Museado / NARA Collection wjc-dpc — Collection wjc-dpc
Recent Folios
Login Register
English (inglés) español magyar (húngaro) हिन्दी (hindi)

Survos folio page chat

[Tobacco] Target List

Ask the Scholar

Page 40 of 40
I can add historical knowledge about this page.

Page image

Page 40

OCR

TOBACCO - TARGET Selected Tobacco Votes, S 1415 94562878 P.02 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Comments Description Table Table Table Cover- Table Table Table Cloture Waive Kennedy Gregg Durbin dell Gramm Ketry Reed Budget Act Senator Abraham Y N N Y N N Y Y N Bennett Y Y N Y N N Y Y Y Bond Y N N Y N N Y N N Brownback Y N N Y N Y Y N N Campbell Y N Y Y N N Y N N Chafee N Y N N Y N N Y Y Collins Y N N Y Y N N Y Y JUL-01-1998 14:16 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO D'Amato N N N Y N N N Y Y DeWine Y Y N Y N Y N Y Y Domenici Y N N Y N N Y N N Frist Y Y Y Y N Y Y Y N Gorten Y Y Y Y N Y Y N N Grassley N N N Y N N Y Y Y Hagel Y N Y Y N Y Y N N Hatch Y Y + Y N N Y N N Jeffords N Y N N Y N N Y Y Lugar N N Y Y N Y Y N N Mack Y Y Y Y Y Y Y N N McCain Y Y Y Y N N Y Y Y 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Comments Description Table Table Tible Cover- Table Table Table Cloure Waive 94562878 P.03 Kennedy Gregg Durbin dell Gramm Kerry Reed Budget Act Senator Roberts Y N N Y N Y Y N N Roth Y N Y Y N Y N Y Y Smith, G. N N N Y N N Y Y Y Snowe N N N Y Y N N Y Y Specter N N - - - - - - - Stevens Y Y Y Y N Y Y N N Key: Y Yea N Nay + Annourced For JUL-01-1998 14:17 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO - Did No: Vote JUL-01-1998 14:17 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO 94562878 P.04 1 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 144 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Cigarette Taxes. McCain, R-Ariz., motion to table (kill) the Kennedy, D-Mass., amendment to the modified Senate Commerce Committee substitute amendment. The Kennedy amendment would replace language in the bill that would raise the federal cigarette fees by $1.10 per pack with language to raise the fees by $1.50 per pack. Motion agreed to 58-40: R 45-8; D 13-32 (ND 8-29, SD 5-3). May 20, 1998. Item Key: 13347 2 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 145 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Tobacco Industry Liability. McCain, R-Ariz., motion to table (kill) the Gregg, R-N.H., amendment that would eliminate the bill's $8 billion annual cap on legal damages that tobacco companies could be forced to pay. Motion rejected 37-61: R 17-37; D 20-24 (ND 14-22, SD 6-2). May 21, 1998. A "yea" was a vote in support of the president's position. Item Key: 13356 3 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 149 ** $1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Look-Back Provisions. Lott, R-Miss., motion Lo table (kill) the Durbin, D-III., amendment to the Durbin amendment to the Gramm, R-Texas, motion to recommit the bill with instructions. The second-degree Durbin amendment, which is virtually identical to the underlying Durbin amendment, would toughen the bill's so-called look-back provisions, which would penalize the tobacco industry for failure to achieve targeted reductions in youth smoking. The amendment raises the underlying bill's 10-year reduction target from 60 percent to 67 percent and lifts the maximum annual penalties from $4 billion to $7 billion. Motion rejected 29-66: R 24-28; D 5-38 (ND 0-35, SD 5-3). June 04, 1998. (Subsequently, the second-degree Durbin amendment was adopted by voice vote.) Item Key: 13383 4 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 151 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Drug Prevention. Coverdell, R-Ga., amendment to the Durbin, D-I11., amendment to the Gramm, R-Texas, motion to recommit the bill with instructions. The Coverdell amendment would authorize $16 billion over five years from the bill's tobacco revenues for drug prevention efforts. It would increase funding for border patrol, as well as anti-drug trafficking efforts of the FBI and the Drug Enforcement Administration, allow federal funds to be spent on school vouchers for public school children who have been victims of violent crimes on school property, ban federal funding for needle-exchange programs and encourage states to establish voluntary drug testing programs for all first-time individuals seeking a driver's license. Adopted 52-46: R 52-2; D 0-44 (ND 0-36, SD 0-8). June 09, 1998. 1 Washington Abl Congressonal Quarter JUL-01-1998 14:18 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO 94562878 P.05 Item Key: 13394 5 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 154 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Marriage Penalty. Kerry, D-Mass., motion to table (kill) the Gramm, R-Texas, amendment to the Durbin, D-Ill., amendment to the Gramm motion to recommit the bill with instructions. The Gramm amendment would allow couples with combined incomes under $50,000 a year to claim an additional $3,300 income tax deduction, thus eliminating the so-called marriage penalty for those in that income bracket, at a cost of $46 billion over 10 years. The amendment also would allow self-employed individuals to deduct the full cost of their health insurance on their income taxes. Motion rejected 48-50: R 5-49; D 43-1 (ND 36-0, SD 7-1). June 10, 1998. (Subsequently, the Gramm amendment was adopted by voice vote.) Item Key: 13405 6 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 157 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Child Care Block Grants. McCain, R-Ariz., motion to table (kill) the Kerry, D-Mass., amendment to the Durbin, D-Ill., amendment to the Gramm, R-Texas, motion to recommit the bill with instructions. The Kerry amendment would require states to spend at least 50 percent of the restricted-use tobacco revenue, which is 50 percent of the money states would receive, on the child care and development block grant programs. Motion rejected 33-66: R 33-21; D 0-45 (ND 0-37, SD 0-8). June 11, 1998. (Subsequently, the Kerry amendment, after being modified, was adopted by voice vote.) Item Key: 13418 7 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 159 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Advertising Tax Deductions. Gorton, R-wash., motion to table (kill) the Reed, D-R.I., amendment to the Durbin, D-Ill., amendment to the Gramm, R-Texas, motion to recommit the bill with instructions. The Reed amendment would eliminate advertising tax deductions for those tobacco companies that the Food and Drug Administration determines are directing their advertisements at children. Motion rejected 47-47: R 43-9; D 4-38 (ND 2-32, SD 2-6). June 15, 1998. Item Key: 13423 8 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 161 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Cloture. Motion to invoke cloture (thus limiting debate) on the modified Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee substitute amendment to the bill to increase tobacco restrictions. The substitute would require the tobacco industry to pay $516 billion over 25 years for anti-smoking, education and research programs, raise taxes on cigarettes by $1.10 per pack over five years, grant authority to the Food and Drug Administration to regulate nicotine and impose penalties on the tobacco industry if youth smoking does not decrease by 60 percent over 10 years. 2 Washington AN -, Congressional Burnery JUL-01-1998 14:18 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO 94562878 P.06 Motion rejected 57-42: - R 14-40; D 43-2 (ND 37-0, SD 6-2). June 17, 1998. Three-fifths of the total Senate (60) is required to invoke cloture. A "yea" was a vote in support of the president's position. Item Key: 13434 9 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 162 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Budget Act Waiver. Daschle, D-S.D., motion to waive the Budget Act with respect to the Stevens, R-Alaska, point of order against the bill to increase tobacco restrictions. The bill, as amended, would require the tobacco industry to pay $516 billion over 25 years for anti-smoking, education and research programs, raise taxes on cigarettes by $1.10 per pack over five years, grant authority to the Food and Drug Administration to regulate nicotine and impose penalties on the tobacco industry if youth smoking does not decrease by 60 percent over 10 years. Motion rejected 53-46: R 11-43; D 42 3 (ND 37-0, SD 5-3). June 17, 1998. A three-fifths majority vote (60) of the total Senate is required to waive the Budget Act. (Subsequently, the chair upheld the point of order, and the bill was returned to the Senate Commerce Committee.) A "yea" was a vote in support of the president's position. Item Key: 13435 3 Washington AM - Corpressond Quarterly Today's debate: Buying influence Did tobacco company money kill the anti-smoking bill? OUR VIEW One link is plain to see. Weak fund-raising Tobacco vote laws keep biggest gifts hidden. Senators' campaign contributions from tobacco political action committees and For a money-hungry politician, feeding at individuals, 1993-98, and the two votes the table of Big Tobacco can be quite tasty. The that killed the tobacco bill last week 46 senators who obliged their cancer-peddling (y is for the bill; n against the bill): patrons by voting to kill the anti-smoking bill last week have taken in more than $1.3 million Senator Total Votes Helms, R-N.C. $118,950 n-n in tobacco money since 1993. Faircloth, R-N.C. 108,486 n-n Not surprisingly. of the 15 senators who McConnell, R-Ky. 86,575 n-n pocketed the most, 13 were on the industry's Thompson, R-Tenn. 65,850 n-n side in the final vote. Among the biggest bene- Hollings, D-S.C. 62,900 y-n ficiaries are senators from Michigan, Pennsyl- Hutchison, R-Texas 53,123 n-n vania, even Montana - far from tobacco coun- Warner, R-Va. 49,816 n-n Robb, D-Va. 42,950 n-n try. It's the latest sordid example of the links D'Amato, R-N.Y. 41,166 y-y between politics and special-interest money. Burns, R-Mont. 38,500 n-n But those visible exchanges, which voters Dodd, D-Conn. 35,249 y-y presumably can judge. aren't even the worst of Santorum, R-Pa. 34,500 n-n it. Hidden donations amount to far more. Gramm, R-Texas 32,750 n-n Nearly 75% of Big Tobacco's efforts to pur- Abraham, R-Mich. 30,700 y-n chase favor - $30 million since 1987 and Inhofe, R-Okla. 30,500 n-n Coverdell, R-Ga. 29,500 n-n more than $4 million last year alone - is fun- Shelby, R-Ala. 26,666 n-n neled through back channels where its final Kerrey, D-Neb. 26,500 y-y destination can't be tracked. Craig, R-Idaho 26,000 n-n At least 18 members of Congress serve as Lott, R-Miss. 25,850 n-n conduits for tobacco money to reach their col- Hagel, R-Neb. 24,000 n-n leagues through innocuous-sounding "leader- Smith, R-N.H. 24,000 n-n Allard, R-Colo. 23,450 n-n ship political action committees." Senate Campbell, R-Colo. 23,166 n-n Majority Leader Trent Lott and Majority Whip Frist, R-Tenn. 23,000 y-n Don Nickles, for example, each have "majority Roberts, R-Kan. 22,097 n-n fund" accounts to route thousands in tobacco DeWine, R-Ohio 22,000 y-y and other special-interest money to others. Thomas, R-Wyo. 22,000 n-n Further, the bulk of tobacco's "investment" Grams, R-Minn. 19,000 n-n Kyl, R-Ariz. 17,500 n-n in politicians is in "soft money," a loophole Thurmond, R-S.C. 17,500 n-n that lets corporations, unions and wealthy indi- Conrad, D-N.D. 17,000 y-y viduals evade the legal curbs on contributions. Breaux, D-La. 15,000 y-y Republican and Democratic committees served Roth, R-Del. 14,750 y-y as money laundries for more than $3.2 million Lieberman, D-Conn. 14,500 y-y from tobacco (82% to Republicans) in the most Nickles, R-Okla. 14,166 n-n Cochran, R-Miss. 14,000 n-n recent 15 months reported. Philip Morris has Domenici, R-N.M. 14,000 n-n been the GOP's No. 1 sugar daddy for three Mack, R-Fla. 13,000 n-n years running. Bryan, D-Nev. 12,500 y-y With this kind of addiction, small wonder Kerry, D-Mass. 12,000 y-y that party leaders killed modest campaign Kempthorne, R-Idaho 11,166 n-n reform in the Senate and are trying to do so in Grassley, R-lowa 11,166 y-y the House. As long as campaigns are paid for Moynihan, D-N.Y. 9,500 y-y Ford, D-Ky. 9,000 n-n by tobacco and other interests, not by the pub- Gorton, R-Wash. 9,000 n-n lic, no one should be surprised that they win. Hatch, R-Utah 9,000 n-n Ashcroft, R-Mo. 8.000 n-n MONDAY, JUNE 22, 1998 USA TODAY OPPOSING VIEW I take contri- Baucus, D-Mont. 8,000 y-y butions. So Bond, R-Mo. 8,000 n-n Inouye, D-Hawaii 8,000 y-y what? The issue is free speech. Snowe, R-Maine 8,000 y-y Specter, R-Pa. 7,916 absent By Mitch McConnell Reid, D-Nev. 7,000 y-y Moseley-Braun, D-III. 5,500 y-y The brouhaha over tobacco contributions il- Murkowski, R-Alaska 5,166 n-n lustrates the power of public disclosure. Being Gregg, R-N.H. 5,166 y-n from a tobacco state, I proudly hail my tobac- Torricelli, D-N.J. 5,000 y-y CO contributions. Politicians from other states Wyden, D-Ore. 5,000 y-y Levin, D-Mich. 4,250 y-y brag of spurning them. To each his own; the Cleland, D-Ga. 4,000 y-y voters can be trusted to decide what is appro- Daschle, D-S.D. 4,000 y-y priate. To that end, I trust USA TODAY will Lautenberg, D-N.J. 4,000 y-y analyze the relationship between trial-lawyer McCain, R-Ariz. 4,000 y-y contributions and votes against fee caps in the Rockefeller, D-W.Va. 4,000 y-y tobacco bill: Kennedy, D-Mass. 3,250 y-y Byrd, D-W.Va. 3,000 85% of trial-lawyer contributions to fed- y-y Bennett, R-Utah 2,666 y-y eral campaigns in the 1995-96 election cycle Landrieu, D-La. 2,500 y-y went to Democrats. Lugar, R-ind. 2,500 n-n 90% of Senate Democrats last week vot- Akaka, D-Hawaii 2,000 y-y ed against an amendment to the tobacco bill to Coats, R-Ind. 2,000 n-n cap lawyer fees at $4,000 an hour; 90% voted Dorgan, D-N.D. 2,000 y-y against a $1,000-an-hour cap; 98% voted Graham, D-Fla. 2,000 y-y Harkin, D-lowa 2,000 y-y against a $250-an-hour cap. Johnson, D-S.D. 2,000 y-y Is the Democrats' trial-lawyer bonanza at- Smith, R-Ore. 2,000 y-y tributable to principles attracting contributions Feingold, D-Wis. 1,900 y-y or contributions dictating principles, including Hutchinson, R-Ark. 1,750 n-n a nearly universal aversion to any caps on tri- Jeffords, R-Vt. 1,100 y-y al-lawyer fees? Are trial lawyers motivated by Biden, D-Del. 1,000 y-y Durbin, D-III. 1,000 y-y principle in their strident opposition to fee caps Feinstein, D-Calif. 