Ask the Scholar
Document scope · 1 page
Scholar
Ask about this object, its catalog metadata, its source description, or the page inventory.
For page-specific OCR and visual context, open one of the page chats.
Scholar Source Context
Document identity
localId
55031011
label
HRC Health care Book No.12: Health Reform [2]
core
doc
dtoType
document
citationUrl
pageCount
1
Source metadata
id
55031011
sourceUrl
contentType
document
title
HRC Health care Book No.12: Health Reform [2]
citationUrl
collections
Records of the First Lady's Office (Clinton Administration)
Melanne Verveer's Issues and Events files
imageCount
1
hasImages
yes
source
import
hasTranscription
no
Source extras
naId
55031011
levelOfDescription
fileUnit
otherTitles
42219138-20130534S-039-015-2022
recordType
description
ocrSource
nara-archive
Single page context
seq
1
pageIndex
0
type
document
mediaId
7646470f8df56f2e
ocrText
Withdrawal/Redaction Sheet
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
SUBJECT/TITLE
DATE
RESTRICTION
AND TYPE
001. schedule
Schedule for Hillary Rodham Clinton Secret Service (Partial) (1 page)
01/13/1998
b(7)(E), b(6)
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
First Lady's Office
Melanne Verveer
OA/Box Number: 18538
FOLDER TITLE:
HRC Healthcare Book #12: Health Reform [2]
2013-0534-S
rc1768
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - [44 U.S.C. 2204(a)]
Freedom of Information Act - [5 U.S.C. 552(b)]
P1 National Security Classified Information [(a)(1) of the PRA]
b(1) National security classified information [(b)(1) of the FOIA]
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office [(a)(2) of the PRA]
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute [(a)(3) of the PRA]
an agency [(b)(2) of the FOIA]
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute [(b)(3) of the FOIA]
financial information [(a)(4) of the PRA]
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
information [(b)(4) of the FOIA]
and his advisors, or between such advisors [a)(5) of the PRA]
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(b)(6) of the FOIA]
personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRA]
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes [(b)(7) of the FOIA]
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
of gift.
financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA]
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C.
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
2201(3).
concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA]
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
Clinton Presidential Records
Digital Records Marker
This is not a presidential record. This is used as an administrative
marker by the William J. Clinton Presidential Library Staff.
This marker identifies the place of a tabbed divider. Given our
digitization capabilities, we are sometimes unable to adequately
scan such dividers. The title from the original document is
indicated below.
1/4/99 Healthcare
Event
Divider Title:
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
MONDAY, JANUARY 4, 1999
FINAL
WASHINGTON, D.C.
SCHEDULER:
WENDY ARENDS
202/456-7007
PHONE
202/456-5340 FAX
202/518-8209
HOME
WHCA PAGER
#4781
PREV RON
The White House
-
10:40am-
BRIEFING [w/POTUS]
11:05am
Map Room
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
11:05am
PROCEED to Blue Room [w/POTUS]
11:10am-
MEET AND GREET [w/POTUS]
11:15am
Blue Room
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
PARTICIPANTS: 5-10 guests
11:15am-
HEALTHCARE EVENT [w/POTUS]
12:05pm
Grand Foyer
POOL PRESS/WH PHOTO
FORMAT:
-
The President and the First Lady, accompanied
by Secretary Robert Rubin, Secretary Donna
Shalala, Director Janice LaChance and
Patricia Darlak, are announced into the
Grand Foyer.
I
The First Lady makes remarks and introduces
Patricia Darlak.
I
Patricia Darlak makes remarks and introduces
the President.
-
The President makes remarks and introduces
the Vice President via satellite.
-
The President proceeds to his seat.
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
MONDAY, JANUARY 4, 1999
PAGE 2
-
The Vice President and Mrs. Gore make remarks
and begin the discussion.
-
Upon conclusion of the discussion, the Vice
President makes concluding remarks and bids
farewell.
-
The President makes concluding remarks.
-
The President and the First Lady depart.
PARTICIPANTS: 40 guests
RON
The White House
THE WHITE HOUSE
WASHINGTON
TO:
THE PRESIDENT AND THE FIRST LADY
WHAT:
HEALTHCARE EVENT
WHEN:
MONDAY, JANUARY 4, 1999
WHERE:
GRAND FOYER
NOTES:
APPROX. 40 GUESTS/IN-HOUSE POOL PRESS/BUSINESS ATTIRE
10:30 a.m.
THE PRESIDENT and THE FIRST LADY receive briefing in the Oval
Office.
11:05 a.m.
THE PRESIDENT and THE FIRST LADY proceed to the Blue Room.
11:10 a.m.
THE PRESIDENT and THE FIRST LADY meet the following in the
Blue Room.
Contact: Bruce Reed
Blue Room Participants:
Person TBD
Sen. Chaffee
Rep. Moran
Director La Chance
Secretary Shalala
Secretary Rubin
11:15 a.m.
THE PRESIDENT and THE FIRST LADY accompanied by Person
TBD, Director La Chance, Secretary Shalala and Secretary Rubin are
announced to honors onto the stage in Grand Foyer.
PROGRAM BEGINS
THE FIRST LADY makes welcoming remarks and introduces
Person TBD.
Person TBD makes remarks and introduces THE PRESIDENT.
THE PRESIDENT makes remarks and introduces THE VICE
PRESIDENT.
THE PRESIDENT proceeds to his seat.
THE VICE PRESIDENT and MRS. GORE make remarks via
satellite and begin a discussion.
THE VICE PRESIDENT makes concluding remarks and bids
farewell.
THE PRESIDENT makes concluding remarks.
12:05 p.m.
Upon conclusion of the event, THE PRESIDENT and THE FIRST
LADY depart.
For Official Government Use Only
President's List
HEALTHCARE CEREMONY - Monday JAN 4 1999 - 10:00 AM White House - Business - East Visitors
Entrance
Page 1
THE PRESIDENT AND FIRST LADY
REPORT DATE: January 2, 1999
REPORT TIME: 2:10 PM
Accepts and No Responses
A
Mr. Daniel C. Adcock
Assistant Legislative Director, National Association of Retired Federal Employees
Washington, DC
A
Ms. Linda Anthony
Executive Director, Pennsylvania Coalition of People's With Disabilities
Harrisburg, PA
A
Mr. Howard Bedlin
Vice President for Public Policy & Advocacy, National Council on The Aging
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Robert B. Blancato
Chairman of the Advisory Board, National Silver Haired Congress
Washington, DC
A
Ms. Deborah Briceland-Betts
Executive Director, Older Women's League
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Stephen R. Conner
Vice President, National Hospice Association
Arlington, VA
A
Ms. Maria Cordone
Director of Commuity Service & Older Workers, IAM & Retirees
Upper Marlboro, MD
A
Mr. Lawrence Crecy
Executive Vice President, National Caucus & Center on Black Aged
Washington, DC
Ms. Hilda L. Crespo
Hispanic Working Group on Healthcare
Washington, DC
A
Ms. Jean Daniel
Policy Director, National Association of Area Agencies on Aging
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Justin Dart
Founder, Justice for All
Guest: Mr. Tim Yazawa
A
Dr. Jane L. Delgado
President and CEO, COSSMHO
Rockville, MD
Ms. Beth Foley
Executive Director, Council for Exceptional Children
Reston, VA
A
Mr. Marty Ford
Assistant Director, Association of Retarded Citizens
Washington, DC
For Official Government Use Only
Page 2
REPORT DATE: January 2, 1999
REPORT TIME: 2:10 PM
Accepts and No Responses
A
Mr. Burton Fretz
Executive Director, National Senior Citizens Law Center
Washington, DC
Mr. Timothy Mark Fuller
Executive Director, Gray Panthers
Washington, DC
Ms. Helen Gibson
Supervisor for Special Programs, CWA Retirees
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Val John Halamandaris
President & CEO, National Association for Homecare
Washington, DC
Mr. Robert Kafka
ADAPT
Ms. Carmela LaCayo
President & CEO, National Association for Hispanic Elderly
Pasadena, CA
A
Mr. Paul Arthur Marchand
Chairman, Consortium for Citizens with Disabilities
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Stephen R. McConnell
Senior Vice President, Alzheimer's Association
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Mike Oxford
Executive Director, National Council on Independent Living
Mr. Stephen Protulis
National Council of Senior Citizens
Silver Spring, MD
A
Mr. Stephen Regenstreif
Director, AFSCME Retiree Program
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Max Richtman
Executive Vice President, National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare
Washington, DC
A
Ms. Judith Assmus Riggs
Director for Federal Policy, Alzheimer's Association
Washington, DC
A
Dr. Elena Rios
President, National Hispanic Medical Association
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Michael Rodgers
Senior Vice President for Government Relations, American Association of Homes & Services for the Aging
Washington, DC
For Official Government Use Only
Page 3
REPORT DATE: January 2, 1999
REPORT TIME: 2:10 PM
Accepts and No Responses
A
Mr. John Charles Rother
Director of Legislation & Public Policy, American Association of Retired Persons (AARP)
Washington, DC
Mr. Daniel Schulder
National Council of Senior Citizens
Silver Spring, MD
A
Mr. Gerry Shea
Assistant to the President for Government Affairs, AFL-CIO
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Samuel J. Simmons
President, National Caucus & Center on Black Aged
Washington, DC
A
Dr. Marta Sotomayor
President & CEO, National Hispanic Council on Aging
Washington, DC
A
Ms. Victoria Wagman
Policy Associate, National Council on the Aging, Inc.
Washington, DC
Ms. Roberta Weiner
Older Women's League
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Bruce Yarwood
Legislative Counsel, American Health Care Association
Washington, DC
A
Mr. Tony Young
Senior Policy Analyst, United Cerebral Palsy Association
Guest: Mr. David Fields
For Official Government Use Only
ALKING IT OVER COLUMN: January 13, 1999
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/First_Lady/html/columns/hrc011399.htm
TALKING IT OVER
HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
January 13, 1999
Not long ago, I had the opportunity to catch up with an old friend from
Chicago. In the course of the conversation, he told me about his daughter,
Lauren. Although Lauren was a happy, healthy baby at birth, she began to have
seizures at the age of 7 months. Seventeen years later, the seizures continue,
the cause has never been identified, and Lauren's development has been
irrevocably delayed. She will never live independently and will require lifelong
supervision and support. As her father spoke, I could see and hear the
devastating impact Lauren's epilepsy has had, not only on her own life but also
on her entire family.
When I heard Lauren's story, I was determined to learn more about this
condition and bolster this administration's efforts to improve treatment and find
a cure.
Nearly 200,000 Americans are diagnosed with epilepsy each year. Current
treatments control symptoms in most of their cases. Yet the word epilepsy still
provokes profound fear and misunderstanding.
Epilepsy is a chronic brain disorder characterized by spontaneous, recurrent
seizures that range from brief lapses in attention to prolonged losses of
consciousness with convulsions. It affects more than 2 million Americans --
one out of every 100. Of these, 300,000 are children. Head injuries, brain
tumors, stroke, lead poisoning, genetic conditions and infectious illnesses can
cause epilepsy. But in more than half of all cases like Lauren's no
explanation is ever found.
According to a new report, "Epilepsy: A Report to the Nation," sponsored by
the Epilepsy Foundation of America, anti-seizure drugs and other forms of
treatment can control or eliminate seizures in 75 percent of those affected.
These people live nearly normal lives lives that can be both personally and
professionally fulfilling. But even they never escape the uncertainty or the
potential social stigma that comes out of ignorance - a stigma that can crush
the spirit as surely as the disorder debilitates the body and the brain.
Tragically, though, for the nearly 600,000 like Lauren, the disorder is
intractable. Drugs, diet, surgery and other treatments just don't bring their
seizures under control.
One of the most heartbreaking aspects of epilepsy is the toll it takes on
children. Seizures in early childhood often produce developmental delays and
brain damage that can lead to a lifetime of dependence and extraordinary costs.
Children with epilepsy are at special risk for learning problems.
They fall behind in reading, language development and general knowledge.
Children who have frequent seizures can't even go to school. Perhaps worst of
all, they live in constant fear of their next seizure.
If these children are ever to live the normal, healthy and happy lives they
1 of 2
6/14/2000 9:56 AM
TALKING IT OVER COLUMN: January 13, 1999
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/First_Lady/html/columns/hrc011399.htm
deserve, we must dedicate ourselves to finding a cure now.
I'm pleased that the President's budget for this year includes a 14 percent
expansion for the National Institutes of Health, the largest funding increase
ever. Of this, an unprecedented $76 million is for epilepsy research alone. But
we must still do more.
This week, I'll be in Chicago for the dedication of a new epilepsy center at
Rush Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital and a major nationwide fund-raiser for
epilepsy research. There, I'll release the Epilepsy Foundation's report and talk
about the administration's next steps in the effort to eliminate the disorder.
Next year, NIH researchers will convene the first-ever administration
conference on epilepsy, bringing together more than 150 experts and members
of the public focused on finding a cure. In addition, the Centers for Disease
Control and the Agency for Health Care Policy Research together will launch a
campaign to educate medical practitioners about the critical need for early and
accurate diagnosis.
