Ask the Scholar

Document scope · 1 page
doc
Scholar
Ask about this object, its catalog metadata, its source description, or the page inventory. For page-specific OCR and visual context, open one of the page chats.

Scholar Source Context

Document identity
localId
536448529
label
JL 1-1: Pardon - Tokyo Rose (Iva Toguri) (2)
core
doc
dtoType
document
pageCount
1
Source metadata
id
536448529
contentType
document
title
JL 1-1: Pardon - Tokyo Rose (Iva Toguri) (2)
collections
Kenneth A. Lazarus Files (Ford Administration)
Kenneth Lazarus's Subject Files
subjects
Japan
Pardon
World War, 1939-1945
Japanese Americans
imageCount
1
hasImages
yes
source
import
hasTranscription
no
Source extras
naId
536448529
coverageEndDate
logicalDate
1976-12-31
month
12
year
1976
coverageStartDate
logicalDate
1976-08-01
month
8
year
1976
levelOfDescription
fileUnit
recordType
description
ocrSource
nara-archive
Single page context
seq
1
pageIndex
0
type
document
mediaId
67aa6f7e7488aff0
ocrText
The original documents are located in Box 20, folder "JL 1-1: Pardon - Tokyo Rose (Iva Toguri) (2)" of the Kenneth Lazarus Files at the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library. Copyright Notice The copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the making of photocopies or other reproductions of copyrighted material. Gerald R. Ford donated to the United States of America his copyrights in all of his unpublished writings in National Archives collections. Works prepared by U.S. Government employees as part of their official duties are in the public domain. The copyrights to materials written by other individuals or organizations are presumed to remain with them. If you think any of the information displayed in the PDF is subject to a valid copyright claim, please contact the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library. Some items in this folder were not digitized because it contains copyrighted materials. Please contact the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library for access to these materials. COMMITTEE FOR IVA TOGURI OF THE JAPANESE AMERICAN CITIZENS LEAGUE JACL Headquarters Bldg. 1765 Sutter Street San Francisco, California 94115 Attorney Wayne M. Collins, Clifford I. Uyeda, M.D. Consultant Chairman Partial Listing - DEC 2 1976 Individual Endorsements: November 30, 1976 Gov. George A. Ariyoshi, Hawaii Mayor Tom Bradley, Los Angeles Rep. Yvonne B. Burke, California Lt Gov. Melvyn Dymally, California Secretary of State March Fong Eu, Calif. Dr. Myron Kuropas Rep. Donald M. Fraser, Minnesota Special Assistant to the President Prof. S.I. Hayakawa, S.F. State Univ. Rep. Spark M. Matsunaga, Hawaii for Ethnic Affairs Rep. Abner J. Mikva, Illinois The White House Assemblyman S. Floyd Mori, California Mayor George R. Moscone, San Francisco Washington, D.C. 20500 Rep. B.F. Sisk, California Atty Gen. Evelle J. Younger, California Dear Dr. Kuropas: Organizational Endorsements: American Civil Liberties Union, No. Calif. Chapter Thank you for your past aids in matters relating Americans for Democratic Action, to Japanese Americans. I have heard much about you No. Calif. Chapter from Mr. Ross Harano of Chicago. He suggested that California State Legislature National Council of the I forward to you some of the recent informations I Churches of Christ have on Mrs. Iva Toguri d'Aquino of Chicago who was San Francisco Board of Supervisors San Francisco Commission on convicted in 1949 as a mythical "Tokyo Rose. " the Status of Women Willard Anderson Post #2471, Just last week Attorney George S. Guysi of VFW, Dalles, Oregon Oklahoma City called. His letter appears in the Media Editorial Endorsements: Wall Street Journal (2/23/76, copy enclosed). He Dayton Daily News (Ohio) Denver Post was the intelligence corps officer in charge of Honolulu Advertiser investigating Mrs. Iva Toguri d'Aquino in Japan Los Angeles Times Minneapolis Tribune after the war. He said that he would be glad to San Francisco Chronicle testify for Iva if the administration so desires. San Francisco Examiner San Francisco KFRC-Radio He can be reached at: Seattle Post Intelligencer (405) 232-0661 (office) Washington Star (D.C.) (405) 843-7622 (home) Supporting Articles: Chicago Daily News Chicago Tribune Enclosed are copies of supporting documents Christian Science Monitor which may be of interest to you. Honolulu Star-Bulletin National Observer Wall Street Journal Sincerely yours, Washington Post Clifford Uyeda, anyon cc: Mr. Ross Harano. LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD R. GERALD FORDA IVA TOGURI: LIBRARY SUMMARY OF A TRAGIC CASE "The case was a political one. It arose in the immediate Using the name "Orphan Ann," Iva Toguri was one of post-war (World War II) period when the public temper many women announcers used by Japanese-controlled was still inflamed against Japan and citizens of this country radio stations scattered in fourteen locations throughout of Japanese ancestry. It was not merely difficult, but Asia and the Pacific. But unknown to anyone in Japan at impossible to obtain justice at the time for an accused the time, American soldiers coined the name "Tokyo Rose" person of such ancestry, however innocent. Iva (Toguri) and applied it to any and all women broadcasters heard was one of the victims of the war. She became a casualty on Japanese radio. "Tokyo Rose" was a generic term, of our judicial system which failed to protect her funda- created from the loneliness, frustrations, and fantasies of mental constitutional rights, and failed to accord her even the American soldiers - and the image was not entirely the decency of a fair trial Thus wrote attorney Wayne unfavorable. American soldiers eagerly tuned in to hear M. Collins, Sr., in an unsuccessful petition for presidential their favorite "Tokyo Rose" play the latest American pop pardon in 1968. music, read amazingly accurate war news, and dabble in humor and nostalgia. The Iva Toguri case is a tragic story of how a young American woman was trapped in Japan during World War At the end of the war, American journalist capitalized II, how she became victimized by a romantic image on the tremendous curiosity about the identity of the created by American soldiers, and how she is still affected legendary "Tokyo Rose." Iva Toguri was one of the many today, some thirty years later. women implicated, but she alone became the scapegoat. The U.S. Occupation Forces imprisoned her in Japan for more than one year without charges, without legal Iva Toguri was born in Los Angeles in 1916 and was counsel, and without trial. After thorough investigations, raised in Southern California. Shortly after her college the Department of Justice concluded there was no case graduation in 1941, she went to Japan to help care for and ordered her released in 1946. But when she applied a seriously sick relative. World War Il broke out before to return to the United States in 1947, a fire-storm of she could return, and she was left stranded in an unfamiliar protest was ignited by the newspapers and radio, and country. As an enemy alien in wartime Japan, Iva Toguri she was arrested again in Japan in 1948. She was ordered faced severe survival problems: she was denied food to stand trial for treason in San Francisco - then a strong- rations, was repudiated by her Japanese relatives, and was hold of anti-Japanese prejudice. without money. Japanese authorities constantly harassed her and demanded that she renounce her American A Federal Grand Jury refused to indict Iva Toguri unless citizenship and apply for Japanese citizenship, but she the American POW who worked with her at Radio Tokyo repeatedly refused. was similarly charged with treason. But when prosecutors promised to charge the former POW before an army Since she had no skills in the Japanese language, she court martial, the Grand Jury issued an eight-count indict- had to seek employment utilizing her English language ment against her. (The promise was never kept. The man ablilities. Wherever she worked, she encountered was promoted to major shortly thereafter.) When the trial difficulties because of her outspoken pro-American attitude. started in 1949, prosecutors quickly removed all non- Eventually, she was hired as a typist in the business office whites from the jury. Ironically, the prosecution's case of Radio Tokyo. There she met three male prisoners of rested largely on the testimony of two "turncoat" war (POWs) assigned to the "Zero Hour" (English language American civilian men who worked for Radio Tokyo. music program) who were covertly burlesquing the intent Other prosecution witnesses could only recite the legend of Japanese broadcasts. When Japanese authorities decided of "Tokyo Rose," and could not identify the person on to add a female voice to the program, the POWs trial, The main defense witnesses were the three former recommended Iva Toguri. Initially she refused, but after POWs who had originally asked her to broadcast. Iva