Ask the Scholar

Document scope · 1 page
doc
Scholar
Ask about this object, its catalog metadata, its source description, or the page inventory. For page-specific OCR and visual context, open one of the page chats.

Scholar Source Context

Document identity
localId
1553653
label
China, Republic of (4)
core
doc
dtoType
document
pageCount
1
Source metadata
id
1553653
contentType
document
title
China, Republic of (4)
collections
Presidential Country Files for East Asia and the Pacific (Ford Administration)
East Asia and Pacific Country Files
subjects
Taiwan
China
Arms transfers
Foreign aid
imageCount
1
hasImages
yes
source
import
hasTranscription
no
Source extras
naId
1553653
coverageEndDate
logicalDate
1975-06-30
month
6
year
1975
coverageStartDate
logicalDate
1975-04-01
month
4
year
1975
levelOfDescription
fileUnit
recordType
description
ocrSource
nara-archive
Single page context
seq
1
pageIndex
0
type
document
mediaId
c41229b080b345fd
ocrText
The original documents are located in Box 4, folder "China, Republic of (4)" of the Presidential Country Files for East Asia and the Pacific at the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library. Copyright Notice The copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the making of photocopies or other reproductions of copyrighted material. The Council donated to the United States of America his copyrights in all of his unpublished writings in National Archives collections. Works prepared by U.S. Government employees as part of their official duties are in the public domain. The copyrights to materials written by other individuals or organizations are presumed to remain with them. If you think any of the information displayed in the PDF is subject to a valid copyright claim, please contact the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library. Digitized from Box 4 of Presidential Country Files for East Asia and the Pacific at the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library TOP SECRET EYES ONLY CHIANG KAI-SHEK FUNERAL TRIP ART KEY POINTS A. In conversations with the following, I used the talking points provided by the Secretary of State. 1. KOREAN PRIME MINISTER KIM. Wednesday, April 16. -- Explained why strong measures necessary to correct Communist activities at home. Drew parallel with these activities and Mao's method used in takeover of China. -- Communists use every possible means to divide our two nations. -- Now trying to infiltrate religious circles. -- Want to weed out Communists very early. -- Because of Vietnam some raise questions about US commitments. Korean Government feels it has full commitment and is taking measures to reassure people no reason for doubt of US. -- Korea can take care of herself. Trying to maintain stability and develop. Trying not to become burden to US. FORD LIBRARY a 07VH30 DECLASSIFIED E.O. 12958, SEC. 3.5 NSC MEMO, 11/24/98, STATE DEPT. GUIDELINES BY GG , NARA, DATE 4/20/01 TOP SECRET - EYES ONLY TOP SECRET - EYES ONLY 2. SOUTH VIETNAM SENATE PRESIDENT LAM AND AMBASSADOR TO REPUBLIC OF CHINA (President Thieu's brother). Wednesday, April 16. -- If Congress and President would tell North Vietnamese to stop they would. -- Morale is key factor. President Ford's speech had very positive effect. Congres- sional approval of aid would be a sustaining factor. If Congress only talks about taking out 6,000 Americans it has very negative influence. -- President Thieu might consider stepping down if he were sure it would ensure real assistance and support from Congress. 3. PREMIER CHIANG CHING-KUO. Thursday, April 17. -- Four basic principles. -- No matter how much world situation changes, ROC belongs to camp of democratic nations headed by US. -- Policy is and will remain totally Anti-Communist. -- Cooperation and solidarity among people living on Taiwan. FORD & BRAB) 07VH39 2 TOP SECRET - EYES ONLY TOP SECRET - EYES ONLY -- Continue economic construction so all can enjoy better standard of living. -- One of last things President Chiang said was that Government and people of US are the best friends of our people. This is guiding principle. -- Chiang has told US visitors ROC does not expect substantial US support. Do not want American boys involved. Counseled US against involvement in Vietnam. War in Asia must be fought by Asians themselves. -- All ROC expects from US is moral and spiritual support. -- Both PRC and Russia are enemies. Won't play one against another. -- Invited President Ford and Vice President to visit Taiwan. 4. FOREIGN MINISTER MIYAZAWA OF JAPAN. Thursday, April 17. -- In US reassessment of policies in Asia, should not take any actions very rapidly. FORD & GERALD 3 TOP SEGRET - EYES ONLY TOP SECRET - EYES ONLY B. In addition to the above, I met with a number of other foreigners in Taiwan. -- Former Prime Ministers Kishi and Sato of Japan. -- Saudi Arabians, Cambodians. C. Schedule and reporting telegrams attached. FORD LIBRARY & GERALD 4 TOP SECRET - EYES ONLY TOP SECRET - EYES ONLY ADMIRAL GAYLER - CINCPAC - HAWAII. Sunday, April 13. Vietnam -- South Vietnam has only 2 weeks to a month. -- Situation not reversible by aid. -- We should evacuate now. We should at least start getting women and children out. -- Perhaps could take people out on planes bringing in food, aid, and ammunition. -- We should not be deceived by ease of Cambodian operation. Extraction from Vietnam will be a major military operation. We should start reducing numbers now. FORD LIBRARY & GERALD TOP SECRET - EYES ONLY 2 ACTION COPY OF STATE COPY / OF 15 COPIES # Department of State UNITED STATES or TELEGRAM SECKET NOD655 PAGE 01 1787522 CONTROL: 41370 RECD: 17 APR 75 14-10 4:09AM ACTION NOUS-00 INFO OCT-01 1001 W 050859 0 170748Z APR 75 FM THE WHITE HOUSE TO SECSTATE INFO AMEMBASSY TAIPEI SECRE T NODIS Wh50708 FROM JON HOWE TAGS: GVIP (HOCKEFELLER, NELSON A.) E.O.: 11652: GDS 1. FOLLOWING ARE SUBSTANTIVE HIGHLIGHTS OF APRIL 17 MEETING BETWEEN VICE PRESIDENT ROCKEFELLER AND PREMIER CHIANG CHING-KUU. DETAILED MEMORANDUM OF CONVERSATION WILL BE PREPARED LATER, 2. THE PREMIER WAS OBVIOUSLY GRATIFIED WITH THE PRESIDENT'S SELECTION OF THE VICE PRESIDENT TO HEAD THE U.S. DELEGATION TO HIS FATHER'S FUNERAL. HE EXPRESSED WARM THANKS FUR THE PRESIDENT'S CON- DOLENCE STATEMENT AND HIS MESSAGE OF CONDOLENCE TO HIM ON THE OCCASION OF HIS FATHER'S DEATH. HE PAGE 2 RUEAOWN 2210 SECRET CHARACTERIZED THE VICE PRESIDENT'S ATTENDANCE AS INDICATIVE OF CONTINUED PRIENDSHIP BETWEEN THE TWO COUNTRIES. HE NOTED THAT IT WAS VERY TOUCHING TO HAVE FRIENDS SUCH AS THE UNITED STATES. THE VICE PRESIDENT NOTED THAT THE FRIENDSHIP BETWEEN OUR TWO COUNTRIES WAS DEEP AND LASTING AND THAT IT WOULD CONTINUE. THIS FRIENDSHIP WOULD REMAIN UNAFFECTED BY PRESIDENT CHIANG'S DEATH. THE U.S. WILL CONTINUE TO VALUE ITS FRIENDLY AND ECONOMIC TIES TO THE ROC. FORD =, THE PREMIER RELATED FOUR BASIC PRINCIPLES WHICH & WOULD GOIDE HOC POLICIES. HE SAIU THESE PRINCIPLES SECRET GERALD LIBRARY GG 4/20/01 NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF State Department of State UNITED STATES OF AMERICA TELEGRAM SECRET PAGE 02 1707532 HAD BEEN REPEATEDLY STRESSED TO HIM BY HIS FATHER DURING THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS. THE ROC WOULD STEADFASTLY ADHERE TO THEM. THESE PRINCIPLES ARE: (1) NO MATTER HOW MUCH THE WORLD SITUATION CHANGES, THE ROC WOULD CONTINUE TO BELONG TU THE CAMP OF DEMOCRATIC NATIONS MEADED BY THE U.S. (2) THE ROC WOULD MAINTAIN A CONSISTENTLY ANTI- PAGE 3 RUEADWN 2210 5 ECRET COMMUNIST POLICY UNTIL FINAL VICTORY WAS ACHIEVED. (3) THE RUC WOULD STRIVE TO ACHIEVE COOPERATION AND SOLIDARITY BETWEEN THE PEOPLES LIVING ON TAIWAN. (4) THE ROC WOULD CONTINUE TO PRESS ON WITH ECONOMIC CONSTRUCTION IN ORDER TO IMPROVE THE LIVING STANDARD OF THE PEOPLE 5. THE VICE PRESIDENT NOTED THAT TAIWAN WAS FORTUNATE THAT A STRONG LEAUERSHIP WAS INHERITING PRESIDENT'S MANTLE. ME TOLD HOW IMPRESSED WE ALL WERE WITH THE ECUNOMIC MIRACLE THAT HAD OCCURRED ON TAIWAN. 