I have heard from many families around the country who have been touched by
epilepsy. Some share the pain of lives destroyed and promising futures
extinguished. Others marvel at the seemingly miraculous -- when drugs,
surgery or diet actually bring an end to the nightmare.
But the message is the same: More research dollars are critical if we are to
devise innovative, safe and effective treatments or find a cure. No one has said
it better than the parents of 12-year-old Philip Gattone, whose seizures ceased
following a combination of successful surgery and drug therapy. They wrote:
"Today, Philip plays sports, participates in school activities and
clubs, and loves learning. He has friends that care about him. He is
our hero.
"There are so many children that need help. The fight for a cure is
a daily battle, and it is real. It is a fight that must be won. Only
research and new treatments will help these special families
achieve their dreams of recovery from epilepsy."
For more information on epilepsy, visit the Epilepsy Foundation of America at
www.efa.org.
COPYRIGHT 1999 CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Talking it Over
Read our Privacy Policy
2 of 2
6/14/2000 9:56 AM
Clinton Presidential Records
Digital Records Marker
This is not a presidential record. This is used as an administrative
marker by the William J. Clinton Presidential Library Staff.
This marker identifies the place of a tabbed divider. Given our
digitization capabilities, we are sometimes unable to adequately
scan such dividers. The title from the original document is
indicated below.
1/13/99 Rush Epilepsy
Chicago, IL
Divider Title:
Withdrawal/Redaction Marker
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
SUBJECT/TITLE
DATE
RESTRICTION
AND TYPE
001. schedule
Schedule for Hillary Rodham Clinton Secret Service (Partial) (1 page)
01/13/1998
b(7)(E), b(6)
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
First Lady's Office
Melanne Verveer
OA/Box Number: 18538
FOLDER TITLE:
HRC Healthcare Book #12: Health Reform [2]
2013-0534-S
rc1768
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - [44 U.S.C. 2204(a)]
Freedom of Information Act [5 U.S.C. 552(b)]
P1 National Security Classified Information [(a)(1) of the PRA]
b(1) National security classified information [(b)(1) of the FOIA]
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office [(a)(2) of the PRA]
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute [(a)(3) of the PRA]
an agency [(b)(2) of the FOIA]
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute [(b)(3) of the FOIA]
financial information [(a)(4) of the PRA]
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
information [(b)(4) of the FOIA]
and his advisors, or between such advisors [a)(5) of the PRA]
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(b)(6) of the FOIA]
personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRA]
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes [(b)(7) of the FOIA]
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
of gift.
financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA]
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C.
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
2201(3).
concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA]
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 13, 1998
FINAL
WASHINGTON, DC / CHICAGO, IL / WASHINGTON, DC
TRAVELLING PARTY:
THE FIRST LADY
HUMA ABEDIN
RALPH ALSWANG
MARSHA BERRY
KELLY CRAIGHEAD
PATTI SOLIS DOYLE
NEERA TANDEN
[001]
(b)(6), (b)(7)e
CHICAGO
LEAD ADVANCE:
KAREN BURCHARD
CHICAGO HILTON & TOWERS
ROOM 1100
312/922-4400
PHONE
312/337-8189
FAX
1-800-759-8888
PIN: 891-7483
PRESS ADVANCE:
LORI GREENBAUM
773/244-9543
HOME
312/337-7400
OFFICE
312/806-1126
CELL PHONE
SITE ADVANCE:
SONYA COOVER
773/388-1513
HOME
312/337-7400
OFFICE
SITE ADVANCE:
MARGARET MCCARTHY
773/472-0848
HOME
312/337-7400
OFFICE
SITE ADVANCE:
BECCA GOLDSTEIN
773/929-1251
HOME
312/337-7400
OFFICE
SITE ADVANCE:
RICH HANSON
773/539-0156
HOME
312/337-7400
OFFICE
SCHEDULER:
EVAN RYAN
202/456-6751
PHONE
202/456-5340
FAX
202/483-0383
HOME
WHCA PAGER
#4223
PREV RON
The White House
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 13, 1998
PAGE 2
12:10 pm
DEPART South Portico
EN ROUTE Andrews Air Force Base
[drive time: 25 minutes]
12:35 pm
ARRIVE Andrews Air Force Base
12:45 pm
WHEELS UP Andrews Air Force Base
EN ROUTE Chicago Midway Airport
[flight time: 1 hour, 45 minutes, -1 hour]
1:30 pm
WHEELS DOWN Chicago Midway Airport
1:40 pm
DEPART Chicago Midway Airport
EN ROUTE Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital
[drive time: 30 minutes]
2:10 pm
ARRIVE Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital
GREETERS:
Dr. Leo Henikoff, President and CEO
Dr. Michael Smith, Director, Rush Epilepsy Center
2:15 pm-
TOUR OF THE RUSH EPILEPSY CENTER
2:35 pm
Rush Epilepsy Center
Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital
Hold: Room 348
Phone: 312/942-8124
Fax: 312/942-8129
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
FORMAT:
-The First Lady tours the four patient rooms of
the Rush Epilepsy Center with
-The First Lady pauses in hallway en route the
Herrick Room to unveil a plaque renaming the
wing for Dr. Frank Morrell.
NOTE: Dr. Frank Morrell's family will be present
at plaque unveiling.
CONTACT: Dr. Diane Macheever 312/942-6950
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 13, 1998
PAGE 3
2:40 pm-
ROUNDTABLE DISCUSSION
3:00 pm
Herrick Room
Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital
Hold: Sippey Room
Phone: 312/942-8128
Fax: 312/942-8130
POOL SPRAY (at top) PRINT PRESS (remains) /WH PHOTO
FORMAT:
-Dr. Michael Smith, Director, Rush Epilepsy
Center, opens the roundtable discussion.
-Roundtable participants make brief remarks.
-The First Lady makes brief closing remarks.
PARTICIPANTS:
The First Lady
Dr. Michael Smith, Director, Rush Epilepsy Center
Lawrence Gorski, Director, Mayor's Office for
Disabilities
Susan Axelrod
Liz Harris
Sharon Datro
CONTACT: Dr. Diane Macheever 312/942-6950
3:00 pm-
HOLD
3:05 pm
3:05 pm-
INAUGURATION OF THE RUSH EPILEPSY CENTER
3:30 pm
Brainard Conference Room
Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital
Hold: Sippey Room
Phone: 312/942-8128
Fax: 312/942-8130
OPEN PRESS
FORMAT:
-Dr. Leo Henikoff makes welcoming remarks and
introduces Congressman Danny Davis.
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 13, 1998
-Congressman Danny Davis makes brief remarks and
introduces Jeanne Carpenter.
PAGE 4
-Jeanne Carpenter, President, Epilepsy Foundation
of America makes brief remarks and introduces
Leeann Brigido Smith, parent of epilepsy patient.
-Leann Brigido Smith makes biref remarks and
introduces the First Lady.
-The First Lady makes remarks.
-The First Lady departs.
PARTICIPANTS: 100 guests
CONTACT: Dr. Diane Macheever 312/942-6950
3:35 pm
DEPART Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital
EN ROUTE John C. Haines School
[drive time: 20 minutes]
3:55 pm
ARRIVE John C. Haines School
INSIDE GREETERS:
Gandy Heaston, Principal
Mayor Richard Daley
Alderman Danny Solis
PROCEED ON ELEVATOR TO SECOND FLOOR
STAFF NOTE: Staff should proceed up the one flight of stairs.
SECOND FLOOR GREETERS:
Momma Hawk and 2 youth
4:00 pm-
AFTER SCHOOL EDUCATION EVENT
5:00 pm
John C. Haines School
247 W. 23rd Place
Chicago, IL
Hold: Classroom 1
Phone: 773/534-9200
Fax: 773/534-9209
OPEN PRESS
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 13, 1998
PAGE 5
FORMAT:
-The First Lady tours the Media Center, the site
of the Lighthouse After School Program, where
there are 8th graders doing research, and 3rd
graders reading from their Peace journals.
OPEN PRESS
-The First Lady proceeds to the Arts & Crafts room
to see the 2nd graders creating art projects.
-The First Lady walks downstairs to the Multi-
Purpose Room.
MULTI-PURPOSE ROOM GREETERS:
Gery Chico, School Board Chair
Paul Vallas, Chairman of the Public School System
Patricia McBride, Parent
Carolyn Williams Meza, General Superintendent,
Chicago Park District
John Rogers, President, Chicago Park District
Board
-The First Lady proceeds to stage.
-Gandy Heaston, Principal, makes welcoming remarks
and introduces two students.
-The two students, Color Guards, present the
Colors, and lead the Pledge of Allegiance.
-Gandy Heaston makes brief remarks and introduces
Alderman Danny Solis.
-Alderman Danny Solis makes brief remarks and
introduces Mayor Richard Daley.
-Mayor Richard Daley makes brief remarks and
introduces Patricia McBride, parent.
-Patricia McBride makes brief remarks and
introduces the First Lady.
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 13, 1998
-The First Lady makes remarks.
-Two students present the Mayor and the First Lady
with scarves and origami flowers.
PAGE 6
-The First Lady has the option of working a
ropeline on departure.
NOTE: On departure from the building, the 1st and 2nd grade
students will be assembled to bid farewell to the First Lady.
PARTICIPANTS: 400 guests
CONTACT: Sarah Pang 312/744-2728
800/800-9725
5:05 pm
DEPART John C. Haines School
EN ROUTE The Drake Hotel
[drive time: 30 minutes]
5:35 pm
ARRIVE The Drake Hotel
GREETERS:
Chicago Hilton and Towers Hotel General Manager
5:40 pm-
HOLD/MIX & MINGLE
6:00 pm
Room 139
Chicago Hilton and Towers
Phone: 312/787-2200
Fax: 312/787-1431
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
PARTICIPANTS: 38 guests
6:05 pm-
RECEIVING LINE
6:35 pm
The Drake Room
The Drake Hotel
Hold: Room 140
Phone: 312/787-2200
Fax: 312/787-1431
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
FORMAT:
-The First Lady does a photo receiving line.
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 13, 1998
PARTICIPANTS: 100 guests
CONTACT: Jan Kostner 312/337-7400
PAGE 7
6:45 pm-
CURE FUNDRAISER DINNER
7:30 pm
Gold Coast Room
The Drake Hotel
Hold: Room 140
Phone: 312/787-2200
Fax: 312/787-1431
OPEN PRESS
FORMAT:
-David Axelrod makes welcoming remarks and
introduces Susan Axelrod.
-Susan Axelrod makes brief remarks and introduces
the video.
-Video is played.
-Representative Rod Blagojevich makes brief
remarks and introduces Senator Herb Cole.
-Senator Herb Cole makes remarks and introduces
the First Lady.
-The First Lady makes remarks.
-The First Lady departs.
PARTICIPANTS: 400 guests
CONTACT: Jan Kostner 312/337-7400
7:35 pm
DEPART The Drake Hotel
EN ROUTE Chicago Midway Airport
[drive time: 40 minutes]
8:15 pm
ARRIVE Chicago Midway Airport
8:25 pm
WHEELS UP Chicago Midway Airport
EN ROUTE Andrews Air Force Base
[flight time: 1 hour, 25 minutes, +1 hour]
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 13, 1998
10:50 pm
WHEELS DOWN Andrews Air Force Base
PAGE 8
WEATHER FORECAST FOR WASHINGTON, DC: Mostly cloudy with scattered
rain showers by mid-afternoon. Winds southwest at 10 to 15 knots.
Low 38F. High 46F.
WEATHER FORECAST FOR CHICAGO, IL: Cloudy. High 18. Low 12.
January 12, 1999
ANNOUNCING NEW EFFORTS TO ADDRESS EPILEPSY
Date:
Wednesday, January 13, 1999
Time:
2:15pm to 3:30pm
Location:
Rush Epilepsy Center
Chicago, Illinois
From:
Neera Tanden
I.
PURPOSE
To highlight epilepsy, a condition that affects millions of Americans, by 1) releasing a new
report that details the effects of epilepsy on families, communities and the nation, and 2)
announcing a series of initiatives designed to promote education and research on this condition.
II.
BACKGROUND
OVERVIEW
As part of this event, you will tour the epilepsy wing of Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's medical
center, take part in a roundtable with people who have experience with epilepsy, and proceed to a
speaking program. Your involvement in this event is designed to bring attention to a disease that
has received little attention in the past. You will also make a series of announcements related to
promoting effective research and proper education of physicians as well as patients.
NEW ANNOUNCEMENTS
New Report
You will release "Epilepsy: A Report to the Nation," sponsored by the Epilepsy Foundation of
America. The report found that epilepsy and seizures affect 2.3 million Americans of all ages,
300,000 of whom are children. The report also found that epilepsy has $12.5 billion in direct and
indirect costs to our nation. In addition, the study reports that approximately 181,000 new cases
of seizures and epilepsy occur each year, and 10% of the American population will experience a
seizure in their lifetime. It also found that one fifth to one quarter of the people with controlled
seizures are significantly less likely to work than the rest of the population; of the unemployed
64% said that they were unemployed as a direct result of their epilepsy. In the epileptic
population 17% report that problems on the job were the chief challenge to their disorder. The
report also found that while advances in medical treatment enable many people to live normal
lives free of seizures, 25% of those with epilepsy -- 600,000 people -- resist control and become
intractable. The study found that epilepsy remains a formidable barrier to normal life for this
group, affecting educational attainment, employment, and personal fulfillment.