she was threatened by Japanese authorities and was Toguri herself testified she firmly believed she was helping secretly assured by her POW friends that she could help the United States. the American war efforts, she agreed. After the longest and most expensive trial on record at the Iva Toguri is now 59 years of age and lives quietly in a time, spectators and journalists were nearly unanimous in Midwestern city. She is still classified as a stateless person predicting complete acquittal or, at worst, a hung jury. and is denied most civil rights. Iva Toguri firmly proclaims When the jury reported a deadlock, the judge reminded her innocence. A renewed effort is underway to redeem them how expensive the trial had been for the government her name and restore her American citizenship via a and appealed to their sense of patriotic duty. Thus presidential pardon. With the support of the American admonished, the all-white jury returned a verdict of people, Iva Toguri may finally be accorded the justice guilty on one of the eight counts. The judge sentenced to which she is entitled. her to ten years imprisonment and a $10,000 fine. Loss of American citizenship was automatic. The preceding is just a brief outline of the ordeal and tragedy of Iva Toguri. For further information and a free Iva Toguri was released from prison in 1956, with reduced copy of the booklet, "Iva Toguri (d'Aquino): Victim of a time for good behavior. But the Immigration and Natural- Legend," please contact: ization Service promptly attempted to deport her as an "undesirable alien." In 1958 the government admitted there was nowhere they could deport her, and reclassified her a "stateless person." In 1968 a federal court ordered the confiscation of her life insurance policies as partial payment of the fine. In 1971 the Justice Department summoned her into federal court to demand payment of the remaining fine. The fine was recently satisfied when her father died and left a will stipulating that the fine be paid from his estate. Three appeals for review to the Supreme Court were denied, and two petitions for pardon to the President were unanswered. The National Committee for Iva Toguri Japanese American Citizens League 1765 Sutter Street San Francisco, California 94115 (415) 921-5225 September 1975. -1- SUPPORTERS OF PRESIDENTIAL PARDON FOR IVA TOGURI d'AQUINO. Media (Editorials) : 01/08/76 - Denver Post. 02/06/76 - Honolulu Advertiser. 02/09/76 - San Francisco Chronicle. 02/15/76 - Washington Star (D.C.) 02/19/76 - Valley News (San Fernando, Calif.) 03/02/76 - Seattle Post Intelligencer. 03/04/76 - San Francisco Examiner. 03/07/76 - Los Angeles Times. 03/29/76 - San Francisco KFRC-Radio. 04/22/76 - Los Angeles Times. 06/03/76 - San Francisco Examiner. 06/27/76 - Dayton Daily News (Ohio). (continued on page 3) Individuals (statements made): 02/18/76 - Governor George R. Ariyoshi, Hawaii. 02/24/76 - Congressman John Krebs, California. 03/20/76 - Dr. S. I. Hayakawa. LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD 03/22/76 - Congressman Spark M. Matsunaga, Hawaii. 03/25/76 - Assemblyman Paul T. Bannai, California. 04/08/76 - Congressman B. F. Sisk, California. 04/09/76 - Secretary of State March Fong Eu, California. 05/04/76 - Congressman Abner J. Mikva, Illinois. .2/ -2- 05/12/76 - Congressman Donald M. Fraser, Minnesota. 05/20/76 - Assemblyman S. Floyd Mori, California. 05/23/76 - Attorney General Evelle J. Younger, California. 06/01/76 - City and County Supervisor Quenton L. Kopp, San Francisco. 06/ /76 - County Supervisor Kenneth Hahn, Los Angeles. 06/02/76 - State Senator Milton Marks, California. 06/29/76 - Lieut. Governor Melvyn Dymally, California. 07/10/76 - Mayor George Moscone of San Francisco. 08/06/76 - Mayor Tom Bradley of Los Angeles. 08/19/76 - Congresswoman Yvonne B. Burke, California. 10/04/76 - Assemblyman Vic Fazio, California. Organizations: 03/09/76 - San Francisco Commission on the Status of Women. 03/11/76 - American Civil Liberties Union, Northern Calif. Chapter. 04/22/76 - Americans for Democratic Action (ADA), Northern Calif. Chapter. 05/05/76 - National Council of the Churches of Christ. 05/12/76 - Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States (VFW), Willard Anderson Post #2471, Dalles, Oregon. 06/24/76 - California State Legislature: Assembly 60-0, Senate 22-0. 07/06/76 - San Francisco Board of Supervisors. 07/09/76 - 41st Infantry Division Association. 07/14/76 - Council of the City and County of Honolulu, Hawaii. 09/16/76 - Los Angeles City Council. FORD & 03RALD LIBRARY 3/ -3- 09/28/76 - San Jose (Calif.) City Council. 09/28/76 - Human Relations Commission cf the County of Santa Clara, Calif. 10/01/76 - VFW Nisei Memorial Post #1629, Monterey Peninsula, Calif. 10/05/76 - VFW Nisei Post #8985, Sacramento, Calif. 11/13/76 - American Veterans Committee. 11/18/76 -- Board of Supervisors, County of Santa Clara (California). Media (Editorials) (continued from page 1): 11/22/76 - Denver Post. 11/22/76 - Honolulu Advertiser. 11/22/76 - Oakland Tribune. 11/19/76 - Chicago Sun-Times. LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD CASE OF "TOKYO ROSE" RECENT PRESS NOTES DENVER POST (Robert Pattridge, editorial page editor) 01/08/76 - "Clemency Due in 'Tokyo Rose' Case" "It is time for clemency. It is past time Iva Toguri d'Aquino, victim of a legend, has paid a price deserving of renewed American citizenship." SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE (Jerry Carroll & Keith Power) 02/04/76 - "Was 'Tokyo Rose' Really a Patriot?" 02/05/76 - "How the Tokyo Rose Myth was Created" 02/06/76 - "The Trial of 'Tokyo Rose'--A Tragedy of Error?" 02/09/76 - Editorial: "The Afterlight on Tokyo Rose" "In the light of the facts shown in the Chronicle review of this sorry case, President Ford should grant her pardon. She will be 60 years old on the Fourth of July." 02/16/76 - "'Tokyo Rose' Juror Urges a Pardon" WALL STREET JOURNAL (Edwin McDowell) 02/06/76 - "The Case of 'Tokyo Rose" "Convicted of treason 20 years ago, she still maintains her innocence. And she's probably right." "...a presidential pardon would be tacit acknowledgement that in singling her out, the government was punishing a legend rather than the human being who stood in the dock of justice." HONOLULU ADVERTISER 02/06/76 - Editorial: "...a valuable service, both real and symbolic, would be done by restoring to Mrs. Iva Toguri d'Aquino her American citizenship." 03/09/76 - "'Tokyo Rose' case. Ariyoshi calls for pardon" (Peter Rosegg) WASHINGTON STAR (D.C.) 02/15/76 - Editorial: "After reading Mr. McDowell's article, we are LIGRAST GERALD R. FORD persuaded that the case of 'Tokyo Rose' does merit official consideration. "It is consonant with our sense of justice to re-examine whether injustice was done. Acknowledging error is a mark of maturity, in nations as in individuals." 2/ -2- SAN FRANCISCO EXAMINER (Dexter Waugh) 02/23/76 - "Clemency at Last for Tokyo Rose? Young Collins Will Try" 03/04/76 - Editorial: "The Strange Case of Tokyo Rose" " this country should look once more at the strange case of Tokyo Rose. If the facts are what they seem to be, a presidential pardon should be granted And it would be a tacit acknowledgement that the government singled her out and punished a legend, rather than a human being." SEATTLE POST INTELLIGENCER 03/02/76 - Editorial: "The Strange Case of Tokyo Rose" (Identical to the San Francisco Examiner editorial) CHICAGO TRIBUNE (Linda Witt) 02/23/76 - "Was Tokyo Rose ally or enemy?" 02/24/76 - "Was Tokyo Rose mocking the Japanese?" 02/25/76 - "Pardon for Tokyo Rose?" CHICAGO DAILY NEWS (Lois Wille) 02/23/76 - "The saga of Tokyo Rose: Was she really a traitor?" CHICAGO SUN-TIMES (Michael Miner) 02/26/76 - "Japanese Americans take up fìght to clear Tokyo Rose" LOS ANGELES TIMES (Harriet Stix) GERALD R. FORD LIBRARY 02/24/76 - "Tokyo Rose: Propagandist or Pawn?" 03/07/76 - Editorial: "At War With a Legend" "Iva Toguri d'Aquino was convicted of treason under perhaps the most widely misunderstood set of circumstances that ever brought any American into court on that charge." "A presidential pardon would be an act of grace by the government." SAN FRANCISCO BAY GUARDIAN (Dean Lipton) 03/05/76 - "The Press and 'Tokyo Rose' How a trumped-up journalistic scoop led to three decades of injustice" -3- WASHINGTON POST (Nicholas von Hoffman) 03/10/76 - "Trial with Error? Sleep Tight Tokyo Rose" NEWSWEEK 03/22/76 - "Pardon for Tokyo Rose?" REGISTER AND TRIBUNE SYNDICATE (S. I. Hayakawa) 03/20/76 - "The Woman Who was Not 'Tokyo Rose'" "None of the 27 prisoners of war who broadcast on Radio Tokyo was punished by his government. In fact, Captain Ince had been promoted to Major immediately after his liberation, apparently for doing the same kind of work at Radio Tokyo for which Mrs. d'Aquino was tried for treason." 