Ask the Scholar

Document scope · 1 page
doc
Scholar
Ask about this object, its catalog metadata, its source description, or the page inventory. For page-specific OCR and visual context, open one of the page chats.

Source Description

Records pertain to the Office of Science and Technology Policy.

Scholar Source Context

Document identity
localId
285792603
label
Executive Office of the President: Presidential Priorities (4) [3 of 7] [1992]
core
doc
dtoType
document
pageCount
1
Source metadata
id
285792603
contentType
document
title
Executive Office of the President: Presidential Priorities (4) [3 of 7] [1992]
description
Records pertain to the Office of Science and Technology Policy.
identifierLocal
62090-001
collections
Records of the White House Office of Science and Technology (George H. W. Bush Administration)
Allan D. Bromley Files
imageCount
1
hasImages
yes
source
import
hasTranscription
no
Source extras
naId
285792603
levelOfDescription
fileUnit
recordType
description
ocrSource
nara-archive
Single page context
seq
1
pageIndex
0
type
document
mediaId
037d7649018dd067
ocrText
Originally Processed With FOIA(s): FOIA Number: 2005-0336-F 2005-0336-F FOIA MARKER This is not a textual record. This is used as an administrative marker by the George Bush Presidential Library Staff. Record Group/Collection: George H.W. Bush Presidential Records Collection/Office of Origin: Science and Technology Policy, Office of (OSTP) Series: Bromley, D. Allan, Files Subseries: Presidential Priorities Files OA/ID Number: 62090 Folder ID Number: 62090-001 Folder Title: Executive Office of the President: Presidential Priorities (4) [3 of 7] [1992] Stack: Row: Section: Shelf: Position: 0 0 0 0 These are all closed out (UNCED Letters/ MATT Document Originally Attached to Following Page "Document Control" TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201694 ORIGINATOR: 02 STATUS I DIRECTORATE STATUS FROM: WEINZIERL, Hubert: GERMAN ASSOCIATION FOR THE PROTECTION OF NATURE TO: PRESIDENT BUSH DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/27/92 SUBJECT: URGES THE PRESIDENT TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE U.S. ROLE IN ENVIRONMENTAL LEADERSHIP AND ATTEND THE UNCED "EARTH SUMMIT" IN BRAZIL. DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ENVIRONMENT ASSIGNED: ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: FOR DAB'S SIGNATURE ACTION: SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: 05/19/92 STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: COPIES TO: D. Allan Bromley WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: OSTP RECEIVED: 05/12/92 DEPT RECEIVED: FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: * 169T THE WHITE HOUSE OFFICE RECEIVED REFERRAL 12 P12: 13 MAY 12, 1992 TO: OFFICE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY MAIL ROOM ACTION REQUESTED: DIRECT REPLY, FURNISH INFO COPY DESCRIPTION OF INCOMING: ID: 326867 MEDIA: LETTER, DATED FEBRUARY 27, 1992 TO: PRESIDENT BUSH FROM: MR. HUBERT WEINZIERL CHAIRMAN (PROJEKTSTELLE UNCED DNR/BUND) GERMAN ASSOCIATION FOR THE PROTECTION OF NATURE AND THE * KONIGSWINTERER STR. 665 5300 BONN 3 FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY SUBJECT: URGES THE PRESIDENT TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE U.S. ROLE IN ENVIRONMENTAL LEADERSHIP AND ATTEND THE UNCED "EARTH SUMMIT" IN BRAZIL, JUN 92 PROMPT ACTION IS ESSENTIAL -- IF REQUIRED ACTION HAS NOT BEEN TAKEN WITHIN 9 WORKING DAYS OF RECEIPT, PLEASE TELEPHONE THE UNDERSIGNED AT 456-7486. RETURN CORRESPONDENCE, WORKSHEET AND COPY OF RESPONSE (OR DRAFT) TO: AGENCY LIAISON, ROOM 91, THE WHITE HOUSE, 20500 SALLY KELLEY DIRECTOR OF AGENCY LIAISON PRESIDENTIAL CORRESPONDENCE ID# 326867 THE WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENCE TRACKING WORKSHEET INCOMING DATE RECEIVED: MAY 08, 1992 NAME OF CORRESPONDENT: MR. HUBERT WEINZIERL SUBJECT: URGES THE PRESIDENT TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE U.S. ROLE IN ENVIRONMENTAL LEADERSHIP AND ATTEND THE UNCED "EARTH SUMMIT" IN BRAZIL, JUN 92 ACTION DISPOSITION ROUTE TO: ACT DATE TYPE C COMPLETED OFFICE/AGENCY (STAFF NAME) CODE YY/MM/DD RESP D YY/MM/DD KAR OFFICE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY POLIC ORG 92/05/88 / N / / REFERRAL NOTE: RL / / / / REFERRAL NOTE: / / / / REFERRAL NOTE: / / / / REFERRAL NOTE: / / / / REFERRAL NOTE: COMMENTS: INCOMING REC'D AT THE WHITE HOUSE MAY 4 92 * ENVIRONMENT ** CONSERVATION ADDITIONAL CORRESPONDENTS: 1 MEDIA:L INDIVIDUAL CODES: 3500 4610 4690 MI MAIL USER CODES: (A) (B) (C) *ACTION CODES: *DISPOSITION *OUTGOING * * * *CORRESPONDENCE: * *A-APPROPRIATE ACTION *A-ANSWERED *TYPE RESP=INITIALS * *C-COMMENT/RECOM *B-NON-SPEC-REFERRAL * OF SIGNER * *D-DRAFT RESPONSE *C-COMPLETED * CODE = A * *F-FURNISH FACT SHEET *S-SUSPENDED *COMPLETED = DATE OF * *I-INFO COPY/NO ACT NEC* * OUTGOING * *R-DIRECT REPLY W/COPY * * * *S-FOR-SIGNATURE * * * *X-INTERIM REPLY * * * REFER QUESTIONS AND ROUTING UPDATES TO CENTRAL REFERENCE (ROOM 75, OEOB) EXT-2590 KEEP THIS WORKSHEET ATTACHED TO THE ORIGINAL INCOMING LETTER AT ALL TIMES AND SEND COMPLETED RECORD TO RECORDS MANAGEMENT. Projektstelle 326867 OSTP UNCED DNR/BUND Königswinterer Str. 665 5300 Bonn 3 Telefon: 0228 440203 Deutscher Naturschutzring, Bund für Umwelt und Naturschutz Deutschland Telefax: 0228 443643 Königswinterer Str. 665, 5300 Bonn 3 President of the United States of America Bonn, denFeb. 27, 1992 The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, D.C. USA Dear Mr. President, with this letter we are following up our courier of February 10, 1992. Regrettably, we have not yet received any reply. Your recent statements about "a very important domestic operation" hint that local and national problems may keep you from attending the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED) in June this year in Rio de Janeiro. Despite domestic issues, we - the undersigned organizations, representing 99 member organizations with 2.6 million individual members - think the United States should help in the present international developments where the future of the planet and of mankind is at stake! Up to now in the preparatory negotiations on UNCED, the United States has failed to exercise its often declared general leadership. Although the U.S. has held several positive positions during the PrepCom process, its position overall has been to avoid commitment to policies that will advance the goals of the Earth Summit and to avoid leadership on critical environmental issues according to the Consortium for Action to Protect the Earth (CAPE '92). "The book has not yet been closed on preparations for Rio - the centerpiece of the Earth Summit, an effective climate treaty, remains to be negotiated. Come May, the United States will have to provide legally binding commitments to limit carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases if Rio is to produce any meaningful results. " During the preparatory process towards UNCED, the United States delegation has rather limited progress on the following policies: - it has sought to remove the entire chapter addressing the impact of consumption on the environment and to delete or weaken references to consumption throughout the negotiations; - it has assisted in substantially weakening recommendations on promoting greater energy efficiency and renewables as well as on incorporating full cost pricing on energy use - despite the fact that at the London G-7 Summit, the United States agreed to seek to 'price energy from all sources so as to reflect costs fully, including environmental costs'. The U.S. also strongly opposed environmental impact assessments of policy measures relating to energy despite the fact that it was supporting such assessments in other parts of Agenda 21, for UN institutions, and in the proposed Earth Charter. - it has weakened language to remove price distortions and to develop full cost environmental accounting and global corporate environmental management; - it has opposed proposals by other nations to adopt a ban on the transboundary traffic of hazardous and radioactive wastes. Such ban has been adopted between European and developing nations. In addition to your consideration not to attend the Rio Conference, all these points will contribute to a shrinking respect of the United States abroad - and will bring your country to isolation from the international community which is getting ready to undergo the necessary changes to care for the Earth. Preparations for the Earth Summit are nearing an end. The planning process for a climate change treaty and other critical issues of the Earth Summit will continue at the next and final round of negotiations for the first (mentioned) in New York from April 30 to May 8. Dear Mr. President, now is one of the last opportunities to reconsider your position on the United Nations Conference. We encourage you to be consistent to the United States' role in environmental leadership, a role you have claimed so many times. Strong commitments are needed for our common future ; the world is watching the United States and its President - in particular for this biggest and most important conference of the UN. Therefore, we urgently ask you not to disappoint these expectations which in many countries of the world, but certainly in your own as well are linked especially to your person. Looking forward to a more positive echo we remain Yours sincerely W.G.J. Prof Dr. W. Engelhardt Hubert Weinzierl President Chairman Deutscher Naturachutzring Bund für Umwelt und Naturschutz Deutschland (German League for the (German Association for Protection of the Environment the Protection of Nature and Nature Conservation) and the Environment) THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON May 28, 1992 Dear Mr. Weinzierl and Professor Engelbart: Thank you for your letter to President Bush about global environmental issues, particularly regarding the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED). The President appreciates your comments and suggestions. The United States has been, and will continue to be, a leader in environmental stewardship. President Bush believes that global stewardship is our shared responsibility and our shared opportunity. He is committed to working with the international community to produce strategies for managing the Earth's natural resources in ways that assure the sustainability of humanity on this planet and in ways that maximize our potential for growth and opportunity for all. It is the President's conviction that environmental protection and economic growth, well managed, complement one another. Global stewardship is a continuing process of political, economic, and social decision-making that meets the needs of the present generation, while expanding the opportunities of future generations. UNCED provides an unprecedented opportunity for addressing a broad range of such concerns that are of vital interest to developed nations and the developing nations alike. In keeping with his commitment to fostering greater cooperation in approaching the environmental problems, the President has announced that he will attend the Rio Conference. President Bush recognizes the widespread interest in addressing the issue of global climate change. In that regard, the President is pleased with the successful negotiation of a framework convention on climate change. Enclosed is a statement about the role that the United States has played in safeguarding our environment and about issues relating to UNCED. I hope that this information is helpful to you. It comes to you with the President's best wishes. Sincerely yours, Dauan Romley D. Allan Bromley The Assistant to the President for Science and Technology Mr. Hubert Weinzierl Professor W. Engelbart Konigswinterer Str. 665 5300 Bonn 3 Federal Republic of Germany "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201266 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Merritt C. Bragdon TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/26/92 