1,000 y-y or because so many of them stand to become Glenn, D-Ohio 1,000 y-y billionaires from tobacco lawsuit fees exceed- Sarbanes, D-Md. 1,000 y-y ing $90,000 an hour? Reed, D-R.I 500 y-y USA TODAY sees campaign finance "re- Leahy, D-Vt. 250 y-y form" as salvation from so-called "special in- Collins, R-Maine 200 y-y Bingaman, D-N.M. 0 terests" - a reformer pejorative reserved for y-y Boxer, D-Calif. 0 y-y practicing capitalists. The reform agenda USA Brownback, R-Kan. 0 n-n TODAY advocates stifles speech and partici- Bumpers, D-Ark. 0 y-y pation by citizens, candidates, groups and par- Chafee, R-R.I. 0 y-y ties, and it is stymied by the Constitution. To- Enzi, R-Wyo. 0 n-n bacco is a convenient nemesis, but USA Kohl, D-Wis. 0 y-y Mikulski, D-Md. 0 TODAY's agenda extends far beyond that in- y-y Murray, D-Wash. 0 y-y dustry, as it silences the voices of anyone not Sessions, R-Ala. 0 n-n fortunate enough to control a newspaper. Stevens, R-Alaska 0 n-n Wellstone, D-Minn. 0 y-y Sen. Mitch McConnell. R-Ky., chairs the Na- Source. Center for Reponsive Politics. Federal Election Commission and USA TODAY research tional Republican Senatorial Committee. Peep shows Ozzie and Harriet (1952-1966), which invit- ed viewers to share the sanitized upbringing of David and Ricky Nelson. And it explains Last Tuesday, a woman identified only as our morbid interest in documentaries like An Elizabeth gave birth live on the Internet. This American Family, the 1973 PBS series chart- comes hard on the heels of such exhibition- ing the disintegration of the Loud family. ist exercises as the JenniCam, which is fo- What's the universal appeal of such tech- cused unblinkingly on the quarters of Jennifer no-peeping? We are all closet voyeurs, of Ringley. She doesn't shrink from it for any course. But maybe we are all closet exhibi- activity. tionists, too. Maybe we sense that liberation The urge to share too much (and the equal is nothing more than the lack of shame. Ei- urge to peek too much) is a constant force of ther way, the future seems obvious. Eventu- human nature. It explains our uneasy interest ally. point-and-shoot, point-and-click tech- in movies like The Truman Show, about a nology will make candid windows onto character whose entire life is secretly script- mundane events too common to care about. ed and broadcast. It explains our cheerful in- Then viewers will have to get a new life - terest in such shows as The Adventures of their own. USA TODAY MONDAY, JUNE 22, 1998 TUBACCO- CLOTURE 6/17/98 Target list (green file) Abraha DeWine Chefre Gregg Jeffrds Grassley Melain D'Amato Shave First Roth Bennett 6.Smith Collins t Robb Inhofe Halen Thumad Coats B.de Coder Robts Alake Sandonm keypthome Feingold X Ford Altahier Reid Enzi Wamen M-B Thompson Thomas Reed Lugar Campbell Johnson Fairsbill Branback Hollings kyl Sessions (Clelad ?) Hutchison Shelby Magel Murkoushi Bond Starms Mack TAP cur DRUG ENE. INTER. CAP ON LAWER'S FEES TOUGHENED WOK-BACK 10°K - BACK CHILD CARE FUNDING RUBIN SAFE PRES LETTER LETTER or - VER / SAP / ON COVERDALE cov. + TERM. , ERSKINE LETTER/ PETER. z CHECK FORCES ON N. DAKOTA BOTH TRANSPORT & FARMERS. w FED. HERITAGE ADVISORY 10 RIVERS (NEKT MONTH) ** 7 TOURISM TERSON ON NCC 5 BYRD MEETING 6 HOAE: ABRAHAM - HOLLINGS BENNETT - 98 FORD BOND - 98 ROBB- DASCHLE BROWNBACK 98 CORTON - VP GRASSLEY - 98 cleland GRESS - 98 Ferustein CHATCH- Tarricelli KEMPTHORNE ERSKINE 98 MACK ERSKINE C. Varmas) MURKOWSKI- - 98 MY ROTH- SMITH - STEVENS 98 sb, a Sto Donna Chalee Specter ?? Telferds Surve dollars D. D'Aniato Dewine FUST Lufar Coch-an Sessions Bruce Reed DATE: June 17, 1998 9:17 Rahm 62531 9:49 Eileen O'Connor 638-5234 10:10 Ron Fournier 776-9441 10:13 Cynthia Rice 62846 10:20 John Harris 334-7401 11:00 Larry Stein Call him in VP's office when you get in the car 12:02 Bennett Kelly 213-8921977 12:10 Sally Katzen 62800 Re: Benchmarking issue of poverty measurements -- she wants to call DOC and wants to know where we are 2:25 Jeff Nesbitt 703-589-1320 3:00 Jeff Nesbitt 703-589-1320 Bill Knapp 5:15pm against pe C Inhole Smith 622 63 Beneft 55 I'm mining Mc Roth for relection 65m (Vemp) Cyr 50% But whity are Ste Grass Che Band Vempthome people her? Benett Gorton Dick M. Jef Shelly Gress Mack EB-Lott Snow Abroah campbell BC on hand job Collie, you says have as bu Fult Bruback Cochum Any they have dent dirty Dev Make Abraham 4 62564 Da A JUN. - 17'98 (WED) 05:47 P. 001 JUN 17 1998 (Date) Roll Call Vote Legislative NO. 161 SUBJECT MOTION To INVOKE CLOTURE ON THE MODIFIED COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE to S. 1415 YEAS NAYS Abraham Akaka 100 5:19p Allard Ashcroft Baucus Bennett Biden / Bingaman Bond 7 Boxer ARE to Breaux Brownback Bryan Bumpers Burns / Byrd Campbell 4 Chafee 5 Cleland Coats Cochran Collins na 6 Conrad Coverdell Craig 2 D'Amato N Daschle DeWine 8 Dodd Domenici L 9 Dorgan à Durbin Enzi Faireloth Feingold 11 Feinstein ars Ford Frist Glenn Garton 4 3 Graham, Florida Gramm, Texas Grams, Minnesota Grassley Gregg IIngel Harkin Hatch 5 Grams, Minnesota Grassley Gregg Hagel Harkin Hatch 4 Helms 6 Hollings Hutchinson, Arkansas Hutchison, Texhs Inhofe Inouye 13 Jeffords Johnson Kempthorne 14 Kennedy 15 Kerrey, Nebraska 16 Kerry, Massachnectts Kohl Kyl 17 Landrieu ns 18 Lautenberg Leahy Levin 19 Lieberinan Lott 7 Lugar Mack 20 McCain McConnell 8 R/ Mikulski 115 Moseley-Braun 115 22 Moynihan Murkowski 23 Murray MRS. Nickles 9 Reed, Rhode Island Reid, Nevada Robb 10 Roberts 24 Rockefeller Roth Santorum Surbanes Sessions Shelby Smith, New Humpshire Smith, Oregon 25 Snowe MS. Specter + Stevens Thomas Thompson Thurmond 26 Torricolli Warner Wellstone Wyden CPU. 1990 17-010 (iner) 57 42 700 55:47 (07M) 86 LI NOC Bruce N. Reed 06/15/98 07:05:25 PM Record Type: Record To: Elena Kagan/OPD/EOP, Cynthia A. Rice/OPD/EOP CC: Subject: Target List Here's a working list for cloture and the point of order. What do you think? SOLID REPUBLICANS (11) Bond Chafee Collins D'Amato -DeWine Frist Jeffords Lugar McCain Gordon Smith Snowe LEAN YES (2-3) Campbell - LN Grassley Specter (if he recovers) COULD GO EITHER WAY (8) Abraham Bennett Gorton LY Gregg Mack - LN ( Harold Varmus to call) Stevens Murkowski LN Roth LONG SHOTS (5) - Brownback Burns Cochran (Stevens) Domenici Hatch Kyl Kempthorne (- (- call EB) Sessions DEMOCRATS SURE TO OPPOSE CLOTURE (2) Ford Robb DEMOCRATS WHO PROBABLY VOTE FOR CLOTURE BUT AGAINST THE BILL (4) Cleland Feinstein Hollings Torricelli Senate Roll Call Vote http://www.cspan.org/rollcall/v985201.htm Description During debate on tobacco legislation, Senators tabled an amendment offered by Sen. John Ashcroft (R-MO) that would have eliminated the proposed tax increase on cigarettes. In effect, tabling an amendment in the Senate kills it. An "aye" vote is opposed to the amendment. Yea - 72 Nay - 26 Present - 1 NV - 1 27 R; 45 D 26 R; 0 D 1 R; 0 D 1 R; 0 D Abraham, Spencer (R-MI) Allard, Wayne (R-CO)? Lott, Trent Smith, Bob Bennett, Robert F. (R-UT) Ashcroft, John (R-MO) (R-MS) (R-NH) Bond, Christopher S. (R-MO) Burns, Conrad R. (R-MT) Brownback, Sam (R-KS)- Coats, Dan (R-IN) ? ? Campbell, Ben Nighthorse Cochran, Thad (R-MS) (R-CO) Coverdell, Paul (R-GA) Chafee, John H. (R-RI) Craig, Larry E. (R-ID) ? Collins, Susan (R-ME)- Domenici, Pete V. (R-NM) D'Amato, Alfonse M. (R-NY). Enzi, Mike (R-WY) DeWine, Mike (R-OH) Faircloth, Lauch (R-NC) Frist, William H. (R-TN) Gramm, Phil (R-TX) ? Gorton, Slade (R-WA) Grams, Rod (R-MN) Grassley, Charles (R-IA) ? Hagel, Chuck (R-NE)? Gregg, Judd (R-NH)- Helms, Jesse (R-NC) ? Hatch, Orrin G. (R-UT) Hutchison, Kay Bailey Jeffords, James M. (R-VT) (R-TX)- Lugar, Richard G. (R-IN) Hutchinson, Tim (R-AR) Mack, Connie (R-FL) Inhofe, James M. (R-OK) McCain, John (R-AZ) Kempthorne, Dirk (R-ID) ? Murkowski, Frank H. (R-AK)(i Kyl, Jon (R-AZ)- Roberts, Pat (R-KS)? McConnell, Mitch (R-KY) Roth, William V., Jr. (R-DE) Nickles, Don (R-OK) Santorum, Rick (R-PA) ? Sessions, Jeff (R-AL) Smith, Gordon (R-OR)- ? Shelby, Richard C. (R-AL) Snowe, Olympia J. (R-ME) ? Thomas, Craig (R-WY) Specter, Arlen (R-PA)- Thompson, Fred (R-TN) Stevens, Ted (R-AK) Warner, John W. (R-VA) Thurmond, Strom (R-SC) Akaka, Daniel K. (D-HI) Baucus, Max (D-MT) Biden, Joseph R., Jr.(D-DE) Bingaman, Jeff (D-NM) Boxer, Barbara (D-CA) Breaux, John B. (D-LA) Bryan, Richard H. (D-NV) Bumpers, Dale (D-AR) Byrd, Robert C. (D-WV) 17-8 firm 60P Gregg Cleland, Max (D-GA) 11% ? Conrad, Kent (D-ND) Dodd, Christopher J. (D-CT) Tear yes Dorgan, Byron L. (D-ND) 22 4 firm yes Durbin, Richard (D-IL) Daschle, Thomas A. (D-SD) Feingold, Russell D. (D-WI) Feinstein, Dianne (D-CA) Ford, Wendell H. (D-KY) Glenn, John (D-OH) Graham, Bob (D-FL) Harkin, Tom (D-IA) 1 of 2 05/21/98 11:58:01 Recent Roll Call Votes http://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HITM Legislative Activities RECENT FLOOR VOTES The following record votes took place on the Senate floor during the past week. (Rollcall Vote No. 158 Leg.) June 11, 1998, 5:45 PM BILL NO.: S.1415 AMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2701 TITLE: Motion to Table Faircloth Amdt. No. 2701 REQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2 RESULT: Motion to Table Agreed to YEAS--50 Akaka Glenn Mikulski Baucus - Gorton Moseley-Braun - Bennett Graham Moynihan 38 D, 12 R Biden Harkin Murray Breaux - Hatch Reed Bryan Hollings Reid - Campbell Inouye Robb Cleland - Jeffords Rockefeller - Cochran Johnson - Roth Conrad Kennedy Sarbanes - D'Amato Kerrey - Shelby Daschle Kerry - Smith (OR) - DeWine Kohl - Thompson Durbin Landrieu Torricelli Feingold Lautenberg Wellstone Feinstein Leahy Wyden Ford Levin NAYS--45 41 R, 4D Abraham Enzi Lugar Allard Faircloth Mack Ashcroft Frist McCain Bond Gramm McConnell Brownback Grams Murkowski Burns Grassley Nickles - Byrd Gregg Roberts Chafee Hagel Santorum 1 of 9 06/14/98 17:08:21 Recent Roll Call Votes http://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM Coats Helms Sessions Collins Hutchinson Smith (NH) Coverdell Hutchison Snowe Craig Inhofe Stevens - Dodd Kempthorne Thomas Domenici Kyl Thurmond - Dorgan - Lieberman Warner ANSWERED 'PRESENT' 2 Boxer Lott NOT VOTING 3 Bingaman Bumpers Specter (Rollcall Vote No. 157 Leg.) June 11, 1998, 2:10 PM BILL NO.: S.1415 AMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2689 TITLE: Motion to Table Kerry Amdt. No. 2689 REQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2 RESULT: Motion to Table Failed YEAS 33 Allard Grams McConnell Ashcroft Gregg Nickles Brownback Hagel Roberts Coats Helms Roth Cochran Hutchinson Santorum Craig Inhofe Sessions DeWine Kempthorne Smith (NH) Enzi Kyl Stevens Frist Lott Thomas Gorton Lugar Thompson Gramm Mack Thurmond NAYS 66 45D, 21 R Abraham - Domenici Lautenberg Akaka Dorgan Leahy Baucus Durbin Levin - Bennett - Faircloth Lieberman Biden Feingold - McCain Bingaman Feinstein Mikulski - Bond Ford Moseley-Braun Boxer Glenn Moynihan Breaux Graham - Murkowski Bryan - Grassley Murray Bumpers Harkin Reed - Burns - Hatch Reid Byrd Hollings Robb - Campbell - Hutchison Rockefeller 2 of 9 06/14/98 17:08:21 Recent Roll Call Votes http://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM - Chafee Inouye Sarbanes Cleland - Jeffords - Shelby - Collins Johnson - Smith (OR) Conrad Kennedy - Snowe - Coverdell Kerrey Torricelli - D'Amato Kerry - Warner Daschle Kohl Wellstone Dodd Landrieu Wyden NOT VOTING--- 1 Specter (Rollcall Vote No. 156 Leg.) June 11, 1998, 12:01 PM BILL NO.: S.1415 TITLE: Motion to invoke cloture on modified Committee substitute REQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 3/5 RESULT: Cloture Motion Rejected YEAS--43 Akaka Feingold Levin Baucus