Ask the Scholar

Page 1 of 1
I can add historical knowledge about this page.

Page image

Page 1

OCR

The original documents are located in Box 20, folder "Judicial Appointments - District of Columbia (1)" of the Philip Buchen Files at the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library. Copyright Notice The copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the making of photocopies or other reproductions of copyrighted material. Gerald R. Ford donated to the United States of America his copyrights in all of his unpublished writings in National Archives collections. Works prepared by U.S. Government employees as part of their official duties are in the public domain. The copyrights to materials written by other individuals or organizations are presumed to remain with them. If you think any of the information displayed in the PDF is subject to a valid copyright claim, please contact the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library. Digitized from Box 20 of the Philip Buchen Files at the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON Jay had marked this for files -- but thought you'd want to see it. Eva Perfling FORD 0708 LIBRA Forfils ROSEMARY SCOTT ATTORNEY 714 GRAND RAPIDS MUTUAL BUILDING 201 MONROE AVENUE N. W. GRAND RAPIDS, MICHIGAN 49502 GLENDALE 4-7070 October 23, 1974 Mr. Philip W. Buchen, Counsel to the President, The White House, Washington, D.C. 20500 Dear Mr. Buchen: May I thank you for returning my call in reference to Mr. C. Frank Reifsnyder who has been proposed through the United States Department of Justice to the White House for appointment as appellate judge in the District of Columbia. Thank you very much for the anticipated expedition of your consideration of his nomination. I am joined by Marion Jennings in conveying to you our hearty admiration, and I again express my gratitude for your kind attention. Sincerely yours, Dear Rosemary Scott RS:mj GERALD -IBRARY sent to Chapman wrote: Lebeder 10/25/74 No objection to Flaum and Reifsnyder Buchen: Concur Reifonyder C. drank THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON Ilaum, October 15, 1974 Jul MEMORANDUM FOR: PHILIP BUCHEN FROM: SAMUEL A. SCHULHOF CONCUR: WILLIAM N. WALKER SUBJECT: Associate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals Attached is a copy of my proposed memorandum to The President discussing the nomination of C. Frank Reifsnyder as Associate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals. As we wish to finalize this recommendation by Friday, October 18, 1974, please have your office let Greg Lebedev's office know of your opinion as soon as convenient in order that we may accurately represent your views in the final decision memorandum. If we have not heard from your office by that time, we will assume that you have no opinion and go forward with the memorandum. Your observations and assistance will be greatly appreciated. Thank you very much. FORD is LIBRARY OFRALD Attachments THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT THROUGH: DONALD RUMSFELD FROM: SAMUEL A. SCHULHOF CONCUR: WILLIAM N. WALKER SUBJECT: C. Frank Reifsnyder as Associate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals This memorandum seeks your approval of C. Frank Reifsnyder as Associate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals vice Hubert B. Pair, retired. Reifsnyder, 54, currently is an Associate Partner of the Washington law firm of Hogan & Hartson; and his career profile is attached for your review (Tab A). Mr. Reifsnyder is a Republican, and Attorney General Saxbe's letter of recommendation states that the Judicial Appointments Committee of the D. C. Bar Association has submitted a report in which they express their opinion that 11 Mr. Reifsnyder is highly qualified for appointment to this position. 11 (Tab B). Although many other individuals have sought this position, the Attorney General's recommenda. tion is founded upon the competence of Mr. Reifsnyder and the need to strengthen the D. C. Court of Appeals. I, therefore, recommend the nomination of C. Frank Reifsnyder as Associate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals. Approve Disapprove Attachments: Tabs A - B FCRD is LIBRAS G7VE FORD C. FRANK REIFSNYDER Born: September 6, 1920 Ottumwa, Iowa Legal Residence: Maryland Marital Status: Married Wife-Nancy Lee; 3 children Education: 1938-1946 George Washington University A.B. degree (1944) LL.B. degree (1946) Bar: 1945 District of Columbia Experience: 1946-1947 Law Clerk to Chief Judge Bolitha J. Laws, U.S. District Court, District of Columbia 1947-1951 Assistant U.S. Attorney District of Columbia 1951 to present Associate, Partner Hogan & Hartson Washington, D.C. Office: 815 Connecticut Avenue, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20006 202-331-4548 Home: 10605 Stable Lane Potomac, Maryland 20854 301-299-4225 Present Position: Lawyer Political Affiliation: Republican Ethnic Group: Caucasian Salary: $38,250 FORD GERALD LIBRARY Office of the Attorney General SEQUITUR Washington, B. C. 20530 DONORA JUSTITIA October 4, 1974 My dear Mr. President: I have the honor to enclose the nomination of C. Frank Reifsnyder, of Maryland, to be an Associate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals for the term of fifteen years vice Hubert B. Pair, retired. Mr. Reifsnyder was born September 6, 1920 in Ottumwa, Iowa, is married and has three children. He attended George Washington University from 1938 to 1946, receiving his A.B. degree in 1944 and his LL.B. degree in 1946. From 1946 to 1947 Mr. Reifsnyder served as a law clerk to Chief Judge Bolitha J. Laws, United States District Court for the District of Columbia. From 1947 to 1951 he served as Assistant U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia, Since 1951 he has practiced law with the firm of Hogan and Hartson in Washington, D.C. The Judicial Appointments Committee of the Bar Association of the District of Columbia has submitted a report in which they state their opinion