Ask the Scholar

Page 63 of 63
I can add historical knowledge about this page.

Page image

Page 63

OCR

FOIA Number: 2013-0377-F FOIA MARKER This is not a textual record. This is used as an administrative marker by the William J. Clinton Presidential Library Staff. Collection/Record Group: Clinton Presidential Records Subgroup/Office of Origin: Cabinet Affairs Series/Staff Member: Subject Files Subseries: OA/ID Number: 6171 FolderID: Folder Title: FEMA 1994 - Tennessee, South Carolina - Folder 1 [RE: Tennessee Storm November 27, 1994] Stack: Row: Section: Shelf: Position: S 25 3 7 1 DISASTER PRIORITY SUBJECT REQUEST FOR A MAJOR DISASTER DECLARATION STATE OF TENNESSEE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY DATE DEC 13 1994 Federal Emergency Management Agency ACENT FEDERAL Washington, D.C. 20472 MEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT TENNESSEE On November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the State of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western and middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced localized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas. On November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster declaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson. Following this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and local government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted in the affected areas. INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE Four (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One (1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened by the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered. The most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the destruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes impacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with minor damage, and 122 otherwise affected. PUBLIC ASSISTANCE The major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also, the State and local governments provided emergency protective measures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Other public impacts include damage to public roadways, water control facilities, utility systems and public buildings and equipment. DISCUSSION The Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR 206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate. Governor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and Public Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended. Also, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small Business Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would automatically be made eligible for SBA assistance. Damage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties. Preliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of the damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41 percent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured; however, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which were destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families affected are considered to be low-income. Although the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered. All affected individuals identified alternate living accommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to individuals as needs are identified. No health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There are no isolation cases in any of the affected counties. In the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster Housing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average of $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible for an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment Assistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the Department of Labor (DOL). Individual Assistance program cost estimates are: Temporary Housing (100 percent Federal) Home Repairs $ 5,000 Rental Assistance/Transient Accommodations $ 16,000 TOTAL $ 21,000 Individual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal) Grant Amount $ 10,000 Federal Share $ 7,500 TOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE $ 28,500 SBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the required number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In this case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an average loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be eligible for an average loan of about $52,687. Small Business Administration Disaster Loan Program $ 329,634 The primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of felled trees, building materials and personal property. Also included in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to remove totally destroyed public buildings. Public road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and damaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances of pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the use of heavy equipment during the response phase. One school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available to cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary classrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required for a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric utility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has been restored. The State and local governments provided effective emergency protective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Public Assistance program cost estimates are: Debris Removal $ 439,990 Protective Measures $ 222,965 Road Systems $ 6,800 Water Control Facilities $ 3,000 Buildings and Equipment $ 25,000 Utilities $ 459,867 Other (recreation, etc.) $ -0- Total Projected Federal Share Public Assistance $1,157,622 There were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State during FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is currently projected at $62.5 million. Much of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by insurance. State and local governments provided effective emergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local governments to meet individual assistance needs as they are identified. No health and safety risks associated with this event have been identified. CONCLUSIONS The situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the State and local governments. The situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration. RECOMMENDATION That the Governor's request be denied. P.Will James L. Witt Director Date: 12-13-94 Attachments: Turndown Letter Congressional Representation State Map Governor's Request ENGRGENCE Federal Emergency Management Agency FEDERAL AGENCY Washington, D.C. 20472 MEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT TENNESSEE On November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the State of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western and middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced localized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas. On November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster declaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson. Following this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and local government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted in the affected areas. INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE Four (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One (1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened by the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered. The most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the destruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes impacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with minor damage, and 122 otherwise affected. PUBLIC ASSISTANCE The major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also, the State and local governments provided emergency protective measures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Other public impacts include damage to public roadways, water control facilities, utility systems and public buildings and equipment. DISCUSSION The Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR 206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate. Governor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and Public Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended. Also, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small Business Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would automatically be made eligible for SBA assistance. Damage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties. Preliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of the damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41 percent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured; however, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which were destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families affected are considered to be low-income. Although the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered. All affected individuals identified alternate living accommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to individuals as needs are identified. No health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There are no isolation cases in any of the affected counties. In the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster Housing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average of $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible for an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment Assistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the Department of Labor (DOL). Individual Assistance program cost estimates are: Temporary Housing (100 percent Federal) Home Repairs $ 5,000 Rental Assistance/Transient Accommodations $ 16,000 TOTAL $ 21,000 Individual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal) Grant Amount $ 10,000 i Federal Share $ 7,500 TOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE $ 28,500 SBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the required number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In this case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an average loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be eligible for an average loan of about $52,687. Small Business Administration Disaster Loan Program $ 329,634 The primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of felled trees, building materials and personal property. Also included in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to remove totally destroyed public buildings. Public road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and damaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances of pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the use of heavy equipment during the response phase. One school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available to cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary classrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required for a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric utility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has been restored. The State and local governments provided effective emergency protective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Public Assistance program cost estimates are: Debris Removal $ 439,990 Protective Measures $ 222,965 Road Systems $ 6,800 Water Control Facilities $ 3,000 Buildings and Equipment $ 25,000 Utilities $ 459,867 Other (recreation, etc.) $ -0- Total Projected Federal Share Public Assistance $1,157,622 There were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State during FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is currently projected at $62.5 million: Much of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by insurance. State and local governments provided effective emergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local governments to meet individual assistance needs as they are identified. No health and safety risks associated with this event have been identified. CONCLUSIONS The situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the State and local governments. The situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration. RECOMMENDATION That the Governor's request be denied. P.Will James L. Witt Director Date: 12-13-44 Attachments: Turndown Letter Congressional Representation State Map Governor's Request LETTER TO THE GOVERNOR MASSEMENT Federal Emergency Management Agency AGENCY Washington, D.C. 20472 The Honorable Ned McWherter Governor of Tennessee State Capitol Nashville, Tennessee 37243 Dear Governor McWherter: This is in response to your November 30, 1994 request for a major disaster declaration due to tornadoes, severe weather and flooding which impacted the State on November 27. Specifically, you requested Individual Assistance and Public Assistance under PL-288, as amended, for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson. On December 3-4, a Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was jointly conducted in the affected counties by State and local officials, FEMA staff and representatives from the Small Business Administration. The most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the destruction of and damage to private homes. However, PDA information indicates that most of these damages are covered by insurance. All affected individuals have identified alternative living arrangements and there appears to be no need for mass care shelters. The American Red Cross is working with local governments to address individual assistance needs as they are identified. The main impact to the public sector was fallen debris. Virtually all damage to public road systems was due to debris damaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. However, the types of costs associated with debris removal and road repair may be budgeted for and absorbed by the local governments with State assistance. Additionally, although a public school building was damaged, it appears that insurance will cover almost all costs for restoration and temporary facilities during the restoration. Effective emergency protective measures were provided by State and local governments. No health and safety problems associated with this event have been identified. Based upon a review of all available information, we have concluded that the impact of this event is not of the severity and magnitude that warrants a major disaster declaration. Recovery costs for this event seem well within the combined capabilities of the State and local governments. For these reasons, I must inform you that your request for a major disaster declaration is denied. This denial may be appealed within 30 days after the date of this letter. The appeal request, along with additional information justifying the appeal, should be submitted to the President through Kenneth D. Hutchison, Regional Director of FEMA Region IV, located at: 1371 Peachtree Street, NE Suite 700 Atlanta, Georgia 30309 I regret that our decision could not be more positive. However, I am confident that the assistance provided by the State and local governments, and voluntary organizations along with the available insurance, will help the residents of Tennessee to recover from this event. Sincerely, James L. Witt Director - 7 Congressional Representation CONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION The Governor of Tennessee is: Ned R. McWherter (D) 0 Tennessee Senators are: Jim Sasser (D) Harlan Mathews (D) Representing the affected areas: Bob Clement (D) 5th District Bart Gordon (D) 6th District Don Sundquist (R) 7th District John Tanner (D) 8th District Harold E. Ford (D) 9th District For further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500. CONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION The Governor of Tennessee is: Ned R. McWherter (D) Tennessee Senators are: Jim Sasser (D) Harlan Mathews (D) Representing the affected areas: Bob Clement (D) 5th District Bart Gordon (D) 6th District Don Sundquist (R) 7th District John Tanner (D) 8th District Harold E. Ford (D) 9th District For further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500. State Map SENIUM XXXXX DAGH we ASTEMS TUSDALIDSR MML00-0 PUNATI - sure COMETA NHON 3113483 a TOWAO aur CH CLAYTON samph a BENTED NORBLET NEW 3000 NUMBER MUSIC NO.: TOLLO MD now (БЛЕГОО MHD'IS INSURED 303483 MALKER 0813003 NOT THE LATER LOWND SETTIN XIMBITH B000 NOLTY 300M SHOULD MEDICINO 9900 PRILOING NOTED 3460 TENNIS WITHS MMM TEX HINDLE BLOWN NNTIO NODAM NOSITIAL NOVENTH POLITION ЭТОЛЕН 3000 FORMS BOGO MILRIER in NAMED: TMH and TEHRU LAFRATTE UNed LEEN SWB NETWEELS NITINESS PDBS NINN NONED NOW senn ********* NXECS 20GMM SIGHTUS NDEMITY SSUND 3000 3000 NEDEL GILMER MATOO CONLINGELL TEHREU - WALKER TPPPH * SENIO NNN TWO NONE 0.06 30 sheck NEW ORTDOGR TERMS NOTE a SNIOL AUD X and 6-L 130.00 NOREN ***** NOME NTXNT KIDELM NAGONH FRETTE JOHNS NOLTINGH shw DOWN - 308M 300W and WHAD CRUNDY ISSUED 308MON INCLOW NETS 3100 THRUS NOLD 0.0.00 SMIT WHI ATH PERRY and 000MABH 38-CONT NOB ICENTINA NMM подлл A TEMOON NOCIDENT MONNED MADCH BUT 1130000 IN:00 DEMITED GONA MOSEM- 300 300 TOWER MODER TEHOJU XD HURREYS MUS NORELLER NUNB MEDICH amount MOSTA NEW ENERGY NETER HOND MINS MAHUELO NOLSNOH ATTACH MATRUCA MPSHINGTON NOINT AUGH NTINE - NUMBAO LIC06 YESTER X NOTED 3400 SECURITY NEDDER SHDMEH MENUS NOEN-DI CLRIBORNE HRNCOOK AUTO - REFELS STATE OF TENNESSEE MAITTS NICH NUTH DECLAREN ABOTEG MENDCH SEVEND MOUNTO 30-NOW LICOS - NUENHR TEB ATTENT AMERICA NGTM 36481 sceal MISSISSIM NETER 0001 OMTILLS XINDI NELISERO TMCMJ TOWNY NEUZON NGM9 10013 NEW 3501 TESTA NOAT LICOS NOTOR HEALTH 30831 DESTS VIVOV AUD LAUREL TERMS ALEXANDER BUTLER INDUSTRIAL AM 2681 SENTER Name è CBO 9NDWH 3:0d MITUAL LION ALLO NOSCH NOO MINN MOSTOM MOSABUD and 34d MEESTER NORTH GAOLS WHITE MEETOR NIEW - In CHARLED TWO NONT NU-DOWN TILLS NEXA NDAH NUMBER MOSMITTED Action SECTIONO 34066 JFCKSON ONH 1501 WISHBONGH NUMM TENDS MEMBI XIXX NED' NOEN-OP NUMBER NOWN жно unre 30GM - VANDERELACH Broken Lines = County Border Solid Lines = Congressional District A350d NXB 3113AM 0:03:00 RES-DUNCH LOGS Add XIRALII 310+1 NOLTHERN AMERICAN 3681 LIGITE HIM WEEKS ASTEMS March NOGEMAN LEGEND: DATE 3000H L005 DIRTER STON 0402 FLEMING state NOBBED Did WHOD 50th03 TEXAS XXXXXXX SNOTES HEADH ATTN: 9004 ***** we - aug MLCOHO WITHOD 30346 MID/TRI CREEN DETEREHA TOWNO EH amount MUMBER 1903 MEMTED 3000 NUMB FORTHER SEGNIT эмлеп MUSICM NEW TOWO FOOD A/D DOLLARS MYD'S NOUTH with CNTH LAM XIINTH 000ME NOTE SHOULD 32404 MEMOD CARE ENGLISH PRILONG NOHW TRUSHRICHE MOTMS FDAMS XTH HOLY NOB NNTTD RETS NODAM NEEDER MUSKRI 1 MARCH 2000 FORMS 2000 PONIDTRC INSURER TMN 331 CLETTR and you DEPT SNB PRNCL - WILLIAMO MEDICAL signno NOTEST PDES NOW NIM STATE SCHOOL TINTH 300 and NINI asses NOSEMA santo ORDER TENAMI 350000 NON NNW - MAKER 3-053-0 TM TPPH NOUCE STEANIED NTEW REDUED ALCORN 0.06 20 SMIL AND X 190.00 NOW NOOBH THIS NOREM NEDNES 6-L NTXNT NOLTING saw 300mmn MILLIN NAEDWH SUSNE 3004 346M XIII - CRUNDY CHARK MONROE a INLOW NETS 33100 TENDUS KCLCL CODER = SMIT 206079 38-XNB USE COOPABH AND AIREH BON NMM TEMOON NETICE тюдля are - KNIO MUSCH NOTICE - 113000-0 COMETER SUM SC00 ТЕНОЛИ KPC R TOWN NOBRES MIJO INSURED NUMBER KON'T MONOR assured NOTER NOSICE 300 HAMELEN TOSACH LITTRUCA GARDER HIMB CHERTHRY WILLINGHAM NOLSTOH ATTLEM a NOINT ANCH NINO NOREMO SERVICES NOBO THE TEBACO LIC06 THERE MOEN-CX SNDPEN CLAIMERNE ACCOUNT STATE OF TENNESSEE MATTER 1304 AVD m. NXM RETURNS NOTH USA AMOTHO DELIVERY MUCH LICOS y MOUNTO MORE SEVEND TER NOTE MEMBER ATEMY 3481 SCELL WALAM, XINX NEDOT 000L OMERIC NEISRHO THEMI TERMS NO.COM KAMP 3521 TREM KREEN NOAT LICOS REPORT DESTS MMM A/D LAUREL THERE SINICT MEMORE Shine 1234 3634 DEBTH DESCRIPTION ******* 2201 AERO MILLS 2 3:0d MEMITES LICKI SNOWH INVOICE PROGRELL ATEND NOSCLF NOT MOSAMO NON-HO' 3D&d GHO MIN'T NORM WEBSTER NORM FLOYD MUST LARE USA CHARLO THE TELLS NINI NOSTOM NDMH and 3501 SEEND NUMBER NEW 300 LACHDIGTON JFCXSON MISSIGH LICENSE NUMBER TENO: MEMBI XIXNH NOEN-O* NEW жего unre 3400 30GH VANCERELROH 201349 POSEY NETWORK Broken Lines = County Border Solid Lines = Congressional District AMERICANCH KINGS AMERICA XEALT 3009 WMLTON AMM INTERNET - LIGHTS HMH AS EMS - ROWAN CRIFIED LEGEND: LEGOS BOX NORBLE STHON MONROE DRIER BANK FLETING a NORTH HHITD 34d TERO SOLICE GOVERNOR'S REQUEST FEMA RIV DAP TEL:1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:01 No 001 P.02 State of Tennessee AM11:03 MED MOWHERTER November 30, 1994 OUTERMOR The President The White House Washington, D.C. Thru: Mr. Kenneth D. Hutchison Regional Director FEMA Region IV 1371 Peachtree St., N.E. Atlanta, Georgia 30309 Dear Mr. President: Under the provisions of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act, Public Law 93-288, as amended by Public Law 100-707, I respectfully request that you doclare a major disaster for both public and individual assistance for the State of Tennessee in the following counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayotte, Laudordale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson counties. Other counties may be added as preliminary damage survoys are completed On Sunday, November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed across the State of Tennessee. This weather front produced six tornadoes striking portions of west and middle Tennessee. Some areas of west and middle Tennessee received as much as four to five inches of rainfall which caused localized flooding in many communities. On November 28, 1994, the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) . State of Tennessee damage assessment teams began to survey the impact of the storm on Temessee communities, their citizens and infrastructure. While many Tennessee counties were affected by the storm, the connties included in this request were impacted the most A damage survey was completed in the five work hit counties and indicated that families are cligible for assistance under the Individual and Family Grant Program (IPO); families qualify for Temporary Housing Assistance. Total damages to homes and businesses are estimated to exceed $50,000,000. The November storm created a direct and profound hardship for the families that received the brunt of the disaster. Surveys confirm that a number of the victims are low-income households with some victims being olderly. Interviews with potential IFG recipients revealed that some live 8 fixed income, and virtually none have funancial resources to draw upon to begin to recover from the flooding. The housing problem is compounded by the fact that very few rental units are available for victims, a situation that is prevalent in all of the predominantly rural countica that were most affected. The true impact of the storm on public facilities in Tonnessee can only be gauged in the context of the socio-oconomic conditions in this part of the state. Many of these counties are rural and economically depressed, the tax base continues to deteriorate. Furthermore, the impacted counties are faced with a fundamental problem: the cost to restore the infrastructure to pre-disarter condition would consume (or even exceed) existing funds that remain to the local budgets. la short, many of the connties have few FEMA RIV DAP TEL:1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:01 No 001 P.03 Mr. President November 30, 1994 Page 2 resources to draw upon to return their county to pre-disaster condition. The problem is further compounded by the fact that many of these counties are goographically isolated. Additionally, all of these counties were doclared as a result of this year's Ice Storm, Presidential Declaration number 1010. In essence, a clear and convincing case can be made that the November storm had a major impact on the Tennessee counties designated in this request. Simply put, the damages have disrupted the local economics, indeed the local way of life in these counties. Moreover, the State of Tennessee will be limited in our capability to provide direct assistance to the affected counties as this is the fourth major disaster to occur this year. As a result of the emergency situation, I directed the execution of the Tennessee Emergency Management Plan on November 27, 1994. Response and recovery operations are on-going. I also directed that all appropriate actions under State law be taken, and that agencies of State government provide all possible assistance within the boundaries of State law and resources. As indicated, 1 find the situation is beyond the capabilities of the state and the affected local governments to effectively alloviate the existing situation, and I am convinced that supplementary Federal assistance is necessary. Extensive State resources have been used to alleviate the conditions of the disaster to include: the Military Department, Department of Safety, Department of General Services, Department of Human Services, and the Department of Transportation. 