Feinstein Lieberman Biden Glenn Mikulski Bingaman Graham Moseley-Braun Boxer Harkin Moynihan Breaux Hollings Murray Bryan Inouye Reed Bumpers Johnson Reid Byrd Kennedy Rockefeller Cleland Kerrey Sarbanes Conrad Kerry Torricelli Daschle Kohl Wellstone Dodd Landrieu Wyden Dorgan Lautenberg Durbin Leahy NAYS--56 Abraham - Ford McCain Allard Frist McConnell Ashcroft Gorton Murkowski Bennett Gramm Nickles Bond Grams Robb Brownback Grassley Roberts Burns Gregg Roth Campbell Hagel Santorum Chafee Hatch Sessions Coats Helms Shelby Cochran Hutchinson Smith (NH) Collins Hutchison Smith (OR) Coverdell Inhofe Snowe Craig Jeffords Stevens D'Amato Kempthorne Thomas DeWine Kyl Thompson 3 of 9 06/14/98 17:08:21 Recent Roll Call Votes http://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM Domenici Lott Thurmond Enzi Lugar Warner Faircloth Mack NOT VOTING 1 Specter (Rollcall Vote No. 155 Leg.) June 10, 1998, 7:12 PM BILL NO.: S.1415 AMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2688 TITLE: Motion to Table Daschle Amdt. No. 2688 REQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2 RESULT: Motion to Table Agreed to YEAS - 55 Abraham - Feingold McCain Allard Frist McConnell Ashcroft Gorton Murkowski Bennett Gramm Nickles Bond Grams Roberts Brownback Grassley Roth Burns Gregg Santorum Campbell Hagel Sessions Chafee Hatch Shelby Coats Helms Smith (NH) Cochran Hutchinson Smith (OR) Collins Hutchison Snowe Coverdell Inhofe Stevens Craig Jeffords Thomas D'Amato Kempthorne Thompson DeWine Kyl Thurmond Domenici Lott Warner Enzi Lugar Faircloth Mack NAYS--43 Akaka Ford Lieberman Baucus Glenn Mikulski Bingaman Graham Moseley-Braun Boxer Harkin Moynihan Breaux Hollings Murray Bryan Inouye Reed Bumpers Johnson Reid Byrd Kennedy Robb Cleland Kerrey Rockefeller Conrad Kerry Sarbanes Daschle Kohl Torricelli Dodd Landrieu Wellstone Dorgan Lautenberg Wyden Durbin Leahy Feinstein Levin 4 of 9 06/14/98 17:08:21 Recent Roll Call Votes http://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM NOT VOTING 2 Biden Specter (Rollcall Vote No. 154 Leg.) June 10, 1998, 6:44 PM BILL NO.: S.1415 AMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2686 TITLE: Motion to Table Gramm Amdt. No. 2686 as Modified REQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2 RESULT: Motion to Table Failed YEAS 48 Akaka Feingold Levin Baucus Feinstein Lieberman Bingaman Ford Mack Boxer Glenn Mikulski Breaux Graham Moseley-Braun Bryan Harkin Moynihan Bumpers Inouye Murray Byrd Jeffords Reed Chafee Johnson Reid Cleland Kennedy Robb Collins Kerrey Rockefeller Conrad Kerry Sarbanes Daschle Kohl Snowe Dodd Landrieu Torricelli Dorgan Lautenberg Wellstone Durbin Leahy Wyden NAYS 50 Abraham Frist McCain Allard Gorton McConnell Ashcroft Gramm Murkowski Bennett Grams Nickles Bond Grassley Roberts Brownback Gregg Roth Burns Hagel Santorum Campbell Hatch Sessions Coats Helms Shelby Cochran Hollings Smith (NH) Coverdell Hutchinson Smith (OR) Craig Hutchison Stevens D'Amato Inhofe Thomas DeWine Kempthorne Thompson Domenici Kyl Thurmond Enzi Lott Warner Faircloth Lugar NOT VOTING 2 Biden Specter 5 of 9 06/14/98 17:08:21 Recent Roll Call Votes http://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM (Rollcall Vote No. 153 Leg.) June 10, 1998, 11:04 AM BILL NO.: S.1415 TITLE: Motion to Invoke Cloture on Modified Committee Substitute on S.1415 REQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 3/5 RESULT: Cloture Motion Rejected YEAS 43 Akaka Feingold Levin Baucus Feinstein Lieberman Biden Glenn Mikulski Bingaman Graham Moseley-Braun Boxer Harkin Moynihan Breaux Hollings Murray Bryan Inouye Reed Bumpers Johnson Reid Byrd Kennedy Rockefeller Cleland Kerrey Sarbanes Conrad Kerry Torricelli Daschle Kohl Wellstone Dodd Landrieu Wyden Dorgan Lautenberg Durbin Leahy NAYS--55 Abraham Ford McConnell Allard Frist Murkowski Ashcroft Gorton Nickles Bennett Gramm Robb Bond Grams Roberts Brownback Grassley Roth Burns Hagel Santorum Campbell Hatch Sessions Chafee Helms Shelby Coats Hutchinson Smith (NH) Cochran Hutchison Smith (OR) Collins Inhofe Snowe Coverdell Jeffords Stevens Craig Kempthorne Thomas D'Amato Kyl Thompson DeWine Lott Thurmond Domenici Lugar Warner Enzi Mack Faircloth McCain NOT VOTING 2 Gregg Specter (Rollcall Vote No. 152 Leg.) 6 of 9 06/14/98 17:08:21 Recent Roll Call Votes http://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM June 9, 1998, 6:40 PM BILL NO.: S.1415 AMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2634 TITLE: Daschle Amdt. No. 2634 Drug Subst. REQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2 RESULT: Amendment Rejected YEAS--45 Akaka Feingold Levin Baucus Feinstein Lieberman Biden Ford - McCain Bingaman Glenn Mikulski Boxer Graham Moseley-Braun Breaux Harkin Moynihan Bryan Hollings Murray Bumpers Johnson Reed Byrd Kennedy Reid Cleland Kerrey Robb Conrad Kerry Rockefeller Daschle Kohl Sarbanes Dodd Landrieu Torricelli Dorgan Lautenberg Wellstone Durbin Leahy Wyden NAYS--53 Abraham Faircloth Mack Allard Frist McConnell Ashcroft Gorton Murkowski Bennett Gramm Nickles Bond Grams Roberts Brownback Grassley Roth Burns Gregg Santorum Campbell Hagel Sessions Chafee Hatch Shelby Coats Helms Smith (NH) Cochran Hutchinson Smith (OR) Collins Hutchison Snowe Coverdell Inhofe Stevens Craig Jeffords Thomas D'Amato Kempthorne Thompson DeWine Kyl Thurmond Domenici Lott Warner Enzi Lugar NOT VOTING---2 Inouye Specter (Rollcall Vote No. 151 Leg.) June 9, 1998, 6:14 PM BILL NO.: S.1415 7 of 9 06/14/98 17:08:21 Recent Roll Call Votes http://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM AMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2451 TITLE: Coverdell Amdt. No. 2451, as modified REQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2 RESULT: Amendment Agreed to YEAS--52 Abraham Frist McConnell Allard Gorton Murkowski Ashcroft Gramm Nickles Bennett Grams Roberts Bond Grassley Roth Brownback Gregg Santorum Burns Hagel Sessions Campbell Hatch Shelby Coats Helms Smith (NH) Cochran Hutchinson Smith (OR) Collins Hutchison Snowe Coverdell Inhofe Stevens Craig Kempthorne Thomas D'Amato Kyl Thompson DeWine Lott Thurmond Domenici Lugar Warner Enzi Mack Faircloth McCain NAYS 46 Akaka Feingold Levin Baucus Feinstein Lieberman Biden Ford Mikulski Bingaman Glenn Moseley-Braun Boxer Graham Moynihan Breaux Harkin Murray Bryan Hollings Reed Bumpers Jeffords Reid Byrd Johnson Robb - Chafee Kennedy Rockefeller Cleland Kerrey Sarbanes Conrad Kerry Torricelli Daschle Kohl Wellstone Dodd Landrieu Wyden Dorgan Lautenberg Durbin Leahy NOT VOTING 2 Inouye Specter (Rollcall Vote No. 150 Leg.) June 9, 1998, 2:15 PM BILL NO.: S.1415 TITLE: Motion to Invoke Cloture on Modified Committee Substitute to S.1415 REQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 3/5 8 of 9 06/14/98 17:08:21 Recent Roll Call Votes http://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM. RESULT: Cloture Motion Rejected YEAS 42 Akaka Durbin Leahy Baucus Feingold Levin Biden Feinstein Lieberman Bingaman Glenn Mikulski Boxer Graham Moseley-Braun Breaux Harkin Moynihan Bryan Hollings Murray Bumpers Johnson Reed Byrd Kennedy Reid Cleland Kerrey Rockefeller Conrad Kerry Sarbanes Daschle Kohl Torricelli Dodd Landrieu Wellstone Dorgan Lautenberg Wyden NAYS - 56 Abraham - Ford McCain Allard Frist McConnell Ashcroft Gorton Murkowski Bennett Gramm Nickles Bond Grams Robb Brownback Grassley Roberts Burns Gregg Roth Campbell Hagel Santorum Chafee Hatch Sessions Coats Helms Shelby Cochran Hutchinson Smith (NH) Collins Hutchison Smith (OR) Coverdell Inhofe Snowe Craig Jeffords Stevens D'Amato Kempthorne Thomas DeWine Kyl Thompson Domenici Lott Thurmond Enzi Lugar Warner Faircloth Mack NOT VOTING 2 Inouye Specter Back to the Roll Call Votes Page Last Updated JUNE 13, 1998 at 03:41:36 9 of 9 06/14/98 17:08:22 Rev. June 1, 1998 (6:09pm) Senator Staff Phone/fax Comments Sen. Abraham (MI) Elizabeth 4-6098 He supports Gramm amend., Kessler but thinks that Durbin 2nd degree amend. guts Gramm. If there is a cloture vote, he'll go w/ the leadership. His interest is small business and thinks they are taken care of in McCain bill. (5/26) Sen. Bennett (UT) Lisa Norton 4-5444/4-4908 left numerous messages for Chip Yost (LD) both Sen. Bond (MO) Joe Pierle 4-5721 Sen. favors the Dubin amend. and is leaning against Gramm amend. Cloture is not an option yet, and he doesn't see a need for FDA changes. (6/1) Sen. Campbell (CO) Ralssa Quintal 4-5852 left several messages Sen. Chafee (RI) Lisa Layman 4-6183/8-2853 Sen. believes it will be difficult to stave off tax cuts and illegal drug measures. He opposes Gramm; undecided on cloture at this time; not committed to FDA (5/28) Sen. Cochran (MS) Brad Prewitt 4-3063/4-9450 Sen. has not determined his position on Gramm amend. but is concerned that a motion to recommit is merely a delaying tactic that will prevent both a tax cut and tobacco legislation. As a member of the Approps. Committee, he is interested in getting a bill, but he has not said anything about cloture yet. He might consider supporting amendments to lessen FDA's authority. (6/1) 7398413 2 Sen. Collins (ME) Priscilla Hanley 4-2523 Sen. opposes Gramm because she believes funds should be used for tobacco/health related purposes; does support the Roth amend. for self employed. Too soon for cloture; not interested in changing FDA provisions. (6/1) Sen. D'Amato (NY) Adam Chrisney 4-6542 Sen. probably does not support the Gramm amend. on this bill. It is too soon for cloture and he is not in favor of significant changes to FDA (5/28) Sen. DeWine (OH) Robert Hoffman 4-2315/4-6519 He prefers money from S. 1415 for tobacco & public health activities, esp. for kids. He's leaning against Gramm, has no position on cloture or FDA. (6/1) Sen. Frist (TN) Sue Ramthun, 4-7139/8-5044 Katie and Sue are out this Pro-clature Anne Phelps, week; Anne believes that the No on Gramm Katie bill will not be taken up before Wednesday; Sen. supports FDA provisions, but she is not sure about Gramm amend. or cloture. Will check. (5/28) Sen. Gorton (WA) Jeanne Bumpus 4-3271 His position on Gramm amend. is unknown; will probably support cloture eventually. Main concerns are Constitution & having Indians collect tax. Takes his cue from A.G.s (5/26) 3 Sen. Grassley (IA) Jennifer Shaw 4-3744 He supports devoting some of Jim Yokum the revenue to tax cuts, but he prefers the Roth amends. He would not support cloture and his position on FDA amendments is unknown. (6/1) Sen. Jeffords (VT) Sharon Winn 4-3191/8-0411 Sen. would probably oppose Mark Powden 4-6770 the Gramm amend. and support cloture (5/29) Sen. Lugar (IN) Michael Knipe 4-5928/8-4575 Sen.'s position on Gramm is Daniel Diller 4-4814 not clear. He is a cosponsor (LD) of a bill to eliminate marriage penalty, but he might not support adding it to S. 1415, esp. if it threatens passage. But he does want the bill to include tax break. May support cloture later (esp. if his price support buy-out is included). Has no position on FDA, but is interested because of the Ag. Com. (6/1) Sen. Mack (FL) Wendy Gramm 4-4953 He might not support Gramm Mark Smith 4-5274/4-1907 amend. on this bill. Mark does not know if Sen. would support cloture. W/out liability caps, he'll have trouble supporting the bill, even with its spending for public health and farmers. (5/26) Sen. Roth (DE) Mark Eichler 4-2441 Would probably support the Gramm amend. It's far too soon for cloture. The bill will be brought up intermittently between now & August. (5/26) 4 Sen. G. Smith (OR) Annie Brown 4-3753 Sen. opposes the Gramm amend. on this bill. He supports the Durbin look back and the Lugar farmers provisions. He also supports what McCain has for FDA, although it is much more than he had in his bill. He would probably support cloture. (5/28) Sen. Snowe (ME) Tom Geier 4-5344 Sen. probably opposes the Gramm amend. It is too soon for cloture and does not want to diminish FDA authority, but is not wedded to current language. She is most interested in the advertising & marketing parts and is opposed to both approaches to farmers. (5/29) Sen. Specter (PA) Kevin Mathis 4-4254/8-1229 Sen.'s health precludes his participation for awhile (6/1) Sen. Stevens (AK) Ms. Chris 4-3004 Sen. has spoken directly to Schabacker the Secretary about his positions on S. 1415. He is mostly interested in getting the bill to conference. (6/1) Sen. Thompson (TN) Kelvin Moxley 4-4944 He will support anything that will kill the bill because it is big gov't, huge taxes, ineffective, and completely unconstitutional. (5/29) Sen. Warner (VA) Chas Phillips 4-6674 Sen.'s position on Gramm is not determined; does not support cloture. (6/1) 2:30 5/28 Senator Staff Phone/fax Comments Sen. Abraham (MI) Elizabeth Kessler 4-6098 He supports Gramm amend., but thinks that Durbin 2nd degree amend. guts Gramm. If there is a cloture vote, he'll go w/ the leadership. His interest is small business and thinks they are taken care of in McCain bill. (5/26) Sen. Bennett (UT) Lisa Norton 4-5444/4-4908 AA & LD are out this week Sen. Bond (MO) Joe Pierle 4-5721 out this week - no one else can speak about the issue Sen. Campbell (CO) Raissa Quintal 4-5852 out this week; her 2 assistants also are out (vacation & sick leave) Sen. Chafee (RI) Lisa Layman 4-6183/8-2853 Sen. believes it will be difficult to stave off tax cuts and illegal drug measures. He opposes Gramm; undecided on cloture at this time; not committed to FDA Sen. Collins (ME) Priscilla Hanley 4-2523 left voice message - fire drill until 2:30 Sen. D'Amato (NY) Adam Chrisney 4-6542 Sen. probably does not support the Gramm amend. on this bill. It is too soon for cloture and he is not in favor of significant changes to FDA Sen. DeWine (OH) Robert Hoffman 4-2315/4-6519 left voice message (2) Sen. Frist (TN) Sue Ramthun, 4-7139/8-5044 Katie and Sue are out this Anne Phelps, week; Anne believes that the Katie bill will not be taken up before Wednesday; Sen. supports FDA provisions, but she is not sure about Gramm amend. or cloture. Will check. 