that Mr. Reifsnyder is highly qualified for appointment to this position. He bears an excellent reputation as to character and integrity, has judicial temperament, and is, I believe, worthy of appointment as an Associate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals. I recommend the nomination. Respectfully, wm B Sayle The President The White House THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON October 15, 1974 MEMORANDUM FOR: PHILIP BUCHEN FROM: SAMUEL A. SCHULHOF CONCUR: WILLIAM N. WALKER SUBJECT: U.S. District Judge, Northern District of Illinois Attached is a copy of my proposed memorandum to The President discussing the nomination of Joel M. Flaum as U.S. District Judge for the Northern District of Illinois. As we wish to finalize this recommendation by Friday, October 18, 1974, please have your office let Mr. Lebedev's office know of your opinion as soon as convenient in order that we may accurately represent your views in thefinal decision memorandum. If we have not hear from your office by that time, we will assume that you have no opinion and go forward with the memorandum. Your observations and assistance will be greatly appreciated. Thank you very much. Attachments FOND ABVUEIT THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON October 10, 1974 MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT THROUGH: DONALD RUMSFELD FROM: SAMUEL A. SCHULHOF CONCUR: WILLIAM N. WALKER SUBJECT: Joel M. Flaum as United States District Judge for the Northern District of Illinois This memorandum seeks your approval of Joel M. Flaum as U.S. District Judge for the Northern District of Illinois, vice Philip W. Tone, elevated. Mr. Flaum, 37, currently serves as the First Assistant U.S. Attorney in the Northern District of Illinois; and his career profile is attached for your review (Tab A). Mr. Flaum is an Independent, and is primarily supported by Senator Charles Percy (R-Illinois). The Attorney General's letter of recommendation states that the Standing Committee on Federal Judiciary of the ABA has submitted a report in which they indicate that 11 half the members feel that Mr. Flaum is well qualified and the other half feel he is qualified for appointment to this position. " (Tab B) I, therefore, recommend the nomination of Joel M. Flaum as United States District Judge for the Northern District of Illinois. Approve Disapprove FORD GENALD LIBRARY Attachments: Tabs A-B JOEL M. FLAUM Born: November 26, 1936 Hudson, New York Legal Residence: Illinois Marital Status: Married Wife-Thea; two children Education: 1954-1958 Union College, B.A. degree 1958-1959 Albany Law School Northwestern University School of Law 1961-1963 J.D. degree 1963-1964 L.L.M. degree Bar: 1963 Illinois Experience: 1964-1965 Schimberg, Greenberger, Krauss & Jacobs; Chicago, Illinois 1965-1969 Assistant State's Attorney Cook County, Illinois 1967-1969 Lecturer, Northwestern University School of Law 1969-1970 Assistant Attorney General 1970-1972 First Assistant Attorney General State of Illinois 1972 to present Firs: Assistant U.S. Attorney Northern District of Illinois Office: Everett McKinley Dirkse Building 219 South Dearborn Street Chicago, Illinois 60604 Telephone: 312-353-533! Home: 734 West Hutchinson Street Chicago, Illinois 60613 Telephone: 312-935-5524 Present Position: Assistant U.S. Attorney FORD Politics: Independent GERALD LIBRARY Ethnic Group: Caucasian Salary: $40,000 FOOD LIBRARY - / 1 Office of the Attorney General PRO SEQUITUR Washington, n. C. 20530 justitia September 23, 1974 My dear Mr. President: I have the honor to enclose the nomination of Joel M. Flaum, of Illinois, to be United States District Judge for the Northern District of Illinois vice Philip W. Tone, elevated. Mr. Flaum was born November 26, 1936 in Hudson, New York, is married and has two children. He attended Union College from 1954 to 1958 when he received his B.A. degree. He attended Albany Law School from 1958 to 1959 and Northwestern University School of Law from 1961 to 1963 when he received his J.D. degree. He received an L.L.M. degree from Northwestern in 1964. He was admitted to the Illinois State Bar in 1963. From 1964 to 1965 he practiced law with the firm of Schimberg, Greenberger, Krauss & Jacobs in Chicago. He served as Assistant State's Attorney for Cook County, Illinois from 1965 to 1969. From 1967 to 1969 he was a lecturer at Northwestern University School of Law From 1969 to 1970 he was an Assistant Attorney General and from 1970 to 1972, First Assistant Attorney General for the State of Illino S. Since 1972 he has been First Assistant United States Attorney for the Northern District of Illinois. The Standii g Committee on Federal Judiciary of the American Bar Association has submitted a report in which half the members feel that Mr. F. aum is well qualified and the other half feel he is qualified fo : appointment to this position He bears an excellent reputation as to character and integrity, has judicial temperament, and is, I believe, worthy of appointment as 2 United States District Judge. is FORD I recommend the nomination. GERALD LIBRARY Respectfully, The President We B'Sayhe The White House teller Tuesday 10/15/74 4:55 Dudley Chapman checked with Greg Lebedev concerning the nomination of C. Frank Riesnyder to be a judge. It is being circulated for approval now and we have until Friday to give our approval. It apparently has been O.K. 