1 specifically request assistance under the provisions of Section 411 of the Law to establish the Individual and Family Grant Program and Temporary Housing. The state also intends to request assistance from the Small Business Administration and the Department of Agriculture. I certify that pursuant to Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations, the State of Tennessoo will be meeting our prorata share of the total expenditures and obligations for this major disaster. I have designated Ms. John D. White, Jt. as the State Coordinating Officer for this request. He will work with the Federal Emergency Management Agency in damage assessments, response, recovery, and may provide further information or justification on my behalf Sincerely, Governor NRWjwh oc: The Honorable Albert Gore Vice President of the United States FEMA RIV DAP TEL :1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:02 No 001 P.04 State of Tennessee November 30, 1994 NED ANWHESTER GOVERNOR Mr. Billy Max Paul Regional Administrator U.S. Small Business Administration 1375 Peachtroe Street, N.W. Atlanta, Georgia 30307-8102 Dear Mr. Paul: Sunday, November 27, xix tornadoes touched down across the stato of Tennessee leaving death and destruction over eight Tennossee counties. On Sunday, November 27, disaster response personnel from the Tennossee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) and other state agencies assessed the damage in all cight counties. Their damage survey identified over 380 homes/businesses that were destroyed/damaged by the severe weather resulting in over $48 million in damages. The damage survey in Shelby County indicates that more than 25 homes and/or businesses may have each sustained uninsured losses of forty (40) percent or more of their estimated fair replacement value or pro- disaster fair market value. These residents are in need of financial assistance which is not otherwise available 8 reasonable terms in the disaster area. Under the provisions of the Small Businesses Administration (SBA), 13 CFR Part 123, Subpart B, Physical disaster Loans, 1 request that SBA make their disaster loan program available to individuals, families and small businesses in Shelby County and all contiguous counties. Additionally, the state requests a waiver of the continguous requirement for the counties of Crockett, Davidson, Lauderdale, Stowart, Weakley and Williamson be granted and those counties bc eligible for assistance, as most of these countics are poor, rural, and sparacly populated These counties were affected by the same storm incident, but did not receive the minimum 25 homes/butinesses with 40% uninsured losses. I have asked John D. white, Jr., Director of the Twonessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) 615- 741-0001 to assist my office and work with the Small Business Administration regarding any additional information that may be required. Thank you for your assistance. Sincerely, Ned McWhefter Governor NRWjwh oc; The Honorable AI Gore Vice President of the United States Richard 3. Nash, Director Area II. Disaster Assistance FEMA RIV DAP TEL:1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:02 No.001 P.05 STATE accident State of Tennessee NED MeWHERATER GOVERNOR November 30, 1994 The Honorable AI Gore Vice President of the United States Washington, DC 20501 Dear Mr. Vice President: The citizens of the State of Tennessee appreciate your commitment in offering Federal assistance to those devastated by the recent tornadoes and flooding across the state. As per your commitment the state is formally requesting federal assistance for recovery from this disaster. Attached for your information are formal requests from me to the appropriate federal agency requesting this assistance. Additionally, I request the Department of Agriculture provide assistance to affected farmers. The citizens of Tennessee appreciate all you have done in the past and will continue to do in the future for the state. Sincerely, Governor NRM:kdb Attachments (2) TOTAL r.05 PREPARENCY Federal Emergency Management Agency FEDERAL AGENCY Washington, D.C. 20472 MEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT TENNESSEE On November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the State of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western and middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced localized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas. On November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster declaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson. Following this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and local government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted in the affected areas. INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE Four (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One (1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened by the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered. The most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the destruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes impacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with minor damage, and 122 otherwise affected. PUBLIC ASSISTANCE The major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also, the State and local governments provided emergency protective measures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Other public impacts include damage to public roadways, water control facilities, utility systems and public buildings and equipment. DISCUSSION The Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR 206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate. Governor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and Public Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended. Also, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small Business Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would automatically be made eligible for SBA assistance. Damage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties. Preliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of the damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41 percent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured; however, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which were destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families affected are considered to be low-income. Although the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered. All affected individuals identified alternate living accommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to individuals as needs are identified. No health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There are no isolation cases in any of the affected counties. In the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster Housing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average of $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible for an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment Assistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the Department of Labor (DOL). Individual Assistance program cost estimates are: Temporary Housing (100 percent Federal) Home Repairs $ 5,000 Rental Assistance/Transient Accommodations $ 16,000 TOTAL $ 21,000 Individual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal) Grant Amount $ 10,000 Federal Share $ & 7,500 TOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE $ 28,500 SBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the required number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In this case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an average loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be eligible for an average loan of about $52,687. Small Business Administration Disaster Loan Program $ 329,634 The primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of felled trees, building materials and personal property. Also included in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to remove totally destroyed public buildings. Public road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and damaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances of pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the use of heavy equipment during the response phase. One school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available to cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary classrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required for a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric utility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has been restored. The State and local governments provided effective emergency protective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Public Assistance program cost estimates are: Debris Removal $ 439,990 Protective Measures $ 222,965 Road Systems $ 6,800 Water Control Facilities $ 3,000 Buildings and Equipment $ 25,000 Utilities $ 459,867 Other (recreation, etc.) $ -0- Total Projected Federal Share Public Assistance $1,157,622 There were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State during FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is currently projected at $62.5 million. 4 Much of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by insurance. State and local governments provided effective emergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local governments to meet individual assistance needs as they are identified. No health and safety risks associated with this event have been identified. CONCLUSIONS The situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the State and local governments. The situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration. RECOMMENDATION That the Governor's request be denied. James L. Witt F.Will Director Date: 12-13-44 Attachments: Turndown Letter Congressional Representation State Map Governor's Request EXERGENCY MANAGEMENT Federal Emergency Management Agency TREATMENT AGENCY Washington, D.C. 20472 The Honorable Ned McWherter Governor of Tennessee State Capitol Nashville, Tennessee 37243 Dear Governor McWherter: This is in response to your November 30, 1994 request for a major disaster declaration due to tornadoes, severe weather and flooding which impacted the State on November 27. Specifically, you requested Individual Assistance and Public Assistance under PL-288, as amended, for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson. On December 3-4, a Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was jointly conducted in the affected counties by State and local officials, FEMA staff and representatives from the Small Business Administration. The most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the destruction of and damage to private homes. However, PDA information indicates that most of these damages are covered by insurance. All affected individuals have identified alternative living arrangements and there appears to be no need for mass care shelters. The American Red Cross is working with local governments to address individual assistance needs as they are identified. The main impact to the public sector was fallen debris. Virtually all damage to public road systems was due to debris damaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. However, the types of costs associated with debris removal and road repair may be budgeted for and absorbed by the local governments with State assistance. Additionally, although a public school building was damaged, it appears that insurance will cover almost all costs for restoration and temporary facilities during the restoration. Effective emergency protective measures were provided by State and local governments. No health and safety problems associated with this event have been identified. Based upon a review of all available information, we have concluded that the impact of this event is not of the severity and magnitude that warrants a major disaster declaration. Recovery costs for this event seem well within the combined capabilities of the State and local governments. For these reasons, I must inform you that your request for a major disaster declaration is denied. This denial may be appealed within 30 days after the date of this letter. The appeal request, along with additional information justifying the appeal, should be submitted to the President through Kenneth D. Hutchison, Regional Director of FEMA Region IV, located at: 1371 Peachtree Street, NE Suite 700 Atlanta, Georgia 30309 I regret that our decision could not be more positive. However, I am confident that the assistance provided by the State and local governments, and voluntary organizations along with the available insurance, will help the residents of Tennessee to recover from this event. Sincerely, James L. Witt Director & CONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION The Governor of Tennessee is: Ned R. McWherter (D) Tennessee Senators are: Jim Sasser (D) Harlan Mathews (D) Representing the affected areas: Bob Clement (D) 5th District Bart Gordon (D) 6th District Don Sundquist (R) 7th District John Tanner (D) 8th District Harold E. Ford (D) 9th District For further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500. INCLUDE DAGH auro AVD ATCHE TUSDALIDER PUNER WHEN ML03-0 MEMO NOTICE 311348 - UNITED TOTAL REMOVER 100 MEMTED 3000 NO./CN within 3019 MUSICM TOLLO FOOCALE we (9/13/19) ST.O.AR MATCH terms CATER THE - LONGO XENTIN 33000 NOLTH SOWNCH PRICED WORLD 3000 3WD INSURE WOTLE FOME XTM HIGH NINE NATTO 2009 NODAM NOTES NUSKIN FORSYTH ЭТОЛЗВЫ 2000 FORMS 2000 PONTOTIC - TMM 331 NAMED 1234 SNB are TERMS LND INSURED CHRICOOR MEDICAL PDENS signing NOOD NOW NEW ANDERSON SIGNATURE NPENTI IM-SIGNM SUM saw MIN asses NORDER MOSEM-1 ASTICO ORDER TMHMI 35000 NINT NNW - #5 DPPAH SOUGH STENDED security NEW - NOTE 0.008 20 - SMOL CLAY X 190.00 XDJ NOOD TOTAL NONEH 6-L LAURENCE NAMED SUSNE THE TRANSYLVING sho NOTOR 3004 SWEM XII MHAD BELLFICHIE CRUNDY - INSURE Numb 3300 TRINK MOLIC 00:00 SMIT 38-0000 USHI ANN 000MABH AIREM BON INSURA NMM TEMAIN NORICE nognn sure - MONNO MUSCIN SEOU NOSERM QUATE ADNA 300 a TEHOJM XX 6710 30 M TREED MORRIES MUC NEW NUNE IIINI MEDICH users NOTER ENGERD HRBLEN NEW WRTRUCR name DERTH NOLSTOH ATTMEN ORDER MODEL AUGH NTINO LEDS SERVICE NIREMO KISCH NOTED THE TERMS MEMOr EMDPEN VOLUE хорфен CLAREORNE AZIZUNU STATE OF TENNESSEE MATTER 11304 AND The NXM RETURNS NITH AMOTED MAICH NOUNED: MORE SMID LICOS y TER ASSIGN NOTE KIMB 368M 6CDML D-MISSION XDI Netth 000 этытно, MILISRIO TIMEMI TERM NO. IGAMI TESTW KREP 3981 NOAT LIC08 was DENTH - AND BON TENTRO SIGNATURE NORMO-03 Brune ASLEM 3634 DEBTH DEBCTITE 2291 è CONTROL LIDA GRO SNOWH POPE OFFE GRATER ATTO NISCH NOT Itd NOSABLE NEND' and NINN NOSITAL MEBSTER NOWH GAOTH WHICH MATCH NEW sun an CHARLO show MEMBER THE NOM) NDAH 0004 MDI KLMTLE 300 MOBILE NOSXH NEDT NRM MORU TERMS TERM XXXN NOEM-OP MOUTH жно unre 3008 MERDE LINES 0.0.000 VANDERSLAGEN Broken Lines = County Border Solid Lines = Congressional District 20254 POSEY ASSOUNT TIME AND LATER'S 3009 NOUTHW AREN 3461 LICITS HIME NYD NOBICE NORMAH CRAFURD LEGEND: LIDOS ROD - STHON 30804 DIRTER DATE FLB19C and MHID 34d TERO SOLICE FEMA RIV DAP TEL:1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:01 No 001 P.02 State of Tennessee November 30, 03 MED MAWHEETER OUTERSHOR The President The White House Washington, D.C. Thru: Mr. Kenneth D. Hutchison Regional Director FEMA Region IV 1371 Peachtree St., N.E. Atlanta, Georgia 30309 Dear Mr. President: Under the provisions of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act, Public Law 93-288, as amended by Public Law 100-707, 1 respectfully request that you doclare & major disaster for both public and individual assistance for the State of Tennossee in the following countion: Crockott, Davidson, Fayotte, Laudordale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakity, and Williamson counties. Other counties may be added as preliminary damage survoys are completed. On Sunday, November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed across the State of Tennessee. This weather front produced six tornadoes striking portions of west and middle Tennessee. Some areas of west and middle Tennessee received as much as four to five inches of rainfull which caused localized flooding in many communities. On November 28, 1994, the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) - State of Tennessee damage assessment teams began to survey the impact of the storm on Tennessee communities, their citizens and infrastructure. While many Tennessee counties were affected by the storm, the counties included in this request were impacted the most. A damage survey was completed in the five worst bit counties and indicated that families are cligible for assistance under the Individual and Family Grant Program (IPO); families qualify for Temporary Housing Assistance. Total damages to homes and busineases are estimated to exceed $50,000,000. The November storm created a direct and profound hardship for the families that received the brunt of the disaster. Surveys confirm that a number of the victims are low-lacorne households with some victims being olderly. Interviews with potential IFG recipients revealed that some live on fixed income, and virtually none have funancial resources to draw upon to begin to recover from the flooding. The housing problem is compounded by the fact that very few rental units are available for victims, n situation that is prevalent in all of the predominantly rural countics that were most affected. The true impact of the storm on public facilities in Tennessee can only be gauged in the context of 4 the socio-economic conditions in this part of the state. Many of these counties are rural and economically depressed, the tax base continues to deteriorate. Furthermore, the impacted counties are faced with a fundamental problem: the cost to restore the infrastructure to pre-disarter condition would consume (or even exceed) existing funds that remain in the local budgets. la short, many of the connties have few FEMA RIV DAP TEL:1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:01 No 001 P.03 Mr. President November 30, 1994 Page 2 draw to return their county to pre-diraster condition. The problem all is of further these resources to by the fact upon that many of these counties are goographically isolated. Additionally, number 1010. compounded counties were doclared as a result of this year's Ice Storm. Presidential Declaration a clear and convincing case can be made that the November storm had a major the impact local in essence, counties designated in this request. Simply put, the damages have disrupted will be limited on the Tennessee indeed the local way of life in these countion. Moreover, the State of Tennessee disaster to economics, in our capability to provide direct assistance to the affected counties as this is the fourth major occur this year. result of the emergency situation, 1 directed the execution of the Tomessees Emergency directed Management that all appropriate actions under State law be taken, and that agencies of State government As a Plan on November 27, 1994. Response and recovery operations are on-going. 1 also provide all possible assistance within the boundaries of State law and resources. indicated, I find the situation is beyond the capabilities of the state and the affected Federal local governments As to effectively alloviate the existing situation, and I am convinced that supplementary assistance is necessary. Extensive State resources have been used to alleviate the conditions of the disaster to include: Human the Military Department, Department of Safety, Department of General Services, Department of Services, and the Department of Transportation. 