Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 72
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL -- Attorney Work Product Prepared by SMBD & DOM for POTUS & USDOJ in Anticipation of Litigation budget of CTR based upon market share. These secret cost allocations between the tobacco cartel were again in stark contrast to the Tobacco Companies' public pronouncements that CTR was truly an independent research entity. c. In a 1978 letter from attorney William Shinn of Shook, Hardy & Bacon to, inter alia, Thomas Ahrensfeld, Ernest Pepples and Arthur Sevens, insisted that future activities of the Research Liaison Committee should first be reviewed by the Committee of Counsel for the Tobacco Companies. d. A 1980 letter from the President of the Tobacco Institute to various insurance companies protested discounts being offered to non-smokers and falsely attacked the credibility of any scientific research showing the hazards of smoking. e. A letter dated March 31, 1980 from Bob Seligman of Philip Morris, U.S.A. to Alex Spears of Lorillard Tobacco Company, specified certain subjects which should be avoided for tobacco industry research, including inter alia, "attempt[s] to relate human disease to smoking," though the Defendants previously represented that they would cooperate with public health officials. f. Letters dated May 7, 1982 exchanged between Daniel Milway of the Tobacco Institute and various presidents of the Tobacco Companies regarding the level of funding to support independent biomedical research expose the pretense of the Tobacco Companies purported commitment to independent research as communicated to public officials and others. 68