Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 12
Gerald Shea - MANUF WPD Page 1 LABOR Manufacturing Matters: Why Manufacturing is Special and the Economic Policies Needed to Foster a Strong Manufacturing Sector Executive summary Today, the manufacturing sector is in crisis having lost 491,000 jobs since March 1998. This loss of jobs is the direct result of the global economic slow down that followed the east Asian financial crisis that began in mid-1997. The massive devaluations of the currencies of the crisis countries, and the slow but steady appreciation of the dollar against many of the world's other currencies have also contributed to a sharp slow down in manufacturing export growth and an acceleration in the growth of manufacturing imports. The impact of these developments is reflected in our trade deficit which has reached record levels and threatens to surge to over $300 billion this year. Despite the traumatic impact on manufacturing, economic policy has done little to assist manufacturing in coping with the current crisis. This failure has its origins in misguided conventional wisdom that asserts that manufacturing jobs do not matter. A job is a job, and all that policy makers need be concerned about is that the total supply of jobs grows at a rate sufficient to ensure full employment. The foundation of this conventional wisdom is that manufacturing employment has fallen steadily as a share of total private employment for almost four decades. However, while the share of manufacturing employment has fallen steadily, the absolute level of manufacturing employment rose through to 1979. Since 1979, both the share and the absolute number of manufacturing jobs have fallen, and with those losses came rising income inequality, slowed productivity growth, and a deepening trade deficit. A modest turn around in the 1990s yielded slow steady growth in the number of manufacturing jobs which promised to break the decline in manufacturing employment, but this promise has been shattered by recent events. This paper provides argues that manufacturing does indeed matter to the overall health of the economy. Productivity growth is key to a rising standard of living. Manufacturing productivity growth has been significantly faster than productivity growth in the rest of the non-farm business sector since 1979. Had the manufacturing sector been larger, overall national productivity growth would have been faster. The paper presents evidence that productivity growth in the manufacturing sector spills over positively on to productivity growth in the non-manufacturing sector. This finding is consistent with the fact that the bulk of national R&D spending is done in the manufacturing sector, and with the claim that social returns to R&D spending exceed private returns. It is also consistent with the fact that manufacturing has strong backward input linkages to the non-manufacturing economy. Wages and income distribution. Manufacturing employment pays higher wages and