Ask the Scholar

Document scope · 1 page
doc
Scholar
Ask about this object, its catalog metadata, its source description, or the page inventory. For page-specific OCR and visual context, open one of the page chats.

Scholar Source Context

Document identity
localId
44169702
label
Latin America - Santiago - Summit of Americas Prep
core
doc
dtoType
document
pageCount
1
Source metadata
Source extras
naId
44169702
levelOfDescription
fileUnit
otherTitles
42-t-12352811-20091155F-004-012-2016
recordType
description
ocrSource
nara-archive
Single page context
seq
1
pageIndex
0
type
document
mediaId
7279669bf52390e2
ocrText
Case Number: 2009-1155-F FOIA MARKER This is not a textual record. This is used as an administrative marker by the Clinton Presidential Library Staff. Folder Title: Latin America- Santiago- Summit of America Prep Staff Office-Individual: National Economic Council-Brainard, Lael Original OA/ID Number: CF 1188 Row: Section: Shelf: Position: Stack: 23 4 10 1 V Withdrawal/Redaction Sheet Clinton Library DOCUMENT NO. SUBJECT/TITLE DATE RESTRICTION AND TYPE 001. briefing Reviving the Summit of the Americas Diplomatic Strategy (4 pages) ca. 01/1997 P1/b(1) paper 002. paper FTAA Scenario (9 pages) 12/23/1996 P1/b(1) 003. paper Jimmy Carter to President Clinton, re: Visits to Chile, Argentina, 01/28/1997 P1/b(1) Brazil, and Jamaica (8 pages) 004. memo Samuel Berger and Mack McLarty to the President, re: Your Trip to ca. 01/1998 P1/b(1) the Santiago Summit of the Americas, April 17-20 (4 pages) 005. list Chile State Visit Deliverables (I page) n.d. P1/b(1) COLLECTION: Clinton Presidential Records National Economic Council Brainard, Lael OA/Box Number: CF 1188 FOLDER TITLE: Latin America - Santiago - Summit of Americas Prep 2009-1155-F ke2431 RESTRICTION CODES Presidential Records Act - |44 U.S.C. 2204(a)] Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.C. 552(b)] P1 National Security Classified Information |(a)(1) of the PRA] b(1) National security classified information [(b)(1) of the FOIA P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office |(a)(2) of the PRA] b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of P3 Release would violate a Federal statute |(a)(3) of the PRA] an agency [(b)(2) of the FOIA] P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute [(b)(3) of the FOIA] financial information [(a)(4) of the PRA] b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President information [(b)(4) of the FOIA] and his advisors, or between such advisors [a)(5) of the PRA| b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy [(b)(6) of the FOIA] personal privacy |(a)(6) of the PRA] b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement purposes |(b)(7) of the FOIA] C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of of gift. financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA] PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C. h(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information 2201(3). concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA] RR. Document will be reviewed upon request. PHOTOCOPY PRESERVATION Latin America: National Elections, 1998-2001 The Bahamas Cuba Mexico Dominican Republic St. Kitts and Nevis Belize Jamaice Haiti Puerto Rico Antigua and Barbuda Honduras (U.S.) Dominica Montserrat (UK) St. Vincent and St. Lucia Guatemala El Salvador Nicaragua the Grenadines Barbados Grenada 1 Trinidad and Tobago Costa Rica Venezuela Guyana Panama Suriname French Guiana Colombia (Fr.) Ecuador CLINTON LIBRARY PHOTOCOPY Galapagos 2/o Islands (Ecua.) Peru Brazil Bolivia Paraguay Chile Election Timetable Color coded by year of election Year Country Election Date Type of Election Argentina Uruguay 1998 Belize Late summer General Brazil October Presidential, legislative, gubernatorial, municipal Colombia March-October Legislative, municipal May Presidential Costa Rica February Presidential, legislative, municipal Dominican Republic May Legislative, local Ecuador May Presidential Paraguay May Presidential, legislative Venezuela December Presidential, legislative, gubernatorial, district, municipal 1999 Antigua and Barbuda March Executive Argentina May Presidential Barbados January Executive Bolivia December Municipal Chile December Presidential El Salvador March Presidential Guatemala November Presidential, legislative, municipal Panama May Presidential, general St. Vincent and May Executive the Grenadines Uruguay November Presidential 2000 Dominica March Executive Dominican Republic May Presidential Grenada March Executive Haiti December Presidential Mexico August Presidential, legislative, state Peru April Presidential, legislative St. Kitts and Nevis March Executive Trinidad and Tobago December Executive 2001 Honduras November Presidential, general Montserrat (UK) October Executive Nicaragua October Presidential, general Suriname May Executive Boundary representation is not necessarily authoritative. 745149 1-98 THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON March 5, 1997 MEMORANDUM FOR PETER ALLGEIER, USTR JIM DOBBINS, NSC MEG LUNSAGER, TREASURY BRYAN SAMUEL, STATE REGINA VARGO, COMMERCE DAN ZELLIKOW, TREASURY FROM: LAEL BRAINARD, NEC SUB SUBJECT: Latin America Economic Issues Working Group Meeting The meeting on Friday will focus on Latin America economic issues in preparation for the President's trip to the region. Please find attached an agenda for the meeting on Friday and background materials as follows: US-Brazil Bilateral Trade Review Status Report Argentina Non-paper on Bilateral Trade Issues Issues for Recife Vice Ministerial Recommendations (FTAA) Please provide clearance information to Gay Joshlyn, 456-2801. Attachments Withdrawal/Redaction Marker Clinton Library DOCUMENT NO. SUBJECT/TITLE DATE RESTRICTION AND TYPE 001. briefing Reviving the Summit of the Americas Diplomatic Strategy (4 pages) ca. 01/1997 P1/b(1) paper COLLECTION: Clinton Presidential Records National Economic Council Brainard, Lael OA/Box Number: CF 1188 FOLDER TITLE: Latin America - Santiago - Summit of Americas Prep 2009-1155-F ke2431 RESTRICTION CODES Presidential Records Act - [44 U.S.C. 2204(a)] Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.C. 552(b)] PI National Security Classified Information [(a)(1) of the PRA] b(1) National security classified information |(b)(1) of the FOIA] P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office [(a)(2) of the PRA| b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of P3 Release would violate a Federal statute |(a)(3) of the PRA] an agency [(b)(2) of the FOIA] P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute [(b)(3) of the FOIA] financial information |(a)(4) of the PRA] b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President information [(b)(4) of the FOIA] and his advisors, or between such advisors |a)(5) of the PRA| b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy |(b)(6) of the FOIA] personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRA b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement purposes |(b)(7) of the FOIA] C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of of gift. financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA] PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C. b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information 2201(3). concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA] RR. Document will be reviewed upon request. Withdrawal/Redaction Marker Clinton Library DOCUMENT NO. SUBJECT/TITLE DATE RESTRICTION AND TYPE 002. paper FTAA Scenario (9 pages) 12/23/1996 P1/b(1) COLLECTION: Clinton Presidential Records National Economic Council Brainard, Lael OA/Box Number: CF 1188 FOLDER TITLE: Latin America - Santiago - Summit of Americas Prep 2009-1155-F ke2431 RESTRICTION CODES Presidential Records Act - |44 U.S.C. 2204(a)] Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.C. 552(b)] PI National Security Classified Information |(a)(1) of the PRA] b(1) National security classified information [(b)(1) of the FOIA] P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office |(a)(2) of the PRA] b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of P3 Release would violate a Federal statute |(a)(3) of the PRA| an agency [(b)(2) of the FOIA| P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute |(b)(3) of the FOIA] financial information |(a)(4) of the PRA] b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President information |(b)(4) of the FOIA] and his advisors, or between such advisors [a)(5) of the PRAJ b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy |(b)(6) of the FOIA] personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRA b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement purposes [(b)(7) of the FOIA] C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of of gift. financial institutions |(b)(8) of the FOIA| PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C. b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information 2201(3). concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA] RR. Document will be reviewed upon request. 12/06/96 FRI 13:14 FAX 202 647 0791 ARA 001 1 Copy to fail Return to me 2 Bureau of Inter-American Affairs U.S. Department of State Washington, DC 20520 202-647-6754 Fax: 202-647-0791 FAX TRANSMISSION COVER SHEET Date: December 6, 1996 To: NEC - Dan Tarullo 456-1605 USTR - Peter Allgeier 395-9675 Treasury - Meg Lundsager 622-5304 NEC - Jim Dobbins 456-9131 Fax: Subject: Latin American Review Paper Sender: Bryan SAMUELQM YOU SHOULD RECEIVE 3 PAGE(S), INCLUDING THIS COVER SHEET. IF YOU DO NOT RECEIVE ALL THE PAGES, PLEASE CALL 202-647-6754. Attached is the "State Department paper" which Dan requested at his November 20 meeting. I'd appreciate copies of USTR's and Treasury's submissions when available. Thanks. 12/06/96 FRI 13:15 FAX 202 647 0791 ARA 002 United States Department of State Washington, D.C. 20520 December 6, 1996 Memorandum for NEC - Mr. Tarullo From: ARA - Bryan Samuel an Subject: Western Hemisphere: Economic Policy Issues Setting Our economic policy toward the region remains rooted in the vision of the Miami summit: a hemisphere of freely elected states, trading freely. New security threats (narcotics, migration, environment) are transnational in scope and often benefit from a coordinated, hemispheric approach. In fact, developments in Latin America and the Caribbean region -- far more than in the rest of the developing world -- have a direct and immediate effect on the United States and our domestic interests. Democracy in the region remains shallow and its institutions need shoring up. Endemic corruption, tied closely to the narcotics problem, complicates this chore. Economic reforms are progressing generally, though in fits and starts, and public support is weak. Income distribution is badly skewed, and poverty remains pervasive. Basic services like health and education lag behind most other regions of the world. In some countries, human rights are a significant problem. Although U.S. economic influence in the region is unchallenged, U.S. leadership suffers from slights over perceived U.S. heavy-handedness (Helms-Burton, Samper visa, drug decertification process). Our regional trade agenda -- especially Chile accession and NAFTA parity -- has languished while others in the hemisphere are actively negotiating market opening agreements. Trade agenda Our top economic priority is to re-gain momentum for our trade agenda: FTAA, NAFTA accession for Chile and perhaps others, NAFTA parity for CBI countries. Trade agreements help lock in economic reforms and provide greater predictability for U.S. exporters and investors. The President's fast-track authority has assumed almost symbolic proportions for countries who seem reluctant to negotiate seriously with us without it. NAFTA accession for Chile could energize the FTAA. NAFTA parity is essentially making good on a promise, and, if it is not forthcoming, we need to look at alternative actions to address the economic problems peculiar to the Caribbean. 12/06/96 FRI 13:15 FAX 202 647 0791 ARA 003 2 Economic growth By and large, the region has adopted our view of what constitutes sound economic policy, though individual countries probably require encouragement or risk back-sliding. Others seem to be taking a breather. Conditionality of various debt relief and lending programs helps, as does diplomatic pressure. Foreign investment flows into the region are crucial to feed privatization initiatives and to address high unemployment. BITs or other investment initiatives could lower risks for U.S. investors. Summit Process Since the Miami summit, ministers of trade, finance, energy, and telecom have met to set objectives and determine work plans. Other meetings held under the summit mantle have addressed such issues as hunger, sustainable development, and education. The hemisphere's labor ministers have also met, but under ILO auspices. We have been fairly successful at pushing our agenda. Another round of meetings, including two more trade ministerials, will precede the next hemispheric summit, tentatively scheduled for March 1998 in Santiago. Regulatory initiatives (financial services, energy, telecom) seem the most fertile ground for economic deliverables. The next trade ministerial in May in Brazil should set negotiating groundrules for the FTAA. In the S&T area, the emphasis is on agricultural research and sustainable use of natural resources. Financial Assistance Concessional lending is necessary to assist the poorest in the region, and we need to continue to press our case with Congress. ESF will be targeted to secure the peace in Haiti, Guatemala, Peru/Ecuador, Nicaragua and El Salvador. We will dedicate significant funds to counternarcotics and administration of justice programs. Development assistance priorities include democracy, environment, health and population programs. Diplomatic overtures In the near term, possible Presidential visits to Mexico and to the region could provide a clear, positive picture of U.S. attention to the region. Frei comes here at the end of February. Chretien will probably visit during the spring. Clear: Jeff Davidow, Peter Allgeier UNCLASSIFIED RECORD ID: 9700691 NSC/RMO PROFILE RECEIVED: 03 FEB 97 18 TO: NATL SECURITY COUN FROM: PRESIDENT DOC DATE: 02 FEB 97 SOURCE REF: KEYWORDS: LATIN AMERICA NAFTA DRUGS MP PERSONS: CARTER, JIMMY SUBJECT: PRES REQUEST NSC RECOM ON CARTER ANALYSIS OF FREE TRADE IN LATIN AMER ACTION: PREPARE MEMO FOR