5. THE PREMIER RETURNED TO THE QUESTION OF ROC RELATIONS WITH THE U.S. HE REFERRED TO HIS FATHER'S REPEATED ADMONITIONS TO HIM OVER THE YEARS THAT REGARDLESS OF THE PROBLEMS AND UNCERTAINTIES OF THE WORLD SITUATION, THE GOVERNMENT AND PEOPLE OF THE U.S. WERE THE BEST OF FRIENDS OF THE ROC AND ITS PEOPLE. ACCORDING TO THE PREMIER, SHORTLY PAGE 4 RUEADW 2210 SECRET R E BEFORE HE DIED THE PRESIDENT AGAIN REAFFIRMED THIS SENTIMENT. THE PREMIER NOTED THAT HE REGARDS FORD HIS FATHER'S ADMONITION AS A GUIDING PRINCIPLE & 7. THE PREMIER RECOUNTED THAT IN MEETING OFFICIAL AMERICAN VISITORS OVER THE YEARS. PRESIDENT CHIANG SECRET GERALD LIBRARY NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF & STATE Department of State UNITED TELEGRAM STATES OF SECRET PAGE 03 170753Z HAD CONSISTENTLY ADVISED AGAINST THE USE OF AMERICAN TROOPS IN VIETNAM. THE PRESIDENT MADE CLEAR TO THESE VISITORS THAT THE ROC DUES NOT EXPECT SUB- STANTIAL ASSISTANCE FROM THE U.S. ALL IT DESIRED WAS AMERICAN SPIRITUAL AND MORAL SUPPORT. THE PREMIER REITERATED THAT THE ROC CONTINUES ONLY TO SEEK AMERICAN MORAL AND SPIRITUAL SUPPORT. E. AGAIN PUTTING IT IN TERMS OF A PRINCIPLE ESTABLISHED BY THE LATE PRESIDENT AND ONE THAT WOULD BE UNFAILINGLY AUHERED TO BY HIM, THE PREMIER STATED THAT THE ROC VIEWS BOTH MOSCOW AND PEKING AS ENEMIES AND WOULD NOT HAVE ANY DEALINGS WITH ONE IN ORDER TO PLAY IT OFF AGAINST THE OTHER # THE PREMIER AGAIN STRESSED THIS WOULD REMAIN 4 GUIDING PRINCIPLE FOR THE ROC. PAGE 5 RUEADWW 2210 SECHET 9, THE PREMIER EXTENDED AN INVITATION TO BOTH PRESIDENT FORD AND VICE PRESIDENT ROCKEFELLER TO VISIT TAIWAN AT THEIR CONVENIENCE. ThE VICE PRESIDENT SAID HE WUULD TRANSMIT THIS KIND INVITATION TO PRESIDENT FORD. ON THE SUBJECT OF VISITS, THE VICE PRESIDENT TOLD THE PREMIER THAT THERE WERE NO AGREEMENTS OR COMMITMENTS UNDERTAKEN WITH RESPECT TO THE PRESIDENT'S FORTHCOMING VISIT TO THE PRC. UNGER EOT FORD & SECRET GERALD LIBRARY NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY 3a 7508518 2814 DEPARTMENT OF STATE Washington, D.C. 20520 SECRET April 29, 1975 MEMORANDUM FOR LIEUTENANT GENERAL BRENT SCOWCROFT THE WHITE HOUSE Subject: Sales of Military Equipment to the Republic of China The Republic of China (ROC) is seeking US approval for the extension of two of its military co-production projects: F5E aircraft and T-53 air- craft engines. We also have a long outstanding ROC request to purchase the Harpoon anti-ship missile. Decisions are required on responses to these requests. For commercial reasons, the F5E is the most urgent of the ROC requests, because the ROC must inform Northrop of its intentions by May 1 or forfeit most of a million dollar deposit. The ROC already has approval for the co-production with the Northrop Company of 100 F5E's. This program will be completed in November 1977. It now seeks approval to produce an additional 20 aircraft. These would be the first installment of a planned-for produc- tion of an additional 100 F5's: 75 F5E's and 25 F5F's, a two-seat version capable of both training and combat missions. Although we are supporting the construction of the first 100 aircraft with FMS credit, the ROC has not asked for further assistance, and we do not recommend it. An additional 20 F5E's would increase ROC Air Force strength by mid-1978 to an estimated 272 combat aircraft, including 120 F5E's, 71 of the older F5A's and F5B's and 81 F-104's and F-100's which are rapidly approaching the end of their projected service life. FORD ? SECRET GDS GG4/20/01 GERALD SEGRET 2. The T-53 engines are being co-produced by the ROC and the Avco Lycoming Company for use in the ROC's UH-1H helicopter. A total of 80 engines will be com- pleted by June, 1976. Avco Lycoming has now asked for an export license to produce an additional 43 engines, which would be used in an ROC-designed basic trainer aircraft. These are new requests. We are still holding a ROC request of May, 1974 to purchase the Harpoon anti-ship missile which is stimulated by concern over the increas- ing threat to its Navy posed by the PRC's growing strength in high speed patrol boats armed with Styx missiles. The ROC wants to mount Harpoon on patrol boats which it intends to purchase. Harpoon is not yet in the US Navy inventory and earliest delivery to the ROC would be mid-1977 at best. The ROC has not been specific about the number it wants, but has requested approval of a sale in principle. Our Embassy in Taipei supports all three of these requests. It particularly sees strong military and political justifications for the additional F5E's and Harpoon. USLO has specifically expressed serious reservations about the additional F5E's, arguing that the PRC will view approval as another US "transfusion" to the ROC and as slippage in the implementation of the Shanghai Communique. We regard the question of additional F5E's as the most important. In view of the overwhelming size of the PRC air force and the critical importance of maintaining control of the air in defending Taiwan, there is a valid military requirement for this modest augmentation of ROC air strength. Largely through our educational efforts, the ROC, which continues to view its security in predominantly military terms, assigns highest priority to maintaining a credible air defense. Our refusal to meet a request in this vital area would be interpreted by the ROC as evidence of a new and far more restrictive policy on weapons supply, with dangerous implication for its security. ROC worries about its diplomatic relationship with the US would be accompanied by fear that it would also be cut off from access to US arms. If the cumulative SECRET FORD of GERALD LIBRARY SECRET 3. effect of negative US decisions on arms supply were to generate such alarm in Taipei, the ROC could be prompted into actions which would complicate our course with the PRC. On the other hand, approval of this request would demonstrate to the ROC our continued interest in Taiwan's security, regardless of the question of our formal ties with it. The ROC would hope that a favorable decision on 20 additional F5E's would portend US approval of further F5E's, but we could caution against such an inference. There is little question that US agreement to more F5E's for the ROC would upset Peking, and we would have to be prepared to hold firm and defend our action as consistent with normalization. The PRC has not made a major issue over the original F5E project, and it is familiar with the limited capabilities of this aircraft. We believe that Peking would not react immediately and vigorously to an additional 20 aircraft. To improve chances of this, we would stipulate that the ROC not publicize the decision. Over the longer run, in reaction to this type of activity the PRC might press us to adopt more restrictive practices on the supply of military equipment to the ROC. We believe that to balance an affirmative decision on more F5E's, we should not approve the ROC requests for the Harpoon missile or for additional production of T-53 engines. While the ROC has a valid military require- ment for an anti-ship missile, it is not limited to a US source of supply. Taipei has already obtained a small number of the Israeli "Gabriel" missile for testing pur- poses, and the Italian "Ottomat" is also available. Both of these are more comparable to the Styx than the Harpoon, which is considerably