2 Sen. Gorton (WA) Jeanne Bumpus 4-3271 His position on Gramm amend. is unknown; will probably support cloture evenutally. Main concerns are Constitution & having Indians collect tax. Takes his cue from A.G.s (5/26) Sen. Grassley (IA) Jennifer Shaw 4-3744 left voice message (2) Jim Yokum Sen. Jeffords (VT) Sharon Winn 4-3191/8-0411 left voice message Sen. Lugar (IN) Michael Knipe 4-5928/8-4575 left voice message (2) Sen. Mack (FL) Wendy Gramm 4-4953 He might not support Gramm Mark Smith 4-5274/4-1907 amend. on this bill. Mark does not know if Sen. would support cloture. W/out liability caps, he'll have trouble supporting the bill, even with its spending for public health and farmers. (5/26) Sen. Roth (DE) Mark Eichler 4-2441 Would probably support the Gramm amend. It's far too soon for cloture. The bill will be brought up intermittently between now & August. (5/26) Sen. G. Smith (OR) Annie Brown 4-3753 Sen. opposes the Gramm amend. on this bill. He supports the Durbin lookback and the Lugar farmers provisions. He also supports what McCain has for FDA, although it is much more than he had in his bill. He would probably support cloture. Sen. Snowe (ME) Tom Geier 4-5344 left voice message (2) Sen. Specter (PA) Kevin Mathis 4-4254/8-1229 out until 5/29 MAY-20-98 15:10 FROM:OMB ID: PAGE 2/2 Proposed Uses of Tobacco Legislation Receipts (In Billions of Nominal Dollars - FY99-03) RECEIPTS Net Receipts 65.4 100% Minimum/Maximum Allocation USES Min. % $ 5 Yrs Max. % $ 5 Yrs Health & Health-Related Research 14.4 22% NIH 79% 11.4 87% 12.5 NSF Biomedical/Basic Research 0% Clinical Cancer Trials 4.5% 0.4 4.5% 0.4 CDC/AHCPR 12% 1.7 18% 2.6 Public Health 14.4 22% Cessation 25% 3.6 35% 5.0 Indian Health Service 3% 0.4 7% 1.0 Prevention & Education (Prev., Advertising, Surveys) 50% 7.2 65% 9.4 Licensing & Enforcement (FDA, Licensing, Anti-Smuggling) 17.5% 2.5 22.5% 3.2 Clinical Cancer Trials 4.5% 0.4 4.5% 0.4 State Funds, Direct 26.2 40% Unrestricted 13.1 2.5 Specified 13.1 PUB HEALTH 13+0 RESEARCH 1510 60B Farmers & Farm Communities 10.5 16% FARMERS 10 Compensation 0.0 25 Other/Medicare 0.0 STATES 2A # 10B TAX TOTAL USES 65.4 12.5B 1.25 tax 4 Intl is Lic 1 Countries 1.25 Prev 1 Surveys ,25 FDA 1.2 Cess 4 ATF ,3 6 28 2.SB 5/20/98 uses22.x/s MAY-26-1998 08:33 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO 94562878 P.02 Thoughts on next steps for Tobacco 1. Recess PR strategy * Focus on subset of Republican opponents of May 20. 1998 Ashcroft amendment. * Make sure groups have strategy - Ads, lobbying in state, op - eds, letters to editor. Potus / Vpotus / Secretary activities. Administration strategy re: Editorials, media interviews,etc. in targeted states. 2. Senate floor strategy Handicap Gramm vote and develop strategy - chart and talking points on effect on health spending, lobby target list. Strategy for cloture vote - Lobby target list of Republicans during recess. * Strategy for standoff on farmers. Brainstorm re: Adding muscle to floor managers. Identify "teams" of Senators to debate key issues (price, black market, FDA etc) - Organize and supply talking points. 3. Other legislative activity * Work on "clean up" with JR/Ivan - Determine which changes will build support, disarm critics, or preempt amendments. Outreach to committes on key issues - Labor / FDA and Health spending, Judiciary / Legal issues, Finance / State menu. Administration staff teams to meet with Republican target list during recess on key issues. Senate Roll Call Vote http://www.cspan.org/rollcall/v985201.html Hollings, Ernest F. (D-SC) Inouye, Daniel K. (D-HI) Johnson, Tim (D-SD) Kennedy, Edward M. (D-MA) Kerrey, J. Robert (D-NE) Kohl, Herb (D-WI) Kerry, John F. (D-MA) Landrieu, Mary (D-LA) Lautenberg, Frank R. (D-NJ) Leahy, Patrick J. (D-VT) Levin, Carl (D-MI) Lieberman, Joseph I. (D-CT) Mikulski, Barbara A. (D-MD) Moseley-Braun, Carol (D-IL) Moynihan, Daniel Patrick (D-NY) Murray, Patty (D-WA) Reed, Jack (D-RI) Reid, Harry (D-NV) Robb, Charles S. (D-VA) Rockefeller, John D., IV (D-WV) Sarbanes, Paul S. (D-MD) Torricelli, Robert (D-NJ) Wellstone, Paul D. (D-MN) Wyden, Ron (D-OR) 2 of 2 05/21/98 11:58:01 Date: 05/20/98 Time: 17:39 SThe 58-40 roll call by which the Senate rejected a The 58-40 roll call by which the Senate rejected a $1.50-per-pack increase in the tobacco tax. On this vote, a ''yes'' vote was against the increase and a ''no'' vote was in favor. Voting ''yes'' were 13 Democrats and 45 Republicans. Voting ''no'' were 32 Democrats and 8 Republicans. DEMOCRATS YES= Breaux, La.; Byrd, W.Va.; Cleland, Ga.; Feingold, Wis.; Feinstein, Calif. Ford, Ky. Hollings, S.C.; Inouye, Hawaii; Kerrey, Neb.; Mikulski, Md.; Reid, Nev.; Robb, Va.; Torricelli, N.J. DEMOCRATS NO= Akaka, Hawaii; Baucus, Mont.; Biden, Del.; Bingaman, N.M.; Boxer, Calif.; Bryan, Nev.; Bumpers, Ark.; Conrad, N.D.; Daschle, S.D.; Dodd, Conn.; Dorgan, N.D.; Durbin, Ill.; Glenn, Ohio; Graham, Fla.; Harkin, Iowa; Johnson, S.D.; Kennedy, Mass.; Kerry, Mass.; Kohl, Wis.; Landrieu, La.; Lautenberg, N.J.; Leahy, Vt.; Levin, Mich.; Lieberman, Conn.; Moseley-Braun, Ill.; Moynihan, N.Y.; Murray, Wash.; Reed, R.I.; Rockefeller, W.Va.; Sarbanes, Md.; Wellstone, Minn.; Wyden, Ore. REPUBLICANS YES= Abraham, Mich.; Allard, Colo.; Ashcroft, Mo.; Bennett, Utah; Bond, Mo.; Brownback, Kan.; Burns, Mont.; Campbell, Colo.; Coats, Ind.; Cochran, Miss.; Collins, Maine; Coverdell, Ga.; Craig, Idaho; DeWine, Ohio; Domenici, N.M.; Enzi, Wyo.; Faircloth, N.C.; Frist, Tenn.; Gorton, Wash.; Gramm, Texas; Grams, Minn.; Gregg, N.H.; Hagel, Neb.; Hatch, Utah; Helms, N.C.; Hutchinson, Ark.; Hutchison, Texas; Inhofe, Okla.; Kempthorne, Idaho; Kyl, Ariz.; Mack, Fla.; McCain, Ariz.; McConnell, Ky.; Murkowski, Alaska; Nickles, Okla.; Roberts, Kan. Roth, Del.; Santorum, Pa.; Sessions, Ala.; Shelby, Ala.; Stevens, Alaska; Thomas, Wyo.; Thompson, Tenn.; Thurmond, S.C.; Warner, Va. REPUBLICANS NO= Chafee, R.I.; D'Amato, N.Y.; Grassley, Iowa; Jeffords, Vt.; Lugar, Ind.; Smith, Ore.; Snowe, Maine; Specter, Pa. REPUBLICANS NOT VOTING= Lott, Miss.; Smith, N.H. APNP-05-20-98 1740EDT FARM.525 Page 1 STRIKING FORD FOR ??? AGAINST Dems Repubs Dems Repubs Dems Repubs Durbin 48 Conrad Thompson 41 McCain 46 Dorgan Thurmond Frist Kerrey Chafee Warner Jeffords Collins LEAN Snowe TO STRIKE Coverdell LOTT * Faircloth's staff has said he is likely to abstain. FAIRCLOTH STRIKING LUGAR FOR ??? AGAINST Dems Repubs Dems Repubs Dems Repubs 44 McCain Durbin Thompson 38 Frist Specter 37 Warner Snowe D'Amato Collins Chaffee Jeffords Dewine Hatch Bennet Mack Stevens Thurmond Fairloth Lott > Abstain Expair ANO Breaux Byrd Bunett Kemy Dewine Bond? M-Bran Robb kohl [Campbell Chafee ] Clelad Landrier Collins Ford liebern D'Ameto Mollings Wgac Grassley Feinstein Reid [Grys Jeffords t6 2 Specter 8 Snone Snone 8-11 Matt: lugar -Mack * X -Smith -Dewine -Bond L4: Bennett Craly * ? Ivan ne Image (Alader Akaka Bacces X (?) Bagaman Bryan X Y X (Hink) / Baypers X BL Byrd Sandanes N Dodd . ? Clead N Torricelli N Glenn X Y Kohl x BR Johnson Landrio (a) Y # levin RE x Grahasencte. Cynthia A. Rice 05/20/98 02:16:49 PM Rob Record Type: Record gov To: Bruce N. Reed/OPD/EOP, Elena Kagan/OPD/EOP, Laura Emmett/WHO/EOP, Cynthia Dailard/OPD/EOP CC: Subject: We will have new data POTUS could talk about tomorrow PerTach Melissa has arranged for the 5:00 pm embargo on the MMWR to NOT apply to the tobacco article. Thus, it will be available to reporters starting at 7:00 am tomorrow morning. She gave me a one page fact sheet so long as we promised we would not leak it ahead of that deadline. Dailard is looking at the materials now (and working on possible Q&As) but it looks like info we could use -- Only 86 percent of teen daily smokers who try to quit actually do so. Young people underestimate the addictiveness of nicotine -- 75 percent of daily smokers who expect to quit are still smoking five years later. 34 Z Lugar wellstone milulski- Alland Aschauft. Gram Abrah TD Carams M-Brain- Akake- Enzi Bide Provers Clem Bond Gregg Murray Grasslay Boxer (P) Motchnson Nickles Banett Masel Inhofe Reed Bingamin Compbell Breasx Johnson Colling Kenndy Brunback Reil Contand cleland Rockefeller Spector Subanas Kerrey- Michourk: Roberts Lautabay Serven 78LN LN Brya D'Ameto leahy Smith Bumpes= Craig - Dodd $1 Sanform Levin Bums Darhle Deleime shelly Dorgo Robb Chafce Byrd Durbin 43 Roth Domenici Branch Fee-gold kohl- Steras Cliled Fairloth B. Kyl Feastein Ford Grahan Hollings Landrier Thrmand Thomps Coats Harkin Mitderson liberma- Forrish Cochae First Hatch Image- Mack Warner coverdell Helms. McCain wyde- Garton Kerry McConnoll Snowe

Page data

Page
40
Source index
0
Type
document
Media ID
ecd16a0e4d847f36
Size
unknown

Document data

ID
26413735
Core
doc
Type
document
DTO data 
{
    "id": "26413735",
    "sourceUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26413735",
    "contentType": "document",
    "title": "[Tobacco] Target List",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26413735",
    "collections": [
        "Records of the Domestic Policy Council (Clinton Administration)",
        "Bruce Reed's Tobacco Files"
    ],
    "iiifBase": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/35/4137/26413735/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2011-0299-S-Tobacco/2011-0299-S-Tobacco-JPG/Box_278/42-t-7367462-20110299S-278-002-2015/42_t_7367462_20110299S_278_002_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "thumbnailUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/35/4137/26413735/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2011-0299-S-Tobacco/2011-0299-S-Tobacco-JPG/Box_278/42-t-7367462-20110299S-278-002-2015/42_t_7367462_20110299S_278_002_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "largeImageUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/35/4137/26413735/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2011-0299-S-Tobacco/2011-0299-S-Tobacco-JPG/Box_278/42-t-7367462-20110299S-278-002-2015/42_t_7367462_20110299S_278_002_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "imageCount": 40,
    "hasImages": true,
    "source": "import",
    "hasTranscription": false
}

Context sent to Scholar

Document identity 
{
    "localId": "26413735",
    "label": "[Tobacco] Target List",
    "core": "doc",
    "dtoType": "document",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26413735"
}
Document source metadata 
{
    "id": "26413735",
    "sourceUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26413735",
    "contentType": "document",
    "title": "[Tobacco] Target List",
    "citationUrl": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26413735",
    "collections": [
        "Records of the Domestic Policy Council (Clinton Administration)",
        "Bruce Reed's Tobacco Files"
    ],
    "iiifBase": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/35/4137/26413735/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2011-0299-S-Tobacco/2011-0299-S-Tobacco-JPG/Box_278/42-t-7367462-20110299S-278-002-2015/42_t_7367462_20110299S_278_002_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "thumbnailUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/35/4137/26413735/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2011-0299-S-Tobacco/2011-0299-S-Tobacco-JPG/Box_278/42-t-7367462-20110299S-278-002-2015/42_t_7367462_20110299S_278_002_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "largeImageUrl": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/35/4137/26413735/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2011-0299-S-Tobacco/2011-0299-S-Tobacco-JPG/Box_278/42-t-7367462-20110299S-278-002-2015/42_t_7367462_20110299S_278_002_2015_Page_001.JPG",
    "imageCount": 40,
    "hasImages": true,
    "source": "import",
    "hasTranscription": false
}
Document source extras 
{
    "url": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26413735",
    "naId": 26413735,
    "levelOfDescription": "fileUnit",
    "otherTitles": [
        "42-t-7367462-20110299S-278-002-2015"
    ],
    "recordType": "description",
    "ocrSource": "nara-archive"
}
Page context 
{
    "seq": 40,
    "pageIndex": 0,
    "type": "document",