1 specifically request assistance under the provisions of Section 411 of the Law to establish assistance the Individual and Family Grant Program and Temporary Housing. The state also intends to request from the Small Business Administration and the Department of Agriculture. Tennesson will be meeting our proruta share of the total expenditures and obligations for this major I certify that pursuant to Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations, the State of disasaer. I have designated Ms. John D. White, Jt. as the State Coordinating Officer for this request. He will work with the Federal Emergency Management Agency in damage assessments, response, recovery, and may provide furthor information or justification on my behalf Sincerely, Governor NRWjwh oc: The Honorable Albert Gore Vice President of the United States FEMA RIV DAP TEL 1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:02 No 001 P.04 State of Tennessee November 30, 1994 MED MAWNESTER GOVERNOR Mr. Billy Max Paul Regional Administrator U.S. Small Business Administration 1375 Peachtroe Street, N.W. Atlanta, Georgia 30307-8102 Dear Mr. Paul: Sunday, November 27, xix tornadoes touched down across the stato of Tennossee leaving death and destruction over eight Tennessee counties. On Sunday, November 27, disaster response personnel from the Tennossee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) and other state agencies assessed the damage in all cight counties. Their damage survey identified over 380 bomes/businesses that were destroyed/damaged by the severe weather resulting in over $48 million in damages. The damage survey in Shelby County indicates that more than 25 homes and/or businesses may have each austained uninsured losses of forty (40) percent or more of their estimated fair replacement value or pro- disaster fair market value. These residents are in need of financial assistance which is not otherwise available B reasonable terms in the disaster was Under the provisions of the Small Businesses Administration (SBA), 13 CFR Part 123, Subport B, Physical disaster Loans, I request that SBA make their disaster loan program available to individuals, families and small businesses in Shelby County and all contiguous counties. Additionally, the state requests a waiver of the continguous requirement for the counties of Crockett, Davidson, Lauderdale, Stowart, Weakley and Williamson be granted and those counties be eligible for assistance, as most of these countics are poor, rural, and sparsely populated. These counties were affected by the same storm incident, but did not receive the minimure 25 homes/businesses with 40% uninsured losses. I have asked John D. white, Jr., Director of the Twessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) 615- 741-0001 to assist my office and work with the Small Business Administration regarding any additional information that may be required. Thank you for your assistance. Sincerely, Ned McWhetter Governor NRWjwh oc: The Honorable Al Gore Vice President of the United States Richard 3. Nash, Director Area II, Disaster Assistance FEMA RIV DAP TEL:1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:02 No.001 P.05 YOU STATE STATES State of Tennessee NED NewaxAtER COVERNOR November 30, 1994 The Honorable AI Gore Vice President of the United States Washington, DC 20501 Dear Mr. Vice President: The citizens of the State of Tennessee appreciate your commitment in offering Federal assistance to those devastated by the recent tornadoes and flooding across the state. As per your commitment the state is formally requesting federal assistance for recovery from this disaster. Attached for your information are formal requests from me to the appropriate federal agency requesting this assistance. Additionally, I request the Department of Agriculture provide assistance to affected farmers. The citizens of Tennessee appreciate all you have done in the past and will continue to do in the future for the state. Sincerely, Governor NRM:kdb - Attachments (2) TOTAL r.05 THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON December 13. 1994 MEMORANDUM FOR DISTRIBUTION FROM: STEPHEN B. SILVERMAN Special Assistant to the President and Deputy Secretary to the Cabinet SUBJECT: RECOMMENDATION FROM THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY (FEMA) TO DENY THE REQUEST FOR A MAJOR DISASTER DECLARATION IN THE STATE OF TENNESSEE Attached for your comment is a recommendation from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) to deny the request for a major disaster declaration for the State of Tennessee. On November 27 a strong weather front passed through the state causing at least six tornadoes to touch down. Many communities also experienced localized flooding. The Federal Emergency Management Agency has concluded that the situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration. Please forward any comments to our office. If there are no objections. the request from the State of Tennessee will be denied. Attachment Federal Emergency Management Agency FREE AGENCY Washington, D.C. 20472 MEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT TENNESSEE On November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the State of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western and middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced localized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas. On November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster declaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson. Following this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and local government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted in the affected areas. INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE Four (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One (1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened by the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered. The most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the destruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes impacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with minor damage, and 122 otherwise affected. PUBLIC ASSISTANCE The major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also, the State and local governments provided emergency protective measures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Other public impacts include damage to public roadways, water control facilities, utility systems and public buildings and equipment. DISCUSSION The Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR 206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate. Governor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and Public Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended. Also, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small Business Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would automatically be made eligible for SBA assistance. Damage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties. Preliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of the damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41 percent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured; however, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which were destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families affected are considered to be low-income. Although the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered. All affected individuals identified alternate living accommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to individuals as needs are identified. No health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There are no isolation cases in any of the affected counties. In the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster Housing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average of $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible for an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment Assistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the Department of Labor (DOL). Individual Assistance program cost estimates are: Temporary Housing (100 percent Federal) Home Repairs $ 5,000 Rental Assistance/Transient Accommodations $ 16,000 TOTAL $ 21,000 Individual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal) Grant Amount $ 10,000 Federal Share $ 7,500 TOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE $ 28,500 SBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the required number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In this case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an average loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be eligible for an average loan of about $52,687. Small Business Administration Disaster Loan Program $ 329,634 The primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of felled trees, building materials and personal property. Also included in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to remove totally destroyed public buildings. Public road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and damaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances of pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the use of heavy equipment during the response phase. One school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available to cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary classrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required for a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric utility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has been restored. The State and local governments provided effective emergency protective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Public Assistance program cost estimates are: Debris Removal $ 439,990 Protective Measures $ 222,965 Road Systems $ 6,800 Water Control Facilities $ 3,000 Buildings and Equipment $ 25,000 Utilities $ 459,867 Other (recreation, etc.) $ -0- Total Projected Federal Share Public Assistance $1,157,622 There were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State during FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is currently projected at $62.5 million. Much of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by insurance. State and local governments provided effective emergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local governments to meet individual assistance needs as they are identified. No health and safety risks associated with this event have been identified. 04 restr CONCLUSIONS The situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the State and local governments. The situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration. RECOMMENDATION That the Governor's request be denied. Signed James L. Witt Director Date: DEC 13 1994 Attachments: Turndown Letter Congressional Representation State Map Governor's Request CONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION The Governor of Tennessee is: Ned R. McWherter (D) Tennessee Senators are: Jim Sasser (D) Harlan Mathews (D) Representing the affected areas: Bob Clement (D) 5th District Bart Gordon (D) 6th District Don Sundquist (R) 7th District John Tanner (D) 8th District Harold E. Ford (D) 9th District For further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500. XXXXXXX SHICTERS OMGH we ATEMS MUN was TUSCALIDSA MIND MM-03-0 311343 MEDITAL AREM TOWN MEMTED INSURED 3000 NOVEN SENT 30181 A MEMBI TOWO MUSICH note anonoo ST.0.AR A/D 24 URTEN terren XEXICH CONEE LATAR KINNO NOL SHOULD 32NM 3WD PRICED MEMORO ENTER imprio WITHS FORMS XTM NUB CULLIAN. RET'S NEW NORMA 1 FORSYTH 2000 PORTS 2000 PONTOTOC TM 331 HART ERNS and NAMED: - TERMS ONE MILLING 99 PDB6 AMERICAN NON Nin a NAME zignn SINGH 3.70 NONT asses THE NOSCHE 50000 NOSEBLI MIND NNM and 305341 TMHAM NONT - STENDED TPPAH souce security NTM - SND CANDOOR NOTE 0.06 20 NO 390.00 NDJ MOOTH are NOMEN X MEDDLES NEXNT 6-L TRICKLYNR NOUTH NORTH TOTAL NIDDEW STD LARGE NAMED 303NB THE TO: 3004 3451 NEMBER & SECURICHE AGENT INLIM asso NETS THE 3300 TEMPS 00:00 SMI MOLICE 56-0000 CHI ARM AIREW DECTILR NEW 000MABH BOUNT INSURANCE MMM TERMIN serve - IDNED MARCH NOTERSH 5401 CRACTER 113000.0 I 3011 ТЕНДИ XPC our IS NOVEMENT BARMSFH NEW are 100N NUMB M:DICM ware 3000 NOTER MISKED NEW WATRUCA BRAINDER KIMB S MHICH OFFIER NONT NESTH ATTEN NIREMO RICH NTINO TERMS 1.000 NOBO THE NOEM-OP ENDIREH CLASSINE the STATE OF TENNESSEE MAITED XXXXH ADDRESS 1304 AND NXW FORERTEON RETERS NOTES AMOTED MANCH LIC08 an TEA NOUSED: MORRIE - ASTILITY AMERICA 36491 NOTW WRLAM SCHOOL XXXX REDUT 0001 зымо TEMPS OMLINE NO. TMPMJ IQMO 3811 TERM NOAT was MANDER INSTRUCTION LICOS DESTS AND LAUREL MM/M Hure RECEIVER - PLEASE LICK MINA 2 recomell anoth DEO# DENITION ATEMO CHARGES ktd FOGON NEC 34d NOSABED GHD NEGHT NEED FLOYD NOWH MATH MARION y trun CHARLED THIS TUS NON) and MDI NOWH LACHINGTON SEENO (NLIMITY) 300 AMOUNT MODT MRIN TOTAL WELDINGH WENT XCDONBH 384633 MORGAN *WD штте 3008 30GM SPENDER RETURNED address RES-OUND VDG4 AIREM Broken Lines = County Border Solid Lines = Congressional District XEREM 31091 LICITE MOLTH-BM WOOM? 346h ARMY È ( MPDS 45 BMS 1 ******* LEGOS ROD LEGEND: DRIER FLETING MONROE 0409 sceno NOBED WHOD, 34d NUCKHAM courts THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON December 13, 1994 MEMORANDUM FOR DISTRIBUTION FROM: STEPHEN B. SILVERMANSOS Special Assistant to the President and Deputy Secretary to the Cabinet SUBJECT: RECOMMENDATION FROM THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY (FEMA) TO DENY THE REQUEST FOR A MAJOR DISASTER DECLARATION IN THE STATE OF TENNESSEE Attached for your comment is a recommendation from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) to deny the request for a major disaster declaration for the State of Tennessee. On November 27 a strong weather front passed through the state causing at least six tornadoes to touch down. Many communities also experienced localized flooding. The Federal Emergency Management Agency has concluded that the situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration. Please forward any comments to our office. If there are no objections, the request from the State of Tennessee will be denied. Attachment PURCHASE Federal Emergency Management Agency FEDERAL AGENCY Washington, D.C. 20472 MEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT TENNESSEE On November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the State of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western and middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced localized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas. On November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster declaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson. Following this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and local government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted in the affected areas. INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE Four (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One (1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened by the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered. The most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the destruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes impacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with minor damage, and 122 otherwise affected. PUBLIC ASSISTANCE The major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also, the State and local governments provided emergency protective measures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Other public impacts include damage to public roadways, water control facilities, utility systems and public buildings and equipment. DISCUSSION The Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR 206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate. Governor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and Public Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended. Also, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small Business Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would automatically be made eligible for SBA assistance. Damage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties. Preliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of the damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41 percent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured; however, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which were destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families affected are considered to be low-income. Although the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered. All affected individuals identified alternate living accommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to individuals as needs are identified. No health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There are no isolation cases in any of the affected counties. In the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster Housing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average of $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible for an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment Assistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the Department of Labor (DOL). Individual Assistance program cost estimates are: Temporary Housing (100 percent Federal) Home Repairs $ 5,000 Rental Assistance/Transient Accommodations $ 16,000 TOTAL $ 21,000 Individual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal) Grant Amount $ 10,000 Federal Share I $ 7,500 TOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE $ 28,500 SBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the required number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In the event of a major disaster declaration for Individual Assistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In this case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an average loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be eligible for an average loan of about $52,687. Small Business Administration Disaster Loan Program $ 329,634 The primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of felled trees, building materials and personal property. Also included in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to remove totally destroyed public buildings. Public road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and damaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances of pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the use of heavy equipment during the response phase. One school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available to cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary classrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required for a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric utility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has been restored. The State and local governments provided effective emergency protective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic control and providing food for affected individuals. Public Assistance program cost estimates are: Debris Removal $ 439,990 Protective Measures $ 222,965 Road Systems $ 6,800 Water Control Facilities $ 3,000 Buildings and Equipment $ 25,000 Utilities $ 459,867 Other (recreation, etc.) $ -0- Total Projected Federal Share Public Assistance $1,157,622 There were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State during FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is currently projected at $62.5 million. Much of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by insurance. State and local governments provided effective emergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local governments to meet individual assistance needs as they are identified. No health and safety risks associated with this event have been identified. CONCLUSIONS The situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the State and local governments. The situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration. RECOMMENDATION That the Governor's request be denied. Signed James L. Witt Director Date: DEC 13 1994 Attachments: Turndown Letter Congressional Representation State Map Governor's Request CONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION The Governor of Tennessee is: Ned R. McWherter (D) Tennessee Senators are: Jim Sasser (D) Harlan Mathews (D) Representing the affected areas: Bob Clement (D) 5th District Bart Gordon (D) 6th District Don Sundquist (R) 7th District John Tanner (D) 8th District Harold E. Ford (D) 9th District For further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500. XXXXXX INITEMS DASH a ATCHE SENIL we TUSCALIDER PUNRI was MACCHO REND 311343 MIDITAL - TIMES CH AMERICANCE MILLAND - MEMTED 300 NORTH LERORE NOVEN MUSICH NEMBER TOLLRO note - COLORAS ST.0.AR URTIN terms MOSTEREH - MIND XEXTH BOOD NOLT: SHOULD SINGH CARD MEMORO 3WD INTER WORLD TRELAHRICHE MOTES FDAMS XTX HEMOLE NOTE YRLOBUSHA CULLMAN. 