more sophisticated, versatile and has a much greater range. As for the T-53 engines for use in the ROC trainer, this is not a vital defense need, and a turn-down here would have the added benefit of avoiding the appearance of helping the ROC develop an independent aircraft production capability. We therefore recommend that the request for 20 more F5E aircraft be approved and that those for Harpoon missiles and additional T-53 engines be disapproved. In the case of Harpoon, we believe that we should continue to remain silent, since the ROC probably already appreci- ates that our silence to date is a face-saving turn-down. SECRET FORD & GERAVE LIBRARY SECRET 4. The Department of Defense strongly supports approval of the 20 additional F5E aircraft. It does not concur in the disapproval of the additional T-53 engines or Harpoon. In view of this difference of opinion, we believe it best to defer an decision on the latter two matters. Jenos Executive S.Spling,Van S. Springsteen Secretary SECRET BERALD & LISHARY CORD 35 DOC RECD G NBR INITIAL ACTION o ISC CORRESPONDENCE PROFILE MO DA MO 7502814 DA HR Fraibe REFERENCE: CIRCLE AS APPROPRIATE TO: PRES FROM: kissinger, H S/S 7508578 UNCLAS LOG IN/OUT SOURCE/CLASS/DESCRIPTION KISSINGER COLBY, W OTHER LOU NO FORN NODIS SCOWCROFT SCHLESINGER, J C EYES ONLY EXDIS DAVIS ST EX SEC S CODEWORD SUBJECT: Stinson tt Roc TS SENSITIVE t of Projects INTERNAL ROUTING AND DISTRIBUTION REC ACTION REQUIRED ACTION INFO CY ADVANCE CYS TO HAK/SCOWCROFT FOR MEMO FOR HAK ( ) STAFF SECRETARY MEMO FOR PRES ( ) FAR EAST FICENCE X REPLY FOR ( ) SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA APPROPRIATE ACTION ( ) DISTRIBUTION/INITIAL ACTION ASGMT MID EAST / NO. AFRICA / so. ASIA MEMO TO ( ) EUROPE / CANADA RECOMMENDATIONS ( ) LATIN AMERICA JOINT MEMO ( ) UNITED NATIONS REFER TO FOR: ( ) ECONOMIC ANY ACTION NECESSARY? ( ) SCIENTIFIC CONCURRENCE. ( ) PROGRAM ANALYSIS DUE DATE: NSC PLANNING COMMENTS: (INCLUDING SPECIAL 5/8 INSTRUCTIONS) CONGRESSIONAL OCEANS POLICY INTELLIGENCE SOLOMON SMYSER DATE FROM TO S SUBSEQUENT ACTION REQUIRED (OR TAKEN): CY TO 10/30 I Action Completed per Pala SUBSEQUENT ROUTING/ACTIONS 2 Cr realls Action complete But Could ant remember details FORD DISPATCH & CY RQMTS: SEE ABOVE PLUS: MICROFILM & FILE RQMTS: NSC/S DISP INSTR NOTIFY & DATE BY M/F'D NOV 1975 SPECIAL DISPOSITION: OPEN CRT ID: 6AB SA SF CROSS REF W/ HP NS SUSPENSE CY ATTACHED: FOLDER: CLOSE WH EP PA DY (NBC-74-21) 4c DOC RECD LOG NBR INITIAL ACTION o ISC CORRESPONDENCE PROFILE Imper COLBY, W MO DA MO DA HR 19 20 12 750345 REFERENCE: CIRCLE AS APPROPRIATE TO: PRES FROM: KISSINGER, S/S UNCLAS LOG IN/OUT SOURCE/CLASS/DESCRIPTION KISSINGER OTHER LOU NO FORN NODIS SCOWCROFT + SCHLESINGER, J C EYES ONLY EXDIS Unger a of SUBJECT: DAVIS The Jay ST EX/SEC Fourt Into w/gat Chenic TS S SENSITIVE CODEWORD INTERNAL ROUTING AND 20 DISTRIBUTION ACTION INFO REC CY 1975 ACTION REQUIRED ADVANCE CYS TO HAK/SCOWCROFT FOR MEMO FOR HAK - ) STAFF SECRETARY MEMO FOR PRES ( ) REPLY FOR FAR EAST ( ) SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA APPROPRIATE ACTION - ) DISTRIBUTION/INITIAL ACTION ASGMT MID EAST / NO. AFRICA / so. ASIA MEMO TO ( ) EUROPE / CANADA RECOMMENDATIONS ( ) LATIN AMERICA JOINT MEMO - ) UNITED NATIONS REFER TO FOR: ( ) ECONOMIC ANY ACTION NECESSARY? ( ) SCIENTIFIC CONCURRENCE. - - PROGRAM ANALYSIS DUE DATE: NSC PLANNING COMMENTS: (INCLUDING SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS) CONGRESSIONAL OCEANS POLICY INTELLIGENCE 15 DATE FROM Sup TO S Jacher SUBSEQUENT ACTION REQUIRED (5-20) (OR TAKEN): CY TO X 5/20 Nacls Noted by b. croft SUBSEQUENT ROUTING/ACTIONS FORD & GERALD LIBRARY DISPATCH CY RQMTS: SEE ABOVE PLUS: MICROFILM & FILE RQMTS: NSC/S DISP INSTR NOTIFY & DATE BY M/F'D BY SPECIAL DISPOSITION: CRT ID: MAY20 1975. SA SF C REF W/ OPEN HP NS ISE CY ATTACHED: X FOLDER: CLOSE WH EP PA DY (NBC-74-21) 4a MEMORANDUM 3456 NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL SECRET GDS ACTION MEMORANDUM FOR: GENERAL SCOWCROFT May 19, 1975 Think FROM: W. R. SMYSER 8 SUBJECT: Your Meeting with Our Ambassador to the Republic of China, Leonard Unger, on May 20, 1975 at 3:00 p.m. You have agreed to meet with Ambassador Unger on May 20, 1975 at 3:00 p.m. to review our policy toward the ROC and our normalization process with Peking. Background Dick Solomon, Jack Froebe, and I met with Ambassador Unger on May 16. Unger made the following points about the evolution of our relations with Taiwan: -- Premier Chiang Ching-kuo (CCK) on May 3 gave Unger a memorandum (attached at Tab A), which CCK asked Unger to transmit to the President. This memorandum is essentially an ROC effort to use the fall of Indochina and the resulting U.S. policy assessment to regain some of the ground the ROC has lost in recent years. The memorandum, in which CCK repeats the views he expressed to the Vice President and to Unger earlier, asserts that Taiwan is indispensible to the security of Japan and to the U.S. position in Asia generally, arguing that Taiwan is an essential link in the off-island defense chain. The memorandum thus would have the U.S. reverse the basic policy goal stated in the Shanghai Communique. It also exudes ROC satisfaction with the President's recent public attention to Taiwan. -- Ambassador Unger believes he should be authorized to deliver an oral reply to CCK, and will give us his suggestions on the substance of a reply. FORD & SECRET GDS GERALD LIBRARY GG 4/20/01 SECRET 2 We must continue the gradual approach to the attenuation of our relations with Taipei, in order to avoid an ROC resort to alternatives of desperation -- such as the Soviet option or a formal declaration of Taiwan's independence from the mainland. The ROC is resigned to U.S. normalization of relations with Peking, but can digest just so many particulars in this process at any one time. The situation in Taipei is not so brittle as to give the Secretary and the President no leeway in their Peking talks. Taipei could adjust to a reversal in the relationship -- a switch of the Embassy and the Liaison Office -- so long as Taipei had some credible assurance on the island's security. (The State ROC Country Director, Burt Levin, interjected, however, that the PRC would never tolerate any official ROC presence in Washington after such a switch.) The ROC, before Indochina's fall, expected the worst from the President's Peking trip a reversal in our representation -- but now is hopeful that this may not be in the cards for this trip at least. He (Ambassador Unger) should be authorized to begin as soon as possible consultations with CCK on what is likely to result from the President's PRC visit, in order to get the difficult adjustment process underway. Unger recognizes, however, that such consultations will not be possible until rather late in the game. On the U.S. military presence on Taiwan, the 327th Air Division can be disestablished in the first quarter of FY 76. Unger said that he would find it useful to continue MAAG and TDC up to the point of diplomatic derecognition -- rather than to have MAAG and TDC amalgamated If MAAG were to continue this way, Unger would expect a reduction in the rank of the heads of these two organizations. Another alternative which Unger suggested would be the merger of MAAG into the DAO. I believe that you should use this meeting with Ambassador Unger to reaffirm existing guidance on China policy, particularly since he will not see the Secretary and since we should have some differences with the EA Bureau, where some people would have us attenuate our relationship with Taipei faster than we believe the ROC can adjust. I will plan to