    "url": "https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/opastorage/live/35/4137/26413735/content/presidential-libraries/clinton/foia/2011-0299-S-Tobacco/2011-0299-S-Tobacco-PDF/Box_278/42-t-7367462-20110299S-278-002-2015.pdf",
    "mediaId": "ecd16a0e4d847f36",
    "ocrText": "TOBACCO - TARGET\nSelected Tobacco Votes, S 1415\n94562878 P.02\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\nComments\nDescription\nTable\nTable\nTable\nCover-\nTable\nTable\nTable\nCloture\nWaive\nKennedy\nGregg\nDurbin\ndell\nGramm\nKetry\nReed\nBudget\nAct\nSenator\nAbraham\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nN\nBennett\nY\nY\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nY\nBond\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nBrownback\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nY\nY\nN\nN\nCampbell\nY\nN\nY\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nChafee\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nCollins\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nJUL-01-1998 14:16 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO\nD'Amato\nN\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nN\nY\nY\nDeWine\nY\nY\nN\nY\nN\nY\nN\nY\nY\nDomenici\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nFrist\nY\nY\nY\nY\nN\nY\nY\nY\nN\nGorten\nY\nY\nY\nY\nN\nY\nY\nN\nN\nGrassley\nN\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nY\nHagel\nY\nN\nY\nY\nN\nY\nY\nN\nN\nHatch\nY\nY\n+\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nJeffords\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nLugar\nN\nN\nY\nY\nN\nY\nY\nN\nN\nMack\nY\nY\nY\nY\nY\nY\nY\nN\nN\nMcCain\nY\nY\nY\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nY\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\nComments\nDescription\nTable\nTable\nTible\nCover-\nTable\nTable\nTable\nCloure\nWaive\n94562878 P.03\nKennedy\nGregg\nDurbin\ndell\nGramm\nKerry\nReed\nBudget\nAct\nSenator\nRoberts\nY\nN\nN\nY\nN\nY\nY\nN\nN\nRoth\nY\nN\nY\nY\nN\nY\nN\nY\nY\nSmith, G.\nN\nN\nN\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nY\nSnowe\nN\nN\nN\nY\nY\nN\nN\nY\nY\nSpecter\nN\nN\n-\n-\n-\n-\n-\n-\n-\nStevens\nY\nY\nY\nY\nN\nY\nY\nN\nN\nKey:\nY\nYea\nN\nNay\n+\nAnnourced For\nJUL-01-1998 14:17 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO\n-\nDid No: Vote\nJUL-01-1998 14:17 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO\n94562878 P.04\n1 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 144 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Cigarette\nTaxes. McCain, R-Ariz., motion to table (kill) the Kennedy, D-Mass.,\namendment to the modified Senate Commerce Committee substitute\namendment. The Kennedy amendment would replace language in the bill that\nwould raise the federal cigarette fees by $1.10 per pack with language\nto raise the fees by $1.50 per pack. Motion agreed to 58-40: R 45-8; D\n13-32 (ND 8-29, SD 5-3). May 20, 1998.\nItem Key: 13347\n2 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 145 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Tobacco\nIndustry Liability. McCain, R-Ariz., motion to table (kill) the Gregg,\nR-N.H., amendment that would eliminate the bill's $8 billion annual cap\non legal damages that tobacco companies could be forced to pay. Motion\nrejected 37-61: R 17-37; D 20-24 (ND 14-22, SD 6-2). May 21, 1998. A\n\"yea\" was a vote in support of the president's position.\nItem Key: 13356\n3 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 149 ** $1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Look-Back\nProvisions. Lott, R-Miss., motion Lo table (kill) the Durbin, D-III.,\namendment to the Durbin amendment to the Gramm, R-Texas, motion to\nrecommit the bill with instructions. The second-degree Durbin amendment,\nwhich is virtually identical to the underlying Durbin amendment, would\ntoughen the bill's so-called look-back provisions, which would penalize\nthe tobacco industry for failure to achieve targeted reductions in youth\nsmoking. The amendment raises the underlying bill's 10-year reduction\ntarget from 60 percent to 67 percent and lifts the maximum annual\npenalties from $4 billion to $7 billion. Motion rejected 29-66: R 24-28;\nD 5-38 (ND 0-35, SD 5-3). June 04, 1998. (Subsequently, the\nsecond-degree Durbin amendment was adopted by voice vote.)\nItem Key: 13383\n4 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 151 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Drug\nPrevention. Coverdell, R-Ga., amendment to the Durbin, D-I11., amendment\nto the Gramm, R-Texas, motion to recommit the bill with instructions.\nThe Coverdell amendment would authorize $16 billion over five years from\nthe bill's tobacco revenues for drug prevention efforts. It would\nincrease funding for border patrol, as well as anti-drug trafficking\nefforts of the FBI and the Drug Enforcement Administration, allow\nfederal funds to be spent on school vouchers for public school children\nwho have been victims of violent crimes on school property, ban federal\nfunding for needle-exchange programs and encourage states to establish\nvoluntary drug testing programs for all first-time individuals seeking a\ndriver's license. Adopted 52-46: R 52-2; D 0-44 (ND 0-36, SD 0-8). June\n09, 1998.\n1 Washington Abl Congressonal Quarter\nJUL-01-1998 14:18 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO\n94562878 P.05\nItem Key: 13394\n5 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 154 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Marriage\nPenalty. Kerry, D-Mass., motion to table (kill) the Gramm, R-Texas,\namendment to the Durbin, D-Ill., amendment to the Gramm motion to\nrecommit the bill with instructions. The Gramm amendment would allow\ncouples with combined incomes under $50,000 a year to claim an\nadditional $3,300 income tax deduction, thus eliminating the so-called\nmarriage penalty for those in that income bracket, at a cost of $46\nbillion over 10 years. The amendment also would allow self-employed\nindividuals to deduct the full cost of their health insurance on their\nincome taxes. Motion rejected 48-50: R 5-49; D 43-1 (ND 36-0, SD 7-1).\nJune 10, 1998. (Subsequently, the Gramm amendment was adopted by voice\nvote.)\nItem Key: 13405\n6 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 157 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Child Care\nBlock Grants. McCain, R-Ariz., motion to table (kill) the Kerry,\nD-Mass., amendment to the Durbin, D-Ill., amendment to the Gramm,\nR-Texas, motion to recommit the bill with instructions. The Kerry\namendment would require states to spend at least 50 percent of the\nrestricted-use tobacco revenue, which is 50 percent of the money states\nwould receive, on the child care and development block grant programs.\nMotion rejected 33-66: R 33-21; D 0-45 (ND 0-37, SD 0-8). June 11, 1998.\n(Subsequently, the Kerry amendment, after being modified, was adopted by\nvoice vote.)\nItem Key: 13418\n7 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 159 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Advertising\nTax Deductions. Gorton, R-wash., motion to table (kill) the Reed,\nD-R.I., amendment to the Durbin, D-Ill., amendment to the Gramm,\nR-Texas, motion to recommit the bill with instructions. The Reed\namendment would eliminate advertising tax deductions for those tobacco\ncompanies that the Food and Drug Administration determines are directing\ntheir advertisements at children. Motion rejected 47-47: R 43-9; D 4-38\n(ND 2-32, SD 2-6). June 15, 1998.\nItem Key: 13423\n8 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 161 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Cloture.\nMotion to invoke cloture (thus limiting debate) on the modified Senate\nCommerce, Science and Transportation Committee substitute amendment to\nthe bill to increase tobacco restrictions. The substitute would require\nthe tobacco industry to pay $516 billion over 25 years for anti-smoking,\neducation and research programs, raise taxes on cigarettes by $1.10 per\npack over five years, grant authority to the Food and Drug\nAdministration to regulate nicotine and impose penalties on the tobacco\nindustry if youth smoking does not decrease by 60 percent over 10 years.\n2 Washington AN -, Congressional Burnery\nJUL-01-1998 14:18 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET TO\n94562878 P.06\nMotion rejected 57-42: - R 14-40; D 43-2 (ND 37-0, SD 6-2). June 17, 1998.\nThree-fifths of the total Senate (60) is required to invoke cloture. A\n\"yea\" was a vote in support of the president's position.\nItem Key: 13434\n9 ** 1998 CQ SENATE VOTE 162 ** S1415. Tobacco Restrictions - Budget Act\nWaiver. Daschle, D-S.D., motion to waive the Budget Act with respect to\nthe Stevens, R-Alaska, point of order against the bill to increase\ntobacco restrictions. The bill, as amended, would require the tobacco\nindustry to pay $516 billion over 25 years for anti-smoking, education\nand research programs, raise taxes on cigarettes by $1.10 per pack over\nfive years, grant authority to the Food and Drug Administration to\nregulate nicotine and impose penalties on the tobacco industry if youth\nsmoking does not decrease by 60 percent over 10 years. Motion rejected\n53-46: R 11-43; D 42 3 (ND 37-0, SD 5-3). June 17, 1998. A three-fifths\nmajority vote (60) of the total Senate is required to waive the Budget\nAct. (Subsequently, the chair upheld the point of order, and the bill\nwas returned to the Senate Commerce Committee.) A \"yea\" was a vote in\nsupport of the president's position.\nItem Key: 13435\n3 Washington AM - Corpressond Quarterly\nToday's debate: Buying influence\nDid tobacco company money\nkill the anti-smoking bill?\nOUR VIEW\nOne link is plain to\nsee. Weak fund-raising\nTobacco vote\nlaws keep biggest gifts hidden.\nSenators' campaign contributions from\ntobacco political action committees and\nFor a money-hungry politician, feeding at\nindividuals, 1993-98, and the two votes\nthe table of Big Tobacco can be quite tasty. The\nthat killed the tobacco bill last week\n46 senators who obliged their cancer-peddling\n(y is for the bill; n against the bill):\npatrons by voting to kill the anti-smoking bill\nlast week have taken in more than $1.3 million\nSenator\nTotal\nVotes\nHelms, R-N.C.\n$118,950\nn-n\nin tobacco money since 1993.\nFaircloth, R-N.C.\n108,486\nn-n\nNot surprisingly. of the 15 senators who\nMcConnell, R-Ky.\n86,575\nn-n\npocketed the most, 13 were on the industry's\nThompson, R-Tenn.\n65,850\nn-n\nside in the final vote. Among the biggest bene-\nHollings, D-S.C.\n62,900\ny-n\nficiaries are senators from Michigan, Pennsyl-\nHutchison, R-Texas\n53,123\nn-n\nvania, even Montana - far from tobacco coun-\nWarner, R-Va.\n49,816\nn-n\nRobb, D-Va.\n42,950\nn-n\ntry. It's the latest sordid example of the links\nD'Amato, R-N.Y.\n41,166\ny-y\nbetween politics and special-interest money.\nBurns, R-Mont.\n38,500\nn-n\nBut those visible exchanges, which voters\nDodd, D-Conn.\n35,249\ny-y\npresumably can judge. aren't even the worst of\nSantorum, R-Pa.\n34,500\nn-n\nit. Hidden donations amount to far more.\nGramm, R-Texas\n32,750\nn-n\nNearly 75% of Big Tobacco's efforts to pur-\nAbraham, R-Mich.\n30,700\ny-n\nchase favor - $30 million since 1987 and\nInhofe, R-Okla.\n30,500\nn-n\nCoverdell, R-Ga.\n29,500\nn-n\nmore than $4 million last year alone - is fun-\nShelby, R-Ala.\n26,666\nn-n\nneled through back channels where its final\nKerrey, D-Neb.\n26,500\ny-y\ndestination can't be tracked.\nCraig, R-Idaho\n26,000\nn-n\nAt least 18 members of Congress serve as\nLott, R-Miss.\n25,850\nn-n\nconduits for tobacco money to reach their col-\nHagel, R-Neb.\n24,000\nn-n\nleagues through innocuous-sounding \"leader-\nSmith, R-N.H.\n24,000\nn-n\nAllard, R-Colo.\n23,450\nn-n\nship political action committees.\" Senate\nCampbell, R-Colo.\n23,166\nn-n\nMajority Leader Trent Lott and Majority Whip\nFrist, R-Tenn.\n23,000\ny-n\nDon Nickles, for example, each have \"majority\nRoberts, R-Kan.\n22,097\nn-n\nfund\" accounts to route thousands in tobacco\nDeWine, R-Ohio\n22,000\ny-y\nand other special-interest money to others.\nThomas, R-Wyo.\n22,000\nn-n\nFurther, the bulk of tobacco's \"investment\"\nGrams, R-Minn.\n19,000\nn-n\nKyl, R-Ariz.\n17,500\nn-n\nin politicians is in \"soft money,\" a loophole\nThurmond, R-S.C.\n17,500\nn-n\nthat lets corporations, unions and wealthy indi-\nConrad, D-N.D.\n17,000\ny-y\nviduals evade the legal curbs on contributions.\nBreaux, D-La.\n15,000\ny-y\nRepublican and Democratic committees served\nRoth, R-Del.\n14,750\ny-y\nas money laundries for more than $3.2 million\nLieberman, D-Conn.\n14,500\ny-y\nfrom tobacco (82% to Republicans) in the most\nNickles, R-Okla.\n14,166\nn-n\nCochran, R-Miss.\n14,000\nn-n\nrecent 15 months reported. Philip Morris has\nDomenici, R-N.M.\n14,000\nn-n\nbeen the GOP's No. 1 sugar daddy for three\nMack, R-Fla.\n13,000\nn-n\nyears running.\nBryan, D-Nev.\n12,500\ny-y\nWith this kind of addiction, small wonder\nKerry, D-Mass.