03/27/76 - "A Pardon for Iva Toguri d'Aquino" "I believe that a pardon is long overdue for Iva Toguri d'Aquino, a loyal American throughout, despite the injustices she has suffered." CHICAGO TRIBUNE (Ronald Yates, Tribune Far East correspondent in Tokyo) 03/22/76 - "Tokyo Rose's accusers claim U.S. forced them to lie" "We had no choice, " said one of the witnesses whose damaging testimony helped send Iva Toguri d'Aquino to prison for six years and two months. "U.S. Occupation Army police came and told me I had no choice but to testify against Iva, or else." "We were told what to say and what not to say two hours every moring for a month before the trial started." "Even though I was a government witness against her, I can say today that Iva Toguri d'Aquino was innocent--she never did anything treasonable." "I've heard Iva is very bitter about our testimony. I understand her bitterness and I feel she has a right to feel that way. I just wish I had the opportunity to talk with Iva and tell her why we had to do it." "We were told that if we didn't cooperate, Uncle Sam might arrange a trial for us too So we cooperated and we did what we were told and now many of us have guilty conscience because of it." & FORD 03/23/76 - "Tokyo Rose 'just a scapegoat': husband" GERALD LIBRARY -4- UPI, TOKYO (Leslie Nakashima) 03/26/76 - "Tokyo Rose said war fantasy victim" CHICAGO TRIBUNE (Linda Witt) 04/01/76 - "'Tokyo Rose' decides to talk" "After being slapped around for 30 years, what am I suppose to think when they suddenly discover I was innocent after all?" "I didn't abandon this country. Wayne Collins used to say it abandoned me But it's been a lonely and solitary life." LOS ANGELES HEARLD-EXAMINER (AP) 03/07/76 - "The Strange Case of Tokyo Rose" SAN JOSE NEWS 03/05/76 - Duplicate of article from Chicago Sun-Times. CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR (Robert M. Press) 03/26/76 - "'Tokyo Rose' conviction brought under scrutiny." WASHINGTON POST (Joel D. Weisman) 03/28/76 - "Voice From Out of the Past" "I had faith in the system. And even after what happened to me I believe in this country. If the trial were held again today, I'm sure I would be found innocent." NEVADA STATE JOURNAL (Jack Stevenson) 04/04/76 - "Iva d'Aquino: Wash She a Traitor or Scapegoat?" NATIONAL OBSERVER (Bruce Koon) 04/03/76 - "'Tokyo Rose,' Three Decades Later" FORD & GERALD LIBRARY -5- "Perhaps the President will have the courage to review her case and restore her American citizenship. Then we can witness whether there are residual feelings of sick- ness and weariness in this country; or whether there is enough moral resilience to grant a tiny bit of respect for this woman." think there's a little magic left in this country. Maybe just enough to bury Tokyo Rose and recognize and honor Iva Toguri d'Aquino." northwest access (Assoc. Students of the University of Washington, Seattle) March/April 1976 - "'Tokyo Rose' - The Estranged American" (Mary Parker) ROCKY MOUNTAIN NEWS (Denver, Colorado) 4/11/76 - "Tokyo Rose: 30 years later, the possibility of a pardon" This Linda Witt's article originally appeared in Chicago Tribune, 4/1/76, under the title: "'Tokyo Rose' decides to talk" LOS ANGELES TIMES (Editorial) 4/22/76 - "A Plea That Should be Heard" "It is evident that Mrs. d'Aquino was convicted unfairly by prejudicial wartime sentiment that still prevailed at the time of her trial. That justice can be alleviated by granting her the pardon she seeks, to restore her citizenship." HONOLULU ADVERTISER 4/23/76 - "Matsunaga says pardon d'Aquino" "On the basis of evidence which has come to light in recent months, her conviction of 1949 of the crime of treason represented a serious miscarriage of justice." "Her years of suffering cannot be obliterated, but that suffering can be partially assuaged by restoring to her that which she has always prized above all else--her U.S. citizenship." FORD i GERALD LIBRARY CINCINNATI ENQUIRER 5/5/76 - Linda Witt and Ronald Yates articles from the Chicago Tribune reprinted. -6- PORTLAND SCRIBE (Oregon) (Sue Sargent) 5/20/76 - "Tokyo Rose: legend/victim" MINNEAPOLIS TRIBUNE (Editorial) 5/25/76 - "'Tokyo Rose' should be pardoned" SAN FRANCISCO EXAMINER (Editorial) 6/3/76 - "Pardon Tokyo Rose" "Of all the petitions for pardons on President Ford's desk, none perhaps is more deserving than that for Iva Toguri d'Aquino "As noted before in this space, she apparently was not a turncoat but a scapegoat, the victim of postwar hysteria. "The Japanese American Citizens League has tried to keep its campaign in behalf of Mrs. d'Aquino out of presidential politics. It would be fitting indeed, though, if Mr. Ford pardoned Mrs. d'Aquino now, restoring her citizenship before her 60th birthday, which falls on July 4." HONOLULU STAR-BULLETIN 6/17/76 - (Hank Sato) "Tokyo Rose called victim of hysteria; Presidential pardon sought this year." 6/18/76 - "California Secretary of State backs d'Aquino pardon" VALLEY NEWS, San Fernando, Calif. (Editorial) 2/29/76 - "Tokyo Rose revew warrented" SAN FRANCISCO EXAMINER (Dexter Waugh) 2/24/76 - "New evidence that Tokyo Rose was framed" (Based on documents obtained from U.S. Justice Dept and FBI files under the Freedom of Information Act.) HONOLULU ADVERTISER (Peter Rosegg) GERALD R. FORD LIBRAPT "Tokyo Rose and me. Norman Reyes' story" 6/27/76 - "FBI coercion at d'Aquino trial? "Jury didn't hear witness' story of Iva d'Aquino. "The story behind Reyes-d'Aquino story." "A case for justice" (Editorial) -7- 6/28/76 - "Trying to outwit radio censors - under the gun in wartime Japan. "d'Aquino trial and the overeager judge." 6/29/76 - "Trapped inside hostile Japan and his duties at Radio Tokyo" DAYTON DAILY NEWS (Ohio) (Editorial) 6/27/76 - "Free Tokyo Rose" SAN JOSE MERCURY (Aramando Acuna) 9/7/76 - "Tokyo Rose: Is 27 Years Enough?" JUNGLEER (publication of the 41st Infantry Division Association) July 1976 - "41sters: Tokyo Rose should be pardoned" "If it were in the power of the 41sters, Mrs. d'Aquino-- 'Tokyo Rose' would be pardoned as promptly as Washington's bureaucratic tape would allow. In fact, there isn't a single man in the 41st Infantry Division who thinks she should have been tried and punished in the first place. The case is considered a travesty on justice and a blot on our postwar behaviro." "When the question of pardon was brought up at the annual Association meeting in Dearborn (Michigan) a few weeks ago (July 8-9; more than 500 41sters attended), it was unanimously agreed to put the Association on the record as being in favor of an immediate pardon." DENVER POST (Editorial) November 22, 1976 - "Heed Plea of Tokyo Rose" LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD "There is much merit to her plea." "Nothing now can restore the years she lost in prison, or salve the heartbreak of unjustly being branded a traitor. But a presidential pardon, restoring the citizenship she cherished through all her travail, would be only simple justice. We urge President Ford to sign it." HONOLULU ADVERTISER: (Editorial) 11/22/76 - "Pardon 'Tokyo Rose" "Her request presents President Ford the opportunity to make -8- a humane and symbolic gesture during his final days in office." "For the President of the United States, a pardon would be a small act that says much about our fairness and compassion as a nation." OAKLAND TRIBUNE (Editorial) 11/22/76 - "Pardon Tokyo Rose" "President Ford should undertake a compassionate act before he leaves office in January--grant a full pardon to Tokyo Rose. " "Now that the official request for pardon has been filed it is time for the President to act." SAN FRANCISCO BAY GUARDIAN (Dean Lipton) 10/08/76 - "New evidence of a Tokyo Rose frameup. Incriminating new evidence of a conspiracy to frame." CHICAGO SUN-TIMES (Editorial) 11/19/76 - "Pardon 'Tokyo Rose'" "Ford can guarantee that with a stroke of a pen. That healing gesture could be among the best of his last acts as President." 