SUBJECT: He is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB's signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document #9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 03/04/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 920166 6030 No. 16th St. Arlington, VA 22205 Feb. 26, 1992 President George Bush The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Washington, DC 20500 Dear Mr. Bush: I strongly urge you to attend the Earth Summit this coming June in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. This UN Conference on Environment and Development offers an extraordinary chance to redirect resources away from military alloca- tions and toward environmental protection and sustain- able economic development. It also offers you an opportunity, in an election year, to deliver on your promise to be an "Enviromental President." In particular, I hope that you will endeavor at the Summit to obtain general agreement on conventions to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, to cut air and water pollution, and to protect the world's forests. Such agree- ments must contain specific timetables in order to be effective. Sincerely, menitt C Merritt C. Bragdon Bragdon "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201258 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Carolyn J. Dennis TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/26/92 SUBJECT: She is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB'S signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document #9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/28/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 51 Earth 9201258 Feb. 26, 1992 Dear President Bush; & am very concerned about the upcoming UNCED meeting (United nations Conference on Environment and Development) in June in Brazil. This is such an outstanding opportunity to set world wide goals for improving and safeguarding the environment, and, alleviating poverty. However, for some reason ?? your / our delegation has been very disipalined to make any agreements- - for example, we have so far not agreed to any control of our CO2 emissions, We also need to push for strong legal controls to implement the agree ments, In addition, & hope you -2- will push for reform of our foreign aid - We need to increase development aid (to at least aid%) and decrease military to attending this conference? - It and how about committing now promises to be a larger gathering of world leaders than even the world Summit for Children in 1990, Let's take a leadership role not a foot dragging role - and be a model for other countries. Sincerely, Carolyn J Dennis "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201213 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Arthur Goldstein TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: SUBJECT: He is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB's signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on docuement number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/24/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: Memo from unced Arthur Goldstein 9201213 2/24/92 Diar Prees Bush- I hope have time to read thuse articles. I have underluned them to sall you fund. I agree with them reasion 110% were Environmental delemmas and The all exacerbated by reasonsfar the the Environment for your slowdowns. Please join us and become an Certher GeldHu Best sake ARTHUR GOLDSTEIN, I.A. 7 WOODLAND AVENUE LARCHMONT, N.Y. 10538 Lead Us to Rio, Mr. President 2/22/92 Other nations seem to understand By Michael Oppenheimer that the warming effect of carbon dioxide, like the ozone-depleting ef- lobal warming negotia- fect of chlorofluorocarbons, cannot be tions at the United reversed for decades. These coun- Nations remain tries have learned not to use the need stalled as the U.S. del- for continued research as an excuse egation and the world for delay. In contrast, the Bush Ad- await a White House ministration uses scientific uncer- shift in policy. Next week's session tainty like a talisman to ward off provides President Bush with one last critics of its inaction. It seems intent chance to become a global environ- on repeating the misjudgments that mental leader instead of a spoiler. led to wholesale ozone depletion. The Administration's recent deci- The President's advisers hold a sign to support measures that will myopic economic view, focusing on speed up the elimination of chloro- exaggerated cost estimates for re- fluorocarbons, the main ozone-deplet- ducing emissions. Instead, they ing chemicals, was welcome and nec- should consider the economic oppor- essary but it doesn't redeem Mr. tunities that will arise in an increas- Bush's 1988 campaign promise to be ingly energy-efficient, environment- an environmental President. The de- conscious world. The climate agree- cision to protect the earth's thinning ment will exert more influence over ozone layer came only after a year technology and trade than a dozen filled with increasingly dire scientific Presidential trips to Japan. Our com- reports. Furthermore, the Du Pont petitors are preparing to take advan- Company, the largest American pro- tage of these possibilities while the ducer of chlorofluorocarbons, had al- U.S. only dithers. Consider the future of the automo- bile. Motor vehicles are responsible for about a quarter of carbon dioxide It's Bush's last emissions from the U.S. There are about two people for each car in chance to be an America but more than 500 people for each car in China. An explosive environmentalist. growth in emissions would occur if China and other developing countries become as dependent on gas-guzzling cars as we are. Obviously, global efforts to protect ready committed to most of the new the climate will create the need for requirements in October. more efficient vehicles. Manufactur- Our Government has generally un- ers already have prototypes getting derestimated the risk posed by 100 miles per gallon and emitting one chlorofluorocarbons. It. has treated quarter as much carbon dioxide as a scientists like a flock of Chicken Lit- typical new car. Carrying out a global tles since they warned of this threat warming treaty would create mar- 18 years ago. Meanwhile, measured kets for such cars, and provide an ozone depletion now exceeds any pre- incentive for other U.S. companies to vious prediction and will at least dou- create the energy-efficient products ble before the elimination of chloro- the world will demand. fluorocarbon emissions reverses its Is the U.S. prepared to compete in course. these new markets? Not if it remains The current U.N. negotiations are a backwater of energy inefficiency aimed at limiting the buildup of green- among industrialized nations. house gases, primarily carbon dioxide Negotiators are rushing to draft a emitted during fossil fuel combustion, climate treaty before the so-called that are expected to cause significant earth summit in Rio de Janeiro in global warming. Almost all the major June. If the American delegation would industrialized nations have agreed to a promote an ironclad timetable for re- modest first step: restricting emis- ducing emissions of carbon dioxide and sions of carbon dioxide by year 2000 to other warming gases now, a strong levels no higher than those in 1990. The treaty that cleans up the atmosphere U.S. has offered nothing. and stimulates new jobs and industries is likely. A weak treaty, or no agree- Michael Oppenheimer is senior scien- ment, could lead to environmental hav- tist at the Environmental Defense OC. That could be inevitable if the Pres- Fund. ident doesn't act next week. The global food supply is threatened by effects of our lifestyle; the destruction of the ozone layer is Houston Post 1/26/92 letting out too many damaging ultraviolet rays, global warming leading to higher rainfall and a rising sea level will cause blights and pest to move northward. The list goes on. Campaigning for Gore does not leave us to squirm mercilessly with no relief. He has, like any good politician, a plan. He calls it a global Marshall Plan, after the original Mar- shall Plan that saw the United States and Britain invest the environment in the rebuilding of Europe after World War II. He envisions annual environmental summit meet- ings, where wealthy and poor nations get together to and the future decide what they can do to stop the damage. He sees Brazil offering to stop the leveling of the rain forests while more developed countries reduce their green- house emissions. Quickly dismissing the idea of a world government, Gore turns to the United Nations as a last resort. He a EARTH IN THE BALANCE: envisions the possibility of a stewardship council simi- Ecology and the Human Spirit lar to the security council we hear from so much these e d days. He sees rich countries volunteering to pay for Houghton Mifflin. 407 pp. $22.95. pollution control equipment for poor countries, only this time it wouldn't be the United States doling out the cash. He volunteers Japan, Europe and the oil- By STEPHANIE GLASS producing states. OF THE HOUSTON POST STAFF He outlines five strategic goals for this international effort: stabilize the world's population; develop envi- OST REMEMBER Al Gore, Democratic sena ronmentally appropriate technologies; create a new M for from Tennessee, from his days as a economic svstem that takes into account ecological contender for the 1988 Democratic presi- consequences: establish a set of agreements, regula- dential nomination. I remember him stumping in the tions and enforcement actions that everyone would Rio Grande Valley, getting up with the sun to jog adhere to; and educate the masses about the global around Rio Grande City surrounded by Secret Service environment. men both on foot and on wheels. Tt is hard to imagine such cooperation, especially This year Gore may have passed up the race, but when there are more than 100 wars around the globe he's stumping for something else: the future of the and more conflicts simmering. And it may seem environment. strange to get this environmental warning from a Instead of rushing from tarmac to tarmac. he's tour- member of the United States Senate — especially one ing the country's book stores to bring the message of not actively campaigning. But forget about the mes- environmental devastation on a global scale and what senger and just worry about the message. It is not to he thinks should be done about it. be taken lightly. It was probably much easier to analyze America's Glass writes about environmental Issues for The Post. problems and suggest solutions. When it comes to the environment, oh, if it only meant cleaning up the United States. What Gore is trying to tell us in Earth in the Balance: Ecology and the Human Spirit is this: It's everybody's problem and everyone must work toward a solution. Either we fix it together or we all lose. Gore's book is full of frightening scenarios that should be required reading. It's easy to cover our lawns with chemicals and not think about where the runoff will go after a rain. Or watch developers clear, land for another subdivision without thinking what species may have been displaced. It is not easy to read a book like this; one is filled with a sense of anxiety, dread. futility, of powerlessness over the problems displayed on such a grand scale. In chilling detail, Gore dishes up the world's envi- ronmental problems, going back thousands of years to trace patterns of destruction. For those who turn a) deaf ear to the prospect of global warming, there is ample evidence of suffering from past climate changes. In the spring of 1815, a large series of volcanic eruptions shook Indonesia. Almost 100,000 people were killed from the eruptions and subsequent starva- tion and disease. A year later the effects were felt in Europe when crops failed, crime swelled, beggars clogged roads and governments fell to revolution. In) From "Earth in the Balance" New