'd by everyone but us. LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD Friday 10/11/74 2:50 Rosemary Scott called from Grand Rapids -- (616) 454-7070 concerned the nomination of C. Frank Riesnyder (apparently nominated and apparently cleared by Justice to be appointed a judge). Returned call10/15/74 Samphthies Dudley Chapman: Kindly advisen me where this nomination stands FORD is GERALD LIBRARY T. 10/15/74 3:40 called Dudleys he will let us know LIBRARY GERALD ? FORD THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON April 28, 1975 MEMORANDUM FOR: JOHN MINTZ GENERAL COUNSEL FBI FROM: KEN LAZARUS SUBJECT: D.C. Judicial Nominations Commission In accordance with my phone conversation with Jack Harrington earlier today, this is to advise that we have no objection to your providing assistance to the D.C. Judicial Nominations Commission in the course of their screening of candidates for appointment to the D.C. Superior Court. Specifically, the Commission's request for access to "Name Check" and "Ident" information should be honored provided that written releases are obtained from the individuals involved and provided to the Bureau. I have discussed this matter with Deputy Attorney General Tyler who concurs with our views. cc: Honorable Harold Tyler Phil Buchen Rod Hills Bernie Rachner FORD & 076839 LIBRARY May 19, 1975 MEMORANDUM FOR: MR. JOHN T. DUFFNER EXECUTIVE ASSISTANT TO THE DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL Enclosed is a copy of a recommendation concerning Edwin C. Brown, Jr. as a candidate for Judge of the District of Columbia Superior Court. I have acknowledged receipt of this letter. Philip W. Buchen Counsel to the President Enclosure FORD is LIBRARY QERALD THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON May 19, 1975 Dear Judge Kronheim: Many thanks for your letter in support of Edwin C. Brown, Jr. as a candidate for Judge of the District of Columbia Superior Court. I am passing this recommendation on to those who will be organizing the material on each of the possible candidates. Sincerely, ThiligW.Buehen Philip Buchen Courisel to the President The Honorable Milton S. Kronheim, Jr. 3120 Chesapeake Street, N. W. Washington, D. C. 20008 DERALD & FORD LIBRARY (ajrt.) Pres THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON July 1, 1975 MEMORANDUM FOR: ALAN WOODS FROM: PHILIP BUCHEN T.W.B. Subject; Associate Judge, District of Columbia Court of Appeals This office concurs in your proposed memo to the President on this appointment. FORD is GERALD LIBRARY THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON 3:20 p.m. June 27 Mr. Buchen, Ken thinks you should talk to A. G. Levi and try to talk him out of this proposal. shirley LIBRARY GERALD 1. FORD THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON 6-27-75 From Lazarus: On the merits, Julia Cooper is far and away the superior candidate. One point not covered in the memo is the fact that Wiley Branton has substantial opposition from powerful conser- vatives on the Hill and is also strongly opposed by key members of the local federal judiciary. We should strongly oppose his nomination lagge Chapman also supports Cooper. LIBRARY GERALD = FORD THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON August 18, 1976 MEMO FOR: Phil Buchen Doug Bennett Bob Linder FROM: Ken Lazarus FYI Tuesday 8/17/76 9:55 Ken advises that the D. C. Judicial Nomination Commission sent over a letter setting forth three names, from which the President would choose one --- for the vacancy when Judge Draper passed away. Dudley Williams was one of the names mentioned. They are sending a second letter on Dudley Williams because he had failed to file tax returns for several years. When these two letters come in, Ken would like copies of the "whole shmear"°!!°!°!" aug 16. Dear Chao. Duncan orig- Dong Bennett LIBRARY GERALD ? FORD John Risher 629-3858 To Benett 8-19-76 76 1976 AUG 16 PM 8 10 Days RDL RECEP. AND SECURITY UNIT HOWARD UNIVERSITY THE 144:1F HOUSE SCHOOL OF LAW WASHINGTON, D.C. 20008 CHARLES T. DUNCAN WASHINGTON CA. DEAN August 16, 1976 The President of the United States The White House Washington, D. C. Dear Mr. President: I have the honor to submit, pursuant to Public Law 93-198 (December 24, 1973), the following nominees for appointment to the Superior Court of the District of Columbia: Edwin Cicero Brown, Jr. Arthur Louis Burnett Dudley Ridault Williams Respectfully yours, Charles T. Humcan Charles T. Duncan Chairman The District of Columbia Judicial Nomination Commission Members: Frederick B. Abramson Clifford L. Alexander Judge Oliver Gasch John W. Hechinger Willie L. Leftwich William Lucy FORD GERALD LIBRARY Judgeships THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON August 28, 1975 Dear Jim: Mildred has brought to my attention your letter of July 30th on my return from a brief vacation combined with a number of speaking commitments. I am not certain at this time whether or not a vacancy is forthcoming in the near future either among the U. S. District Judges for the District of Columbia or the U. S. District Court of Appeals. However, I am asking Phil Buchen to look into the matter and will have him get in contact with you concerning his findings. I can understand the feeling of mixed emotions you and June may have between living in Bay City or the Nation's Capitol. It seems most people who have lived here for any length of time develop a sense of yearning to return. I really enjoyed hearing from you and I'm sure Phil will be in touch with you before too long. Warmest personal regards. Sincerely Jrs Ful Honorable James Harvey U. S. District Court Bay City, Michigan 48706 A&il 4817 GERALD ? FORD United States District Court For the Eastern District of Michigan Bay City, Michigan 4S706 any and CHAMBERS OF JAMES HARVEY DISTRICT JUDGE July 30, 1975 Miss Mildred V. Leonard Personal Assistant to the President The White House Washington, D. C. 20500 Dear Mildred: At the suggestion of Senator Bob Griffin, of Michigan, I am sending the enclosed letter, addressed to President Ford, directly to you, with the request that you deliver it to him. I would suggest that any reply be sent to me at my home address which I have set forth below. Thank you in advance for your assistance in this matter. All of us in Michigan especially appreciate the wonderful help that you have rendered to the President during the many years that you have been with him. With warmest personal regards, Sincerely, Jun JAMES U. S. Harney District Judge Enclosure 673 Kenton Drive Saginaw, Michigan 48603 is FORD GERALD LIBRARY United States District Court For the Enstern