BERGER DUE DATE: 06 FEB 97 STATUS: S STAFF OFFICER: DOBBINS LOGREF: FILES: WH NSCP: CODES: DOCUMENT DISTRIBUTION FOR ACTION FOR CONCURRENCE FOR INFO DOBBINS BRAINARD, L BEERS CLARKE BOYNTON LORIN MALLEY PICCONE PYATT SANDALOW SCHWARTZ SESTAK SIMON VERVILLE WALSH COMMENTS: DISPATCHED BY DATE BY HAND W/ATTCH OPENED BY: NSDRS CLOSED BY: DOC 1 OF 1 UNCLASSIFIED Withdrawal/Redaction Marker Clinton Library DOCUMENT NO. SUBJECT/TITLE DATE RESTRICTION AND TYPE 003. paper Jimmy Carter to President Clinton, re: Visits to Chile, Argentina, 01/28/1997 P1/b(1) Brazil, and Jamaica (8 pages) COLLECTION: Clinton Presidential Records National Economic Council Brainard, Lael OA/Box Number: CF 1188 FOLDER TITLE: Latin America - Santiago - Summit of Americas Prep 2009-1155-F ke2431 RESTRICTION CODES Presidential Records Act - |44 U.S.C. 2204(a)] Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.C. 552(b)] PI National Security Classified Information |(a)(1) of the PRA| b(1) National security classified information |(b)(1) of the FOIA] P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office |(a)(2) of the PRAJ b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of P3 Release would violate a Federal statute [(a)(3) of the PRA] an agency |(b)(2) of the FOIA] P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute |(b)(3) of the FOIA] financial information |(a)(4) of the PRA] b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President information [(b)(4) of the FOIA] and his advisors, or between such advisors [a)(5) of the PRA] b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy [(b)(6) of the FOIA] personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRAJ b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement purposes |(b)(7) of the FOIA] C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of of gift. financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA] PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C. b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information 2201(3). concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA] RR. Document will be reviewed upon request. CONFIDENTIAL 0490 January 23, 1998 DECLASSIFIED E.O. 13526 ACTION White House Guidelines, September 11, 2006 MEMORANDUM FOR SAMUEL R. BERGER By KDE NARA, Date 05/09/14 THROUGH: JAMES F. DOBBINS 2009-1155-F FROM: THEODORE J. PICCONE SUBJECT: Memo to President re Santiago Summit and State Visit Attached is a memorandum to the President requesting he approve our approach to planning for the Santiago Summit, including no other stops in the region and a 24-hour State Visit after the Summit. Concurrence by: [Enter names of concurring NSC staff, initialed off] RECOMMENDATION That you forward the attached memorandum to the President. Attachment Tab A Memorandum to the President CONFIDENTIAL Classified by: Theodore J. Piccone Reason: 1.5 di Declassify On: 1/23/08 Withdrawal/Redaction Marker Clinton Library DOCUMENT NO. SUBJECT/TITLE DATE RESTRICTION AND TYPE 004. memo Samuel Berger and Mack McLarty to the President, re: Your Trip to ca. 01/1998 P1/b(1) the Santiago Summit of the Americas, April 17-20 (4 pages) COLLECTION: Clinton Presidential Records National Economic Council Brainard, Lael OA/Box Number: CF 1188 FOLDER TITLE: Latin America - Santiago - Summit of Americas Prep 2009-1155-F ke2431 RESTRICTION CODES Presidential Records Act - |44 U.S.C. 2204(a)] Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.C. 552(b)] PI National Security Classified Information [(a)(1) of the PRA] b(1) National security classified information ((b)(1) of the FOIA] P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office [(a)(2) of the PRA] b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of P3 Release would violate a Federal statute |(a)(3) of the PRA| an agency |(b)(2) of the FOIA| P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute |(b)(3) of the FOIA] financial information |(a)(4) of the PRAJ b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President information |(b)(4) of the FOIA] and his advisors, or between such advisors [a)(5) of the PRA] b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy |(b)(6) of the FOIA] personal privacy |(a)(6) of the PRA] b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement purposes [(b)(7) of the FOIA] C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of of gift. financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA] PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C. b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information 2201(3). concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA] RR. Document will be reviewed upon request. L A THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON July 30, 1997 MEMORANDUM FOR DISTRIBUTION FROM: MACK MCLARTY SUBJECT: REVIEW OF U.S. NEGOTIATION POSITION FOR SANTIAGO SUMMIT OF THE AMERICAS We are at an important juncture in our preparations for next April's Summit of the Americas in Santiago, Chile, to which the President has committed to attend. Please come to a meeting I will chair on Friday, August 1, at 4:00 pm in room 180 OEOB to discuss. The Summit will be the culmination of over a year of intensive Presidential activity to advance US interests in Latin America and the Caribbean. Building from the 1994 Miami Summit, we hope to solidify our newly emerging partnership with the hemisphere, increasingly based on shared values and common interests, to enhance the President's foreign policy legacy in the community of the Americas. In accordance with the process developed by the Government of Chile and other participating Summit governments including the United States, we will soon be asked to provide a US position concerning specific action items to be included in the Summit agenda. The State Department has led an interagency working group since January to develop an initial set of US proposals (attached), and is prepared to deliver them to the Chileans next week. The outlines of the agenda itself, including education, democracy development, economic integration and trade, and poverty alleviation, were agreed by hemispheric foreign ministers at a meeting in Lima, Peru last month. I believe State has the issues well-framed. Still, it would be useful to conduct an informal White House review of the substance developed by the interagency process. It would be helpful for you to review the proposed action items prior to our meeting, to be able to offer specific suggestions which can be taken into account. The Summit is a priority for the President and our hemispheric agenda, and I greatly appreciate your ongoing efforts in this regard. I look forward to discussing these issues in greater depth with you at our meeting on Friday. Labor in each basket but not separately Similarly for sust.dent. coused reported OM Somet hemispheric actions on drugs PAGE:02 600/2001 U.S. Proposals for Santiago Summit Plan of Action Santiago Agenda Outline USG Proposed Action Item (as approved June 1 in Lima) Governments will: 1. Education - Formulating actions in accordance Establish standards for student performance in reading and mathematics at key grade levels, and with the proposals of the Responsible develop the means to measure students' progress toward achieving the standards. Coordinators in the Plan of Action they TO: 94627226 have prepared on the subject Ensure that an increasing percentage of all children can read independently by the end of the fourth year of primary school Ensure that all primary school teachers receive training to help students reach the standards and that every student has access to basic instructional materials in reading and mathematics. AMERISUMMIT_DOS Develop and convene within six months a hemispheric consultative forum, building on existing mechanisms such as OAS/CIDI and including governments, the private sector, and citizen groups, to facilitate implementation of this initiative and to ensure a continuing policy dialogue on education, and complete by 2001 a set of key policy-relevant education indicators compatible with those being developed by OECD and UNESCO. 2024562215 Additional actions such as student Increase the number of student and teacher exchanges between Summit countries by 25 percent and teacher exchange programs, within the next three years by adopting policies, including tax incentives, to stimulate private distance education programs and sector participation. incorporation of new technologies. t Increase the quality, accessibility, and affordability of distance education programs, in cooperation with the private sector and international financial institutions, as a means of achieving B202 736 7618 universal access to education and training opportunities within the hernisphere. Double by 2002 the number of classrooms at the primary and secondary levels with access to information technology, such as computers and the Internet, for more effective teaching and learning, drawing on ongoing efforts in the private sector and international financial institutions, as well as initiatives such as the GLOBE Program for increasing Internet access and environmental awareness. FROM: 18:50 JUL-25'97 18:58 07/25/97 + U.S. to take lead in drafting for July 31 deadline. July 25, 1997 6:40 PM -2- PAGE:03 800/8000 Santiago Agenda Outline USG Proposed Action Item (as approved June 1 in Lima) Governments will: - Actions to develop training and Increase capacity and efficiency of worker training programs so that the broadest number of skills improvement programs for workers and employers will have the opportunity to benefit from hemispheric integration; as a first workers with the aim of confronting step, establish within two years a comparative database on existing government, employer, and under favorable circumstances worker initiatives that support worker training, with the support of the ILO and IDB. changes resulting from the application and development of new technologies. Develop comparative national systems for the definition and description of occupations and skills, Special attention should be given to with the cooperation of governments, workers, employers, and training providers, with the aim of TO: TO:94627226 programs for adult training. t improving worker employability and labor market efficiency; as a first step, develop and share implementation plans within two years, with support from the ILO and IDB. II. Preserving and Strengthening Democracy and Human Rights AMERISUMMIT DOS - Formulate actions based on the Create an office within the OAS to help resolve peacefully, at the request of involved member work that the Responsible Coordinators states, conflicts within and between countries. of this theme are carrying out Strengthen the sustainable hemispheric capacity to protect and support human rights by providing funding to the Inter-American Institute of Human Rights. 2024562215 - Actions in the area of education for Incorporate, within three years, active methodologies for education in democracy and human democracy and full respect for human rights, including women's rights, in the primary and secondary school curricula of their countries, rights. drawing on expertise from the public and private sectors on curriculum development and reform. - Actions aimed at enhancing the Develop jointly, within one year, model regulations for the formation and operation of non-profit participation of civil society. civil society organizations and formulate a work plan for implementing such regulations in their $202 736 7618 respective countries; in carrying this out, hold working- and high-level conferences and seek technical input from the IDB, OAS, and interested members of the public. - Actions aimed at strengthening Develop laws and regulations, within three years, to promote transparency in local government municipal and regional operations and finance and create mechanisms for citizen participation in local decision-making, administrations. t such as open public hearings and public budget reviews. Take action to assure a range of financing options for municipal governments to expand the delivery of quality services and training for local officials through transfers of national revenue, 18:51 increased local authority for raising revenue locally, and accessing private capital markets. JUL-25 97 18:58 FROM: 07/25/97 f U.S. to take lead in drafting for July 31 deadline. July 25, 1997 6:40 PM -3- 004/009 Santiage Agenda Outline USG Proposed Action Item PAGE: (as approved June 1 in Lima) Governments will: - Actions that guarantee the Condemn violations of human rights of migrants, including migrant workers and their families, protection of the human rights of all promote safe, legal, and orderly migration in the region, and combat trafficking in migrants by migrant workers and their families. t strengthening enforcement measures, considering. as appropriate, new criminal legislation, and conducting information campaigns for migrants regarding the dangers of smuggling operations. - Actions aimed at reinforcing (Counternarcotics) Develop comprehensive national drug plans to counter the production, Hemispheric proceedings to confront trafficking. and consumption of illicit narcotics that include goals, objectives, and methods for corruption, narco- trafficking, and evaluating progress and, working through the OAS/CICAD, establish a hemisphere-wide TO: 94627226 terrorism. t multilateral group to monitor progress in implementation of national plans and to promote opportunities for enhanced hemispheric cooperation. (Counternarootics) Work to ensure that criminals cannot find safe haven anywhere in the region by removing all inappropriate impediments to extradition, including abolishing the denial of AMERI SIMMIT DOS extradition on the basis of nationality. (Money Laundering) Provide funding to establish financial intelligence units that are property trained and equipped with the purpose of analyzing and disseminating Information on money laundering activities to national law enforcement agencies. 2024562215 (Corruption) Seek to sign and ratify the 1996 Inter-American Convention Against Corruption, and establish a mechanism within the OAS to discuss enacting legislation against transnational bribery and to monitor implementation of the Convention, including through mutual evaluations. (Corruption) Establish financial disclosure requirements for senior public officials and adopt and implement measures to prevent bribery in the public procurement process. 