1
NIH Conference to Search for a Cure
You will also announce that next year, the National Institutes of Health will convene the first-
ever Administration conference on epilepsy which will include over 150 experts from across the
country. The conference will consolidate current understanding of epilepsy and work towards
finding a cure for epilepsy. It will also focus on how to best allocate the unprecedented
investment this Administration has made in epilepsy research -- $76 million dollars in this year
alone, up from $54 million dollars in 1995.
New Initiative to Educate Doctors About Epilepsy
A number of people with epilepsy are inaccurately diagnosed, which allows the condition to
deteriorate, often causing brain developmental delays and additional health problems. You will
announce a new partnership between the Centers for Disease Control and the Agency for Health
Care Policy Research to inform practitioners on the importance of early diagnosis to help address
this problem. Together, they will launch an education campaign directed towards primary care
physicians in order to ensure appropriate diagnosis.
Epilepsy Chatroom on the Web
You will also announce a new Internet chat series that will allow consumers, patients, and family
members to engage in live discussions on issues relating to epilepsy, with doctors and other
experts who will be available online to answer specific questions about this disorder. The
website address is www.ivillage.com or www.efa.org, and it will be sponsored by the Epilepsy
Foundation of America and iVillage.com.
BACKGROUND ON EPILEPSY
Epilepsy is a neurological disorder in which nerve cells of the brain release abnormal electrical
impulses from time to time. These cause a temporary malfunction of other nerve cells of the
brain, resulting in an altered or complete loss of consciousness (what is commonly referred to as
a seizure). A pattern of repeated seizures is referred to as epilepsy. There is no known cause in
half of all cases. However, head injuries, brain tumors, lead poisoning, problems in brain
development prior to birth, and certain genetic and infectious illnesses can all cause epilepsy.
There are no visible symptoms, and individuals can suffer an attack without warning.
According to NINDS, the federal government spent $68 million on epilepsy research and
prevention last year and is projected to invest $76 million this year. This is up from $54 million
in 1995. However, according to advocates, only $20.64 is spent on each patient who has
epilepsy. In contrast, $312.00 is spent on the patient with multiple sclerosis and $136.00 on each
patient with Parkinson's Disease, though epilepsy affects more people than those affected by
either disease. In addition to finding the cause of epilepsy, advocates and researchers are
concerned about improving the diagnosis of epilepsy; developing new drugs to control seizures;
and improving and developing new surgical techniques for those who must rely on this form of
treatment.
2
The Rush Epilepsy Center
The Rush Epilepsy Center at Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center in Chicago is
internationally known for its efforts to restore control over their disease to epilepsy patients. The
center was opened in 1972 by Dr. Frank Morrell to focus on providing specialized care for adults
and children with epilepsy and those experiencing symptoms of epilepsy. The center is one of the
nation's most comprehensive facilities for the diagnosis, monitoring, and treatment of epilepsy.
In particular, the center provides care for patients whose disease has been unresponsive to
standard medical management. Their multi-disciplinary staff including epileptologists,
neuropsychologist, physiologists, pediatric neurologists, a neurosurgeon, clinical nurse
specialists, and social workers work to provide a comprehensive individualized program for each
patient by focusing on the medical, social, psychological, and daily effects of epilepsy. Options
for the diagnosis and treatment of epilepsy at the center include diagnostic monitoring, surgical
workup, implanted electrodes, and surgery. The Rush Epilepsy Center is currently under the
direction of Dr. Michael Smith.
As part of this event, you are dedicating the center in honor of Frank Morrell, who died last year,
after working as an epilepsy specialist at Rush for over 20 years. Dr. Morrell was one of the
nation's leading experts on the diagnosis and treatment of epilepsy and seizure disorders.
III.
PARTICIPANTS
Roundtable Participants:
-The First Lady
-Dr. Michael Smith, Director of Rush's Epilepsy Center
-Larry Gorsky, Special Assistant to the Mayor for the Office of Disabilities
-Susan Axelrod, mother of Lauren Axelrod who is a 17-year-old young woman with intractable
epilepsy who has suffered tremendous developmental disabilities as a result of her condition.
- Sharon Ditch, who has been seizure-free since an operation she had two years ago. She will
describe the difference in her life since her operation.
-Liz Harris, who has a milder form of epilepsy but has faced tremendous stigma nevertheless.
(See attachments.)
Speaking Program:
-The First Lady
-Dr. Leo Henikoff, President and CEO of Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke Hospital
-Representative Danny Davis
-Jeanne Carpenter, President of the Epilepsy Foundation of America and a lawyer who suffers
from epilepsy
-LeeAnn Brigido Smith, whose 8 year old son Zachary suffers from intractible epilepsy; as a
result he has tremendous developmental delays
Audience for speaking program
125 people, including medical professionals, advocates and people with epilepsy
3
IV.
SEQUENCE OF EVENTS
Upon arrival at Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital, the First Lady will tour the
epilepsy center, including its four patient rooms, with Dr. Leo Henikoff and Dr. Michael
Smith;
The First Lady will unveil a plaque dedicating the epilepsy center after Dr. Frank Morrell,
an epilepsy specialist who died last year (Dr. Frank Morrell's family will be present at the
plaque unveiling);
The First Lady then proceeds to a roundtable discussion, which will be led by Dr.
Michael Smith and include Larry Gorsky, Special Assistant to Mayor Daley. The
roundtable will include Susan Axelrod, Sharon Ditch and Liz Harris, all of whom will
discuss their particular experiences with epilepsy (see attachments);
The First Lady will then proceed to a speaking program, in which Dr. Leo Henikoff, CEO
and President of Rush, will make welcoming remarks and introduce Representative
Danny Davis;
Representative Danny Davis will make brief remarks and introduce Jeanne Carpenter,
President of the Epilepsy Foundation and a woman with epilepsy;
Jeanne Carpenter will make remarks and introduce LeeAnn Brigido Smith, the parent of a
child with intractible epilepsy;
LeeAnn Brigido Smith will make remarks and introduce the First Lady;
Upon conclusion of her remarks, the First Lady will depart.
V.
PRESS PLAN
Tour
Closed Press
Roundtable
Pool spray at the top only
Speaking program
Open press
VI. REMARKS
Provided by Christy Macy
4
Untitled Document
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990113.ht
RUSH Epilepsy Center
Remarks by First Lady Hillary Rodham Clinton
at RUSH Presbyterian St. Luke's Medical Center
Chicago, Illinois
January 13, 1999
Thank you very much, Lee Ann. Thank you for your willingness to come and share your story and
speak for so many other parents of children with epilepsy and so many adults as well. I think it was
apparent to all of us as we listened to you that your courage and determination in the face of what you
described as heartbreak is just one more call for why we are here today and why we need to be as
focused and persistent as possible in meeting the challenges posed by epilepsy.
I want to thank Congressman Davis for being with us and for his support on so many fronts that are
aimed at, and are actually improving, the lives of people here in Chicago and Illinois and across our
country.
Dr. Henikoff, thank you for giving me the tour that we had together in your neurology unit seeing the
Epilepsy Center. I want to thank Dr. Michael Smith, who is the director of the epilepsy unit, for being
with me and for explaining and answering many of my questions.
I'm delighted that Jeane Carpinter, president of the Epilepsy Foundation of America-and herself
someone who can speak with firsthand knowledge about epilepsy-who was able to come from
Washington to be with us. And I just had the opportunity to meet with some other people who have
stories to tell as well. Before I came in, Dr. Smith and I spent some time with Mrs. Axlerod, a friend of
mine. She and David have been friends of mine for a number of years, and they are parents of a child
with epilepsy. And Susan is the president of CURE, a group that is committed to raising both awareness
about the need for research and funds for research on epilepsy.
I want to thank Sharon Dachrow (phonetic), who was at the roundtable discussion and who has a
success story to tell us about having surgery here at this hospital just 2 1/2 years ago, and has been
seizure-free ever since. I want to thank Liz Harris, who has been with us and who described what life
has been like for her since she was 10 years old and had her first seizure, and how-although she has
been able to manage and do very well, graduating from college and holding down a job-she knows
that she is not seizure-free and she's hoping for the time when she, like Sharon, can be able to say that.
I want to thank Larry Gorski (phonetic), who came from the Mayor's Office on People with
Disabilities, because it is very important that we recognize that it is not only the physical disability that
we can see. And Larry pointed that out-he's in a wheelchair, but we can see that Larry is doing very
well with his visible disability. But it's the invisible disabilities like those brought on by epilepsy that
we also need to be very aware of and very understanding of.
I also want to thank the Morrell family. Dr. Frank Morell's family joined me as we dedicated the
epilepsy unit to Dr. Morrell. They certainly have a great deal to be proud of since Dr. Morrell pioneered
the surgery that Sharon was able to have successfully. And then I met some patients who are ready for
their surgery tomorrow and next week, thanks to Dr. Morrell's back-breaking work. I also want to thank
Dianne McKeaver (phonetic) and others associated with the hospital and the board members of the
entire staff for the work you do every day on behalf of all kinds of people and their problems.
I also want to acknowledge iVillage, which is one of our partners in creating a website about epilepsy
that will bring much needed attention and encouragement, not only to those who are directly affected by
epilepsy, but to countless others who care about this problem and what they all can do about it.
I was thinking about what the connection is between this event here in Chicago and probably the most
important event that happened in our country today, and probably in the world-Michael Jordan's press
1 of 4
6/14/2000 9:56 AM
Untitled Document
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990113.htm
conference and announcement of retirement. Literally, I understand that Michael Jordan's press
conference was news that broke into whatever was going on throughout the world. You know, people
sitting in (unintelligible) and Mongolia are watching TV, and all of a sudden they see Michael on the
television. And it is certainly true that his retirement marks a sad day for all of us who are Bulls fans
and Michael Jordan fans-and people who love basketball and sports around the world-because he
brought to the game such skill that is indescribable and a competitive drive that was unmatched, as well
as dedication and teamwork. And he really lifted us up as we watched him go whipping across that
court, defying gravity and making it seem possible that, indeed, people could fly.
And the President and I both expressed a statement from the White House to give our personal best
wishes to Michael and Juanita and their family. But as I read the comments that Michael made, because
I was unable to watch the press conference as I was flying here, I was struck when he talked about the
challenges he said still lay ahead for him. And he said that certainly one of the biggest challenges
anyone can face is being a parent.
And that is true if our children are healthy. It is even truer if, like Susan or Lee Ann, we have a child
with an acute or chronic condition that literally demands our attention, our concentration, our focus-as
intense as anything like we'll ever do at our work-day in and day out to protect a Zachary from hurting
himself, to make sure that a Laura doesn't lose her total self-confidence and feeling of herself as a
human being as she suffers seizure after seizure.
And I also thought about all of the scientists like Dr. Morrell, and all the physicians here and elsewhere
who bring that same commitment and teamwork to the work you're doing on behalf of epilepsy that
Michael Jordan brought to basketball. I've often thought of him as not just an example for us who love
sports, but as somebody who can tell us what it feels like to reach really deep down inside and deal with
any of life's challenges-many of which we don't know when they will come or where they will come
from. But we can be certain that each of us will be challenged.
And today, you are helping to meet the challenges imposed by epilepsy. The progress we made here is a
tribute to the tireless efforts we made here to the physicians, the nurses, the other staff members, and
everyone associated with the work that has gone on here. I'm also very impressed that each of you
understands so well that this is not just a medical condition-this is one that has social, economic, and
psychological implications as well.
Those of you who work every day with people with epilepsy, and certainly those of you who either
suffer from it or who have a family member who does, knows how widely it affects families and
communities. And I don't think most Americans do. Part of the reason that I wanted to make epilepsy
an issue that would be brought to wider public attention is that starting with the work that began on
health care a couple of years ago, I have followed developments in health care the best a layperson can.
And I've also followed the research that's being done to try to find cures, to push advances, to really
cross new frontiers in medical science. And it struck me that, time and time again, we would make
progress in a disease, and it would really feel very good in the investment that we made. But then I
learned that when you take the number of people in our country who suffer from epilepsy-can you
imagine with the amount of money that we have historically spent, that Congressman Davis referred
to-that we have been spending far less trying to find the source, the reasons behind, and the cure for
this condition than comparable diseases and other kinds of medical conditions.
As I got to thinking about that I realized that I, like many Americans, may have not paid sufficient
attention to epilepsy and the costs that it extracts. Most people, for example, don't understand the
terrible impact of epilepsy on children whose seizures produce developmental delays that can create a
lifetime of dependence, loneliness, and unfulfilled dreams. Most people cannot see the heartbreak or
hear the whispered prayers of parents who watch their children suffer. Most people don't know about
the seemingly endless array of drugs, and hospital trips, and CAT scans, and blood tests, and treatments,
and surgeries that patients with contractible epilepsy must endure.