District of Michigan Bag City, Michigan 4S706 CHAMBERS OF JAMES HARVEY July 30, 1975 DISTRICT JUDGE The Honorable Gerald R. Ford The President The White House Washington, D. C. 20500 Dear Mr. President: I am writing this letter at the suggestion of our mutual friend, Senator Bob Griffin, after recently conferring with him in this regard. Since February 1, 1974, I have been a U. S. District Judge in the Eastern District of Michigan, and I have found it to be a very gratifying and challenging position. I spent most of the first ten months in the Detroit Court, and since January 1st of this year, I have been handling the docket of the late Judge Stephen J. Roth, holding court in both Bay City and Flint, Michigan. In recent weeks I have heard it discussed on several occasions that there may likely be a vacancy in the near future among the U. S. District Judges for the District of Columbia, and also the further possibility that there may be a vacancy on the U. S. District Court of Appeals. I am well aware that both of these possibilities are no more than rumors at the present time. My purpose in writing this letter, however, is to ask that in the event either of such vacancies do occur, my name be considered for such appointment. Senator Griffin advises me, as I am sure you are aware, that recommendations for these appointments originate in the Office of the Attorney General, and are not dependent upon the recommendation of any Senator as is the usual case. If I were appointed to any such position, Senator Griffin would, of course, recommend a successor to my present post in Michigan. is FORD GERALD LIBRARY The Honorable Gerald R. Ford July 30, 1975 I have been a member of the District of Columbia Bar Association since 1963. I have worked harder at acquiring the knowledge and skill necessary to become a good Federal Judge than at anything else in my lifetime, and I believe that I have been successful. My wife, June, and I have enjoyed becoming reacquainted with our friends in Michigan this past year, although I would be less than honest if I did not say that we have missed our many friends in Washington made during the fourteen years that I served in Congress. In addition, however, I am aware that the nature of the cases commenced in the U. S. District Court for the District of Columbia, and heard by the U. S. Court of Appeals there, are more national in scope, and the decisions of greater consequence, than those in the Bay City or Flint Courts, where I presently serve. I am not certain that any vacancies will occur in either the U. S. District Court, or the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, in the months ahead, but I wanted you to be aware of my interest in any event. You have made all of us who worked with you in years past very proud, for your accomplishments since taking office last August are unequaled in history. You may be certain of my continued support in your undertakings in the months and years ahead. Many thanks for your consideration of my request, and my warmest personal regards to you and your family. Sincerely, Jun JAMES Harney HARVEY U. S. District Judge - 2 - LIBRARY GERALD B. FORD mack, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA COURT OF APPEALS WASHINGTON, D. C. 20001 CHAMBERS OF October 22, 1975 Kindy JUDGE JULIA COOPER MACK Mr. Philip Buchen Counsel to the President The White House Washington, D. C. Dear Mr. Buchen: I interrupt my period of adjustment, as the newest Associate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, to thank you for your attendance at my investiture in September of this year. I want the President, and you, to know that such thoughtfulness has set the stage for what is proving to be, for me, a fulfilling experience. Although I neglected to mention this at the ceremony, I would like very much to have a photograph to exhibit along with my Presidential Commission which is hanging now in my Chambers. This display would be singularly meaning- ful to me since I believe I am the first judge to sit under the provisions of the District Self-Government and Govern- mental Reorganization Act. I am committed to justifying the confidence placed in me. Sincerely, Jac Associate Cooper Judge Mack 10/29 Mildred Leonard is handling. BERALD R. FORD shirley

Page data

Page
1
Source index
0
Type
document
Media ID
da2bff0169398b5e
Size
unknown

Document data

ID
4520596
Core
doc
Type
document
DTO data
{
    "id": "4520596",
    "sourceUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/4520596",
    "contentType": "document",
    "title": "Judicial Appointments - District of Columbia (1)",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/4520596",
    "collections": [
        "Philip W. Buchen Files",
        "Philip Buchen's General Subject Files"
    ],
    "subjects": [
        "Washington (D.C.)",
        "Federal judges",
        "Presidential appointments"
    ],
    "iiifBase": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0019/574067/Batch0002/38-0019-f-4520596.pdf",
    "thumbnailUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0019/574067/Batch0002/38-0019-f-4520596.pdf",
    "largeImageUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0019/574067/Batch0002/38-0019-f-4520596.pdf",
    "imageCount": 1,
    "hasImages": true,
    "source": "import",
    "hasTranscription": false
}

Context sent to Scholar

Document identity
{
    "localId": "4520596",
    "label": "Judicial Appointments - District of Columbia (1)",
    "core": "doc",
    "dtoType": "document",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/4520596"
}
Document source metadata
{
    "id": "4520596",
    "sourceUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/4520596",
    "contentType": "document",
    "title": "Judicial Appointments - District of Columbia (1)",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/4520596",
    "collections": [
        "Philip W. Buchen Files",
        "Philip Buchen's General Subject Files"
    ],
    "subjects": [
        "Washington (D.C.)",