sit in on the meeting. Suggested Talking Points I am interested in your appraisal of the ROC's reaction to the FORD fall of Indochina. & GERALD LIBRARY SECRET SECRET 3 -- Understandably, the ROC is probing our policy to see if we might slow the process of normalization with Peking and what influence they (the ROC) might have on us in this respect. I note that Premier Chiang Ching-kuo has sent us a memorandum on the question of our general China policy. How do you suggest that we reply? I want to affirm that the normalization of our relations with Peking will stay on course, although we are not yet sure whether there might be some adjustments in the pace as a result of the setback in Indochina. We are now only beginning to chart what we might try to accomplish during the President's trip to Peking later this year. I understand well your desire to begin to prepare the ROC for any major new steps that might result. By the very nature of the process, however, this will be difficult. Nevertheless, we are sensitive to the need, and will authorize consultations as early as possible, even though this may be considerably later than might be desirable in terms of the ROC's adjustment. What is your assessment of the ROC's estimate as to what is likely to transpire during the President's Peking visit, and what the limits of the ROC's toleration are? The Taiwan NSSM covering both our future military presence in Taiwan and our future military assistance to Taiwan is now in its final stages, and we hope to get out comprehensive guidance in the near future. What is your assessment of the political impact of President Chiang's death? In particular, has it brought on a certain psychological letdown, particularly among mainlanders, which although anticipated all along nevertheless could not really be experienced and dealt with until the event actually occurred? FORD ? GERALO SECRET Department of Stare 4b of / SELINA AMERICA TELEGRAM SECRET 2166 PAGE 01 TAIPEI 02415 050026Z 62 ACTION SS-25 JAF Libiscuss 8 INFO OCT-01 ISO-00 /026 w DB/P CLIFT 02026 R 0304392 MAY 75 ELLIOTT FM AMEMBASSY TAIPEI FROEDE TO SECSTATE WASHDC 5053 8 HORAN KENNEDY LODAL S RCRE TAIPEI 2415 LOW OBER EXDIS RATLIFF S OAKLEY SMYSER E.O. 11552: XGDS-1 SOLUMON TAGS: PFOR, TW, TH, RP, CH STEARMAN SUBJECT: MEETING WITH FOREIGN MINISTER SHEN FARRAR REF: TAIPEI 2255 anderson 1. I CALLED ON FONMIN SHEN CHANG-HUAN AT HIS REQUEST, MAY 3. REFERRING TO MY RECENT CONVERSATION WITH PREMIER CHIANG AT TZU HU (REFTEL), SHEN SAID PREMIER HAD ASKED THAT ESSENCE OF VIEWS PREMIER HAD EXPRESSED ON THAT OCCASION AS WELL AS IN TALK WITH VICE PRESIDENT ROCKEFELLER ON APRIL 16, BE PRESENTED IN BRIEF PAPER AND REQUESTED THAT IT BE TRANSMITTED BY ME TO PRESIDENT FORD WHEN I RETURNED TO WASHINGTON FOR CONSULTATIONS. 2, PAPER WHICH SHEN READ AND HANDED ME COPY IS QUOTED BELOW: REGIN QUOTE THE TRAUMATIC EVENTS THAT HAVE OCCURRED IN INDO-CHINA RECENTLY CANNOT BUT HAVE TREMENDOUS IMPACT ON VARIOUS PARTS OF THE WORLD, PARTICUL RLY IN THE ASTAN AND PACIFIC REGION. THE LEADERS OF THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA AGREE WITH PRESIDENT FORD THAT TO INDULGE IN RECRIMINATION AND IN APPORTIONING BLAMES IS NOT PRODUCTIVE. ON THE OTHER HAND, MANY LESSONS MUST BE DRAWN FROM THIS TRAGEDY TO PREVENT HISTORY FROM REPEATING ITSELF. MILITARILY, THE INDO-CHINA CHAPTER MAY HAVE NOW COME FORD & TO A CLOSE. HOWEVER, A "NEW AGENDA" AS APTLY CALLED BY PRESIDENT FORD SHOULD BE METICULOUSLY DISCUSSED, PLANNED DECLASSIFIED GERALD LIBRARY E.O. 12958, SEC. 3.5. STATE DEPT, GUIDELINES, state 8/7/00 SECRET BY. GG I NARA, DATE 4/20/01 NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY A GRAINA Department of State TELEGRAM STATES or separ SECRET PAGE 02 TAIPEI 02415 050026Z AND PREPARED TO DEAL WITH OTHER PROBABLE AND POSSIBLE INTERNATIONAL CRIES THAT ARE SURELY FORTHCOMING. IT IS UNDERSTANDABLE THAT MANY COUNTRIES IN THIS AREA, ESPECIALLY THAILAND AND THE PHILIPPINES, HAVE BECOME INCREASINGLY NERVOUS, WHICH MIGHT EVEN LEAD TO PANIC, IN THE VIEW OF THE REPUBLIC UF CHINA, THAILAND AND THE PHILIPPINES SHOULD BE GIVEN TOP PRIORITY OF THE U.S. "NEW AGENDA". THAT "AN, COUNTRIES 1N Tnio Trif PHILIPPINES, HAVE SECUME WHILE ATTENDING TO SOUTHEAST ASIA, EQUAL IMPORTANCE L. IN OF NORTHEAST ASIA CANNOT BE GAINSAID. THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA IS COGNIZANT THAT THE U.S. ATTACHES GREAT IMPORTANCE TO JAPAN FOR ITS INDUSTRIAL AND ECONOMIC PROWESS. BUT THE PROTECTION OF JAPAN HINGES UN THE SECURITY AND STABILITY OF THE REPUBLIC OF KOREA AND THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA WHICH ARE VITAL AND INDISPENSABLE FLANKS TO JAPAN. SHOULD FITHER OF THE FLANKS FALL INTU THE HANDS OF AN ADVERSARY OF THE U.S., IT WOULD RENDER JAPAN MILITARILY int VULNERABLE ANU CREATE UNFATHOMABLE CONFUSION AND DIVISION IN ITS DOMESTIC POLITICS. JAPAN'S INDUSTRIAL -1Cm CAPABILITY WOULD THEN BECOME ASSETS TO AMERICA'S ENEMIES. CONFIDENTIALLY, A NUMBER OF JAPAN'S LEADING ELDERLY STATESMEN HAVE EXPRESSED THE FEARS OF SUCH A NIGHTMARE. CORPOSION AND JAPATES INJUSTRIAL TT IS BELIEVED THAT A STRONG CHAIN STRETCHING FROM NOREA, JAPAN, THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA, THE PHILIPPINES, INDONESIA DOWN TO AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND WOULD FORM A RELIABLE AND CREDIBLE FIRST LINE OF DEFENSE FOR THE U.S. DIPLOMATICALLY AND MILITARILY. AST-FICHING F-OM AS PREMIER CHIANG CHING RTC 1020 ICi PRESIDENT IMPINES, NELSON ROCKEFELLER, THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA IS UNEQUIVOCALLY FORD DEDICATED TO THE FOLLOWING POLICY DECISIONS: int & !. UNRELENTING STRUGGLE AGAINST COMMUNISM AND GERALD LIBRARY COMMUNIST REGIMES NO MATTER WHERE THEY ARE AND DETERMINED TO DEFEND THE SECURITY OF TAIWAN, PESCADORES, QUEMOY AND MATSU: 2. FIRM ALIGNMENT WITH THE FREE WORLD, PARTICULARLY STRUGGLE AGAINST COMMUNISM AND WHERE THE ARE AND WETERMINED COMMISST THE SECURITY SECRET QUENOY ANL MAISU: NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY ; STATE Department of State C UNITED AMERICA TELEGRAM STATES of SECRET PAGE 03 TAIPEI 02415 050026Z TO U.S.; 3. FURTHER PROMOTION OF INTERNAL POLITICAL SOLIDARITY; AND 4. REDOUBLED EFFORTS FOR THE CONTINUING DEVELOPMENT OF THE ECONOMIC WELL-BEING OF THE PEOPLE. BY so DOING, THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA WILL BE ABLE TO PLAY A POSITIVE AND CONSTRUCTIVE ROLE IN THE NEW ERA. IT IS THE FERVENT HOPE OF THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA THAT PRESIDENT FORD WILL EXERCISE HIS FARSIGHTED AND STEADFAST STATESMANSHIP WHIC WILL HELP OVERCOME ANY DIFFICULTIES IN THE INTERNATIONAL ARENA. IN THE LIGHT OF PREMIER CHIANG CHING-KUO'S BASIC POLICY DIRECTION, \ PRESIDENT FORD AND THE U.S. GOVERNMENT CAN ALWAYS COUNT UPON THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA AS A LOYAL ALLY AND PARTNER. PRESIDENT FORU HAS REPEATEDLY OFFERED HIS ASSURANCES THAT WHAT TRANSPIRED IN INDU-CHINA SHOULD NOT IMPAIR THE CREDIBILITY OF THE U.S. IN ITS FULFILLMENT OF COMMITMENTS TO THE OTHER ALLIES AND FRIENDS IN ASIA AND THE PACIFIC. THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA IS GRATIFISQBQTH THE WARM SENTIMENTS EXPRESSED BY PRESIDENT FORD TOWARDS THIS COUNTRY IN HIS RECENT APPEARANCE AT THE AMERICAN NEWSPAPER EDITORS ASSOCIATION IN NEW YORK, THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA WOULD APPRECIATE IT IF THE U.S. GOVERNMENT WOULD REPEAT SUCH REASSURANCES WHENEVER THE SAME ARE PUBLICLY GIVEN TO OTHER COUNTRIES OF THE REGION. FREQUENT AND FRANK CONSULTATIUNS BETWEEN THE TWO GOVERNMENTS WOULD BE MOST BENEFICIAL FOR BOTH COUNTRIES. FOR THE TASK OF STABILIZING THAILAND. THE PHILIPPINES AND OTHER