Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 74
February 11, 1998 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-HOUSE H395 LaHood Paxon Shuster Wexler Wise Wynn Largent Pease Whereas a large number of low- and mid- Skeen Weygand Woolsey Yates Latham Peterson (PA) Smith (MI) dle-income families sacrifice a second full- LaTourette Petri Smith (NJ) NOT VOTING-22 time income so that the mother may be at Lazio Pickering Smith (TX) Callahan Miller (FL) Sensenbrenner home with her child; Leach Pitts Snowbarger Diaz-Balart Mink Smith (OR) Whereas the average income of 2-parent Lewis (CA) Pombo Solomon Doolittle Myrick Smith, Linda families with a single income is $20,000 less Lewis (KY) Porter Souder Eshoo Nadler Stearns than the average income of 2-parent families Livingston Portman Spence Gonzalez Poshard Waters with two incomes; LoBiondo Pryce (OH) Stump Harman Ros-Lehtinen White Lucas Quinn Sununu Whereas only 30 percent of preschool chil- Lantos Sawyer Manzullo Radanovich Talent Linder Schiff dren are in paid child care and the remaining McCollum Ramstad Tauzin 70 percent of preschool children are in fami- McCrery Redmond Taylor (NC) 1723 lies that do not pay for-child care, many of McDade Regula Thomas which are low- to middle-income families McHugh Riggs Thornberry Mr. MURTHA changed his vote from struggling to provide child care at home; McInnis Riley Thune "yea" to "nay." McIntosh Whereas child care proposals should not Rogan Tiahrt McKeon Rogers Traficant So the resolution was agreed to. provide financial assistance solely to the 30 Metcalf Rohrabacher Upton The result of the vote was announced percent of families that pay for child care Mica Roukema Walsh as above recorded. and should not discriminate against families Moran (KS) Royce Wamp A motion to reconsider was laid on in which children are cared for by an at- Morella Ryun Watkins Salmon the table. home parent; and Nethercutt Watts (OK) Whereas any congressional proposal that Neumann Sanford Weldon (FL) Ney Saxton increases child care funding should provide Weldon (PA) Northup Scarborough Weller financial relief to families that sacrifice an ANNOUNCEMENT BY THE SPEAKER Norwood Schaefer, Dan Whitfield entire income in order that a mother or fa- Nussle Wicker PRO TEMPORE Schaffer, Bob ther may be at home for their young child: Oxley Sessions Wolf The SPEAKER pro tempore (Mr. Now, therefore, be it Packard Shadegg Young (AK) Pappas Young (FL) UPTON). Pursuant to the provisions of Resolved by the House of Representatives (the Shaw Shays clause 5 of rule I the Chair announces Senate concurring), That the Congress recog- Parker nizes that- Paul Shimkus that he will postpone further proceed- (1) many American families make enor- ings today on the second motion to NAYS-191 mous sacrifices to forgo a second income in suspend the rules on which a recorded order to have a parent care for their child at Abercrombie Gordon Moran (VA) vote or the yeas and nays are ordered home; Ackerman Green Murtha Allen Gutierrez Neal or on which the vote is objected to (2) there should be no bias against at-home Andrews Hall (OH) Oberstar under clause 4 of rule XV. parents; Baesler Hastings (FL) Obey If a recorded vote is ordered on the (3) parents choose many legitimate forms Baldacci Hefner Olver Hilliard first motion, relating to House Concur- of child care to meet their individual needs Barcia Ortiz an at-home parent, grandparent, aunt, Barrett (WI) Hinchey rent Resolution 202, that vote will be Owens uncle, neighbor, nanny. preschool, or child Becerra Hinojosa Pallone taken after debate has concluded on care center; Bentsen Holden Pascrell that motion. Berman Hooley (4) child care needs of at-home parents and Pastor Berry Hoyer If a recorded vote is ordered on the working parents should be given careful con- Bishop Jackson (IL) Payne second motion, relating to Senate 927, sideration by the Congress; Blagojevich Jackson-Lee Pelosi Peterson (MN) that vote will be postponed until (5) any quality child care proposal should Blumenager (TX) Thursday, February 12, 1998. reflect careful consideration of providing fi- Bonior Jefferson Pickett nancial relief for those families where there Borski John Pomeroy Johnson (WI) Price (NC) is'an at-home parent; and Boswell Boucher Johnson, E.B. Rahall (6) mothers and fathers who have chosen DAYCARE FAIRNESS FOR STAY- Boyd Kanjorski Rangel and continue to choose to be at home should Kaptur Reyes AT-HOME PARENTS Brown (CA) be applauded for their efforts. Brown (FL) Kennedy.