Ask the Scholar

Document scope · 1 page
doc
Scholar
Ask about this object, its catalog metadata, its source description, or the page inventory. For page-specific OCR and visual context, open one of the page chats.

Scholar Source Context

Document identity
localId
120358049
label
California
core
doc
dtoType
document
pageCount
1
Source metadata
Source extras
naId
120358049
levelOfDescription
fileUnit
otherTitles
42-t-7432005-20120769F-Seg1-003-003-2017
recordType
description
ocrSource
nara-archive
Single page context
seq
1
pageIndex
0
type
document
mediaId
f5540bc263962112
ocrText
FOIA Number: 2012-0769-F FOIA MARKER This is not a textual record. This is used as an administrative marker by the William J. Clinton Presidential Library Staff. Collection/Record Group: Clinton Presidential Records Subgroup/Office of Origin: Council on Environmental Quality Series/Staff Member: Kathleen (Katie) McGinty Subseries: OA/ID Number: 2886 FolderID: Folder Title: California Stack: Row: Section: Shelf: Position: S 61 5 9 2 5 TUE Los Angeles Times TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 23. 1993 County Agrees to Improve Sewage Treatment Environment: Advanced treatment system will be built by 2002 at a $400-million cost to ratepayers. Agreement caps 15-year mg of war. By MARLA CONE TIMES ENVIRONMENTAL WRITER The new treatment system, to be built at "We fully expect the marine the county's sanitation plant in Carson, community off the Palos Verdes Becoming one of the last urban areas in must he operating by July 1, 2002. or the shell to begin recovery within 10 to the nation to step up its cleansing of cowage county must pay another $1 million fine. 20 years." discharged into the ocean, Los Angeles The agreement culminates a lawsult filed Micle said the sanitation agency County has agreed, after 15 years of battling by the U.S. Environmental Protection hires researchers who study the federal law, to build a $-100-million ad. Agency. the Heal the Bay environmental impact on marine life, "and It has vanced treatment system. organization. the Natural Resources De- been, and still is. our opinion that fense Council and the state's regional water our present discharge is absolutely The county also agreed to pay $2.7 board. million in penalties for violating the Clean The settlement is not yet final, because adequate to protect the environ- Water Act, which requires that all sewage the EPA and the water board have not ment. But it's no question that released into waterways receive secondary officially signed off on it. But attorneys public opinion weighed in our deci- treatment. an advanced cleansing process from both agencies have orally agreed and sion to go to full secondary treat- ment." protect marine life. the sanitation board and two environmen- Secondary treatment is a biolog- Environmentalists from Heal the Bay ta! groups signed the settlement earlier this ical cleansing process that gobbles month. and the Natural Resources Defense Coun- up and decomposes organic materi- cil, who have been trying for years to The penalties include $300.000 to the al and creates a studge. which is persuade the county to comply. called the federal government. $200,000 to the state hauled to a landfill Instead of water board. $1.2 million to im- agreement a major step in cleaning up purped into the ocean. ocean waters off Southern California. prove Los Angeles County's pro- The technique generally makes "This is the single largest source of gram to collect houschold hazard. the ocean cleaner for marine life. pollution into Santa Monica Bay, and the ous wastes and $1 million for an but is of little benefit to the health bay is one of the most cherished and most expanded water reclamation pro- of humans because all sewage dis- used water resources in the entire coun- gram. The NRDC also gets charged from the plant already is try," said NRDC attorney Mitch Bernard. $200.000 to cover legal fees. disinfected to kill bacteria and Under the agreement, all 330 "The law requires a certain level of viruses. Some bottom-divelling million gallons of human and in- marine creatures vanish from sites cleanliness. and that law has been violated dustrial waste that flow daily from where partially treated waste is by the county for a long time. So this Is a the Carson sanitation plant into the discharged. while others become huge victory for the citizens." ocean about a mile off the Palos more abundant. The Los Angeles County Sanitation Dis- Verdes Peninsula must undergo The county has resisted expand- tricts' 2 million ratepayers will pick up the secondary treatment. Currently, ing Its waste water treatment since tab. with each household paying $200 over 60% of the waste undergoes the 1977, the deadline Congress set for 20 years. plus $5 to $10 annually in treatment. which removes a larger municipalities to comply with the operating expenses. said Bob Micle, head of proportion of organic matter, oily Clean Water Act. Los Angeles technical services at the sanitation agency. contaminants and toxic metals in County applied for a special waiver County sanitation officials say they ar- the waste flushed by houscholds in 1979. and the EPA took until gued so long and vigorously to get an and businesses. 