SOUTHEAST ASIAN COUNTRIES THE STRENGTHENING OF THE TIES BETWEEN THE U.S. AND NATIONS IN NORTHEAST ASIA FORD IN GENERAL ANU THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA IN PARTICULAR A LIBRARY SECRET NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY Lipartment of Stat STATE AMERICA TELEGRAM or SECRET S PAGE 04 TAIPEI 02415 0500262 COULD ALSO SERVE AS A CREDIBLE TOKEN OF THE U.S. INTENTION AND DETERMINATION, so THAT THE WAVERING AND NERVOUS COUNTRIES IN THIS AREA WOULD NOT BE DRAWN INTO THE ORBIT OF THE CHINESE COMMUNISTS. END QUOTE 3. I TOLD SHEN THAT EXPRESSION OF ROC VIEWS AS PRESENTED IN PAPER WOULD BE HELPFUL IN CURRENT WASHINGTON REASSESSMENT OF OUR POLICIES AND THAT I WOULD MAKE A PARTICULAR POINT OF BRINGING TO ATTENTION OF OUR POLICY MAKERS. I EXPECTED THIS REASSESSMENT WOULD RESULT IN POLICY FOUNDED ON BASIC, LONG-TERM INTERESTS, AND THAT, IN THIS CONNECTION, I FELT SURE THAT OUR PEOPLE WOULD CONTINUE TO HAVE VERY MUCH IN MIND THE S MEANS OF WHICH A MODUS VIVENDI COULD BE WORKED OUT WITH MAINLAND CHINA IN ORDER TO BETTER ASSURE PEACE AND STABILITY IN EAST ASIA AND ALSO TO SEEK SOLUTIONS TO SOME WORLD PROBLEMS IN WHICH MAINLAND CHINA MUST PLAY A ROLE. I TOLD SHEN THAT WE WECD VERY WELL AWARE OF ROC VIEWS ON THIS SUBJECT AND ITS ESSENTIAL INTEREST IN OUR DEVELOPING RELATIONS WITH THE PRC. SHEN INDICATED HIS UNDERSTANDING, BUT WONDERED IF THE HIGH PRICE WE WOULD HAVE TO PAY FOR FURTHERING DETENTE WITH THE COMMUNISTS WOULD SE WORTH THE CLEAR DISADVANTAGES. HE POINTED UP THE "NONTRUSTWORTHINESS" OF THE CHINESE COMMUNISTS, E.G., INDOCHINA, CONTINUING SUPPORT FOR INSURGENCIES, ETC., AS CONTRASTED WITH THE CLEAR, UNAMBIGUOUS ICIES OF THE ROC WHICH WERE STRONGLY SUPPORTIVE OF THE U.S. S 4. OUR CONVERSATION CONTINUED OVER A RATHER BROAD RANGE OF SUBJECTS WHICH WILL BE REPORTED SEPTELS. 5. REGARDING PREMIER'S REQUEST THAT PAPER QUUTED PARA 2, ABOVE BE TRANSMITTED TO PRESIDENT FORD, I WILL WISH TO DISCUSS THIS DURING MY CONSULTATION WASHINGTON. UNGER FORD & GERALD LIBRARY SECRET NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF-THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY INTERNAL NSC ROUTING 6/30/75 CLIFT DAVIS ELLIOTT HORMATS LODAL OAKLEY SMYSER SOLOMON 5a 1 ml 1 (park. Hrouger FROEBE HORAN GRANGER * LOW OBER GERALD A. LIBRARY FORD STEARMAN JANKA DARGIS no further action SKANCKE FARRAR OTHER ADMIN (TURN THIS TAB UP TO MOVE BACK TO THE SECRETARIAT) BOW ol 5b General: I've told Bud that MAK said OK to so ahead. David ) the Saldn? Whis A. FORD LIBRARY I 5c The ABOARD AIR FORCE ONE Hung Here is the while package on the F-5 10- production for Taiwan The F-5 portion is at the paper chip. But 3 We l med a response Today (Linday) cre the issue. Hoktogs R FORD LIBRARY and - No - 1 Sume AAM5d 3641 MEMORANDUM NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL TOP SEGRET/SENSITIVE URGENT ACTION May 27, 1975 MEMORANDUM FOR: GENERAL SCOWCROFT FROM: W. R. SMYSER RICHARD H. SOLOMON RKS CLINTON E. GRANGER SUBJECT: Co-Production of 50 F-5E's by the Republic of China We have separately sent the Secretary the Taiwan NSSM, which deals with further arms deliveries to the Republic of China and, inter alia, with the question of co-production of another 20 F-5E's. It now turns out that a decision on the 20 F-5E's must be made in the next two days, because the ROC must inform Northrop of its intent by June 1 or forfeit most of a $1 million deposit. We would appreciate your raising this with the Secretary within the next day or two and letting us have a cable reply by Friday, May 30, so that we can advise the ROC in time. As our memorandum on the NSSM indicated, the ROC would not require any U.S. aid to produce the additional 20 aircraft, and we would not recommend giving it. It would, however, regard this as the first installment of its plan to produce an additional 100 F-5's to replace obsolescing aircraft. Our embassy in Taipei strongly recommends approving the additional F-5E's; USLO expresses serious reservations. State and DOD favor approval. We believe it would be consistent with Option 3 in the lower range, which is our general recommendation on providing military equipment to the ROC. All of us recommend urgent approval, which would be consistent with the bureaucracy recommendations in the NSSM and also consistent with what we believe should be our general position on assistance to E.O. 12958, SEC. 3.5 NBC MEMO, 11/24/98, STATE DEPT. GUIDELINES NARA, DATE 4/20/01 the ROC. DECLASSIFIED RECOMMENDATION: That you urgently discuss the co-production of an additional 20 F-5E's with the Secretary to obtain his approval in time to notify the ROC (and Northrop) by the end of this week. FORD & BY TOP SEGRET/SENSITIVE - XGDS GERALD LIBRARY Se CUNFIDENTIAL EYES ONLY WHA077 00 WTE12 TOR: 3018552 DE WTE 2937 1501839 0 301840Z MAY 75 FM THE SITUATION ROOM//TOHAK 060/1 TO GOMPERT/RODMAN ZEM CONFIDENTIA EYES ONLY WH50997 TOHAK 060 MAY 30, 1975 TO: GOMPERT/RODMAN FROM: BUD MCFARLANE TODAY IS THE LAST DAY FOR DECISION ON CO-PRODUCTION OF ADDITIONAL F-5'S IN TAIWAN IF ROC IS TO AVOID DEFAULTING WITH ITS MILLION DOLLAR DEPOSIT. (SMYSER PACKAGE ON THIS SUBJECT, 3641, DATED MAY 27 IS WITH THE GENERAL.) PLEASE ADVISE. WARM REGARDS. 0097 2937 (Attached) NNNN DECLASSIFIED E.O. 12958, SEC. 3.5 NSC MEMO, 11/24/98, STATE DEPT. GUIDELINES BY 66 NARA, DATE 4/20/01 , CONFIDENTIAL EYES™ ONLY FORD LIDRARY & OERALD sf DOC RECD ÓG NBR INITIAL ACTION o SC CORRESPONDENCE PROFILE MO DA MO DA HR 527 7503641 REFERENCE: CIRCLE AS APPROPRIATE TO: PRES FROM: KISSINGER,H S/S UNCLAS LOG IN/OUT SOURCE/CLASS/DESCRIPTION KISSINGER COLBY, W OTHER LOU NO FORN NODIS SCOWCROFT X SCHLESINGER, J C EYES ONLY EXDIS DAVIS ST EX SEC S CODEWORD SUBJECT: Vign + Deasion Audid On Co-Production TS SENSITIVE of F-5ES m ROC INTERNAL ROUTING AND DISTRIBUTION REC ACTION REQUIRED ACTION INFO CY ADVANCE CYS TO HAK/SCOWCROFT FOR MEMO FOR HAK ( ) STAFF SECRETARY MEMO FOR PRES ( ) REPLY FOR FAR EAST ( ) SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA APPROPRIATE ACTION ( ) DISTRIBUTION/INITIAL ACTION ASGMT MID EAST / NO. AFRICA / so. ASIA MEMO TO ( ) EUROPE / CANADA RECOMMENDATIONS ( ) LATIN AMERICA JOINT MEMO ( ) UNITED NATIONS REFER TO FOR: ( ) ECONOMIC ANY ACTION NECESSARY? ( ) SCIENTIFIC CONCURRENCE ( ) PROGRAM ANALYSIS DUE DATE: NSC PLANNING COMMENTS: (INCLUDING SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS) CONGRESSIONAL OCEANS POLICY INTELLIGENCE By ACTION REQUIRED pass (OR TAKEN): DATE FROM TO S SUBSEQUENT CY TO 500/27 Simpl X Decision (5/19) 6/30 lation taken Per Brean Merchant SUBSEQUENT ROUTING/ACTIONS 6/30 C action Complete 0801 LIBRARY & 06 DISPATCH CY RQMTS: SEE ABOVE PLUS: MICROFILM & FILE RQMTS: NSC/S DISP INSTR NOTIFY & DATE BY M/F'D BY SPECIAL DISPOSITION: CRT ID: SA SF CROSS REF w> OPEN CD HP NS X FOLDER: CLOSE AOC SUSPENSE GY ATTACHED: WH EP PA DY (NBC-74-21) 69 SECRET 3450 IMMEDIATE TO HAK 91 5/29/75 TO: GOMPERT/RODMAN SCOTCROFT FOR: SCOWCROFT FROM: MC FARLANE PC7 Attached is a Smyser/Solomon paper containing instructions for DECLASSIFIED NSC MEMO, 11/24/96, STATE DEPT. GUIDELINES NARA, DATE 4/20/01 E.O. 12958, SEC. 3.5 Ambassador Unger for use in his call on CCK which is to take place on Tuesday or Wednesday of this week. I have attached BY 66 the original State draft at Tab D. Warm regards, DEPARTMENT OF STATE THE SECRETARY 6/2 General Scowcroft - Additionally, the Secretary said when he handed me this that he did not want to be driven by the Desks like this! BERRIO R FORD LIBRARY should hold to up will later jane mant divius -lis SECRET MEMORANDUM 3450 NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL SEGRET/SENSITIVE XGDS (3) ACTION May 29, 