        "Federal judges",
        "Presidential appointments"
    ],
    "iiifBase": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0019/574067/Batch0002/38-0019-f-4520596.pdf",
    "thumbnailUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0019/574067/Batch0002/38-0019-f-4520596.pdf",
    "largeImageUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0019/574067/Batch0002/38-0019-f-4520596.pdf",
    "imageCount": 1,
    "hasImages": true,
    "source": "import",
    "hasTranscription": false
}
Document source extras
{
    "url": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/4520596",
    "naId": 4520596,
    "coverageEndDate": {
        "logicalDate": "1977-01-01",
        "month": 1,
        "year": 1977
    },
    "coverageStartDate": {
        "logicalDate": "1974-10-01",
        "month": 10,
        "year": 1974
    },
    "levelOfDescription": "fileUnit",
    "recordType": "description",
    "ocrSource": "nara-archive"
}
Page context
{
    "seq": 1,
    "pageIndex": 0,
    "type": "document",
    "url": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/presidential-libraries/ford/grf-0019/574067/Batch0002/38-0019-f-4520596.pdf",
    "mediaId": "da2bff0169398b5e",
    "ocrText": "The original documents are located in Box 20, folder \"Judicial Appointments - District of\nColumbia (1)\" of the Philip Buchen Files at the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library.\nCopyright Notice\nThe copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the making of\nphotocopies or other reproductions of copyrighted material. Gerald R. Ford donated to the United\nStates of America his copyrights in all of his unpublished writings in National Archives collections.\nWorks prepared by U.S. Government employees as part of their official duties are in the public\ndomain. The copyrights to materials written by other individuals or organizations are presumed to\nremain with them. If you think any of the information displayed in the PDF is subject to a valid\ncopyright claim, please contact the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library.\nDigitized from Box 20 of the Philip Buchen Files\nat the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nJay had marked this for\nfiles -- but thought\nyou'd want to see it.\nEva\nPerfling\nFORD 0708 LIBRA\nForfils\nROSEMARY SCOTT\nATTORNEY\n714 GRAND RAPIDS MUTUAL BUILDING\n201 MONROE AVENUE N. W.\nGRAND RAPIDS, MICHIGAN 49502\nGLENDALE 4-7070\nOctober 23, 1974\nMr. Philip W. Buchen,\nCounsel to the President,\nThe White House,\nWashington, D.C. 20500\nDear Mr. Buchen:\nMay I thank you for returning my call in\nreference to Mr. C. Frank Reifsnyder who has been\nproposed through the United States Department of\nJustice to the White House for appointment as appellate\njudge in the District of Columbia.\nThank you very much for the anticipated\nexpedition of your consideration of his nomination.\nI am joined by Marion Jennings in conveying\nto you our hearty admiration, and I again express my\ngratitude for your kind attention.\nSincerely yours,\nDear\nRosemary Scott\nRS:mj\nGERALD\n-IBRARY\nsent to\nChapman wrote:\nLebeder 10/25/74\nNo objection to Flaum and Reifsnyder\nBuchen:\nConcur\nReifonyder C. drank\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nIlaum,\nOctober 15, 1974\nJul\nMEMORANDUM FOR:\nPHILIP BUCHEN\nFROM:\nSAMUEL A. SCHULHOF\nCONCUR:\nWILLIAM N. WALKER\nSUBJECT:\nAssociate Judge of the District of\nColumbia Court of Appeals\nAttached is a copy of my proposed memorandum to The President\ndiscussing the nomination of C. Frank Reifsnyder as Associate Judge\nof the District of Columbia Court of Appeals.\nAs we wish to finalize this recommendation by Friday, October 18, 1974,\nplease have your office let Greg Lebedev's office know of your opinion\nas soon as convenient in order that we may accurately represent your views\nin the final decision memorandum. If we have not heard from your office\nby that time, we will assume that you have no opinion and go forward with\nthe memorandum. Your observations and assistance will be greatly\nappreciated.\nThank you very much.\nFORD is LIBRARY OFRALD\nAttachments\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nMEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT\nTHROUGH:\nDONALD RUMSFELD\nFROM:\nSAMUEL A. SCHULHOF\nCONCUR:\nWILLIAM N. WALKER\nSUBJECT:\nC. Frank Reifsnyder as Associate Judge\nof the District of Columbia Court of\nAppeals\nThis memorandum seeks your approval of C. Frank Reifsnyder as\nAssociate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals vice\nHubert B. Pair, retired. Reifsnyder, 54, currently is an Associate\nPartner of the Washington law firm of Hogan & Hartson; and his career\nprofile is attached for your review (Tab A).\nMr. Reifsnyder is a Republican, and Attorney General Saxbe's letter\nof recommendation states that the Judicial Appointments Committee\nof the D. C. Bar Association has submitted a report in which they\nexpress their opinion that 11 Mr. Reifsnyder is highly qualified\nfor appointment to this position. 11 (Tab B). Although many other\nindividuals have sought this position, the Attorney General's recommenda.\ntion is founded upon the competence of Mr. Reifsnyder and the need to\nstrengthen the D. C. Court of Appeals.\nI, therefore, recommend the nomination of C. Frank Reifsnyder as\nAssociate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals.\nApprove\nDisapprove\nAttachments: Tabs A - B\nFCRD is LIBRAS G7VE\nFORD\nC. FRANK REIFSNYDER\nBorn:\nSeptember 6, 1920 Ottumwa, Iowa\nLegal Residence:\nMaryland\nMarital Status:\nMarried\nWife-Nancy Lee; 3 children\nEducation:\n1938-1946\nGeorge Washington University\nA.B. degree (1944)\nLL.B. degree (1946)\nBar:\n1945\nDistrict of Columbia\nExperience:\n1946-1947\nLaw Clerk to Chief Judge Bolitha J.\nLaws, U.S. District Court, District\nof Columbia\n1947-1951\nAssistant U.S. Attorney\nDistrict of Columbia\n1951 to present\nAssociate, Partner\nHogan & Hartson\nWashington, D.C.