England, it snowed in the summer. We may think we can forget about the rest of the Sen. AI Gore of Tennessee has developed world when it comes to putting food on our table. But what he calls a global Marshall Plan for the Gore's background as a farmer in Carthage, Tenn environment. aids him in conveying how inextricably linked our capacity to produce crops is with the condition of the rest of the world. "Document Control" TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9200819 ORIGINATOR: 02 STATUS I DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: SEGGERMAN, Anne: THE FOURTH WORLD FOUNDATION TO: PRESIDENT BUSH DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/26/92 SUBJECT: SHE URGES THE U.S. TO BE IN THE FOREFRONT OF SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION DEVELOPING AND CREATING AN ATMOSPHERE FREE FROM FLUOROCARBONS AND CARBON DIOXIDE. DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ENVIRONMENT ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: DIRECT REPLY PER PRES. CO ACTION: Draft for DAB SIG SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: 03/20/92 STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 03/31/92 COPIES TO: D. Allan Bromley WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: DAB signed letter; In enviro files: UNCED; PRES OSTP RECEIVED: 03/16/92 DEPT RECEIVED: FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON March 31, 1992 Dear Mrs. Seggerman: On behalf of President Bush, thank you for your comments and suggestions about global environmental issues. The United States, under President Bush's leadership, is aggressively pursuing international efforts to address problems related to climate change, ozone depletion, forests, oceans, biological diversity, and technology cooperation with developing countries. The Administration has put forward specific proposals in various international fora to address each of these questions. More important, the United States is already taking specific steps here at home, through both legislation and administrative action, to begin tackling these problems. Specifically regarding climate change, you may be pleased to know that the United States has already begun taking actions that will have the effect of reducing net emissions of greenhouse gases. These include: * President Bush proposed and signed into law the 1990 Clean Air Act, which will reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the utility sector through restrictions on utility air pollutants; * The Bush Administration has proposed, both through the National Energy Strategy and through various regulatory measures, to improve energy efficiency in power generation and transmission, buildings, appliances, lighting, and transportation, which will restrain related carbon dioxide emissions; * The President has proposed, through his tree planting initiatives, to increase the acreage and to improve the management of forests, which act as greenhouse gas "sinks"; * The President has proposed to expand the use of renewable and low-emission fuel sources; * Since President Bush took office, he has doubled funding for conservation research and development (R&D) and increased funding for renewable R&D by 69 percent; and OSTP:ENVIRO:NGM:MS:March 31, 1992:#9200819: PRESIDENTIAL Page 2 - Mrs. Seggerman * The Administration has not only proposed, but the President has signed into law, the phaseout of ozone-depleting compounds that are also greenhouse gases. Additionally, in February 1992, in response to new scientific evidence, President Bush was the first head of state to commit his country unilaterally to accelerating the date for the complete phaseout of the production of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs). The President's action moves up the phaseout date of CFCs, which deplete the Earth's ozone layer, to December 31, 1995. Due to a number of previous Administration actions, U.S. production of ozone-depleting substances is already more than 40 percent below levels allowed by the internationally agreed Montreal Protocol. Under the new schedule, the U.S. will eliminate production four years ahead of the current international deadline, thus continuing the record of U.S. leadership in this area extending back to the mid-1970s. The United States supports a comprehensive approach, addressing all greenhouse gases, not just carbon dioxide, and "sinks," such as forests. Focusing exclusively on carbon dioxide emissions, as some have proposed, is an inadequate response. The United States has committed $25 million to assist developing countries in planning to mitigate and/or adapt to climate change. The U.S. has stepped up its own climate action plan, first outlined in February 1991, including actions in such areas as energy efficiency, transportation, reduced emission supply technologies, agriculture, natural resources, and technology R&D. The United States has also committed $50 million to the core fund of the Global Environment Facility (GEF) and $150 million in parallel financing through the U.S. Agency for International Development. In addition to addressing global climate change, the GEF also funds projects concerning biodiversity, international waters, and ozone. The U.S. Global Change Research Program is the world's largest such program and thus provides much of the scientific foundation for international agreements on climate change and ozone depletion. The Bush Administration has invested $2.6 billion in global change research, far more than any other country, with an additional $1.3 billion proposed for year 1993 -- over six times the fiscal 1989 level. Research on the scientific and economic aspects of global climate change will enable policy makers to make better judgments about potential impacts and policy actions. Page 3 - Mrs. Seggerman Regarding the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), scheduled this June in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, President Bush is committed to achieving international agreement on a framework convention on climate change. In addition to a global agreement on climate change, the Bush Administration also hopes UNCED will produce strategies and specific initiatives to improve conservation of forests, oceans, and biological diversity, and to increase technology cooperation with developing countries. You can be sure that the United States will be well represented at the conference. As we move forward into the 1990s, the United States will continue to address global environmental challenges within a context of expanding economic opportunities for all the world's people. The United States wants concrete, practical results from UNCED -- results that will guide future action on the full range of environmental and developmental issues. Thank you for taking the time to express your interest on these environmental issues with President Bush. You can be sure that the President will continue working with other nations to obtain global solutions to these challenging issues. With the President's best wishes, Sincerely yours, The Домаи Assistant D. Allan to Bromley the President Premly for Science and Technology Mrs. Anne Seggerman The Fourth World Foundation, Inc. 5060 Congress Street Fairfield, Connecticut 06430 OSTP STAFFING SHEET SUBJECT: UNCED and the President ORIGINATOR: Nancy Maynard and Matt Stader PHONE X6202 DATE ORIGINATED: 3/31/92 DATE DUE 3/31/92 CORR TRACKING NO: 9200819 EXTERNAL COORDINATION: COMMENTS DATE DIRECTOR X CHIEF OF STAFF GENERAL COUNSEL EXBC. ASST. X ACTION REQUESTED: Damar: Please have Dr. Bromley sian this 3 page letter and return to Signed letter to Kara for processing COORDINATION DATE COMMENTS Concur Henderson. D.A. Nonconcur Concur Phillips, W. Nonconcur Conour Ratchford, J.T. Nonconcur Concur Wong, E Nonconcur maynard, NConcur 3/27 Input comments & Put in Final Form Nonconcur Concur Nonconcur Concur Nonconour Concur Nonconcur Concur Nonconcur Concur Nonconcur Concur Nonconcur Conour Nonconcur Concur Nonconcur THE WHITE HOUSE OFFICE REFERRAL RECEIVED MARCH 13, 1992 09 TO: OFFICE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY ATTN: NANCY MAYNARD MAIL ROOM ACTION REQUESTED: DIRECT REPLY, FURNISH INFO COPY DESCRIPTION OF INCOMING: ID: 314310 MEDIA: LETTER, DATED FEBRUARY 26, 1992 TO: PRESIDENT BUSH FROM: MRS. ANNE SEGGERMAN THE FOURTH WORLD FOUNDATION, INC. 5060 CONGRESS STREET FAIRFIELD CT 06430 SUBJECT: URGES THE U.S. TO BE IN THE FOREFRONT OF SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION DEVELOPING AND CREATING AN ATMOSPHERE FREE FROM FLUOROCARBONS AND CARBON DIOXIDE PROMPT ACTION IS ESSENTIAL -- IF REQUIRED ACTION HAS NOT BEEN TAKEN WITHIN 9 WORKING DAYS OF RECEIPT, PLEASE TELEPHONE THE UNDERSIGNED AT 456-7486. RETURN CORRESPONDENCE, WORKSHEET AND COPY OF RESPONSE (OR DRAFT) TO: AGENCY LIAISON, ROOM 91, THE WHITE HOUSE, 20500 SALLY KELLEY DIRECTOR OF AGENCY LIAISON PRESIDENTIAL CORRESPONDENCE ID# 314310 THE WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENCE TRACKING WORKSHEET INCOMING DATE RECEIVED: MARCH 11, 1992 NAME OF CORRESPONDENT: MRS. ANNE SEGGERMAN SUBJECT: URGES THE U.S. TO BE IN THE FOREFRONT OF SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION DEVELOPING AND CREATING AN ATMOSPHERE FREE FROM FLUOROCARBONS AND CARBON DIOXIDE ACTION DISPOSITION ROUTE TO: ACT DATE TYPE C COMPLETED OFFICE/AGENCY (STAFF NAME) CODE YY/MM/DD RESP D YY/MM/DD RAR 9LD 13 OFFICE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY POLIC ORG 92/03/11 / / REFERRAL NOTE: ATTN: NANCY MAYNARD / / / / REFERRAL NOTE: / / / / REFERRAL NOTE: / / / / REFERRAL NOTE: / / / / REFERRAL NOTE: COMMENTS: INCOMING REC'D IN CORRESP. ANALYSIS THRU PATTY PRESOCK AND SHIRLEY GREEN PER ATTACHED NOTES ADDITIONAL CORRESPONDENTS: MEDIA:L INDIVIDUAL CODES: 4800 MI MAIL USER CODES: (A) (B) (C) *ACTION CODES: *DISPOSITION *OUTGOING * * * *CORRESPONDENCE: * *A-APPROPRIATE ACTION *A-ANSWERED *TYPE RESP=INITIALS * *C-COMMENT/RECOM *B-NON-SPEC-REFERRAL * OF SIGNER * *D-DRAFT RESPONSE *C-COMPLETED * CODE = A * *F-FURNISH FACT SHEET *S-SUSPENDED *COMPLETED = DATE OF * *I-INFO COPY/NO ACT NEC* * OUTGOING * *R-DIRECT REPLY W/COPY * * * *S-FOR-SIGNATURE * * * *X-INTERIM REPLY * * * REFER QUESTIONS AND ROUTING UPDATES TO CENTRAL REFERENCE (ROOM 75, ,OEOB) EXT-2590 KEEP THIS WORKSHEET ATTACHED TO THE ORIGINAL INCOMING LETTER AT ALL TIMES AND SEND COMPLETED RECORD TO RECORDS MANAGEMENT. Patty Presock 3/2 Phil: POTUS has not seen. P. To Lillie THE WHITE HOUSE CEQ WASHINGTON Date: 3/3/92 FOR: SHIRLEY GREEN FROM: PHILLIP BRADY K Assistant to the President and Staff Secretary Information XXX Action Let's Discuss record? Jan- friend? any records (from VP days too) attached, but Patty says 2 responses were courtesy. He does not know, but he sat next to her at some lunch and said she could write in care of Patty. fan 214310 Nanay The Fourth World Foundation, Inc. 5060 Congress Street, Fairfield, Conn. 06430, Phone 203 255-4459 February 26, 1992 Dear Mr. President, As we have had the opportunity in the past to correspond on domestic policy, I hope to call your attention to another 2/22 pressing issue which was raised last Saturday in the New York Times by Michael Oppenheimer: The Environment: While many scholars applaud your action to hasten the elimination of carbon dioxide and fluorocarbon emissions which are hazardous to the ozone layer, it is apparent that there exists an even greater opportunity. This opportunity is the creation of a crash program for the research and development of alternative energy sources. This program would place the United States at the forefront of the resource movement. Here we can create a vision utilizing our advantage of elite science and technology experts, to lead the way in developing natural more environmentally friendly energy sources. This domestic program would also provide a unique opportunity to employ Soviet nuclear intellectuals in projects that would benefit all of man kind. As the goal of reversing 'global warming' gains momentum, legislation for