2000 NEEDS NOSICER NOMM HOJSMIN FOREYTH BODO FORMS 2000 PONTITIOC ЭТТАЗЕН TMN In NAMED: BRNS and HART TENDING LAFR/ETTE PRND MEMBER CHICKER sann MOTEO PICKENS MIRGAN NEW ********* a SCHOOL NDEMITI STATE 300 saw MINI LEWS МОВЖЕНГ NOSIDEN METICO NUMBER TMOM 3100 INFORMATION MALKER #5 TPPAH SOUGH STE/NIED sexed NEW - SMILL MEDICALO MOOD'S 0.06 20 A/D X 190.00 NDJ MXM Line NOREM NEDNESS 6-L NONT MOLTING saw 3000mn NORTH NAEDWH NXXX 3004 3451 NOT & SECURICHIE AGNTS 3DWCH INCLU a NETS COFFEE TERMS KOLD CERVEN CHECKE SAN 206079 38-CONT - ANH AIREM NOGICIAL 00011A8H BON NMM TEMON burn - MADEIN 5000 113000 ADMA ROSERMA 300 a TEHCAM XMI 67830 DE TOMO SUBHISH MORE NORBAN - ADD NUNE KONT NEDICH users NOTER 3000 HAMELEN NEW LITTRUCA WILSINGTON HIND name NISTH BERLO MONT ATTMS AMEH NTNO NURBAD TERMS LIC05 FENTRESS MOBICH a ENDIGH X NIED THE MEMI MMS ABOUNT STATE OF TENNESSEE NAITE XXXMM 1504 AND m. NXM RETURNS NOTH USA APOTED addition MUCH LICOS an NOUNTRY MORE MENHAN TES ATTENT AMOUNT NETW SCILL NUM XINCE NEXT and OMTILS RECEIVED TMGMJ TEMM MORTH IDAHO 3911 TESSAL KREEN NOT LEDS was MONTGO DENTA VIVOV A/D LAUREL THROUGH SINCE artins AND NUMBER 3034 DOSTS NNMB 24H addition LID# ARO MILL SHOWH 3:04 TERREM ATTO NUSCH NOT MOSAMED GND NON-OP 34d KEN NEW a NOTH GATE THERE NETCH NINH snan an amo STATE TUS3 MXXMI NON) NDAH BIGH 883.40 (KLB/TMB AMERICAN 300 NOSXCH MEMORH MOOT NDM TENOS XIXNM NOEM-OP NOTH AMOUNT THINGI CLARK unre 3005 20124 HING ARM MIDDLES Broken Lines = County Border Solid Lines = Congressional District RES-DUNCH VEDICLES AMEN MFRRICK 3109 NOUTHERN AMEN - LIDITE H&B ASTHS NORMAH ******* CHARGED LEGEND: STHON LEGOS FLOYD MONTHS MONROE CARTER DAY FLB10C 6000 NUMBER WHOD, 34d TERMS BEEN INFORMATION COPY DISASTER PRIORITY SUBJECT REQUEST FOR A MAJOR DISASTER DECLARATION STATE OF TENNESSEE EXERGENCY AGEMENT MERITAL FEDERAL AGENCY DATE DEC 13 1994 Federal Emergency Management Agency FEDERAL AGENCY Washington, D.C. 20472 The Honorable Ned McWherter Governor of Tennessee State Capitol Nashville, Tennessee 37243 Dear Governor McWherter: This is in response to your November 30, 1994 request for a major disaster declaration due to tornadoes, severe weather and flooding which impacted the State on November 27. Specifically, you requested Individual Assistance and Public Assistance under PL-288, as amended, for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson. On December 3-4, a Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was jointly conducted in the affected counties by State and local officials, FEMA staff and representatives from the Small Business Administration. The most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the destruction of and damage to private homes. However, PDA information indicates that most of these damages are covered by insurance. All affected individuals have identified alternative living arrangements and there appears to be no need for mass care shelters. The American Red Cross is working with local governments to address individual assistance needs as they are identified. The main impact to the public sector was fallen debris. Virtually all damage to public road systems was due to debris damaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. However, the types of costs associated with debris removal and road repair may be budgeted for and absorbed by the local governments with State assistance. Additionally, although a public school building was damaged, it appears that insurance will cover almost all costs for restoration and temporary facilities during the restoration. Effective emergency protective measures were provided by State and local governments. No health and safety problems associated with this event have been identified. Based upon a review of all available information, we have concluded that the impact of this event is not of the severity and magnitude that warrants a major disaster declaration. Recovery costs for this event seem well within the combined capabilities of the State and local governments. For these reasons, I must inform you that your request for a major disaster declaration is denied. This denial may be appealed within 30 days after the date of this letter. The appeal request, along with additional information justifying the appeal, should be submitted to the President through Kenneth D. Hutchison, Regional Director of FEMA Region IV, located at: 1371 Peachtree Street, NE Suite 700 Atlanta, Georgia 30309 I regret that our decision could not be more positive. However, I am confident that the assistance provided by the State and local governments, and voluntary organizations along with the available insurance, will help the residents of Tennessee to recover from this event. Sincerely, James L. Witt Director FEMA RIV DAP TEL:1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:01 No 001 P.02 State of Tennessee November 30, 03 NED MeWHESTER COTERNOR The President The White House Washington, D.C. Thru: Mr. Kenneth D. Hutchison Regional Director FEMA Region IV 1371 Peachtree St., N.E. Atlanta, Georgia 30309 Dear Mr. President: Under the provisions of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act, Public Law 93-288, as amended by Public Law 100-707, 1 respectfully request that you doclare a major disaster for both public and individual assistance for the State of Tennessee in the following countion: Crockett, Davidson, Fayotte, Laudordale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson counties. Other counties may be added as preliminary damage survoys are completed. On Sunday, November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed across the State of Tennessee. This weather front produced six tornadoes striking portions of west and middle Tennessee. Some areas of west and middle Tennessee received as much as four to five inches of rainfall which caused localized flooding in many communition. On November 28, 1994, the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) . State of Termessee damage assessment teams began to survey the impact of the storm on Tennessee communities, their citizens and infrastructure. While many Teanessee counties were affected by the storm, the connties included in this request were impacted the most. A damage survey was completed in the five work hit counties and indicated that families are cligible for assistance under the Individual and Family Grant Program (IPO); families qualify for Temporary Housing Assistance. Total damages to homes and businesses are estimated to exceed $50,000,000. The November storm created a direct and profound hardship for the families that received the brunt of the disaster. Surveys confirm that a number of the victims are low-lacome households with some victims being olderly. Interviews with potential IFG recipients revealed that some live on fixed income, and virtually none have financial resources to draw upon to begin to recover from the flooding. The housing problem is compounded by the fact that very fow rental units are available for victims, 1 situation that is prevalent in all of the predominantly rural countics that were most affected. The true impact of the storm on public facilities in Tonnessee can only be gauged in the context of the socio-economic conditions in this part of the state. Many of these counties are rural and economically depressed, the tax base continues to deteriorate. Furthermore, the impacted counties are faced with a fundamental problem: the cost to restore the infrastructure to pre-disarter condition would consume (or even exceed) existing funds that remain in the local budgets. la short, many of the connties have few FEMA RIV DAP TEL:1,1,404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:01 No 001 P.03 Mr. President November 30, 1994 Page 2 resources to draw upon to return their county to pre-disaster condition. The problem is further compounded by the fact that many of these counties are goographically isolated. Additionally, all of these counties were doclared as a result of this year's Ice Storm, Presidential Declaration number 1010. In essence, a clear and convincing case can be made that the November storm had a major impact on the Tennessee counties designated in this request. Simply put, the damages have disrupted the local economics, indeed the local way of life in these counties. Moreover, the State of Tennessee will be limited in our capability to provide direct assistance to the affected counties as this is the fourth major disaster to occur this year. As a result of the emergency situation, 1 directed the execution of the Tennessee Emergency Management Plan on November 27, 1994. Response and recovery operations are ou-going. 1 also directed that all appropriate actions under State law be taken, and that agencies of State government provide all possible assistance within the boundaries of State law and resources. As indicated, I find the situation is beyond the capabilities of the state and the affected local governments to effectively alloviate the existing situation, and I am convinced that supplementary Federal assistance is necessary. Extensive State resources have been used to alleviate the conditions of the disaster to include: the Military Department, Department of Safety, Department of General Services, Department of Human Services, and the Department of Transportation. 1 specifically request assistance under the provisions of Section 411 of the Law to establish the Individual and Family Grant Program and Temporary Housing. The state also intends to request assistance from the Small Business Administration and the Department of Agriculture. I certify that pursuant to Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations, the State of Tennesson will be meeting our prorata share of the total expenditures and obligations for this major diseaser. I have designated Ms. John D. White, Jr. as the State Coordinating Officer for this request. He will work with the Federal Emergency Management Agency in damage assessments, response, recovery, and may provide further information or justification 8 my behalf Sincerely, Governor NRW.jwh g The Honorable Albert Gore Vice President of the United States FEMA RIV DAP TEL :1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:02 No 001 P.04 State of Tennessee November 30, 1994 MED MAWNERIER GOVERNOR Mr. Billy Max Paul Regional Administrator U.S. Small Business Administration 1375 Peachtroe Street, N.W. Atlanta, Georgia 30307-8102 Dear Mr. Paul: Sunday, November 27, xix tornadoes touched down across the stato of Tennossco leaving death and destruction over eight Tennossee counties. On Sunday, November 27, disaster response personnel from the Tennossee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) and other state agencies assessed the damage in all cight counties. Their damage survey identified over 380 homes/businesses that were destroyed/damaged by the severe weather resulting in over $48 million in damages. The damage survey in Shelby County indicates that more than 25 homes and/or businesses may have each sustained uninsured losses of forty (40) percent or more of their estimated fair replacement value or pro- disaster fair market value. These residents are in need of financial assistance which is not otherwise available 8 reasonable terms in the disaster area. Under the provisions of the Small Businesses Administration (SBA), 13 CFR Part 123, Subpart B, Physical disaster Loans, 1 request that SBA make their disaster loan program available to individuals, families and small businesses in Shelby County and all contiguous counties. Additionally, the state requests a waiver of the continguous requirement for the counties of Crockett, Davidson, Lauderdale, Stowart, Weakley and Williamson be granted and those counties be eligible for assistance, as most of these countics are poor, rural, and sparacly populated. These counties were affected by the same storm incident, but did not receive the minimum 25 homes/businesses with 40% uninsured losses. I have asked John D. white, jt., Director of the Totacssee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) 615- 741-0001 to assist my office and work with the Small Business Administration regarding any additional information that may be required. Thank you for your assistance. Sincerely, Ned McWherter Governor NRWjwh oc: The Honorable Al Gore Vice President of the United States Richard 3. Nash, Director Area U. Disaster Assistance RIV DAP TEL:1-404-853-4344 Dec 01 94 11:02 No 001 P.05 State of Tennessee NED MeWNRATER GOVERNOR November 30, 1994 The Honorable AI Gore Vice President of the United States Washington, DC 20501 Dear Mr. Vice President: The citizens of the State of Tennessee appreciate your commitment in offering Federal assistance to those devastated by the recent tornadoes and flooding across the state. As per your commitment the state is formally requesting federal assistance for recovery from this disaster. Attached for your information are formal requests from me to the appropriate federal agency requesting this assistance. Additionally, I request the Department of Agriculture provide assistance to affected farmers. The citizens of Tennessee appreciate all you have done in the past and will continue to do in the future for the state. Sincerely, Governor NRM:kdb Attachments (2) TOTAL 1.05 BETH PRICHARD ALPERT anna, The VP is very concerned that you. mouhertes's letter request be handled in a timely manner. Will you Pls. make sure that whoever winds up handling this giver me a call So we can coordinate ? (ext-6-7124) Thanks for your hege! Beth Shana- What 5) the status of this? VP S concerned also tomes. Pina 7060 OF THE SEAL XVI STATE AGRICULTURE MAILRC 7796 TRUST State of Tennessee NED McWHERTER GOVERNOR November 30, 1994 The Honorable Al Gore Vice President of the United States Washington, DC 20501 Dear Mr. Vice President: The citizens of the State of Tennessee appreciate your commitment in offering Federal assistance to those devastated by the recent tornadoes and flooding across the state. As per your commitment the state is formally requesting federal assistance for recovery from this disaster. Attached for your information are formal requests from me to the appropriate federal agency requesting this assistance. Additionally, I request the Department of Agriculture provide assistance to affected farmers. The citizens of Tennessee appreciate all you have done in the past and will continue to do in the future for the state. Sincerely, Governor NRM:kdb Attachments (2) OF THE XVI STATE OF GREAT AGRICUL LORE THE State of Tennessee 796 November 30, 1994 NED McWHERTER GOVERNOR Mr. Billy Max Paul Regional Administrator U.S. Small Business Administration 1375 Peachtree Street, N.W. Atlanta, Georgia 30307-8102 Dear Mr. Paul: Sunday, November 27, six tornadoes touched down across the state of Tennessee leaving death and destruction over eight Tennessee counties. On Sunday, November 27, disaster response personnel from the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) and other state agencies assessed the damage in all eight counties. Their damage survey identified over 380 homes/businesses that were destroyed/damaged by the severe weather resulting in over $48 million in damages. The damage survey in Shelby County indicates that more than 25 homes and/or businesses may have each sustained uninsured losses of forty (40) percent or more of their estimated fair replacement value or pre- disaster fair market value. These residents are in need of financial assistance which is not otherwise available on reasonable terms in the disaster area. Under the provisions of the Small Businesses Administration (SBA), 13 CFR Part 123, Subpart B, Physical disaster Loans, I request that SBA make their disaster loan program available to individuals, families and small businesses in Shelby County and all contiguous counties. Additionally, the state requests a waiver of the continguous requirement for the counties of Crockett, Davidson, Lauderdale, Stewart, Weakley and Williamson be granted and those counties be eligible for assistance, as most of these counties are poor, rural, and sparsely populated. These counties were affected by the same storm incident, but did not receive the minimum 25 homes/businesses with 40% uninsured losses. I have asked John D. white, Jr., Director of the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) 615- 741-0001 to assist my office and work with the Small Business Administration regarding any additional information that may be required. Thank you for your assistance. Sincerely, Ned McWherter Governor NRW:jwh cc: The Honorable Al Gore Vice President of the United States Richard J. Nash, Director Area II, Disaster Assistance THE XVI AGRICULTURE OMMERS State of Tennessee 7796 NED McWHERTER November 30, 1994 GOVERNOR The President The White House Washington, D.C. Thru: Mr. Kenneth D. Hutchison Regional Director FEMA Region IV 1371 Peachtree St., N.E. Atlanta, Georgia 30309 Dear Mr. President: Under the provisions of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act, Public Law 93-288, as amended by Public Law 100-707, I respectfully request that you declare a major disaster for both public and individual assistance for the State of Tennessee in the following counties: Crockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson counties. Other counties may be added as preliminary damage surveys are completed. On Sunday, November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed across the State of Tennessee. This weather front produced six tornadoes striking portions of west and middle Tennessee. Some areas of west and middle Tennessee received as much as four to five inches of rainfall which caused localized flooding in many communities. On November 28, 1994, the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) - State of Tennessee damage assessment teams began to survey the impact of the storm on Tennessee communities, their citizens and infrastructure. While many Tennessee counties were affected by the storm, the counties included in this request were impacted the most. A damage survey was completed in the five worst hit counties and indicated that families are eligible for assistance under the Individual and Family Grant Program (IFG); families qualify for Temporary Housing Assistance. Total damages to homes and businesses are estimated to exceed $50,000,000. The November storm created a direct and profound hardship for the families that received the brunt of the disaster. Surveys confirm that a number of the victims are low-income households with some victims being elderly. Interviews with potential IFG recipients revealed that some live on fixed income, and virtually none have financial resources to draw upon to begin to recover from the flooding. The housing problem is compounded by the fact that very few rental units are available for victims, a situation that is prevalent in all of the predominantly rural counties that were most affected. The true impact of the storm on public facilities in Tennessee can only be gauged in the context of the socio-economic conditions in this part of the state. Many of these counties are rural and economically depressed, the tax base continues to deteriorate. Furthermore, the impacted counties are faced with a fundamental problem: the cost to restore the infrastructure to pre-disaster condition would consume (or even exceed) existing funds that remain in the local budgets. In short, many of the counties have few Mr. President November 30, 1994 Page 2 resources to draw upon to return their county to pre-disaster condition. The problem is further compounded by the fact that many of these counties are geographically isolated. Additionally, all of these counties were declared as a result of this year's Ice Storm, Presidential Declaration number 1010. In essence, a clear and convincing case can be made that the November storm had a major impact on the Tennessee counties designated in this request. Simply put, the damages have disrupted the local economies, indeed the local way of life in these counties. Moreover, the State of Tennessee will be limited in our capability to provide direct assistance to the affected counties as this is the fourth major disaster to occur this year. As a result of the emergency situation, I directed the execution of the Tennessee Emergency Management Plan on November 27, 1994. Response and recovery operations are on-going. I also directed that all appropriate actions under State law be taken, and that agencies of State government provide all possible assistance within the boundaries of State law and resources. As indicated, I find the situation is beyond the capabilities of the state and the affected local governments to effectively alleviate the existing situation, and I am convinced that supplementary Federal assistance is necessary. Extensive State resources have been used to alleviate the conditions of the disaster to include: the Military Department, Department of Safety, Department of General Services, Department of Human Services, and the Department of Transportation. I specifically request assistance under the provisions of Section 411 of the Law to establish the Individual and Family Grant Program and Temporary Housing. The state also intends to request assistance from the Small Business Administration and the Department of Agriculture. I certify that pursuant to Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations, the State of Tennessee will be meeting our prorata share of the total expenditures and obligations for this major disaster. I have designated Mr. John D. White, Jr. as the State Coordinating Officer for this request. He will work with the Federal Emergency Management Agency in damage assessments, response, recovery, and may provide further information or justification on my behalf. Sincerely, Ned Mc Wherter Governor NRW:jwh cc: The Honorable Albert Gore Vice President of the United States

Page data

Page
63
Source index
0
Type
document
Media ID
6b4a82569b5cee7f
Size
unknown

Document data

ID
23907191
Core
doc
Type
document
DTO data
{
    "id": "23907191",
    "sourceUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/23907191",
    "contentType": "document",
    "title": "FEMA 1994 – Tennessee, South Carolina 1994 – Folder 1 [RE: Tennessee Storm Novermber 27, 1994]",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/23907191",
    "collections": [
        "Records of the Office of Cabinet Affairs (Clinton Administration)",
        "Kris Balderston's Files"
    ],
    "iiifBase": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/91/9071/23907191/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2013-0377-F/2013-0377-F-JPG/Box_003/42-t-2790549-20130377-F-003-006-2015/42_t_2790549_20130377_F_003_006_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "thumbnailUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/91/9071/23907191/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2013-0377-F/2013-0377-F-JPG/Box_003/42-t-2790549-20130377-F-003-006-2015/42_t_2790549_20130377_F_003_006_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "largeImageUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/91/9071/23907191/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2013-0377-F/2013-0377-F-JPG/Box_003/42-t-2790549-20130377-F-003-006-2015/42_t_2790549_20130377_F_003_006_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "imageCount": 63,
    "hasImages": true,
    "source": "import",
    "hasTranscription": false
}

Context sent to Scholar

Document identity
{
    "localId": "23907191",
    "label": "FEMA 1994 – Tennessee, South Carolina 1994 – Folder 1 [RE: Tennessee Storm Novermber 27, 1994]",
    "core": "doc",
    "dtoType": "document",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/23907191"
}
Document source metadata
{
    "id": "23907191",
    "sourceUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/23907191",
    "contentType": "document",
    "title": "FEMA 1994 – Tennessee, South Carolina 1994 – Folder 1 [RE: Tennessee Storm Novermber 27, 1994]",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/23907191",
    "collections": [
        "Records of the Office of Cabinet Affairs (Clinton Administration)",
        "Kris Balderston's Files"
    ],
    "iiifBase": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/91/9071/23907191/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2013-0377-F/2013-0377-F-JPG/Box_003/42-t-2790549-20130377-F-003-006-2015/42_t_2790549_20130377_F_003_006_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "thumbnailUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/91/9071/23907191/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2013-0377-F/2013-0377-F-JPG/Box_003/42-t-2790549-20130377-F-003-006-2015/42_t_2790549_20130377_F_003_006_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "largeImageUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/91/9071/23907191/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2013-0377-F/2013-0377-F-JPG/Box_003/42-t-2790549-20130377-F-003-006-2015/42_t_2790549_20130377_F_003_006_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "imageCount": 63,
    "hasImages": true,
    "source": "import",
    "hasTranscription": false
}
Document source extras
{
    "url": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/23907191",
    "naId": 23907191,
    "levelOfDescription": "fileUnit",
    "otherTitles": [
        "42-t-2790549-20130377-F-003-006-2015"
    ],
    "recordType": "description",
    "ocrSource": "nara-archive"
}
Page context
{
    "seq": 63,
    "pageIndex": 0,
    "type": "document",
    "url": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/91/9071/23907191/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2013-0377-F/2013-0377-F-PDF/Box_003/42-t-2790549-20130377-F-003-006-2015.pdf",
    "mediaId": "6b4a82569b5cee7f",