\nOffice:\n815 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.\nWashington, D.C. 20006\n202-331-4548\nHome:\n10605 Stable Lane\nPotomac, Maryland 20854\n301-299-4225\nPresent Position:\nLawyer\nPolitical Affiliation:\nRepublican\nEthnic Group:\nCaucasian\nSalary:\n$38,250\nFORD\nGERALD\nLIBRARY\nOffice of the Attorney General\nSEQUITUR\nWashington, B. C. 20530\nDONORA\nJUSTITIA\nOctober 4, 1974\nMy dear Mr. President:\nI have the honor to enclose the nomination of C. Frank Reifsnyder,\nof Maryland, to be an Associate Judge of the District of Columbia\nCourt of Appeals for the term of fifteen years vice Hubert B. Pair,\nretired.\nMr. Reifsnyder was born September 6, 1920 in Ottumwa, Iowa,\nis married and has three children.\nHe attended George Washington University from 1938 to 1946,\nreceiving his A.B. degree in 1944 and his LL.B. degree in 1946.\nFrom 1946 to 1947 Mr. Reifsnyder served as a law clerk to\nChief Judge Bolitha J. Laws, United States District Court for the\nDistrict of Columbia. From 1947 to 1951 he served as Assistant\nU.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia, Since 1951 he has\npracticed law with the firm of Hogan and Hartson in Washington,\nD.C.\nThe Judicial Appointments Committee of the Bar Association\nof the District of Columbia has submitted a report in which they\nstate their opinion that Mr. Reifsnyder is highly qualified for\nappointment to this position. He bears an excellent reputation\nas to character and integrity, has judicial temperament, and is,\nI believe, worthy of appointment as an Associate Judge of the\nDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals.\nI recommend the nomination.\nRespectfully,\nwm B Sayle\nThe President\nThe White House\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nOctober 15, 1974\nMEMORANDUM FOR:\nPHILIP BUCHEN\nFROM:\nSAMUEL A. SCHULHOF\nCONCUR:\nWILLIAM N. WALKER\nSUBJECT:\nU.S. District Judge, Northern District\nof Illinois\nAttached is a copy of my proposed memorandum to The President\ndiscussing the nomination of Joel M. Flaum as U.S. District Judge for\nthe Northern District of Illinois.\nAs we wish to finalize this recommendation by Friday, October 18, 1974,\nplease have your office let Mr. Lebedev's office know of your opinion as soon\nas convenient in order that we may accurately represent your views in\nthefinal decision memorandum. If we have not hear from your office\nby that time, we will assume that you have no opinion and go forward with\nthe memorandum. Your observations and assistance will be greatly\nappreciated.\nThank you very much.\nAttachments\nFOND\nABVUEIT\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nOctober 10, 1974\nMEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT\nTHROUGH:\nDONALD RUMSFELD\nFROM:\nSAMUEL A. SCHULHOF\nCONCUR:\nWILLIAM N. WALKER\nSUBJECT:\nJoel M. Flaum as United States\nDistrict Judge for the Northern\nDistrict of Illinois\nThis memorandum seeks your approval of Joel M. Flaum as U.S. District\nJudge for the Northern District of Illinois, vice Philip W. Tone, elevated.\nMr. Flaum, 37, currently serves as the First Assistant U.S. Attorney in the\nNorthern District of Illinois; and his career profile is attached for your\nreview (Tab A).\nMr. Flaum is an Independent, and is primarily supported by Senator Charles\nPercy (R-Illinois). The Attorney General's letter of recommendation\nstates that the Standing Committee on Federal Judiciary of the ABA has\nsubmitted a report in which they indicate that 11 half the members feel\nthat Mr. Flaum is well qualified and the other half feel he is qualified for\nappointment to this position. \" (Tab B)\nI, therefore, recommend the nomination of Joel M. Flaum as United States\nDistrict Judge for the Northern District of Illinois.\nApprove\nDisapprove\nFORD\nGENALD\nLIBRARY\nAttachments: Tabs A-B\nJOEL M. FLAUM\nBorn:\nNovember 26, 1936 Hudson, New York\nLegal Residence:\nIllinois\nMarital Status:\nMarried\nWife-Thea; two children\nEducation:\n1954-1958\nUnion College, B.A. degree\n1958-1959\nAlbany Law School\nNorthwestern University\nSchool of Law\n1961-1963\nJ.D. degree\n1963-1964\nL.L.M. degree\nBar:\n1963\nIllinois\nExperience:\n1964-1965\nSchimberg, Greenberger, Krauss\n& Jacobs; Chicago, Illinois\n1965-1969\nAssistant State's Attorney\nCook County, Illinois\n1967-1969\nLecturer, Northwestern University\nSchool of Law\n1969-1970\nAssistant Attorney General\n1970-1972\nFirst Assistant Attorney General\nState of Illinois\n1972 to present\nFirs: Assistant U.S. Attorney\nNorthern District of Illinois\nOffice:\nEverett McKinley Dirkse Building\n219 South Dearborn Street\nChicago, Illinois 60604\nTelephone: 312-353-533!\nHome:\n734 West Hutchinson Street\nChicago, Illinois 60613\nTelephone: 312-935-5524\nPresent Position:\nAssistant U.S. Attorney\nFORD\nPolitics:\nIndependent\nGERALD\nLIBRARY\nEthnic Group:\nCaucasian\nSalary:\n$40,000\nFOOD\nLIBRARY\n-\n/\n1\nOffice of the Attorney General\nPRO\nSEQUITUR\nWashington, n. C. 20530\njustitia\nSeptember 23, 1974\nMy dear Mr. President:\nI have the honor to enclose the nomination of Joel M. Flaum,\nof Illinois, to be United States District Judge for the Northern\nDistrict of Illinois vice Philip W. Tone, elevated.\nMr. Flaum was born November 26, 1936 in Hudson, New York, is\nmarried and has two children.\nHe attended Union College from 1954 to 1958 when he received\nhis B.A. degree. He attended Albany Law School from 1958 to 1959\nand Northwestern University School of Law from 1961 to 1963 when\nhe received his J.D. degree. He received an L.L.M. degree from\nNorthwestern in 1964. He was admitted to the Illinois State Bar\nin 1963.\nFrom 1964 to 1965 he practiced law with the firm of Schimberg,\nGreenberger, Krauss & Jacobs in Chicago. He served as Assistant\nState's Attorney for Cook County, Illinois from 1965 to 1969. From\n1967 to 1969 he was a lecturer at Northwestern University School\nof Law From 1969 to 1970 he was an Assistant Attorney General\nand from 1970 to 1972, First Assistant Attorney General for the\nState of Illino S. Since 1972 he has been First Assistant United\nStates Attorney for the Northern District of Illinois.