1975 MEMORANDUM FOR: SECRETARY KISSINGER FROM: W. R. SMYSE RICHARD H. SOLOMON RMS SUBJECT: Proposed Presidential Reply to the Republic of China Premier Chiang Ching-kuo At Tab A is a draft State cable to Ambassador Unger in Taipei which contains a proposed message from the President to Premier Chiang Ching-kuo. The message, which Ambassador Unger would deliver the following orally to Chiang Ching-kuo, responds to two recent messages from the Premier to the President: -- A memorandum (Tab B) which Chiang Ching-kuo transmitted to Ambassador Unger on May 3. That memorandum summarizes the views he had expressed to the Vice President on April 16 and to the Ambassador earlier. Essentially, Chiang Ching-kuo seizes on the fall of Indochina to suggest that the U.S. once again incorporate Taiwan into its island defense chain in the Western Pacific, arguing that Taiwan and South Korea are indispensible to the security of Japan, which in turn is the cornerstone of U.S. strategy in Asia. Chiang Ching-kuo also reaffirms the Republic of China's commitment to a cooperative relationship with the U.S., and thanks the President for his statement on the Republic of China made before the American Society of Newspaper Editors last month. (Tab C) A follow-on letter of May 7,1 in which Chiang Ching-kuo thanks the President for his reaffirmation of U.S. commitments to the Republic of China and repeats the substance of the May 3 memorandum. The draft oral message expresses appreciation to Chiang Ching-kuo for his two messages, and for the Premier's expression of intent to continue close cooperation with the U.S. It pledges the U.S. to reciprocate this spirit of close cooperation, and at the same time reaffirms the U.S. intent to continue its normalization of relations with Peking. Finally, it endorses Chiang Ching-kuo's suggestion that we continue the frank consultations between our two governments. & DECLASSIFIED E.O. 12958, SEC. 3.5 GERALD LIBRARY NSC MEMO, 11/24/98, STATE DEPT. GUIDELINES SEGRET/SENSITIVE XGDS (3) BY # NARA, DATE 4/20/01 SEGRET/SENSITIVE 2 The draft at Tab A incorporates several changes that we have made in the State draft. We especially call your attention to the first of these changes, the addition of paragraph 5, which we regard as particularly important and which you may or may not wish to confirm. Paragraph 5 has been added by Smyser and Froebe. They believe that the cumulative effect of the Vice President's visit to Taipei, the President's reaffirmation of our commitment to the ROC in the wake of Indochina, and the Vice President's meeting of May 29 with Ambassador Shen may mislead the ROC leadership to believe that we are pulling back from our normalization process with Peking. This could relax the pressure on the ROC to continue its gradual political and psychological adjustment toward a new relationship with us. Paragraph 5's reference to the search for new modalities, followed by paragraph 6's reaffirmation that U.S. normalization with Peking will go forward, is designed to maintain a steady pressure on the ROC for gradual adjustment toward a new relationship with the U.S. at the same that we preserve the ROC's necessary minimum confidence in us by implicitly reaffirming our basic commitment. Solomon, Lord, and Gleysteen, however, believe that paragraph 5 would not be helpful. They hold that at a time when future developments in our relations with Peking are uncertain it would be unwise to stimulate the ROC with a signal that might provoke them to take defensive action via their friends in Congress or through other means. In paragraph 2, after the phrase "It is particularly useful at this time" we removed the phrase in the State cable "when the situation in East Asia is being carefully assessed, together with consideration of future courses of action, We believe this suggestion of an "agonizing reappraisal" of U.S. -Asian policy could have a needlessly unsettling effect and is pointless since we are not making such a reappraisal. In paragraph 6, we dropped a second sentence from the State cable which read "He also notes the smooth transition that has been made to the new leadership in the ROC following upon the sad passing of President Chiang and he wishes the Premier and his government the best of success in their important undertakings. 11 We believe this carries a slightly patronizing air. Instead, we have substituted a reiteration of our standard compliments for the ROC's economic progress and a reaffirmation of our belief that it will continue in the period following President Chiang's death. FORD & SEGRET/SENSITIVE GERALD LIBRARY SECRET/SENSITIVE 3 RECOMMENDATION: That you approve the draft State cable at Tab A as revised: -- To include paragraph 5. APPROVE DISAPPROVE -- To exclude paragraph 5. APPROVE DISAPPROVE FORD LIBRARY & GERALD SECRET/SENSITIVE 6c SECRET GDS IMMEDIATE TO: TAIPEI FROM: SECSTATE SUBJECT: Premier Chiang's Message to President Ford REF: TAIPEI 2415 1. Upon his return to Taipei, Ambassador Unger is authorized to make a presentation along the following lines to Premier Chiang as a response to his message to President Ford which was subject of reftel and also to his follow-on letter to the President of May 7. 2. President Ford thanks Premier Chiang for his message conveyed through Ambassador Unger, and also for his subsequent letter of May 7. It is particularly useful at this time to have the pertinent views of the Republic of China. In this connection, the President has also noted the views which the Premier conveyed earlier to Vice President Rockefeller and which are recalled in the Premier's current message. 3. The President has noted with appreciation the declarations of the Republic of China of its commitment to play a positive and constructive role in the new era ahead. The United States also pledges itself to such a role, and to continue in this spirit the close cooperation between the U.S. and the ROC. GERALD ? FORD SECRET GDS GG 4/20/01 SECRET 2 4. As Premier Chiang is aware from President Ford's earlier statements, the President firmly believes that the U.S. must remain strong and must be in a position to carry out its commitments if peace is to be maintained in Asia and the Pacific. 5. Developments in East Asia over the past several years, many of which have affected our two countries, have made it clear to all that the political and military relationships and confrontations of the 1950s and 1960s have changed and are continuing to evolve. This fluidity in the international environment has created a situation where we all must re-examine arrangements and policies; but this in no way affects our concern for and commitment to the security and well-being of our old allies and friends. 6. The Premier is aware of the efforts of the U.S. to reduce the tensions in East Asia. In particular, the U.S. desires to develop and enlarge communication with the PRC in order to seek peaceful and equitable solutions to outstanding problems where this is possible, and to reduce the dangers of confrontation and conflict. These policies do not ignore the differences, some of them profound, which lie between the United States and the PRC, but they are based on the belief that peaceful resolution of those differences is in all of our interests. 