    "ocrText": "FOIA Number: 2013-0377-F\nFOIA\nMARKER\nThis is not a textual record. This is used as an\nadministrative marker by the William J. Clinton\nPresidential Library Staff.\nCollection/Record Group:\nClinton Presidential Records\nSubgroup/Office of Origin:\nCabinet Affairs\nSeries/Staff Member:\nSubject Files\nSubseries:\nOA/ID Number:\n6171\nFolderID:\nFolder Title:\nFEMA 1994 - Tennessee, South Carolina - Folder 1 [RE: Tennessee Storm November 27, 1994]\nStack:\nRow:\nSection:\nShelf:\nPosition:\nS\n25\n3\n7\n1\nDISASTER\nPRIORITY\nSUBJECT\nREQUEST FOR A MAJOR DISASTER DECLARATION\nSTATE OF TENNESSEE\nFEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY\nDATE\nDEC 13 1994\nFederal Emergency Management Agency\nACENT FEDERAL\nWashington, D.C. 20472\nMEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT\nTENNESSEE\nOn November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the\nState of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western\nand middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced\nlocalized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas.\nOn November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster\ndeclaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson,\nFayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson.\nFollowing this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and\nlocal government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted\nin the affected areas.\nINDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\nFour (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One\n(1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened\nby the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered.\nThe most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the\ndestruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes\nimpacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with\nminor damage, and 122 otherwise affected.\nPUBLIC ASSISTANCE\nThe major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also,\nthe State and local governments provided emergency protective\nmeasures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and\nproviding food for affected individuals. Other public impacts\ninclude damage to public roadways, water control facilities,\nutility systems and public buildings and equipment.\nDISCUSSION\nThe Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR\n206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate.\nGovernor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and\nPublic Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended.\nAlso, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small\nBusiness Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster\ndeclaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would\nautomatically be made eligible for SBA assistance.\nDamage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties.\nPreliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of\nthe damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41\npercent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured;\nhowever, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which\nwere destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families\naffected are considered to be low-income.\nAlthough the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered.\nAll affected individuals identified alternate living\naccommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to\nindividuals as needs are identified.\nNo health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There\nare no isolation cases in any of the affected counties.\nIn the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster\nHousing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average\nof $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible\nfor an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment\nAssistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the\nDepartment of Labor (DOL).\nIndividual Assistance program cost estimates are:\nTemporary Housing (100 percent Federal)\nHome Repairs\n$\n5,000\nRental Assistance/Transient\nAccommodations\n$ 16,000\nTOTAL\n$ 21,000\nIndividual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal)\nGrant Amount\n$ 10,000\nFederal Share\n$\n7,500\nTOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\n$ 28,500\nSBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the\nrequired number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In\nthe event of a major disaster declaration for Individual\nAssistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In\nthis case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an\naverage loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be\neligible for an average loan of about $52,687.\nSmall Business Administration\nDisaster Loan Program\n$ 329,634\nThe primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of\nfelled trees, building materials and personal property. Also\nincluded in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to\nremove totally destroyed public buildings.\nPublic road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and\ndamaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances\nof pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the\nuse of heavy equipment during the response phase.\nOne school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available\nto cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary\nclassrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required\nfor a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric\nutility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has\nbeen restored.\nThe State and local governments provided effective emergency\nprotective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic\ncontrol and providing food for affected individuals.\nPublic Assistance program cost estimates are:\nDebris Removal\n$ 439,990\nProtective Measures\n$\n222,965\nRoad Systems\n$\n6,800\nWater Control Facilities\n$\n3,000\nBuildings and Equipment\n$ 25,000\nUtilities\n$ 459,867\nOther (recreation, etc.)\n$\n-0-\nTotal Projected Federal Share\nPublic Assistance\n$1,157,622\nThere were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State\nduring FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is\ncurrently projected at $62.5 million.\nMuch of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by\ninsurance. State and local governments provided effective\nemergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local\ngovernments to meet individual assistance needs as they are\nidentified. No health and safety risks associated with this event\nhave been identified.\nCONCLUSIONS\nThe situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the\nState and local governments.\nThe situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration.\nRECOMMENDATION\nThat the Governor's request be denied.\nP.Will\nJames L. Witt\nDirector\nDate: 12-13-94\nAttachments:\nTurndown Letter\nCongressional Representation\nState Map\nGovernor's Request\nENGRGENCE\nFederal Emergency Management Agency\nFEDERAL\nAGENCY\nWashington, D.C. 20472\nMEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT\nTENNESSEE\nOn November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the\nState of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western\nand middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced\nlocalized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas.\nOn November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster\ndeclaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson,\nFayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson.\nFollowing this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and\nlocal government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted\nin the affected areas.\nINDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\nFour (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One\n(1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened\nby the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered.\nThe most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the\ndestruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes\nimpacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with\nminor damage, and 122 otherwise affected.\nPUBLIC ASSISTANCE\nThe major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also,\nthe State and local governments provided emergency protective\nmeasures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and\nproviding food for affected individuals. Other public impacts\ninclude damage to public roadways, water control facilities,\nutility systems and public buildings and equipment.\nDISCUSSION\nThe Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR\n206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate.\nGovernor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and\nPublic Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended.\nAlso, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small\nBusiness Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster\ndeclaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would\nautomatically be made eligible for SBA assistance.\nDamage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties.\nPreliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of\nthe damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41\npercent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured;\nhowever, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which\nwere destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families\naffected are considered to be low-income.\nAlthough the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered.\nAll affected individuals identified alternate living\naccommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to\nindividuals as needs are identified.\nNo health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There\nare no isolation cases in any of the affected counties.\nIn the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster\nHousing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average\nof $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible\nfor an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment\nAssistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the\nDepartment of Labor (DOL).\nIndividual Assistance program cost estimates are:\nTemporary Housing (100 percent Federal)\nHome Repairs\n$\n5,000\nRental Assistance/Transient\nAccommodations\n$ 16,000\nTOTAL\n$ 21,000\nIndividual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal)\nGrant Amount\n$ 10,000\ni\nFederal Share\n$\n7,500\nTOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\n$ 28,500\nSBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the\nrequired number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In\nthe event of a major disaster declaration for Individual\nAssistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In\nthis case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an\naverage loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be\neligible for an average loan of about $52,687.\nSmall Business Administration\nDisaster Loan Program\n$ 329,634\nThe primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of\nfelled trees, building materials and personal property. Also\nincluded in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to\nremove totally destroyed public buildings.\nPublic road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and\ndamaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances\nof pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the\nuse of heavy equipment during the response phase.\nOne school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available\nto cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary\nclassrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required\nfor a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric\nutility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has\nbeen restored.\nThe State and local governments provided effective emergency\nprotective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic\ncontrol and providing food for affected individuals.\nPublic Assistance program cost estimates are:\nDebris Removal\n$ 439,990\nProtective Measures\n$ 222,965\nRoad Systems\n$\n6,800\nWater Control Facilities\n$\n3,000\nBuildings and Equipment\n$ 25,000\nUtilities\n$ 459,867\nOther (recreation, etc.)\n$\n-0-\nTotal Projected Federal Share\nPublic Assistance\n$1,157,622\nThere were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State\nduring FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is\ncurrently projected at $62.5 million:\nMuch of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by\ninsurance. State and local governments provided effective\nemergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local\ngovernments to meet individual assistance needs as they are\nidentified. No health and safety risks associated with this event\nhave been identified.\nCONCLUSIONS\nThe situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the\nState and local governments.\nThe situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration.\nRECOMMENDATION\nThat the Governor's request be denied.\nP.Will\nJames L. Witt\nDirector\nDate: 12-13-44\nAttachments:\nTurndown Letter\nCongressional Representation\nState Map\nGovernor's Request\nLETTER TO THE GOVERNOR\nMASSEMENT\nFederal Emergency Management Agency\nAGENCY\nWashington, D.C. 20472\nThe Honorable Ned McWherter\nGovernor of Tennessee\nState Capitol\nNashville, Tennessee 37243\nDear Governor McWherter:\nThis is in response to your November 30, 1994 request for a major\ndisaster declaration due to tornadoes, severe weather and flooding\nwhich impacted the State on November 27. Specifically, you\nrequested Individual Assistance and Public Assistance under PL-288,\nas amended, for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson,\nFayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson.\nOn December 3-4, a Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was jointly\nconducted in the affected counties by State and local officials,\nFEMA staff and representatives from the Small Business\nAdministration.\nThe most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the\ndestruction of and damage to private homes. However, PDA\ninformation indicates that most of these damages are covered by\ninsurance. All affected individuals have identified alternative\nliving arrangements and there appears to be no need for mass care\nshelters. The American Red Cross is working with local governments\nto address individual assistance needs as they are identified.\nThe main impact to the public sector was fallen debris. Virtually\nall damage to public road systems was due to debris damaging\nsidewalk pavement and curbing. However, the types of costs\nassociated with debris removal and road repair may be budgeted for\nand absorbed by the local governments with State assistance.\nAdditionally, although a public school building was damaged, it\nappears that insurance will cover almost all costs for restoration\nand temporary facilities during the restoration.\nEffective emergency protective measures were provided by State and\nlocal governments. No health and safety problems associated with\nthis event have been identified.\nBased upon a review of all available information, we have concluded\nthat the impact of this event is not of the severity and magnitude\nthat warrants a major disaster declaration. Recovery costs for\nthis event seem well within the combined capabilities of the State\nand local governments. For these reasons, I must inform you that\nyour request for a major disaster declaration is denied.\nThis denial may be appealed within 30 days after the date of this\nletter. The appeal request, along with additional information\njustifying the appeal, should be submitted to the President through\nKenneth D. Hutchison, Regional Director of FEMA Region IV, located\nat:\n1371 Peachtree Street, NE\nSuite 700\nAtlanta, Georgia 30309\nI regret that our decision could not be more positive. However, I\nam confident that the assistance provided by the State and local\ngovernments, and voluntary organizations along with the available\ninsurance, will help the residents of Tennessee to recover from\nthis event.\nSincerely,\nJames L. Witt\nDirector\n-\n7\nCongressional Representation\nCONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION\nThe Governor of Tennessee is:\nNed R. McWherter (D)\n0\nTennessee Senators are:\nJim Sasser (D)\nHarlan Mathews (D)\nRepresenting the affected areas:\nBob Clement (D)\n5th District\nBart Gordon (D)\n6th District\nDon Sundquist (R)\n7th District\nJohn Tanner (D)\n8th District\nHarold E. Ford (D)\n9th District\nFor further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500.\nCONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION\nThe Governor of Tennessee is:\nNed R. McWherter (D)\nTennessee Senators are:\nJim Sasser (D)\nHarlan Mathews (D)\nRepresenting the affected areas:\nBob Clement (D)\n5th District\nBart Gordon (D)\n6th District\nDon Sundquist (R)\n7th District\nJohn Tanner (D)\n8th District\nHarold E. Ford (D)\n9th District\nFor further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500.\nState Map\nSENIUM\nXXXXX\nDAGH\nwe\nASTEMS\nTUSDALIDSR\nMML00-0\nPUNATI\n-\nsure\nCOMETA\nNHON\n3113483\na\nTOWAO\naur\nCH\nCLAYTON\nsamph\na\nBENTED\nNORBLET\nNEW\n3000\nNUMBER\nMUSIC\nNO.:\nTOLLO\nMD\nnow\n(БЛЕГОО\nMHD'IS\nINSURED\n303483\nMALKER\n0813003\nNOT\nTHE\nLATER\nLOWND\nSETTIN\nXIMBITH\nB000\nNOLTY\n300M\nSHOULD\nMEDICINO\n9900\nPRILOING\nNOTED\n3460\nTENNIS\nWITHS\nMMM\nTEX\nHINDLE\nBLOWN\nNNTIO\nNODAM\nNOSITIAL\nNOVENTH\nPOLITION\nЭТОЛЕН\n3000\nFORMS\nBOGO\nMILRIER\nin\nNAMED:\nTMH\nand\nTEHRU\nLAFRATTE\nUNed\nLEEN\nSWB\nNETWEELS\nNITINESS\nPDBS\nNINN\nNONED\nNOW\nsenn\n*********\nNXECS\n20GMM\nSIGHTUS\nNDEMITY\nSSUND\n3000\n3000\nNEDEL\nGILMER\nMATOO\nCONLINGELL\nTEHREU\n-\nWALKER\nTPPPH\n*\nSENIO\nNNN\nTWO\nNONE\n0.06 30\nsheck\nNEW\nORTDOGR\nTERMS\nNOTE\na\nSNIOL\nAUD\nX\nand\n6-L\n130.00\nNOREN\n*****\nNOME\nNTXNT\nKIDELM\nNAGONH\nFRETTE\nJOHNS\nNOLTINGH\nshw\nDOWN\n-\n308M\n300W\nand\nWHAD\nCRUNDY\nISSUED\n308MON\nINCLOW\nNETS\n3100\nTHRUS\nNOLD\n0.0.00\nSMIT\nWHI\nATH\nPERRY\nand\n000MABH\n38-CONT\nNOB\nICENTINA\nNMM\nподлл\nA\nTEMOON\nNOCIDENT\nMONNED\nMADCH\nBUT\n1130000\nIN:00\nDEMITED\nGONA\nMOSEM-\n300\n300\nTOWER\nMODER\nTEHOJU\nXD\nHURREYS\nMUS\nNORELLER\nNUNB\nMEDICH\namount\nMOSTA\nNEW\nENERGY\nNETER\nHOND\nMINS\nMAHUELO\nNOLSNOH\nATTACH\nMATRUCA\nMPSHINGTON\nNOINT\nAUGH\nNTINE\n-\nNUMBAO\nLIC06\nYESTER\nX\nNOTED\n3400\nSECURITY\nNEDDER\nSHDMEH\nMENUS\nNOEN-DI\nCLRIBORNE\nHRNCOOK\nAUTO\n-\nREFELS\nSTATE OF TENNESSEE\nMAITTS\nNICH\nNUTH\nDECLAREN\nABOTEG\nMENDCH\nSEVEND\nMOUNTO\n30-NOW\nLICOS\n-\nNUENHR\nTEB\nATTENT\nAMERICA\nNGTM\n36481\nsceal\nMISSISSIM\nNETER\n0001\nOMTILLS\nXINDI\nNELISERO\nTMCMJ\nTOWNY\nNEUZON\nNGM9\n10013\nNEW\n3501\nTESTA\nNOAT\nLICOS\nNOTOR\nHEALTH\n30831\nDESTS\nVIVOV\nAUD\nLAUREL\nTERMS\nALEXANDER\nBUTLER\nINDUSTRIAL\nAM\n2681\nSENTER\nName\nè\nCBO\n9NDWH\n3:0d\nMITUAL\nLION\nALLO\nNOSCH\nNOO\nMINN\nMOSTOM\nMOSABUD\nand\n34d\nMEESTER\nNORTH\nGAOLS\nWHITE\nMEETOR\nNIEW\n-\nIn\nCHARLED\nTWO\nNONT\nNU-DOWN\nTILLS\nNEXA\nNDAH\nNUMBER\nMOSMITTED\nAction\nSECTIONO\n34066\nJFCKSON\nONH\n1501\nWISHBONGH\nNUMM\nTENDS\nMEMBI\nXIXX\nNED'\nNOEN-OP\nNUMBER\nNOWN\nжно\nunre\n30GM\n-\nVANDERELACH\nBroken Lines = County Border\nSolid Lines = Congressional District\nA350d\nNXB\n3113AM\n0:03:00\nRES-DUNCH\nLOGS\nAdd\nXIRALII\n310+1\nNOLTHERN\nAMERICAN\n3681\nLIGITE\nHIM\nWEEKS\nASTEMS\nMarch\nNOGEMAN\nLEGEND:\nDATE\n3000H\nL005\nDIRTER\nSTON\n0402\nFLEMING\nstate\nNOBBED\nDid\nWHOD\n50th03\nTEXAS\nXXXXXXX\nSNOTES\nHEADH\nATTN:\n9004\n*****\nwe\n-\naug\nMLCOHO\nWITHOD\n30346\nMID/TRI\nCREEN\nDETEREHA\nTOWNO\nEH\namount\nMUMBER\n1903\nMEMTED\n3000\nNUMB\nFORTHER\nSEGNIT\nэмлеп\nMUSICM\nNEW\nTOWO\nFOOD\nA/D\nDOLLARS\nMYD'S\nNOUTH\nwith\nCNTH\nLAM\nXIINTH\n000ME\nNOTE\nSHOULD\n32404\nMEMOD\nCARE\nENGLISH\nPRILONG\nNOHW\nTRUSHRICHE\nMOTMS\nFDAMS\nXTH\nHOLY\nNOB\nNNTTD\nRETS\nNODAM\nNEEDER\nMUSKRI\n1\nMARCH\n2000\nFORMS\n2000\nPONIDTRC\nINSURER\nTMN\n331\nCLETTR\nand\nyou\nDEPT\nSNB\nPRNCL\n-\nWILLIAMO\nMEDICAL\nsignno\nNOTEST\nPDES\nNOW\nNIM\nSTATE\nSCHOOL\nTINTH\n300\nand\nNINI\nasses\nNOSEMA\nsanto\nORDER\nTENAMI\n350000\nNON\nNNW\n-\nMAKER\n3-053-0\nTM\nTPPH\nNOUCE\nSTEANIED\nNTEW\nREDUED\nALCORN\n0.06 20\nSMIL\nAND\nX\n190.00\nNOW\nNOOBH\nTHIS\nNOREM\nNEDNES\n6-L\nNTXNT\nNOLTING\nsaw\n300mmn\nMILLIN\nNAEDWH\nSUSNE\n3004\n346M\nXIII\n-\nCRUNDY\nCHARK\nMONROE\na\nINLOW\nNETS\n33100\nTENDUS\nKCLCL\nCODER\n=\nSMIT\n206079\n38-XNB\nUSE\nCOOPABH\nAND\nAIREH\nBON\nNMM\nTEMOON\nNETICE\nтюдля\nare\n-\nKNIO\nMUSCH\nNOTICE\n-\n113000-0\nCOMETER\nSUM\nSC00\nТЕНОЛИ\nKPC\nR\nTOWN\nNOBRES\nMIJO\nINSURED\nNUMBER\nKON'T\nMONOR\nassured\nNOTER\nNOSICE\n300\nHAMELEN\nTOSACH\nLITTRUCA\nGARDER\nHIMB\nCHERTHRY\nWILLINGHAM\nNOLSTOH\nATTLEM\na\nNOINT\nANCH\nNINO\nNOREMO\nSERVICES\nNOBO\nTHE\nTEBACO\nLIC06\nTHERE\nMOEN-CX\nSNDPEN\nCLAIMERNE\nACCOUNT\nSTATE OF TENNESSEE\nMATTER\n1304\nAVD\nm.\nNXM\nRETURNS\nNOTH\nUSA\nAMOTHO\nDELIVERY\nMUCH\nLICOS\ny\nMOUNTO\nMORE\nSEVEND\nTER\nNOTE\nMEMBER\nATEMY\n3481\nSCELL\nWALAM,\nXINX\nNEDOT\n000L\nOMERIC\nNEISRHO\nTHEMI\nTERMS\nNO.COM\nKAMP\n3521\nTREM\nKREEN\nNOAT\nLICOS\nREPORT\nDESTS\nMMM\nA/D\nLAUREL\nTHERE\nSINICT\nMEMORE\nShine\n1234\n3634\nDEBTH\nDESCRIPTION\n*******\n2201\nAERO\nMILLS\n2\n3:0d\nMEMITES\nLICKI\nSNOWH\nINVOICE\nPROGRELL\nATEND\nNOSCLF\nNOT\nMOSAMO\nNON-HO'\n3D&d\nGHO\nMIN'T\nNORM\nWEBSTER\nNORM\nFLOYD\nMUST\nLARE\nUSA\nCHARLO\nTHE\nTELLS\nNINI\nNOSTOM\nNDMH\nand\n3501\nSEEND\nNUMBER\nNEW\n300\nLACHDIGTON\nJFCXSON\nMISSIGH\nLICENSE\nNUMBER\nTENO:\nMEMBI\nXIXNH\nNOEN-O*\nNEW\nжего\nunre\n3400\n30GH\nVANCERELROH\n201349\nPOSEY\nNETWORK\nBroken Lines = County Border\nSolid Lines = Congressional District\nAMERICANCH\nKINGS\nAMERICA\nXEALT\n3009\nWMLTON\nAMM\nINTERNET\n-\nLIGHTS\nHMH\nAS EMS\n-\nROWAN\nCRIFIED\nLEGEND:\nLEGOS\nBOX\nNORBLE\nSTHON\nMONROE\nDRIER\nBANK\nFLETING\na\nNORTH\nHHITD\n34d\nTERO\nSOLICE\nGOVERNOR'S REQUEST\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL:1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94 11:01 No 001 P.02\nState of Tennessee\nAM11:03\nMED MOWHERTER\nNovember 30, 1994\nOUTERMOR\nThe President\nThe White House\nWashington, D.C.\nThru: Mr. Kenneth D. Hutchison\nRegional Director\nFEMA Region IV\n1371 Peachtree St., N.E.\nAtlanta, Georgia 30309\nDear Mr. President:\nUnder the provisions of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act,\nPublic Law 93-288, as amended by Public Law 100-707, I respectfully request that you doclare a major\ndisaster for both public and individual assistance for the State of Tennessee in the following counties:\nCrockett, Davidson, Fayotte, Laudordale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson counties. Other\ncounties may be added as preliminary damage survoys are completed\nOn Sunday, November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed across the State of Tennessee.\nThis weather front produced six tornadoes striking portions of west and middle Tennessee. Some areas of\nwest and middle Tennessee received as much as four to five inches of rainfall which caused localized\nflooding in many communities.