Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 35
DRAFT September 8, 1999 LABELING OF FOODS DERIVED FROM CROPS DERIVED THROUGH GENETIC ENGINEERING: DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL IMPLICATIONS Consumer concern in some countries and regions, especially in the European Union (EU), has resulted in major trade issues for U.S. firms that export agricultural products, particularly corn and soybean. For example, last year shipments of corn products were refused in Europe due to the possibility that the products might contain some amount of (or be "contaminated" with) bioengineered material. Approvals of new bioengineered agricultural products in Europe have been stalled since March 1998. This paper summarizes the Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) responsibility for food safety and labeling requirements in the U.S., explains why the U.S. had not required special labeling for bioengineered foods and food ingredients, discusses the safety and labeling requirements of other countries for bioengineered foods and food ingredients, and highlights some of the complex issues, domestic and international, for considering special labeling requirements for these products. U.S. Food Safety and Labeling Requirements: Foods Derived from Crops FDA is the agency charged under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) with the responsibility for overseeing the safety and labeling of prepackaged food and feed products, domestic and imported, that are derived from crops. FDA has established comprehensive scientific guidance for producers to assist them in meeting their legal duty to ensure the safety of the foods they market, and firms have consulted with FDA on safety and labeling issues regarding over forty bioengineered food and feed products. In general, special labeling has not been required because the products do not exhibit substantial differences from conventional food and feed products. Two of these products, high oleic soybean oil and laurate canola, were given new common/usual names because the products differ substantially in composition and use in food. Labeling includes the information contained on the package label and any accompanying informational material. The FDCA requires that labeling be truthful and not misleading and that the label bear the "common or usual" name of the food (e.g., potato). If the food product is fabricated from two or more ingredients, the ingredients must be listed in descending order of predominance. The FDCA also specifies certain other information that must be included in labeling. Labeling must reveal information that is material to representations made or implied about the food or information that is material to consequences for the consumer that may arise from consuming the food. As is the case for other foods, the labeling of a bioengineered food product must comply with all requirements of the FDCA. For example, substantial changes in composition, nutritional value, or new requirements for storage, preparation, or cooking or the presence of a new allergen must be disclosed in food labeling.