\nThe Standii g Committee on Federal Judiciary of the American\nBar Association has submitted a report in which half the members\nfeel that Mr. F. aum is well qualified and the other half feel he\nis qualified fo : appointment to this position He bears an excellent\nreputation as to character and integrity, has judicial temperament,\nand is, I believe, worthy of appointment as 2 United States District\nJudge.\nis\nFORD\nI recommend the nomination.\nGERALD\nLIBRARY\nRespectfully,\nThe President\nWe B'Sayhe\nThe White House\nteller\nTuesday 10/15/74\n4:55 Dudley Chapman checked with Greg Lebedev\nconcerning the nomination of C. Frank Riesnyder\nto be a judge.\nIt is being circulated for approval now and we have\nuntil Friday to give our approval.\nIt apparently\nhas been O.K. 'd by everyone but us.\nLIBRARY GERALD R. FORD\nFriday 10/11/74\n2:50 Rosemary Scott called from Grand Rapids --\n(616) 454-7070\nconcerned the nomination of C. Frank Riesnyder\n(apparently nominated and apparently cleared by\nJustice to be appointed a judge).\nReturned\ncall10/15/74\nSamphthies\nDudley Chapman:\nKindly advisen me where this\nnomination stands\nFORD is GERALD LIBRARY\nT.\n10/15/74 3:40\ncalled Dudleys he\nwill let us know\nLIBRARY GERALD ? FORD\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nApril 28, 1975\nMEMORANDUM FOR:\nJOHN MINTZ\nGENERAL COUNSEL\nFBI\nFROM:\nKEN LAZARUS\nSUBJECT:\nD.C. Judicial Nominations Commission\nIn accordance with my phone conversation with Jack Harrington\nearlier today, this is to advise that we have no objection to\nyour providing assistance to the D.C. Judicial Nominations\nCommission in the course of their screening of candidates\nfor appointment to the D.C. Superior Court. Specifically,\nthe Commission's request for access to \"Name Check\" and\n\"Ident\" information should be honored provided that written\nreleases are obtained from the individuals involved and\nprovided to the Bureau.\nI have discussed this matter with Deputy Attorney General\nTyler who concurs with our views.\ncc: Honorable Harold Tyler\nPhil Buchen\nRod Hills\nBernie Rachner\nFORD & 076839 LIBRARY\nMay 19, 1975\nMEMORANDUM FOR:\nMR. JOHN T. DUFFNER\nEXECUTIVE ASSISTANT TO\nTHE DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL\nEnclosed is a copy of a recommendation\nconcerning Edwin C. Brown, Jr. as a candidate\nfor Judge of the District of Columbia Superior\nCourt. I have acknowledged receipt of this\nletter.\nPhilip W. Buchen\nCounsel to the President\nEnclosure\nFORD is LIBRARY QERALD\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nMay 19, 1975\nDear Judge Kronheim:\nMany thanks for your letter in support of\nEdwin C. Brown, Jr. as a candidate for\nJudge of the District of Columbia Superior\nCourt.\nI am passing this recommendation on to\nthose who will be organizing the material\non each of the possible candidates.\nSincerely,\nThiligW.Buehen Philip Buchen\nCourisel to the President\nThe Honorable Milton S. Kronheim, Jr.\n3120 Chesapeake Street, N. W.\nWashington, D. C. 20008\nDERALD & FORD LIBRARY\n(ajrt.)\nPres\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nJuly 1, 1975\nMEMORANDUM FOR:\nALAN WOODS\nFROM:\nPHILIP BUCHEN T.W.B.\nSubject;\nAssociate Judge,\nDistrict of Columbia\nCourt of Appeals\nThis office concurs in your proposed memo\nto the President on this appointment.\nFORD is GERALD LIBRARY\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\n3:20 p.m.\nJune 27\nMr. Buchen,\nKen thinks you should\ntalk to A. G. Levi\nand try to talk him\nout of this proposal.\nshirley\nLIBRARY GERALD 1. FORD\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\n6-27-75\nFrom Lazarus:\nOn the merits, Julia Cooper is far and away the\nsuperior candidate. One point not covered in\nthe memo is the fact that Wiley Branton has\nsubstantial opposition from powerful conser-\nvatives on the Hill and is also strongly opposed\nby key members of the local federal judiciary.\nWe should strongly oppose his nomination\nlagge\nChapman also supports Cooper.\nLIBRARY GERALD = FORD\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nAugust 18, 1976\nMEMO FOR: Phil Buchen\nDoug Bennett\nBob Linder\nFROM:\nKen Lazarus\nFYI\nTuesday 8/17/76\n9:55\nKen advises that the D. C. Judicial\nNomination Commission sent over a letter\nsetting forth three names, from which\nthe President would choose one ---\nfor the vacancy when Judge Draper passed\naway.\nDudley Williams was one of the names\nmentioned. They are sending a second letter\non Dudley Williams because he had failed to\nfile tax returns for several years.\nWhen these two letters come in, Ken would\nlike copies of the \"whole shmear\"°!!°!°!\"\naug 16.\nDear Chao. Duncan\norig- Dong Bennett\nLIBRARY GERALD ? FORD\nJohn Risher 629-3858\nTo Benett 8-19-76 76\n1976 AUG 16 PM 8 10\nDays RDL\nRECEP. AND SECURITY UNIT\nHOWARD UNIVERSITY\nTHE 144:1F HOUSE\nSCHOOL OF LAW\nWASHINGTON, D.C. 20008\nCHARLES T. DUNCAN\nWASHINGTON CA.\nDEAN\nAugust 16, 1976\nThe President of the United States\nThe White House\nWashington, D. C.\nDear Mr. President:\nI have the honor to submit, pursuant to Public Law 93-198\n(December 24, 1973), the following nominees for appointment to\nthe Superior Court of the District of Columbia:\nEdwin Cicero Brown, Jr.\nArthur Louis Burnett\nDudley Ridault Williams\nRespectfully yours,\nCharles T. Humcan\nCharles T. Duncan\nChairman\nThe District of Columbia\nJudicial Nomination Commission\nMembers:\nFrederick B. Abramson\nClifford L. Alexander\nJudge Oliver Gasch\nJohn W. Hechinger\nWillie L. Leftwich\nWilliam Lucy\nFORD\nGERALD\nLIBRARY\nJudgeships\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nAugust 28, 1975\nDear Jim:\nMildred has brought to my attention your letter of July\n30th on my return from a brief vacation combined with\na number of speaking commitments.\nI am not certain at this time whether or not a vacancy\nis forthcoming in the near future either among the U. S.