\n12,000\ny-y\nthat party leaders killed modest campaign\nKempthorne, R-Idaho\n11,166\nn-n\nreform in the Senate and are trying to do so in\nGrassley, R-lowa\n11,166\ny-y\nthe House. As long as campaigns are paid for\nMoynihan, D-N.Y.\n9,500\ny-y\nFord, D-Ky.\n9,000\nn-n\nby tobacco and other interests, not by the pub-\nGorton, R-Wash.\n9,000\nn-n\nlic, no one should be surprised that they win.\nHatch, R-Utah\n9,000\nn-n\nAshcroft, R-Mo.\n8.000\nn-n\nMONDAY,\nJUNE\n22,\n1998\nUSA\nTODAY\nOPPOSING VIEW\nI take contri-\nBaucus, D-Mont.\n8,000\ny-y\nbutions. So\nBond, R-Mo.\n8,000\nn-n\nInouye, D-Hawaii\n8,000\ny-y\nwhat? The issue is free speech.\nSnowe, R-Maine\n8,000\ny-y\nSpecter, R-Pa.\n7,916\nabsent\nBy Mitch McConnell\nReid, D-Nev.\n7,000\ny-y\nMoseley-Braun, D-III.\n5,500\ny-y\nThe brouhaha over tobacco contributions il-\nMurkowski, R-Alaska\n5,166\nn-n\nlustrates the power of public disclosure. Being\nGregg, R-N.H.\n5,166\ny-n\nfrom a tobacco state, I proudly hail my tobac-\nTorricelli, D-N.J.\n5,000\ny-y\nCO contributions. Politicians from other states\nWyden, D-Ore.\n5,000\ny-y\nLevin, D-Mich.\n4,250\ny-y\nbrag of spurning them. To each his own; the\nCleland, D-Ga.\n4,000\ny-y\nvoters can be trusted to decide what is appro-\nDaschle, D-S.D.\n4,000\ny-y\npriate. To that end, I trust USA TODAY will\nLautenberg, D-N.J.\n4,000\ny-y\nanalyze the relationship between trial-lawyer\nMcCain, R-Ariz.\n4,000\ny-y\ncontributions and votes against fee caps in the\nRockefeller, D-W.Va.\n4,000\ny-y\ntobacco bill:\nKennedy, D-Mass.\n3,250\ny-y\nByrd, D-W.Va.\n3,000\n85% of trial-lawyer contributions to fed-\ny-y\nBennett, R-Utah\n2,666\ny-y\neral campaigns in the 1995-96 election cycle\nLandrieu, D-La.\n2,500\ny-y\nwent to Democrats.\nLugar, R-ind.\n2,500\nn-n\n90% of Senate Democrats last week vot-\nAkaka, D-Hawaii\n2,000\ny-y\ned against an amendment to the tobacco bill to\nCoats, R-Ind.\n2,000\nn-n\ncap lawyer fees at $4,000 an hour; 90% voted\nDorgan, D-N.D.\n2,000\ny-y\nagainst a $1,000-an-hour cap; 98% voted\nGraham, D-Fla.\n2,000\ny-y\nHarkin, D-lowa\n2,000\ny-y\nagainst a $250-an-hour cap.\nJohnson, D-S.D.\n2,000\ny-y\nIs the Democrats' trial-lawyer bonanza at-\nSmith, R-Ore.\n2,000\ny-y\ntributable to principles attracting contributions\nFeingold, D-Wis.\n1,900\ny-y\nor contributions dictating principles, including\nHutchinson, R-Ark.\n1,750\nn-n\na nearly universal aversion to any caps on tri-\nJeffords, R-Vt.\n1,100\ny-y\nal-lawyer fees? Are trial lawyers motivated by\nBiden, D-Del.\n1,000\ny-y\nDurbin, D-III.\n1,000\ny-y\nprinciple in their strident opposition to fee caps\nFeinstein, D-Calif.\n1,000\ny-y\nor because so many of them stand to become\nGlenn, D-Ohio\n1,000\ny-y\nbillionaires from tobacco lawsuit fees exceed-\nSarbanes, D-Md.\n1,000\ny-y\ning $90,000 an hour?\nReed, D-R.I\n500\ny-y\nUSA TODAY sees campaign finance \"re-\nLeahy, D-Vt.\n250\ny-y\nform\" as salvation from so-called \"special in-\nCollins, R-Maine\n200\ny-y\nBingaman, D-N.M.\n0\nterests\" - a reformer pejorative reserved for\ny-y\nBoxer, D-Calif.\n0\ny-y\npracticing capitalists. The reform agenda USA\nBrownback, R-Kan.\n0\nn-n\nTODAY advocates stifles speech and partici-\nBumpers, D-Ark.\n0\ny-y\npation by citizens, candidates, groups and par-\nChafee, R-R.I.\n0\ny-y\nties, and it is stymied by the Constitution. To-\nEnzi, R-Wyo.\n0\nn-n\nbacco is a convenient nemesis, but USA\nKohl, D-Wis.\n0\ny-y\nMikulski, D-Md.\n0\nTODAY's agenda extends far beyond that in-\ny-y\nMurray, D-Wash.\n0\ny-y\ndustry, as it silences the voices of anyone not\nSessions, R-Ala.\n0\nn-n\nfortunate enough to control a newspaper.\nStevens, R-Alaska\n0\nn-n\nWellstone, D-Minn.\n0\ny-y\nSen. Mitch McConnell. R-Ky., chairs the Na-\nSource. Center for Reponsive Politics. Federal Election Commission\nand USA TODAY research\ntional Republican Senatorial Committee.\nPeep shows\nOzzie and Harriet (1952-1966), which invit-\ned viewers to share the sanitized upbringing\nof David and Ricky Nelson. And it explains\nLast Tuesday, a woman identified only as\nour morbid interest in documentaries like An\nElizabeth gave birth live on the Internet. This\nAmerican Family, the 1973 PBS series chart-\ncomes hard on the heels of such exhibition-\ning the disintegration of the Loud family.\nist exercises as the JenniCam, which is fo-\nWhat's the universal appeal of such tech-\ncused unblinkingly on the quarters of Jennifer\nno-peeping? We are all closet voyeurs, of\nRingley. She doesn't shrink from it for any\ncourse. But maybe we are all closet exhibi-\nactivity.\ntionists, too. Maybe we sense that liberation\nThe urge to share too much (and the equal\nis nothing more than the lack of shame. Ei-\nurge to peek too much) is a constant force of\nther way, the future seems obvious. Eventu-\nhuman nature. It explains our uneasy interest\nally. point-and-shoot, point-and-click tech-\nin movies like The Truman Show, about a\nnology will make candid windows onto\ncharacter whose entire life is secretly script-\nmundane events too common to care about.\ned and broadcast. It explains our cheerful in-\nThen viewers will have to get a new life -\nterest in such shows as The Adventures of\ntheir own.\nUSA TODAY\nMONDAY, JUNE 22, 1998\nTUBACCO-\nCLOTURE 6/17/98\nTarget list\n(green file)\nAbraha\nDeWine\nChefre\nGregg\nJeffrds\nGrassley\nMelain\nD'Amato\nShave\nFirst\nRoth\nBennett\n6.Smith\nCollins\nt Robb\nInhofe\nHalen\nThumad\nCoats\nB.de\nCoder\nRobts\nAlake\nSandonm\nkeypthome\nFeingold\nX Ford\nAltahier\nReid\nEnzi\nWamen\nM-B\nThompson\nThomas\nReed\nLugar\nCampbell\nJohnson\nFairsbill\nBranback\nHollings\nkyl\nSessions\n(Clelad ?)\nHutchison\nShelby\nMagel\nMurkoushi\nBond\nStarms\nMack\nTAP cur\nDRUG ENE. INTER.\nCAP ON LAWER'S FEES\nTOUGHENED WOK-BACK 10°K - BACK\nCHILD CARE FUNDING\nRUBIN SAFE PRES LETTER LETTER or - VER / SAP /\nON COVERDALE\ncov. + TERM.\n,\nERSKINE LETTER/ PETER.\nz\nCHECK FORCES ON N. DAKOTA BOTH TRANSPORT & FARMERS.\nw\nFED. HERITAGE ADVISORY 10 RIVERS (NEKT MONTH) **\n7\nTOURISM TERSON ON NCC\n5\nBYRD MEETING\n6\nHOAE:\nABRAHAM -\nHOLLINGS\nBENNETT - 98\nFORD\nBOND - 98\nROBB- DASCHLE\nBROWNBACK\n98\nCORTON -\nVP\nGRASSLEY - 98\ncleland\nGRESS - 98\nFerustein\nCHATCH-\nTarricelli\nKEMPTHORNE\nERSKINE\n98\nMACK ERSKINE\nC. Varmas)\nMURKOWSKI- - 98\nMY\nROTH-\nSMITH -\nSTEVENS\n98\nsb, a Sto\nDonna\nChalee\nSpecter ??\nTelferds\nSurve\ndollars\nD. D'Aniato\nDewine\nFUST\nLufar\nCoch-an\nSessions\nBruce Reed\nDATE: June 17, 1998\n9:17\nRahm\n62531\n9:49\nEileen O'Connor\n638-5234\n10:10\nRon Fournier\n776-9441\n10:13\nCynthia Rice\n62846\n10:20\nJohn Harris\n334-7401\n11:00\nLarry Stein\nCall him in VP's office when you get in the car\n12:02\nBennett Kelly\n213-8921977\n12:10\nSally Katzen\n62800\nRe: Benchmarking issue of poverty measurements -- she wants to\ncall DOC and wants to know where we are\n2:25\nJeff Nesbitt\n703-589-1320\n3:00\nJeff Nesbitt\n703-589-1320\nBill Knapp\n5:15pm\nagainst\npe\nC\nInhole\nSmith\n622 63\nBeneft\n55\nI'm mining\nMc\nRoth\nfor relection\n65m\n(Vemp)\nCyr\n50%\nBut whity are\nSte\nGrass\nChe\nBand\nVempthome\npeople her?\nBenett\nGorton\nDick M.\nJef\nShelly\nGress\nMack\nEB-Lott\nSnow\nAbroah\ncampbell\nBC on hand job\nCollie,\nyou says have as bu\nFult\nBruback\nCochum\nAny\nthey have dent dirty\nDev\nMake\nAbraham\n4\n62564\nDa\nA\nJUN. - 17'98 (WED) 05:47\nP. 001\nJUN 17 1998\n(Date)\nRoll Call Vote\nLegislative\nNO. 161\nSUBJECT MOTION To INVOKE CLOTURE\nON THE MODIFIED COMMITTEE\nSUBSTITUTE to S. 1415\nYEAS\nNAYS\nAbraham\nAkaka\n100\n5:19p\nAllard\nAshcroft\nBaucus\nBennett\nBiden\n/\nBingaman\nBond\n7\nBoxer ARE\nto\nBreaux\nBrownback\nBryan\nBumpers\nBurns\n/\nByrd\nCampbell\n4\nChafee\n5\nCleland\nCoats\nCochran\nCollins na\n6\nConrad\nCoverdell\nCraig\n2\nD'Amato\nN\nDaschle\nDeWine\n8\nDodd\nDomenici\nL\n9\nDorgan\nà\nDurbin\nEnzi\nFaireloth\nFeingold\n11\nFeinstein ars\nFord\nFrist\nGlenn\nGarton\n4\n3\nGraham, Florida\nGramm, Texas\nGrams, Minnesota\nGrassley\nGregg\nIIngel\nHarkin\nHatch\n5\nGrams, Minnesota\nGrassley\nGregg\nHagel\nHarkin\nHatch\n4\nHelms\n6\nHollings\nHutchinson, Arkansas\nHutchison, Texhs\nInhofe\nInouye\n13\nJeffords\nJohnson\nKempthorne\n14\nKennedy\n15\nKerrey, Nebraska\n16\nKerry, Massachnectts\nKohl\nKyl\n17\nLandrieu ns\n18\nLautenberg\nLeahy\nLevin\n19\nLieberinan\nLott\n7\nLugar\nMack\n20\nMcCain\nMcConnell\n8\nR/\nMikulski 115\nMoseley-Braun 115\n22\nMoynihan\nMurkowski\n23\nMurray MRS.\nNickles\n9\nReed, Rhode Island\nReid, Nevada\nRobb\n10\nRoberts\n24\nRockefeller\nRoth\nSantorum\nSurbanes\nSessions\nShelby\nSmith, New Humpshire\nSmith, Oregon\n25\nSnowe MS.\nSpecter\n+\nStevens\nThomas\nThompson\nThurmond\n26\nTorricolli\nWarner\nWellstone\nWyden\nCPU. 1990 17-010 (iner)\n57\n42\n700\n55:47 (07M) 86 LI NOC\nBruce N. Reed\n06/15/98 07:05:25 PM\nRecord Type:\nRecord\nTo:\nElena Kagan/OPD/EOP, Cynthia A. Rice/OPD/EOP\nCC:\nSubject: Target List\nHere's a working list for cloture and the point of order. What do you think?\nSOLID REPUBLICANS (11)\nBond\nChafee\nCollins\nD'Amato\n-DeWine\nFrist\nJeffords\nLugar\nMcCain\nGordon Smith\nSnowe\nLEAN YES (2-3)\nCampbell - LN\nGrassley\nSpecter (if he recovers)\nCOULD GO EITHER WAY (8)\nAbraham\nBennett\nGorton LY\nGregg Mack - LN ( Harold Varmus to call)\nStevens\nMurkowski LN\nRoth\nLONG SHOTS (5)\n- Brownback\nBurns\nCochran (Stevens)\nDomenici\nHatch\nKyl\nKempthorne (- (- call EB)\nSessions\nDEMOCRATS SURE TO OPPOSE CLOTURE (2)\nFord\nRobb\nDEMOCRATS WHO PROBABLY VOTE FOR CLOTURE BUT AGAINST THE BILL (4)\nCleland\nFeinstein\nHollings\nTorricelli\nSenate Roll Call Vote\nhttp://www.cspan.org/rollcall/v985201.htm\nDescription\nDuring debate on tobacco legislation, Senators tabled an amendment offered by Sen. John Ashcroft\n(R-MO) that would have eliminated the proposed tax increase on cigarettes. In effect, tabling an\namendment in the Senate kills it. An \"aye\" vote is opposed to the amendment.\nYea - 72\nNay - 26\nPresent - 1\nNV - 1\n27 R; 45 D\n26 R; 0 D\n1 R; 0 D\n1 R; 0 D\nAbraham, Spencer (R-MI)\nAllard, Wayne (R-CO)?\nLott, Trent\nSmith, Bob\nBennett, Robert F. (R-UT)\nAshcroft, John (R-MO)\n(R-MS)\n(R-NH)\nBond, Christopher S. (R-MO)\nBurns, Conrad R. (R-MT)\nBrownback, Sam (R-KS)-\nCoats, Dan (R-IN)\n?\n?\nCampbell, Ben Nighthorse\nCochran, Thad (R-MS)\n(R-CO)\nCoverdell, Paul (R-GA)\nChafee, John H. (R-RI)\nCraig, Larry E. (R-ID) ?\nCollins, Susan (R-ME)-\nDomenici, Pete V. (R-NM)\nD'Amato, Alfonse M. (R-NY).\nEnzi, Mike (R-WY)\nDeWine, Mike (R-OH)\nFaircloth, Lauch (R-NC)\nFrist, William H. (R-TN)\nGramm, Phil (R-TX)\n?\nGorton, Slade (R-WA)\nGrams, Rod (R-MN)\nGrassley, Charles (R-IA) ?\nHagel, Chuck (R-NE)?\nGregg, Judd (R-NH)-\nHelms, Jesse (R-NC)\n?\nHatch, Orrin G. (R-UT)\nHutchison, Kay Bailey\nJeffords, James M. (R-VT)\n(R-TX)-\nLugar, Richard G. (R-IN)\nHutchinson, Tim (R-AR)\nMack, Connie (R-FL)\nInhofe, James M. (R-OK)\nMcCain, John (R-AZ)\nKempthorne, Dirk (R-ID) ?\nMurkowski, Frank H. (R-AK)(i\nKyl, Jon (R-AZ)-\nRoberts, Pat (R-KS)?\nMcConnell, Mitch (R-KY)\nRoth, William V., Jr. (R-DE)\nNickles, Don (R-OK)\nSantorum, Rick (R-PA)\n?\nSessions, Jeff (R-AL)\nSmith, Gordon (R-OR)-\n?\nShelby, Richard C. (R-AL)\nSnowe, Olympia J. (R-ME) ?\nThomas, Craig (R-WY)\nSpecter, Arlen (R-PA)-\nThompson, Fred (R-TN)\nStevens, Ted (R-AK)\nWarner, John W. (R-VA)\nThurmond, Strom (R-SC)\nAkaka, Daniel K. (D-HI)\nBaucus, Max (D-MT)\nBiden, Joseph R., Jr.(D-DE)\nBingaman, Jeff (D-NM)\nBoxer, Barbara (D-CA)\nBreaux, John B. (D-LA)\nBryan, Richard H. (D-NV)\nBumpers, Dale (D-AR)\nByrd, Robert C. (D-WV)\n17-8 firm 60P Gregg\nCleland, Max (D-GA)\n11%\n?\nConrad, Kent (D-ND)\nDodd, Christopher J. (D-CT)\nTear\nyes\nDorgan, Byron L. (D-ND)\n22 4 firm yes\nDurbin, Richard (D-IL)\nDaschle, Thomas A. (D-SD)\nFeingold, Russell D. (D-WI)\nFeinstein, Dianne (D-CA)\nFord, Wendell H. (D-KY)\nGlenn, John (D-OH)\nGraham, Bob (D-FL)\nHarkin, Tom (D-IA)\n1 of 2\n05/21/98 11:58:01\nRecent Roll Call Votes\nhttp://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HITM\nLegislative Activities\nRECENT FLOOR VOTES\nThe following record votes took place on the Senate floor during the past week.\n(Rollcall Vote No. 158 Leg.)\nJune 11, 1998, 5:45 PM\nBILL NO.: S.1415\nAMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2701\nTITLE: Motion to Table Faircloth Amdt. No. 2701\nREQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2\nRESULT: Motion to Table Agreed to\nYEAS--50\nAkaka\nGlenn\nMikulski\nBaucus\n- Gorton\nMoseley-Braun\n- Bennett\nGraham\nMoynihan\n38 D, 12 R\nBiden\nHarkin\nMurray\nBreaux\n- Hatch\nReed\nBryan\nHollings\nReid\n- Campbell\nInouye\nRobb\nCleland\n- Jeffords\nRockefeller\n- Cochran\nJohnson\n- Roth\nConrad\nKennedy\nSarbanes\n- D'Amato\nKerrey\n- Shelby\nDaschle\nKerry\n- Smith (OR)\n- DeWine\nKohl\n- Thompson\nDurbin\nLandrieu\nTorricelli\nFeingold\nLautenberg\nWellstone\nFeinstein\nLeahy\nWyden\nFord\nLevin\nNAYS--45\n41 R, 4D\nAbraham\nEnzi\nLugar\nAllard\nFaircloth\nMack\nAshcroft\nFrist\nMcCain\nBond\nGramm\nMcConnell\nBrownback\nGrams\nMurkowski\nBurns\nGrassley\nNickles\n- Byrd\nGregg\nRoberts\nChafee\nHagel\nSantorum\n1 of 9\n06/14/98 17:08:21\nRecent Roll Call Votes\nhttp://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM\nCoats\nHelms\nSessions\nCollins\nHutchinson\nSmith (NH)\nCoverdell\nHutchison\nSnowe\nCraig\nInhofe\nStevens\n- Dodd\nKempthorne\nThomas\nDomenici\nKyl\nThurmond\n- Dorgan\n- Lieberman\nWarner\nANSWERED 'PRESENT' 2\nBoxer\nLott\nNOT VOTING 3\nBingaman\nBumpers\nSpecter\n(Rollcall Vote No. 157 Leg.)