And most people are not aware of the toll that this condition take on adults-on their ability to get or
keep a job, drive a car, maintain relationships, or even have a positive self-image of themselves. I can
2 of 4
6/14/2000 9:56 AM
Untitled Document
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990113.htm
only imagine how difficult it must be to live with those endless "what ifs": "What if I get a seizure when
I'm crossing the street, or cooking for my family, or holding my baby in my arms?" Sharon told us
about the seizure she had on a bus one time, not just once, but many times over and over again. While
most people with epilepsy, thankfully today, can control their seizures, even they must live with
something they cannot control-the cruel social stigma and stereotyping that comes with widespread
ignorance of this disorder. That can damage the spirit as much as seizures themselves damage the brain.
And clearly we have to do a better job of educating ourselves and increasing awareness among all
Americans.
Today I am pleased to release a new study sponsored by the Epilepsy Foundation of America. This is a
report to the nation aimed at heightening public awareness that this disease, this disorder, affects 2.3
million Americans, and it has a staggering cost to individuals and communities of at least $2.5 million a
year.
The report also makes clear that there will be approximately 181,000 new cases of seizures and epilepsy
to occur this year-that's an annual figure-and that 10 percent of the American population will
experience a seizure during their lifetimes. This is not a disease that leaves anyone out. It can strike at
any age-from 6 months to 60, or 70, or 80 years of age-any person, any walk of life.
So we hope that this study will help to educate people about the effects of epilepsy and will help dispel
misinformation and misunderstanding that are often as devastating as the condition itself. But we have
to do more than pubic awareness, as important as that is. We have to do more research and we have to
find a cure.
That's why I'm so proud of the unprecedented commitment that the President has made to fighting
epilepsy and finding a cure. Under this Administration, funding for epilepsy research has grown
dramatically-from a $54 million commitment in 1995 to a projected $76 million commitment this
year.
Today, as a result of improved research and treatments, half a million Americans are receiving medical
relief from their seizures and are able to lead normal, productive lives. Unfortunately, though, too many
who suffer from epilepsy are still forced to choose from disabling seizures and debilitating side effects.
So while science has been able to solve many of the world's most common diseases in this century, the
hundreds of thousands of Americans with intractable epilepsy suffer as much as those who had this
condition hundreds, even thousands of years ago.
You know better than I the stories that come to this hospital, which has established itself as a
world-wide center for the treatment and diagnosis of epilepsy. So with this audience of people who
understand this condition, I'd like to list a few more things that I think we should be doing in order to
help you do your work better, and to give more hope to people like Lee Ann and Susan.
We have to redouble our efforts to find a cure. Although we can celebrate the dramatic increase in
federal funding for epilepsy research, we have to do more. I'm pleased to announce that next year, the
National Institutes of Health will convene the first ever White House Initiated Conference on Epilepsy.
More than 150 experts from around the country, and indeed the world, will participate, focusing on how
best to allocate the unprecedented investment that has been made in epilepsy research.
Second, we have to do more to educate doctors about epilepsy. I heard from Dr. Smith how common it
is for doctors who do not practice neurology or who do not see many epilepsy patients not to know what
they are seeing, and therefore to misdiagnose the condition. When people with epilepsy are
misdiagnosed, their condition continues to degenerate, often causing increasingly severe effects on brain
development. So to address this problem, the Centers for Disease Control and the Agency for Health
Care Policy Research are launching a new initiative that will reach out to thousands of doctors and
inform them about how to make appropriate early diagnoses.
Third, we have to make information about epilepsy more accessible, in our schools, our doctor's offices,
3 of 4
6/14/2000 9:56 AM
Untitled Document
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990113.htm
our communities.
So I'm also pleased to announce a new educational source. The Epilepsy Foundation of America and
iVillage, an Internet company, will launch an Internet chat room that will offer consumers, patients and
family members a safe and valuable opportunity to engage in live discussions with epilepsy specialists.
It is very important that people who are searching for answers, and doctors, and others who are involved
in this have a way of communicating and getting good and accurate information out to the public.
If we are going to see the end to the anguish and suffering of those with epilepsy, and find a cure, then
all of us will have to do more to become involved-the government, the business sector, the
not-for-profit sector, and certainly the medical and scientific research sector. Tonight, I will be
attending a fund-raiser for CURE, a new advocacy group that has been founded here in Chicago to raise
money for epilepsy research.
So, whether we're involved in raising private funds, or lobbying for more public support, or helping to
educate our friends and neighbors, or helping to educate physicians-we can all do something to help
bring the day closer when there is no more ignorance about epilepsy, and hopefully when there is no
more suffering. What better way to carry on Dr. Morrell's legacy than to commit ourselves to fulfilling
the vision of hope that he established here. And I would hope as well that those of you who are experts
in epilepsy will find some time to reach into the larger community so that when a seizure occurs on a
bus, or in an office, or in school, people will not back away or recoil in fear. But, instead, will
understand that this is another condition medically caused and explained that we all have to do
something about it. And that will give some comfort to those families that are struggling so terribly
against the odds, to try to make sure that their children and their loved ones not only get the treatment
they need, but that someday get the cure that they deserve.
Thank you all very much.
Read our Privacy Policy
4 of 4
6/14/2000 9:56 AM
January 12, 1999
ANNOUNCING NEW EFFORTS TO ADDRESS EPILEPSY
Date:
Wednesday, January 13, 1999
Time:
2:15pm to 3:30pm
Location:
Rush Epilepsy Center
Chicago, Illinois
From:
Neera Tanden
I.
PURPOSE
To highlight epilepsy, a condition that affects millions of Americans, by 1) releasing a new
report that details the effects of epilepsy on families, communities and the nation, and 2)
announcing a series of initiatives designed to promote education and research on this condition.
II.
BACKGROUND
OVERVIEW
As part of this event, you will tour the epilepsy wing of Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's medical
center, take part in a roundtable with people who have experience with epilepsy, and proceed to a
speaking program. Your involvement in this event is designed to bring attention to a disease that
has received little attention in the past. You will also make a series of announcements related to
promoting effective research and proper education of physicians as well as patients.
NEW ANNOUNCEMENTS
New Report
You will release "Epilepsy: A Report to the Nation," sponsored by the Epilepsy Foundation of
America. The report found that epilepsy and seizures affect 2.3 million Americans of all ages,
300,000 of whom are children. The report also found that epilepsy has $12.5 billion in direct and
indirect costs to our nation. In addition, the study reports that approximately 181,000 new cases
of seizures and epilepsy occur each year, and 10% of the American population will experience a
seizure in their lifetime. It also found that one fifth to one quarter of the people with controlled
seizures are significantly less likely to work than the rest of the population; of the unemployed
64% said that they were unemployed as a direct result of their epilepsy. In the epileptic
population 17% report that problems on the job were the chief challenge to their disorder. The
report also found that while advances in medical treatment enable many people to live normal
lives free of seizures, 25% of those with epilepsy -- 600,000 people -- resist control and become
intractable. The study found that epilepsy remains a formidable barrier to normal life for this
group, affecting educational attainment, employment, and personal fulfillment.
1
NIH Conference to Search for a Cure
You will also announce that next year, the National Institutes of Health will convene the first-
ever Administration conference on epilepsy which will include over 150 experts from across the
country. The conference will consolidate current understanding of epilepsy and work towards
finding a cure for epilepsy. It will also focus on how to best allocate the unprecedented
investment this Administration has made in epilepsy research -- $76 million dollars in this year
alone, up from $54 million dollars in 1995.
New Initiative to Educate Doctors About Epilepsy
A number of people with epilepsy are inaccurately diagnosed, which allows the condition to
deteriorate, often causing brain developmental delays and additional health problems. You will
announce a new partnership between the Centers for Disease Control and the Agency for Health
Care Policy Research to inform practitioners on the importance of early diagnosis to help address
this problem. Together, they will launch an education campaign directed towards primary care
physicians in order to ensure appropriate diagnosis.
Epilepsy Chatroom on the Web
You will also announce a new Internet chat series that will allow consumers, patients, and family
members to engage in live discussions on issues relating to epilepsy, with doctors and other
experts who will be available online to answer specific questions about this disorder. The
website address is www.ivillage.com or www.efa.org, and it will be sponsored by the Epilepsy
Foundation of America and iVillage.com.
BACKGROUND ON EPILEPSY
Epilepsy is a neurological disorder in which nerve cells of the brain release abnormal electrical
impulses from time to time. These cause a temporary malfunction of other nerve cells of the
brain, resulting in an altered or complete loss of consciousness (what is commonly referred to as
a seizure). A pattern of repeated seizures is referred to as epilepsy. There is no known cause in
half of all cases. However, head injuries, brain tumors, lead poisoning, problems in brain
development prior to birth, and certain genetic and infectious illnesses can all cause epilepsy.
There are no visible symptoms, and individuals can suffer an attack without warning.
According to NINDS, the federal government spent $68 million on epilepsy research and
prevention last year and is projected to invest $76 million this year. This is up from $54 million
in 1995. However, according to advocates, only $20.64 is spent on each patient who has
epilepsy. In contrast, $312.00 is spent on the patient with multiple sclerosis and $136.00 on each
patient with Parkinson's Disease, though epilepsy affects more people than those affected by
either disease. In addition to finding the cause of epilepsy, advocates and researchers are
concerned about improving the diagnosis of epilepsy; developing new drugs to control seizures;
and improving and developing new surgical techniques for those who must rely on this form of
treatment.
2
The Rush Epilepsy Center
The Rush Epilepsy Center at Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center in Chicago is
internationally known for its efforts to restore control over their disease to epilepsy patients. The
center was opened in 1972 by Dr. Frank Morrell to focus on providing specialized care for adults
and children with epilepsy and those experiencing symptoms of epilepsy. The center is one of the
nation's most comprehensive facilities for the diagnosis, monitoring, and treatment of epilepsy.
In particular, the center provides care for patients whose disease has been unresponsive to
standard medical management. Their multi-disciplinary staff including epileptologists,
neuropsychologist, physiologists, pediatric neurologists, a neurosurgeon, clinical nurse
specialists, and social workers work to provide a comprehensive individualized program for each
patient by focusing on the medical, social, psychological, and daily effects of epilepsy. Options
for the diagnosis and treatment of epilepsy at the center include diagnostic monitoring, surgical
workup, implanted electrodes, and surgery. The Rush Epilepsy Center is currently under the
direction of Dr. Michael Smith.
As part of this event, you are dedicating the center in honor of Frank Morrell, who died last year,
after working as an epilepsy specialist at Rush for over 20 years. Dr. Morrell was one of the
nation's leading experts on the diagnosis and treatment of epilepsy and seizure disorders.
III.
PARTICIPANTS
Roundtable Participants:
-The First Lady
-Dr. Michael Smith, Director of Rush's Epilepsy Center
-Larry Gorsky, Special Assistant to the Mayor for the Office of Disabilities
-Susan Axelrod, mother of Lauren Axelrod who is a 17-year-old young woman with intractable
epilepsy who has suffered tremendous developmental disabilities as a result of her condition.
- Sharon Ditch, who has been seizure-free since an operation she had two years ago. She will
describe the difference in her life since her operation.
-Liz Harris, who has a milder form of epilepsy but has faced tremendous stigma nevertheless.
(See attachments.)
Speaking Program:
-The First Lady
-Dr. Leo Henikoff, President and CEO of Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke Hospital
-Representative Danny Davis
-Jeanne Carpenter, President of the Epilepsy Foundation of America and a lawyer who suffers
from epilepsy
-LeeAnn Brigido Smith, whose 8 year old son Zachary suffers from intractible epilepsy; as a
result he has tremendous developmental delays
Audience for speaking program
125 people, including medical professionals, advocates and people with epilepsy
3
IV.
SEQUENCE OF EVENTS
Upon arrival at Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital, the First Lady will tour the
epilepsy center, including its four patient rooms, with Dr. Leo Henikoff and Dr. Michael
Smith;
The First Lady will unveil a plaque dedicating the epilepsy center after Dr. Frank Morrell,
an epilepsy specialist who died last year (Dr. Frank Morrell's family will be present at the
plaque unveiling);
The First Lady then proceeds to a roundtable discussion, which will be led by Dr.
Michael Smith and include Larry Gorsky, Special Assistant to Mayor Daley. The
roundtable will include Susan Axelrod, Sharon Ditch and Liz Harris, all of whom will
discuss their particular experiences with epilepsy (see attachments);
The First Lady will then proceed to a speaking program, in which Dr. Leo Henikoff, CEO
and President of Rush, will make welcoming remarks and introduce Representative
Danny Davis;
Representative Danny Davis will make brief remarks and introduce Jeanne Carpenter,
President of the Epilepsy Foundation and a woman with epilepsy;
Jeanne Carpenter will make remarks and introduce LeeAnn Brigido Smith, the parent of a
child with intractible epilepsy;
LeeAnn Brigido Smith will make remarks and introduce the First Lady;
Upon conclusion of her remarks, the First Lady will depart.
V.
PRESS PLAN
Tour
Closed Press
Roundtable
Pool spray at the top only
Speaking program
Open press
VI.
