Mr. Ronald Lally Ms. Roberta Malavenda Director Deputy Director for Programs Center for Child and Family Studies Save the Children Child Care Support Program WestEd 1447 Peachtree Street, NE 180 Harbor Dr., Suite 112 Suite 700 Sausalito, CA 94965 Atlanta, GA 30309 Ms. Deborah Phillips Ms. Carole Quarterman Staff Director Project Director National Research Council Board on Children, Youth and The Family Place Families 8726 Woodward Avenue 2101 Constitution Avenue, NW Detroit, MI 48202 Harris Bldg, Room 156 Washington, DC 20418 Ms. Nancy Sconyers Ms. Michelle Seligson National Association of Child Advocates Executive Director Suite 600 School Age Child Care Project 1522 K Street, NW Wellesley College Washington, DC 20006-1202 Center for Research on Women Wellesley, MA 02181 Ms. Gail Solit Ms. Yasmina Vinci Director Executive Director Gallaudet University Child Development Center National Association of Child Care Resource and Referral Kendall School, 3rd Floor Agencies 800 Florida Avenue, NE 1319 F Street, NW Washington, DC 20002 Suite 810 Washington, DC 20004 Ms. Alice Walker-Duff Ms. Lynn White Executive Director National Child Care Association Crystal Stairs 1029 Railroad Street 5105 W. Gold Leaf Circle Conyers, GA 30207 Los Angeles, CA 90056 Ms. Barbara Willer Mr. Ron Areglado National Association for the Education of Young Children Associate Executive Director for Programs 1509 16th Street, NW National Association of Elementary School Principles Washington, DC 20036 1515 Duke Street Alexandria, VA 22314-3483 Ms. Duffy Campbell Ms. Deborah Eaton National Women's Law Center President 11 Dupont Circle, NW National Association for Family Child Care Suite 800 9167 Berkview Lane Washington, DC 20036 Spring Valley, CA 91977 Ms. Billie Warford Mr. Bruce Hershfield Montana Early Childhood Project Director, Child Day Care Services 117 Herrick Hall Child Welfare League of America Montana State University 440 First Street, NW Bozeman, MT 59717 Suite 310 Washington, DC 20001-2085 Mr. Matthew Melmed Ms. Billie Osbourne-Fears Executive Director Starting Point for Child Care & Early Education Zero to Three 3135 Euclid, Suite 301 National Center for Clinical Infant Programs Cleveland, OH 44115 734 15th Street, NW, 10th Floor Washington, DC 20005-2101 Dr. Robert Hannenmann Dr. James Poole American Academy of Pediatrics American Academy of Pediatrics- North Carolina 2600 Greenbush Street 270 Horizon Drive Lafayette, IN 47904 Raleigh, NC 27615 Ms. Julie Quaid Ms. Susan Russell Director Executive Director Confederated Tribes of the Warm Springs Reservation Day Care Services Association PO Box C PO Box 901 1257 Kot-Num Road Chapel Hill, NC 27514 Warm Springs, OR 97761 Ms. Tutti Sherlock Ms. Patty Siegel Minnesota R & R Network California Child Care Institute 2116 Campus Drive, SE California Resource & Referral Network Rochester, MN 55904 111 New Montgomery Street, 7th floor San Francisco, CA 94105 Ms. Rhea Starr Ms. Shirley Stubbs-Gillette Child Care Advocate USA Child Care YWCA of the USA KCMC Child Development Corporation 512 Bean Blosom Drive 2104 East 18th Street Lancaster, PA 17603 Kansas City, MO 64127-2524 Ms. Claudia Wayne Ms. Heather Weiss National Center for the Early Chilhood Workforce Harvard Family Research Project 733 15th Street, NW Harvard Graduate School of Education Suite 800 Longfellow Hall Washington, DC 20005 Appian Way Cambridge, MA 02138 Ms. Bernice Weissbourd Mr. Norman Yee President, Family Focus Executive Director Family Resource Coalition Wu Yee Children's Services 310 South Peoria Street 831 Broadway Suite 510 San Francisco Chicago, IL 60607 CA, 94108 Ms. Kathleen Christensen Mr. Larry Kirkman Program Officer Executive Director Alfred P. Sloan Foundation Benton Foundation Suite 2550 1634 Eye Street, NW 630 Fifth Avenue Washington, DC 20006 New York, NY 10111-0242 Ms. Mary Larner Ms. Deanna Gombey David and Lucille Packard Foundtion David and Lucille Packard Foundation Center for the Future of Children Center for the Future of Children 300 Second Street, Suite 102 300 Second Street, Suite 102 Los Altos, CA 94022 Los Altos, CA 94022 Mr. Michael Levine Ms. Janet Levy Carnegie Corporation of New York Annie E. Casey Foundation 437 Madison Avenue 701 St. Paul Street New York, NY 10022 Baltimore, MD 21202 Ms. Luba Lynch Ms. Janice Molnar A.L. Mailman Famly Foundation Ford Foundation 707 Westchester Avenue Urban Poverty Program White Plains, NY 10604 320 East 43rd Street New York, NY 10017 Ms. Marge Patrusca Ms. Barbara Reisman Director Executive Director Health and Human Services Programs Schumann Fund of New Jersey The Howard Heinz Endowment 21 Van Vleck Street 330 CNG Tower Montclaire, NJ 07042 Pittsburgh, PA 15222 Ms. Linda Rich Ms. Pam Stevens Pew Charitable Trusts Program Officer One Commerce Square DeWitt Wallace -- Reader's Digest Fund 200 Market Street, Suite 1700 2 Park Avenue, 23rd Floor Philadelphia, PA 19103-7017 New York, NY 10016 Ms. Ruby Takaneshi Ms. Dee Topel Foundation for Child Development Traveler's