\nJune 11, 1998, 2:10 PM\nBILL NO.: S.1415\nAMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2689\nTITLE: Motion to Table Kerry Amdt. No. 2689\nREQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2\nRESULT: Motion to Table Failed\nYEAS 33\nAllard\nGrams\nMcConnell\nAshcroft\nGregg\nNickles\nBrownback\nHagel\nRoberts\nCoats\nHelms\nRoth\nCochran\nHutchinson\nSantorum\nCraig\nInhofe\nSessions\nDeWine\nKempthorne\nSmith (NH)\nEnzi\nKyl\nStevens\nFrist\nLott\nThomas\nGorton\nLugar\nThompson\nGramm\nMack\nThurmond\nNAYS 66\n45D, 21 R\nAbraham\n- Domenici\nLautenberg\nAkaka\nDorgan\nLeahy\nBaucus\nDurbin\nLevin\n-\nBennett\n- Faircloth\nLieberman\nBiden\nFeingold\n- McCain\nBingaman\nFeinstein\nMikulski\n- Bond\nFord\nMoseley-Braun\nBoxer\nGlenn\nMoynihan\nBreaux\nGraham\n- Murkowski\nBryan\n- Grassley\nMurray\nBumpers\nHarkin\nReed\n- Burns\n- Hatch\nReid\nByrd\nHollings\nRobb\n- Campbell\n- Hutchison\nRockefeller\n2 of 9\n06/14/98 17:08:21\nRecent Roll Call Votes\nhttp://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM\n- Chafee\nInouye\nSarbanes\nCleland\n- Jeffords\n- Shelby\n- Collins\nJohnson\n-\nSmith (OR)\nConrad\nKennedy\n- Snowe\n- Coverdell\nKerrey\nTorricelli\n- D'Amato\nKerry\n- Warner\nDaschle\nKohl\nWellstone\nDodd\nLandrieu\nWyden\nNOT VOTING--- 1\nSpecter\n(Rollcall Vote No. 156 Leg.)\nJune 11, 1998, 12:01 PM\nBILL NO.: S.1415\nTITLE: Motion to invoke cloture on modified Committee substitute\nREQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 3/5\nRESULT: Cloture Motion Rejected\nYEAS--43\nAkaka\nFeingold\nLevin\nBaucus\nFeinstein\nLieberman\nBiden\nGlenn\nMikulski\nBingaman\nGraham\nMoseley-Braun\nBoxer\nHarkin\nMoynihan\nBreaux\nHollings\nMurray\nBryan\nInouye\nReed\nBumpers\nJohnson\nReid\nByrd\nKennedy\nRockefeller\nCleland\nKerrey\nSarbanes\nConrad\nKerry\nTorricelli\nDaschle\nKohl\nWellstone\nDodd\nLandrieu\nWyden\nDorgan\nLautenberg\nDurbin\nLeahy\nNAYS--56\nAbraham\n- Ford\nMcCain\nAllard\nFrist\nMcConnell\nAshcroft\nGorton\nMurkowski\nBennett\nGramm\nNickles\nBond\nGrams\nRobb\nBrownback\nGrassley\nRoberts\nBurns\nGregg\nRoth\nCampbell\nHagel\nSantorum\nChafee\nHatch\nSessions\nCoats\nHelms\nShelby\nCochran\nHutchinson\nSmith (NH)\nCollins\nHutchison\nSmith (OR)\nCoverdell\nInhofe\nSnowe\nCraig\nJeffords\nStevens\nD'Amato\nKempthorne\nThomas\nDeWine\nKyl\nThompson\n3 of 9\n06/14/98 17:08:21\nRecent Roll Call Votes\nhttp://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM\nDomenici\nLott\nThurmond\nEnzi\nLugar\nWarner\nFaircloth\nMack\nNOT VOTING\n1\nSpecter\n(Rollcall Vote No. 155 Leg.)\nJune 10, 1998, 7:12 PM\nBILL NO.: S.1415\nAMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2688\nTITLE: Motion to Table Daschle Amdt. No. 2688\nREQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2\nRESULT: Motion to Table Agreed to\nYEAS - 55\nAbraham\n- Feingold\nMcCain\nAllard\nFrist\nMcConnell\nAshcroft\nGorton\nMurkowski\nBennett\nGramm\nNickles\nBond\nGrams\nRoberts\nBrownback\nGrassley\nRoth\nBurns\nGregg\nSantorum\nCampbell\nHagel\nSessions\nChafee\nHatch\nShelby\nCoats\nHelms\nSmith (NH)\nCochran\nHutchinson\nSmith (OR)\nCollins\nHutchison\nSnowe\nCoverdell\nInhofe\nStevens\nCraig\nJeffords\nThomas\nD'Amato\nKempthorne\nThompson\nDeWine\nKyl\nThurmond\nDomenici\nLott\nWarner\nEnzi\nLugar\nFaircloth\nMack\nNAYS--43\nAkaka\nFord\nLieberman\nBaucus\nGlenn\nMikulski\nBingaman\nGraham\nMoseley-Braun\nBoxer\nHarkin\nMoynihan\nBreaux\nHollings\nMurray\nBryan\nInouye\nReed\nBumpers\nJohnson\nReid\nByrd\nKennedy\nRobb\nCleland\nKerrey\nRockefeller\nConrad\nKerry\nSarbanes\nDaschle\nKohl\nTorricelli\nDodd\nLandrieu\nWellstone\nDorgan\nLautenberg\nWyden\nDurbin\nLeahy\nFeinstein\nLevin\n4 of 9\n06/14/98 17:08:21\nRecent Roll Call Votes\nhttp://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM\nNOT VOTING\n2\nBiden\nSpecter\n(Rollcall Vote No. 154 Leg.)\nJune 10, 1998, 6:44 PM\nBILL NO.: S.1415\nAMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2686\nTITLE: Motion to Table Gramm Amdt. No. 2686 as Modified\nREQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2\nRESULT: Motion to Table Failed\nYEAS 48\nAkaka\nFeingold\nLevin\nBaucus\nFeinstein\nLieberman\nBingaman\nFord\nMack\nBoxer\nGlenn\nMikulski\nBreaux\nGraham\nMoseley-Braun\nBryan\nHarkin\nMoynihan\nBumpers\nInouye\nMurray\nByrd\nJeffords\nReed\nChafee\nJohnson\nReid\nCleland\nKennedy\nRobb\nCollins\nKerrey\nRockefeller\nConrad\nKerry\nSarbanes\nDaschle\nKohl\nSnowe\nDodd\nLandrieu\nTorricelli\nDorgan\nLautenberg\nWellstone\nDurbin\nLeahy\nWyden\nNAYS 50\nAbraham\nFrist\nMcCain\nAllard\nGorton\nMcConnell\nAshcroft\nGramm\nMurkowski\nBennett\nGrams\nNickles\nBond\nGrassley\nRoberts\nBrownback\nGregg\nRoth\nBurns\nHagel\nSantorum\nCampbell\nHatch\nSessions\nCoats\nHelms\nShelby\nCochran\nHollings\nSmith (NH)\nCoverdell\nHutchinson\nSmith (OR)\nCraig\nHutchison\nStevens\nD'Amato\nInhofe\nThomas\nDeWine\nKempthorne\nThompson\nDomenici\nKyl\nThurmond\nEnzi\nLott\nWarner\nFaircloth\nLugar\nNOT VOTING\n2\nBiden\nSpecter\n5 of 9\n06/14/98 17:08:21\nRecent Roll Call Votes\nhttp://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM\n(Rollcall Vote No. 153 Leg.)\nJune 10, 1998, 11:04 AM\nBILL NO.: S.1415\nTITLE: Motion to Invoke Cloture on Modified Committee Substitute on S.1415\nREQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 3/5\nRESULT: Cloture Motion Rejected\nYEAS 43\nAkaka\nFeingold\nLevin\nBaucus\nFeinstein\nLieberman\nBiden\nGlenn\nMikulski\nBingaman\nGraham\nMoseley-Braun\nBoxer\nHarkin\nMoynihan\nBreaux\nHollings\nMurray\nBryan\nInouye\nReed\nBumpers\nJohnson\nReid\nByrd\nKennedy\nRockefeller\nCleland\nKerrey\nSarbanes\nConrad\nKerry\nTorricelli\nDaschle\nKohl\nWellstone\nDodd\nLandrieu\nWyden\nDorgan\nLautenberg\nDurbin\nLeahy\nNAYS--55\nAbraham\nFord\nMcConnell\nAllard\nFrist\nMurkowski\nAshcroft\nGorton\nNickles\nBennett\nGramm\nRobb\nBond\nGrams\nRoberts\nBrownback\nGrassley\nRoth\nBurns\nHagel\nSantorum\nCampbell\nHatch\nSessions\nChafee\nHelms\nShelby\nCoats\nHutchinson\nSmith (NH)\nCochran\nHutchison\nSmith (OR)\nCollins\nInhofe\nSnowe\nCoverdell\nJeffords\nStevens\nCraig\nKempthorne\nThomas\nD'Amato\nKyl\nThompson\nDeWine\nLott\nThurmond\nDomenici\nLugar\nWarner\nEnzi\nMack\nFaircloth\nMcCain\nNOT VOTING\n2\nGregg\nSpecter\n(Rollcall Vote No. 152 Leg.)\n6 of 9\n06/14/98 17:08:21\nRecent Roll Call Votes\nhttp://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM\nJune 9, 1998, 6:40 PM\nBILL NO.: S.1415\nAMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2634\nTITLE: Daschle Amdt. No. 2634 Drug Subst.\nREQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2\nRESULT: Amendment Rejected\nYEAS--45\nAkaka\nFeingold\nLevin\nBaucus\nFeinstein\nLieberman\nBiden\nFord\n- McCain\nBingaman\nGlenn\nMikulski\nBoxer\nGraham\nMoseley-Braun\nBreaux\nHarkin\nMoynihan\nBryan\nHollings\nMurray\nBumpers\nJohnson\nReed\nByrd\nKennedy\nReid\nCleland\nKerrey\nRobb\nConrad\nKerry\nRockefeller\nDaschle\nKohl\nSarbanes\nDodd\nLandrieu\nTorricelli\nDorgan\nLautenberg\nWellstone\nDurbin\nLeahy\nWyden\nNAYS--53\nAbraham\nFaircloth\nMack\nAllard\nFrist\nMcConnell\nAshcroft\nGorton\nMurkowski\nBennett\nGramm\nNickles\nBond\nGrams\nRoberts\nBrownback\nGrassley\nRoth\nBurns\nGregg\nSantorum\nCampbell\nHagel\nSessions\nChafee\nHatch\nShelby\nCoats\nHelms\nSmith (NH)\nCochran\nHutchinson\nSmith (OR)\nCollins\nHutchison\nSnowe\nCoverdell\nInhofe\nStevens\nCraig\nJeffords\nThomas\nD'Amato\nKempthorne\nThompson\nDeWine\nKyl\nThurmond\nDomenici\nLott\nWarner\nEnzi\nLugar\nNOT VOTING---2\nInouye\nSpecter\n(Rollcall Vote No. 151 Leg.)\nJune 9, 1998, 6:14 PM\nBILL NO.: S.1415\n7 of 9\n06/14/98 17:08:21\nRecent Roll Call Votes\nhttp://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM\nAMENDMENT NO.: S.AMDT.NO. 2451\nTITLE: Coverdell Amdt. No. 2451, as modified\nREQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 1/2\nRESULT: Amendment Agreed to\nYEAS--52\nAbraham\nFrist\nMcConnell\nAllard\nGorton\nMurkowski\nAshcroft\nGramm\nNickles\nBennett\nGrams\nRoberts\nBond\nGrassley\nRoth\nBrownback\nGregg\nSantorum\nBurns\nHagel\nSessions\nCampbell\nHatch\nShelby\nCoats\nHelms\nSmith (NH)\nCochran\nHutchinson\nSmith (OR)\nCollins\nHutchison\nSnowe\nCoverdell\nInhofe\nStevens\nCraig\nKempthorne\nThomas\nD'Amato\nKyl\nThompson\nDeWine\nLott\nThurmond\nDomenici\nLugar\nWarner\nEnzi\nMack\nFaircloth\nMcCain\nNAYS 46\nAkaka\nFeingold\nLevin\nBaucus\nFeinstein\nLieberman\nBiden\nFord\nMikulski\nBingaman\nGlenn\nMoseley-Braun\nBoxer\nGraham\nMoynihan\nBreaux\nHarkin\nMurray\nBryan\nHollings\nReed\nBumpers\nJeffords\nReid\nByrd\nJohnson\nRobb\n-\nChafee\nKennedy\nRockefeller\nCleland\nKerrey\nSarbanes\nConrad\nKerry\nTorricelli\nDaschle\nKohl\nWellstone\nDodd\nLandrieu\nWyden\nDorgan\nLautenberg\nDurbin\nLeahy\nNOT VOTING\n2\nInouye\nSpecter\n(Rollcall Vote No. 150 Leg.)\nJune 9, 1998, 2:15 PM\nBILL NO.: S.1415\nTITLE: Motion to Invoke Cloture on Modified Committee Substitute to S.1415\nREQUIRED FOR MAJORITY: 3/5\n8 of 9\n06/14/98 17:08:21\nRecent Roll Call Votes\nhttp://www.senate.gov/activities/VOTED.HTM.\nRESULT: Cloture Motion Rejected\nYEAS 42\nAkaka\nDurbin\nLeahy\nBaucus\nFeingold\nLevin\nBiden\nFeinstein\nLieberman\nBingaman\nGlenn\nMikulski\nBoxer\nGraham\nMoseley-Braun\nBreaux\nHarkin\nMoynihan\nBryan\nHollings\nMurray\nBumpers\nJohnson\nReed\nByrd\nKennedy\nReid\nCleland\nKerrey\nRockefeller\nConrad\nKerry\nSarbanes\nDaschle\nKohl\nTorricelli\nDodd\nLandrieu\nWellstone\nDorgan\nLautenberg\nWyden\nNAYS - 56\nAbraham\n-\nFord\nMcCain\nAllard\nFrist\nMcConnell\nAshcroft\nGorton\nMurkowski\nBennett\nGramm\nNickles\nBond\nGrams\nRobb\nBrownback\nGrassley\nRoberts\nBurns\nGregg\nRoth\nCampbell\nHagel\nSantorum\nChafee\nHatch\nSessions\nCoats\nHelms\nShelby\nCochran\nHutchinson\nSmith (NH)\nCollins\nHutchison\nSmith (OR)\nCoverdell\nInhofe\nSnowe\nCraig\nJeffords\nStevens\nD'Amato\nKempthorne\nThomas\nDeWine\nKyl\nThompson\nDomenici\nLott\nThurmond\nEnzi\nLugar\nWarner\nFaircloth\nMack\nNOT VOTING\n2\nInouye\nSpecter\nBack to the Roll Call Votes Page\nLast Updated JUNE 13, 1998 at 03:41:36\n9 of 9\n06/14/98 17:08:22\nRev. June 1, 1998 (6:09pm)\nSenator\nStaff\nPhone/fax\nComments\nSen. Abraham (MI)\nElizabeth\n4-6098\nHe supports Gramm amend.,\nKessler\nbut thinks that Durbin 2nd\ndegree amend. guts Gramm.\nIf there is a cloture vote, he'll\ngo w/ the leadership. His\ninterest is small business and\nthinks they are taken care of\nin McCain bill. (5/26)\nSen. Bennett (UT)\nLisa Norton\n4-5444/4-4908\nleft numerous messages for\nChip Yost (LD)\nboth\nSen. Bond (MO)\nJoe Pierle\n4-5721\nSen. favors the Dubin amend.\nand is leaning against Gramm\namend. Cloture is not an\noption yet, and he doesn't see\na need for FDA changes. (6/1)\nSen. Campbell (CO)\nRalssa Quintal\n4-5852\nleft several messages\nSen. Chafee (RI)\nLisa Layman\n4-6183/8-2853\nSen. believes it will be\ndifficult to stave off tax cuts\nand illegal drug measures.\nHe opposes Gramm;\nundecided on cloture at this\ntime; not committed to FDA\n(5/28)\nSen. Cochran (MS)\nBrad Prewitt\n4-3063/4-9450\nSen. has not determined his\nposition on Gramm amend.\nbut is concerned that a\nmotion to recommit is merely\na delaying tactic that will\nprevent both a tax cut and\ntobacco legislation. As a\nmember of the Approps.\nCommittee, he is interested in\ngetting a bill, but he has not\nsaid anything about cloture\nyet. He might consider\nsupporting amendments to\nlessen FDA's authority. (6/1)\n7398413\n2\nSen. Collins (ME)\nPriscilla Hanley\n4-2523\nSen. opposes Gramm because\nshe believes funds should be\nused for tobacco/health\nrelated purposes; does\nsupport the Roth amend. for\nself employed. Too soon for\ncloture; not interested in\nchanging FDA provisions.\n(6/1)\nSen. D'Amato (NY)\nAdam Chrisney\n4-6542\nSen. probably does not\nsupport the Gramm amend.\non this bill. It is too soon for\ncloture and he is not in favor\nof significant changes to FDA\n(5/28)\nSen. DeWine (OH)\nRobert Hoffman\n4-2315/4-6519\nHe prefers money from S.\n1415 for tobacco & public\nhealth activities, esp. for kids.\nHe's leaning against Gramm,\nhas no position on cloture or\nFDA. (6/1)\nSen. Frist (TN)\nSue Ramthun,\n4-7139/8-5044\nKatie and Sue are out this\nPro-clature\nAnne Phelps,\nweek; Anne believes that the\nNo on Gramm\nKatie\nbill will not be taken up\nbefore Wednesday; Sen.\nsupports FDA provisions, but\nshe is not sure about Gramm\namend. or cloture. Will\ncheck. (5/28)\nSen. Gorton (WA)\nJeanne Bumpus\n4-3271\nHis position on Gramm\namend. is unknown; will\nprobably support cloture\neventually. Main concerns\nare Constitution & having\nIndians collect tax. Takes his\ncue from A.G.s (5/26)\n3\nSen. Grassley (IA)\nJennifer Shaw\n4-3744\nHe supports devoting some of\nJim Yokum\nthe revenue to tax cuts, but\nhe prefers the Roth amends.