Letter from Secretary of War Robert Patterson to President Harry S. Truman, with Attachment

Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 6
WAR DEPARTMENT WASHINGTON 4 March 1946 The President The White House Dear Mr. President: I do not concur with the recommendation that Philippine collaborationists be tried by a tribunal constituted by U. S. military authorities. I believe that the United States should not undertake this responsibility and particularly that the military should not do so. My views are based on practical considerations as well as considerations of policy. Policy Considerations against U. S. Assumption of Responsibility The Philippines are to be independent by July 4 of this year. U. S. prosecution of collaborationists at the last moment before independence would indicate to the Philippine people and the world that we do not trust the ability of the Philippine Government to manage its own affairs. This evidence of lack of faith would weaken the new Government at the outset. Moreover, selection of a group of defendants purporting to be the most important collaborationists would have grave political implications, which might leave us open to a charge of attempt- ing to influence Philippine political life after independence. The proposed prosecutions would be a departure from our known policy which has been in effect since the liberation of the Islands. General MacArthur's directive, which was approved by President Roosevelt, provided: 11 the ultimate disposition of all civil collaborationists is primarily the responsibility of the civil authorities. # In compliance with this directive, General MacArthur has con- sistently maintained the position toward the Philippine people that prosecution of collaborationists is a responsibility of the Commonwealth Government. A change in this policy in the last few months before independence would certainly be viewed with suspicion.