REMARKS
Provided by Christy Macy
4
JAN-12-99 08:07 PM
P.02
FIRST LADY HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
RUSH EPILEPSY CENTER
RUSH-PRESBYTERIAN-ST. LUKE'S MEDICAL CENTER
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS
JANUARY 13, 1999
THANK YOU, LEE ANN, FOR TELLING US YOUR STORY. THANK
YOU EVEN MORE FOR YOUR COURAGE AND DETERMINATION IN THE
FACE OF SUCH HEARTBREAK. MUCH MORE ATTENTION NEEDS TO BE
PAID TO WHAT YOU-- AND THOSE WHO I HAVE JUST MET WITH --
HAVE TO SAY ABOUT THE EXTRAORDINARY CHALLENGES FACING
EPILEPSY PATIENTS AND THEIR FAMILIES EVERY DAY. I HOPE THAT
WHAT WE DO HERE TODAY WILL HELP SHINE THE NATIONAL
SPOTLIGHT ON THIS DISEASE - AND SPUR US ALL TO REDOUBLE OUR
EFFORTS TO END THE SUFFERING AND FIND A CURE.
I'M VERY PLEASED TO BE HERE AT CHICAGO'S RUSH-
PRESBYTERIAN- ST. LUKE'S MEDICAL CENTER -- AND TO HAVE HAD
THE OPPORTUNITY TO TOUR THIS HIGHLY ACCLAIMED EPILEPSY
CENTER.
I
JAN-12-99 08:07 PM
P.03
THE PROGRESS BEING MADE HERE IS A TRIBUTE TO THE
TIRELESS EFFORTS OF ALL OF YOU: DR. HENIKOFF (DIRECTOR OF THE
MEDICAL CENTER); DR. SMITH (DIRECTOR OF THE EPILEPSY
CENTER); DEDICATED STAFF; PATIENTS; AND FAMILY MEMBERS.
THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU DO, EVERY SINGLE DAY, TO GIVE
PEOPLE WITH EPILEPSY THE CARE AND UNDERSTANDING THEY NEED
AND DESERVE.
IT'S ALSO A PRIVILEGE TO JOIN JEANE CARPINTER FOR
TODAY'S EVENTS. HER PERSONAL COURAGE AND PUBLIC
ADVOCACY IS AN INSPIRATION TO US ALL.
WE'VE COME TOGETHER TO DEDICATE THIS CENTER IN THE
MEMORY OF THE REMARKABLE MAN WHO FOUNDED IT MORE THAN
25 YEARS AGO. A BRILLIANT SCIENTIST AND A COMPASSIONATE
HUMAN BEING, DR. FRANK MORRELL COMBINED QUALITIES NOT
OFTEN FOUND IN A SINGLE INDIVIDUAL. AND IN THE PROCESS - HE
TRANSFORMED THE WAY WE TREAT AND CARE FOR THOSE WITH
EPILEPSY. THANK YOU FOR INVITING ME TO JOIN YOU ON THIS
SPECIAL OCCASION.
2
JAN-12-99 08:07 PM
P.04
ALL OF YOU HERE KNOW FIRSTHAND HOW DRAMATICALLY
EPILEPSY CAN CHANGE PEOPLE'S LIVES -- OFTEN OVERNIGHT - AND
HOW WIDELY IT AFFECTS FAMILIES AND COMMUNITIES HERE AND
ACROSS THE COUNTRY. YET WHEN YOU STEP OUTSIDE THESE
WALLS, THERE REMAINS ENORMOUS IGNORANCE ABOUT THIS
CONDITION.
MOST PEOPLE DON'T UNDERSTAND THE TERRIBLE IMPACT OF
EPILEPSY ON CHILDREN - WHOSE SEIZURES PRODUCE
DEVELOPMENTAL DELAYS AND BRAIN DAMAGE THAT CAN LEAD TO
A LIFETIME OF DEPENDENCE, LONELINESS, AND UNFULFILLED
DREAMS. MOST PEOPLE CAN'T SEE THE HEARTBREAK, OR HEAR THE
WHISPERED PRAYERS OF PARENTS WHO WATCH THEIR CHILDREN
SUFFER. MOST PEOPLE DON'T KNOW ABOUT THE SEEMINGLY
ENDLESS ARRAY OF DRUGS; HOSPITAL TRIPS; CAT SCANS AND BLOOD
TESTS; TREATMENTS AND SURGERIES THAT MANY PATIENTS MUST
ENDURE. AND THEY ARE UNAWARE OF THE TERRIBLE TOLL THIS
DISEASE TAKES ON ADULTS AND THEIR ABILITY TO GET OR KEEP
A JOB; DRIVE A CAR; MAINTAIN RELATIONSHIPS; OR HAVE A
POSITIVE SELF IMAGE.
3
JAN-12-99 08:07 PM
P.05
I CAN ONLY IMAGINE HOW DIFFICULT IT MUST BE TO LIVE
WITH THOSE ENDLESS "WHAT IF'S": WHAT IF I GET A SEIZURE WHEN
I'M CROSSING THE STREET, OR COOKING FOR MY FAMILY, OR
HOLDING MY CHILD IN MY ARMS? AND WHILE MOST PEOPLE WITH
EPILEPSY CAN CONTROL THEIR SEIZURES -- THEY MUST LIVE WITH
SOMETHING THEY CAN'T CONTROL: THE CRUEL SOCIAL STIGMA
THAT COMES WITH WIDESPREAD IGNORANCE OF THIS DISEASE. IT
CAN DAMAGE THE SPIRIT AS MUCH AS THE SEIZURES THEMSELVES
- AND WE MUST DO ALL WE CAN TO END IT.
CLEARLY WE MUST DO A FAR BETTER JOB OF EDUCATING THE
PUBLIC ABOUT THE EXTENT OF THE PROBLEM OF EPILEPSY IN
AMERICA. TODAY, I'M RELEASING A NEW STUDY - SPONSORED BY
THE EPILEPSY FOUNDATION OF AMERICA - AIMED AT HEIGHTENING
THAT PUBLIC AWARENESS. "EPILEPSY: A REPORT TO THE NATION"
CONFIRMS THAT EPILEPSY AND SEIZURES AFFECT 2.3 MILLION
AMERICANS - AT A YEARLY COST TO FAMILIES AND COMMUNITIES
OF $12.5 BILLION.
4
JAN-12-99 08:08 PM
P.06
IT ALSO REPORTS THAT 181,000 NEW CASES OF SEIZURES AND
EPILEPSY OCCUR EVERY YEAR - AND THAT 10% OF THE AMERICAN
POPULATION WILL EXPERIENCE A SEIZURE DURING THEIR LIFETIMES.
WE HOPE THIS STUDY WILL GO A LONG WAY TOWARD
EDUCATING PEOPLE ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF EPILEPSY ON PEOPLE OF
ALL AGES, AND WILL HELP DISPEL THE MISINFORMATION AND
MISUNDERSTANDING THAT ARE OFTEN AS DEVASTATING AS THE
DISEASE ITSELF. THE REPORT ALSO TELLS US THAT WE NEED TO DO
MORE- MUCH MORE- TO FIND A CURE.
THAT'S WHY I'M so PROUD OF THE UNPRECEDENTED
COMMITMENT THE PRESIDENT HAS MADE TO FIGHTING EPILEPSY,
AND FINDING A CURE. UNDER HIS ADMINISTRATION, FUNDING FOR
EPILEPSY RESEARCH HAS GROWN DRAMATICALLY FROM $54
MILLION IN 1995 TO A PROJECTED $76 MILLION THIS YEAR.
5
JAN-12-99 08:08 PM
P.07
TODAY-- AS A RESULT OF IMPROVED RESEARCH AND
TREATMENTS, HALF A MILLION AMERICANS ARE RECEIVING
MEDICAL RELIEF FROM THEIR SEIZURES, AND ARE ABLE TO LEAD
NORMAL, PRODUCTIVE LIVES. ADULTS ARE RETURNING TO WORK;
CHILDREN ARE ONCE AGAIN JOINING THEIR FRIENDS ON THE
PLAYGROUND. AND PARENTS AND SIBLINGS ARE DARING TO
IMAGINE THE DAY WHEN LIFE CAN RETURN TO NORMAL.
UNFORTUNATELY, FAR TOO MANY WHO SUFFER FROM
EPILEPSY ARE STILL FORCED TO CHOOSE BETWEEN DISABLING
SEIZURES, AND DEBILITATING SIDE EFFECTS. AND WHILE SCIENCE
HAS BEEN ABLE TO SOLVE MANY OF THE WORLD'S MOST COMMON
DISEASES IN THIS CENTURY - THE 350,000 AMERICANS WITH
INTRACTABLE EPILEPSY SUFFER AS MUCH AS THOSE WHO HAD THIS
CONDITION HUNDREDS, EVEN THOUSANDS OF YEARS AGO.
BEFORE I CAME HERE, I HEARD ABOUT MEGAN, A 4-YEAR-OLD
WHO IS UNABLE TO SPEAK BECAUSE OF THE RAVAGES OF EPILEPSY.
AT ONE POINT SHE HAD OVER 100 SEIZURES A DAY, AND HER
MOTHER SAYS SHE'S TERRIFIED THAT WHEN HER DAUGHTER HAS
ONE OF HER BIG SEIZURES, "THAT WE WON'T BE ABLE TO BRING HER
6
JAN-12-99 08:08 PM
P.08
BACK." HER PARENTS DREAM OF THE DAY "WHEN CHILDREN LIKE
MEGAN CAN LIVE A NORMAL LIFE."
CLEARLY, WE MUST DO MORE TO MAKE THAT DREAM A
REALITY FOR THE MILLIONS OF AMERICANS LIKE MEGAN AND HER
PARENTS WHO SUFFER FROM EPILEPSY IN ALL OF ITS FORMS.
FIRST, WE MUST REDOUBLE OUR EFFORTS TO FIND A CURE. I'VE
ALREADY MENTIONED THE DRAMATIC RISE IN FEDERAL FUNDING
FOR EPILEPSY RESEARCH OVER THE PAST FEW YEARS. AND TODAY,
I'M PLEASED TO ANNOUNCE THAT NEXT YEAR, THE NATIONAL
INSTITUTE OF HEALTH WILL CONVENE THE FIRST EVER
ADMINISTRATION CONFERENCE ON EPILEPSY. MORE THAN 150
EXPERTS FROM AROUND THE COUNTRY WILL PARTICIPATE,
FOCUSING ON HOW TO BEST ALLOCATE THE UNPRECEDENTED
INVESTMENT THIS ADMINISTRATION HAS MADE IN EPILEPSY
RESEARCH.
7
JAN-12-99 08:09 PM
P.09
SECOND, WE MUST DO MORE TO EDUCATE DOCTORS ABOUT
EPILEPSY. WHEN PEOPLE WITH EPILEPSY ARE MIS-DIAGNOSED, THEIR
DISEASE CONTINUES TO DEGENERATE, CAUSING INCREASINGLY
SEVERE EFFECTS ON BRAIN DEVELOPMENT. TO ADDRESS THIS
PROBLEM, THE CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL AND THE AGENCY
FOR HEALTH CARE POLICY RESEARCH ARE LAUNCHING A NEW
INITIATIVE THAT WILL REACH OUT TO THOUSANDS OF DOCTORS,
AND INFORM THEM ABOUT HOW TO MAKE APPROPRIATE EARLY
DIAGNOSES.
THIRD, WE MUST MAKE INFORMATION ABOUT EPILEPSY MORE
ACCESSIBLE. TODAY, I'M ALSO PLEASED TO ANNOUNCE THAT THE
EPILEPSY FOUNDATION OF AMERICA AND iVILLAGE, AN INTERNET
COMPANY, WILL LAUNCH AN INTERNET CHAT ROOM THAT WILL
OFFER CONSUMERS, PATIENTS AND FAMILY MEMBERS A SAFE AND
VALUABLE OPPORTUNITY TO ENGAGE IN LIVE DISCUSSIONS WITH
EPILEPSY SPECIALISTS.
8
JAN-12-99 08:09 PM
P.10
IF WE ARE TO BEAT THIS DISEASE, THEN ALL OF US MUST GET
INVOLVED. WE'VE HEARD TODAY ABOUT SOME OF THE NEW STEPS
BEING TAKEN BY THE GOVERNMENT, BUSINESS, AND THE NON
PROFIT SECTOR. TONIGHT, I WILL BE ATTENDING A FUND RAISER
FOR CURE-- AN ADVOCACY GROUP THAT HAS JUST BEEN FOUNDED
HERE IN CHICAGO TO RAISE MONEY FOR EPILEPSY RESEARCH.
so WHETHER WE'RE INVOLVED IN RAISING PRIVATE FUNDS,
LOBBYING FOR MORE PUBLIC SUPPORT; OR HELPING TO EDUCATE
OUR FRIENDS AND NEIGHBORS - WE CAN ALL HELP BRING THE DAY
CLOSER WHEN THERE IS NO MORE IGNORANCE, AND NO MORE
SUFFERING. THE DAY WHEN WE FINALLY FIND A CURE FOR
EPILEPSY. WHAT BETTER WAY TO CARRY ON DR. MORRELL'S
LEGACY THAN TO COMMIT OURSELVES TO FULFILLING THAT VISION
OF HOPE.
THANK YOU.
9
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/In.univ.5=c12ab4c6920bf5c0785b43c6ac83d26f
Copyright 1999 Chicago Sun-Times, Inc.