1990 to deny the request, Heal the exemption from the federal law, not only to The expanded treatment will Bay and the NRDC notified the save residents from the expense. but also eliminate half of the solid wastes. county two years ago that they because they believe the waste water already is sufficiently treated to protect the about 35 million pounds per year. intended to sue, and the EPA that the county sanitation plant stepped in to file the suit In Janu- environment. ary, 1992. "This is $400 million that will come out of currently releases into the ocean. according to sanitation district da- "There's no question citizens the pockets of the public." Micle said. "If ta. made this happen." said the you had that much to spend in this "Removing that much pollution NRDC's Bernard. "The fact that mmunity. would you spend it to take will be a tremendous boon to citizens initiated and pursued the ds out of the ocean 50 we have a marine life." said Mark Gold, staff process makes it an even bigger calthier environment for clams and other Victory." scientist for Heal the Bay, based in organisms. or would you spend it on health Santa Monica. care or child care or drug prevention?" 2 TUE 3 Los Angeles Times Westside THURSDAY AUGUST 12, 1993 Herring suggested that miscom- munication at the county level may DeLano said that even in dry Cities May Face Create programs to encourage be the root of the complaint. He weather. about 25 million gallons of residents and business owners to noted that technical data sought by untreated runoff flows into Santa keep their driveways and side- the group-such as the locations of Monica Bay every day, in a rain- walks clean, so when it rains the Lawsuits Over possible hazardous materials and a storm, runoff can swell to 10 billion debris will not be swept into the map of Culver City's storm drain- gallons a day. With that water storm drains. age system-was forwarded in come posticides washed off lawns, Storm Runoff 1990 to the Los Angeles County motor oil from driveways, pet Provide regular cleaning of Department of Public Works. droppings. toxic heavy metals and city catch basins. tons of trash. Set up inspection programs for WESTSIDE which oversees the region's storm drainage network. But whether the Storm drain systems should not auto shops, gas stations, restau- county made that information be confused with municipal sewer rants and other businesses where By GORDON DILLOW systems, in which waste water is debris and pollutants are common. SPECIAL TO THE TIMES available to the council is unclear, treated before being discharged. Set up municipal disposal ccn- Herring sold. Except for material trapped in ters for used oil and other house- A national environmental group has put Herring acknowledged that the two Westside cities on notice, Clean up city failed to provide some types of catch basins, usually everything in hold hazardous wastes. runoff data going back as far as a storm drain system makes its your storm water, or cise. Encourage water conservation. The Natural Resources Defense Council 1980, but only because the city way to the ocean without being Westside industrial firms that treated. ans notified Beverly Hills and Culver City lacked the procedures for collect- are accused by the council of not ing it back then. Delano said that If cities would at it will file lawsuits against them if they complying with water runoff regu- not start complying with storm-water "They (the Natural Resources inform their citizens and business lations include: Blackhawk Oil provisions of the federal Clean Water ACL Defense Council) are procedurally people about the dangers of urban Company in Culver City, Coast correct in that some of the infor- runoff-and back up the education Specifically, the group wants the cities to Enameling Company in Marina del with a little enforcement-it could clean up "urban runoff" from lawns, road- mation has not been provided." Rey and Gebe Electronic Services Herring said. "But technically it is go a long way toward making the Inc. in Los Angeles. Also named ways and other sources that flows untreat- impossible [to provide] because It runoff, and the ocean. cleaner. were South Bay companies Airco cd through storm drainage systems into Santa Monica Bay. doesn't exist." "If I flush my radiator into the Gases, Allied Signal Casting, Fi- Also threatened with lawsuits were Her- A Beverly Hills official said street, it's like pouring radiator berglass Production & Tooling Inc., Tuesday that the complaints made fluid directly into the ocean." Dc- Star Biochemicals. C.P. Hall