202 736 7618 (Terrorism) Carry out measures to fight terrorism as agreed in the 1996 Inter-American Specialized Conference on Terrorism, and seek to sign, ratify, and/or accede to international conventions related to terrorism, in accordance with their domestic laws. 18:52 JUL-25'97 18:58 FROM: 07/25/97 t U.S. to take lead in drafting for July 31 deadline. July 25. 1997 6:40 PM -4- PAGE:05 800/800 Santiago Agenda Outline USG Proposed Action Item (as approved June 1 in Lima) Governments will: - Actions in the area of confidence (Note: Leaders should agree in the political declaration or in the introduction to this initialive to and security building measures implement fully the recommendations of the 1995 Santiago Conference on Confidence and Security between states. Building Measures (CSBMs).) Promote programs to train civilians in CSBMs and military budget formulation. Promote non-traditional CSBMs such as border parks and other mechanisms in appropriate circumstances. TO: 94627226 - Actions in the area of Strengthen their justice systems, including support for the independence of the judiciary, strengthening judicial systems. specifically by implementing measures by 2002 to: a) support the ment selection for judges at all levels to attract and retain superior candidates, b) double the number of public defenders, and c) strengthen the role of prosecutors in addressing common and serious crime as well as civil suits. AMERTSUMMIT DOS . Actions aimed at cooperating on Strengthen the capacities of labor ministries so they more fully support the hemispheric economic projects for modemization of the state integration process and can respond to the needs of workers and employers, specifically, by that the countries of the Hemisphere improving the quality of the services offered to workers, the integration of technology into these may undertake in the administration of services, the quality of labor market information, and safety and health conditions in the labor matters in accordance with the workplace, as well as by decentralizing, where appropriate, their presences to cover more areas 2024562215 regulations and the legislation in force within their respective countries. in each country. t Give special attention to the integration of youth, women, and the disabled Into the workforce, and to the particular needs and services for such segments of the workforce and exchange experiences among labor ministries on best practices in these areas, with the assistance of the ILO. 202 736 7818 III. Economic integration and Free Trade - Actions related to the negotiation of About (5) action items to be developed by the San Jose Trade Ministerial. the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) in accordance with the progress achieved by the Ministers in charge of the subject 18:53 - Actions on capital markets to be About (2) action items to be developed by the Santiago Finance Ministerial. determined after the meeting of JUL-25'97 18:58 FROM: Ministers of Finance this December. t 07/25/97 ! U.S. to take lead in drafting for July 31 deadline. July 25, 1997 6:40 PM -5- 800/900 PAGE:0 Santiago Agenda Outline USG Proposed Action Item {as approved June 1 in Lima) Governments will: - Actions for the development of Improve forecasting, warning, and response capabilities to mitigate the damage caused by cooperation in science and technology. natural hazards and their impact on society and the economy, specifically by improving preparedness, public awareness, and forecasts, and by applying science and technology to address the effect of climate variability on areas such as health, agriculture, and water. - Actions related to regional energy Prepare, by 2000, national energy strategies defining actions and establishing deadlines for the cooperation. ! implementation of market-based regulatory, fiscal, and legislative frameworks, including the TO: 94627226 creation of mechanisms for public participation and capacity-building, that ensure the efficient and socially beneficial development and use of cross-border energy trade, protect the environment, and advance rural electrification. - Actions for the establishment of an (Transportation) Increase cooperation in transportation and promote the integration of AMERI SUMMIT DOS adequate hemispheric infrastructure, transportation systems and services in the Americas via the Hemispheric Transportation Initiative especially in matters of transportation (HTI). and telecommunications (Transportation) Establish a Hemispheric Land Transportation Standards Committee to analyze In accordance with the agreement of the Hemispheric Ministers of the manner in which operating and safety regulations and standards in road and rail transport are Transportation to the effect that the employed at the international, national, and regional levels in each country, and examine ways to 2024562215 mitigate the negative impact of transportation on the environment. Western Hemisphere Transportation Initiative (HTI) be (Transportation) Develop a plan for improving compliance with international standards and included in the agenda of the recommended practices, such as those established by the International Civil Aviation Summit of the Americas. Organization and the International Maritime Organization, to ensure the highest level of safety in air and sea transport systems to improve infrastructure and to increase environmental protection 202 738 7618 (Telecommunications) Agree to implement by 2000 the regulatory principles of the WTO agreement on basic telecommunications reference paper with the alm of fostering competition and universal service and eliminating barriers to market access. (Telecommunications) Agree to direct that OAS/CITEL will develop and begin to implement, on a voluntary basis and by the end of 1998, a framework for mutual recognition agreements (MRAs) for certification of telecommunications and information technology equipment, drawing on existing 18:53 CITEL Guidelines for Certification and other multilateral efforts on MRAs. FROM: JUL-25 97 18:59 07/25/97 t U.S. to take lead in drafting for July 31 deadline. July 25, 1997 6:40 PM -6- PAGE:07 07 007/009 Santiage Agenda Outline USG Proposed Action Item (as approved June 1 in Lima) Governments with M. Eradication of Poverty and Discrimination - Actions in support of micro- Ensure that the hemisphere's poor families, especially women of those families, have access to enterprises and small and medium- financial services for self-employment in microenterprises and small businesses by the year sized businesses as a way of 2000. promoting the creation of new jobs through access to sources of credit, the Remove barriers to expanding microenterprise development in national financial systems and TO: TO:94627226 development of vocational training, strengthen the capacity of informal/formal sector Institutions to deliver financial services to programs designed to obtain an microenterprises and small businesses increase in productivity, and the Encourage, in support of these commitments on microenterprise, the active participation of introduction and application of new and AMERISUMMIT DOS multilateral and bilateral agencies, development banks, commercial banks, non-government more advanced technologies. organizations and other intermediary credit organizations. The education theme may be considered in any of these action initiatives. - Actions for the implementation or Increase the availability and reduce the cost of land titles by: (1) decentralizing and increasing 2024562215 modernization of effective systems of the transparency of land registries and adopting a unified approach to parcel-based property property registration for those countries registration; (2) foster the use of Global Positioning Systems (GPS) technology for surveying and that require it t property mapping; and (3) eliminating unnecessary and overlapping administrative procedures or fees for registration. implement measures to protect the property interests of and access to natural resources for indigenous populations. 202 736 7818 JUL-25°97 18:59 FROM: 07/25/97 18:54 1, t U.S. to take lead in drafting for July 31 deadline. July 25, 1997 6:40 PM -8- 009/009 Santiago Agenda Cutline USG Proposed Action Item (as approved June 1 in Lima) Governments will: . Actions aimed at promoting greater Develop within one year national plans to improve participation of indigenous populations in participation of indigenous populations society, including provision for primary education in indigenous languages as a bridge to the through adequate access to education, national language. health and work training. - Actions to combat hunger and (Note: Leaders in the political declaration or introductory remarks to the poverty initiative should malnutrition. endorse the implementation of the 1996 World Food Summit Plan of Action.) Reduce child mainutrition by targeting health and nutrition programs on children younger than three years, which is the age group most vulnerable to mainutrition, giving increased emphasis to the proper feeding of children in this age group combined with increased use of immunizations, vitamin supplementation, and growth monitoring. AMERISUMMIT DOS 202 736 7618 07/25/97 18:56 1 U.S. to take lead in drafting for July 31 deadline. July 25, 1997 6:40 PM -7- 1008/009 Santiago Agenda Outline USG Proposed Action Item (as approved June 1 in Lima) Governments will: - Actions in the area of health based Reduce transmission of disease and raise the quality of life and productivity of the poor by on the proposal of the Pan-American applying effective, low-cost technologies for safe water supplies, sanitation, and solid waste Health Organization. management Seek to increase the availability of vaccines and basic drugs, especially for the most needy, by establishing systems that encourage the development and marketing of such vaccines and pharmaceuticals in a market-based environment, encouraging research that results in the development and production of new vaccines. Monitor critical health issues in the region, and guide changes in health sector resources and programs for maximum impact by upgrading their contributions to and participation in regional health information networks, including surveillance for infectious diseases and progress in health AMERTSUMMIT DOS sector reform. Actions in accordance with the Review existing laws to identify legal barriers to women's full and equal participation in economic agreements adopted at the Conference and political life and areas in which laws are needed to protect women and female children on Women held in Managua, including against all forms of domestic violence and, upon having done so, develop a timetable for the a specific program related to education. introduction and passage of legislation in these areas. Establish an office and provide adequate resources, Including staff, to ensure implementation of and compliance with obligations agreed to at the Fourth World Conference on Women In September 1995. - Actions at the national level leading Review labor codes to ensure they provide for core labor standards, including freedom of to the goal of ensuring quality jobs, and association, the right to organize and bargain collectively, the prohibition of forced labor, the of safeguarding the basic rights and elimination of exploitative forms of child labor, and non-discrimination in employment and T202 736 7618 interests of workers and to this end, occupation, consistent with international standards, with the assistance of the ILO. freely promote respect for relevant ILO conventions. t Strengthen labor ministries to ensure that the administrative and judicial capacities exist to adequately implement core labor standards and to enable ministries to promote labor- management relations systems of collective bargaining and dispute resolution that reinforce democratic values and promote economic competitiveness, with the assistance of the ILO and IDB; ministers of labor will meet in 1999, and subsequently as appropriate, to report on national labor code reviews and assess progress toward enhancing administrative and judicial capacities. 07/25/97 18:65 + U.S to take lead in drafting for July 31 deadline. July 25, 1997 6:40 PM 02/16/98 17:55 202 456 9130 NSC-INTERAMERICA 005/007 12/30/97 10:40 202 736 7618 AMERISUMMIT DOS NSC DOBBINS 002/004 United States Department of State Washington, D.C. 20520 MEMORANDUM December 12, 1997 TO: Mr. Genaro Arriagada FROM: ARA - Jeffrey Davidow SUBJECT: Santiago Summit Deliverables As we promised during our recent luncheon discussion, we have drawn up a list of "deliverables" for the Santiago Summit which could capture the imagination of people everywhere. They focus on programs that will be launched by the presidents that will affect lives in real ways. We have not included issues such as resolving the Ecuador-Peru border question for very practical reasons. While this matter may be developed sufficiently to enable the two parties and four guarantors to use the Summit locale to sign an agreement, we would not want to fix the talks' conclusion to the April 18 deadline for fear of producing resistance on the part of one or the other of the parties. The attached list is ambitious and will require efforts on the part of both our governments - - working with others -- to achieve it by the time of the Summit. Attachments: As stated 02/16/98 17:55 202 456 9130 NSC-INTERAMERTCA AMERISUMMIT DOS NSC DOBBINS 12/30/97 10:40 202 736 7618 NON-PAPER ON SANTIAGO SUMMIT DELIVERABLES In an effort to strengthen the message of the Santiago Summit, Hemispheric nations should develop several key deliverables that will either appear directly in the Summit documents or in public statements by key leaders participating in the Summit, spelling out commitments in specific terms. Emphasizing a "people's component" in the Summit's initiatives, some of the deliverables which could be highlighted in each of the four baskets could be: Education Basket Educating the 21st Century's Citizens: Working with the World Bank and the IDB and through public statements by leaders at the Summit, spell out specific levels of resources to be dedicated to implement the Summit's education initiative-in the range of billions of dollars; announce a specific number - --in the thousands per year-- of educational exchanges of students and teachers; and obtain commitments from the private sector to dedicate satellite time for use by education entities across the Hemisphere to enable effective distance learning. Democracy and Human Rights Basket Judicial Reform: Emphasize judicial reform as a critical step toward a "a second wave of reforms" across the Hemisphere, by bolstering existing judicial educational institutions throughout the region, and mobilizing international donor support to establish an inter- American judicial studies center somewhere in the Hemisphere. Press Freedom: Ensure greater freedom of the press by instituting a region-wide annual report by an objective agent-whether an ombudsman or rapporteur-- operating within an entity of the OAS. Military Transparency: Agree to full transparency in arms transfers and defense spending as well as pre-notification of military exercises. Drug Alliance: Establish a Hemispheric anti-drug alliance, to include a credible multinational evaluation system of national drug plans. Extradition Initiative: To make our nations and cities more secure, launch an Inter- American Extradition Initiative to ensure that no criminal can escape prosecution. 