Chicago Sun-Times
View Related Topics
January 14, 1999, THURSDAY, Late Sports Final Edition
SECTION: NEWS; Pg. 7
LENGTH: 385 words
HEADLINE: First lady hangs tough during visit to Chicago
SOURCE: JIM FROST
BYLINE: BY SCOTT FORNEK AND ADRIENNE DRELL
BODY:
First lady Hillary Rodham Clinton came to Chicago on Wednesday to help raise awareness about
epilepsy, push for federal funds for after-school programs, mingle with grammar school students and pay
tribute to Michael Jordan.
The busy day came on the eve of her husband's impeachment trial.
"You know something?" she said. "It's hard to walk away, but it's the right thing to do."
Clinton was not talking about the events in Washington. She was talking to third-graders about how to
resolve conflicts peacefully. Her advice came during a visit to an after-school program at Haines
Elementary School in the Armour Square neighborhood.
But the first lady did walk away from reporters' questions about the perjury and obstruction of justice
charges her husband faces.
"I am delighted to be here with all of you to discuss this very important disease," Clinton told
participants in a round-table discussion on epilepsy at Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center,
moments after a reporter shouted a question about the impeachment.
She did weigh in on Jordan, calling it "a sad day for Bulls fans."
Later, in a speech at Haines, Clinton called for an additional $ 400 million for after-school programs.
She said the money would help other cities mimic Chicago's Lighthouse program, which provides a mix
of study help, recreational activities and warm meals to 175,000 students.
But the impeachment hung like a cloud over her visit.
A group of eighth-graders Clinton visited at Haines had plenty to say to reporters before the first lady
entered the room.
"I don't think he should have been impeached, because it's his business what he does behind closed
doors," said Arkesha Green, 14, who lives in Chatham.
Arkesha said she admires how the first lady is handling the situation, although she would do it
differently. "It would have been a divorce quick, fast and hard," she said.
Late Wednesday, Clinton spoke at a benefit at the Drake Hotel that raised more than $ 300,000 for
Citizens United for Research in Epilepsy.
1 of 2
7/13/2000 3:57 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/ln.univ.5=c12ab4c6920bf5c0785b43c6ac83d26f
Referring to Jordan's retirement, she said, "Nobody in this room will ever play professional basketball,
but there are champions among us -- children who suffer but do the best they can every day, and family
members who watch their champion children struggling."
GRAPHIC: Hillary Rodham Clinton chats with students at Haines Elementary. She visited here on the
eve of her husband's impeachment trial.
LANGUAGE: English
LOAD-DATE: January 14, 1999
FOCUSTM
Search: General News;st. luke's medical center and hillary w/2 clinton
To narrow this search, please enter a word or phrase:
FOCUS
Example: House of Representatives
About LEXIS-NEXIS
Terms and Conditions
What's New
Copyright © 2000 LEXIS-NEXIS Group. All rights reserved.
2 of 2
7/13/2000 3:57 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/ln.univ.5=ab741707263f4968fd42113d7662c4af
Copyright 1999 Paddock Publications, Inc.
Chicago Daily Herald
January 14, 1999, Thursday, Cook,Lake
SECTION: News; Pg. 9
LENGTH: 436 words
HEADLINE: First lady lends voice to epilepsy group
BYLINE: Madeleine Doubek Daily Herald Political Editor
BODY: Burr Ridge resident Susan Axelrod's daughter, Lauren, has battled epilepsy for nearly all of her
17 years.
She is developmentally disabled and waits in "extreme terror" for the flurry of seizures that seem to
come in bunches, Axelrod told first lady Hillary Rodham Clinton Wednesday.
Liz Harris, an adult with epilepsy, described going "from job to job because of my seizures. Epilepsy, to
them, sounded like leprosy." Sharon Datro told Clinton, "People would think I was drunk at work,"
when she suffered epileptic episodes.
LeAnn Brigidio Smith's 8-year-old son, Zachary, has never imagined himself a superhero, she said. That
is difficult to do when your entire young life has been spent wearing helmets and face shields to protect
you from hurting yourself.
"How can it be possible in 1999 that there is nothing to help my son?" Smith asked a crowd of hospital
workers and others gathered at Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center to dedicate a new
epilepsy monitoring unit, the Frank Morrell Epilepsy Center. The unit is named for a deceased physician
from the hospital who did pioneering epilepsy research.
Clinton came to Chicago Wednesday to help dedicate the new center and to help raise more than $
300,000 as the featured speaker at the first fund-raiser of Citizens United for Research in Epilepsy
founded by Axelrod, Hanover Park resident Debbie Flader and Nancy Monica of Lake in the Hills.
"We've got to raise public awareness" about epilepsy, Clinton told her audience. "This is the kind of
disease where the stigma and the rejection can actually aggravate the disease."
Clinton tried to raise awareness Wednesday not only with her visit, but also by releasing a new report on
epilepsy which found it affects 2.3 million Americans of all ages. Ten percent of Americans will
experience a seizure in their lifetimes, according to the report sponsored by the Epilepsy Foundation of
America.
Clinton also said the National Institutes of Health will host a first-ever epilepsy conference next year.
The Centers for Disease Control and the Agency for Health Care Policy Research will embark upon a
campaign to better educate doctors about diagnosing the disease quickly. A new Internet chat series also
is being launched and can be accessed at www.ivillage.com or www.efa.org, Clinton said.
"This is a very important issue and we're making progress," Clinton said. "I can only imagine how
difficult it must be to live with those endless what ifs. What if I have a seizure while I'm crossing the
street, or I'm cooking for my family, or I'm holding my baby in my arms."
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
LOAD-DATE: January 15, 1999
1 of 2
7/13/2000 3:58 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/ln.univ.5=f88fc83b717fdf21c0c5a08770005527
Copyright 1999 PR Newswire Association, Inc.
PR Newswire
January 14, 1999, Thursday
SECTION: Financial News
DISTRIBUTION: TO CITY AND MEDICAL EDITORS
LENGTH: 756 words
HEADLINE: National Report Puts Annual Cost of Epilepsy at $12.5 Billion; First Lady Hillary
Rodham Clinton Cites as Cause for National Concern
DATELINE: CHICAGO, Jan. 14
BODY:
The Epilepsy Foundation has issued a special end-of-the-millennium report in which the preliminary
annual national cost of epilepsy is reported to be approximately $12.5 billion. The figure represents the
national cost for 1995 based on direct medical cost information gathered from patient records at two
clinical centers, and indirect costs primarily employment-related -- based on the experience of more
than 1,000 individuals at participating epilepsy centers.
The brief 17-page document, "Epilepsy: Report to the Nation," paints a disturbing picture of the
personal, economic, and medical impact of epilepsy and special burdens the condition poses on its
victims and their loved ones. It is the first report to the nation about the disorder since 1978 when
the temporary Commission for the Control of Epilepsy and Its Consequences, Department of Health
Education and Welfare, issued its findings.
"Epilepsy: Report to the Nation" was released today to coincide with a visit here by First Lady Hillary
Rodham Clinton to dedicate the new epilepsy wing at the Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical
Center. Mrs. Clinton has cited the Foundation report and multibillion dollar cost figure as cause
for national concern for people with the condition.
"It's so important that we bring attention to epilepsy because it affects millions of Americans at great
cost to their families, communities and the nation. We must work to get rid of the stigma that people
with epilepsy face in our society, and to find a cure for those who suffer from the condition," said Mrs.
Clinton.
In releasing the report, Epilepsy Foundation president Jeanne Carpenter, Esq. said, "It's time to go
aggressively on the offensive against this long-neglected condition. Freedom from seizures must become
a national health priority." Carpenter, who has epilepsy and also participated in today's dedication
ceremonies, said further that, "We are extremely gratified that Mrs. Clinton recognizes the importance of
epilepsy as a major national health problem and is promoting increased public awareness and
understanding."
According to the new report, 2.3 million Americans have epilepsy, only about 500,000 of whom are
receiving medical care which successfully controls their seizures. Nearly half, or about one million
patients, are receiving inadequate treatment for their seizures. Even with the increase in new medical and
surgical options for treating epilepsy in recent years, one-fourth of patients, about 600,000, have seizures
that do not respond to available therapies.
"When seizures persist," says the report, "epilepsy is once again as devastating today as it was 100 -- or
1,000 years ago."
"Epilepsy: Report to the Nation" calls for a major national offensive with five main objectives:
-- Making the cure of intractable seizures and all forms of epilepsy a
1 of 2
7/13/2000 3:58 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/In.univ.5=f88fc83b717fdf21c0c5a08770005527
research priority.
-- Ensuring access to specialized care for all people with epilepsy who
need it.
-- Educating the public so that seizure-related stigma and discrimination
are eliminated.
-- Providing employment, special education, and other targeted programs so
that people with epilepsy are fully integrated into society.
-- Developing new strategies to prevent epilepsy.
The report states that seizures and epilepsy develop in 181,000 Americans
of all ages each year, and that epilepsy strikes most cruelly against the
young and the very old. The condition affects all aspects of life and wreaks
havoc on family life and employment prospects.
"Epilepsy: Report to the Nation" draws on information from a variety of
scientific studies, among them the Epilepsy Foundation's National Cost of
Epilepsy Study currently in progress and an as yet unpublished large
community-based survey of quality of life and concerns of people with
epilepsy. The full text of the report can be downloaded from the
organization's web site, news and publications section, at www.efa.org.
The Epilepsy Foundation is the national non-profit health organization
that supports research, advocacy, education and service for people with
epilepsy and their families. Direct services in the local community are
provided by the Epilepsy Foundation of Los Angeles, Orange, San Bernardino and
Ventura Counties (1-800-564-0445). The national office is based in Landover,
MD.
SOURCE Epilepsy Foundation
CONTACT: Peter Van Haverbeke of the Epilepsy Foundation, 800-470-1655, ext. 641, or Local
Epilepsy Foundation, 800-564-0445, ext. 11
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
LOAD-DATE: January 15, 1999
FOCUSTM
Search: General News;st. luke's medical center and hillary w/2 clinton
To narrow this search, please enter a word or phrase:
FOCUS
Example: House of Representatives
About LEXIS-NEXIS
Terms and Conditions
What's New
Copyright © 2000 LEXIS-NEXIS Group. All rights reserved.
2 of 2
7/13/2000 3:58 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/ln.univ.5=7cea9a8268cafdffd182ebe1d7d4baad
Copyright 1999 Chattanooga Publishing Company
Chattanooga Times / Chattanooga Free Press
January 17, 1999, Sunday
SECTION: LIFESTYLE; Pg. G3
LENGTH: 759 words
HEADLINE: First Lady Advocates Epilepsy Research Funding
BYLINE: HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
BODY:
Not long ago, I had the opportunity to catch up with an old friend from Chicago. In the course of the
conversation, he told me about his daughter, Lauren. Although Lauren was a happy, healthy baby at
birth, she began to have seizures at the age of 7 months. Seventeen years later, the seizures continue, the
cause has never been identified, and Lauren's development has been irrevocably delayed. She will never
live independently and will require lifelong supervision and support.
As her father spoke, I could see and hear the devastating impact Lauren's epilepsy has had, not only on
her own life but also on her entire family.
When I heard Lauren's story, I was determined to learn more about this condition and bolster this
administration's efforts to improve treatment and find a cure.
Nearly 200,000 Americans are diagnosed with epilepsy each year. Current treatments control symptoms
in most of their cases. Yet the word epilepsy still provokes profound fear and misunderstanding.
Epilepsy is a chronic brain disorder characterized by spontaneous, recurrent seizures that range from
brief lapses in attention to prolonged losses of consciousness with convulsions. It affects more than 2
million Americans, one out of every 100. Of these, 300,000 are children.
Head injuries, brain tumors, stroke, lead poisoning, genetic conditions and infectious illnesses can cause
epilepsy. But in more than half of all cases like Lauren's -- no explanation is ever found.
According to a new report, "Epilepsy: A Report to the Nation," sponsored by the Epilepsy Foundation
of America, anti-seizure drugs and other forms of treatment can control or eliminate seizures in 75
percent of those affected. These people live nearly normal lives lives that can be both personally and
professionally fulfilling. But even they never escape the uncertainty or the potential social stigma that
comes out of ignorance - -- a stigma that can crush the spirit as surely as the disorder debilitates the body
and the brain.
Tragically, though, for the nearly 600,000 like Lauren, the disorder is intractable. Drugs, diet, surgery
and other treatments just don't bring their seizures under control.
One of the most heartbreaking aspects of epilepsy is the toll it takes on children. Seizures in early
childhood often produce developmental delays and brain damage that can lead to a lifetime of
dependence and extraordinary costs. Children with epilepsy are at special risk for learning problems.
They fall behind in reading, language development and general knowledge. Children who have frequent
seizures can't even go to school. Perhaps worst of all, they live in constant fear of their next seizure.
If these children are ever to live the normal, healthy and happy lives they deserve, we must dedicate
ourselves to finding a cure now.
1 of 2
7/13/2000 4:03 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/In.univ.5=7cea9a8268cafdffd182ebe1d7d4baad
I'm pleased that the president's budget for this year includes a 14 percent expansion for the National
Institutes of Health, the largest funding increase ever. Of this, an unprecedented $76 million is for
epilepsy research alone. But we must still do more.