\nDistrict Judges for the District of Columbia or the U. S.\nDistrict Court of Appeals. However, I am asking Phil Buchen\nto look into the matter and will have him get in contact\nwith you concerning his findings.\nI can understand the feeling of mixed emotions you and June\nmay have between living in Bay City or the Nation's Capitol.\nIt seems most people who have lived here for any length of\ntime develop a sense of yearning to return.\nI really enjoyed hearing from you and I'm sure Phil will\nbe in touch with you before too long.\nWarmest personal regards.\nSincerely Jrs Ful\nHonorable James Harvey\nU. S. District Court\nBay City, Michigan 48706\nA&il 4817 GERALD ? FORD\nUnited States District Court\nFor the Eastern District of Michigan\nBay City, Michigan 4S706\nany\nand\nCHAMBERS OF\nJAMES HARVEY\nDISTRICT JUDGE\nJuly 30, 1975\nMiss Mildred V. Leonard\nPersonal Assistant to the President\nThe White House\nWashington, D. C. 20500\nDear Mildred:\nAt the suggestion of Senator Bob Griffin, of Michigan,\nI am sending the enclosed letter, addressed to President Ford,\ndirectly to you, with the request that you deliver it to him.\nI would suggest that any reply be sent to me at my home\naddress which I have set forth below.\nThank you in advance for your assistance in this\nmatter. All of us in Michigan especially appreciate the\nwonderful help that you have rendered to the President\nduring the many years that you have been with him.\nWith warmest personal regards,\nSincerely,\nJun JAMES U. S. Harney District\nJudge\nEnclosure\n673 Kenton Drive\nSaginaw, Michigan 48603\nis\nFORD\nGERALD\nLIBRARY\nUnited States District Court\nFor the Enstern District of Michigan\nBag City, Michigan 4S706\nCHAMBERS OF\nJAMES HARVEY\nJuly 30, 1975\nDISTRICT JUDGE\nThe Honorable Gerald R. Ford\nThe President\nThe White House\nWashington, D. C. 20500\nDear Mr. President:\nI am writing this letter at the suggestion of our mutual friend,\nSenator Bob Griffin, after recently conferring with him in this regard.\nSince February 1, 1974, I have been a U. S. District Judge\nin the Eastern District of Michigan, and I have found it to be a very\ngratifying and challenging position. I spent most of the first ten\nmonths in the Detroit Court, and since January 1st of this year, I have\nbeen handling the docket of the late Judge Stephen J. Roth, holding\ncourt in both Bay City and Flint, Michigan.\nIn recent weeks I have heard it discussed on several occasions\nthat there may likely be a vacancy in the near future among the U. S.\nDistrict Judges for the District of Columbia, and also the further\npossibility that there may be a vacancy on the U. S. District Court\nof Appeals. I am well aware that both of these possibilities are no\nmore than rumors at the present time.\nMy purpose in writing this letter, however, is to ask that in\nthe event either of such vacancies do occur, my name be considered\nfor such appointment.\nSenator Griffin advises me, as I am sure you are aware,\nthat recommendations for these appointments originate in the Office\nof the Attorney General, and are not dependent upon the recommendation\nof any Senator as is the usual case. If I were appointed to any such\nposition, Senator Griffin would, of course, recommend a successor\nto my present post in Michigan.\nis\nFORD\nGERALD\nLIBRARY\nThe Honorable Gerald R. Ford\nJuly 30, 1975\nI have been a member of the District of Columbia Bar Association\nsince 1963. I have worked harder at acquiring the knowledge and skill\nnecessary to become a good Federal Judge than at anything else in my\nlifetime, and I believe that I have been successful.\nMy wife, June, and I have enjoyed becoming reacquainted with\nour friends in Michigan this past year, although I would be less than\nhonest if I did not say that we have missed our many friends in\nWashington made during the fourteen years that I served in Congress.\nIn addition, however, I am aware that the nature of the cases commenced\nin the U. S. District Court for the District of Columbia, and heard by\nthe U. S. Court of Appeals there, are more national in scope, and the\ndecisions of greater consequence, than those in the Bay City or Flint\nCourts, where I presently serve.\nI am not certain that any vacancies will occur in either the\nU. S. District Court, or the Court of Appeals for the District of\nColumbia, in the months ahead, but I wanted you to be aware of my\ninterest in any event.\nYou have made all of us who worked with you in years past\nvery proud, for your accomplishments since taking office last August\nare unequaled in history. You may be certain of my continued support\nin your undertakings in the months and years ahead.\nMany thanks for your consideration of my request, and my\nwarmest personal regards to you and your family.\nSincerely,\nJun JAMES Harney HARVEY\nU. S. District Judge\n- 2 -\nLIBRARY GERALD B. FORD\nmack,\nDISTRICT OF COLUMBIA COURT OF APPEALS\nWASHINGTON, D. C. 20001\nCHAMBERS OF\nOctober 22, 1975\nKindy\nJUDGE JULIA COOPER MACK\nMr. Philip Buchen\nCounsel to the President\nThe White House\nWashington, D. C.\nDear Mr. Buchen:\nI interrupt my period of adjustment, as the newest\nAssociate Judge of the District of Columbia Court of\nAppeals, to thank you for your attendance at my investiture\nin September of this year. I want the President, and you,\nto know that such thoughtfulness has set the stage for\nwhat is proving to be, for me, a fulfilling experience.\nAlthough I neglected to mention this at the ceremony,\nI would like very much to have a photograph to exhibit\nalong with my Presidential Commission which is hanging now\nin my Chambers. This display would be singularly meaning-\nful to me since I believe I am the first judge to sit under\nthe provisions of the District Self-Government and Govern-\nmental Reorganization Act.\nI am committed to justifying the confidence placed in\nme.\nSincerely,\nJac Associate Cooper Judge Mack\n10/29\nMildred Leonard is handling.\nBERALD R. FORD\nshirley"
}