reductions in the production of both carbon dioxide and fluorocarbons should be enacted. While some theories state that 'global warming' may be partially caused by sun spots and other environmental effects, this has yet to be proven. Therefore at this time it is imperative that the United Stated take a leadership position in `cooling' down the atmosphere. Given that the world is organizing these standards, many of which will be presented at the earth summit in Rio de Janeiro this June, your position to phase out fluorocarbons ahead of schedule should be followed to its fullest vision by reallocating our resources and researching and creating alternatives energy models, such as solar, wind and geothermal energy. In order to create and thrive in an atmosphere free from fluorocarbons and carbon dioxide, the United States should be at the forefront of scientific innovation developing such alternatives and presenting them to the world. Such bold initiative would reduce our dependence on outside nations for oil and other fossil fuels and give the United States a corner on the world market for such products. The climate agreement and other such programs would effectively create a new industry and give the United States an international economic comparative advantage by reducing the cost of doing business. Both of these beneifts would provide great long term benefits to the economy. In summary at this critical junction in time the United States has the opportunity to improved the environment while creating long term structural benefits to the domestic economy. The global warming negotiations taking place at the United Nations could be a prominent opportunity to present these ideas. Thank you for the opportunity to express my views. Respectfully with warm personal regards, ame Segzerman 032171CU DOCUMENT= 1 OF 3 PAGE = 1 OF 1 OPID DG DOCDATE 890421 RECTYP IBA MEDIA L pres STAFF C. BOYDEN GRAY CUGRAY days NAME ANNE CRELLIN SEGGERMAN STREET 5060 CONGRESS STREET ADDR FAIRFIELD CT 06430 SUBJECT LETTER THANKING BOYDEN GRAY FOR RECOMMENDING HER TO THE COMMITTEE FOR HOUSING FOR HANDICAPPED FAMILIES SUBCODE FG999 HS HE001-06 INDCODE 4000 ACTION CUOFC ORG 890428 C 890510 CUAT07 RSA 890501 C 890510 CUGRAY RSI 890501 C COMMENTS NO RESPONSE NECESSARY - CLOSE OUT I0607 * End of document. 104433 DOCUMENT= 3 OF 3 PAGE = 1 OF 2 OPID CB DOCDATE 891212 RECTYP OBA MEDIA L NAME MRS. ANNE C. SEGGERMAN PSAL ANNE ORG THE FOURTH WORLD FOUNDATION, INC. STREET 5060 CONGRESS STREET ADDR FARIFIELD CT 06430 SUBJECT THANKS FOR THAT THOUGHTFUL LETTER AND YOUR INVITATION TO STOP BY YOUR HOME DURING OUR UPCOMING VISIT TO ST. MARTIN -- BARBARA JOINS ME IN SENDING OUR WARMEST BEST WISHES TO YOU AND HARRY FOR A SPECIAL HOLIDAY SEASON FILLED WITH MUCH HAPPINESS AND PEACE SUBCODE IV089 CO173 TR050 PP005-01 HO006 CO051 INDCODE 4690 ACTION RM DSP 891213 CP2 A 891212 COMMENTS REGRETTED BY PHONE TO ANNE SEGGERMAN -BRIDGET SysAvl Appl 496815VP DOCUMENT= 4 OF 8 PAGE = 1 OF 1 OPID TM DOCDATE 870708 SOURCE IBA MEDIA L PRECIP GEORGE BUSH VPBUSH AUTHOR ANNE CRELLIN SEGGERMAN PSAL ANNE STREET 5060 CONGRESS STREET ADDR FAIRFIELD CT 06430 SUBJECT ENCLOSED REPORT AND PRESENTATION TO THE PRESIDENTIAL COMMITTEE ON MENTAL RETARDATION SUBCODE RS HE001-04 OTHCNTL VP ACTION VPGRE1 ORG 870714 C 870728 VPBUSH RSI 870714 GB C 870810 I0607 * End of document. 557357VP DOCUMENT= 6 OF 8 PAGE = 1 OF 1 OPID TM DOCDATE 880421SysAvl Appl SOURCE IBA MEDIA L PRECIP GEORGE BUSH VPBUSH AUTHOR ANNE CRELIN SEGGERMAN PSAL ANNE STREET 5060 CONGRESS STREET ADDR FAIRFIELD CT 06430 SUBJECT PERSONAL SUBCODE AF OTHCNTL VP ACTION VPBUSH ORG 880425 GB A 880429 I0607 * End of document. 570885VP DOCUMENT= 7 OF 8 PAGE = 1 OF 1 OPID TM DOCDATE 880511 SOURCE IBA MEDIA L PRECIP GEORGESBHAH1 Appl VPBUSH AUTHOR HARRY G. A. SEGGERMAN STREET 5060 CONGRESS STREET ADDR FAIRFIELD CT 06430 SUBJECT COMMENTS ON PLANT CLOSING BILL OTHCNTL VP ACTION VPGRE1 ORG 880517 S 880531 VPBUSH RSI 880517 C 880517 I0607 * End of document. DOCDATE 850723 SOURCE. IBA MEDIA L vp days PRECIP GEORGE BUSH VPBUSH AUTHOR MR. HARRY G. A. SEGGERMAN STREET 5060 CONGRESS STREET ADDR FAIRFIELD CT 06430 SUBJECT COMMENTS MADE ON THE DAVID BRINKLEY SHOW ON SUNDAY, JUL 21 INDCODE 4000 OTHCNTL VP ACTION VPGREG ORG 850806 C 850820 VPBUSH RSI 850806 C 850806 COMMENTS NOT RETURNED TO FILES I0607 * End of document. 420848VP DOCUMENT= 2 OF 8 PAGE = 1 OF 1 OPID LC DOCDATE 860728 SOURCE IBA SysAvl Appl MEDIA L PRECIP GEORGE BUSH VPBUSH AUTHOR MR. AND MRS. HARRY SEGGERMAN STREET 5060 CONGRESS STREET ADDR FAIRFIELD CT 06430 SUBJECT INVITATION FOR THE VICE PRESIDENT AND MRS. BUSH TO ATTEND A RECEPTION IN HONOR OF DR. THOMAS PATRICK MELADY AND ROBERT PRESTON IN FAIRFIELD, CT ON 10 AUG 86 SUBCODE VI086 OTHCNTL INVT860810 ACTION VPHUTT ORG 860728 RGRT BY PHONE C 860804 VPBUSH RSI 860728 C 860728 VPROSE RSI 860728 C 860728 I0607 * End of document. 479351VP DOCUMENT= 3 OF 8 PAGE = 1 OF 1 OPID TM DOCDATE 870509 SOURCE IBA MEDIA L PRECIP GEORGE BUSH VPBUSH AUTHOR ANNE C. SEGGERMAN ORG THE SHROUD OF TURIN EXHIBITION COMMITTEE STREET 5060 CONGRESS STREET ADDR FAIRFIELD CT 06430 SUBJECT INVITATION - THE SHROUD OF TURIN LUNCHEON AND PRESENTATION WASHINGTON, DC - MAY 13, 87 SUBCODE VI087 OTHCNTL VP ACTION VPIRAS ORG 870512 HI A 870526 VPBUSH RSI 870512 C 870512 VPBATE RSI 870512 C 870512 I0607 * End of document. "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201273 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Steve Spriggs TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/26/92 SUBJECT: He is urging the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB's signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document #9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/29/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 5.1 9201273 SC FUNDING CORPORATION ISC SC FUNDING CORP 5 PARK PLAZA . SUITE 1150 IRVINE, CALIFORNIA . 92714 (714) 724-1442 . (800) 562-4404 FAX (714) 724-1341 February 26, 1992 President George Bush The White House Washington, DC 20500 Dear Mr. President: The Earth Charter is an idea that deserves your support. I support the Earth Charter. As a grand- father you should also. Sincerely yours, the Spees Steve Spriggs Please Call STEVE SPRIGGS PAGER # : (714) 637-7243 ACCESS CODE : 921342 "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201224 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Louis S. Campbell TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/25/92 SUBJECT: He is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB's signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/27/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: UNcord 9201224 P.O. Box 7259 Corona-Elmhurst, N.Y. 11373 February 24, 1992 President George Bush The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, D.C. 20500 Dear President Bush: This coming June of 1992, heads of state, government ministers, and non-government officials will meet in Brazil for a United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED). The aim: to find ways to reconcile economic activities with the need to protect the earth and ensure a sustainable future. For developing nations, the challenge is to break the vicious circle of dependence on Western technology and indebtedness. For industrialized nations, the task is to reorient patterns of economic activity, to curb their outsize consumption of the planet's natural resources and the enormous contamination that results. The Sierra Club has joined the Consortium for Action to Protect the Earth (CAPE 92), an environmental coalition to coordinate efforts on UNCED. I respectfully unge you, Mr. President, to undertake a conservation-oriented energy policy that will curb carbon dioxide emissions by 20 percent from 1988 levels by the year 2000, to seek preservation of primary forests as the main goal of a global forest agreement--and as a demonstration of United States commitment, demand an immediate halt to logging of primary and ancient forests in the United States, especially since, as you know, trees absorb carbon dioxide. I also urge expansion of existing international treaties, such as the law of the Sea Convention, to reverse the decline of marine ecosystems and to focus on land-based sources of ocean pollution, and work for a strengthened United Nations for setting environmental standards, monitoring, and assisting nations' compliance. Mr. President, our great and universally respected nation has always been a leader among nations in "doing the right thing." I sincerely and whole-heartedly believe that it is our country 1 obligation to take and maintain a leadership role in curbing global warming and the destruction of tropical forests, in order to avoid the otherwise certain destruction of the earth and all its inhabitants. Sincerely yours, Louis S. Campbell Runs S.Carpbell Member, Sierra Club "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201226 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Sara Ebenreck, PhD TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/25/92 SUBJECT: She is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB'S signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/27/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: a N conference SARA EBENRECK 3451 Sixes Road Prince Frederick, MD 20678 (301) 855-1064 9201226 February 25, 1992 President George Bush White House 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. Washington DC Dear President Bush: This letter is to add my voice to many others urging that you personally go to the June 1992 UN Conference on Environment and Development in Brazil. Global environmental and justice issues, ranging from depletion of the ozone layer to trade agreements, are at the heart of issues that we need to face as a nation. Your appearance at that conference gives a highly important symbolic support to the working of crafting agreements that can help us assure planet Earth remains systainable for just human habitation for the next century. Sincerely, Sara Ebenreck, PhD "Document Control" TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201147 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: GEBERT, ANDREW TO: PRESIDENT BUSH DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/25/92 SUBJECT: HE IS WRITING TO URGE THE PRESIDENT TO ATTEND THE EARTH SUMMIT (UNCED) IN RIO DE JANEIRO, BRAZIL DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: DRAFT FOR DAB'S SIGNATURE SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 03/13/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 9201142 THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON April 2, 1992 Dear Mr. Gebert: On behalf of President Bush, thank you for your comments and suggestions about global environmental issues and the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED). The President appreciates your concerns and has asked that I respond to your letter of February 25, 1992 regarding these issues. The United States, under President Bush's leadership, is aggressively pursuing international efforts to address problems related to climate change, ozone depletion, forests, oceans, biological diversity, and technology cooperation with developing countries. The Administration has put forward specific proposals in various international fora to address each of these questions. More important, the United States is already taking specific steps here at home, through both legislation and administrative action, to begin tackling these problems. Specifically regarding climate change, you may be pleased to know that the United States has already begun taking actions that will have the effect of reducing net emissions of greenhouse gases. These include: * President Bush proposed and signed into law the 1990 Clean Air Act, which will reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the utility sector through restrictions on utility air pollutants; * The Bush Administration has proposed, both through the National Energy Strategy and through various