Co. mosa Beach. El Segundo. Rancho Palos about his city miss the mark. Lano said. "People need to know and Allied Signal Inc. Verdes and Westlake Village. as well as Beverly Hills takes fastidious that. The problem is that unless Caltrons and 12 private Industrial firms. care of its streets and alleyways to you're at the beach. It's out of sight, Heal the Bay. a Santa Monica- The cities and firms have 60 days to out of mind." keep trush and pollutants out of the based environmental group. is join- respond to the complaints in the "notice of DeLano said some of the 19 cities ing the council in its threatened council. intent to sue" letters sent recently by the county-owned storm drains, said Daniel Webster. director of public and three other government enti- actions against the private firms, works. ties in the Santa Monica Bay wa- but not against the municipalities. "We hope this will wake them up." said Evereu DeLano. a Natural Rc- The group's letter contended tershed have made progress in Don Phillips, plant manager at sources Defense Council attorney. that the city failed to file reports implementing regulations and pro- Allied Signal in El Segundo. which pertaining to clean water require- grams to control urban runoff pol- manufactures refrigerant products. "It really Isn't that tough for them to comply. if they want to. There's ments, a charge that Webster dis- lution, including the cities of Los said in response to the threatened putes. Some reports. such as the Angeles and Santa Monica and Los lawsuit "To our knowledge we are just not that much they have to do. Angeles County. But he said the in compliance with all regulations." But we definitely aren't bluffing. monthly rainfall report. were filed We're after compliance." and not checked off by the county cities that are being threatened with lawsuits either have not made He added. however, that the com- Culver City Alty. Norm Herring and other reports are in progress, he said, enough progress or in some cases pany is checking the regulations to said the city is "still evaluating" Webster said that while the city "haven't even begun to adopt the make certain. Phillips said his the council's complaint. programs they're supposed to." company does not have any storm He said that the city has done its plans to discuss the complaints best to comply with regional runoff with the group in a meeting facill- The Natural Resources Defense water runoff because "everything Council also wants cities to: stays within the plant." rules and takes scriously the tated by the county, he believes Stencil signs near storm drain the "Intent to sue" is an attempt to Dennis Signorovitch. a spokes- group's concerns. openings to discourage people from keep the pressure on cities to man for Allied Signal, said the III there's something else we can pouring motor oil or coolant. grass do to satisfy these folks. It's impor- implement new programs rather Natural Resources Defense Council clippings, trash and other pollu- tant to us," he said. than an evaluation of what the erred in saying Allied Signal Cast- tants into the storm drain. citles are doing now. ing in Torrance was not in compli- Caltrans attorney Anthony Ruf- Sct up phone lines to receive ance with the clean water regula- folo said his agency has "put a lot of effort" into complying with dumping. reports of illegal storm drain tions. The company, Signorovitch said. is covered by permits issued runoff regulations. "We're still Increase street sweeping. to 11.5 parent company. studying this (notice of intent let- Representatives of the other from." ter] to see where they're coming firms either declined comment on the threatened lawsuits or could not be reached for comment. JAN-25-94 TUE 13:48 Cos Angeles Times SUNDAY, JULY 5, 1992 Scientists Say Pico-Kenter Drain Is Clean Environment: Water in the befouled storm runoff channel is now being treated at a sewage plant. COASTAL A t a news conference on the By NANCY HILL-HOLTZMAN sand at the end of Pico Boule- TIMES STAFF WRITER vard. Los Angeles Mayor Tom Bradley and Santa Monica Mayor It's safe to go back in the water Ken Genser knocked down the again. signs that for almost two years To prove the point. a Heal the have warned swimmers that it was Bay scientist plunged into the surf unsafe to swim near the drain that at the mouth of the Pico-Kenter carried contaminant-filled urban storm drain on a perfect beach day runoff into the sca. Los Angeles Thursday. City Councilwoman Ruth Galanter The swim was the finale of a and former Santa Monica Mayor celebration of the reopening of the Judy Abdo, who initiated the di- ocean near a storm drain notorious version project that made the re- for spewing filth into the sca. opening possible, also were on "Today is a day of victory and hand. celebration." said Adi Liberman, The diversion is a temporary executive director of Heal the Bay. measure, possible