\nHe would not support cloture\nand his position on FDA\namendments is unknown.\n(6/1)\nSen. Jeffords (VT)\nSharon Winn\n4-3191/8-0411\nSen. would probably oppose\nMark Powden\n4-6770\nthe Gramm amend. and\nsupport cloture (5/29)\nSen. Lugar (IN)\nMichael Knipe\n4-5928/8-4575\nSen.'s position on Gramm is\nDaniel Diller\n4-4814\nnot clear. He is a cosponsor\n(LD)\nof a bill to eliminate marriage\npenalty, but he might not\nsupport adding it to S. 1415,\nesp. if it threatens passage.\nBut he does want the bill to\ninclude tax break. May\nsupport cloture later (esp. if\nhis price support buy-out is\nincluded). Has no position\non FDA, but is interested\nbecause of the Ag. Com. (6/1)\nSen. Mack (FL)\nWendy Gramm\n4-4953\nHe might not support Gramm\nMark Smith\n4-5274/4-1907\namend. on this bill. Mark\ndoes not know if Sen. would\nsupport cloture. W/out\nliability caps, he'll have\ntrouble supporting the bill,\neven with its spending for\npublic health and farmers.\n(5/26)\nSen. Roth (DE)\nMark Eichler\n4-2441\nWould probably support the\nGramm amend. It's far too\nsoon for cloture. The bill will\nbe brought up intermittently\nbetween now & August.\n(5/26)\n4\nSen. G. Smith (OR)\nAnnie Brown\n4-3753\nSen. opposes the Gramm\namend. on this bill. He\nsupports the Durbin look\nback and the Lugar farmers\nprovisions. He also supports\nwhat McCain has for FDA,\nalthough it is much more than\nhe had in his bill. He would\nprobably support cloture.\n(5/28)\nSen. Snowe (ME)\nTom Geier\n4-5344\nSen. probably opposes the\nGramm amend. It is too\nsoon for cloture and does not\nwant to diminish FDA\nauthority, but is not wedded\nto current language. She is\nmost interested in the\nadvertising & marketing parts\nand is opposed to both\napproaches to farmers. (5/29)\nSen. Specter (PA)\nKevin Mathis\n4-4254/8-1229\nSen.'s health precludes his\nparticipation for awhile (6/1)\nSen. Stevens (AK)\nMs. Chris\n4-3004\nSen. has spoken directly to\nSchabacker\nthe Secretary about his\npositions on S. 1415. He is\nmostly interested in getting\nthe bill to conference. (6/1)\nSen. Thompson (TN)\nKelvin Moxley\n4-4944\nHe will support anything that\nwill kill the bill because it is\nbig gov't, huge taxes,\nineffective, and completely\nunconstitutional. (5/29)\nSen. Warner (VA)\nChas Phillips\n4-6674\nSen.'s position on Gramm is\nnot determined; does not\nsupport cloture. (6/1)\n2:30 5/28\nSenator\nStaff\nPhone/fax\nComments\nSen. Abraham (MI)\nElizabeth Kessler\n4-6098\nHe supports Gramm amend.,\nbut thinks that Durbin 2nd\ndegree amend. guts Gramm.\nIf there is a cloture vote, he'll\ngo w/ the leadership. His\ninterest is small business and\nthinks they are taken care of\nin McCain bill. (5/26)\nSen. Bennett (UT)\nLisa Norton\n4-5444/4-4908\nAA & LD are out this week\nSen. Bond (MO)\nJoe Pierle\n4-5721\nout this week - no one else\ncan speak about the issue\nSen. Campbell (CO)\nRaissa Quintal\n4-5852\nout this week; her 2 assistants\nalso are out (vacation & sick\nleave)\nSen. Chafee (RI)\nLisa Layman\n4-6183/8-2853\nSen. believes it will be\ndifficult to stave off tax cuts\nand illegal drug measures.\nHe opposes Gramm;\nundecided on cloture at this\ntime; not committed to FDA\nSen. Collins (ME)\nPriscilla Hanley\n4-2523\nleft voice message - fire drill\nuntil 2:30\nSen. D'Amato (NY)\nAdam Chrisney\n4-6542\nSen. probably does not\nsupport the Gramm amend.\non this bill. It is too soon for\ncloture and he is not in favor\nof significant changes to FDA\nSen. DeWine (OH)\nRobert Hoffman\n4-2315/4-6519\nleft voice message (2)\nSen. Frist (TN)\nSue Ramthun,\n4-7139/8-5044\nKatie and Sue are out this\nAnne Phelps,\nweek; Anne believes that the\nKatie\nbill will not be taken up\nbefore Wednesday; Sen.\nsupports FDA provisions, but\nshe is not sure about Gramm\namend. or cloture. Will\ncheck.\n2\nSen. Gorton (WA)\nJeanne Bumpus\n4-3271\nHis position on Gramm\namend. is unknown; will\nprobably support cloture\nevenutally. Main concerns\nare Constitution & having\nIndians collect tax. Takes his\ncue from A.G.s (5/26)\nSen. Grassley (IA)\nJennifer Shaw\n4-3744\nleft voice message (2)\nJim Yokum\nSen. Jeffords (VT)\nSharon Winn\n4-3191/8-0411\nleft voice message\nSen. Lugar (IN)\nMichael Knipe\n4-5928/8-4575\nleft voice message (2)\nSen. Mack (FL)\nWendy Gramm\n4-4953\nHe might not support Gramm\nMark Smith\n4-5274/4-1907\namend. on this bill. Mark\ndoes not know if Sen. would\nsupport cloture. W/out\nliability caps, he'll have\ntrouble supporting the bill,\neven with its spending for\npublic health and farmers.\n(5/26)\nSen. Roth (DE)\nMark Eichler\n4-2441\nWould probably support the\nGramm amend. It's far too\nsoon for cloture. The bill will\nbe brought up intermittently\nbetween now & August.\n(5/26)\nSen. G. Smith (OR)\nAnnie Brown\n4-3753\nSen. opposes the Gramm\namend. on this bill. He\nsupports the Durbin lookback\nand the Lugar farmers\nprovisions. He also supports\nwhat McCain has for FDA,\nalthough it is much more than\nhe had in his bill. He would\nprobably support cloture.\nSen. Snowe (ME)\nTom Geier\n4-5344\nleft voice message (2)\nSen. Specter (PA)\nKevin Mathis\n4-4254/8-1229\nout until 5/29\nMAY-20-98 15:10 FROM:OMB\nID:\nPAGE\n2/2\nProposed Uses of Tobacco Legislation Receipts\n(In Billions of Nominal Dollars - FY99-03)\nRECEIPTS\nNet Receipts\n65.4 100%\nMinimum/Maximum Allocation\nUSES\nMin. % $ 5 Yrs\nMax. % $ 5 Yrs\nHealth & Health-Related Research\n14.4\n22%\nNIH\n79%\n11.4\n87%\n12.5\nNSF Biomedical/Basic Research\n0%\nClinical Cancer Trials\n4.5%\n0.4\n4.5%\n0.4\nCDC/AHCPR\n12%\n1.7\n18%\n2.6\nPublic Health\n14.4\n22%\nCessation\n25%\n3.6\n35%\n5.0\nIndian Health Service\n3%\n0.4\n7%\n1.0\nPrevention & Education (Prev., Advertising, Surveys)\n50%\n7.2\n65%\n9.4\nLicensing & Enforcement (FDA, Licensing, Anti-Smuggling)\n17.5%\n2.5\n22.5%\n3.2\nClinical Cancer Trials\n4.5%\n0.4\n4.5%\n0.4\nState Funds, Direct\n26.2\n40%\nUnrestricted\n13.1\n2.5\nSpecified\n13.1\nPUB HEALTH\n13+0\nRESEARCH\n1510\n60B\nFarmers & Farm Communities\n10.5\n16%\nFARMERS\n10\nCompensation\n0.0\n25\nOther/Medicare\n0.0\nSTATES\n2A\n#\n10B\nTAX\nTOTAL USES\n65.4\n12.5B\n1.25\ntax\n4\nIntl is\nLic 1\nCountries 1.25\nPrev 1\nSurveys ,25\nFDA 1.2\nCess 4\nATF\n,3\n6\n28\n2.SB\n5/20/98 uses22.x/s\nMAY-26-1998 08:33 FROM DHHS-OFFICE OF THE SECRET\nTO\n94562878 P.02\nThoughts on next steps for Tobacco\n1. Recess PR strategy\n*\nFocus on subset of Republican opponents of May 20. 1998 Ashcroft amendment.\n*\nMake sure groups have strategy - Ads, lobbying in state, op - eds, letters to editor.\nPotus / Vpotus / Secretary activities.\nAdministration strategy re: Editorials, media interviews,etc. in targeted states.\n2. Senate floor strategy\nHandicap Gramm vote and develop strategy - chart and talking points on effect on health\nspending, lobby target list.\nStrategy for cloture vote - Lobby target list of Republicans during recess.\n*\nStrategy for standoff on farmers.\nBrainstorm re: Adding muscle to floor managers.\nIdentify \"teams\" of Senators to debate key issues (price, black market, FDA etc) -\nOrganize and supply talking points.\n3. Other legislative activity\n*\nWork on \"clean up\" with JR/Ivan - Determine which changes will build support, disarm\ncritics, or preempt amendments.\nOutreach to committes on key issues - Labor / FDA and Health spending, Judiciary /\nLegal issues, Finance / State menu.\nAdministration staff teams to meet with Republican target list during recess on key\nissues.\nSenate Roll Call Vote\nhttp://www.cspan.org/rollcall/v985201.html\nHollings, Ernest F. (D-SC)\nInouye, Daniel K. (D-HI)\nJohnson, Tim (D-SD)\nKennedy, Edward M. (D-MA)\nKerrey, J. Robert (D-NE)\nKohl, Herb (D-WI)\nKerry, John F. (D-MA)\nLandrieu, Mary (D-LA)\nLautenberg, Frank R. (D-NJ)\nLeahy, Patrick J. (D-VT)\nLevin, Carl (D-MI)\nLieberman, Joseph I. (D-CT)\nMikulski, Barbara A. (D-MD)\nMoseley-Braun, Carol (D-IL)\nMoynihan, Daniel Patrick\n(D-NY)\nMurray, Patty (D-WA)\nReed, Jack (D-RI)\nReid, Harry (D-NV)\nRobb, Charles S. (D-VA)\nRockefeller, John D., IV (D-WV)\nSarbanes, Paul S. (D-MD)\nTorricelli, Robert (D-NJ)\nWellstone, Paul D. (D-MN)\nWyden, Ron (D-OR)\n2 of 2\n05/21/98 11:58:01\nDate: 05/20/98 Time: 17:39\nSThe 58-40 roll call by which the Senate rejected a\nThe 58-40 roll call by which the Senate rejected a\n$1.50-per-pack increase in the tobacco tax.\nOn this vote, a ''yes'' vote was against the increase and a\n''no'' vote was in favor.\nVoting ''yes'' were 13 Democrats and 45 Republicans.\nVoting ''no'' were 32 Democrats and 8 Republicans.\nDEMOCRATS YES=\nBreaux, La.; Byrd, W.Va.; Cleland, Ga.; Feingold, Wis.;\nFeinstein, Calif. Ford, Ky. Hollings, S.C.; Inouye, Hawaii;\nKerrey, Neb.; Mikulski, Md.; Reid, Nev.; Robb, Va.; Torricelli,\nN.J.\nDEMOCRATS NO=\nAkaka, Hawaii; Baucus, Mont.; Biden, Del.; Bingaman, N.M.;\nBoxer, Calif.; Bryan, Nev.; Bumpers, Ark.; Conrad, N.D.; Daschle,\nS.D.; Dodd, Conn.; Dorgan, N.D.; Durbin, Ill.; Glenn, Ohio; Graham,\nFla.; Harkin, Iowa; Johnson, S.D.; Kennedy, Mass.; Kerry, Mass.;\nKohl, Wis.; Landrieu, La.; Lautenberg, N.J.; Leahy, Vt.; Levin,\nMich.; Lieberman, Conn.; Moseley-Braun, Ill.; Moynihan, N.Y.;\nMurray, Wash.; Reed, R.I.; Rockefeller, W.Va.; Sarbanes, Md.;\nWellstone, Minn.; Wyden, Ore.\nREPUBLICANS YES=\nAbraham, Mich.; Allard, Colo.; Ashcroft, Mo.; Bennett, Utah;\nBond, Mo.; Brownback, Kan.; Burns, Mont.; Campbell, Colo.; Coats,\nInd.; Cochran, Miss.; Collins, Maine; Coverdell, Ga.; Craig, Idaho;\nDeWine, Ohio; Domenici, N.M.; Enzi, Wyo.; Faircloth, N.C.; Frist,\nTenn.; Gorton, Wash.; Gramm, Texas; Grams, Minn.; Gregg, N.H.;\nHagel, Neb.; Hatch, Utah; Helms, N.C.; Hutchinson, Ark.; Hutchison,\nTexas; Inhofe, Okla.; Kempthorne, Idaho; Kyl, Ariz.; Mack, Fla.;\nMcCain, Ariz.; McConnell, Ky.; Murkowski, Alaska; Nickles, Okla.;\nRoberts, Kan. Roth, Del.; Santorum, Pa.; Sessions, Ala.; Shelby,\nAla.; Stevens, Alaska; Thomas, Wyo.; Thompson, Tenn.; Thurmond,\nS.C.; Warner, Va.\nREPUBLICANS NO=\nChafee, R.I.; D'Amato, N.Y.; Grassley, Iowa; Jeffords, Vt.;\nLugar, Ind.; Smith, Ore.; Snowe, Maine; Specter, Pa.\nREPUBLICANS NOT VOTING=\nLott, Miss.; Smith, N.H.\nAPNP-05-20-98 1740EDT\nFARM.525\nPage 1\nSTRIKING FORD\nFOR\n???\nAGAINST\nDems\nRepubs\nDems\nRepubs\nDems\nRepubs\nDurbin\n48\nConrad\nThompson\n41\nMcCain\n46\nDorgan\nThurmond\nFrist\nKerrey\nChafee\nWarner\nJeffords\nCollins LEAN\nSnowe\nTO\nSTRIKE\nCoverdell\nLOTT\n*\nFaircloth's staff has said he is likely to abstain.\nFAIRCLOTH\nSTRIKING LUGAR\nFOR\n???\nAGAINST\nDems\nRepubs\nDems\nRepubs\nDems\nRepubs\n44\nMcCain\nDurbin\nThompson\n38\nFrist\nSpecter\n37\nWarner\nSnowe\nD'Amato\nCollins\nChaffee\nJeffords\nDewine\nHatch\nBennet\nMack\nStevens\nThurmond\nFairloth Lott > Abstain\nExpair\nANO\nBreaux\nByrd\nBunett\nKemy\nDewine\nBond?\nM-Bran\nRobb\nkohl\n[Campbell Chafee ]\nClelad\nLandrier\nCollins\nFord\nliebern\nD'Ameto\nMollings\nWgac\nGrassley\nFeinstein\nReid\n[Grys Jeffords\nt6\n2\nSpecter\n8\nSnone\nSnone\n8-11\nMatt: lugar\n-Mack * X\n-Smith\n-Dewine\n-Bond\nL4: Bennett\nCraly\n*\n?\nIvan ne Image (Alader\nAkaka\nBacces\nX (?)\nBagaman Bryan X Y\nX\n(Hink)\n/ Baypers X\nBL\nByrd\nSandanes N\nDodd . ?\nClead N\nTorricelli N\nGlenn X Y\nKohl\nx\nBR\nJohnson\nLandrio (a) Y\n#\nlevin\nRE\nx\nGrahasencte.\nCynthia A. Rice\n05/20/98 02:16:49 PM\nRob\nRecord Type:\nRecord\ngov\nTo:\nBruce N. Reed/OPD/EOP, Elena Kagan/OPD/EOP, Laura Emmett/WHO/EOP, Cynthia Dailard/OPD/EOP\nCC:\nSubject: We will have new data POTUS could talk about tomorrow\nPerTach\nMelissa has arranged for the 5:00 pm embargo on the MMWR to NOT apply to the tobacco article.\nThus, it will be available to reporters starting at 7:00 am tomorrow morning. She gave me a one\npage fact sheet so long as we promised we would not leak it ahead of that deadline. Dailard is\nlooking at the materials now (and working on possible Q&As) but it looks like info we could use --\nOnly 86 percent of teen daily smokers who try to quit actually do so.\nYoung people underestimate the addictiveness of nicotine -- 75 percent of daily smokers who\nexpect to quit are still smoking five years later.\n34\nZ\nLugar\nwellstone milulski-\nAlland\nAschauft.\nGram\nAbrah\nTD\nCarams\nM-Brain-\nAkake-\nEnzi\nBide\nProvers\nClem\nBond\nGregg\nMurray\nGrasslay\nBoxer (P)\nMotchnson\nNickles\nBanett\nMasel\nInhofe\nReed\nBingamin\nCompbell\nBreasx\nJohnson\nColling\nKenndy Brunback\nReil\nContand\ncleland\nRockefeller\nSpector Subanas\nKerrey-\nMichourk: Roberts\nLautabay\nServen\n78LN LN\nBrya\nD'Ameto\nleahy\nSmith\nBumpes=\nCraig -\nDodd\n$1\nSanform\nLevin\nBums\nDarhle\nDeleime\nshelly\nDorgo\nRobb\nChafce Byrd\nDurbin\n43\nRoth\nDomenici\nBranch\nFee-gold\nkohl-\nSteras\nCliled\nFairloth\nB.\nKyl\nFeastein Ford\nGrahan\nHollings\nLandrier\nThrmand\nThomps\nCoats\nHarkin\nMitderson\nliberma-\nForrish\nCochae\nFirst\nHatch\nImage-\nMack\nWarner\ncoverdell\nHelms.\nMcCain\nwyde-\nGarton\nKerry\nMcConnoll\nSnowe"
}