regulatory measures, to improve energy efficiency in power generation and transmission, buildings, appliances, lighting, and transportation, which will restrain related carbon dioxide emissions; * The President has proposed, through his tree planting initiatives, to increase the acreage and to improve the management of forests, which act as greenhouse gas "sinks"; * The President has proposed to expand the use of renewable and low-emission fuel sources; Page 2 - - Mr. Gebert * Since President Bush took office, he has doubled funding for conservation research and development (R&D) and increased funding for renewable R&D by 69 percent; and * The Administration has not only proposed, but the President has signed into law, the phaseout of ozone-depleting compounds that are also greenhouse gases. Additionally, in February 1992, in response to new scientific evidence, President Bush was the first head of state to commit his country unilaterally to accelerating the date for the complete phaseout of the production of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs). The President's action moves up the phaseout date of CFCs, which deplete the Earth's ozone layer, to December 31, 1995. Due to a number of previous Administration actions, U.S. production of ozone-depleting substances is already more than 40 percent below levels allowed by the internationally agreed Montreal Protocol. Under the new schedule, the U.S. will eliminate production four years ahead of the current international deadline, thus continuing the record of U.S. leadership in this area extending back to the mid-1970s. The United States supports a comprehensive approach, addressing all greenhouse gases, not just carbon dioxide, and "sinks," such as forests. Focusing exclusively on carbon dioxide emissions, as some have proposed, is an inadequate response. The United States has committed $25 million to assist developing countries in planning to mitigate and/or adapt to climate change. The U.S. has stepped up its own climate action plan, first outlined in February 1991, including actions in such areas as energy efficiency, transportation, reduced emission supply technologies, agriculture, natural resources, and technology R&D. The United States has also committed $50 million to the core fund of the Global Environment Facility (GEF) and $150 million in parallel financing through the U.S. Agency for International Development. In addition to addressing global climate change, the GEF also funds projects concerning biodiversity, international waters, and ozone. The U.S. Global Change Research Program is the world's largest such program and thus provides much of the scientific foundation for international agreements on climate change and ozone depletion. The Bush Administration has invested $2.6 billion in global change research, far more than any other country, with an additional $1.3 billion proposed for year 1993 over six times the fiscal 1989 level. Research on the scientific and economic aspects Page 3 - - Mr. Gebert of global climate change will enable policy makers to make better judgments about potential impacts and policy actions. Regarding the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), scheduled this June in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, President Bush is committed to achieving international agreement on a framework convention on climate change. In addition to a global agreement on climate change, the Bush Administration also hopes UNCED will produce strategies and specific initiatives to improve conservation of forests, oceans, and biological diversity, and to increase technology cooperation with developing countries. You can be sure that the United States will be well represented at the conference. As we move forwardinto the 1990s, the United States will continue to address global environmental challenges within a context of expanding economic opportunities for all the world's people. The United States wants concrete, practical results from UNCED - results that will guide future action on the full range of environmental and developmental issues. Thank you for taking the time to express your interest on these environmental issues with President Bush. You can be sure that the President will continue working with other nations to obtain global solutions to these challenging issues. With the President's best wishes, Sincerely yours, D.Anan Biamley D. Allan Bromley The Assistant to the President for Science and Technology Mr. Andrew Gebert 4 Briarwood Lane Woodstock, New York 12498 UNLED ZIP A1COMPUS 6208013A001 (C1ENGLE4 - 0067) 2/25/92 17:23 20501 THE HONORABLE GEORGE W. BUSH THE WHITE HOUSE 1600 PENNSYLVANIA AVE. NW WASHINGTON DC 20501 Re: Global Warming Treaty Dear President George W. Bush : It is imperative that the US reverse its stand on CO2 emmissions in the current negotiations at the UN toward a framework treaty on climate change. Even before new scientific evidence cast doubt on the administration's claims that the US could fulfill its responsibility in this matter simply by reducing CFC emissions, the potentional consequences of global warming are too massive and dire to merit any but the most serious and cautious approach. The threat of climate cachange is one of equity - equity between generations, equity betwee hemispheres. For it is the people who have enjoyed littled or none of the benefits and conveniences of our squanderous energy policies - the people of the Third World and the people of future generations - who will be forced to deal with the consequences of those policies We must act now - erring, if necessary, on the side of caution - t e reduce what experts agree is the single greatest threat to the human future. Please follow up on your promise to be the "Environmental President." At base, economic growth and environmental protection are not incompatible. The upcoming UNCED conference in Brazil will be a major step toward defining a new paradigm of economic growth - sustainable development - and I urge you to attend as a constructive participant. Finding this new paradigm will, more than anything, require vision, a quality which the American people have come to expect and appreciate in you. Sincerely, Andrew Gebert 4 Briarwood Lane Woodstock NY Woodstock, NY 12498 CompuServe Mail: 70413, 2053 "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201222 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Sister Anne Greenslade TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: SUBJECT: She is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB'S signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/25/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: Earth Summit LORETTO EARTH NETWORK February 25, 1992 9201222 President George Bush The White House Washington, D.C., 20500 LORETTO EARTH NETWORK South Platte Bioregion Dear Mr. President: 3001 S. Federal Blvd. Denver, CO 80236-2798 In your April, 1991 address to Congress on "Strategic Principals" for future United States environmental policies, you elaborated on the following principals: 1) Harnessing the Power of the Marketplace LORETTO EARTH NETWORK Mississippi River Bioregion 2) Stewardship of the Natural Resources 590 East Lockwood 3) Creative Partnerships St. Louis, MO 63119-3279 4) Pollution prevention 5) Vigorous Law Enforcement 6) Cooperative International Solutions President Bush, as the leader of the most powerful nation on earth, I urge you to accept the invitation of the General Assembly of the United Nations to participate in the EARTH SUMMIT. Do let the world know that you will attend the EARTH SUMMIT. I also urge you to direct your Administration to give positive leadership on the important issues that are under consideration now in preparation for the EARTH SUMMIT. Much of the world now sees the United States as blocking agreements. One major issue is global warming and energy use related to it. Targets and timetables are needed. Europe is serious about this. The developing nations will not act unless they see the industrialized countries willing to do so and/or help them to do SO. LORETTO EARTH NETWORK We should aim to reduce carbon dioxide emmissions from Ohio River Bioregion Loretto Motherhouse 1988 levels by 20% by the year 2000. Nerinx, KY 40049-9999 Two other major specific areas which we can give needed leadership are biodiversity and forest protection. Binding agreements as soon as possible are important. It should be unthinkable, on behalf of this and future LORETTO EARTH NETWORK generations, that we continue to lose species as we now Rio Grande Bioregion are. It is all kinds of forests, both ours and tropical 1300 Hardaway El Paso, TX 79903-3198 forests, that need protection. In conclusion, I ask you to support: page 2 LORETTO EARTH NETWORK 1) An international convention with targets and LORETTO EARTH NETWORK timetables to reduce the threat of global climate South Platte Bioregion 3001 S Federal Blvd. change. Denver, CO 80236-2798 2) Forest principles calling for programs to curb global deforestation, protect substantial portions of mature native forests, give indigenous forest- dwellers legal control of their own territories, LORETTO EARTH NETWORK and provide incentives for sustainable management Mississippi River Bioregion 590 East Lockwood of production forests. St Louis. MO 63119-3279 3) A global convention with action plans to preserve the biological diversity of plant and animal species. 4) New global institutions and financing to protect and restore the world's environment. President Bush, your presence and your leadership are essential, not only to the international negotiations that are being considered now, but also at the EARTH SUMMIT that will be held in Rio de Janeiro June 1-12. I pray that you will respond to these major and critical issues and ask that the Holy Spirit will guide and direct you. Very Sincerely, Lister arre Greenslade, I.L. LORETTO EARTH NETWORK Ohio River Bioregion Sister Anne Greenslade, S.L. Loretto Motherhouse Nerinx, KY 40049-9999 4000 S. Wadsworth Blvd. Littleton, CO 80123 LORETTO EARTH NETWORK Rio Grande Bioregion 1300 Hardaway El Paso, TX 79903-3198 "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201232 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Philip Lessin TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/25/92 SUBJECT: He is writing to urge the President to attend the (UNCED) conference in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB'S signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document #9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/27/29 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 9201232 Feb25, 1992 President George Bush White House 1600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Washington, D.C 20500 Dear Mr prresident, I Im writing to impress you with the need tor you to support a strong climate convention with specific timetables for reduction of C02 emissions Sincerely yours, Philip Lessin 10401 GROSVENORPL#1410 ROCKVILLE, MD. 20852 P.Lessin 10401 GROSVENOR Pa 1410 BEBAIL # P.M. MD MSC 29 USA 26FEB 30 ROCKVILLE, MD. 2023 1992 PRESIDENT BUSH 1600 Pennsylvania Ave.,N.W., Washington, D.C. 20500 "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201217 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Bruce E. Rittenhouse TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: SUBJECT: He is writing to urge the President to attend theEarth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB'S signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 02/04/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/25/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 10443 Red Granite Ter. Oakton, VA 22124 February 25, 1992 President George Bush The White House Washington, DC 20500 Dear President Bush: I strongly urge you to make an immediate public commitment to the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (the "Earth Summit"). U.S. participation in this process is needed now to catalyze an