because water The celebration was possible be- conservation in the region has cause, except during rainstorms. made space available at Hyperion. the befouled water is now being Ultimately, Santa Monica will build diverted from the storm drain to a reclamation plant to deal with the Hyperion scwage plant where waste water, known as urban run- it is treated before it is released off. into the Pacific Ocean. Abdo said she recalled the day in The success of the cleanup effort December, 1990, when representa- comes none too soon. About a week tives of a surfers' group, the Free ago, the Santa Monica Bay Resto- Pacific Assn.. and from Heal the ration Project announced the re- Bay came into her office and asked sults of an earlier study that dc- her to either clean up the Pico- tected viruses confirming the Kenter storm drain or put a plug in presence of human feces in the it. She took them up on it. water near the Pico-Kenter drain, In 1990, the water near the as well as in two other Santa mouth of the drain was failing Heal Monica Bay locations. Water from the Bay's safety tests with a grade the drain has been directed to the of "F." Hyperion plant only since Memori- On Thursday. the water made al Day. the honor roll. 5 TUE Cos Angeles Times SUNDAY JUNE 21, 1992 The line extends from the spot New Sewer Line Brings near La Cienega and Rodeo to the Hyperion plant but will eventually become part of a 23-mile backbone stretching to the Los Angeles- Hope for a Cleaner Ocean Glendale treatment plant. Workers will repair the old sew- er line after it dries out, and it will from the old line earlier this be used as a backup for the new Environment: A month. sending about 100 million line. $115-million replacement gallons a day into the new line, As a result of the new projects, which extends from the cdge of the sewer bills across Los Angeles system promises to end Crenshaw District to the Hyperion have been rising steadily, and cities Treatment Plant in Playa del Rey. that contract with Los Angeles for the dumping of raw The new line has a capacity to scwer services are not happy. sewage into Santa carry 500 million gallons a day. Smith said. In a ceremony Thursday near La Most cities pay their sewer tab Monica Bay. Cienega Boulevard and Rodco out of fees collected from individu- Road, Los Angeles City Council- al monthly scwer bills and from COASTAL woman Ruth Galanter officially voter-approved bond issues de- opened the scwer by tossing sever- signed to spread the costs out over By BERNICE HIRABAYASHI al handfuls of rose petals and time. TIMES STAPF WRITER daistes into an opening through But many are demanding justifi- which spectators could see the cation for the spiraling costs. Some Heal the Bay President Doro- rushing river of scwage. cities, whether on purpose or not, thy Green wore an especially "We were able to replace a very are falling behind on payments. large smile for the crowd of about old and very sad scwer system," Los Angeles is suing El Segundo 200 people gathered before her Galanter said. "I'm sure all of [my for not paying a single sower bill in Thursday. constituents] will be very grateful the past several years, Smith said. And she had good reason. After when this is done. and some of The bill now stands in excess of $2 seven years of lobbying local those trucks go away and leave million. wastewater authorities to raise them alone." But at Thursday's press confer- standards for treating sowage, Jeanne Breunig, who headed the ence, Felicia Marcus. president of she was finally able to participate citizens committee formed to ad- the Los Angeles Board of Public in the opening of a new sower line dress concerns of residents. said Works, drow attention to past ac- that promises to end the dumping the noise and dust were a nuisance complishments, such as cleaning of raw sewage into Santa Monica during construction of the eight- up sludge on the ocean floor. Bay. mile underground pipe. adding that people should feel their The North Outfall Replace- But the city acted sensitively sewer bill dollars are being used ment Sewer (NORS). which took and responsibly, she said. Several well. This latest project. especially, 2½ years and $115 million to families in Westchester who com- will allow environmentalists and build. will replace a badly deteri- plained of loud noise from the drought-watchers alike to rejoice orated scwer built in the 1920s. underground excavation, for exam- during wet wether instead of fear- During rainstorms, the old ple. were moved to local hotels at ing the scwage spills they often scwer line routinely filled to the city expense. bring, she said. brim. forcing workers to divert Heal the Bay galvanized public "Now it can rain, and we don't raw scwage directly into the sca awareness and played a major role have to feel guilty about it," she via Ballona Creek. in the approval in 1985 of a $3.4- said. billion plan to upgrade and expand the city's sprawling sewer system, "T he primary beneficiaries of said Bradley Smith, deputy engi- the NORS system being neer for the City of Los Angeles. built are the occan and the people The system serves the Westside, who use the ocean," said Green, San Fernando Valley, Glendale and whose environmental group has Burbank. been fighting for more than a decade to clean up Santa Monica I n 1986. the state regional water Bay. "There will no longer be quality control board issued an those raw scwage spills into the emergency order requiring the city bay." to complete the replacement pipe- Workers diverted the flow line by April. 