\nOn November 28, 1994, the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) . State of\nTennessee damage assessment teams began to survey the impact of the storm on Temessee communities,\ntheir citizens and infrastructure. While many Tennessee counties were affected by the storm, the connties\nincluded in this request were impacted the most A damage survey was completed in the five work hit\ncounties and indicated that families are cligible for assistance under the Individual and Family Grant\nProgram (IPO); families qualify for Temporary Housing Assistance. Total damages to homes and\nbusinesses are estimated to exceed $50,000,000.\nThe November storm created a direct and profound hardship for the families that received the brunt\nof the disaster. Surveys confirm that a number of the victims are low-income households with some\nvictims being olderly. Interviews with potential IFG recipients revealed that some live 8 fixed income, and\nvirtually none have funancial resources to draw upon to begin to recover from the flooding. The housing\nproblem is compounded by the fact that very few rental units are available for victims, a situation that is\nprevalent in all of the predominantly rural countica that were most affected.\nThe true impact of the storm on public facilities in Tonnessee can only be gauged in the context of\nthe socio-oconomic conditions in this part of the state. Many of these counties are rural and economically\ndepressed, the tax base continues to deteriorate. Furthermore, the impacted counties are faced with a\nfundamental problem: the cost to restore the infrastructure to pre-disarter condition would consume (or\neven exceed) existing funds that remain to the local budgets. la short, many of the connties have few\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL:1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94\n11:01 No 001 P.03\nMr. President\nNovember 30, 1994\nPage 2\nresources to draw upon to return their county to pre-disaster condition. The problem is further\ncompounded by the fact that many of these counties are goographically isolated. Additionally, all of these\ncounties were doclared as a result of this year's Ice Storm, Presidential Declaration number 1010.\nIn essence, a clear and convincing case can be made that the November storm had a major impact\non the Tennessee counties designated in this request. Simply put, the damages have disrupted the local\neconomics, indeed the local way of life in these counties. Moreover, the State of Tennessee will be limited\nin our capability to provide direct assistance to the affected counties as this is the fourth major disaster to\noccur this year.\nAs a result of the emergency situation, I directed the execution of the Tennessee Emergency\nManagement Plan on November 27, 1994. Response and recovery operations are on-going. I also directed\nthat all appropriate actions under State law be taken, and that agencies of State government provide all\npossible assistance within the boundaries of State law and resources.\nAs indicated, 1 find the situation is beyond the capabilities of the state and the affected local\ngovernments to effectively alloviate the existing situation, and I am convinced that supplementary Federal\nassistance is necessary.\nExtensive State resources have been used to alleviate the conditions of the disaster to include: the\nMilitary Department, Department of Safety, Department of General Services, Department of Human\nServices, and the Department of Transportation.\n1 specifically request assistance under the provisions of Section 411 of the Law to establish the\nIndividual and Family Grant Program and Temporary Housing. The state also intends to request assistance\nfrom the Small Business Administration and the Department of Agriculture.\nI certify that pursuant to Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations, the State of\nTennessoo will be meeting our prorata share of the total expenditures and obligations for this major\ndisaster.\nI have designated Ms. John D. White, Jt. as the State Coordinating Officer for this request. He\nwill work with the Federal Emergency Management Agency in damage assessments, response, recovery,\nand may provide further information or justification on my behalf\nSincerely,\nGovernor\nNRWjwh\noc:\nThe Honorable Albert Gore\nVice President of the United States\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL :1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94 11:02 No 001 P.04\nState of Tennessee\nNovember 30, 1994\nNED ANWHESTER\nGOVERNOR\nMr. Billy Max Paul\nRegional Administrator\nU.S. Small Business Administration\n1375 Peachtroe Street, N.W.\nAtlanta, Georgia 30307-8102\nDear Mr. Paul:\nSunday, November 27, xix tornadoes touched down across the stato of Tennessee leaving death and\ndestruction over eight Tennossee counties.\nOn Sunday, November 27, disaster response personnel from the Tennossee Emergency Management\nAgency (TEMA) and other state agencies assessed the damage in all cight counties. Their damage survey\nidentified over 380 homes/businesses that were destroyed/damaged by the severe weather resulting in over\n$48 million in damages.\nThe damage survey in Shelby County indicates that more than 25 homes and/or businesses may have each\nsustained uninsured losses of forty (40) percent or more of their estimated fair replacement value or pro-\ndisaster fair market value. These residents are in need of financial assistance which is not otherwise\navailable 8 reasonable terms in the disaster area.\nUnder the provisions of the Small Businesses Administration (SBA), 13 CFR Part 123, Subpart B,\nPhysical disaster Loans, 1 request that SBA make their disaster loan program available to individuals,\nfamilies and small businesses in Shelby County and all contiguous counties. Additionally, the state\nrequests a waiver of the continguous requirement for the counties of Crockett, Davidson, Lauderdale,\nStowart, Weakley and Williamson be granted and those counties bc eligible for assistance, as most of these\ncountics are poor, rural, and sparacly populated These counties were affected by the same storm incident,\nbut did not receive the minimum 25 homes/butinesses with 40% uninsured losses.\nI have asked John D. white, Jr., Director of the Twonessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) 615-\n741-0001 to assist my office and work with the Small Business Administration regarding any additional\ninformation that may be required. Thank you for your assistance.\nSincerely,\nNed McWhefter\nGovernor\nNRWjwh\noc; The Honorable AI Gore\nVice President of the United States\nRichard 3. Nash, Director\nArea II. Disaster Assistance\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL:1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94 11:02 No.001 P.05\nSTATE accident\nState of Tennessee\nNED MeWHERATER\nGOVERNOR\nNovember 30, 1994\nThe Honorable AI Gore\nVice President\nof the United States\nWashington, DC 20501\nDear Mr. Vice President:\nThe citizens of the State of Tennessee appreciate your commitment in offering Federal\nassistance to those devastated by the recent tornadoes and flooding across the state. As\nper your commitment the state is formally requesting federal assistance for recovery from\nthis disaster. Attached for your information are formal requests from me to the\nappropriate federal agency requesting this assistance. Additionally, I request the\nDepartment of Agriculture provide assistance to affected farmers.\nThe citizens of Tennessee appreciate all you have done in the past and will continue to do\nin the future for the state.\nSincerely,\nGovernor\nNRM:kdb\nAttachments (2)\nTOTAL r.05\nPREPARENCY\nFederal Emergency Management Agency\nFEDERAL\nAGENCY\nWashington, D.C. 20472\nMEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT\nTENNESSEE\nOn November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the\nState of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western\nand middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced\nlocalized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas.\nOn November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster\ndeclaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson,\nFayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson.\nFollowing this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and\nlocal government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted\nin the affected areas.\nINDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\nFour (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One\n(1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened\nby the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered.\nThe most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the\ndestruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes\nimpacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with\nminor damage, and 122 otherwise affected.\nPUBLIC ASSISTANCE\nThe major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also,\nthe State and local governments provided emergency protective\nmeasures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and\nproviding food for affected individuals. Other public impacts\ninclude damage to public roadways, water control facilities,\nutility systems and public buildings and equipment.\nDISCUSSION\nThe Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR\n206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate.\nGovernor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and\nPublic Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended.\nAlso, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small\nBusiness Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster\ndeclaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would\nautomatically be made eligible for SBA assistance.\nDamage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties.\nPreliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of\nthe damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41\npercent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured;\nhowever, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which\nwere destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families\naffected are considered to be low-income.\nAlthough the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered.\nAll affected individuals identified alternate living\naccommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to\nindividuals as needs are identified.\nNo health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There\nare no isolation cases in any of the affected counties.\nIn the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster\nHousing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average\nof $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible\nfor an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment\nAssistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the\nDepartment of Labor (DOL).\nIndividual Assistance program cost estimates are:\nTemporary Housing (100 percent Federal)\nHome Repairs\n$\n5,000\nRental Assistance/Transient\nAccommodations\n$ 16,000\nTOTAL\n$ 21,000\nIndividual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal)\nGrant Amount\n$ 10,000\nFederal Share\n$ & 7,500\nTOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\n$ 28,500\nSBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the\nrequired number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In\nthe event of a major disaster declaration for Individual\nAssistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In\nthis case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an\naverage loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be\neligible for an average loan of about $52,687.\nSmall Business Administration\nDisaster Loan Program\n$ 329,634\nThe primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of\nfelled trees, building materials and personal property. Also\nincluded in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to\nremove totally destroyed public buildings.\nPublic road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and\ndamaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances\nof pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the\nuse of heavy equipment during the response phase.\nOne school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available\nto cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary\nclassrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required\nfor a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric\nutility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has\nbeen restored.\nThe State and local governments provided effective emergency\nprotective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic\ncontrol and providing food for affected individuals.\nPublic Assistance program cost estimates are:\nDebris Removal\n$\n439,990\nProtective Measures\n$\n222,965\nRoad Systems\n$\n6,800\nWater Control Facilities\n$\n3,000\nBuildings and Equipment\n$ 25,000\nUtilities\n$ 459,867\nOther (recreation, etc.)\n$\n-0-\nTotal Projected Federal Share\nPublic Assistance\n$1,157,622\nThere were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State\nduring FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is\ncurrently projected at $62.5 million. 4\nMuch of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by\ninsurance. State and local governments provided effective\nemergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local\ngovernments to meet individual assistance needs as they are\nidentified. No health and safety risks associated with this event\nhave been identified.\nCONCLUSIONS\nThe situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the\nState and local governments.\nThe situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration.\nRECOMMENDATION\nThat the Governor's request be denied.\nJames L. Witt F.Will\nDirector\nDate: 12-13-44\nAttachments:\nTurndown Letter\nCongressional Representation\nState Map\nGovernor's Request\nEXERGENCY\nMANAGEMENT\nFederal Emergency Management Agency\nTREATMENT AGENCY\nWashington, D.C. 20472\nThe Honorable Ned McWherter\nGovernor of Tennessee\nState Capitol\nNashville, Tennessee 37243\nDear Governor McWherter:\nThis is in response to your November 30, 1994 request for a major\ndisaster declaration due to tornadoes, severe weather and flooding\nwhich impacted the State on November 27. Specifically, you\nrequested Individual Assistance and Public Assistance under PL-288,\nas amended, for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson,\nFayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson.\nOn December 3-4, a Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was jointly\nconducted in the affected counties by State and local officials,\nFEMA staff and representatives from the Small Business\nAdministration.\nThe most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the\ndestruction of and damage to private homes. However, PDA\ninformation indicates that most of these damages are covered by\ninsurance. All affected individuals have identified alternative\nliving arrangements and there appears to be no need for mass care\nshelters. The American Red Cross is working with local governments\nto address individual assistance needs as they are identified.\nThe main impact to the public sector was fallen debris. Virtually\nall damage to public road systems was due to debris damaging\nsidewalk pavement and curbing. However, the types of costs\nassociated with debris removal and road repair may be budgeted for\nand absorbed by the local governments with State assistance.\nAdditionally, although a public school building was damaged, it\nappears that insurance will cover almost all costs for restoration\nand temporary facilities during the restoration.\nEffective emergency protective measures were provided by State and\nlocal governments. No health and safety problems associated with\nthis event have been identified.\nBased upon a review of all available information, we have concluded\nthat the impact of this event is not of the severity and magnitude\nthat warrants a major disaster declaration. Recovery costs for\nthis event seem well within the combined capabilities of the State\nand local governments. For these reasons, I must inform you that\nyour request for a major disaster declaration is denied.\nThis denial may be appealed within 30 days after the date of this\nletter. The appeal request, along with additional information\njustifying the appeal, should be submitted to the President through\nKenneth D. Hutchison, Regional Director of FEMA Region IV, located\nat:\n1371 Peachtree Street, NE\nSuite 700\nAtlanta, Georgia 30309\nI regret that our decision could not be more positive. However, I\nam confident that the assistance provided by the State and local\ngovernments, and voluntary organizations along with the available\ninsurance, will help the residents of Tennessee to recover from\nthis event.\nSincerely,\nJames L. Witt\nDirector\n&\nCONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION\nThe Governor of Tennessee is:\nNed R. McWherter (D)\nTennessee Senators are:\nJim Sasser (D)\nHarlan Mathews (D)\nRepresenting the affected areas:\nBob Clement (D)\n5th District\nBart Gordon (D)\n6th District\nDon Sundquist (R)\n7th District\nJohn Tanner (D)\n8th District\nHarold E. Ford (D)\n9th District\nFor further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500.\nINCLUDE\nDAGH\nauro\nAVD\nATCHE\nTUSDALIDER\nPUNER\nWHEN\nML03-0\nMEMO\nNOTICE\n311348\n-\nUNITED\nTOTAL\nREMOVER\n100\nMEMTED\n3000\nNO./CN\nwithin\n3019\nMUSICM\nTOLLO\nFOOCALE\nwe\n(9/13/19)\nST.O.AR\nMATCH\nterms\nCATER\nTHE\n-\nLONGO\nXENTIN\n33000\nNOLTH\nSOWNCH\nPRICED\nWORLD\n3000\n3WD\nINSURE\nWOTLE\nFOME\nXTM\nHIGH\nNINE\nNATTO\n2009\nNODAM\nNOTES\nNUSKIN\nFORSYTH\nЭТОЛЗВЫ\n2000\nFORMS\n2000\nPONTOTIC\n-\nTMM\n331\nNAMED\n1234\nSNB\nare\nTERMS\nLND\nINSURED\nCHRICOOR\nMEDICAL\nPDENS\nsigning\nNOOD\nNOW\nNEW\nANDERSON\nSIGNATURE\nNPENTI\nIM-SIGNM\nSUM\nsaw\nMIN\nasses\nNORDER\nMOSEM-1\nASTICO\nORDER\nTMHMI\n35000\nNINT\nNNW\n-\n#5\nDPPAH\nSOUGH\nSTENDED\nsecurity\nNEW\n-\nNOTE\n0.008 20\n-\nSMOL\nCLAY\nX\n190.00\nXDJ\nNOOD\nTOTAL\nNONEH\n6-L\nLAURENCE\nNAMED\nSUSNE\nTHE\nTRANSYLVING\nsho\nNOTOR\n3004\nSWEM\nXII\nMHAD\nBELLFICHIE\nCRUNDY\n-\nINSURE\nNumb\n3300\nTRINK\nMOLIC\n00:00\nSMIT\n38-0000\nUSHI\nANN\n000MABH\nAIREM\nBON\nINSURA\nNMM\nTEMAIN\nNORICE\nnognn\nsure\n-\nMONNO\nMUSCIN\nSEOU\nNOSERM\nQUATE\nADNA\n300\na\nTEHOJM\nXX\n6710 30\nM\nTREED\nMORRIES\nMUC\nNEW\nNUNE\nIIINI\nMEDICH\nusers\nNOTER\nENGERD\nHRBLEN\nNEW\nWRTRUCR\nname\nDERTH\nNOLSTOH\nATTMEN\nORDER\nMODEL\nAUGH\nNTINO\nLEDS\nSERVICE\nNIREMO\nKISCH\nNOTED\nTHE\nTERMS\nMEMOr\nEMDPEN\nVOLUE\nхорфен\nCLAREORNE\nAZIZUNU\nSTATE OF TENNESSEE\nMATTER\n11304\nAND\nThe\nNXM\nRETURNS\nNITH\nAMOTED\nMAICH\nNOUNED:\nMORE\nSMID\nLICOS\ny\nTER\nASSIGN\nNOTE\nKIMB\n368M\n6CDML\nD-MISSION\nXDI\nNetth\n000\nэтытно,\nMILISRIO\nTIMEMI\nTERM\nNO.\nIGAMI\nTESTW\nKREP\n3981\nNOAT\nLIC08\nwas\nDENTH\n-\nAND\nBON\nTENTRO\nSIGNATURE\nNORMO-03\nBrune\nASLEM\n3634\nDEBTH\nDEBCTITE\n2291\nè\nCONTROL\nLIDA\nGRO\nSNOWH\nPOPE\nOFFE GRATER\nATTO\nNISCH\nNOT\nItd\nNOSABLE\nNEND'\nand\nNINN\nNOSITAL\nMEBSTER\nNOWH\nGAOTH\nWHICH\nMATCH\nNEW\nsun\nan\nCHARLO\nshow\nMEMBER\nTHE\nNOM)\nNDAH\n0004\nMDI\nKLMTLE\n300\nMOBILE\nNOSXH\nNEDT\nNRM\nMORU\nTERMS\nTERM\nXXXN\nNOEM-OP\nMOUTH\nжно\nunre\n3008\nMERDE\nLINES\n0.0.000\nVANDERSLAGEN\nBroken Lines = County Border\nSolid Lines = Congressional District\n20254\nPOSEY\nASSOUNT\nTIME\nAND\nLATER'S\n3009\nNOUTHW\nAREN\n3461\nLICITS\nHIME\nNYD\nNOBICE\nNORMAH\nCRAFURD\nLEGEND:\nLIDOS\nROD\n-\nSTHON\n30804\nDIRTER\nDATE\nFLB19C\nand\nMHID\n34d\nTERO\nSOLICE\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL:1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94\n11:01 No 001 P.02\nState of Tennessee\nNovember 30, 03\nMED MAWHEETER\nOUTERSHOR\nThe President\nThe White House\nWashington, D.C.\nThru: Mr. Kenneth D. Hutchison\nRegional Director\nFEMA Region IV\n1371 Peachtree St., N.E.\nAtlanta, Georgia 30309\nDear Mr. President:\nUnder the provisions of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act,\nPublic Law 93-288, as amended by Public Law 100-707, 1 respectfully request that you doclare & major\ndisaster for both public and individual assistance for the State of Tennossee in the following countion:\nCrockott, Davidson, Fayotte, Laudordale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakity, and Williamson counties. Other\ncounties may be added as preliminary damage survoys are completed.\nOn Sunday, November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed across the State of Tennessee.\nThis weather front produced six tornadoes striking portions of west and middle Tennessee. Some areas of\nwest and middle Tennessee received as much as four to five inches of rainfull which caused localized\nflooding in many communities.\nOn November 28, 1994, the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) - State of\nTennessee damage assessment teams began to survey the impact of the storm on Tennessee communities,\ntheir citizens and infrastructure. While many Tennessee counties were affected by the storm, the counties\nincluded in this request were impacted the most. A damage survey was completed in the five worst bit\ncounties and indicated that families are cligible for assistance under the Individual and Family Grant\nProgram (IPO); families qualify for Temporary Housing Assistance. Total damages to homes and\nbusineases are estimated to exceed $50,000,000.\nThe November storm created a direct and profound hardship for the families that received the brunt\nof the disaster. Surveys confirm that a number of the victims are low-lacorne households with some\nvictims being olderly. Interviews with potential IFG recipients revealed that some live on fixed income, and\nvirtually none have funancial resources to draw upon to begin to recover from the flooding. The housing\nproblem is compounded by the fact that very few rental units are available for victims, n situation that is\nprevalent in all of the predominantly rural countics that were most affected.\nThe true impact of the storm on public facilities in Tennessee can only be gauged in the context of\n4\nthe socio-economic conditions in this part of the state. Many of these counties are rural and economically\ndepressed, the tax base continues to deteriorate. Furthermore, the impacted counties are faced with a\nfundamental problem: the cost to restore the infrastructure to pre-disarter condition would consume (or\neven exceed) existing funds that remain in the local budgets. la short, many of the connties have few\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL:1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94\n11:01 No 001 P.03\nMr. President\nNovember 30, 1994\nPage 2\ndraw to return their county to pre-diraster condition. The problem all is of further these\nresources to by the fact upon that many of these counties are goographically isolated. Additionally, number 1010.