11/18/76 - "Tokyo Rose again seeks pardon: 'America is my home'' FORD & GERALD LIBRARY IVA IKUKO TOGURI d'AQUINO R. GERALD FORD LIBRARY The tragic story of Iva Toguri spans 35 years. It testimonies during the trial. began in 1941 when, at the request of her parents, Wayne M. Collins was her chief counsel, and continued she went to visit her seriously sick aunt. World War II to represent her for over 25 years until his death in broke out before she could return. She took great pride 1974. His son, also Wayne M. Collins, is now her in her American citizenship, and she repeatedly refused attorney and will file a petition for presidential to renounce it in spite of constant threats in wartime pardon. Japan. Iva Toguri has served a total of 8½ years in prison, She became one of 14 English speaking women including two years before the trial. Upon her release announcers at Radio Tokyo. "Tokyo Rose" was a in 1956 the Immigration and Naturalization Service name coined by Americans, and applied to any and attempted to deport her to Japan as an "undesirable all women broadcasters heard on Japanese radio. Iva alien". She was eventually classified a "stateless person". Toguri was the most unlikey candidate to fill the In 1968 a federal court ordered the confiscation of image of a seductive voiced siren who was supposed her insurance policies as partial payment of the to undermine the morale of the American fighting men. $10,000 fine. The remainder was satisfied in 1975 Iva Toguri's voice was crisp and sharp. She was out- when her father's will stipulated that the fine be paid spokenly pro-American, even to the discomfort of from his estate. other Americans at Radio Tokyo who were trying The long ordeal continued not only the humiliation to make the best of the situation. However, at the end but a plague of threatening letters and phone calls of the war, she alone was imprisoned without charge throughout the three intervening decades. and without legal counsel. The JACL National Iva Toguri Committee was After a thorough one-year investigation in Japan, formed in April 1975 to support Wayne M. Collins' the Department of Justice and Occupation Forces efforts to secure a presidential pardon and to restore concluded they had no case against her and released her cherished American citizenship. A booklet, "Iva her in 1946. She was re-arrested the following year Toguri (d'Aquino): Victim of a Legend", was published after the U.S. media caused an outcry when she by the committee in September 1975 to educate the applied to return home to America. American people. Responses from the public and At the trial held in San Francisco in 1949, she the media have been phenomenal. was convicted on one of eight counts on the Nothing can be said or done to erase over 30 years uncorroborated testimony of two "turncoat" American of suffering, abuse and humiliation endured by Iva civilians who worked for Radio Tokyo. In an incredible Toguri. Remarkalby, she has remained steadfastly miscarriage of justice, for words she did not say, loyal to the United States despite atrocious treatment Iva Toguri d'Aquino was sentenced to 10 years by our government. In this bicentennial year when imprisonment, fined $10,000 and she lost her American we are celebrating the glories of a nation conceived citizenship. In March of 1976, in Tokyo, the two in justice and fair play for all, we urge our President "turncoat" witnesses admitted that they were coerced to correct one of the greatest personal miscarriages of by the United States government to give false justice recorded in the history of our country. The Case of "Tokyo Rose' By EDWIN McDowell zona (where her mother died soon after- acts of treason, opened in July 1949, lasted Twenty years agn last month Iva Toguri almost 10 totalled THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, FRIDAY. FEB. 6, 1976 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, Monday, Feb. 23, 1976 Letters to the Editor of the Journal More on Tokvo Rose Editor. The Wall Street Journal: George S. Guysi: Intelligence Corps officer in charge of investigation of Mrs. Iva Toguri d'Aquino after the war. LIBRARY GERALD P. FORD GEORGE S. GUYST Oklahoma City, Okla. 24 THE DENVER POST Thurs., Jan. 8, 1976 THE DENVER POST FORD LIBRARY DERAILY Clemency Due in 'Tokyo Rose' Case By ROBERT PATTRIDGE "And earthly power doth then show likest guilty on one count. The jury found you guilty of God's, This opinion column is by the editorial page one overt act: "That on a day during October When mercy seasons justice." --WILLIAM editor of The Denver Post. 1944, the exact date being to the Grand Jurors SHAKESPEARE unknow, defendant in the offices of the Broad- casting Corporation of lenen did snook inia The Honolulu Advertiser Established July 2, 1856 THURSTON TWIGG SMITH President & Publisher GEORGE CHAPLIN Editor-in-Chief FORD LIBRARY BUCK BUCHWACH Executive Editor JOHN CRIFFIN Editorial Page Editor MIKE MIDDLESWORTH Managing Editor 2. GENE HUNTER Associate Editor GERALD Friday, February 6, 1976 Case of "Tokyo Rose' Mon., Feb. 9, 1976 San Francisco THE VOICE OF THE WEST Chronicle Founded 1865 by Charles and M. H. de Young George T. Cameron, Publisher 1925-55 Charles de Young Thieriot Editor and Publisher Gordon Potes Richard Thieriot Managing Editor Associate Editor Templeton Peck Editorial Page Editor THIS NEWSPAPER'S REVIEW of the Editorials Tokyo Rose affair, the first major attempt we're aware of to get at the unfortunate factual record, details the post-war hysteria and understandable circumstances that found The Afterlight a Los Angeles county native, a pre-med graduate of UCLA, in the dock on charges of treason. The inventory shows that the proceed- ing was marred by bribery, government On Tokyo Rose obstruction. unscrupulous journalism, missing evidence, mistaken identity, witness intimida- tion the violation of constitutional safeguards San Francisco Chronicle The Largest Daily Circulation in Northern California MONDAY, FEB. 16, 1976 777-1111 LIBRARY 'Tokyo Rose' Juror FORD Urges a Pardon & GERALD By Jerry Carroll and Keith Power been whipped up during World Back Page Col. 2 'TOKYO ROSE' JUROR URGES PARDON From Page 1 The host of a bland chatter- "The Army forbade any of its despite the Army findings, and and-platters program on Radio To- officers or men to come to the brought Iva to trial It was to be the LIBRARY 1080 & GERALD Page 16 San Francisco Chronicle Monday, February 16, 1976 The Washington Star JOE L. ALLERITTON. Publisher JAMES G. BELLOWS, Editor SIDNEY EPSTEIN, Managing Editor EDWIN M. YODER JR., Associate Editor SUNDAY, FEBRUARY 15, 1976 GREATO DRD "Tokyo Rose,' echo of history Identical editorial OPINION in Seattle Post Intelli- gencer, 3/2/76. San Francisco Examiner Page 28 * Thursday, Mar. 4, 1976 T) Strange Case of Tokyo Rose LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD OTIS CHANDLER, Publisher Nos Angeles Times ROBERT D. NELSON Executive Vice President and General Manager FORD LIBRARY HARRISON GRAY OTIS, 1882-1917 WILLIAM F. THOMAS HARRY CHANDLER, 1917-1944 Executive Vice President and Editor NORMAN CHANDLER, 1944-1960 is CHARLES C. CHASE, Vice President-Production GERALD ROBERT L. FLANNES, Vice President and Assistant to the Publisher ROBERT C. LOBDELL; Vice President and General Counsel VANCE L. STICKELL, Vice President-Sales JAMES BASSETT, Associate Editor ANTHONY DAY, Editor of the Editorial Pages ROBERT J. DONOVAN, Associate Editor FRANK P. HAVEN, Managing Editor JEAN SHARLEY TAYLOR, Associate Editor SUNDAY MORNING, MARCH 7, 1976 At War With a Legend 2-PART IX Chicago THE WORLD'S Tribune FORD LIBRARY & QERALD GREATEST NEWSPAPER 7Star Final Monday, March 22, 1976 6 Sections 15c Tokyo Rose accusers: We were forced to lie Page 15 Chicago Tribune, Monday, March 22, 1976 Section 1 GERATID She was innocent, they say LIBRARY Tokyo Rose's accusers claim U.S. forced them to lie Among the American-born witnesses at and agonizing plunge into infamy began. Key Japanese witnesses in the Tokyo the trial were Kenichi Oki. 63, who was "Iva never made a treasonable broad- Rose trial, interviewed by Tribune production manager of the "Zero Hour," cast in her life," asserted one of her Tokyo Correspondent Ronald Yates, and George Mitsushio, 71, who was nro- former superiors, whose testimony nev- told him they had never talked with gram director for Radio Tokyo's English- ertheless helped nail down the prosecu- the press about their roles in her language broadcasts. They provided tion's case 27 years ago. "She got a raw conviction. This is the first of two some of the most damaging testimony deal-she was railroaded into jail." stories on Tokyo Rose. against Mrs. d'Aquino. Such statements are 180 degrees away BOTH OKI AND Mitsushio, who were from those made by the same men at By Ronald Yates born in California and who eventually Mrs. d'Aquino's trial, however. became Japanese citizens, live today in Both Mitsushio and Oki, for example, Far East correspondent Tokyo and are successful businessmen. testified not only that they saw Mrs. Chicago Tribune Press Service One of the key Japan-born witnesses d'Aquino commit overt acts of treason, in comunit Chicago Tribune, Tuesday, March 23, 1976 for a mammoth country like the United States to crucify a Japanese-American- all we had to do was look at Iva," he continued. "So we 'cooperated' and we R. did what we were told and now many of us have guilty consciences because of it." GERALD FROM TERUO OZASA, 54, who worked as LIBRARY the Zero Hour's sound engineer and who A Plea That Should Be Heard - 4-22-16 L.A. Times Editorial 4/22/76 LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD Minneapolis Tribune Established 1867 Charles W. Bailey Editor Wallace Allen Managing Editor Leonard Inskip Editorial Editor 6A Tuesday, May 25, 1976 'Tokyo Rose' should be pardoned FORD & GERALD LIBRARY The Sunday Advertiser Established July 2, 1856 THURSTON TWIGG-SMITH President & Publisher GEORGE CHAPLIN Editor-in-Chief BUCK BUCHWACH Executive Editor RUW JOHN GRIFFIN Editorial Page Editor MIKE MIDDLESWORTH Managing Editor Honolulu, June 27, 