1993. Los 5 TUE Angeles 13:50 Times WESTSIDE, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 26, 1991 Good as Gold Environment: Heal the Bay's staff scientist is credited with bringing credibility to efforts to clean up Santa Monica Bay. SANTA MONICA By JAMES RAINEY WARNING G TIMES STAFF WRITER STORM CRAW NO waver - (*) AUX MAILAS ark Gold grew up around Santa to M Monica Bay. a As a child, he learned to swim at Marina del Rey. Later, he hung out with friends at Will Rogers State Beach. By ADVERTENCIA the time he got to high school, his family had moved from Beverly Hills to Malibu, MARCAS home will OF where he spent endless summers body- ESTER surfing at a break the locals call "Little CERTIFICATE EMPLOYEES Dume." At 28, Gold still lives for the ocean. But now, it's his job. staff scientist for the environmental Heal the Bay. he has become a in the effort to clean up Santa Monica Bay. Respected in the activist community and among government bu- reaucrats and waste dischargers, Gold has brought scientific rigor and credibil- LISA ROMEREIN / Los Angeles Times ity to lobbying on behalf of Los Angeles' Mark Gold played a role in having signs installed at the Pico-Kenter drain. reigning environmental cause. In the process, he has helped define the Santa Monica-based Heal the Bay was coming from the massive Hyperion sources and types of bay pollution-even born in 1985, at a time when there had Treatment Plant near El Segundo. forcing the closure of a popular Santa been several major sewage spills and In 1987, a federal judge ordered the city Monica Beach last year when he found when bay pollution was becoming a hot of Los Angeles to stop dumping scwage sewage in a storm drain. Gold has also led political issue. Although it had only a sludge in the bay and to upgrade treat- the fight for increased warnings to keep handful of members. the group began to ment at the Hyperion Plant. Heal the Bay the public out of polluted waters, report- publicize Santa Monica Bay pollution and was assigned by the court to monitor ed on the failure of local cities to properly to fight a move by the city of Los Angeles compliance with the landmark environ- monitor the waste that flows into storm to give less than full treatment to sewage drains, and spurred negotiations for im- proved treatment of the sewage that the county discharges into the ocean off the Palos Verdes Peninsula " A lot of environmental groups can send someone to a hearing to read an impassioned letter," said Adi Liber- man, Heal the Bay's executive director. "But Mark is there with expert testimo- ny. No one else [in the local environmen- tal community] can speak with the kind prity and respect that he can." g Wilson, chief of the Bays and staaries unit of the state Water Re- sources Control Board, agreed: "Mark brought Heal the Bay a lot of technical information and a strong contact in the scientific community." TUE 13:51 GOLD: the Bay mental agreement. Gold quickly expanded his work Gold's impact has been so great "It was like we won the first from oversight of the Hyperion that at least one other local envi- battle, but then the real war improvements to a myriad of other ronmental group, the Coalition for starts," recalled Felicia Marcus, a projects, including some that are Clean Air, has been persuaded to Heal the Bay founder who now ongoing: hire its own staff scientist. helps control the sewage plant as A comprehensive analysis of "Mark is one of the first guys president of the city's Board of water in a few notorious storm I've met who is a Ph.D.