\ncompounded counties were doclared as a result of this year's Ice Storm. Presidential Declaration\na clear and convincing case can be made that the November storm had a major the impact local\nin essence, counties designated in this request. Simply put, the damages have disrupted will be limited\non the Tennessee indeed the local way of life in these countion. Moreover, the State of Tennessee disaster to\neconomics, in our capability to provide direct assistance to the affected counties as this is the fourth major\noccur this year.\nresult of the emergency situation, 1 directed the execution of the Tomessees Emergency directed\nManagement that all appropriate actions under State law be taken, and that agencies of State government\nAs a Plan on November 27, 1994. Response and recovery operations are on-going. 1 also provide all\npossible assistance within the boundaries of State law and resources.\nindicated, I find the situation is beyond the capabilities of the state and the affected Federal local\ngovernments As to effectively alloviate the existing situation, and I am convinced that supplementary\nassistance is necessary.\nExtensive State resources have been used to alleviate the conditions of the disaster to include: Human the\nMilitary Department, Department of Safety, Department of General Services, Department of\nServices, and the Department of Transportation.\n1 specifically request assistance under the provisions of Section 411 of the Law to establish assistance the\nIndividual and Family Grant Program and Temporary Housing. The state also intends to request\nfrom the Small Business Administration and the Department of Agriculture.\nTennesson will be meeting our proruta share of the total expenditures and obligations for this major\nI certify that pursuant to Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations, the State of\ndisasaer.\nI have designated Ms. John D. White, Jt. as the State Coordinating Officer for this request. He\nwill work with the Federal Emergency Management Agency in damage assessments, response, recovery,\nand may provide furthor information or justification on my behalf\nSincerely,\nGovernor\nNRWjwh\noc:\nThe Honorable Albert Gore\nVice President of the United States\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL 1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94 11:02 No 001 P.04\nState of Tennessee\nNovember 30, 1994\nMED MAWNESTER\nGOVERNOR\nMr. Billy Max Paul\nRegional Administrator\nU.S. Small Business Administration\n1375 Peachtroe Street, N.W.\nAtlanta, Georgia 30307-8102\nDear Mr. Paul:\nSunday, November 27, xix tornadoes touched down across the stato of Tennossee leaving death and\ndestruction over eight Tennessee counties.\nOn Sunday, November 27, disaster response personnel from the Tennossee Emergency Management\nAgency (TEMA) and other state agencies assessed the damage in all cight counties. Their damage survey\nidentified over 380 bomes/businesses that were destroyed/damaged by the severe weather resulting in over\n$48 million in damages.\nThe damage survey in Shelby County indicates that more than 25 homes and/or businesses may have each\naustained uninsured losses of forty (40) percent or more of their estimated fair replacement value or pro-\ndisaster fair market value. These residents are in need of financial assistance which is not otherwise\navailable B reasonable terms in the disaster was\nUnder the provisions of the Small Businesses Administration (SBA), 13 CFR Part 123, Subport B,\nPhysical disaster Loans, I request that SBA make their disaster loan program available to individuals,\nfamilies and small businesses in Shelby County and all contiguous counties. Additionally, the state\nrequests a waiver of the continguous requirement for the counties of Crockett, Davidson, Lauderdale,\nStowart, Weakley and Williamson be granted and those counties be eligible for assistance, as most of these\ncountics are poor, rural, and sparsely populated. These counties were affected by the same storm incident,\nbut did not receive the minimure 25 homes/businesses with 40% uninsured losses.\nI have asked John D. white, Jr., Director of the Twessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) 615-\n741-0001 to assist my office and work with the Small Business Administration regarding any additional\ninformation that may be required. Thank you for your assistance.\nSincerely,\nNed McWhetter\nGovernor\nNRWjwh\noc: The Honorable Al Gore\nVice President of the United States\nRichard 3. Nash, Director\nArea II, Disaster Assistance\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL:1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94 11:02 No.001 P.05\nYOU\nSTATE\nSTATES\nState of Tennessee\nNED NewaxAtER\nCOVERNOR\nNovember 30, 1994\nThe Honorable AI Gore\nVice President\nof the United States\nWashington, DC 20501\nDear Mr. Vice President:\nThe citizens of the State of Tennessee appreciate your commitment in offering Federal\nassistance to those devastated by the recent tornadoes and flooding across the state. As\nper your commitment the state is formally requesting federal assistance for recovery from\nthis disaster. Attached for your information are formal requests from me to the\nappropriate federal agency requesting this assistance. Additionally, I request the\nDepartment of Agriculture provide assistance to affected farmers.\nThe citizens of Tennessee appreciate all you have done in the past and will continue to do\nin the future for the state.\nSincerely,\nGovernor\nNRM:kdb\n-\nAttachments (2)\nTOTAL r.05\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nDecember 13. 1994\nMEMORANDUM FOR DISTRIBUTION\nFROM:\nSTEPHEN B. SILVERMAN\nSpecial Assistant to the President\nand Deputy Secretary to the Cabinet\nSUBJECT:\nRECOMMENDATION FROM THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY\nMANAGEMENT AGENCY (FEMA) TO DENY THE REQUEST\nFOR A MAJOR DISASTER DECLARATION IN THE\nSTATE OF TENNESSEE\nAttached for your comment is a recommendation from the Federal Emergency Management\nAgency (FEMA) to deny the request for a major disaster declaration for the State of\nTennessee. On November 27 a strong weather front passed through the state causing at least\nsix tornadoes to touch down. Many communities also experienced localized flooding. The\nFederal Emergency Management Agency has concluded that the situation does not warrant a\nmajor disaster declaration.\nPlease forward any comments to our office. If there are no objections. the request from the\nState of Tennessee will be denied.\nAttachment\nFederal Emergency Management Agency\nFREE AGENCY\nWashington, D.C. 20472\nMEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT\nTENNESSEE\nOn November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the\nState of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western\nand middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced\nlocalized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas.\nOn November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster\ndeclaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson,\nFayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson.\nFollowing this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and\nlocal government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted\nin the affected areas.\nINDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\nFour (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One\n(1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened\nby the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered.\nThe most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the\ndestruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes\nimpacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with\nminor damage, and 122 otherwise affected.\nPUBLIC ASSISTANCE\nThe major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also,\nthe State and local governments provided emergency protective\nmeasures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and\nproviding food for affected individuals. Other public impacts\ninclude damage to public roadways, water control facilities,\nutility systems and public buildings and equipment.\nDISCUSSION\nThe Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR\n206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate.\nGovernor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and\nPublic Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended.\nAlso, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small\nBusiness Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster\ndeclaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would\nautomatically be made eligible for SBA assistance.\nDamage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties.\nPreliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of\nthe damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41\npercent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured;\nhowever, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which\nwere destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families\naffected are considered to be low-income.\nAlthough the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered.\nAll affected individuals identified alternate living\naccommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to\nindividuals as needs are identified.\nNo health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There\nare no isolation cases in any of the affected counties.\nIn the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster\nHousing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average\nof $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible\nfor an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment\nAssistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the\nDepartment of Labor (DOL).\nIndividual Assistance program cost estimates are:\nTemporary Housing (100 percent Federal)\nHome Repairs\n$\n5,000\nRental Assistance/Transient\nAccommodations\n$ 16,000\nTOTAL\n$ 21,000\nIndividual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal)\nGrant Amount\n$ 10,000\nFederal Share\n$\n7,500\nTOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\n$ 28,500\nSBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the\nrequired number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In\nthe event of a major disaster declaration for Individual\nAssistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In\nthis case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an\naverage loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be\neligible for an average loan of about $52,687.\nSmall Business Administration\nDisaster Loan Program\n$ 329,634\nThe primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of\nfelled trees, building materials and personal property. Also\nincluded in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to\nremove totally destroyed public buildings.\nPublic road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and\ndamaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances\nof pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the\nuse of heavy equipment during the response phase.\nOne school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available\nto cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary\nclassrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required\nfor a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric\nutility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has\nbeen restored.\nThe State and local governments provided effective emergency\nprotective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic\ncontrol and providing food for affected individuals.\nPublic Assistance program cost estimates are:\nDebris Removal\n$ 439,990\nProtective Measures\n$ 222,965\nRoad Systems\n$\n6,800\nWater Control Facilities\n$\n3,000\nBuildings and Equipment\n$ 25,000\nUtilities\n$ 459,867\nOther (recreation, etc.)\n$\n-0-\nTotal Projected Federal Share\nPublic Assistance\n$1,157,622\nThere were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State\nduring FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is\ncurrently projected at $62.5 million.\nMuch of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by\ninsurance. State and local governments provided effective\nemergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local\ngovernments to meet individual assistance needs as they are\nidentified. No health and safety risks associated with this event\nhave been identified.\n04\nrestr\nCONCLUSIONS\nThe situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the\nState and local governments.\nThe situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration.\nRECOMMENDATION\nThat the Governor's request be denied.\nSigned\nJames L. Witt\nDirector\nDate: DEC 13 1994\nAttachments:\nTurndown Letter\nCongressional Representation\nState Map\nGovernor's Request\nCONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION\nThe Governor of Tennessee is:\nNed R. McWherter (D)\nTennessee Senators are:\nJim Sasser (D)\nHarlan Mathews (D)\nRepresenting the affected areas:\nBob Clement (D)\n5th District\nBart Gordon (D)\n6th District\nDon Sundquist (R)\n7th District\nJohn Tanner (D)\n8th District\nHarold E. Ford (D)\n9th District\nFor further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500.\nXXXXXXX\nSHICTERS\nOMGH\nwe\nATEMS\nMUN\nwas\nTUSCALIDSA\nMIND\nMM-03-0\n311343\nMEDITAL\nAREM\nTOWN\nMEMTED\nINSURED\n3000\nNOVEN\nSENT\n30181\nA\nMEMBI\nTOWO\nMUSICH\nnote\nanonoo\nST.0.AR\nA/D\n24\nURTEN\nterren\nXEXICH\nCONEE\nLATAR\nKINNO\nNOL\nSHOULD\n32NM\n3WD\nPRICED\nMEMORO\nENTER\nimprio\nWITHS\nFORMS\nXTM\nNUB\nCULLIAN.\nRET'S\nNEW\nNORMA\n1\nFORSYTH\n2000\nPORTS\n2000\nPONTOTOC\nTM\n331\nHART\nERNS\nand\nNAMED:\n-\nTERMS\nONE\nMILLING\n99\nPDB6\nAMERICAN\nNON\nNin\na\nNAME\nzignn\nSINGH\n3.70\nNONT\nasses\nTHE\nNOSCHE\n50000\nNOSEBLI\nMIND\nNNM\nand\n305341\nTMHAM\nNONT\n-\nSTENDED\nTPPAH\nsouce\nsecurity\nNTM\n-\nSND\nCANDOOR\nNOTE\n0.06 20\nNO\n390.00\nNDJ\nMOOTH\nare\nNOMEN\nX\nMEDDLES\nNEXNT\n6-L\nTRICKLYNR\nNOUTH\nNORTH\nTOTAL\nNIDDEW\nSTD\nLARGE\nNAMED\n303NB\nTHE\nTO:\n3004\n3451\nNEMBER\n&\nSECURICHE\nAGENT\nINLIM\nasso\nNETS\nTHE\n3300\nTEMPS\n00:00\nSMI\nMOLICE\n56-0000\nCHI\nARM\nAIREW\nDECTILR\nNEW\n000MABH\nBOUNT\nINSURANCE\nMMM\nTERMIN\nserve\n-\nIDNED\nMARCH\nNOTERSH\n5401\nCRACTER\n113000.0\nI\n3011\nТЕНДИ\nXPC\nour\nIS\nNOVEMENT\nBARMSFH\nNEW\nare\n100N\nNUMB\nM:DICM\nware\n3000\nNOTER\nMISKED\nNEW\nWATRUCA\nBRAINDER\nKIMB\nS\nMHICH\nOFFIER\nNONT\nNESTH\nATTEN\nNIREMO\nRICH\nNTINO\nTERMS\n1.000\nNOBO\nTHE\nNOEM-OP\nENDIREH\nCLASSINE\nthe\nSTATE OF TENNESSEE\nMAITED\nXXXXH\nADDRESS\n1304\nAND\nNXW\nFORERTEON\nRETERS\nNOTES\nAMOTED\nMANCH\nLIC08\nan\nTEA\nNOUSED:\nMORRIE\n-\nASTILITY\nAMERICA\n36491\nNOTW\nWRLAM\nSCHOOL\nXXXX\nREDUT\n0001\nзымо\nTEMPS\nOMLINE\nNO.\nTMPMJ\nIQMO\n3811\nTERM\nNOAT\nwas\nMANDER\nINSTRUCTION\nLICOS\nDESTS\nAND\nLAUREL\nMM/M\nHure\nRECEIVER\n-\nPLEASE\nLICK\nMINA\n2\nrecomell\nanoth\nDEO#\nDENITION\nATEMO\nCHARGES ktd\nFOGON\nNEC\n34d\nNOSABED\nGHD\nNEGHT\nNEED\nFLOYD\nNOWH\nMATH\nMARION\ny\ntrun\nCHARLED\nTHIS\nTUS\nNON)\nand\nMDI\nNOWH\nLACHINGTON\nSEENO\n(NLIMITY)\n300\nAMOUNT\nMODT\nMRIN\nTOTAL\nWELDINGH\nWENT\nXCDONBH\n384633\nMORGAN\n*WD\nштте\n3008\n30GM\nSPENDER\nRETURNED\naddress\nRES-OUND\nVDG4\nAIREM\nBroken Lines = County Border\nSolid Lines = Congressional District\nXEREM\n31091\nLICITE\nMOLTH-BM\nWOOM?\n346h\nARMY\nÈ\n(\nMPDS\n45 BMS\n1\n*******\nLEGOS\nROD\nLEGEND:\nDRIER\nFLETING\nMONROE\n0409\nsceno\nNOBED\nWHOD,\n34d\nNUCKHAM\ncourts\nTHE WHITE HOUSE\nWASHINGTON\nDecember 13, 1994\nMEMORANDUM FOR DISTRIBUTION\nFROM:\nSTEPHEN B. SILVERMANSOS\nSpecial Assistant to the President\nand Deputy Secretary to the Cabinet\nSUBJECT:\nRECOMMENDATION FROM THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY\nMANAGEMENT AGENCY (FEMA) TO DENY THE REQUEST\nFOR A MAJOR DISASTER DECLARATION IN THE\nSTATE OF TENNESSEE\nAttached for your comment is a recommendation from the Federal Emergency Management\nAgency (FEMA) to deny the request for a major disaster declaration for the State of\nTennessee. On November 27 a strong weather front passed through the state causing at least\nsix tornadoes to touch down. Many communities also experienced localized flooding. The\nFederal Emergency Management Agency has concluded that the situation does not warrant a\nmajor disaster declaration.\nPlease forward any comments to our office. If there are no objections, the request from the\nState of Tennessee will be denied.\nAttachment\nPURCHASE\nFederal Emergency Management Agency\nFEDERAL\nAGENCY\nWashington, D.C. 20472\nMEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT\nTENNESSEE\nOn November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed through the\nState of Tennessee. At least six tornadoes touched down in western\nand middle portions of the State. Many communities experienced\nlocalized flooding as up to five inches of rain fell in some areas.\nOn November 30, Governor Ned McWherter requested a major disaster\ndeclaration for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson,\nFayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson.\nFollowing this request, on December 3-4, a joint FEMA, State, and\nlocal government Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was conducted\nin the affected areas.\nINDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\nFour (4) deaths and 30 injuries are attributed to this event. One\n(1) person has been reported missing. One (1) shelter was opened\nby the American Red Cross (ARC), but no individuals were sheltered.\nThe most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the\ndestruction of and damage to private homes. There were 233 homes\nimpacted as follows: 45 destroyed, 28 with major damage, 38 with\nminor damage, and 122 otherwise affected.\nPUBLIC ASSISTANCE\nThe major impact on the public sector was widespread debris. Also,\nthe State and local governments provided emergency protective\nmeasures such as search and rescue efforts, traffic control and\nproviding food for affected individuals. Other public impacts\ninclude damage to public roadways, water control facilities,\nutility systems and public buildings and equipment.\nDISCUSSION\nThe Governor's request complies with the requirements of 44 CFR\n206.36. The State financial commitment is considered adequate.\nGovernor McWherter has requested both Individual Assistance and\nPublic Assistance programs under Public Law 93-288, as amended.\nAlso, Governor McWherter has requested assistance through the Small\nBusiness Administration (SBA). In the event of a major disaster\ndeclaration for Individual Assistance, designated counties would\nautomatically be made eligible for SBA assistance.\nDamage assessments were conducted in the eight affected counties.\nPreliminary information indicates that approximately 92 percent of\nthe damaged dwellings are owner-occupied. Overall, about 41\npercent of the impacted dwellings are expected to be insured;\nhowever, over 87 percent of the homes with major damage or which\nwere destroyed are insured. Less than 3 percent of the families\naffected are considered to be low-income.\nAlthough the ARC opened one shelter, no individuals were sheltered.\nAll affected individuals identified alternate living\naccommodations. The ARC is continuing to provide assistance to\nindividuals as needs are identified.\nNo health and safety issues were identified during the PDA. There\nare no isolation cases in any of the affected counties.\nIn the event of a declaration, assistance under the Disaster\nHousing Program may be made available to 14 families at an average\nof $1,500. Under the IFG program, two individuals may be eligible\nfor an average grant of $5,000. No Disaster Unemployment\nAssistance (DUA) requirements were reported by the State or the\nDepartment of Labor (DOL).\nIndividual Assistance program cost estimates are:\nTemporary Housing (100 percent Federal)\nHome Repairs\n$\n5,000\nRental Assistance/Transient\nAccommodations\n$ 16,000\nTOTAL\n$ 21,000\nIndividual and Family Grants (75 percent Federal)\nGrant Amount\n$ 10,000\nFederal Share I\n$\n7,500\nTOTAL INDIVIDUAL ASSISTANCE\n$ 28,500\nSBA reported that none of the affected counties would have the\nrequired number of eligible applicants for an SBA declaration. In\nthe event of a major disaster declaration for Individual\nAssistance, SBA assistance would be automatically provided. In\nthis case, approximately 17 homeowners may be eligible for an\naverage loan of $1,629 through SBA. One (1) business may be\neligible for an average loan of about $52,687.\nSmall Business Administration\nDisaster Loan Program\n$ 329,634\nThe primary impact to the public sector was debris consisting of\nfelled trees, building materials and personal property. Also\nincluded in the estimated cost of debris removal are costs to\nremove totally destroyed public buildings.\nPublic road system impact was primarily due to debris falling and\ndamaging sidewalk pavement and curbing. Although minor instances\nof pavement failure were noted, this failure is attributable to the\nuse of heavy equipment during the response phase.\nOne school was damaged in Shelby County. Insurance was available\nto cover a majority of the costs of restoration and for temporary\nclassrooms during restoration. Also, minor repairs are required\nfor a water control facility. The distribution line of an electric\nutility system was damaged, but repairs were prompt and power has\nbeen restored.\nThe State and local governments provided effective emergency\nprotective measures including search and rescue operations, traffic\ncontrol and providing food for affected individuals.\nPublic Assistance program cost estimates are:\nDebris Removal\n$\n439,990\nProtective Measures\n$\n222,965\nRoad Systems\n$\n6,800\nWater Control Facilities\n$\n3,000\nBuildings and Equipment\n$ 25,000\nUtilities\n$ 459,867\nOther (recreation, etc.)\n$\n-0-\nTotal Projected Federal Share\nPublic Assistance\n$1,157,622\nThere were two Presidentially declared major disasters in the State\nduring FY'94. The combined Federal Share for these disasters is\ncurrently projected at $62.5 million.\nMuch of the damage to the private and public sector is covered by\ninsurance. State and local governments provided effective\nemergency response. The ARC is continuing to work with the local\ngovernments to meet individual assistance needs as they are\nidentified. No health and safety risks associated with this event\nhave been identified.\nCONCLUSIONS\nThe situation does not exceed the response capabilities of the\nState and local governments.\nThe situation does not warrant a major disaster declaration.\nRECOMMENDATION\nThat the Governor's request be denied.\nSigned\nJames L. Witt\nDirector\nDate: DEC 13 1994\nAttachments:\nTurndown Letter\nCongressional Representation\nState Map\nGovernor's Request\nCONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATION\nThe Governor of Tennessee is:\nNed R. McWherter (D)\nTennessee Senators are:\nJim Sasser (D)\nHarlan Mathews (D)\nRepresenting the affected areas:\nBob Clement (D)\n5th District\nBart Gordon (D)\n6th District\nDon Sundquist (R)\n7th District\nJohn Tanner (D)\n8th District\nHarold E. Ford (D)\n9th District\nFor further information, contact FEMA at (202) 646-4500.