Foundation 345 East 46th Street 388 Greenwich Street Room 700 New York, NY 10013 New York, NY 10017-3562 Ms. Valora Washington Ms. Wilma Wells W.K. Kellogg Foundation The Danforth Foundation One Michigan Avenue East 231 South Bemiston Avenue Battle Creek, MI 49017-4058 Suite 1080 St Louis, MO 63105-1996 Ms. Caroline Zinnser Dr. Stacie Goffin Rockefeller Brothers Fund Ewing Marion:Kauffman Foundation 1290 Avenue of the Americas 4900 Oak Street Room 3450 Kansas City, MO 64112-2776 New York, NY 10104 Mr. Roger Brown Ms. Margaret Browning Chief Executive Officer Director, Work/Life Benefit Programs Bright Horizons Children's Centers Mentor Graphics One Kendall Square 8005 SW Boeckman Road Building 200 Wilsonville, OR 97068 Cambridge, MA 02139 Mr. Ted Childs Ms. Madeline Fried Director, Workforce Diversity Principal IBM Fried and Scher Route 9 465 Carlisle Drive Town of Mount Pleasant Herndon, VA 20170 North Tarrytown, NY 10591 Ms. Dana Friedman Ms. Kimberly Hains Senior Vice President Senior Vice President for Work and Family Corporate Family Solutions Nationsbank Suite 145 NCI-021-02-05 14 Vanderventer Avenue 401 North Trycon Street Port Washington, NY 11050 Charlotte, NC 28255 Ms. Rosemary Jordano Mr. Chris Kjeldsen President Vice President, Community & Workplace Programs Children First, Inc. Johnson & Johnson One International Place One Johnson & Johnson Plaza 7th Floor New Brunswick, NJ 08933 Boston, MA 02110 Ms. Donna Klein Ms. Fran Rodgers Director, Work-Life Program Work Family Directions Marriott International 930 Commonwealth Avenue West 10400 Fernwood Road Boston, MA 02215 Bethesda, MD 20817 Mr. Charles Romeo Ms. Kathy Zweber Director, Employee Benefits Director, Work Life and Wellness Initiatives ConAgra Refrigerated Foods Companies Motorola 2000 South Batavia Avenue 1303 East Algonquin Road Geneva, IL 60134 Schaumberg, IL 60196 Dr. Barbara Bowman Dr. Jerlean Daniels Erikson Institute for Advanced Study of Child Development University of Pittsburgh 420 North Wabash Avenue Cathedral of Learning, Room 1717 Chicago IL, 60611 4200 Fifth Avenue Pittsburgh PA, 15260 Ms. Anne Mitchell Ms. Louise Stoney Early Childhood Policy Research Louise Stoney Associates HCR 1 Box 77 10 Tillinghast Ave. Honey Hollow Road Albany NY, 12204 Climax NY, 12042 Mr. Doug Baird Ms. Susan Muenchow Associated Day Care Services Florida Children's Forum 95 Berkeley Street, 3rd Floor 259 East 7th Avenue Boston MA, 02116 Tallahassee FL, 32308 Ms. Bobbie Webber CCR&R of Linn and Benton Counties Department of Family Resources 6500 SW Pacific Blvd. Albany OR, 97321 THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON June 9, 1997 Mr. Larry Aber National Center for Children in Poverty Columbia University School of Public Health 154 Haven Avenue Ney York, NY 10032 Dear Mr. Aber: Improving the quality, accessibility and affordability of child care in our country is a priority for the President and his Administration. As you may know, the President recently announced that he and the First Lady will host a White House Conference on Child Care this fall to explore the strengths and weaknesses of child care delivery and discuss ways to improve it. Because we know you share the President's commitment, and because of your impressive work in the area of child care, we are eager to hear your views and benefit from your experience as we develop the White House Conference. Please join us and other leaders in the child care field on June 30, 1997 at 3:00 p.m. in Room 472 Old Executive Office Building for an informal discussion. Please call Laura Emmett at 202-456-5584 with your dob and ssn if you can join us. If you cannot attend, please feel free to send us your thoughts and guidance, to Nicole Rabner, Office of the First Lady, The White House, Washington, D.C. 20502. We look forward to working with you. Sincerely yours, meen Denn Eleakey Melanne Verveer Elena Kagan Assistant to the President Deputy Assistant to the President and Chief of Staff to the First Lady for Domestic Policy July 18, 1997 FIELD(Prefix) FIELD(First) FIELD(Last) FIELD(Title) FIELD(Organization) FIELD(Address 1) FIELD(Address 2) FIELD(City), FIELD(State) FIELD(Zip) Dear FIELD(Prefix) FIELD(Last): Thank you very much for joining us to discuss the upcoming White House Conference on Child Care. The meeting was valuable to us both in shaping the conference and exploring policy options. We encourage you to continue to advise us. Please send written comments to Jennifer Klein, Special Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy, 2nd floor West Wing, The White House, Washington, D.C. 20502, or feel free to call Jennifer or Nicole Rabner at (202)456-6266. We hope that the White House Conference will make the compelling case -- which we heard from so many of you -- that making quality child care more affordable and accessible is good for the economy and central to a productive American workforce, as well as critical to our children's healthy development and ability to learn. Thank