02/16/98 17:55 202 456 9130 NSC- INTERAMERICA 10:41 202 736 7618 AMERISUMMIT DOS - NSC DOBBINS 0 004/004 Economic Integration Basket Financial Markets: Adopt measures to ensure more stability of the regions financial institutions, especially during international market disruptions. Enhanced Aviation Accords: Agree to improve air safety and launch an effort to obtain the world's first regional Open Skies regime to enable faster, safer, more efficient air travel. Global Electronic Commerce: Adopt a set of principles to develop electronic commerce and the internet as a means to improve information exchange and economic growth. Sustainable Energy and the Environment: Dramatically upgrade the region's sustainable energy programs, especially focusing on having all Summit nations adopt specific measures addressing global warming and climate change. Poverty and Discrimination Basket Labor Rights and Productivity: Bolster labor ministries to ensure labor rights are protected and that essential training and services are provided to enhance worker productivity and improve working conditions and standard of living. Property Registration for the Poor: Enable the poor to obtain legal registration of and deeds to their property to empower them to become effective participants in every economy. Healthier People: Pledge to eliminate dangerous communicable diseases by the year 2000 through a comprehensive immunization program; bring child nutrition throughout the Hemisphere to internationally-recommended levels; and create the Americas Telemedicine Network to provide doctors everywhere with real-time information for the treatment of the sick. Hemispheric Institutions Reform Inter-American Institutions: Establish a blue-ribbon commission of Hemispheric notables to review and make recommendations by the Summit following Santiago on structural and organizational reforms of the major inter-American institutions to make them more relevant to the Hemisphere's needs in the 21st century. U.S. General Comments on the Draft Declaration of Principles Message: The document should have a central message that gives the historical and philosophical reasons for the Summit and the Plan of Action. This message should take note of and support the hemisphere's continuing integration and its consolidation of gains in democracy and free markets since the Miami Summit. Democracy delivers. The overall thrust of the message should recognize that the hemisphere must enact "the second generation" of reforms if it is to deliver improved lives for the peoples of the Americas. For governance, this means building the institutions that support democratic rule and rule of law at the local, regional, and national level. For the economy, this means further expanding and opening our economies while wiping out the obstacles that keep many in poverty from participating in the economic life of their nation. Education should be highlighted as the transcendent factor in these processes and the key for raising the quality of life of all people in the hemisphere. With these gains in open markets and open societies, however, have emerged new challenges (growing income disparity, transnational crime, labor displacement, environmental degradation, etc.) that must be addressed in a spirit of cooperation. This approach should resonate throughout the document, making clear the commitments of the Heads of State and Government in each of the Summit themes. Organization: The Declaration should reflect the same areas of interest - in the same order - that appears in the Plan of Action. The current format does not follow the flow of the Plan of Action and sometimes separates in the Declaration concepts that are together in the Action Plan. This could be resolved by grouping the current sections as follows: I. Education (this should be placed first) II. Democracy and Human Rights (should include the ideas in the sections on "Access to Responsive, Effective, Independent Justice, "Peace and Security, and "Factors Creating Instability.") III. Economic Integration, Financial Stability and Free Trade (should include ideas in the sections on "Globalization" and "Integration and Free Trade," pending discussion by ministers of trade in San José as well as a section on energy which the ministers of energy will submit.) IV. Poverty, Social Fairness and Anti-Discrimination V. Conclusionary Notes on "The Environment" and "Building Hemispheric Institutions" Furthermore, there should be more consideration in the Declaration to the contents of the Plan of Action (e.g., the "Poverty" section does not address worker productivity or labor rights, as in the Plan of Action). While not repeating every action item, we should look for ways to highlight some of the innovative proposals to give the reader a feel for the progressive nature of the document. Relation to Miami Summit: There should be an explicit commitment to the Miami Plan of Action similar to that given the Miami Declaration. Translation: We would like to offer our services in polishing the English version of the Declaration so that it accurately reflects the flavor of the Spanish text. Specific U.S. Comments to the Draft Declaration of Principles CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS POLITICAL DECLARATION II SUMMIT OF THE AMERICAS We, the democratically elected Chiefs of State and Government S of See General Comments for comments on the "message" of the the countries of the Americas, meeting in Santiago, Chile, within the Declaration of Principles. framework of the II Summit of the Americas and with the purpose of examining the current situation in the region, of evaluating the hemispheric cooperation and integration process and adopting measures required to give a renewed momentum to this joint effort, so as to better use the capacities of our countries, to contribute to resolve the severe problems still afflicting an important segment of our people and respond to the concerns and demands of our citizens. A consistent and renewed hemispheric action that complement the ongoing national programs in our respective nations will permit our countries to make good use of, and confront in a better way, the benefits, opportunities, challenges and hopes that the XXI Century brings along. In this context, we have subscribed the following Political Declaration: 1. We reaffirm our full adherence to the Declaration of Principles We would like to extend the commitment of leaders to include both the subscribed during the I Summit of the Americas held in December of Miami Declaration and Plan of Action, which launched many activities 1994, and our firm intention to continue the effort initiated on that that still remain relevant today. occasion. That Summit constituted an important venue to promote the strengthening of links and the execution of inter-hemispheric cooperation programs. We have confirmed the progress attained in the implementation process of the commitments there undertaken, as well as in those areas requiring greater dynamism and stimulus. - 2 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS 2. in the framework of friendship, solidarity and cooperation that drives our nations, we reiterate our decisive will to strengthen consultations among our governments and to always privilege a dialogue in matters of interest for the Hemisphere. DEMOCRACY AND HUMAN RIGHTS 3. We express our firm conviction that citizen's participation will only Paragraphs 3 and 4 should be reversed. Para 4 is a more general be increased by democracies that vigorous and experiencing constant comment about democratic rule and therefore should come first. Para improvement. By adapting government structures to systems that are 3 is about citizen participation and refinement of democratic increasingly more agile and representative, we will ensure that the institutions and should come next. important principles of respect for human beings and the full development of their capacities shall attain the effectiveness they The objective of this paragraph is to underscore the role of citizen deserve. For that purpose, permanent efforts must be made both participation. We believe the paragraph could be restated as follows: internally as well as in the field of international cooperation, in order to "Strong citizen participation is essential to the healthy functioning of make these objectives possible and increase support mechanisms democracy and the observance of human rights. We pledge to ensure intended to continuously develop the democratic system. that our government institutions are modernized to promote such participation domestically and internationally and to be more responsive to the needs of our peoples." Concrete measures of second generation include: A. Strengthened Rule of Law to guarantee that all individuals have the right to due process under the law. Focus should be on legal equality for men and women, pretrial detention, and the establishment of an independent judiciary. B. Importance of decentralization and extension of democracy to local and subnational governments with emphasis on direct elections of local officials, increased authority for raising revenue locally, increased responsibility for appropriate government functions such as the provision of social services, and improved capacity to assume these new responsibilities. C. Creation of conditions for a vibrant civil society with specific 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 3 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS attention to: access to information, opportunity to participate in decision-making, and the establishment of clear procedures for seeking redress. D. Increased efforts to ensure freedom of thought and expression. Special emphasis should be given to the creation of a free press and the establishment of an Ombudsmen function at the IIDH. 4. The experience of our countries indicates wazzu that Democracy, The concept of this paragraph could be more clearly stated as follows: in addition to being an indispensable civic exercise for the generation "While free and fair elections are essential to the democratic system, it of the nations' periodic representative authorities, requires instruments is equally important to promote democratic values and culture. In this and mechanisms permitting to strengthen its conceptual and ethical regard, we reaffirm our commitment to democracy and the rule of law. basis; to enhance its development and safeguard its operation. For these purposes, we unequivocally state our firm intention to continue to build an hemispheric community based on governments emanating from and authentic democratic will. The consolidation of a democratic culture will permit us to turn into a reality a more fair, dignified, prosperous, tolerant and free society in the Americas. 5. We reaffirm our interest in continuing to enhance the instruments As drafted, human rights are only referred to in their relation to intended to strengthen the respect for human rights, being the international treaties. Also, the language implies that governments fundamental basis for a sound and pluralistic democracy, as well as agree to all agreements in this area without specifying which their universal, indivisible and inter-dependent nature, as established agreements or the status of their negotiation. We would like to see a in universally accepted international treaties. A particularly important more explicit statement on the support of human rights. The reference element in this context is the subscription by the Hemispheric to international treaties could be summarized as: "We recognize the governments of the international agreements dealing with this issue. importance of international human rights treaty instruments and underline the importance of promoting their universal acceptance." PEACE AND SECURITY 6. Peace among peoples constitutes the fundamental basis of human harmonious relations and the main requirement to enable the full 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 4 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS development of nations. With legitimate pride, we confirm that this is the predominant concept in our Hemisphere. It is our objective to safeguard and increase all those actions intended to secure this superior asset. It is also our desire to share this hope and effort with all other regions of the world, that must encompass all countries in the planet. 7. In current times, where there is no room for ideological borders, the concept of security, as originally conceived by the nations of the Hemisphere in an environment of cold war and bi-polar confrontation, must adapt to this new vision. To that end, we call upon the regional institutions of the Hemisphere to analyze and propose cooperation mechanisms in this area that are in tune with the evolution of world events and with other relevant concepts that may have an impact on security and harmonious relations among our countries. 