international consensus to address the greatest threat our nation faces. We are part of a process which is rapidly destroying the ability of our world to sustain human agriculture, economic activity, and ultimately human society. Carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases are being added to the atmosphere at a rate which will change the earth's climate faster than natural ecosystems can adapt. This has the potential to create droughts, flooding, agricultural failures and mass extinctions. These, in turn, will lead to famine, mass migrations, and conflict over food and water resources. Old growth northern forests and tropical rain forests are being logged at a rate which destroys their other economic benefits: storing carbon, generating oxygen, preserving rainfall patterns, slowing water runoff, preventing erosion, preserving habitat for tens of thousands of species (many of which have economic as well as intrinsic value), and creating recreational opportunities. We still have the ability to slow the pace of global warming, to preserve the ecological integrity of the remaining forests, and to prevent the extinction of thousands of species. But you must act now, to bring proposals to address these issues to the final preparatory meeting for the Earth Summit, beginning March 2. The environment cannot wait until after this year's electoral process. U.S. intransigence now will be used by other nations to justify another decade of unsustainable depletion of the natural capital upon which our economic and social institutions are based. I can think of no better forum than the Earth Summit for you to showcase the necessity of your belief in international cooperation. We cannot afford the new isolationism of left or right which would ignore the global concerns which will define our safety and our livelihood in the years to come. This is a defining moment. Your actions now will help determine whether your legacy is an inheritance of health and prosperity, or disease and want. Please attend the Earth Summit and commit the U.S. to participating in global conventions to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, reduce air and water pollution, protect species from extinction, and protect forests. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Sincerely, Brune Rittinhouse Bruce E. Rittenhouse "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201223 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Francine Salom TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/25/92 SUBJECT: She is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB's signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/27/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: BREATEN OF BORRD RD Board of Education City of New York UNCONP CITY OF CITY OF NEW THE Science Advisory Standing Committee Francine Salom, Chairman Standing Committee South Shore High School 6565 Flatlands Avenue Brooklyn, New York 11236 22/01/23 531-4454 Ext. 24 February 25, 1992 President Bush The White House Washington, D.C. 20500 Dear President Bush: You call yourself the "environmental President. " Unfortunately, your actions have done much to demonstrate your anti-environment philosophy. We urge you to commit the United States to cutting carbon dioxide emissions in the climate treaty negotiations and attend the Earth Summit to provide the leadership needed to address critical global environmental issues. We are also very concerned with your destructive wetland policy and are most anxious to learn what is being done to restore and protect the wetlands. Redefining wetlands to serve special interests does not and will not help but will only exacerbate the problems. Keep in mind the words of Nobelist Dr. Richard Feynman. "For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations for Nature cannot be fooled. Obviously, politics is just the reverse. Public relations takes precedence over reality. Nevertheless, the ozone layer is being depleted; our natural resources are being needlessly destroyed, never to be replaced. It is essential that personal biases and misconceptions not endanger us all. Your cooperation is vital. We would appreciate hearing from you about this matter, and request a realistic, honest response and not self-serving public relations. Sincerely yours, Francine Salom "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201225 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Arthur Strauss, M.D. TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/25/92 SUBJECT: He is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB'S signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/27/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: global warming February 25, 1992 President George Bush 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, DC 20500 Dear President Bush: I am writing you about a subject of great concern to millions of people - global warming. This impending crisis needs to be addressed immediately. Long-term savings, according to a recent study "America's Energy Choices," from a more energy-efficient economy and rapid commercialization of renewable energy technologies, can be in the trillions of dollars by the year 2030. I am asking you to take a leadership role regarding the global warming crisis, put politics aside and realize your promise of being "the environmental President" by: 1) reverse the United State's position on global climate change and join virtually every other industrial country in committing to at least stabilize U.S. carbon dioxide emissions at 1990 levels. 2) attend the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro this June. Sincerely, 9201225 ASPABSS Arthur Strauss, M.D. 50 Sunlight Irvine, CA 92715 AS: djc CC: C. Riddiough "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201218 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Jodean Marks Mark Allen TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: SUBJECT: They are urging the president to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB'S signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 02/04/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/24/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 7201218 3815 W Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. February 18, 1992 President George Bush 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, D.C. Dear Mr. President: We are writing out of our concern about the environment. A unique opportunity presents itself for the United States, the world's lone superpower, to provide leadership in the global effort to protect the environment. The United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), is coming up this June in Brazil. We ask that you lead the United States delegation to UNCED in order to show this country's commitment to sustainable development in the context of environmental protection. An agreement on global warming that binds the nations of the world to a twenty percent cut in greenhouse emissions is an essential first step to curbing huge and potentially disastrous shifts in climate. The international scientific consensus is that global warming is happening and the consequences could include disruption of agriculture, flooding of all coastal cities, and massive extinctions of plant and animal populations due to inability to migrate as rapidly as climate zones shift. All of these changes are likely to occur in the next 50 to 100 years. In addition, the United States must agree to a ban on international traffic in toxic wastes. Apparently, at present we are the only nation opposed to such a ban. In sum, the United States must join, and in fact should lead, the nations of the world in putting the needs of humanity and the Earth above the needs of business as usual. The recent announcement that the ozone layer is thinning above major United States population centers should also lend a sense of urgency to our role at UNCED. Please do all you can to maximize the United States' constructive role at UNCED. Sincerely, polean marks Jodean Marks MarhAller Mark Allen "Document Control" TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201142 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: HALL, LEA TO: PRESIDENT BUSH DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/24/92 SUBJECT: SHE IS WRITING TO URGE THE PRESIDENT TO ATTEND THE EARTH SUMMIT (UNCED) IN RIO DE JANEIRO, BRAZIL DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: DRAFT FOR DAB'S SIGANTURE SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 03/13/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 9261142 THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON April 2, 1992 Dear Ms. Hall: On behalf of President Bush, thank you for your comments and suggestions about global environmental issues and the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED). The President appreciates your concerns and has asked that I respond to your letter of February 24, 1992 regarding these issues. The United States, under President Bush's leadership, is aggressively pursuing international efforts to address problems related to climate change, ozone depletion, forests, oceans, biological diversity, and technology cooperation with developing countries. The Administration has put forward specific proposals in various international fora to address each of these questions. More important, the United States is already taking specific steps here at home, through both legislation and administrative action, to begin tackling these problems. Specifically regarding climate change, you may be pleased to know that the United States has already begun taking actions that will have the effect of reducing net emissions of greenhouse gases. These include: * President Bush proposed and signed into law the 1990 Clean Air Act, which will reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the utility sector through restrictions on utility air pollutants; * The Bush Administration has proposed, both through the National Energy Strategy and through various regulatory measures, to improve energy efficiency in power generation and transmission, buildings, appliances, lighting, and transportation, which will restrain related carbon dioxide emissions; * The President has proposed, through his tree planting initiatives, to increase the acreage and to improve the management of forests, which act as greenhouse gas "sinks"; * The President has proposed to expand the use of renewable and low-emission fuel sources; Page 2 - Ms. Hall * Since President Bush took office, he has doubled funding for conservation research and development (R&D) and increased funding for renewable R&D by 69 percent; and * The Administration has not only proposed, but the President has signed into law, the phaseout of ozone-depleting compounds that are also greenhouse gases. Additionally, in February 1992, in response to new scientific evidence, President Bush was the first head of state to commit his country unilaterally to accelerating the date for the complete phaseout of the production of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs). The President's action moves up the phaseout date of CFCs, which deplete the Earth's ozone layer, to December 31, 1995. Due to a number of previous Administration actions, U.S. production of ozone-depleting substances is already more than 40 percent below levels allowed by the internationally agreed Montreal Protocol. Under the new schedule, the U.S. will eliminate production four years ahead of the current international deadline, thus continuing the record of U.S. leadership in this area extending back to the mid-1970s. The United States supports a comprehensive approach, addressing all greenhouse gases, not just carbon dioxide, and "sinks," such as forests. Focusing exclusively on carbon dioxide emissions, as some have proposed, is an inadequate response. The United States has committed $25 million to assist developing countries in planning to mitigate and/or adapt