Next year, NIH researchers will convene the first administration conference on epilepsy, bringing
together more than 150 experts and members of the public focused on finding a cure. In addition, the
Centers for Disease Control and the Agency for Health Care Policy Research together will launch a
campaign to educate medical practitioners about the critical need for early and accurate diagnosis.
I have heard from many families around the country who have been touched by epilepsy. The message
is the same: More research dollars are critical if we are to devise innovative, safe and effective
treatments or find a cure. No one has said it better than the parents of 12-year-old Philip Gattone, whose
seizures ceased following a combination of successful surgery and drug therapy. They wrote:
"Today, Philip plays sports, participates in school activities and clubs, and loves learning. He has friends
that care about him. He is our hero.
"There are so many children that need help. The fight for a cure is a daily battle, and it is real. It is a
fight that must be won. Only research and new treatments will help these special families achieve their
dreams of recovery from epilepsy."
For more information on epilepsy, visit the Epilepsy Foundation of America at www.efa.org.
To find out more about Hillary Rodham Clinton and read her past columns, visit the Creators Syndicate
web page at www.creators.com.
c. 1999 Creators Syndicate Inc.
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
LOAD-DATE: January 25, 1999
FOCUSTM
Search: General News;epilepsy and hillary w/2 clinton
To narrow this search, please enter a word or phrase:
FOCUS
Example: House of Representatives
About LEXIS-NEXIS
Terms and Conditions
What's New
Copyright © 2000 LEXIS-NEXIS Group. All rights reserved.
2 of 2
7/13/2000 4:03 PM
Clinton Presidential Records
Digital Records Marker
This is not a presidential record. This is used as an administrative
marker by the William J. Clinton Presidential Library Staff.
This marker identifies the place of a tabbed divider. Given our
digitization capabilities, we are sometimes unable to adequately
scan such dividers. The title from the original document is
indicated below.
1/22/99 NARAL
Divider Title:
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
FRIDAY, JANUARY 22, 1999
FINAL
WASHINGTON, D.C.
NARAL LUNCHEON
ADVANCE:
MICHELLE KREISS
301/384-7118
PHONE
WHCA PAGER
#4350
NARAL PRESS
ADVANCE:
GEORGE SHELTON
202/778-0740
PHONE
STATE DEPARTMENT
ADVANCE:
CHARLIE DUNCAN
202/647-4820
PHONE
SCHEDULER:
WENDY ARENDS
202/456-7007
PHONE
202/456-5340
FAX
202/518-8209
HOME
WHCA PAGER
#4781
PREV RON
The White House
-
10:00am-
MEETING with Family Planning Advocates
10:45am
Map Room
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
FORMAT:
-
The Vice President makes welcoming remarks
and introduces the First Lady.
-
The First Lady makes brief remarks and opens
up the meeting for discussion.
-
Upon conclusion, the First Lady departs.
PARTICIPANTS: 25 guests
10:50am-
DROP-BY with Women from Northern Ireland
11:05am
Diplomatic Reception Room
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
PARTICIPANTS: 30 guests
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
FRIDAY, JANUARY 22, 1999
PAGE 2
11:10am-
DOWN TIME
12:30pm
12:30pm-
DROP-BY with Close-Up Students
12:45pm
Diplomatic Reception Room
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
PARTICIPANTS: 28 guests
12:45pm
DEPART South Portico
VIA Motorcade
EN ROUTE Omni Shoreham
[Drive time: 15 minutes]
1:00pm
ARRIVE Omni Shoreham Hotel
2500 Calvert Street, NW
Washington, D.C.
GREETERS:
Jose Campo, General Manager
David Cooper, Banquet Manager
Jim Taylor, Chief of Security
1:05pm-
REMARKS to NARAL's 33rd Anniversary Celebration
1:35pm
Grand Ballroom
Omni Shoreham Hotel
HRC Hold: Backstage sitting area
Phone: 202/756-5290
Fax: 202/756-5179
Staff Hold: Backstage sitting area
OPEN PRESS/WH PHOTO
FORMAT:
-
Kate Michelman, President, NARAL, makes
introductory remarks and introduces the
First Lady onto stage.
-
The First Lady makes remarks.
-
Upon conclusion, the First Lady has the
option to work a ropeline.
PARTICIPANTS: 700-750 guests
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
FRIDAY, JANUARY 22, 1999
PAGE 3
1:35pm-
MEET AND GREET
1:45pm
Regency Hold
Omni Shoreham Hotel
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
PARTICIPANTS: 16 guests
1: 45pm
DEPART Omni Shoreham
VIA Motorcade
EN ROUTE State Department
[Drive time: 15 minutes]
2: 00pm
ARRIVE State Department
GREETER:
Mel French, Chief of Protocol
2: 00pm-
PRIVATE LUNCH
2:55pm
Secretary Albright's Office, 7th Floor
State Department
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
2: 55pm
PROCEED upstairs
VIA Elevator
3: 00pm-
INTERAGENCY COUNCIL ON WOMEN MEETING
4: 00pm
Jefferson Room, 8th Floor
State Department
HRC Hold: Secretary Albright's Office
Phone: 202/647-5548
CLOSED PRESS/WH PHOTO
FORMAT:
-
Secretary Madeleine Albright, Council Chair,
makes welcoming remarks and introduces
Theresa Loar, Director, President's
Interagency Council on Women and Senior
Coordinator for International Women's Issues.
-
Theresa Loar makes remarks.
-
Secretary Albright introduces Ambassador
Craig Johnstone, Director, Office of
Resources, Plans and Policy.
SCHEDULE FOR HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON
FRIDAY, JANUARY 22, 1999
PAGE 4
-
Craig Johnstone makes remarks.
-
Secretary Albright introduces Secretary
Donna Shalala.
-
Secretary Shalala makes remarks.
-
Secretary Albright introduces Nancy Hendry,
General Counsel, Peace Corps.
-
Nancy Hendry makes remarks.
-
Secretary Albright introduces Kitty Higgins,
Deputy Secretary, Department of Labor.
-
Kitty Higgins makes remarks.
-
Secretary Albright introduces the First Lady.
-
The First Lady makes remarks.
-
Upon conclusion, Secretary Albright makes
closing remarks.
-
The First Lady departs.
PARTICIPANTS: 27 participants
4:05pm
DEPART State Department
VIA Motorcade
EN ROUTE South Portico
[Drive time: 10 minutes]
4: 15pm
ARRIVE South Portico
RON
The White House
January 21, 1999
NARAL 30th ANNIVERSARY CELEBRATION
DATE:
Friday, January 22
TIME:
1:05 pm - 1:35 pm
LOCATION:
Omni Shoreham Hotel
Washington, D.C.
FROM:
Brenda Costello and
Natasha McMahan
I.
PURPOSE
To deliver the keynote address at NARAL's 30th anniversary celebration, and to highlight
the Administration's commitment to finding common ground in order to make abortion
safe, legal, and rare.
II.
BACKGROUND
Overview
The event will highlight National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League's
(NARAL's) thirty-year history of advocacy on behalf of a woman's freedom to choose and
the 26th annual recognition of the landmark decision in Roe V. Wade, the Supreme Court
decision legalizing abortion. Friday's luncheon will take place at Omni Shoreham Hotel
in Washington. There will be 700-750 guests who will be from NARAL and its affiliate
organizations. In addition, the luncheon will honor the memory of Dr. Barnett Slepian, the
Buffalo physician, murdered in his home last October, along with other physicians and
health care professionals who uphold the freedom to choose despite the climate of fear and
intimidation.
National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League (NARAL)
NARAL has a grassroots network of 30 state affiliates and 500,000 members nationwide.
NARAL's work is divided among three organizations, 1) NARAL, INC., which works
through the political system to effect reproductive health policy; 2) NARAL-PAC, which
is the political action committee and driving force behind the election of many pro-choice
candidates, and 3) The NARAL Foundation, which supports the in-depth research and
legal work of the organization. Since 1969, the National Abortion and Reproductive Rights
Action League (NARAL) and its affiliates have been the leading force in the fight for
reproductive freedom in America.
Serving as the political arm of the pro-choice movement, NARAL has been involved in
several key races throughout the country to elect pro-choice candidates to Congress. While
advocating for programs that reduce unintended pregnancy and make abortion less
necessary, NARAL has pursued its mission of securing and protecting the freedom to
choose. NARAL advocates that the freedom to make personal decisions without
governmental interference is one of the most fundamental principles on which our nation
was founded. NARAL is leading the way to promote policies that will make abortion less
necessary.
NARAL's legislative efforts played a vital role in passing the Freedom of Access to Clinic
Entrances Act, which prohibits unlawful anti-choice violence and harassment that
jeopardizes access to abortion services. In addition, NARAL has been involved in recent
initiatives such as educating Americans, electing pro-choice candidates and advocates for
pro-choice legislation to secure the freedom to choose, and defending reproductive choice
from assaults by the radical right. NARAL is committed to reducing teenage pregnancy
and sexually transmitted disease. In a paper presented at the American Enterprise Institute
for Public Policy Research Conference on Teenage Sexual Activity and Contraceptive Use,
statistics revealed that between 1990 and 1995, the percentage of teen girls who had ever
had sexual intercourse declined by five percent, marking the first decline in more than 20
years, yet the rates of teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted disease among teens
remains unacceptably high.
Format
Actress Dana Delany and Penelope Ann Miller will make their remarks. Next, Kate
Michelman, President of NARAL, will make introductory remarks and introduce you.
Upon conclusion of your remarks, you have the option to work a ropeline. There will be
700-750 guests in attendance, including many members of Congress and the
Administration (list attached).
III.
PARTICIPANTS
Meet and Greet
-Kate Michelman, President, NARAL
-Susie Gelman, Co-Chair of Event
-Selwa "Lucky" Roosevelt, Co-Chair of Event
-Michael Gelman, Principal and Founder of Washington-based Accounting Firm
-Mrs. Lynn Slepian, widow of slain provider, Dr. Barnett Slepian
-Marilyn Buckham, Executive Director of the Buffalo Women's Clinic
-Vicki Saporta, Executive Director, National Abortion Federation
-Nancy Silverman, NARAL Foundation Board Member and New York Philanthropist
-Roselyne Swig, Philanthropist and Community Activist
-Candy Cox, Senior Vice President, DDB/Elgin Worldwide
-Rick Gross, NARAL Board Member, Washington Attorney, Democratic Party Fundraiser
(wife Roberta, Inspector General, NASA)
-Susan McLane, NARAL Board Member, Women's Campaign Fund
-Dana Delany, actress
-Penelope Ann Miller, actress
-Morris Wortman, M.D., OB-GYN
-Lisa Perry, New York Philanthropist
Program
-Kate Michelman, President, NARAL
-The First Lady
IV.
SEQUENCE OF EVENTS
Kate Michelman will make introductory remarks and introduces the First Lady
onto stage.
The First Lady makes remarks.
Upon conclusion the First Lady has the option to work a ropeline.
V.
PRESS
Open press.
VI. REMARKS
Provided by Laura Schiller.
JAN-21-99 THU 05:17 PM
NARAL LUNCHEON - Full Program
P.02
Friday, January 22, 1999
445
11:30 am-noon
VIP Reception
11:30 am
Harpist plays in Reception Area
11:50 am
Begin Calls for Seating
All courses pre-set on table
NOON
Voice-over intros Co-Chairs, The Honorable Selwa Lucky
Roosevelt and Susie Gelman
Co-Chairs intro Kate Michelman
12:03 pm
Kate Michelman delivers Opening Remarks
12:10 pm
vo introduces Dana Delany for
Wall of Honor segment
12:13 pm
15-minute Program Break for Luncheon
12:28 pm
Kate Michelman delivers NARAL's history retrospective
Ending with 60-second "I Believe" video
12:43 pm
vo intros Penelope Ann Miller for
Messages Segment
12:48 pm
vo intros Reverend Carlton Veazey for
Moment of Silence
12:51 pm
vo intros Dr. Ralph Hale and Dr. John Choate of ACOG,
accompanied by Kate Michelman for
Slepian Award Segment:
ACOG Remarks (5 minutes)
Award Presentation to Mrs. Slepian
1:01 pm
Kate Michelman returns to podium
Asks Dr. Wortman to stand for recognition
Kate introduces First Lady Hillary Rodham Clinton
1:10 pm
Mrs. Clinton delivers Keynote Address
1:35 pm
Kate thanks audience
NARAL Publications -- TEENS IN CRI...ategy to Protect Adolescent Health
http://www.naral.org/publications/teensincrisis.html
NARAL
Promoting Reproductive Choices
Publications
TEENS IN CRISIS:
A Comprehensive Strategy to Protect Adolescent Health
National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League (NARAL/The NARAL
Foundation) Kate Michelman, President
Paper presented at the American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research
Conference on Teenage Sexual Activity and Contraceptive Use: An Update May 1, 1998
Recent surveys identify several positive trends concerning teenage sexual activity and
contraceptive use. Between 1990 and 1995, the percentage of teen girls who had ever had
sexual intercourse declined by five percent -- marking the first decline in more than 20
Source
years.1 In 1995, 78 percent of teen girls used contraception at first intercourse as compared
to 65 percent in 1988 and 48 percent in 1982.2 In addition, the teen pregnancy, birth and
abortion rates have been declining.3
Although these findings are notable, the U.S. continues to face an adolescent reproductive
health crisis. The rates of teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted disease (STD) and
human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infections among teens remain unacceptably high.
