Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 111
Indian MEMORANDUM FOR MARIA ECHAVESTE FROM: MARY SMITH SUBJECT: Consultation and Coordination with Indian Tribal Governments We are about to ask the President to issue a revised Executive Order to establish regular and meaningful consultation and collaboration with tribal officials in the development of Federal policies that have tribal implications. This Order expands upon the provisions in E.O. 13084, "Consultation and Coordination with Indian Tribal Governments" (May 14, 1998), to make it equivalent in scope and procedure to E.O. 13132, "Federalism" (August 4, 1999). An issue remains: whether, how, and in what way to instruct agencies to coordinate with Alaska Native corporations established under the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act (ANCSA corporations). Status After the President signed the Federalism Order, we drafted a counterpart for Indian tribal governments. The Federalism Order is based upon the federal relationship between the national government and State governments; the new tribal consultation order is based upon the parallel government-to-government relationship between the United States government and Indian tribal governments. After OMB had circulated a January 24 draft order to Federal agencies for final clearance, we decided -- as we had with the Federalism Order -- to circulate the same draft to Indian tribes and tribal organizations to seek their comments. We have received their comments, incorporated a number of their suggestions, transmitted the resultant draft to agencies for their final review, and adopted some of their suggestions as well. But for one issue, we are ready formally to submit the draft tribal consultation order for signature. This issue concerns the ANCSA corporations. On February 24, we received a letter from an ANCSA corporation urging that the ANCSA corporations be included into the definition of "Indian tribe" as used in the draft tribal consultation order to establish "a federal government obligation to consult with them concerning regulations, proposed acts of Congress and other federal actions that may directly affect their future." On April 20, we received a letter from the Alaska Inter-Tribal Council, urging us not to include ANCSA corporations within the scope of the tribal consultation order: "Such inclusion would cast serious doubt on the meaning of 'government to government relationship' and would undermine the existing sovereign status of federal recognized tribes both inside and outside Alaska." ANCSA Corporations. In the 1960s, Alaskan Natives protested that their aboriginal title to lands had never been extinguished and that land could not be conveyed to the State of Alaska, private individuals, or oil companies until these claims were resolved. In response, Congress enacted