8. Notwithstanding the above, we have verified different experiences leading to the promotion of mutual confidence and security measures between States, which have demonstrated their validity and importance. We reaffirm our interest to continue to develop initiatives in this field, as well as to implement the agreements arising from the Conferences on Confidence and Security Building Measures held in the Hemisphere to this date. FACTORS AFFECTING STABILITY 9. World and regional reality clearly demonstrate the emergence of We believe it would be appropriate to include in this section a new common threats, resulting from phenomena such as drug reference to the Hemispheric Alliance Against Drugs, which is trafficking, terrorism, corruption and other forms of international crimes currently contemplated in the Plan of Action. This is a significant step that not only hinder the normal economic, social and cultural forward for the hemisphere, and it should have specific mention in the development of our societies, but also our democratic stability. Declaration, as follows: Equally dangerous for the region are the consequences of those crimes, which manifest themselves in an alarming increase in urban "We reaffirm our strong commitment to work individually and delinquency, the school attrition rate, abusive labor practices on collectively to combat illegal narcotics and related crimes. As part of women and the youth, as well as other alterations that affect the an ongoing Alliance Against Drugs, we resolve to strengthen our 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 5 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS normal development of our societies. We congratulate ourselves in efforts to assure that drug traffickers and those who profit from their the fact that the Hemisphere has taken appropriate and timely crimes will find no refuge from justice in the hemisphere. We also measures to confront these new forms of crime and reaffirm our resolve to create a credible and objective process for evaluating intention to continue to deepen cooperation in this field and, if needed, national counternarcotics performance." to define additional joint actions to counteract this disgrace. We would like to add to the list of "new common threats" the crime of money laundering. It should be noted here because this crime deserves mention as it is often a transnational phenomenon that can be unwittingly facilitated by greater integration of financial markets. GLOBALIZATION 10. We trust that the process of globalization characterizing the While we are supportive of protection of the environment in the context current development of humanity will increase hemispheric relations of globalization, we would not wish to imply the "right" to a healthy based on the fundamental principles of independence and environment, which to our knowledge is not an internationally sovereignty. Similarly, we reaffirm that only by means of an inter- recognized right. We would therefore prefer wording, and this may be dependence founded on the sovereign equality of States and on a point of translation, that tracks more closely with the Rio Declaration, common principles and values permitting an economic growth based Principle 1, which speaks of citizens being "entitled to a healthy on practices of free trade; on the respect for rights of our citizens to a environment. healthy environment; and on policies that ensure the required equity, shall we strengthen the peace and sustained progress in which the Also, we believe another issue that is relevant to this topic is the rights Hemisphere lives. of workers. We have suggested language to address all of these concerns, as follows: "promote economic growth and development based on the practices of free trade and on respect for the rights of workers, while protecting the environment." Also, we have questions about the reference to "policies that ensure the required equity." As drafted, this could be construed to imply an obligation by governments to ensure the proper distribution of income. 11. The phenomenon of globalization offers new opportunities for the Paras 11 and 12 mischaracterize globalization as the cause of "social planet's sustainable development and opens a broad field to attain a and political exclusion" and "volatility of capital." Globalization, more efficient cooperation on the part of the international community. however, is a reality that brings both benefits and challenges. However, we must not ignore the fact that highly inconvenient and Furthermore, finance ministers met in Santiago in December and risky situations could occur, translating into an increase in the agreed to language to be incorporated into this Declaration. We intend 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 6 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS differences in economic development among nations, inducing to to submit this language for the current section entitled, "Integration and social and political exclusion, with the serious negative repercussions Free Trade," In their language, the ministers make reference to the that such situation would produce. financial volatility of markets, which makes para 12 unnecessary. We would therefore prefer more positive language that combines the ideas of paragraphs 11 and 12 as they pertain to globalization, as follows: "The nations of the hemisphere, recognizing the challenges posed by globalization, and the need, particularly of vulnerable groups in society, to adjust to the new realities globalization brings with it, agree to work together to ease the transition to the ever more global economies and societies" 12. We call upon the international community to make all possible See comment above. efforts in order to timely develop resolution mechanisms for the problems that arise from globalization, in particular those relating to the volatility of capital. We live in an increasingly inter-dependent global economy, and if the appropriate prevention and correction mechanisms are not adopted on time, potential de-stabilizing factors could be evident for individual economies. EDUCATION 13. We agree that education constitutes the strategic basis for the This section is largely a restatement of the Plan of Action. which is not development of our nations and a superior tool to consolidate the parallel with the rest of the Declaration. We would therefore propose cultural identity of our peoples. deleting paragraphs 15 and 17. We believe this section should instead contain exciting language to reflect adequately the emphasis leaders place on this initiative. It should give central focus to the four principles of the Action Plan: equity, quality, relevance, and efficiency. We could highlight a few of the more innovative ideas from the Plan of Action, such as: A. Strengthen the teaching profession. B. Increase investments at the primary and secondary level. 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 7 CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS C. Provide local communities with more control over schools. D. Establish standards for educational performance and monitor progress against those standards. 14. We are convinced that Education is the main instrument to convert our countries into those sound democracies we all long for, and that it constitutes the fundamental element to have access to higher levels of development. Only through education shall we make our men and women into citizens with opportunities to access the world of knowledge, of technology and of the new ways of individual and social growth that are nowadays only available to minorities. Currently, the true wealth of nations lies in the quality of the people who are part of them. The development of the capacities of men and women sets the limits and possibilities of the nations' welfare. 15. We have extensively discussed the projects that are being As stated above, we would propose deleting this paragraph. If there is implemented in each of our countries to increase and duly respond to a consensus for its inclusion, however, we would offer the following the educational needs of our populations, giving also due comments. consideration to those factors arising from an adequate appreciation of the cultural identity of each nation and community that comprise them. We should not refer to "projects" or "proyectos," but rather to fundamental efforts to strengthen all aspects of education systems to meet the challenges with which they are confronted. The Plan of Action captures this thought. The issue of educational reform in most of our countries is controversial and politically difficult. This paragraph should give as much impetus and support as possible to those serious efforts to raise educational quality and equitable access. 16. Recognizing that in the Hemisphere education faces common The four principles from the Plan of Action are equity, quality, challenges, prospects and difficulties, and agreeing with the solutions relevance, and efficiency. "Relevance" is incorrectly translated as to respond to such situation, we undertake to implement educational "pertinence" and "efficiency" is missing. policies that enforce the criteria of equality, equity, and pertinence. 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 8 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS As stated above, we would support deleting the summary of the action items in the following paragraph and instead highlight a few innovative actions in this section to reinforce the four principles. Examples could include: linking schools in the Americas through technology to increase mutual understanding, developing comparable indicators of educational quality; and using exchanges to spread understanding of the best innovations in teaching and managing education institutions. There should also be a reference to the development of worker training programs under this cooperative effort. 17. We agree that this matter must be addressed as a whole, in such This paragraph should be dropped for reasons stated above. If there way that it not only comprises an increase in and reallocation of is consensus for including it, however, we would offer the following resources within the countries in order to achieve these goals, but comments: rather also incorporating duly upgraded plans and programs. These plans should contemplate the development of sound training in values The reference to an "increase in resources" is not appropriate to all and a combination between the capacity to compete and experience countries. In our own case, for example, most educational funding is solidarity. With that we will seek to prepare persons for their dynamic provided by states and local school districts. The Plan of Action incorporation to the world of labor and their responsible participation stresses the "optimization of resources" in support of the four as citizens; to introduce educational technologies that are available principles, and there should be a similar reference here. and have demonstrated their efficiency; to permit access to information technology to the most extensive levels; and enable the The phrase "training in values," could be improved upon so as not to permanent training of teachers, including an exchange of pupils and sound like an indoctrination program. Perhaps the language could be teachers between the various countries of the region, as well as changed to reflect "training to reinforce values." initiatives intended to strengthen higher education. The final sentence is not a true representation of the contents of the Plan of Action. There is too much emphasis placed on educational technology. There should not be a close link between "teacher training" and "teacher and student exchange" as these are separate concepts. Finally, "initiatives in higher education" is misleading; the Action Plan speaks only of involving higher education in strengthening primary and secondary education and in carrying out educational exchange. 18. With this purpose, we reaffirm our intention to continue to 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 9 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS strengthen international cooperation and request international institutions to substantially increase the attention they give to the issue of Education. Considering the importance we assign to this issue, we have attached specific concepts and proposals on that area to the Action Plan. ACCESS TO AN AGILE, EFFICIENT, AND INDEPENDENT JUSTICE SYSTEM 19. Convinced of the need to satisfy, on a timely and effective The importance of the judicial branch was not addressed in the prior manner, the demands for justice of our populations, we are conscious Summit. We believe that we have an excellent opportunity to send a that this must be an area of renewed attention and upgrading. We will strong message to the hemisphere by having our leaders highlight the strive to reinforce and adapt, whenever necessary, the systems of important role an independent and effective judicial branch plays in administration of justice, adopting the relevant measures so that all the promoting democratic consolidation, economic, development and the population may have a prompt, impartial and agile access to it. We protection of human rights. undertake to review the administration systems and organizational structure of the public services that make up the system of Instead of pledging to do more studies and reviews, as stated in the administration of justice, to analyze its social gains and carry out the proposed language, leaders should be more forward leading in the relevant economic and statistical studies. reform of judicial branches, including an endorsement of the independence of the judiciary. Specifically, they can point out that as a way of supporting the improvement of the judicial system, leaders will promote the creation of an Inter-American Judicial Studies Center (a proposal that is currently being discussed). We therefore suggest the following language: "We are convinced of the importance of the judicial branch in promoting democratic consolidation, economic development, and adequate protection of human rights. We therefore will support an independent and effective judicial system and adopt the necessary measures so that all citizens may have access to a prompt, impartial and readily accessible justice system. In order to bolster and support judicial reform, we will establish the Inter-American Justice Studies Center." 