1976 its 8's behivin 183 A case for justice 991: LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD Accident OPINION San Trancisco Examiner Page 28 * Thursday, June 3, 1976 Pardon Tokyo Rose LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD . new MAY EXECUTIVE CHAMBERS HONOLULU GEORGE R. ARIYOSHI GOVERNOR February 18, 1976 The President The White House Washington, D.C. Dear Mr. President: A During World War II, as you know, many Japanese-American in our Nation suffered shocking injustices involving seizure of property and virtual incarceration and suffered unwarranted calumny and abuse resulting from official policies. As one with some first hand experience, I believe that every individual was at least in some way affected by wave of hostile racism that swept over the Country. Those dark days are past now and for the most part, they remain only in the memory of us, the older generation, and I suspect that our children regard them as horror stories that could never happen again. Many outstand- ing Americans have expressed the deepest regret that such things could have occurred. The whole nightmarish experience might be pushed permanently into the limbo except for one piece of unfinished business--the case of "Tokyo Rose. " The name evokes memories among all of us who were involved in WW II for it reminds us of a legend that has since proved, like many other legends, almost certainly false in most aspects. We do know that one woman, Iva Toguri d'Aquino, an American citizen, bore the brunt of the emotional hostility that accrued to that legend. Mrs. d'Aquino lost her freedom, her citizenship, and almost any future except basic survival. Now, evidence has been gathered and compiled which seems to cast grave doubt that Mrs. d'Aquino was ever anything but a loyal American citizen and that she was and remains the victim of miscarriage of justice created in part by the after effect of the same wave of hostility and prejudice against Japanese-Americans that I mentioned above. LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD The President Page 2 I do not pretend to have conclusive evidence in this case, but I do believe current representations carry weight enough to merit a thorough investigation by you, Mr. President, with a view toward consideration of a pardon for Mrs. d'Aquino. I ask that you institute such an investigation. If current representa- tions about this case are valid, the cause of American justice may best be served by sympathetic and humane consideration, no matter how tardy. With warm personal regards, I remain, Yours very truly, George R. Ariyoshi FORD & GERALD LIBRARY STATE TRANS E EXECUTIVE CHAMBERS HONOLULU GEORGE R. ARIYOSHI GOVERNOR February 20, 1976 Clifford I. Uyeda, M.D. Chairman, National JACL Iva Toguri Committee National Headquarters 1765 Sutter Street San Francisco, California 94115 Dear Dr. Uyeda: Thank you very much for your letter of January 14, 1976, regarding the case of Iva Toguri d'Aquino. I am in wholehearted agreement that the case of this unfortunate woman should be investigated by the President with a view toward considering a Presidential pardon. Toward that end, I have written President Ford. A copy of my letter is enclosed for your interest. With warm personal regards, I remain, Yours very truly, George R. Ariyoshi Enclosure FORD is GERALO LIBRARY xxXxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx XXXXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXX February 20, 1976 Mr. Gerald Ford President of the United States White House Washington, D. C. Dear Mr. President: I am writing in support of the petition to pardon Mrs. Iva Toguri d'Aquino. While in the Public Health Service, I was closely associated with Mrs. d'Aquino at the Federal Reformatory for Women, Alderson, V. Va. I found her faithful, cooperative, and helpful. She seemed, even during her incarceration to be a loyal American. Yours truly, E. Rae Hudspeth, M.D. ERH/cf CCI Mrs. d'Aquino Japanese-American Citizens League FORD & LIBRARY GERALD 17th Disorier, Co. WASHINGTON OFFICE COUNTY Maise OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20515 (202) 225-334) Congress of the United States DISTRICT OFFICES Room 41:4 FEDERAL BUILDING House of Representatives 1130 0" STREET Ferero CALIFORNIA 93721 (709) 487-5487 Mashington D.C. 20515 210 SOUTH MODNEY BOULEVARD SUITE F COMMITTED BUSINESS VISALIA CALIFORNIA 93277 February 24, 1976 (209) 733-5036 ENERGY ENVIRONMENT 404 NORTH TRAIN STREET AND MANEGRO CALIFORNIA 93230 TRADE (209) 582 2896 Mr. Fred Y, Hirasuna P. 0. Box 11801 Fresno, California 93775 Dear Mr. Hirasuna: Thank you for your letter of February 19, 1976, with reference to Mrs. Iva Toguri. I read the excellently written pamphlet which you were kind enough to enclose and wish you every success in your attempts to petition for a presidential pardon. You may rest assured that 1 shall do whatever I properly can to see that justice is done. Thank you for bringing this matter to my attention, and if I may be of further assistance, please do not hesitate to call on me. Sincerely, John Kabo JOHN KREBS Member of Congress JK:J R. GERALD FORD LIBRARY YORK REVOLUTIONS THIS STATIONERY PRINTED ON PAPER MADE WITH RECY CLEO FIBERS HAYAKAWA COLUMN REGISTER AND TRIBUNE SYNDICATE March 20, 1976 FORD LIBRARA The Woman a. who IVas Not GERALD "TOKYO Rose" An Associated Press dispatch of Oct. 21, 1946, reporting the announcement of U.S. Attorney James M. Carter, seemed to be By S.I. HAYAKAWA the end of the matter: "Because Tokyo Rose was a 'composite months of imprisonment with the declaration, "No prosecution [This is the first of two articles on the case of Iva Toguri d'Aquino.] contemplated." Saturday, March 27, HAYAKAWA COLUMN 1976. A Pardon For Iva DINNED Toguri D'Aquino By S.I. HAYAKAWA [This is the second of two articles on the case of Iva Toguri d'Aquino.] western UNION Telegram NO. WDS.- - CL. OF SVC. PD. OR COLL. CASH NO. CHARGE TO THE ACCOUNT OF THIS MESSAGE WILL BE SENT PRESS OVER NIGHT AS A TELEGRAM UNLESS IT IS DPR NPR TELEGRAM GWAO 84664 OTHERWISE INDICATED. Send the following message, subject to the Telegraph Company's conditions, ruies and regulations, which are on file with regulatory authorities. Mr. David E. Ushio National Executive Director Japanese American Citizens League 5415 North Clark Street Chicago, Illinois AS A MEMBER OF CONGRESS, I FULLY SUPPORT THE GROWING NATIONWIDE EFFORT TO SEEK A PRESIDENTIAL PARDON FOR IVA TOGURI d'AQUINO. ON THE BASIS OF EVIDENCE WHICH HAS COME TO LIGHT IN RECENT MONTHS, HER CONVICTION IN 1949 OF THE CRIME OF TREASON REPRESENTED A SERIOUS MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE. SINCE HER CONVICTION, HOWEVER, MRS. d'AQUINO HAS NOT ONLY PAID HER FINE AND SERVED A PRISON TERM, BUT SHE HAS LIVED FOR R. YEARS IN MENTAL ANGUISH WHILE STEADFASTLY MAINTAINING HER GERALD FORD INNOCENCE. LIBRARY HER YEARS OF SUFFERING CANNOT BE OBLITERATED, BUT THAT SUFFERING CAN BE PARTIALLY ASSUAGED BY RESTORING TO HER THAT WHICH SHE HAS ALWAYS PRIZED ABOVE ALL ELSE--HER U.S. CITIZENSHIP. IN THIS BICENTENNIAL YEAR OF OUR NATION, THE GRANTING OF A PRESIDENTIAL PARDON AND THE RESTORATION OF U.S. CITIZENSHIP TO MRS. d'AQUINO WOULD DRAMATICALLY SERVE AS A SYMBOLIC ACT ON THE PART OF OUR GOVERNMENT TO DEMONSTRATE THAT OUR SYSTEM'S GREATNESS LIES IN PART IN ITS FLEXIBILITY TO RECTIFY ITS OWN ERRORS. AS A PEOPLE WHO ARE COMMITTED TO SERVING THE ENDS OF JUSTICE, ALL AMERICANS OUGHT TO JOIN IN A CONCERTED EFFORT TO SERVE JUSTICE, ONCE DENIED AND TOO LONG DELAYED IN THE CASE OF IVA TOGURI d'AQUINO. SPARK MATSUNAGA FORD & GERALD LIBRARY WU 1211 (RI-70) UNITED STATES CONGRESSMAN STATE CAPITOL COMMITTEES: DACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA 95814 FINANCE, INSURANCE AND TEL.: (916) 445-0965 COMMERCE DISTRICT OFFICE JUDICIARY 1919 W. REDONDO BEACH BLVD. Assembly REVENUE AND TAXATION SUITE 107 COMMISSION FOR GARDENA, CALIFORNIA 90247 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TEL.: (213) 327-5920 JOINT COMMITTEE ON JOB DEVELOPMENT California Tegislature COMMISSION OF THE CALIFORNIA'S PAUL T. BANNAI ASSEMBLYMAN, FIFTY-THIRD DISTRICT 13 March 25, 1976 Honorable Gerald Ford President, United States of America White House Washington, D.C. My dear Mr. President: I have written you on various matters of concern in the past and appreciate the assistance you have given me. Now I write to ask that you look into a matter which I believe by your actions could help in righting a wrong committed many years ago. Knowing that you are a fair person, I will give you what I feel are my thoughts relative to a miscarriage of justice in the case of Iva Toguri d'Aquino, who had the misfortune of being one of those identified as "Tokyo Rose". After, reading over much of what has been published about her, I feel that Mrs. d'Aquino is entitled to a full pardon and restoration of her rights as a citizen of the United States, which I am sure she cherishes so very much. Having served in the