7. With the foregoing in mind, President Ford endorses the desirability of frank discussions and has made this reply to the Premier's FORD & message in that spirit. He again wishes to express his profound GERALD SECRET SECRET 3 admiration for the progress that the Republic of China has made, and to express his hope and conviction that this progress will continue under the leadership of the Premier and of the government of the Republic of China. . & SECRET ; and 6d Department of State SELING AMERICAN TELEGRAM STATES or SECRET 2166 PAGE 01 TAIPEI 02415 050026Z 62 JAF Libiscuss. ACTION SS-25 INFO OCT-01 ISO-00 /026 w DB/P CLIFT 02020 R 0304392 MAY 75 ELLIOTT FM AMEMBASSY TAIPEI FROEDE TO SECSTATE WASHDC 5053 8 HORAN KENNEDY LODAL SECRE T TAIPEI 2415 LOW OBER EXDIS RATLIFF OAKLEY SMYSER E.O. 11652: XGDS-1 SOLOMON TAGS: PFOR, TH, TH, RP, CH STEARMAN SUBJECT: MEETING WITH FOREIGN MINISTER SHEN FARRAR REF: TAIPEI 2255 anderson 1. I CALLED ON FONMIN SHEN CHANG-HUAN HUAN AT HIS REQUEST, MAY 3. REFERRING TO MY RECENT CONVERSATION WITH PREMIER CHIANG AT TZU HU (REFTEL), SHEN SAID PREMIER HAD ASKED saves THAT ESSENCE OF VIEWS PREMIER HAD EXPRESSED ON THAT OCCASION AS WELL AS IN TALK WITH VICE PRESIDENT ROCKEFELLER ON APRIL 16, BE PRESENTED IN BRIEF PAPER AND REQUESTED THAT IT BE TRANSMITTED BY ME TO PRESIDENT FORD WHEN I RETURNED TO WASHINGTON FOR CONSULTATIONS. 2, PAPER WHICH SHEN READ AND HANDED ME COPY IS QUOTED BELOW: REGIN QUOTE THE TRAUMATIC EVENTS THAT HAVE OCCURRED IN INDO-CHINA RECENTLY CANNOT BUT HAVE TREMENDOUS IMPACT ON VARIOUS PARTS OF THE WORLD, PARTICUL RLY IN THE ASTAN AND PACIFIC REGION. THE LEADERS OF THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA AGREE WITH PRESIDENT FORD THAT TO INDULGE IN RECRIMINATION AND IN APPORTIONING BLAMES IS NOT PRODUCTIVE. ON THE OTHER HAND, MANY LESSONS MUST BE DRAWN FROM THIS TRAGEDY TO PREVENT HISTORY FROM REPEATING ITSELF. MILITARILY, THE INDO-CHINA CHAPTER MAY HAVE NOW COME TO A CLOSE. HOWEVER, A "NEW AGENDA" AS APTLY CALLED BY FORD PRESIDENT FORD SHOULD BE METICULOUSLY DISCUSSED, PLANNED ? S DECLASSIFIED E.O. 12958, SEC. 3.5 HERALD RALD LIBRARY STATE DEPT, GUIDELINES, 8/2/00 111 SECRET NARA DATE 4/20/01 NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY B. UNITED the the Department of State TELEGRAM STATES of SECRET PAGE 02 TAIPEI 02415 050026Z AND PREPARED TO DEAL WITH OTHER PROBABLE AND POSSIBLE INTERNATIONAL CRIES THAT ARE SURELY FORTHCOMING. TT IS UNDERSTANDABLE THAT MANY COUNTRIES IN THIS AREA, ESPECIALLY THAILAND AND THE PHILIPPINES, HAVE BECOME INCREASINGLY NERVOUS, WHICH MIGHT EVEN LEAD TO PANIC, IN THE VIEW OF THE REPUBLIC UF CHINA, THAILAND AND THE PHILIPPINES SHOULD BE GIVEN TOP PRIORITY OF THE U.S. "NEW AGENDA". THAT MANY COUNTRIES 1N Tnio THE PAILIPPINES. HAVE SECUME WHILE ATTENDING TO SOUTHEAST ASIA, EQUAL IMPORTANCE L. IN OF NORTHEAST ASIA CANNOT BE GAINSAID. THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA IS COGNIZANT THAT THE U.S. ATTACHES GREAT IMPORTANCE TO JAPAN FOR ITS INDUSTRIAL AND ECONOMIC PROWESS. BUT THE PROTECTION OF JAPAN HINGES UN THE SECURITY AND STABILITY OF THE REPUBLIC OF KOREA AND THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA WHICH ARE VITAL AND INDISPENSABLE FLANKS TO JAPAN. SHOULD FITHER OF THE FLANKS FALL INTU THE HANDS OF AN ADVERSARY OF THE U.S., IT WOULD RENDER JAPAN MILITARILY int VUI. NERABLE AND CREATE UNFATHOMABLE CONFUSION AND STABILITY DIVISION IN ITS DOMESTIC POLITICS. JAPAN'S INDUSTRIAL CAPABILITY WOULD THEN BECOME ASSETS TO AMERICA'S ENEMIES. CONFIDENTIALLY, A NUMBER OF JAPAN'S LEADING SARY ELDERLY STATESMEN HAVE EXPRESSED THE FEARS OF SUCH A NIGHTMARE. CONFUSION AND JAPARIS INJUSTRIAL IT IS BELIEVED THAT A STRONG CHAIN STRETCHING FROM NOREA, JAPAN, THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA, THE PHILIPPINES, INDONESIA DOWN TO AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND WOULD FORM A RELIABLE AND CREDIBLE FIRST LINE OF DEFENSE FOR THE U.S. DIPLOMATICALLY AND MILITARILY. EST-FICHING FROM AS PREMIER CHIANG CHING 1020 IC PRESIDENT THRINES, FORD & NELSON ROCKEFELLER, THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA IS UNEQUIVOCALLY DEDICATED TO THE FOLLOWING POLICY DECISIONS: For int GERALD LIBRARY 1. UNRELENTING STRUGGLE AGAINST COMMUNISM AND COMMUNIST REGIMES NO MATTER WHERE THEY ARE AND DETERMINED TO DEFEND THE SECURITY OF TAIWAN, PESCADORES, QUEMOY AND MATSU: DERISIONS: 2. FIRM ALIGNMENT WITH THE FREE WORLD, PARTICULARLY STRUGGLE COMMUNISM AND WHERE THE ARE AND JETERMINED COMMINST To THE SECURITY SECRET PHSLACORES. QUENOY ANU MAISU; NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY A OF STATE Department of State of STATE UNITED AMERICA TELEGRAM SECRET PAGE 03 TAIPEI 02415 0500262 TO U.S.; 3. FURTHER PROMOTION OF INTERNAL POLITICAL SOLIDARITY; AND 4. REDOUBLED EFFORTS FOR THE CONTINUING DEVELOPMENT OF THE ECONOMIC WELL-BEING OF THE PEOPLE. BY so DOING, THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA WILL BE ABLE TO PLAY A POSITIVE AND CONSTRUCTIVE ROLE IN THE NEW ERA. IT IS THE FERVENT HOPE OF THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA THAT PRESIDENT FORD WILL EXERCISE HIS FARSIGHTED AND STEADFAST STATESMANSHIP WHIC WILL HELP OVERCOME ANY DIFFICULTIES IN THE INTERNATIONAL ARENA. IN THE LIGHT OF PREMIER CHIANG CHING-KUO'S BASIC POLICY DIRECTION, \ PRESIDENT FORD AND THE U.S. GOVERNMENT CAN ALWAYS COUNT UPON THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA AS A LOYAL ALLY AND PARTNER. PRESIDENT FORU HAS REPEATEDLY OFFERED HIS ASSURANCES THAT WHAT TRANSPIRED IN INDU-CHINA SHOULD NOT IMPAIR THE CREDIBILITY OF THE U.S. IN ITS FULFILLMENT OF COMMITMENTS TO THE OTHER ALLIES AND FRIENDS IN ASIA AND THE PACIFIC. THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA IS GRATIFISQBQTH THE WARM SENTIMENTS EXPRESSED BY PRESIDENT FORD TOWARDS THIS COUNTRY IN HIS RECENT APPEARANCE AT THE AMERICAN NEWSPAPER EDITORS' ASSOCIATION IN NEW YORK. THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA WOULD APPRECIATE IT IF THE U.S. GOVERNMENT WOULD REPEAT SUCH REASSURANCES WHENEVER THE SAME ARE PUBLICLY GIVEN TO OTHER COUNTRIES OF THE REGION FREQUENT AND FRANK CONSULTATIONS BETWEEN THE TWO GOVERNMENTS WOULD BE MOST BENEFICIAL FOR BOTH COUNTRIES. FOR THE TASK OF STABILIZING THAILAND, THE PHILIPPINES AND OTHER SOUTHEAST ASIAN COUNTRIES THE STRENGTHENING OF FORD THE TIES BETWEEN THE U.S. AND NATIONS IN NORTHEAST ASIA s \ TN GENERAL ANU THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA IN PARTICULAR GERALD LIBRARY SEGRET NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY GRING MAKE Department of State TELEGRAM / or SECRET S PAGE 04 TAIPEI 02415 050026Z COULD ALSO SERVE AS A CREDIBLE TOKEN OF THE U.S. INTENTION AND DETERMINATION, SO THAT THE WAVERING AND NERVOUS COUNTRIES IN THIS AREA WOULD NOT BE DRAWN INTO THE ORBIT OF THE CHINESE COMMUNISTS. END QUOTE 3. I TOLD SHEN THAT EXPRESSION OF ROC VIEWS AS PRESENTED IN PAPER WOULD BE HELPFUL IN CURRENT WASHINGTON REASSESSMENT OF OUR POLICIES AND THAT I WOULD MAKE A PARTICULAR POINT OF BRINGING TO ATTENTION OF OUR POLICY MAKERS. I EXPECTED THIS REASSESSMENT WOULD RESULT IN POLICY FOUNDED ON BASIC, LONG-TERM TERM INTERESTS, AND THAT, IN THIS CONNECTION, I FELT SURE THAT OUR PEOPLE WOULD CONTINUE TO HAVE VERY MUCH IN MIND THE S MEANS OF WHICH A MODUS VIVENDI COULD BE WORKED OUT WITH MAINLAND CHINA IN ORDER TO BETTER ASSURE PEACE AND STABILITY IN EAST ASIA AND ALSO TO SEEK SOLUTIONS TO SOME WORLD PROBLEMS IN WHICH MAINLAND CHINA MUST PLAY A ROLE. I TOLD SHEN THAT WE WECD VERY WELL AWARE OF ROC VIEWS ON THIS SUBJECT AND ITS ESSENTIAL INTEREST IN OUR DEVELOPING RELATIONS WITH THE PRC. SHEN INDICATED HIS UNDERSTANDING, BUT WONDERED IF THE HIGH PRICE WE WOULD HAVE TO PAY FOR FURTHERING DETENTE WITH THE COMMUNISTS WOULD BE WORTH THE CLEAR DISADVANTAGES. HE POINTED UP THE "NONTRUSTWORTHINESS" OF THE CHINESE COMMUNISTS, E.G., INDOCHINA, CONTINUING SUPPORT FOR INSURGENCIES, ETC., AS CONTRASTED WITH THE CLEAR, UNAMBIGUOUS POLICIES OF THE ROC WHICH WERE STRONGLY SUPPORTIVE OF THE U.S. S 4. OUR CONVERSATION CONTINUED OVER A RATHER BROAD RANGE OF SUBJECTS WHICH WILL BE REPORTED SEPTELS. 