to climate change. The U.S. has stepped up its own climate action plan, first outlined in February 1991, including actions in such areas as energy efficiency, transportation, reduced emission supply technologies, agriculture, natural resources, and technology R&D. The United States has also committed $50 million to the core fund of the Global Environment Facility (GEF) and $150 million in parallel financing through the U.S. Agency for International Development. In addition to addressing global climate change, the GEF also funds projects concerning biodiversity, international waters, and ozone. The U.S. Global Change Research Program is the world's largest such program and thus provides much of the scientific foundation for international agreements on climate change and ozone depletion. The Bush Administration has invested $2.6 billion in global change research, far more than any other country, with an additional $1.3 billion proposed for year 1993 over six times the fiscal 1989 level. Research on the scientific and economic aspects Page 3 - - Ms. Hall of global climate change will enable policy makers to make better judgments about potential impacts and policy actions. Regarding the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), scheduled this June in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, President Bush is committed to achieving international agreement on a framework convention on climate change. In addition to a global agreement on climate change, the Bush Administration also hopes UNCED will produce strategies and specific initiatives to improve conservation of forests, oceans, and biological diversity, and to increase technology cooperation with developing countries. You can be sure that the United States will be well represented at the conference. As we move forward into the 1990s, the United States will continue to address global environmental challenges within a context of expanding economic opportunities for all the world's people. The United States wants concrete, practical results from UNCED - results that will guide future action on the full range of environmental and developmental issues. Thank you for taking the time to express your interest on these environmental issues with President Bush. You can be sure that the President will continue working with other nations to obtain global solutions to these challenging issues. With the President's best wishes, Sincerely yours, D.Anan Ramley D. Allan Bromley The Assistant to the President for Science and Technology Ms. Lea Hall 5042 Queen Avenue, South Minneapolis, Minnesota 55410 UNCED NATURE REPAY OUR DEBT TO "REPLANT RAINFOREST February 24, 1992 President George Bush 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, DC 20515 Dear President, Ambassador Ryan visited Minneapolis/St. Paul this week and we were glad of the opportunity to meet with him. We hold high hopes for the outcomes of the Earth Summit. I am a small business owner, and because I import wood products from Central America, I am mindful every day of my dependence on the forests of the world. For other businesses, the connection between survival, profitability, and earth stewardship is less apparent but real. The time has come when not only environmental activists but also the business community is recognizing the critical need for international accords on forest management, water management, greenhouse gases and ozone-depleting chemicals, and generally sustainable use of all natural resources. Your performance as environmental president has been widely and rightly criticized. The Earth Summit presents a critically important moment in history, and I urge you to apply your considerable statesmanship to supporting its success. See to it that we come out of it proudly, as global leaders in the fashioning of an Earth Charter that no nation can afford to violate. Sincerely, Lea Hall Lea Hall, President TERRA TRADING 5042 Queen Ave., South Minneapolis, MN 55410 (612) 925-3434 "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201316 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: L. Christian Hauck TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/24/92 SUBJECT: He is writing to show his support for President Bush's "No Regret's Policy" position. DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB's signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 03/10/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: OSTPI maynard 9101316 SUNFLOWER ELECTRIC POWER CORPORATION P.O. Box 980 301 West 13th Street Hays, Kansas 67601 913 - 628 - 2845 February 24, 1992 The Honorable George Bush President of the United States The White House Washington, D.C. 20500 Dear Mr. President: Sunflower Electric Power Corporation is a rural wholesale power supplier, created with the assistance of the Rural Electrification Administration to fill the bulk electrical power needs of the people of western Kansas. Our existence and viability is tied to the continued operation of our Holcomb Station powerplant, a 325 MW coal-fired installation located in the southwestern part of Kansas. Millions of consumer dollars have been spent on the environmental protection features incorporated into the Holcomb Station design; it complies with the strictest EPA standards, and is fueled with low-sulfur Wyoming federal coal brought by rail over 700 miles for conversion into electricity. We see no threat more serious to our continued existence than a tax or penalty on coal or its combustion, or a tax or cap on carbon dioxide emissions. We know that you are under pressure to abandon your "no regrets" policy on this issue. Your policy is well-considered and sensible, and we urge that it not be abandoned or modified. We would also respectfully suggest that you not attend the United Nations conference in Brazil this Spring. From the "science" that will be the basis for any actions taken with respect to SO₂ at the UN conference, it appears that acceptance of global warming as a fact, and a determination that CO₂ is the culprit is at once ill-advised and predetermined. Sunflower's Board of Directors is very interested in this issue, and unanimously adopted the resolution enclosed with this letter. We sincerely hope that our views are helpful to you as this issue is approached. Manch Very truly yours, L. Christian Hauck President and CEO LCH:wpw RESOLUTION Of the Board of Directors of Sunflower Electric Power Corporation Unanimously Adopted on February 21, 1992 WHEREAS, current popular theories of catastrophic global warming are not substantiated by scientific evidence and there is considerable scientific debate as to whether or not any global warming is actually occurring; and WHEREAS, the United States is being pressured to sign a treaty at the United Nations Council for Environment and Development (UNCED) meeting in June which would limit carbon dioxide (CO₂) production; and WHEREAS, several proposals have been made in Congress to impose taxes on carbon fuels or CO₂ emissions as a means of limiting such emissions; and WHEREAS, such CO2 caps and taxes would substantially increase the cost of electricity produced by Sunflower Electric Power Corporation and other electric utilities relying on coal for their power supply, resulting in severe cost impacts on electric consumers and ultimately damaging the economy of the United States; and WHEREAS, Sunflower owns and operates Holcomb Station as the primary source of electric energy for the 150,000 rural western Kansas consumers that own Sunflower through Sunflower's member cooperatives; and WHEREAS, Holcomb Station is one of the nation's few "superclean" coal-fired power plants, constructed and operated under extremely stringent environmental restrictions which already have imposed significant capital and operating cost penalties on Sunflower and its consumers; and WHEREAS, the use of domestic coal for the production of electricity is a benefit to the economic security of the nation in that it replaces the use of imported oil in meeting the nation's energy needs; and WHEREAS, President Bush, in the face of mounting unjustified pressure, has steadfastly held firm to a position that is known as the "no regrets" policy, which policy has been strongly endorsed by our National Rural Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA), in a letter from NRECA's Executive Vice President to President George Bush; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Board of Directors of Sunflower Electric Power Corporation, representing the interests of the 150,000 Americans served by the Sunflower-associated systems: 1. Strongly commends President Bush for adhering to the "no regrets" policy position as the most sensible approach to global climate issues when the science is yet uncertain, and 2. Urges the formal addition of a "no-tax, no-cap" position on CO₂ to the "no regrets" policy. SUNFLOWER ELECTRIC POWER CORPORATION P.O. Box 980 301 West 13th Street Hays, Kansas 67601 913 - 628-2845 February 24, 1992 The Honorable George Bush President of the United States The White House Washington, D.C. 20500 Dear Mr. President: Sunflower Electric Power Corporation is a rural wholesale power supplier, created with the assistance of the Rural Electrification Administration to fill the bulk electrical power needs of the people of western Kansas. Our existence and viability is tied to the continued operation of our Holcomb Station powerplant, a 325 MW coal-fired installation located in the southwestern part of Kansas. Millions of consumer dollars have been spent on the environmental protection features incorporated into the Holcomb Station design; it complies with the strictest EPA standards, and is fueled with low-sulfur Wyoming federal coal brought by rail over 700 miles for conversion into electricity. We see no threat more serious to our continued existence than a tax or penalty on coal or its combustion, or a tax or cap on carbon dioxide emissions. We know that you are under pressure to abandon your "no regrets" policy on this issue. Your policy is well-considered and sensible, and we urge that it not be abandoned or modified. We would also respectfully suggest that you not attend the United Nations conference in Brazil this Spring. From the "science" that will be the basis for any actions taken with respect to SO₂ at the UN conference, it appears that acceptance of global warming as a fact, and a determination that CO₂ is the culprit is at once ill-advised and predetermined. Sunflower's Board of Directors is very interested in this issue, and unanimously adopted the resolution enclosed with this letter. We sincerely hope that our views are helpful to you as this issue is approached. Very truly yours, Mandh L. Christian Hauck President and CEO LCH:wpw RESOLUTION Of the Board of Directors of Sunflower Electric Power Corporation Unanimously Adopted on February 21, 1992 WHEREAS, current popular theories of catastrophic global warming are not substantiated by scientific evidence and there is considerable scientific debate as to whether or not any global warming is actually occurring; and WHEREAS, the United States is being pressured to sign a treaty at the United Nations Council for Environment and Development (UNCED) meeting in June which would limit carbon dioxide (CO₂) production; and WHEREAS, several proposals have been made in Congress to impose taxes on carbon fuels or CO₂ emissions as a means of limiting such emissions; and WHEREAS, such CO₂ caps and taxes would substantially increase the cost of electricity produced by Sunflower Electric Power Corporation and other electric utilities relying on coal for their power supply, resulting in severe cost impacts on electric consumers and ultimately damaging the economy of the United States; and WHEREAS, Sunflower owns and operates Holcomb Station as the primary source of electric energy for the 150,000 rural western Kansas consumers that own Sunflower through Sunflower's member cooperatives; and WHEREAS, Holcomb Station is one of the