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 10 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS POVERTY, SOCIAL EQUITY AND PREVENTING DISCRIMINATION 20. Overcoming poverty and social exclusion continues to be the The significant theme of the section on poverty should be removing largest challenge confronted by our Hemisphere. We are conscious the barriers that deny the opportunity to participate in the economy. A that the positive growth indicators shown in the Americas in the last significant barrier in this area is access to credit and other financial years have not translated into a solution for poverty, inequity and services, which is addressed in the microenterprise section of the social exclusion, which still persist in vast sectors of our countries. Action Plan. A second barrier is clear land titling and registration. The region as a whole must make an additional effort to finally Lack of access to quality health care and the scourge of malnutrition overcome this situation in the next years, and thus achieve the are also barriers to development of human potential and should be required equilibrium that will permit not only better and more fair living highlighted in this section. and development conditions for our peoples, but also to reinforce the legitimacy and efficiency of the system. We also believe that this language should reflect the issues taken up in the Plan of Action. We would like to offer the following wording that the chair could use with regard to the basic rights of workers by adding after the first clause in the first sentence, "creating the conditions that will generate decent wages and respect for the rights of workers." The paragraph would be amended to read: "The region as a whole must make an additional effort to finally overcome this situation in the next years, creating the conditions that will generate quality jobs and respect for the rights of workers, and thus achieve the required equilibrium that will permit not only better and more fair living and development conditions for our peoples, but also to reinforce the legitimacy and efficiency of the system." We would also propose that the Declaration make a strong endorsement of the rights of women, which is an increasingly important and relevant issue for our hemisphere. Currently the document only mentions women with regard to education. We suggest the following language: "We reaffirm our commitment to eliminate discrimination on the basis of gender from our societies. We will promote the legal equality of women, as well as their increased participation in the economic and political life of our respective 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 11 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS nations." There should be some mention of removing the barriers to broad participation in national life for indigenous peoples. 21. To adequately respond to this challenge, we will apply those policies that have demonstrated their validity in practice, both in the macro-economic field, that of integration and cooperation, as well as in specific projects in areas such as fostering micro, small and medium- size enterprises, by adequately allocating resources and specifically training those sectors that require it. ENVIRONMENT 22. We reassert that human beings have the right to a healthy and As this is the only reference to the Santa Cruz Summit in the Summit productive life, in harmony with nature, and that to attain it we must documents, we would like to see more specific language with regard to increase our national efforts as well as those of international it and, more broadly, the environment, as follows: cooperation deriving from the approval of the Action Plan of the Summit on Sustainable Development, held in Santa Cruz de la Sierra, "We recognize that despite our efforts, degradation of the environment Bolivia, in December 1996. and natural resource base presents an increasing threat to our future and to the quality of life for our citizens. We therefore reconfirm our dedication to policies that lead to sustainable development in a manner consistent with the protection of health, safety, and the environment. To this end, we must increase our national and international efforts in this area, including the implementation of the Plan of Action adopted at the Santa Cruz Summit on Sustainable Development, held in Bolivia in December 1996. The annual sustainable development ministerials, called for in the first Summit of the Americas, will review progress toward these ends and develop recommendations for further action." INTEGRATION AND FREE TRADE In response to the Second Meeting of Finance Ministers of the Western Hemisphere, held December 2-3, 1997 in Santiago, we would like this heading to read: "Integration, Financial Stability and Free Trade" 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 12 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS We would also like to point out that energy ministers will produce language for incorporation in this section in their Jan. 15-16 meeting in Caracas. The issues of infrastructure, transportation, and telecommunications, and science and technology are absent from this section and should have some reference. In the area of telecommunications, a reference to "the use of the Internet in developing global electronic commerce" would identify an innovative proposal contemplated in the Plan of Action. We also believe that it would be appropriate to include a reference to the workforce in this section of the Declaration. This issue was not significantly treated in the Miami Summit, and we believe leaders should therefore make a more direct statement about the importance of the labor sector. We could suggest the following language, to be added to this section: "A strong and viable labor sector is vital to the achievement of hemispheric integration and to the equitable distribution of its benefits. Consistent with the Declaration of Buenos Aires of the Tenth Inter- American Conference of Ministers of Labor, held in October 1995, we are committed to policies that will foster a healthy, educated, productive and secure workforce, which shares in the benefits of economic growth." Labor Ministries can and should make a positive contribution to the hemispheric integration process. We recognize the need to strengthen the capacity of Ministries of Labor to support more fully the hemispheric integration process. Our Ministries of Labor should work together to exchange information and experiences regarding best practices and to enhance cooperation on innovative labor market policies. 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 13 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS We also recognize the need to establish a framework that addresses the labor dimension of hemispheric integration, complementing the Free Trade Area of the Americas. Our Ministers of Labor should meet before the end of 1998 to begin the construction of such a framework and to report to us at the next Summit of the Americas on progress made. We call on the OAS, the IDB, other appropriate regional and sub- regional organizations and the International Labor Organization to support the efforts of Ministries of Labor to further the hemispheric integration process." 23. We reassert our full conviction that hemispheric integration We note that the language recommended by finance ministers in constitutes an essential and complementary element to national December has not been included. We have reviewed the ministers' policies to attain a level of development permitting us to overcome the language and adapted it to the format of this Declaration. We would most urgent problems affecting our countries. In this context, we therefore like to propose a new paragraph be added between reaffirm our commitment toward a global, dynamic and equitable paragraphs 23 and 24, as follows: integration process, that in addition to increasing the links between our peoples, will favor the performance of the objectives we have posed "Within the region, we have made significant progress in establishing for ourselves. sound fiscal and monetary policies, in opening our economies and in achieving and maintaining price stability. Improved economic fundamentals in the region have helped to preserve confidence against a backdrop of global financial instability. Recent financial market volatility lends greater urgency to our common agenda of pursuing sound macroeconomic policies and strengthening and modernizing financial markets in our countries, and reaffirms our commitment to deeper economic and financial integration in the Western Hemisphere. We welcome our Finance Ministers' December 1997 action agenda to strengthen and modernize financial sectors in the region. Implementation of the Basle Core Principles of Effective Banking Supervision is fundamental to our efforts to ensure financial sector growth and stability throughout the hemisphere." 24. The establishment of the Free Trade Area of the Americas, at the As was agreed earlier, this language will be produced by trade 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 14 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS latest by the year 2005, continues to be a priority. By subscribing this ministers at the March 19 Trade Ministerial in San José. We therefore Declaration, we announce with satisfaction our commitment to start reserve comment on language pertaining to this topic until that time. specific negotiations leading to that objective, based on the proposal made at the Ministerial Conference on Trade of San Jose de Costa Rica, while approving the methodology and work schedule proposed to us. HEMISPHERIC INSTITUTIONALITY 25. The Chiefs of State and Government of the Americas recognize that the resolution of the situations discussed in this Declaration require gradual and irreplaceable national efforts, as well as adequate and dynamic international cooperation. For this purpose, we call upon the international institutions of the Hemisphere and upon other world institutions working on these issues, to increase and speed up their decision making processes, determine new priorities in accordance with the agreements arising from this Summit and, accordingly, rationalize their resources in order to serve, with due promptness and efficiency, the needs for which they were established. 26. We consider that the time has come to make a critical analysis of We believe that a thorough review of hemispheric institutions should the hemispheric institutionality, with the aim of approaching the turn of be conducted by a commission composed of eminent persons from the Century with international structures that constitute a better both governments and the private sector. Recommendations of the support for the reforms that our States must continue to implement. commission will of course be reviewed by the foreign ministers and For this purpose, we request our Minister of Foreign Affairs to become eventually by the Heads of State and Government at the next Summit. a means of evaluation and analysis, proposing ideas to us settled by This method will take advantage of the technical expertise available in them on this matter, giving due consideration to the contribution meant the hemisphere on this topic and ensure a thorough political vetting. by these institutions and agencies in terms of the development of our countries, as well as the potential they represent. It is our intention that this assessment should entail specific and innovating proposals in all areas of hemispheric activities. 27. We agree to meet during the year in a III Summit of the We believe that we should not fix an exact year but instead opt for a Americas general statement confirming the need to have periodic Summits in the hemisphere "every three to four years." We cannot fix the exact year 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 - 15 - CHILEAN ENGLISH TRANSLATION COMMENTS because of electoral schedules and much depends upon the calendar of the host government. Santiago, April 19, 1998 01/15/98 4:01 981/P1 April 3, 1998 INFORMATION MEMORANDUM FOR SANDY BERGER, MACK MCLARTY, JIM STEINBERG, JOHN PODESTA, GENE SPERLING, ANNE LEWIS FROM: ANTONY BLINKEN AND DAVID LEAVY SUBJECT: Summit of the Americas Thursday Message Event As part of the effort to define our overall message for Latin America and specifically for the President's trip to Chile we have come up with the following proposal for a message event on Thursday April 16th. The event assumes the following: that the absence of fast track negotiating authority will have a negative impact on our trade agenda and will be a major theme of the media for the entire visit; that the press will have a low level of interest in this trip generally unless a credible storyline is defined; and that the best way to address the perceived negative of no fast track is to demonstrate leadership and confidence in the wisdom of economic integration going against the conventional wisdom. President's resolite, consistent two making open markets work for all Concept hade partners The event would focus on our core message for the whole trip: "second-stage reforms aimed at making democracy deliver. These include reforms aimed at widening opportunity -- poverty alleviation, education and job training -- and reforms aimed at vsy creating a mature and stable economy -- banking and security regulation, anti-corruption, judicial reform. 