Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 108
Trade PEPSICO The Coca-Cola Company December 16, 1999 John Podesta The White House Washington, D.C. 20500 will follow you with Dear Mr. Podesta: weelsusc The Coca-Cola Company and PepsiCo, Inc. seek your assistance in gaining relief from discriminatory and punitive taxation which is imposed on our products by the Government of India. We are writing to you jointly because we want to underscore the importance our industry attaches to this issue. In advance of President Clinton's State Visit early next year and with important deadlines within India for the approval of a new budget and major tax reforms, we need your help to see that this issue is placed at the top of the Administration's commercial agenda during President Clinton's visit. As you work now with your Indian counterparts to develop "deliverables" for the President's trip, we would be grateful for your assistance in urging the reduction of the discriminatory taxes on our products. Not only will this benefit our two companies, but it will benefit thousands of PepsiCo and Coca-Cola workers, partners and suppliers in India -- and send a clear signal that India welcomes foreign investment. Our two companies currently employ, directly and indirectly, more than 125, 000 workers in India. This figure does not include self-employment provided to vendors, retailers, and artisans, nor does it take into account the multiplier effect which provides employment in ancillary industries such as bottling, sugar and refrigeration. In addition, we have combined direct investments of more than $1 billion. India subjects American soft drinks to cumulative federal taxes of 40% -- among the highest imposed on our products anywhere in the world. There are two components to this 40% cumulative tax. First, India collects a 24% excise tax on our products. This 24% level is reserved for a so-called "demerit" band of products. Supposedly, this band applies to "luxury items" or to products that are considered "injurious to health." By contrast, other consumer products face excise taxes of 8% or 16%. Second, on top of the punitive demerit tax, our products face an additional 16% "surcharge." India's taxes are also blatantly discriminatory. Coca-Cola and PepsiCo account for more than 95% of the developing soft drink market in India. Taxes on competing and substitutable consumer products, such as coffee, tea and bottled water, are far less than those imposed on soft drinks. Other food products, such as chocolate and ice cream, are also taxed at a lower level. By contrast, the current demerit classification puts our products in the same category as firearms, ammunition and chewing tobacco. Tax rationalization for the soft drink industry is a matter of fairness and equity for American producers.