nation's few "superclean" coal-fired power plants, constructed and operated under extremely stringent environmental restrictions which already have imposed significant capital and operating cost penalties on Sunflower and its consumers; and WHEREAS, the use of domestic coal for the production of electricity is a benefit to the economic security of the nation in that it replaces the use of imported oil in meeting the nation's energy needs; and WHEREAS, President Bush, in the face of mounting unjustified pressure, has steadfastly held firm to a position that is known as the "no regrets" policy, which policy has been strongly endorsed by our National Rural Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA), in a letter from NRECA's Executive Vice President to President George Bush; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Board of Directors of Sunflower Electric Power Corporation, representing the interests of the 150,000 Americans served by the Sunflower-associated systems: 1. Strongly commends President Bush for adhering to the "no regrets" policy position as the most sensible approach to global climate issues when the science is yet uncertain, and 2. Urges the formal addition of a "no-tax, no-cap" position on CO₂ to the "no regrets" policy. SUNFLOWER ELECTRIC POWER CORPORATION P.O. Box 980 301 West 13th Street Hays, Kansas 67601 913 628 2845 February 24, 1992 The Honorable George Bush President of the United States The White House Washington, D.C. 20500 Dear Mr. President: Sunflower Electric Power Corporation is a rural wholesale power supplier, created with the assistance of the Rural Electrification Administration to fill the bulk electrical power needs of the people of western Kansas. Our existence and viability is tied to the continued operation of our Holcomb Station powerplant, a 325 MW coal-fired installation located in the southwestern part of Kansas. Millions of consumer dollars have been spent on the environmental protection features incorporated into the Holcomb Station design; it complies with the strictest EPA standards, and is fueled with low-sulfur Wyoming federal coal brought by rail over 700 miles for conversion into electricity. We see no threat more serious to our continued existence than a tax or penalty on coal or its combustion, or a tax or cap on carbon dioxide emissions. We know that you are under pressure to abandon your "no regrets" policy on this issue. Your policy is well-considered and sensible, and we urge that it not be abandoned or modified. We would also respectfully suggest that you not attend the United Nations conference in Brazil this Spring. From the "science" that will be the basis for any actions taken with respect to SO₂ at the UN conference, it appears that acceptance of global warming as a fact, and a determination that CO₂ is the culprit is at once ill-advised and predetermined. Sunflower's Board of Directors is very interested in this issue, and unanimously adopted the resolution enclosed with this letter. We sincerely hope that our views are helpful to you as this issue is approached. Very truly yours, Wound L. Christian Hauck President and CEO LCH:wpw RESOLUTION Of the Board of Directors of Sunflower Electric Power Corporation Unanimously Adopted on February 21, 1992 WHEREAS, current popular theories of catastrophic global warming are not substantiated by scientific evidence and there is considerable scientific debate as to whether or not any global warming is actually occurring; and WHEREAS, the United States is being pressured to sign a treaty at the United Nations Council for Environment and Development (UNCED) meeting in June which would limit carbon dioxide (CO₂) production; and WHEREAS, several proposals have been made in Congress to impose taxes on carbon fuels or CO₂ emissions as a means of limiting such emissions; and WHEREAS, such CO₂ caps and taxes would substantially increase the cost of electricity produced by Sunflower Electric Power Corporation and other electric utilities relying on coal for their power supply, resulting in severe cost impacts on electric consumers and ultimately damaging the economy of the United States; and WHEREAS, Sunflower owns and operates Holcomb Station as the primary source of electric energy for the 150,000 rural western Kansas consumers that own Sunflower through Sunflower's member cooperatives; and WHEREAS, Holcomb Station is one of the nation's few "superclean" coal-fired power plants, constructed and operated under extremely stringent environmental restrictions which already have imposed significant capital and operating cost penalties on Sunflower and its consumers; and WHEREAS, the use of domestic coal for the production of electricity is a benefit to the economic security of the nation in that it replaces the use of imported oil in meeting the nation's energy needs; and WHEREAS, President Bush, in the face of mounting unjustified pressure, has steadfastly held firm to a position that is known as the "no regrets" policy, which policy has been strongly endorsed by our National Rural Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA), in a letter from NRECA's Executive Vice President to President George Bush; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Board of Directors of Sunflower Electric Power Corporation, representing the interests of the 150,000 Americans served by the Sunflower-associated systems: 1. Strongly commends President Bush for adhering to the "no regrets" policy position as the most sensible approach to global climate issues when the science is yet uncertain, and 2. Urges the formal addition of a "no-tax, no-cap" position on CO₂ to the "no regrets" policy. April 8, 1992 Dear Mr. Hauck: On behalf of President Bush, thank you for your very kind comments on US activities related to the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee (INC) on a framework convention on climate change. The President appreciates your support and has asked that I respond to your letter of February 24, 1992 regarding this issue. The President strongly believes that US policies in this area must be based on the most solid scientific and economic information base available. As you mentioned, the US Global Change Research Program is the world's largest such program and thus provides much of the scientific foundation for international agreements on climate change and ozone depletion. In fact, the Bush Administration has invested $2.6 billion in global change research to date, with an additional $1.3 billion proposed for fiscal 1993. Research on the scientific and economic aspects of global climate change will enable policy makers to make better judgements about potential impacts and policy actions. Thank you for taking the time to express your interest on this issue and we appreciate your support. With the President's best wishes, Sincerely yours, D. Allan Bromley The Assistant to the President for Science and Technology Mr. L. Christian Hauck President, Sunflower Electric Power Corporation P.O. Box 980, 301 West 13th Street Hays, Kansas 67601 "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201220 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Paul and Debbie Johansson TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: SUBJECT: He is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB'S signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/24/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 9201220 UNCOM President George Bush 1600 Pensylvania Ave. Washington DC 20500 Feb. 18/1992 Re: UNCED meeting. Dear President Bush, We are deeply concerned about Your Adninistrations opposition to many of the suggestions proposed for the UNCED meeting in Rio de Janeiro 6/1/1992. We urge you to work with all other Countries toward finding solutions for the many serious problems that face our Planet. As you well know, our environmental problems are growing more severe every day and solutions are available, it is the political will that is missing. We believe you are not supplying the leadership needed on this issue. We urge you to change your mind. Sincerely Yours Paul and Debbie Johansson 595 Bluebird Canyon Dr. Laguna Beach, Calif. 91651 "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201229 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: John B. Marks TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: 02/24/92 SUBJECT: He is writing to urge the President to attend the (UNCED) conference in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB's signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/27/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL PRIORITY CENTRAL FILES: 9401229 0668 S.W. PALATINE HILL Road PORTLAND, OR 97219 24 Fet 92 Dear the President: tiators to press forward toward international Congratulation on instructing our nego- banning CFCs Now. of the time to accompany and this with new initiatives is on carbon choxide methon lmissions which are causing the global craiming The U.S. should but world in this, hot hold it back Respectfully, John B. marks EORTLA 24FEB 1992 I PM 29 USA Resident Denge Bush The White House Washing to DC20500 "Document Control" TYPE: Presidential Priority DOCUMENT NUMBER: 9201221 ORIGINATOR: 05 STATUS DIRECTORATE STATUS C FROM: Sharon Morkin TO: President Bush DATE OF CORRESPONDENCE: SUBJECT: She is writing to urge the President to attend the Earth Summit (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro DIRECTORATE STAFF ASSIGNED: ASSIGNED: Nancy Maynard ACTION STAFF REQUIRED: ACTION: Draft for DAB'S signature SENDER'S DUE DATE: OSTP DUE DATE: STAFF DUE DATE DATE COMPLETED: DATE COMPLETED/DEPT: 04/02/92 COPIES TO: WHITE HOUSE TRACKING #: CONTACT PERSON: PHONE: EXT: REMARKS: See response on document number 9201148 OSTP RECEIVED: DEPT RECEIVED: 02/24/92 FILE: P-EOP-PRESIDENTIAL CENTRAL FILES: UNCOM February 17, 1992 Presidents Day President George Bush White House Washington, D.C. Sharon Morkin Oakland School 1605 East Oakland Avenue 920RL/ Bloomington, Illinois 61701 Dear President Bush, My name is Sharon Morkin. I am a second grade teacher at Oakland School in Bloomington, Illinois and have been for more than twenty-six years. In 1990 I was selected as one of the top ten elementary science teachers in the state of Illinois. Last year I was one of three finalists in Illinois for the Presidential Awards for Excellence in Teaching Science. I work hard to develop in my young students a sense of wonder, an appreciation and respect for life, as well as, a responsibility for the care and preservation of our fragile environment. These children are the bright future of our country and need your support to help ensure that future in a healthy environment. Your administration must play a lead role in encouraging environmental protection. The United States needs to be a world leader in environmental protection. We should be helping other industrialized and developing nations move toward a clean and healthy environment. President Bush, I strongly urge you to: a) Support a global warming treaty to cut emissions of carbon dioxide and other ozone-destroying gases; b) Agree to a ban on the international trafficking of toxic waste; and c) Commit to attending the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), taking place in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, from June 1-12, 1992. This conference is a beginning of the end to acid rain, global warming, rainforest destruction, ocean polution, hunger and poverty. If all countries of the world would unite with this common goal an environmentally sustainable future would be there for my second grade students. It is my opinion that this conference will be a failure without the strong leadership of the United States. As a Republican I supported you in the defeat of Communism. Now I hope to support you in the defeat of the next biggest threat to our world--the destruction of our global environment. Please make environmental protection a high priority. Sincerely yours, Sharon Morkin