3s. The event would have two complementary parts. The first part would be a joint roundtable with President Clinton and President Frei and six to eight leaders of non-governmental organizations concerned with aspects of these second-stage reforms. The two Presidents would engage the people at the grass roots level who are making the transition to globalization and free markets work for everybody, i.e. educators improving learning and curriculums, job trainers providing new skills etc. 2 The second part would be speeches by the two Presidents to a crowd of approximately 500 American and Chilean business leaders. POTUS remarks would reaffirm U.S. commitment to open markets, trade liberalization and hemispheric integration - highlighting the opportunities and benefits for our people (talk about Chile's/region's economic growth, responsible financial reforms that helped shield against Asian flu, launch of FTAA, open skies agreement, export-related jobs etc.), while emphasizing our commitment to bring everyone along (reference discussion with NGOs, bilateral education MOU, civil society committee for FTAA negotiations, possible initiative on child labor and also highelighting affers 1 make financial systems Message more milent and stable. This two-tier event would highlight that despite the absence of fast track, our agenda of opening markets, creating jobs, and building business opportunities is still in the fast lane. The structure of the message would also underscore the importance we attach to addressing education, labor, environment, job training, etc., SO that globalization works for all citizens. The event would also highlight the major theme of the Santiago Summit: ensuring that democracy and free markets deliver. It will be our first chance to explain what we mean by "second- stage reforms": providing good schools and health care for all, so that every child has the opportunity for a better life; strengthening the rule of law, the independence of judges, and the professionalism of the police, so that the justice system is fair, efficient, and honest; attacking corruption, so public contracts are awarded based on merit, not bribes; establishing banking and securities regulation that permits sustained growth while guarding against insider trading and market instability; reaching out to all sectors of society to ensure their participation in shaping the future. Withdrawal/Redaction Marker Clinton Library DOCUMENT NO. SUBJECT/TITLE DATE RESTRICTION AND TYPE 005. list Chile State Visit Deliverables (1 page) n.d. P1/b(1) COLLECTION: Clinton Presidential Records National Economic Council Brainard, Lael OA/Box Number: CF 1188 FOLDER TITLE: Latin America - Santiago Summit of Americas Prep 2009-1155-F ke2431 RESTRICTION CODES Presidential Records Act - |44 U.S.C. 2204(a)] Freedom of Information Act - [5 U.S.C. 552(b)] P1 National Security Classified Information |(a)(1) of the PRA b(1) National security classified information |(b)(1) of the FOIA] P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office |(a)(2) of the PRA] b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of P3 Release would violate a Federal statute |(a)(3) of the PRA] an agency |(b)(2) of the FOIA] P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute |(b)(3) of the FOIA] financial information |(a)(4) of the PRA] b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President information [(b)(4) of the FOIA] and his advisors, or between such advisors |a)(5) of the PRA| b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy [(b)(6) of the FOIA] personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRA] b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement purposes [(b)(7) of the FOIA] C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of of gift. financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA| PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C. b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information 2201(3). concerning wells |(b)(9) of the FOIA] RR. Document will be reviewed upon request. SUMMIT OF THE AMERICAS ACTION ITEMS "From Miami to Santiago: Advancing the Common Agenda" Summit Action Miami Summit Progress Since Miami Summit Santiago Summit Items Commitments Goals 1. Strengthen Strengthen the OAS Unit for Funding for UPD increased 155% Extend democratic reforms and Democracy Promotion of Democracy (UPD) in four years to $3.5 million practices to local level Adopt the new protocols for the Washington and Managua defense of democracy and social Protocols enacted issues 2. Protect Human Reinforce commitment to OAS developing pilot projects Establish rapporteur at OAS to Rights international conventions based on a hemispheric action protect press freedom addressing human rights plan 3. Invigorate Civil Better facilitate operation and USAID created NGO network of Agree to develop common Society financing of civil society groups 80 citizens groups in the principles for fostering the Americas participation of citizen groups Emphasize education in democratic values to produce better citizens 4. Promote Cultural Increase exchanges among The Kennedy Center for the Foster further exchanges of Values universities and centers of culture Performing Arts established 25 students, teachers, and school fellowships for fine arts study administrators in the hemisphere New Museum of the Americas being developed via the IDB and private sector 5. Combat Negotiate new hemispheric As of February 1998, 23 countries Increase transparency through use Corruption agreement on corruption have signed and eight countries of asset disclosure statements for have ratified the OAS Anti- senior public officials Corruption Convention (U.S. ratification pending) Page 1 of 5 04/03/98 5:13 PM SUMMIT OF THE AMERICAS ACTION ITEMS "From Miami to Santiago: Advancing the Common Agenda" Summit Action Miami Summit Progress Since Miami Summit Santiago Summit Items Commitments Goals 6. Control Illegal Increase collective and individual Numerous kingpins of the Cali Create a hemispheric anti-drug Drugs and efforts to fight drug trafficking and Medelin drug cartels were alliance with a multilateral review Related Crime Develop a hemispheric strategy arrested process, based on standards against drugs Overall drug use in the U.S. has developed from Miami Summit Forge a common approach to declined; 1999 U.S. anti-drug and other international for a addressing financial crimes budget largest in history Improve extradition procedures OAS Anti-Drug Strategy in the and denial of safe havens to Hemisphere signed December criminals 1996 Commit to establish national units Summit governments are to investigate financial crimes implementing a common anti- money laundering strategy, supported by the OAS 7. Fight Terrorism Hold a conference on terrorism to Recommendations adopted at the Commit to implement Lima recommend common actions Lima Conference on Terrorism Conference recommendations against terrorism April 1996 U.S. anti-terrorism laws greatly strengthened, which allows 30 foreign organizations to be designated as terrorists, and their assets to be frozen 8. Build Mutual Develop recommendations via a Eleven recommendations being Increase transparency in defense Confidence hemispheric conference for implemented on a voluntary basis budgets improving mutual security Twenty-one Summit countries Endorse regime for advanced report an 87% increase in the notification of major arms practice of CSBMs in region acquisitions since 1995 Page 2 of 5 04/03/98 5:13 PM SUMMIT OF THE AMERICAS ACTION ITEMS "From Miami to Santiago: Advancing the Common Agenda" Summit Action Miami Summit Progress Since Miami Summit Santiago Summit Items Commitments Goals 9. Promote Free Complete negotiations on the Trade ministers have met Launch FTAA negotiation phase Trade in the Free Trade Area of the Americas annually and established 23 Americas (FTAA) by 2005 working groups to set the stage for FTAA negotiations 10. Expand Capital Develop a comprehensive list of Database of region's financial Enact measures to ensure more Markets all national capital flow systems completed in December stability of the region's financial regulations to promote 1997 institutions transparency 11. Develop Foster a greater role for the Private sector, governments, IDB, Commit to new infrastructure Hemispheric private sector and multilateral and World Bank all supporting development, especially in Infrastructure development banks in infrastructure development transportation systems infrastructure projects 12. Improve Tele- Improve the hemispheric Passage of new telecom Stimulate electronic commerce communications information infrastructure, legislation in the region that sets through Internet and other including through regulatory clear liberalization rules and technologies reform and consistency in promotes private sector equipment guidelines participation 13. Promote Science Undertake new scientific Regional fund begins operations Agree to increase cooperative and Technology cooperation and increase national in 1998 to support agricultural research in the effects of El Niño scientific capacities technology projects and other natural hazards 14. Expand Tourism Stimulate tourism in the Number of passengers in 1997 Incorporate tourism industry into hemisphere between the U.S. and Latin FTAA negotiations America exceeded trans-Pacific travel by 50% and rivaled trans- Atlantic flows Page 3 of 5 04/03/98 5:13 PM SUMMIT OF THE AMERICAS ACTION ITEMS "From Miami to Santiago: Advancing the Common Agenda" Summit Action Miami Summit Progress Since Miami Summit Santiago Summit Items Commitments Goals 15. Improve Access Guarantee universal attendance of USAID launched hemispheric Channel additional funds into to Quality primary school and 75% effort to implement education primary and secondary schools, Education attendance of secondary level by initiative including IFIs 2010 Since the Miami Summit, primary Promote educational standards school attendance in Mexico, Expand programs for textbooks Brazil, and Ecuador has reached and distance learning 90% 16. Providing Basic Develop a program to combat Hemispheric initiative aimed at Commit to new immunization Health Service communicable diseases eradicating measles by 200 programs in the hemisphere launched in 1995 with First Promote telemedicine use to Lady's assistance improve access to medical information 17. Promote Role of Design policies and programs for Approval of system of indicators Commit to remove barriers to the Women in maximizing the role of women in to monitor women's rights full participation of women in Society social, economic and political life Several Summit countries passed economic and political life and to laws bolstering women's rights protect women from domestic violence 18. Encourage Request development banks to IDB adopted five-year, $600 Open new credit lines, training, Microenterprise establish funds for million strategy to promote and technology for and Small microenterprise microenterprise microenterprise Business 19. Establish White Voluntarily establish national Several missions have been Consider increased humanitarian Helmets corps to assist in humanitarian deployed worldwide via the UN; relief operations under mutual relief U.S. provides technical assistance confidence and hunger programs as requested Page 4 of 5 04/03/98 5:13 PM SUMMIT OF THE AMERICAS ACTION ITEMS "From Miami to Santiago: Advancing the Common Agenda" Summit Action Miami Summit Progress Since Miami Summit Santiago Summit Items Commitments Goals 20. Promote Initiate new projects in renewable Renewable Energy in the Advance Kyoto climate change Sustainable energy, energy efficiency, and Americas Initiative (REIA) accords and clean energy Energy Use and clean and conventional energy identified 150 renewable energy development Regional Energy Promote programs to reduce projects to the private sector with Cooperation greenhouse gas emissions an estimated value of $2 billion Santiago designated as the first Hemispheric Clean City, a program modeled after U.S. program 21. Establish Improve management of parks Countries are now participating in Endorse implementation of Santa Partnership for and protected areas a global program to preserve Cruz Summit Plan of Action Biodiversity coral reefs Biodiversity-rich parks in Bolivia, Brazil, Peru and Central America created or enlarged 22. Establish Develop national plans to By 1996, twelve countries had Commit to expand programs to Partnership for eliminate lead from gasoline eliminated leaded gas; by 2001, improve quality of drinking water Pollution Improve access to safe drinking 20 countries expected Promote values in environmental Prevention water Water supply and sanitation stewardship system constructed in Haiti Page 5 of 5 04/03/98 5:13 PM THE WHITE HOUSE Office of the Press Secretary (Santiago, Chile) For Immediate Release April 18, 1998 FACT SHEET PROMOTING DEMOCRACY AND HUMAN RIGHTS AT THE SANTIAGO SUMMIT The Summit leaders reaffirmed their Miami Summit commitment that strengthening democracy, justice and human rights is a vital hemispheric priority. The Summit leaders agreed to intensify efforts to promote the "second generation" of reforms including democratic reforms at the regional and local level, protecting the rights of migrant workers and their families, improving the capabilities and competence of judicial systems, and encouraging a strong and active civil society. Strengthening Local Government and Civil Society The Summit leaders pledged to strengthen the participation of civil society groups like NGOs, academia, think tanks, advocacy groups, interest groups etc. in local and national decision making. The Summit leaders, to strengthen the integrity of governmental institutions, pledged to promptly ratify the Inter-American Convention Against Corruption. To this end, President Clinton has submitted the Convention to the U.S. Senate for advice and consent to ratification. The Summit leaders will continue strengthening the OAS's Unit for the Promotion of Democracy The Summit leaders also pledged to work together in finding ways to prevent financial contributions to electoral campaigns from organized crime and drug trafficking. Protecting Human Rights The protection and promotion of human rights are a continuing concern to all Summit governments and consist of more than preventing "political arrests" or torture. In celebrating the 2 50th anniversary the OAS Charter, the Summit leaders renew their commitments to improve the status of indigenous populations, migrant workers, women and children, and the disabled. The Summit leaders also pledged: 1. That governments will seek to attain legal equality between men and women by the year 2002; 2. To define and develop comprehensive policies aimed at promoting and protecting human rights at a domestic level; 3. To guarantee that all individuals have the right to due process of law, including the presumption of innonence and the right to trial within a reasonable period of time; 4. That governments will implement national information systems to address child abuse, especially the exploitation of children through prostitution, pornography and trafficking. 5. To support the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights through the establishment of a Special Rapporteur for Migrant Workers. 