(MA) Rivers Mr. GOODLING. Mr. Speaker, I move The SPEAKER pro tempore. Pursu- Brown (OH) Kennedy (RI) Rodriguez Cardin Roemer to suspend the rules and agree to the Kennelly ant to the rule, the gentleman from Carson Kildee Rothman concurrent resolution (H. Con. Res. 202) Pennsylvania (Mr. GOODLING) and the Clay Kilpatrick Roybal-Allard expressing the sense of the Congress gentleman from California (Mr. MAR- Clayton Kind (WI) Rush that the Federal Government should TINEZ), each will control 20 minutes. Clement Kleczka Sabo Clyburn Klink Sanchez acknowledge the importance of at- The Chair recognizes the gentleman Condit Kucinich Sanders home parents and should not discrimi- from Pennsylvania (Mr. GOODLING). Conyers LaFalce Sandlin nate against families who forego a sec- Mr. GOODLING. Mr. Speaker, I yield Costello Lampson Schumer ond income in order for a mother or fa- Coyne Levin myself such time as I may consume. Scott Cramer Lewis (GA) ther to be at home with their children, Serrano Mr. Speaker, I rise today to support Cummings Lipinski Sherman as amended. House Concurrent Resolution 202, the Danner Lofgren Sisisky The Clerk read as follows: equitable child care resolution, which I Davis (FL) Lowey Skaggs Davis (IL) Luther H. CON. RES. 202 introduced on January 27, 1998, to en- Skelton DeFazio Maloney (CT) Slaughter Whereas studies have found that quality sure that any child care proposal that DeGette Maloney (NY) Delahunt Smith, Adam child care, particularly for infants and young this Congress may consider this year Manton DeLauro Snyder children, requires a sensitive, interactive, addresses the needs of parents who Markey Deutsch Martinez Spratt loving, and consistent caregiver; choose to stay at home to care for Dicks Mascara Stabenow Whereas most parents meet and exceed the their child. Almost all of the child care Dingell Stark Matsui aforementioned criteria, circumstances al- Stenholm proposals in Congress focus solely on Dixon McCarthy (MO) lowing, often parental care marks the best Doggett McCarthy (NY) Stokes form of child care; expanding commercial child care, de- Dooley McDermott Strickland Stupak Whereas the recent National Institute for spite the fact that only 30 percent of Doyle McGovern Edwards McHale Tanner Child Health and Development study found preschool children are cared for by paid Engel McIntyre Tauscher that the greatest factor in the development child care providers. And of that 30 per- Etheridge McKinney Taylor (MS) of a young child is "what is happening at cent, an even smaller percentage are in Evans McNulty Thompson home and in families"; commercial child care. We know the Farr Meehan Thurman Whereas a child's interaction with his or majority of preschool children are Fattah Meek (FL) Tierney her parents has the most significant impact Fazio Meeks (NY) Torres cared for by their mother or father who on their development, any Federal child care Filner Menendez Towns policy should enable and encourage parents stay at home for that purpose. Yet Ford Millender- Turner Frank (MA) McDonald Velazquez to spend more time with their children; Federal child care proposals would in- Frost Miller (CA) Vento Whereas nearly 1/2 of preschool children dicate that we should not consider Furse Minge Visclosky have at-home mothers and only 1/3 of pre- those who stay home as child care pro- Gejdenson Moakley Watt (NC) school children have mothers who are em- viders. It is inconceivable to me that Gephardt Mollohan Waxman ployed full time: the Federal Government would tell