South Pacific during World War II, and having heard "Tokyo Rose", I still can't think of anything in my memory which would have singled out this one person, Mrs. d'Aquino, as someone to be convicted of treason. The only count of which Mrs. d'Aquino was convicted was to undermine American morale during war time, which I do not think was the case. At the very worst, I believe that she has paid any debt to society during all these years that she has maintained that she was not guilty of the things of which she was accused. I am sure that you personally do not have all the time to read of all the details of this case, but I am sure that with your large staff adequately researching this matter, you will find through their indepth study LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD CARSON, HAWTHORNE. GARDENA, LAWNDALE. LENNOX AND PORTIONS OF LOS ANGELES CITY AND COUNTY Honorable Gerald Ford 2 March 25, 1976 President, United States of America of the case, that Mrs. d'Aquino should be given clemency and that : you could right atremendous wrong to this one individual who wants nothing more than to be a United States citizen. In this year of 1976 when we are celebrating our Bicentennial and have reviewed also 200 years of true American justice, I, and many other Americans, believe that your actions of clemency for Mrs. d'Aquino would not only be the just thing to do, but would also restore the faith of many Americans in our great American way of life, liberty and honor. Sincerely, Paily fromal PAUL T. BANNAI Assemblyman, 53rd District State of California PTB:aj BERALD FORD LIBRARY B. F. SISK DISTRICT DEFICES: BETTY L. CORNELIUS 19TH DISTRICT. CALKFORNIA FIELD REPRESENTATIVE 157 COMMITTEE ON RULICE CONGRESS OF THE UNITED STATES Room 2001. FEDERAL Business 1190 o BTWEET HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES FREENS. CALIFORNIA 98721 Haves OFFICE Musane 200-487-5004 WASHINGTON, D.C. 20515 WASHINGTON, D.C. 20515 SHIRLEY G. GIBBON TONY COELHO ADMIDISTRATIVE ASSISTANT Reom 20A. FEDERAL Buildine April 8, 1976 1123 "*§"* STREET MODESTO. CALIFORNIA 95354 208-827-1914 Mr. Fred Y, Hirasuna Post Office Box 11801 Fresno, California 93775 Dear Fred: Thank you for your note and enclosed copy of a booklet published by the National Committee for Iva Toguri, Japanese American Citizens League. I have read the booklet and certainly feel that the case of Iva Toguri is a most tragic one. I personally believe that she 15 deserving of a full presidential pardon and restoration of her American citizenship, but as you know, Fred, the President and only the President has pardon authority under the Constitution. I understand that the pardon petition has not as yet been presented. presumably to avoid conflict with the forthcoming Presidential election. I have every confidence that at such time as 11 15 presented It will be accorded the most careful and sympathetic consideration by the President. with kind personal regards, Beinie B. F. SISK MEMBER OF CONGRESS MINOLUTION ) FORD & GERALD LIBRARY 1770-19 Executive Office (916) 445-6371 Certification (916) 445-1430 GREAT SEAL OF A THE STATE Corporation Index (916) 445-2900 Office of the Secretary of State 111 Capitol Mall Corporation Records (916) 445-1768 Election Division (916) 445-0820 OF March Fong Eu Sacramento, California 95814 Legal Division (Corp.) (916) 445-0620 Notary Public Division (916) 445-6507 CALIFORNIA State Archives (916) 445-4293 Uniform Commercial Code (916) 445-8061 April 9, 1976 Clifford I. Uyeda, M.D. Chairman National Iva Toguri Committee Japanese American Citizens League 1765 Sutter Street San Francisco, CA 94115 Dear Dr. Uyeda: Please count me among the supporters of Japanese American Citizens League's efforts in behalf of Iva Toguri d'Aquino. Please also accept my congratulations for a fine job. Sincerely, manh 7mg En MARCH FONG EU MFE:gsw LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD NATIONAL COUNCIL OF THE CHURCHES OF CHRIST IN THE U.S.A. COMMISSION ON JUSTICE, LIBERATION & HUMAN FULFILLMENT 475 Riverside Drive, New York, N.Y. 10027 Room 824 (212) 870-2915 William P. Thompson President Claire Randall General Secretary Jovelino Ramos Asst. Gen. Sec. M. William Howard Chairman May 5, 1976 Mr. Gerald Ford The President of the United States Washington, DC 20001 Dear Mr. President: The Commission on Justice; Liberation and Human Fulfillment of the National Council of Churches has gone on record in support of the campaign of Amnesty for Iva Toquri. Convicted 20 years ago as an accomplice in the "Tokyo Rose" incident, she has always claimed her innocence on the basis of a respectable volume of evidences. In the light of the facts and present historical circumstances, this Commission urges you to use your presidential powers to grant her a pardon and to renew her American citizenship. Sincerely yours, Gold Ramos Jovelino Ramos Executive Director CJLHF /dr LIBRATE GERALD R. FOOD THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON May 12, 1976 Dear Congressman Fraser: The President has asked me to reply to your letter of April 23, 1976, recommending that he grant a pardon to Iva Toguri D'Aquino. Iva Toguri D'Aquino filed a petition for pardon after completion of sentence in November 1968. The petition was denied in October 1969. Like any other person who has been convicted of a Federal felony, has served the sentence and been a law-abiding member of the community for several years subsequent to the completion of the sentence, she is eligible to reapply for a pardon if she chooses. However, she has not done so. If she should reapply, her petition would receive the same consideration accorded to other eligible petitioners. Your interest in this matter is appreciated. Sincerely, Kenneth A. Lazarus Associate Counsel to the President The Honorable Donald M. Fraser House of Representatives Washington, D. C. 20515 LIBRARY GERALD ? OF V.F.W. WILLARD ANDERSON POST NO. 2471 The Dalles, Oregon 97058 May 12, 1976 The Honorable Bob Packwood United States Senate 1317 Dirksen Building Washington, D. C. 20510 Dear Senator Packwood: We of V. F. W. Post #2471 strongly urge you to urge President Ford to give Iva Toguri (known as Tokyo Rose) a full pardon on July 4, 1976. We Joey form Pymete nuclice Hoffman Jeran m Hulan 9.7.20e ith Tepsor. In Roy Ryan Wm e Jones froe Dishimat Ornalle Cram LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD VETERANS OF FOREIGN WARS OF THE UNITED STATES S.I. Hayakawa 225 ELDRIDGE AVENUE P.O. Box 100 MILL VALLEY, CALIFORNIA 94941 415.383:6695 June 28, 1976 The President The White House Washington, D.C. 20500 My Dear Mr. President: As you are no doubt aware, both houses of the California legislature have now asked you to pardon Iva Toguri d'Aquino and to restore her American citizenship. Having been born an American, she neither wants nor is entitled to citizenship in any other country. After examining the history of her trial and reviewing the evidence on which Mrs. d'Aquino was tried and convicted of treason in 1949, the following newspapers have urged a pardon for her: Denver Post, San Francisco Chronicle, Wall Street Journal, Honolulu Advertiser, Washington Star, San Francisco Examiner, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, Chicago Daily News, Wash- ington Post Syndicate (Nicholas von Hoffman), Register and Tribune Syndicate (S. I. Hayakawa). Other publications, including National Observer, Christian Science Monitor, and Newsweek have published stories that seriously question the justice of her conviction. My own columns on the subject are enclosed, as is the summary of the case prepared by the National Committee for Iva Toguri of the Japa- nese-American Citizens League. I am sure that others have recommended that Mrs. d'Aquino's pardon be issued on her 60th birthday, which happens to fall on July 4, 1976. Since the basic rea- son for her conviction was that she fell into jeopardy because she refused to give up her American citizenship and to take refuge in declaring herself a Japanese national, recognition of her stubborn patriotism would be especially appropriate on this day. I hope you agree. You were kind to receive the Republican candidates for the U.S. Senate in your office on the morning of June 16. It is an occasion that I shall always remember with pleasure. Respectfully yours, S.I.Hayahawn FORD & GERALD LIBRARY S. I. Hayakawa SIH/ka Enclosures cc: The Honorable Barry M. Goldwater, Jr. The Honorable Hiram Fong Dr. Clifford Uyeda (916) 445-9533 June 29, 1976 The Nonorable Gerald R. Ford The White House Washington, D.C. 20500 Dear President Ford: As Lieutenant Governor of the State of California, I am urging you to speedily grant a full and unconditional presidential pardon to Iva Toguri d'Aquino, alleged "Tokyo Rose" of World War II. There could be no better way and no better time to show this nation's greatness and sense of compassion than to grant such a pardon on the July 4 observance of our 200th birthday. I am