you for your important contribution. Sincerely yours, Elena Kagan Deputy Assistant to the President For Domestic Policy Child can focus group 6/20/97 focus. resources n andience resource down payment" speeptional care in communicating ml parents. how parents understand icsue- media (down Wnks. policy part feedback on policy form creative - move field forward. we need parents to behetter consumers" as E. waking Natl child carefromeded Cherrios brakfact. Recog Day - Pres. embracing SC. dissation action - Parents awad of many fus- understand of Kg quality, 4. challenges - concrete prob. -how to translate what gual. parents - elofert Resources * -more info not main igne. iresoures-critical. deal u/ affordability livectly. bak affordability of quality of staff. - Recrimement of providers stating - Subsidies - cost of care. * fill the gap of affoddbuty for parents. Ellen: 1. frading / push toward community molalization planning fundung for communities 2. Jash force on francing ve: affordability. - (Dong price taskford -co Y- encomyment of efate TF, aswell 3. Quality a Я by. to states gone done in promote states doing spec. cmb traing / scholarship funds 4. ABC coming next ak. N atimal public prev cottab partnership lefters employers) ready to Think about arore there Look at Instances of Excellege smart short, Teach., MM Pres. articulate a nsimetor nature challenge to plates, counties to match The 100m; bus higher ed, con. Det party together - more ag greative. CC. fits into all prices - all Dept Labor, Ed., continum of care CCDF leg commistment (dont overlook) [cd double .7] Community college- (how to make if happen) princhple of gual. universal access - Impact on each federal agency fed For: model celebrate communities that have done innovative wk. IL, RI 15070 of por universal access. play down competition of welfare recipients VS. love income Need to he well grounded in data - status gno. amashall Plan for Cc. - Jeoh Acreditition Issue. web. Child care focus group 6/23/97 3pm clearer a sense of what child care is, how it feto into the landscape us picture. >> Economy context. [still congines "bakycittung confext - bad to larger fam ec. picture ] change nature of discourse on child pare Depends on for in the workforce. perspective of both children/ adults econ (numan ( perspectives Jrance: welcoming of child into society (we invest in our child vent foo (ate) with up The profession training etc 4 not focus on Flashing good Mings That are not replicable - substance WH r Couf ev 10 yes - used to he. got a dielogue going 1970 conf - child care - top priority - a lot of towlding - Jackson consti mency onented supply of priferronals in Me field. "Itt about time - training into inspructure models strengthen highlighting infrastructure historical context how c.c. was developed human resources some: quality of a staff dictase quality of pregram the separt. move toward universal RC. Cuarty-toward a broader have of care until we do, lower income people will be droads. valid qual of ad. paying full cost of care - Ifficult for covergaes, anddle income Wking toward a "wking society -people have to wk am consumer of CC has 10 have a better Ground the substanti consumer Icsues understand of CC r quality of CC understand in real $ terms the return on the inks trent. what do we set when fours Work Society needs at / chol just the individual audience -imp. in room That day business people- Take The suilt out of the needing child care commission Coof cd - caren laddeer/compensation - infrastructure. pick up on the Drain Ango. intro Peg package a for or infrastution dev. create consumer demand lutro by package healthy economy makes the demand for ce n Adopto Jish take Chanters of Commerce- key bus people hear the econ. is wes., generate pub no will ( consuma groups to bear this. who to buy into this. A WH inv. people left out and people in me muddle - whing people of am. - 7eg that wd address it closer to universality Tax Credit Emergency leg / Marshall plan - Disabler relief age prece of TANF will expload A nothing out There for jamp children ( as well as school age care) link quality peed of supply for subsidies for law income Gov can look at laws + A evaluate eval late Leg package. - a into Mese five Things them 1. traing/ recruitment 2. schotarship) transfer us. 3. faculities 4. standards. - Academy quality 4cc A compaign Handards Zigler- giving up fight for nat'l stundards- - put out st for consumer Grant program-if -if state meets X standard - gets dellar. for communities public priv partnerting - com. can get you dollars if may have prwates dollars is well. Reding DC7C of expanding the plades -n making if refundable - r for accrediptm on in fold - fak wedeb to form mes., commenties - Elts 45 - vehicle that do good Phings, providers - higher edl voc tech schools welfare traing - programs. CC is central to fam support -> facel Econ dev. -communty service 7 of funds. tenters - using houring dev dollars - clearup lang - pricep the that