Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 15
3/14/54: Reel 1, ack 2, te 1 MR. KENNAN: My impression, in looking at it from the outside and later as an Ambassador in Moscow, that perhaps the truce negotiations were stickéer than they might otherwise have been, due to the extreme militarization of the talks and the publicity that attended them. This business of going into the tents with all these journalists waiting there to be given whatever was exchanged at least didn't seem to me to be the most suitable way of going at it if you had wanted to exhaust your possibilities there. Whether anything else could have been done naturally no one can say, but it wasn't tried; it couldn't be, really for a very good and sound reason. I can see that. MR. RUSK: I might just comment on that. The principal reasons why the talks were limited to military talks were: first, that neither Peiping nor Moscow had accepted any political responsibility for their troops in the field. We thought it would make it easier to avoid great issues of prestige and responsibility if we took that theory of the case, if by doing so we could get it settled. Secondly, there was the problem of status. Should we have representatives of the Government of the United States sit down HARRY on a political basis and talk to those people who call themselves the Kansas realism TRUM representatives of the Chinese Volunteers in Korea on the one side and the North Korean regime on the other? That did not seem to be in keeping with our own dignity, as it were, as a government; and we would not be in touch with responsible representatives. And third--and perhaps even more important, political talks might easily have broadened from the Korean situation into other Far Eastern questions such as Formosa, the recogni- tion of Peiping, Peiping membership in the UN, Indochina, etc. We thought that, if we injected those broad political issues into the Korean affair, it would be possible for the Communists, by appearing to agree on Korea, to shift the burden of the casus belli in Korea away from the agression in Korea to our refusal to give them Formosa, for example. And we would 0001396 have a very great difficulty in holding together our allies if the Com--