convinced that Ms. Toguri's conviction on one count of treason, and her subsequent loss of citizenship, were based on falsified and misconstrued evidence. Not only have the men who provided the most critical testimony at her trial admitted they lied; her actual broadcasts indicate there was no propaganda designed to reduce the morale of American troops in the Pacific. In fact, Iva Toguri, a U.S. citizen by birth, was in Japan to visit a sick aunt when the war broke out, and only took the broadcasting position at the urging of American POWs who convinced her that she would be able to reduce the effect of Japanese propaganda in her new job. If anything, Iva Toguri was an aid to American soldiers. The Honorable Gerald R. Ford June 29, 1976 Page Two I believe that by restoring full citizenship to this native Californian, who was falsely accused, falsely tried, and falsely convicted of a crime she did not commit, we will be correcting a serious miscarriage of justice, a miscarriage of justice that is so unfortunate in this time of national celebration in honor of the 200th anniversary of our Independence. Sincerely, MERVYN M. DYMALLY MMD:cw FORD alifryeda anda STATE CITY JUL 1 2 1976 QUENTIN L.KOPP CITY HALL THE SLAW PRESIDENT San Francisco CA 94102 Board of Supervisors Telephone 558-2338 and 981-0245 July 7, 1976 Mr. David Ushio National Executive Director Japanese American Citizens League 1765. Sutter St. San Francisco, CA 94115 Dear Dave: The Board of Supervisors adopted at yesterday's Board meeting the Resolution urging the President of the United States to pardon Iva Toguri d'Aquino. I have directed the Clerk of the Board to request that the Mayor sign this Resolution at once, so that San Francisco may be the first city in the United States to pass such a Resolution. It was gratifying for me to be a part of the effort to seek a pardon for Mrs. d'Aquino. I sincerely hope that the effort is successful. Sincerely yours, Quenton QUENTIN L. KOPP QLK:kb LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD OFFICE OF THE MAYOR SAN FRANCISCO GEORGE R. MOSCONE July 16, 1976 Clifford I. Uyeda, M.D. Chairman, Iva Toguri Committee Japanese American Citizens League 1765 Sutter Street San Francisco, CA 94115 Dear. Dr. Uyeda: Thank you for your letter of July 12 regarding the conviction of Iva Toguri d'Aquino in 1949, and your concern that she be exonerated by way of Presidential pardon. I want you to know that I share your interest in this issue, and for the reason signed into law the resolution to which you refer last Friday, July 10, 1976. I am hopeful that President Ford will see fit to grant a full pardon to Iva Toguri d'Aquino. Thank you again for your letter and expression of concern. Sincerely George R. Moscone Mayor LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK CITY AND CITY AND COUNTY OF HONOLULU HONOLULU, HAWAII 96813 / TELEPHONE 523-4291 EILEEN K. LOTA. CITY CLERK JOHN M. kamana. JR. DEPUTY CITY CLERK August 2, 1976 The National Committee for Iva Toguri 1765 Sutter Street San Francisco, CA 94115 Enclosed for your information is a Resolution which was adopted by the Council of the City and County of Honolulu. Egaileen K. Lota EILEEN K. LOTA City Clerk enclosure RESOLUTION PETITIONING GERALD R. FORD, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, TO GRANT A PARDON TO IVA IKUKO TOGURI d'AQUINO. WHEREAS, we, the members of the Council of the City and County of Honolulu, as the elected representatives of a diverse ethnic community, have dedicated ourselves to the democratic principles of liberty, justice and the pursuit of happiness, without regard to race, religion or creed that are the cornerstones of our great American republic; and WHEREAS, this Council believes the denial of justice and freedom for one is the abnegation of these God-given rights for all Americans; and WHEREAS, this Council feels that Iva Ikuko Toguri d'Aquino was a victim of wartime hysteria and post-war hysteria in her conviction, fine and imprisonment on a charge of treason as the mythical "Tokyo Rose," a conviction which since has been found to be undeserving and unjust; and WHEREAS, Iva Ikuko Toguri d'Aquino served six (6) years in prison and continues to suffer immeasurably from humiliation and the loss of her citizenship as the result of her highly questionable and unjust conviction; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City and County of Honolulu that Gerald R. Ford, President of these United States, be, and he is, hereby petitioned to proceed forthwith to grant a pardon to Iva Ikuko Toguri d'Aquino and to bestow all executive and other remedies available under the law as justice demands; and BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED that the Clerk be, and she is, hereby directed to transmit copies of this resolution to The Honorable Gerald R. Ford, President of the United States; The Honorable Edward H. Levi, Attorney General, U. S. Department of Justice; Mr. Lawrence M. Traylor, Esq., Office of the Pardon Attorney, U. S. Department of Justice; Members of the Hawaii Congressional Delegation; and The National Committee for Iva Ikuko Toguri d'Aquino. INTRODUCED BY: Mailyn Bornkowt W. DATE OF INTRODUCTION: July 14, 1976 Honolulu, Hawaii Torake Gaterimento COUNCILMEN CITY COUNCIL ADOPTED CITY AND COUNTY OF HONOLULU HONOLULU, HAWAII as amended Meeting Held I hereby certify that the foregoing RESOLUTION was adopted' by JUL 2 8 1976 the COUNCIL of the City and County of Honolulu, by the vote and on Reference: the date indicated on the right margin hereof. AYE NO A/E BORNHORST Report No. IGR CR 1151 ATTEST: CLEMENT E HOLCK KAAPU E KOGA E EILEEN CITY CLERK K. LOTA CHAIRMAN GEORGE PRESIDING G. AKAHANE OFFICER LOO Resolution No. MATSUMOTO PACARRO (As Amended) 273 Dated JUL 28 1976 AKAHANE 603 Tos City OF 105 CITY Angeles FOUNDED 184.1 CITY HALL LOS ANGELES. CALIFORNIA 90012 OFFICE OF THE MAYOR TOM BRADLEY (213) 485-3311 MAYOR August 6, 1976 The Honorable Gerald Ford President of the United States of America The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, D. C. 20500 Dear Mr. President: I am writing to ask that a full presidential pardon be granted to Iva Toguri d'Aquino, who was convicted of treason in 1949 as the legendary "Tokyo Rose" when public feeling against Japan and the Japanese was running high. As Mayor of Los Angeles, where we have the largest concentra- tion of Japanese Americans on the mainland of America, I have seen them rebound from the injustices of racial bigotry and become some of our outstanding citizens. The passions of war have cooled, and as your invitation to the Emperor and Empress of Japan to visit here last year indicates, much has been forgiven. We have had an opportunity to examine Mrs. d'Aquino's trial dispassionately and see that it was not justice's finest hour. The great irony was that her conviction was possible because she clung tenaciously to her American citizenship, while key witnesses against her in similar circumstances renounced their U. S. citizenship to escape prosecution. Much of the evidence against her was questionable, and U. S. and Allied POW's who wrote her material in the alleged treasonable radio broadcasts were never prosecuted. R. FORD - over - LIBRARY - 2 - Iva Toguri d'Aquino has served her prison sentence and has paid her fine. She even lost her citizenship which she had refused to give up in the face of harassment by Japanese police when she was stranded in Japan without funds during World War II. Mrs. d'Aquino is a native of Los Angeles and was 60 years old on July 4, 1976. I join the Japanese American Citizens League, with nearly 100 chapters throughout the United States, in urging your compassionate pardon and full restoration of citizenship to a woman who was a victim of her times. A presidential pardon at this time would be "an act of grace", as the Los Angeles Times pointed out in an editorial in March this year. Sincerely, Dom TOM BRADLEY Burdly Mayor TB/gb SEALD R. FORD LISEART YVONNE BRATHWAITE BURKE WASHINGTON OFFICE: 28TH DISTRICT, CALIFORNIA 336 CANNON HOUSE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON, D.C. 20515 COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS (202) 225-7084 SURCOMMITTEES: HUD-INDEPENDENT AGENCIES Congress of the United States WENDELL M. HOLLOWAY ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT DEPARTMENTS OF STATE, JUSTICE, COMMERCE, THE JUDICIARY AND Douse of Representatives DISTRICT OFFICE: RELATED AGENCIES INGLEWOOD CITY HALL 1 MANCHESTER BOULEVARD Mashington, D.C. 20515 INGLEWOOD, CALIFORNIA 90301 (213) 678-5424 MARGUERITE J. ARCHIE August 19, 1976 DISTRICT ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT Mr. Tsuneishi Japanese American Citizens League 125 Weller Street, Room 310 Los Angeles, CA 90012 Dear Mr. Tsuneishi: In response to your letters seeking my support for a Presidential pardon for Ms. Iva Toguri, your organization may use my name as one of your supporters. After reviewing the