-quality Public Works. "We had to stay in drains. When the study, under the scientist, but who also knows how their face to make sure it all got auspices of the Santa Monica Bay to speak English," said Tim Little, done." Restoration Project, was released the clean air group's executive It was Gold, working toward a in June, 1990, it showed that the director. "We went out and tried to doctorate at UCLA in Environ- drain at the foot of Pico Boulevard find a clone of him." mental Science and Engineering, had been polluted with sewage. Even Jim Stahl, the assistant who was chosen in 1988 to monitor Signs and a rope with buoys general manager of the Sanitation the city's compliance and to act as were subsequently installed to Districts, who has often been at Heal the Bay's staff scientist. warn swimmers to stay away from. odds with Gold in negotiations over Gold had worked for a time for the water near the mouth of the the county's sewage treatment, an environmental consulting firm. storm drain, just south of Santa' said: "He has attempted at all times One of the projects he dealt with Monica Pier. Gold recently helped to bring science and scientific facts there proposed turning ecological- negotiate an agreement so the into the decision-making process, ly sensitive Ballona Lagoon in polluted storm water can be redi- rather than perception. I think it's Venice into a marina. rected to Hyperion for full treat- an improvement over how things ment. were in the past." thought to myself, 'What am A survey this year that showed Heal the Bay and Gold are not 1 doing?' Gold recalled. "It local cities are woefully behind in loved in all quarters, though. Some just never seemed right. I wasn't complying with a federal program waste dischargers and public comfortable doing that kind of that requires them to measure and health officials said the group can work for a massive development begin to control pollution that still be too alarmist-not giving project. flows into storm drains. enough credit for improvements in "I had been close to Santa Moni- Negotiations, along with a law- sewage treatment and unduly fan- ca Bay for a real long time," he yer from the Natural Resources ning public concern about the said. "And I really wanted to apply Defense Council, that seek to end health impacts of swimming in what I was learning to some- the dumping of partially treated Santa Monica Bay. thing I cared about.' sewage by the county Sanitation "In every organization, there is Although they had increasing Districts into the bay. an audience and an agenda," said clout and succeeded in drawing A study that quantified house- one official, who asked not to be public attention to pollution in the bay. Heal the Bay members in the hold hazardous wastes that people named. early days sometimes tended to- dump into the trash and the ward hyperbole. Some "liked to streets, which eventually find their G old counters that he would shoot from the hip," Marcus con- way into storm drains and, thus, rather err on the side of cau- ceded. the occan. tion by warning the public when A protocol. soon to be consid- there are any signs of serious At a hearing before the Regional ered by the Los Angeles County contamination. Water Quality Control Board just Board of Supervisors, that he He said one of his long-term weeks before Gold was hired, for instance. two group members in helped write, instructing public goals is to help settle that long- white lab coats held aloft a smelly officials in closing Santa Monica running debate over the safety of bottle of muck and declared that Bay beaches when spills endanger swimming in the bay, particularly one-quarter of the underwater the public health. near storm drains. His drain studies shelf off the Palos Verdes Peninsu- Gold said he is "extremely well already have laid the groundwork paid" at $45,000 a year-even for a comprehensive health survey la was made of sewer sludge, though he could make at least half that would determine, once and for observers recalled. again as much in the private sec- all, whether people are getting sick "There was no serious study to show that this was true," said one tor-because he enjoys what he is from swimming near the outlets. doing. His work on storm drains "It's something I have been person familiar with the hearing, who asked not to be named. "It also will be the basis for the pushing for since I started working dissertation that he hopes to com- here," Gold said. "People still are really damaged their credibility." plete by this summer. asking, 'Is it safe to swim in Santa Monica Bay?' You have people so H cal the Bay founding president Dorothy Green did not recall S upporters say his growth as 8 polarized on that issue." speaker and an advocate has In the meantime, Gold still lives that hearing at the Regional Water been even greater than as a scien- near the ocean-in Santa Monica Quality Control Board and insisted tist. "He came to us with no with his wife, Lisette Bauersachs, the group has always been careful about the information it presented. political skills," Green said. "He an environmental engineer whom But Green said she hired Gold, knew the issues, but he didn't he met in the UCLA program. And "realizing that an organization is know how to translate that into he still loves to swim in the bay. only as credible as the information political action. Now he really "But I follow all our good ad- it has." directs that whole part of the vice," said Gold, ever the advocate. organization." "Which is: Don't swim within two days of a storm and don't swim within 100 yards of a flowing storm "