6. That governments will strengthen the capacities of labor ministries to protect worker rights. Rule of Law The lack of effective, credible and transparent justice systems throughout Latin America and the Caribbean threaten to undermine the democratic progress and trust of citizens in their governments. Governments are being openly challenged by their electorates to end impunity, combat corruption, provide protection from rising domestic and international crime, and to create a secure legal environment for trade and investment. To facilitate this process, the Summit will endorse establishment of a justice studies center for the hemisphere, whose purpose will be to facilitate training of personnel, exchange of information and other forms of technical cooperation to improve justice systems. The justice studies center would serve as a central repository for information on best practices and stand ready to assist with technical tasks, such as development of curricula for judges or prosecutors, as may be requested by different countries or institutions. The center promises to become an important link to a better future for the Americas. In addition, the Summit leaders also agreed: 1. Develop mechanisms that permit easy and timely access to justice by all persons, with particular reference to persons with low income, by adopting measures to enhance the transparency, efficiency, and effectiveness of the courts; 3 2. Adapt legislation and proceed with necessary institutional reforms and measures to guarantee the comprehensive protection of the rights of children and youths to meet the obligations established under the United Nations Convention on Right of the Child; 3. Foster the establishment and strengthening of specialized tribunals or courts for family matters and in accordance with their respective legal systems; Freedom of the Press Over the last few years, approximately 200 journalists have been killed in investigating threats to democracy such as corruption and narcotrafficking. To continue the leaders support the creation of a Special Rapporteur for Freedom of Expression as part of the Inter-American Commission for Human Rights. The Rapporteur will help resolve specific human rights cases involving the press and focus international attention on attacks against the hemisphere's emerging Fourth Estate, as their investigative reporting provokes increasing threats from narcotrafficking and other criminal elements. # # # THE WHITE HOUSE Office of the Press Secretary (Santiago, Chile) For Immediate Release April 18, 1998 FACT SHEET ADVANCING OUR COMMON SECURITY AT THE SANTIAGO SUMMIT The Summit leaders discussed the importance of strengthening their partnership to combat the new transnational threats facing the region including the production and distribution of narcotics, illegal arms trafficking and terrorism. To combat these threats and to strengthen the hemisphere's common security, the leaders agreed to the following: Narco ics The Summit leaders launched a Multilateral Counterdrug Alliance to better organize and coordinate efforts in the hemishpere to stem the production and distribution of drugs. The centerpiece of this alliance will be a mechnasim to evaluat each member country's progress in achieving their agreed counternarcotics goals. The Summit leaders also agreed to the following anti-drugs efforts, including: 1. Increase cooperation in areas such as the collection and analysis of data, standardization of systems that measure illicit consumption, scientific and technical; 2. Encourage the developments of campaigns to foster greater social awareness of the dangers of drug abuse for individuals, the family and society as well as community participation plans; 3. Improve and update cooperative mechanisms to prosecute and extradite individuals charged with the traffic in narcotics and other related crimes; 4. Establish or strengthen existing, duly trained specialized units responsible for requesting, analyzing and exchanging information on money laundering and assets used in criminal activity; 5. Reinforce international and national control mechanisms to impede the illicit traffic and diversion of chemical precursors; 6. Continue to develop their national and multilateral efforts in order to achieve full application of the Hemispheric Anti-Drug Strategy; 2 7. Enhance their national policies to prevent illicit drug consumption at the community level, in schools and by the most vulnerable groups, such as children and young people; 8. Develop appropriate treatment, rehabilitation and reintegration programs with a view to alleviating the social effects, human suffering and other adverse effects associated with drug abuse; 9. Eliminate illict crops through the increased support of national alternative development programs as well as eradication and interdiction; Terrorism To prevent, combat and eliminate the common threat of terrorism, the Summit leaders agreed to encourage states that have not yet done so to sign, ratify or accede to, the international conventions related to terrorism and convene, under the auspices of the OAS, the Second Specialized Inter- American Conference to evaluate the progress attained and to define future courses of action for the prevention, combat and elimination of terrorism. Arms Trafficking Illegal traffic in firearms and explosives also poses a common threat to the hemisphere's public safety and democratic institutions. To meet this threat, the Summit leaders called for the rapid ratification and entry into force of the Inter- American Convention to Combat the Illicit Manufacturing of and Trafficking in Firearms, Ammunition Explosives and Related material. This Convention will help ensure effective international cooperation to prevent and combat illict transnational traffice in firearms and ammunition, while establishing or strengthening systems to enhance the tracing of firearms used in criminal activity. Building Conference and Securi y Among S a es To continue to promote regional dialogue, transparency in defense policy and mutual confidence, the Summit leaders entrusted the OAS to follow up on and expand topics relating to confidence and security building measures with the goal of a Special Conference on Security within the framework of the OAS to be held, at the latest, at the beginning of the next decade. # # # Resources Available for Santiago Summit Initiatives Projections for FY 1998-2000 (US$ million) IDB/World Bank* USAID Total I. Education: Investing in People Early childhood 460 460 Evaluations, assessments, and indicators 450 6 456 Preparation of teachers and educational administrators 1,161 11 1,172 Education reform, including local community control 3,651 11 3,662 Bilingual education and foreign language teaching 101 3 104 Technical and vocational training for workers 697 11 708 Textbooks and other educational materials 862 11 873 Information and distance learning technologies 854 3 857 Exchanges and internships 5 24 29 Total Education 8,241 79 8,320 II. Strengthening Democracy and Protecting Human Rights Modernization of municipal and regional governments 4,359 25 4,384 Corruption 190 25 215 Strengthening justice systems 776 90 866 Upgrading and modernizing labor ministries 212 1 213 Strengthening civil society 36 36 Human Rights 22 22 Education for Democracy 26 26 Control of Illicit Narcotics: Alternative Development Projects 114 114 Total Democracy and Human Rights 5,537 339 5,876 * Lending projections assume that countries from the region will be willing to borrow from multilateral development banks for projects included in the 1998-2000 pipeline. Figures are estimates based on thematic categories of the Santiago Action Plan. Resources Available for Santiago Summit Initiatives, page 2 IDB/World Bank* USAID Total III. Economic Integration and Free Trade Cleaner energy, including renewable sources 841 6 847 Infrastructure, especially transportation and telecommunications 14,799 5 14,804 Science and technology, including mitigating El Niño effects 3,079 15 3,094 Strengthening financial markets 3 3 Total Economic Integration 18,719 28 ** 18,747 IV. Eradicating Poverty and Discrimination Promotion of microenterprise and medium-sized businesses 926 120 1,046 Land and parcel property registration for the poor 440 10 450 Health care, especially in the area of low-cost vaccine production, 7,639 20 7,659 application of information technologies, and basic sanitation Strengthening women's position in society, especially in the area of 82 82 legal reform for equality and attacking domestic violence Respect for core labor standards 95 12 107 Indigenous communities (health, education, institutions) 2,086 2,086 Hunger and malnutrition, especially pregnant and nursing mothers, 665 375 *** 1,040 infants and the elderly Total Eradicating Poverty and Discrimination 11,933 537 12,470 Totals 44,430 983 Region Total (FY 1998-2000) 45,413 * Lending projections assume that countries from the region will be willing to borrow from multilateral development banks for projects included in the 1998-2000 pipeline. Figures are estimates based on thematic categories of the Santiago Action Plan. ** This does not include approximately $225 million USAID will provide for environmental and agricultural programs. Includes $340 million in Food Assistance. 04/09/98 Resources Available for Santiago Summit Initiatives Projections for FY 1998-2000 (US$ million) 15:12 IDB/World Bank* USAID Total 1. Education: Investing in People Early childhood 460 460 Fax Evaluations, assessments, and indicators 450 6 456 1,161 DepL/Agency To Mahaney Education reform, including local community control 3,651 11 3,662 FAX TRANSMITTAL OPTIONAL FORM 99 (7-90) Preparation of teachers and educational administrators 11 1,172 8191 96/ Z020 Bilingual education and foreign language teaching 101 3 104 Technical and vocational training for workers 697 IT 1561 708 Textbooks and other educational materials 862 11 873 Information and distance learning technologies 854 3 857 Exchanges and internships 5 25 30 Total Education 8,241 80/30 8,321 Fax Phone II. Strengthening Democracy and Protecting Human Rights From Mark Wells Mark Wells Modernization of municipal and regional governments 4,359 25 4,384 Corruption 190 25 215 # of pages Strengthening justice systems 776 90 866 Upgrading and modernizing labor ministries 212 3 215 Strengthening civil society 36 36 Human Rights 22 22 = 25 25 Education for Democracy Control of Illicit Narcotics: Alternative Development Projects 114 114 INVOICE GIV soa Total Democracy and Human Rights 5,537 340 5,877 1 * Lending projections assume that countries from the region will be willing to borrow from multilateral development banks for projects included in the 1998-2000 pipeline. Figures are estimates based on thematic calegories of the Santiago Action Plan. 04/09/98 Resources Available for Santiago Summit Initiatives, page 2 1 IDB/World Bank* USAID Total 15:12 III. Economic Integration and Free Trade Cleaner energy, including renewable sources 841 100 941 Infrastructure, especially transportation and telecommunications 14,799 5 14,804 Science and technology, including mitigating El Niño effects 3,079 40 3,119 Strengthening financial markets 3 3 202 736 7618 Total Economic Integration 18,719 147 18,866 IV. Eradicating Poverty and Discrimination Promotion of microenterprise and medium-sized businesses 926 120 1,046 Land and parcel property registration for the poor 440 10 14 450 Health care, especially in the area of low-cost vaccine production, 7,639 60 7,699 application of information technologies, and basic sanitation Strengthening women's position in society, especially in the area of 82 20 102 legal reform for equality and attacking domestic violence Respect for core labor standards 95 12 107 Indigenous communities (health, education, institutions) 2,086 2,086 Hunger and malnutrition, especially pregnant and nursing mothers, 665 375 *** 1,040 infants and the elderly Total Eradicating Poverty and Discrimination 11,933 597 12,530 1,214 AMERISUMMIT DOS +++ AID GILMORE Totals 44,430 1104 Region Total (FY 1998-2000) 45,594 Lending projections assume that countries from the region will be willing to borrow from multilateral development banks for projects included in the 1998-2000 pipeline. Figures are estimates based on thematic categories of the Santiago Action Plan. ** Includes $340 million in Food Assistance. 002 SUMMIT OF THE AMERICAS GRANT FUNDING FY 1995 - 2000 in SUPPORT OF THE FOUR OBJECTIVES ( 000s) FY 95-97 FY 98-00 OVERALL EDUCATION 127,438 130,000 STRENGTHENING DEMOCRACY/ HUMAN RIGHTS 267,823 340,000 ECONOMIC INTEGRATION AND FREE TRADE 120,000 147,000 ERADICATING POVERTY (reflects drop in PL 480) 734,533 597,000 Microenterprise 67,104 120,000 Child Survival 127,000 Measles 7,000 TOTALS 1,249,794 1,214,000 NOTE: GCC IS INCLUDED IN THE TRADE LINE, MOST OF WHICH IS BIODIVERESITY. Total Biodiversity 72,000 The Santiago Summit PREPARING THE AMERICAS FOR THE 21ST CENTURY Channels more funds into primary and secondary education as a foundation for democracy, prosperity, and equal opportunity Enhances teacher training, standards, textbook availability. and distance Education: learning programs Investing in People, Reforms curricula for a changing global marketplace Defining our Shared Increases international student and teacher exchanges Future Promotes teaching of democratic values and environmental stewardship Promotes lifelong learning, including women and displaced workers Resources from IDB. World Bank, and AID of $8.3 billion over three years Bolsters fundamental democratic freedoms and establishes a rapporteur for a free press Provides for a regional justice studies center to train judges and improve justice for all Strengthens local governmental institutions through decentralization Attacks the global scourges of corruption, terrorism and crime Launches an Alliance Against Drugs to evaluate and improve performance Stops conflicts before they start by building trust and openness in arms regimes and security budgets Strengthens labor ministries to enhance worker rights and working conditions, including the elimination of exploitative forms of child labor Resources from IDB. World Bank. and AID of $5.8 billion over three years Meets Miami commitment for the Free Trade Area of the Americas by 2005 by launching negotiations Creates healthier. more stable financial markets Building Our Wealth Through Protects the environment for future generations by addressing climate change and clean energy development Economic Integration and Trade Builds a hemispheric neighborhood for safer and more efficient air, sea, and land transportation networks Stimulates development of the Internet and other technologies Resources from IDB, World Bank. and AID of $18.7 billion over three years Opens new credit lines, training, and technologies for the microentrepreneur Rejecting Streamlines property registration for the poor Poverty Amid Enhances the role of women and vulnerable groups in society Growing Reduces illness by expanding immunization and improves the quality of drinking water Prosperity Attacks hunger and malnutrition, especially of mothers and infants, the aged, and the physically disabled Denotes environmental Resources from IDB. World Bank, and AID of $12.4 billion over three years component