5. REGARDING PREMIER'S REQUEST THAT PAPER QUUTED PARA 2, ABOVE BE TRANSMITTED TO PRESIDENT FORD, I WILL WISH TO DISCUSS THIS DURING MY CONSULTATION WASHINGTON. UNGER FORD & OF LIBRARY NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE SECRET AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY be OFFICE OF THE PREMIER REPUBLIC OF CHINA - May 7, 1975 Dear Mr. President: In consequence of the traumatic events in Indo-China, many countries in this area, especially Thailand and the Philippines, have become increasingly wavering. It is most gratifying and assuring that you made a timely statement at the press conference on May 6, that it is your aim to tie more closely together South Korea with the U.S., to reaf- firm your commitments to the Republic of China, to work more closely with Indonesia, with the Philippines and with other Pacific nations. In order to deal with the probable and possible inter- national crises that are surely forthcoming, a 'new agenda' as you aptly called should be meticulously planned and prepared. In my view, Thailand and the Philippines should be given top priority in the agenda. However, while attending to Southeast Asia, equal importance of Northeast Asia cannot be gainsaid. We are cognizant that the U.S. attaches great importance to Japan. But the protection of Japan hinges on the security and stability of the Republic of Korea and the Republic of China which are vital and indispensable flanks to Japan. Should either of the flanks fall into the hands of an adversary of the U.S., it would render Japan militarily vul- nerable and create unfathomable confusion and division in its domestic politics. Japan's industrial capability would then become assets to America's enemies. A number of Japan's leading elder statesmen have expressed to me their fears of such a nightmare. I believe that the strengthening of the ties between the U.S. and nations in Northcast Asia in general and the Republic of China in particular could well serve as a credible token of the U.S. intention and determination. A strong chain stretching FORD R DECLASSIFIED E.O. 12958, SEC. 3.5 STATE DEPT, GUIDELINES, state NARA, DATE 4/20/01 GERALO LIBRARY BY , from Korea, Japan, the Republic of China, the Philippines, Indonesia down to Australia and New Zealand would form a reliable and credible first line of defense for the U.S. diplomatically and militarily. As I have mentioned to Vice President Rockefeller during his recent trip to Taipei that the Republic of China is dedicated to the following policy: (1) Unrelenting struggle against communism and communist regimes and determined to defend the security of Taiwan, Pescadores, Quemoy and Matsu; (2) Firm alignment with the free world, particularly the U.S.; (3) Further promotion of internal political solidarity; and (4) Redoubled efforts for the continuing development of the economic well-being of the people. By so doing, we shall continue to play a positive and con- structive role in the new era. In view of the above, Mr. President, the U.S. Government can always count on the Republic of China as a loyal ally and partner. 1 shall be grateful for your consideration of my views which are presented with all sincerity and frankness that I command. With best wishes for your continued success and personal well-being, Sincerely yours, Chiang Ching. know Chiang Ching-kuo His Excellency President Gerald R. Ford The White House Washington, D.C. FORD LIBRARY & 6f SECRET EA/ROC:AMB - L UNGER 5/19/75 EXT 22012 EA:WHGLEYSTEEN S/S S/P - MR. LORD NSC - MR. SOLOMON NSC - MR. SMYSER ROUTINE TAIPEI GLEYSTE 'E.O. 11652: XGDS-3 UNCE TAGS: PFOR CH LORD S/S SUBJECT: PREMIER CHIANG'S MESSAGE TO PRESIDENT FORD SOLON REF: TAIPEI 2415 SAYBER 1. UPON HIS RETURN TO TAIPEI, AMBASSADOR UNGER IS 98 AUTHORIZED TO SPEAK ALONG THE FOLLOWING LINES TO PREMIER CHIANG AS A RESPONSE TO HIS MESSAGE FOR PRESIDENT FORD WHICH WAS SUBJECT OF REFTEL: 2. PRES. FORD THANKS PREMIER CHIANG FOR HIS MESSAGE CONVEYED THROUGH AMB. UNGER. IT IS PARTICULARLY USEFUL AT THIS TIME WHEN THE SITUATION IN EAST ASIA IS BEING CAREFULLY ASSESSED, TOGETHER WI... CONSIDERA- TION OF FUTURE COURSES OF ACTION, TO HAVE THE PEI [NENT VIEWS OF THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA. IN THIS CONNECTION, THE PRESIDENT HAS ALSO NOTED THE VIEWS WHICH THE PREMIER EARLIER CONVEYED TO VP ROCKEFELLER AND WHICH ARE RECALLED IN THE PREMIER'S CURRENT MESSAGE. 3. IN PARTICULAR THE PRESIDENT HAS NOTED THE DECLARATIONS OF THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA OF ITS COMMIT- MENT TO PLAY A POSITIVE AND CONSTRUCTIVE ROLE IN THE NEW ERA AHEAD. THE UNITED STATES ALSO PLEDGES ITSELF GERÄLD DECLASSIFIED SECRET E.O. 12958, SEC. 3.5 STATE DEPT, GUIDELINES GG NARA, DATE 4/20/01 , FORM DS 322A{0CR} SECRET 2 TO CONTINUING IN THIS SPIRIT THE CLOSE COOPERATION BETWEEN THE US AND THE ROC. 4- AS PREMIER CHIANG IS AWARE FROM PRESIDENT FORD'S EARLIER STATEMENTS, THE PRESIDENT FIRMLY BELIEVES THAT THE US MUST REMAIN STRONG AND MUST BE IN A POSI- TION TO CARRY OUT ITS COMMITMENTS IF PEACE IS TO BE MAINTAINED IN ASIA AND THE PACIFIC- 5. AT THE SAME TIME THE PREMIER IS AWARE OF THE EFFORTS OF THE US TO REDUCE THE TENSIONS IN EAST ASIA. IN PARTICULAR THE US DESIRES TO DEVELOP AND ENLARGE COMMUNICATION WITH THE PRC IN ORDER TO SEEK PEACEFUL AND EQUITABLE SOLUTIONS TO OUTSTANDING PROBLEMS WHERE THIS IS POSSIBLE AND REDUCE THE DANGERS OF CONFRONTA- TION AND CONFLICT- THE US DOES NOT HIDE THE DIFFER- ENCES, SOME OF THEM PROFOUND, WHICH LIE BETWEEN us AND THE PRC BUT IT IS PERSUADED THAT THE PEACE OF THE WORLD AND OF EAST ASIA DEMANDS THAT CONTINUING EFFORTS BE MADE BY THE US TO FIND PEACEFUL RESOLUTIONS FOR SUCH DIFFERENCES. 6. WITH ALL OF THE FOREGOING IN MIND, PRES. FORD ENDORSES THE DESIRABILITY OF FRANK DISCUSSIONS AND HAS MADE THIS REPLY TO THE PREMIER'S MESSAGE IN THAT SPIRIT. HE ALSO NOTES THE SMOOTH TRANSITION THAT HAS BEEN MADE TO THE NEW LEADERSHIP IN THE ROC FOLLOW- ING UPON THE SAD PASSING OF PRESIDENT CHIANG AND HE WISHES THE PREMIER AND HIS GOVERNMENT THE BEST OF SUCCESS IN THEIR IMPORTANT UNDERTAKINGS. YY FORD GERALD SECRET 6g DOC RECD LOG NBR INITIAL ACTION o NSC CORRESPONDENCE PROFILE MO DA MO DA HR 529 5 29 19 7503450 TO: PRES + Smyser FROM.MISSINGER.H COLBY, W Solomon REFERENCE: CIRCLE AS APPROPRIATE S/S UNCLAS LOG IN/OUT SOURCE/CLASS/DESCRIPTION KISSINGER OTHER LOU NO FORN NODIS SCOWCROFT SCHLESINGER, J c EYES ONLY EXDIS DAVIS ST EX SEC $ CODEWORD SUBJECT: Proposed Pur reply to Premium Chrong TS SENSITIVE Clung-Kro of Republic of Chend m US } Roc relations INTERNAL ROUTING AND DISTRIBUTION REC ACTION REQUIRED ACTION INFO CY ADVANCE CYS TO HAK/SCOWCROFT FOR MEMO FOR HAK ) STAFF SECRETARY MEMO FOR PRES ) REPLY FOR FAR EAST I , SUB.SAHARAN AFRICA APPROPRIATE ACTION 1 ) DISTRIBUTION/INITIAL ACTION ASGMT MID EAST / NO. AFRICA / so. ASIA MEMO TO ) EUROPE / CANADA RECOMMENDATIONS ( ) LATIN AMERICA JOINT MEMO ) UNITED NATIONS REFER TO FOR: 1 ) ECONOMIC ANY ACTION NECESSARY? I ) SCIENTIFIC CONCURRENCE ) PROGRAM ANALYSIS DUE DATE: NSC PLANNING COMMENTS: (INCLUDING SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS) CONGRESSIONAL OCEANS POLICY INTELLIGENCE DATE FROM TO $ SUBSEQUENT ACTION REQUIRED (OR TAKEN): CY TO 5/29 HAL X Deaser (6/10) 6/9/75 SMYSER 5" FURTHER AcTioN / SEE HAK NOTE SUBSEQUENT ROUTING/ACTIONS 7/16/95 "C" SEE 7504822 FOR Tion GERALD & FORD LIBRARY DISPATCH CY RQMTS: SEE ABOVE PLUS: MICROFILM &. FILL RQMTS: NSC/S DISP INSTR NOTIFY & DATE BY JUL D 18 1975 Y SPECIAL DISPOSITION: CRT ID: SA SF CROSS REF W/ OPEN HP NS SUSPENSE CY ATTACHED: YES FOLDER: CLOSE Aos WH EP PA or