materials you sent me and the recent remarks in the Congressional Record of my colleague, the Honorable Spark Matsunaga, I recognize the tragedy of discrimination and post-war hysteria which confronted this American citizen. It is based, as always, on igno- rance. Recognizing the delicate political climate at this time, I will be happy to contact the President with my support at whatever appropriate time you advise. Very truly yours, Um Benk YVONNE BRATHWAITE BURKE MEMBER OF CONGRESS YBB:CLF:ba SEALD R. FORD LISERAY FORD LIBRARY R. SEALTO GUA RDIAN SINCE 1986. THE WEEKLY NEWSPAPER OF SAN FRANCISCO AND THERAY AREA. OCTOBER 0 THROUGH OCTOBER 15, VOL 11 NO.1 THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY GUARDIAN, OCTOBER 8, 1976 Incriminating new evidence of a conspiracy to frame By Dean Lipton western Telegram SFA111(1028) (2-012252E322) PD 11/17/76 1028 1976 NOV 17 AM 7: 34 ICS IPMMTZZ CSP 3012295671 TDMT BETHESDA MD 212 11-17 1028A EST PMS DON HAYASHI ACTING NATIONAL DIRECTOR, JAPANESE AMERICAN CITIZENS LEAGUE, FONE 9AM PST, 921-5225 AND DLR IMMY AFTER, DLR 1765 (POST) ST SUTTER SAN FRANCISCO CA 94115 THE AMERICAN VETERANS COMMITTEE (AVC) WHICH WAS FOUNDED DURING WORLD WAR II BY AMERICAN SERVICEMEN AND SERVICEWOMEN, AT IT'S FALL NATIONAL BOARD MEETING HELD IN WASHINGTON DC ON NOVEMBER 13 1976, PASSED A RESOLUTION "REQUESTING THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES TO GRANT A PARDON TO IVA TOGURI SO THAT HER AMERICAN CITIZENSHIP MAY BE RESTORED". THE AMERICAN VETERANS COMMITTEE WHOSE VETERAN-MEMBERS LOCATED ALL SF-1201 (R5-69) OVER THE COUNTRY AND WHO SERVED IN FOUR WARS, WORLD WAR II, WORLD WAR I, KOREA AND VIET-NAM, IS A HIGHLY RESPECTED ESTABLISHED VETERANS ORGANIZATION WITH A UNIQUE MOTTO "CITIZENS FIRST, VETERANS SECOND". THE AVC DEDICATED ITSELF "IO ACHIEVE A MORE DEMOCRATIC AND PROSPEROUS AMERICA AND MORE STABLE WORLD". THE FIRST TRULY INTEGRATED VETERANS ORGANIZATION, AVC, SINCE IT'S FOUNDING HAS BEEN IN THE FOREFRONT IN THE STRUGGLE FOR RACIAL JUSTICE CIVIL RIGHTS AND CIVIL LIBERTIES, EQUAL RIGHTS AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY FOR ALL AMERICANS. AVC WAS ONE OF THE FOUNDERS OF THE WORLD VETERANS FEDERATION DURING THE EARLY '50'S. THE AVC NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS ARE IN WASHINGTON DC. AMONG AVC HONORARY MEMBERS HAVE BEEN: HARRY S TRUMAN, MRS ELEANOR ROOSEVELT, RALPH BUNCH AND SENATOR PAUL DOUGLAS. SAUL ROSEN, NATIONAL CHAIRMAN, AMERICAN VETERANS COMMITTEE SF-1201 (R5-69) LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD 1333 CONNECTICUT AVE NORTHWEST WASHINGTON DC 20036 NNNN MEMBERS OF THE DARD SIG SANCHEZ BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SEAL DOMINIC L. CORTESE DAN McCORQUODALE 000 + RODNEY J. DIRIDON + SANTA CLARA COUNTY GERALDINE F. STEINBERG BOARD OF SUPERVISORS COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA ROOM 524 / COUNTY ADMINISTRATION BUILDING DONALD M. RAINS 70 WEST HEDDING ST. / SAN JOSE, CALIFORNIA 95110 / 299-2323 CLERK/BOARD OF SUPERVISORS November 18, 1976 The Honorable Gerald Ford The White House Washington, D.C. 20500 Dear Mr. President: The Board of Supervisors of the County of Santa Clara, at its regular meeting of November 16, 1976, considered the adoption of a Resolution urging that Iva Toguri D'Aquino (Tokyo Rose) be granted a Presidential Pardon. It was the action of the Board of Supervisors to adopt the subject Resolution urging that a Presidential Pardon be granted to Tokyo Rose. Yours truly, BOARD OF SUPERVISORS Gary F. Voecks Assistant Clerk GFV:bf CC: The National Committee for Iva Toguri Human Relations Commission LIBRARY GERALD R. FORD MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SIG SANCHEZ DOMINIC L. CORTESE BOARD + SANTA * COUNTY SEAL + DAN MCCORQUODALE RODNEY J. DIRIDON GERALDINE F. STEINBERG CLARA BOARD OF SUPERVISORS COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA ROOM 524 / COUNTY ADMINISTRATION BUILDING DONALD M. RAINS 70 WEST HEDDING ST. / SAN JOSE, CALIFORNIA 95110 / 299-2323 CLERK/BOARD OF SUPERVISORS November 18, 1976 The Honorable Jimmy Carter The White House Washington, D.C. 20500 Dear Mr. President-Elect: The Board of Supervisors of the County of Santa Clara, at its regular meeting of November 16, 1976, considered the adoption of a Resolution urging that Iva Toguri D'Aquino (Tokyo Rose) be granted a Presidential Pardon. It was the action of the Board of Supervisors to adopt the subject Resolution urging that a Presidential Pardon be granted to Tokyo Rose. Yours truly, BOARD OF SUPERVISORS Gary F. Voecks Assistant Clerk GFV:bf CC: The National Committee for Iva Toguri Human Relations Commission LIBRARY GERALD R. 0803 RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF THE COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA, STATE OF CALIFORNIA, REGARDING PRESIDENTIAL PARDON FOR IVA TOGURI D'AQUINO WHEREAS, IVA TOGURI D'AQUINO, an American woman of Japanese ancestry, was stranded in Japan at the start of World War II while making a humanitarian visit to care for a sick aunt; and WHEREAS, during the course of World War II, and as the result of threats, humiliation and deprivation for her pro- American stance, she participated in Radio Tokyo broadcasts with thirteen (13) English-speaking women, collectively known as "Tokyo Rose" by American GIs, announcing a program of popular American music; and WHEREAS, the United States Department of Justice prosecuted only IVA TOGURI D'AQUINO of all those participating in the Radio Tokyo broadcasts; and WHEREAS, key witnesses for the prosecution have only recently admitted their testimony was perjured through coercion by the United States government; and it is now. apparent that much of the other evidence and the conduct of her trial were highly suspect and prejudicial in nature, and that in view of the motivations and climate of public hysteria at the time of the trial the verdict is and still remains a blot on the integrity of American jurisprudence; and WHEREAS, it appears that IVA TOGURI D'AQUINO has remained steadfastly loyal to America after spending eight and one-half (8-1/2) years in federal prison and paying Ten Thousand Dollars ($10,000.00 in fines unjustly imposed, suffering harassment and humiliation from the persecution administered by the United States government, and being victimized by the legend of "Tokyo Rose"; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of Supervisors of the County of Santa Clara, State of California, that it appears to such Board that IVA TOGURI D'AQUINO was unjustly - 1 - BERALD R. FORD accused, tried and convicted for treason as the mythical "Tokyo Rose" in the aftermath of World War II; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the President of the United States is hereby urged to consider favorably her petition for pardon; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that IVA TOGURI D'AQUINO be given a full and unconditional Presidential Pardon to correct the mis- carriage of justice in her case and to redeem her name and to restore her American citizenship; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Clerk of this Board is directed to furnish the President of the United States with a copy of this resolution. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of Supervisors of the County of Santa Clara, State of California, on November 16, 1976, by the following vote: AYES: Supervisors SANCHEZ, CORTESE, MC CORQUODALE, STEINBERG NOES: Supervisors NONE ABSENT: Supervisors DIRIDON Disaldine J. Sinhug Geraldine F. Steinberg Chairman pro tempore ATTEST: DONALD M. RAINS, Clerk Board of Supervisors Board of Supervisors Gary F. Voecks SB:ms Assistant Clerk The foregoing instrument is a correct copy of the original ATTEST: DONALD M. RAINS Clerk of the Board By Benerly Fogle DEPUTY CLERK R GERATO FORD - 2 - LIBRARY 18 THE DENVER POST Mon., Nov. 22, 1976 THE POST'S OPINION Heed Plea of Tokyo Rose THE DENVER POST Founded on October 28, 1895 by F.G. Bonfils and H. H. Tammen Helen G. Bonfils, Officer and Director, 1933-72 "Dedicated in perpetuity to the service of the people, that no good cause shall lack a champion and that evil shall not thrive unopposed" DONALD R. SEAWELL, President, Chairman of the Board CHARLES R. BUXTON, Executive Vice President, Editor and Publisher GERALD R. FORD EARL R. MOORE, Secretary-Treasurer WILLIAM HORNBY, Vice President, ROBERT H. SHANAHAN, Vice President, Executive Editor General Manager A-10 The Honolulu Advertiser Established July 2, 1856 THURSTON TWIGG-SMITH President & Publisher GEORGE CHAPLIN Editor-in-Chief BUCK BUCHWACH Executive Editor JOHN GRIFFIN Editorial Page Editor MIKE MIDDLESWORTH Managing Editor Monday, November 22, 1976 Pardon "Tokyo Rose' GEALO R. FORD LISAARY VIEWPOINTS TRIBUNE:DITORIAL VIEWPOINTS Pardon Tokyo Rose VIEWPOINTS 22 Mon., Nov. 22, 1976 Oakland Tribune JOSEPH W. KNOWLAND FRANK FINNEY Editor and Publisher GAYLE MONTGOMERY Executive Editor Associate Editor DEVELO 0803 R. LIBRARY