\nXXXXXX\nINITEMS\nDASH\na\nATCHE\nSENIL\nwe\nTUSCALIDER\nPUNRI\nwas\nMACCHO\nREND\n311343\nMIDITAL\n-\nTIMES\nCH\nAMERICANCE\nMILLAND\n-\nMEMTED\n300\nNORTH\nLERORE\nNOVEN\nMUSICH\nNEMBER\nTOLLRO\nnote\n-\nCOLORAS\nST.0.AR\nURTIN\nterms\nMOSTEREH\n-\nMIND\nXEXTH\nBOOD\nNOLT:\nSHOULD\nSINGH\nCARD\nMEMORO\n3WD\nINTER\nWORLD\nTRELAHRICHE\nMOTES\nFDAMS\nXTX\nHEMOLE\nNOTE\nYRLOBUSHA\nCULLMAN.\n2000\nNEEDS\nNOSICER\nNOMM\nHOJSMIN\nFOREYTH\nBODO\nFORMS\n2000\nPONTITIOC\nЭТТАЗЕН\nTMN\nIn\nNAMED:\nBRNS\nand\nHART\nTENDING\nLAFR/ETTE\nPRND\nMEMBER\nCHICKER\nsann\nMOTEO\nPICKENS\nMIRGAN\nNEW\n*********\na\nSCHOOL\nNDEMITI\nSTATE\n300\nsaw\nMINI\nLEWS\nМОВЖЕНГ\nNOSIDEN\nMETICO\nNUMBER\nTMOM\n3100\nINFORMATION\nMALKER\n#5\nTPPAH\nSOUGH\nSTE/NIED\nsexed\nNEW\n-\nSMILL\nMEDICALO\nMOOD'S\n0.06 20\nA/D\nX\n190.00\nNDJ\nMXM\nLine\nNOREM\nNEDNESS\n6-L\nNONT\nMOLTING\nsaw\n3000mn\nNORTH\nNAEDWH\nNXXX\n3004\n3451\nNOT\n&\nSECURICHIE\nAGNTS\n3DWCH\nINCLU\na\nNETS\nCOFFEE\nTERMS\nKOLD\nCERVEN\nCHECKE\nSAN\n206079\n38-CONT\n-\nANH\nAIREM\nNOGICIAL\n00011A8H\nBON\nNMM\nTEMON\nburn\n-\nMADEIN\n5000\n113000\nADMA\nROSERMA\n300\na\nTEHCAM\nXMI\n67830\nDE\nTOMO\nSUBHISH\nMORE\nNORBAN\n-\nADD\nNUNE\nKONT\nNEDICH\nusers\nNOTER\n3000\nHAMELEN\nNEW\nLITTRUCA\nWILSINGTON\nHIND\nname\nNISTH\nBERLO\nMONT\nATTMS\nAMEH\nNTNO\nNURBAD\nTERMS\nLIC05\nFENTRESS\nMOBICH\na\nENDIGH\nX\nNIED\nTHE\nMEMI\nMMS\nABOUNT\nSTATE OF TENNESSEE\nNAITE\nXXXMM\n1504\nAND\nm.\nNXM\nRETURNS\nNOTH\nUSA\nAPOTED\naddition\nMUCH\nLICOS\nan\nNOUNTRY\nMORE\nMENHAN\nTES\nATTENT\nAMOUNT\nNETW\nSCILL\nNUM\nXINCE\nNEXT\nand\nOMTILS\nRECEIVED\nTMGMJ\nTEMM\nMORTH\nIDAHO\n3911\nTESSAL\nKREEN\nNOT\nLEDS\nwas\nMONTGO\nDENTA\nVIVOV\nA/D\nLAUREL\nTHROUGH\nSINCE\nartins\nAND\nNUMBER\n3034\nDOSTS\nNNMB\n24H\naddition\nLID#\nARO\nMILL\nSHOWH\n3:04\nTERREM\nATTO\nNUSCH\nNOT\nMOSAMED\nGND\nNON-OP\n34d\nKEN\nNEW\na\nNOTH\nGATE\nTHERE\nNETCH\nNINH\nsnan\nan\namo\nSTATE\nTUS3\nMXXMI\nNON)\nNDAH\nBIGH\n883.40\n(KLB/TMB\nAMERICAN\n300\nNOSXCH\nMEMORH\nMOOT\nNDM\nTENOS\nXIXNM\nNOEM-OP\nNOTH\nAMOUNT\nTHINGI\nCLARK\nunre\n3005\n20124\nHING\nARM\nMIDDLES\nBroken Lines = County Border\nSolid Lines = Congressional District\nRES-DUNCH\nVEDICLES\nAMEN\nMFRRICK\n3109\nNOUTHERN\nAMEN\n-\nLIDITE\nH&B\nASTHS\nNORMAH\n*******\nCHARGED\nLEGEND:\nSTHON\nLEGOS\nFLOYD\nMONTHS\nMONROE\nCARTER\nDAY\nFLB10C\n6000\nNUMBER\nWHOD,\n34d\nTERMS\nBEEN\nINFORMATION COPY\nDISASTER\nPRIORITY\nSUBJECT\nREQUEST FOR A MAJOR DISASTER DECLARATION\nSTATE OF TENNESSEE\nEXERGENCY\nAGEMENT MERITAL FEDERAL AGENCY\nDATE\nDEC 13 1994\nFederal Emergency Management Agency\nFEDERAL\nAGENCY\nWashington, D.C. 20472\nThe Honorable Ned McWherter\nGovernor of Tennessee\nState Capitol\nNashville, Tennessee 37243\nDear Governor McWherter:\nThis is in response to your November 30, 1994 request for a major\ndisaster declaration due to tornadoes, severe weather and flooding\nwhich impacted the State on November 27. Specifically, you\nrequested Individual Assistance and Public Assistance under PL-288,\nas amended, for the following eight counties: Crockett, Davidson,\nFayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson.\nOn December 3-4, a Preliminary Damage Assessment (PDA) was jointly\nconducted in the affected counties by State and local officials,\nFEMA staff and representatives from the Small Business\nAdministration.\nThe most prevalent effect on individuals is related to the\ndestruction of and damage to private homes. However, PDA\ninformation indicates that most of these damages are covered by\ninsurance. All affected individuals have identified alternative\nliving arrangements and there appears to be no need for mass care\nshelters. The American Red Cross is working with local governments\nto address individual assistance needs as they are identified.\nThe main impact to the public sector was fallen debris. Virtually\nall damage to public road systems was due to debris damaging\nsidewalk pavement and curbing. However, the types of costs\nassociated with debris removal and road repair may be budgeted for\nand absorbed by the local governments with State assistance.\nAdditionally, although a public school building was damaged, it\nappears that insurance will cover almost all costs for restoration\nand temporary facilities during the restoration.\nEffective emergency protective measures were provided by State and\nlocal governments. No health and safety problems associated with\nthis event have been identified.\nBased upon a review of all available information, we have concluded\nthat the impact of this event is not of the severity and magnitude\nthat warrants a major disaster declaration. Recovery costs for\nthis event seem well within the combined capabilities of the State\nand local governments. For these reasons, I must inform you that\nyour request for a major disaster declaration is denied.\nThis denial may be appealed within 30 days after the date of this\nletter. The appeal request, along with additional information\njustifying the appeal, should be submitted to the President through\nKenneth D. Hutchison, Regional Director of FEMA Region IV, located\nat:\n1371 Peachtree Street, NE\nSuite 700\nAtlanta, Georgia 30309\nI regret that our decision could not be more positive. However, I\nam confident that the assistance provided by the State and local\ngovernments, and voluntary organizations along with the available\ninsurance, will help the residents of Tennessee to recover from\nthis event.\nSincerely,\nJames L. Witt\nDirector\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL:1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94\n11:01 No 001 P.02\nState of Tennessee\nNovember 30,\n03\nNED MeWHESTER\nCOTERNOR\nThe President\nThe White House\nWashington, D.C.\nThru: Mr. Kenneth D. Hutchison\nRegional Director\nFEMA Region IV\n1371 Peachtree St., N.E.\nAtlanta, Georgia 30309\nDear Mr. President:\nUnder the provisions of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act,\nPublic Law 93-288, as amended by Public Law 100-707, 1 respectfully request that you doclare a major\ndisaster for both public and individual assistance for the State of Tennessee in the following countion:\nCrockett, Davidson, Fayotte, Laudordale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson counties. Other\ncounties may be added as preliminary damage survoys are completed.\nOn Sunday, November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed across the State of Tennessee.\nThis weather front produced six tornadoes striking portions of west and middle Tennessee. Some areas of\nwest and middle Tennessee received as much as four to five inches of rainfall which caused localized\nflooding in many communition.\nOn November 28, 1994, the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) . State of\nTermessee damage assessment teams began to survey the impact of the storm on Tennessee communities,\ntheir citizens and infrastructure. While many Teanessee counties were affected by the storm, the connties\nincluded in this request were impacted the most. A damage survey was completed in the five work hit\ncounties and indicated that families are cligible for assistance under the Individual and Family Grant\nProgram (IPO); families qualify for Temporary Housing Assistance. Total damages to homes and\nbusinesses are estimated to exceed $50,000,000.\nThe November storm created a direct and profound hardship for the families that received the brunt\nof the disaster. Surveys confirm that a number of the victims are low-lacome households with some\nvictims being olderly. Interviews with potential IFG recipients revealed that some live on fixed income, and\nvirtually none have financial resources to draw upon to begin to recover from the flooding. The housing\nproblem is compounded by the fact that very fow rental units are available for victims, 1 situation that is\nprevalent in all of the predominantly rural countics that were most affected.\nThe true impact of the storm on public facilities in Tonnessee can only be gauged in the context of\nthe socio-economic conditions in this part of the state. Many of these counties are rural and economically\ndepressed, the tax base continues to deteriorate. Furthermore, the impacted counties are faced with a\nfundamental problem: the cost to restore the infrastructure to pre-disarter condition would consume (or\neven exceed) existing funds that remain in the local budgets. la short, many of the connties have few\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL:1,1,404-853-4344\nDec 01 94\n11:01\nNo\n001\nP.03\nMr. President\nNovember 30, 1994\nPage 2\nresources to draw upon to return their county to pre-disaster condition. The problem is further\ncompounded by the fact that many of these counties are goographically isolated. Additionally, all of these\ncounties were doclared as a result of this year's Ice Storm, Presidential Declaration number 1010.\nIn essence, a clear and convincing case can be made that the November storm had a major impact\non the Tennessee counties designated in this request. Simply put, the damages have disrupted the local\neconomics, indeed the local way of life in these counties. Moreover, the State of Tennessee will be limited\nin our capability to provide direct assistance to the affected counties as this is the fourth major disaster to\noccur this year.\nAs a result of the emergency situation, 1 directed the execution of the Tennessee Emergency\nManagement Plan on November 27, 1994. Response and recovery operations are ou-going. 1 also directed\nthat all appropriate actions under State law be taken, and that agencies of State government provide all\npossible assistance within the boundaries of State law and resources.\nAs indicated, I find the situation is beyond the capabilities of the state and the affected local\ngovernments to effectively alloviate the existing situation, and I am convinced that supplementary Federal\nassistance is necessary.\nExtensive State resources have been used to alleviate the conditions of the disaster to include: the\nMilitary Department, Department of Safety, Department of General Services, Department of Human\nServices, and the Department of Transportation.\n1 specifically request assistance under the provisions of Section 411 of the Law to establish the\nIndividual and Family Grant Program and Temporary Housing. The state also intends to request assistance\nfrom the Small Business Administration and the Department of Agriculture.\nI certify that pursuant to Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations, the State of\nTennesson will be meeting our prorata share of the total expenditures and obligations for this major\ndiseaser.\nI have designated Ms. John D. White, Jr. as the State Coordinating Officer for this request. He\nwill work with the Federal Emergency Management Agency in damage assessments, response, recovery,\nand may provide further information or justification 8 my behalf\nSincerely,\nGovernor\nNRW.jwh\ng\nThe Honorable Albert Gore\nVice President of the United States\nFEMA RIV DAP\nTEL :1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94 11:02 No 001 P.04\nState of Tennessee\nNovember 30, 1994\nMED MAWNERIER\nGOVERNOR\nMr. Billy Max Paul\nRegional Administrator\nU.S. Small Business Administration\n1375 Peachtroe Street, N.W.\nAtlanta, Georgia 30307-8102\nDear Mr. Paul:\nSunday, November 27, xix tornadoes touched down across the stato of Tennossco leaving death and\ndestruction over eight Tennossee counties.\nOn Sunday, November 27, disaster response personnel from the Tennossee Emergency Management\nAgency (TEMA) and other state agencies assessed the damage in all cight counties. Their damage survey\nidentified over 380 homes/businesses that were destroyed/damaged by the severe weather resulting in over\n$48 million in damages.\nThe damage survey in Shelby County indicates that more than 25 homes and/or businesses may have each\nsustained uninsured losses of forty (40) percent or more of their estimated fair replacement value or pro-\ndisaster fair market value. These residents are in need of financial assistance which is not otherwise\navailable 8 reasonable terms in the disaster area.\nUnder the provisions of the Small Businesses Administration (SBA), 13 CFR Part 123, Subpart B,\nPhysical disaster Loans, 1 request that SBA make their disaster loan program available to individuals,\nfamilies and small businesses in Shelby County and all contiguous counties. Additionally, the state\nrequests a waiver of the continguous requirement for the counties of Crockett, Davidson, Lauderdale,\nStowart, Weakley and Williamson be granted and those counties be eligible for assistance, as most of these\ncountics are poor, rural, and sparacly populated. These counties were affected by the same storm incident,\nbut did not receive the minimum 25 homes/businesses with 40% uninsured losses.\nI have asked John D. white, jt., Director of the Totacssee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) 615-\n741-0001 to assist my office and work with the Small Business Administration regarding any additional\ninformation that may be required. Thank you for your assistance.\nSincerely,\nNed McWherter\nGovernor\nNRWjwh\noc: The Honorable Al Gore\nVice President of the United States\nRichard 3. Nash, Director\nArea U. Disaster Assistance\nRIV DAP\nTEL:1-404-853-4344\nDec 01 94 11:02 No 001 P.05\nState of Tennessee\nNED MeWNRATER\nGOVERNOR\nNovember 30, 1994\nThe Honorable AI Gore\nVice President\nof the United States\nWashington, DC 20501\nDear Mr. Vice President:\nThe citizens of the State of Tennessee appreciate your commitment in offering Federal\nassistance to those devastated by the recent tornadoes and flooding across the state. As\nper your commitment the state is formally requesting federal assistance for recovery from\nthis disaster. Attached for your information are formal requests from me to the\nappropriate federal agency requesting this assistance. Additionally, I request the\nDepartment of Agriculture provide assistance to affected farmers.\nThe citizens of Tennessee appreciate all you have done in the past and will continue to do\nin the future for the state.\nSincerely,\nGovernor\nNRM:kdb\nAttachments (2)\nTOTAL 1.05\nBETH PRICHARD ALPERT\nanna,\nThe VP is very concerned\nthat you. mouhertes's\nletter request be\nhandled in a timely\nmanner. Will you\nPls. make sure that\nwhoever winds up\nhandling this giver\nme a call So we\ncan coordinate ?\n(ext-6-7124)\nThanks for your hege!\nBeth\nShana- What 5) the status of this?\nVP S concerned also tomes.\nPina\n7060\nOF\nTHE\nSEAL\nXVI\nSTATE\nAGRICULTURE MAILRC 7796 TRUST\nState of Tennessee\nNED McWHERTER\nGOVERNOR\nNovember 30, 1994\nThe Honorable Al Gore\nVice President\nof the United States\nWashington, DC 20501\nDear Mr. Vice President:\nThe citizens of the State of Tennessee appreciate your commitment in offering Federal\nassistance to those devastated by the recent tornadoes and flooding across the state. As\nper your commitment the state is formally requesting federal assistance for recovery from\nthis disaster. Attached for your information are formal requests from me to the\nappropriate federal agency requesting this assistance. Additionally, I request the\nDepartment of Agriculture provide assistance to affected farmers.\nThe citizens of Tennessee appreciate all you have done in the past and will continue to do\nin the future for the state.\nSincerely,\nGovernor\nNRM:kdb\nAttachments (2)\nOF\nTHE\nXVI\nSTATE\nOF\nGREAT\nAGRICUL\nLORE\nTHE\nState of Tennessee\n796\nNovember 30, 1994\nNED McWHERTER\nGOVERNOR\nMr. Billy Max Paul\nRegional Administrator\nU.S. Small Business Administration\n1375 Peachtree Street, N.W.\nAtlanta, Georgia 30307-8102\nDear Mr. Paul:\nSunday, November 27, six tornadoes touched down across the state of Tennessee leaving death and\ndestruction over eight Tennessee counties.\nOn Sunday, November 27, disaster response personnel from the Tennessee Emergency Management\nAgency (TEMA) and other state agencies assessed the damage in all eight counties. Their damage survey\nidentified over 380 homes/businesses that were destroyed/damaged by the severe weather resulting in over\n$48 million in damages.\nThe damage survey in Shelby County indicates that more than 25 homes and/or businesses may have each\nsustained uninsured losses of forty (40) percent or more of their estimated fair replacement value or pre-\ndisaster fair market value. These residents are in need of financial assistance which is not otherwise\navailable on reasonable terms in the disaster area.\nUnder the provisions of the Small Businesses Administration (SBA), 13 CFR Part 123, Subpart B,\nPhysical disaster Loans, I request that SBA make their disaster loan program available to individuals,\nfamilies and small businesses in Shelby County and all contiguous counties. Additionally, the state\nrequests a waiver of the continguous requirement for the counties of Crockett, Davidson, Lauderdale,\nStewart, Weakley and Williamson be granted and those counties be eligible for assistance, as most of these\ncounties are poor, rural, and sparsely populated. These counties were affected by the same storm incident,\nbut did not receive the minimum 25 homes/businesses with 40% uninsured losses.\nI have asked John D. white, Jr., Director of the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) 615-\n741-0001 to assist my office and work with the Small Business Administration regarding any additional\ninformation that may be required. Thank you for your assistance.\nSincerely,\nNed McWherter\nGovernor\nNRW:jwh\ncc: The Honorable Al Gore\nVice President of the United States\nRichard J. Nash, Director\nArea II, Disaster Assistance\nTHE\nXVI\nAGRICULTURE\nOMMERS\nState of Tennessee\n7796\nNED McWHERTER\nNovember 30, 1994\nGOVERNOR\nThe President\nThe White House\nWashington, D.C.\nThru: Mr. Kenneth D. Hutchison\nRegional Director\nFEMA Region IV\n1371 Peachtree St., N.E.\nAtlanta, Georgia 30309\nDear Mr. President:\nUnder the provisions of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act,\nPublic Law 93-288, as amended by Public Law 100-707, I respectfully request that you declare a major\ndisaster for both public and individual assistance for the State of Tennessee in the following counties:\nCrockett, Davidson, Fayette, Lauderdale, Shelby, Stewart, Weakley, and Williamson counties. Other\ncounties may be added as preliminary damage surveys are completed.\nOn Sunday, November 27, 1994, a strong weather front passed across the State of Tennessee.\nThis weather front produced six tornadoes striking portions of west and middle Tennessee. Some areas of\nwest and middle Tennessee received as much as four to five inches of rainfall which caused localized\nflooding in many communities.\nOn November 28, 1994, the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) - State of\nTennessee damage assessment teams began to survey the impact of the storm on Tennessee communities,\ntheir citizens and infrastructure. While many Tennessee counties were affected by the storm, the counties\nincluded in this request were impacted the most. A damage survey was completed in the five worst hit\ncounties and indicated that families are eligible for assistance under the Individual and Family Grant\nProgram (IFG); families qualify for Temporary Housing Assistance. Total damages to homes and\nbusinesses are estimated to exceed $50,000,000.\nThe November storm created a direct and profound hardship for the families that received the brunt\nof the disaster. Surveys confirm that a number of the victims are low-income households with some\nvictims being elderly. Interviews with potential IFG recipients revealed that some live on fixed income, and\nvirtually none have financial resources to draw upon to begin to recover from the flooding. The housing\nproblem is compounded by the fact that very few rental units are available for victims, a situation that is\nprevalent in all of the predominantly rural counties that were most affected.\nThe true impact of the storm on public facilities in Tennessee can only be gauged in the context of\nthe socio-economic conditions in this part of the state. Many of these counties are rural and economically\ndepressed, the tax base continues to deteriorate. Furthermore, the impacted counties are faced with a\nfundamental problem: the cost to restore the infrastructure to pre-disaster condition would consume (or\neven exceed) existing funds that remain in the local budgets. In short, many of the counties have few\nMr. President\nNovember 30, 1994\nPage 2\nresources to draw upon to return their county to pre-disaster condition. The problem is further\ncompounded by the fact that many of these counties are geographically isolated. Additionally, all of these\ncounties were declared as a result of this year's Ice Storm, Presidential Declaration number 1010.\nIn essence, a clear and convincing case can be made that the November storm had a major impact\non the Tennessee counties designated in this request. Simply put, the damages have disrupted the local\neconomies, indeed the local way of life in these counties. Moreover, the State of Tennessee will be limited\nin our capability to provide direct assistance to the affected counties as this is the fourth major disaster to\noccur this year.\nAs a result of the emergency situation, I directed the execution of the Tennessee Emergency\nManagement Plan on November 27, 1994. Response and recovery operations are on-going. I also directed\nthat all appropriate actions under State law be taken, and that agencies of State government provide all\npossible assistance within the boundaries of State law and resources.\nAs indicated, I find the situation is beyond the capabilities of the state and the affected local\ngovernments to effectively alleviate the existing situation, and I am convinced that supplementary Federal\nassistance is necessary.\nExtensive State resources have been used to alleviate the conditions of the disaster to include: the\nMilitary Department, Department of Safety, Department of General Services, Department of Human\nServices, and the Department of Transportation.\nI specifically request assistance under the provisions of Section 411 of the Law to establish the\nIndividual and Family Grant Program and Temporary Housing. The state also intends to request assistance\nfrom the Small Business Administration and the Department of Agriculture.\nI certify that pursuant to Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations, the State of\nTennessee will be meeting our prorata share of the total expenditures and obligations for this major\ndisaster.\nI have designated Mr. John D. White, Jr. as the State Coordinating Officer for this request. He\nwill work with the Federal Emergency Management Agency in damage assessments, response, recovery,\nand may provide further information or justification on my behalf.\nSincerely,\nNed Mc Wherter\nGovernor\nNRW:jwh\ncc:\nThe Honorable Albert Gore\nVice President of the United States"
}