More teens may be using contraception at first intercourse; however, teens continue to fail
to use contraception consistently or appropriately. Moreover, the frequency of unwanted
sexual intercourse among teen girls is alarming.
In searching for solutions to this adolescent reproductive health crisis, some individuals and
groups have focused on abstinence-only education. An emphasis on abstinence-only
education is misplaced. Abstinence education is an essential part of sexuality education, but
abstinence should not be the only lesson taught. Sexuality education should teach teens to
deal with peer pressure and pressure from partners to engage in sexual activity, but teens
should also learn how to protect themselves if they do become sexually active.
Rather than focusing on abstinence-only education, the U.S. must demonstrate a national
commitment to remedying this adolescent crisis through a multi-pronged approach. Such an
approach would invest in the development of young women by valuing their lives, inspiring
them to seek better futures, enhancing self-sufficiency, preparing them for higher education,
providing job training and ensuring access to health care. We need to embark on a
campaign to increase family planning funding, improve and expand access to
contraceptives, and increase awareness of and access to emergency contraceptives. Finally,
we must launch a national effort to require comprehensive sexuality education throughout
our primary and secondary schools. This approach would protect teens by promoting
abstinence while simultaneously providing teens with the contraceptive and STD/HIV
prevention information they need to make responsible decisions if and when they become
sexually active.
I. America is Facing a Crisis in Adolescent Reproductive Health.
Despite the positive trends identified in the 1995 National Survey of Family Growth and
1995 National Survey of Adolescent Males, the U.S. continues to face a crisis in adolescent
reproductive health. Although some statistics demonstrate a decline in teen sexual activity,
1 of 11
1/21/99 1:55 PM
PAGE 12
LEVEL 1 - 7 OF 50 STORIES
Copyright 1998 The New York Times Company
The New York Times
October 26, 1998, Monday, Late Edition - Final
SECTION: Section A; Page 1; Column 6; Metropolitan Desk
LENGTH: 1148 words
HEADLINE: Beliefs Pushed Doctor to Keep Abortion Role
BYLINE: By JOSEPH BERGER
DATELINE: AMHERST, N.Y., Oct. 25
BODY:
Some of those who knew him said today that Dr. Barnett A: Slepian continued
to perform abortions in the face of death threats because he had what one friend
called "a stubborn kind of courage."
Others said he persisted not for ideological reasons but because he was
simply a conscientious doctor who wanted to practice the full range of
gynecological medicine that he had been trained in, even if that included the
procedures that many in the aggressive anti-abortion movement in western New
York equated with murder.
Having babies come into the world was his life," said Ellen Fink, a
ytime friend. "But he performed abortions because he believed it was a
woman's legal right to choose."
Dr. Slepian, a 52-year-old gynecologist and obstetrician who lived in this
suburb of Buffalo, was shot fatally in the back Friday night as he stood in his
kitchen chatting with his wife, Lynne, and son Andrew. He had just returned from
synagogue where he had gone to mark the yahrzeit, or anniversary, of his
father's death.
Today, his friends, patients and relatives were heartsick at his murder, but
also fearful to speak about it because the sniper who lay in wait in the woods
behind Dr. Slepian's house and shot him with a high-powered rifle through an
undraped window was at large. Still, a few took time to talk to reporters
because, they said, they wanted to make sure the man they knew was portrayed not
as a pro-abortion zealot, but as a well-rounded doctor, father and husband.
Dr. Slepian, who as a young man was so determined to become a doctor that he
studied medicine in Spanish in Guadalajara, Mexico, when American schools would
not accept him, was a person who prized his time with his four sons: Andrew, 15;
Brian, 13; Michael, 10, and Philip, 7. He was a devoted jogger, having run a
marathon, and was, one friend said, "a health nut" who carefully watched such
demons as cholesterol and salt. He belonged to a Reform synagogue, Temple Beth
Am.
He was painfully aware that he and his family could be the target of a fierce
ent of abortions and took precautions. In the last five years, there had
PAGE
13
The New York Times, October 26, 1998
b
four attacks -- none fatal -- against doctors in the United States-Canadian
r region, and two abortion doctors had been killed in other parts of the
ed States. As recently as Friday morning, Dr. Slepian received a two-page
ning from the downtown Buffalo clinic where he worked, urging him to beware
of sniper attacks.
"Do not assume that you are safe once you are at home,' the warning said.
"Close the drapes in your house so you are not visible from outside.'
In fact, Dr. Slepian often kept the blinds drawn at home and he called the
police whenever he received a death threat. Neighbors said there were a number
of periods when an Amherst patrol car was stationed outside Dr. Slepian's
two-story brick colonial in a well-to-do enclave here.
But he refused to change his approach to medicine, even when his friends
warned him some anti-abortion protesters would view his death as a "coup" that
would virtually eliminate poor people's access to abortion in the Buffalo area.
"He knew the risks well," said Glenn Edward Murray, who was Dr. Slepian's
lawyer and longtime friend. "We had discussed the fatal dangers he placed
himself in by continuing to perform abortions. We discussed security measures.
He was dedicated to providing women with safe and legal abortions and was
unwilling to abandon his clients because of threats."
Mr. Murray, who talked in carefully measured tones but still found himself
choked with emotion, said that Dr. Slepian, as a young intern and resident in
the Buffalo area, had been taught by mentors how dangerous and sometimes fatal
=
alley" abortions performed by bad practitioners or by the women themselves
be. Even as he had four children of his own, he was determined that he
1d perform abortions for women who needed them, no matter how poor they were.
So in addition to a private practice he had in this leafy suburban town in
the prairie-flat countryside east of Buffalo, Dr. Slepian chose to work
regularly at a clinic in downtown Buffalo that had been singled out by
protesters and was the last of its kind in Buffalo -- Buffalo GYN Women's
Services. Now, that clinic has been left without a doctor.
His wife, Lynne, a trained nurse who stayed home in recent years to raise
their sons, was as resolute as he was in not letting the protesters stop her
husband from practicing medicine as he saw fit.
Dr. Slepian, a slender, wiry man with the bearded face of a scholar, was born
in Cambridge, Mass., into a lower-middle-class family of four children, each of
whom went on to considerable accomplishment as an adult. One of his two
brothers, Jacob, is also a doctor, specializing in ear, nose and throat
medicine.
Dr. Slepian, whom friends called Bart, was raised in Rochester, N.Y.,
attended college at the University of Denver in Colorado and received his
medical degree from the Autonomous University of Guadalajara. A residency at the
State University of New York at Buffalo brought him to this' area 20 years ago,
and he stayed.
Although some gynecologists will quietly perform abortions for their longtime
g patients, Dr. Slepian was one of only a few doctors in western New York
PAGE 14
The New York Times, October 26, 1998
were willing to perform abortions openly at public clinics. Nonetheless, his
ds said, he counseled women seeking abortion to consider alternatives like
cion.
In 1988, protesters taunted him outside his home on Hanukkah. When he emerged
carrying a baseball bat, a clash ensued and Dr. Slepian was eventually charged
with a misdemeanor for damaging a protester's vehicle. In 1992 he again became a
target in a coordinated protest by 200 picketers from the anti-abortion group
Operation Rescue that was known as "Spring of Life."
In recent years, patients who visited him at the downtown clinic or his
private office in Amherst periodically endured shouts from picketers of "You're
murdering your babies." A longtime patient who asked that she be identified only
as Karen said that Dr. Slepian frequently apologized for the protesters'
disruptions. Still, Karen said she knew him mainly as a devoted gynecologist who
saw her through infertility treatments and delivered her daughter.
"He wasn't supposed to be there for the delivery but he came anyway and when
I asked him, 'What are you doing here,' he said, 'I wouldn't miss it for the
world.' " Similarly, she said, he went out of his way to visit another patient
when she was in the hospital for a non-gynecological ailment. "I thought I'd
come over to have donuts and coffee with you when I heard you were in the
hospital," Karen heard that he told the friend.
"He was the type of man," Karen said, "that I would put my life in his hands
and not question what he had to say. And I can't say that about all doctors."
HIC: Photos: Dr. Barnett A. Slepian was one of Buffalo's last abortion
rs. (Associated Press); Mourners left flowers and a sign yesterday at the
erst, N.Y., clinic of Dr. Barnett A. Slepian, an abortion doctor who was
siain Friday. (Michael J. Okoniewski for The New York Times) (pg. B10)
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
LOAD-DATE: October 26, 1998
PAGE
4
LEVEL 1 - 3 OF 50 STORIES
Copyright 1998 The New York Times Company
The New York Times
October 27, 1998, Tuesday, Late Edition - Final
SECTION: Section B; Page 1; Column 2; Metropolitan Desk
LENGTH: 1265 words
HEADLINE: Slain Physician Eulogized as Caring Man
BYLINE: By JOSEPH BERGER
DATELINE: AMHERST, N.Y., Oct. 26
BODY:
Alan Dickison went to the funeral of Dr. Barnett A. Slepian this afternoon
carrying his two towheaded children, Connor, 4, and Kelsey, 2, a boy and girl
whom Dr. Slepian had delivered.
"This man was about children," he said, brandishing the two children toward a
cluster of reporters. "This man was not about abortions."
As the Federal Bureau of Investigation announced a $100,000 reward in its
investigation of Dr. Slepian's slaying on Friday and the abortion clinic where
r ad worked vowed to be open for business on Tuesday morning, Dr. Slepian was
jized today by a brother and a niece and, in a letter, from President
iton as a kind and dedicated physician who did not let threats and protests
stop him from fulfilling what he regarded as his duty to care for women, no
matter what their needs.
Yet, among the hundreds of mourners who spilled out from a suburban funeral
home here, there were many patients like the Dickison family who resented Dr.
Slepian's description in many television and newspaper accounts as merely an
"abortion doctor." Such a depiction, they said, was feeding into the agenda of
the fierce enemies of abortion.
"They raise the stakes and then some extremist shoots him in the back in the
middle of the night," said Mr. Dickison, a registered nurse.
Dr. Slepian, he said, was a doctor who cared for women through pregnancy,
infertility, childbirth and menopause. His murder, he and other mourners said,
has deprived the Buffalo area of a doctor who brought hundreds of babies into
the world and attended to women who for medical or personal reasons could not
carry an embryo to term.
Marcia Sperduti, weeping as she walked toward the funeral home, told how
Dr. Slepian had saved her son's life by rushing to perform a Caesarean on her
when her son's umbilical cord became knotted in the womb.
"Thank God I'm not having any more children, because Dr. Slepian is not alive
to deliver them, she said.
PAGE
5
The New York Times, October 27, 1998
`s Dr. Slepian's coffin was taken away for burial, the F.B.I. announced it
ffering a $100,000 reward for information leading to the capture of his
er. But law enforcement officials who spoke on the condition of anonymity
a that so far, little information had been developed about the killer -- what
he or she looked like or what car was used in the getaway. Ballistics tests have
not yet been completed on the bullet, which was fired by a sniper with a
high-powered rifle from a wooded field behind Dr. Slepian's home.
Officials said they were theorizing that this slaying was connected to four
other sniper attacks since 1994 on doctors who performed abortions. Three
attacks took place in Canada and one in Rochester, and there were injuries,
though none of those doctors was killed. The F.B.I. and the Amherst Police
Department have spoken to Canadian investigators about Friday's shooting.
Dr. Slepian, 52, who had a private practice here, but also was the primary
doctor at the only abortion clinic in downtown Buffalo, was shot in the back on
Friday night as he stood chatting with his wife, Lynne, and 15-year-old son,
Andrew, in the kitchen of their Amherst home. The killer had fired his
high-powered rifle at an undraped window.
At a news conference, John B. Askey, the Chief of Police of Amherst, revealed
that six hours before Dr. Slepian was killed, his wife had called the police to
inform them of a fax from the National Abortion Federation warning its 350
member clinics in the United States and Canada of the possibility of impending
assaults because of the approach of Nov. 11.
The holiday, known as Veterans Day in the United States, is Remembrance Day
"anada, and this day to remember war dead has been embraced by abortion
ents as a memorial day. The sniper shootings of the three Canadian doctors
the one American took place in the days leading up to Nov. 11.
Chief Askey said that Mrs. Slepian did not ask that a patrol car be stationed
at the house, and the police did not send one. Asked if he regretted not doing
so, he said: "I regret that Dr. Slepian is dead."
Officials at Buffalo GYN Womenservices, the clinic where Dr. Slepian worked
15 to 24 hours a week performing abortions for largely poor and low-wage
clients, said today that they had received offers from more than a half-dozen
doctors around the country offering to take over Dr. Slepian's duties. Melinda
Dubois, assistant director, said she expected the four-day-a week clinic, the
only abortion clinic in western New York, to resume operations on Tuesday.
"There are so many doctors that respected Bart," she said, using Dr.
Slepian's nickname, "that they'd be willing to come into this area to take care
of our patients.'
At the same time, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan announced in Washington
that any doctors who volunteered to work at the clinic would receive
round-the-clock protection from the United States Marshals' Service.
The Senator said marshals, assigned by John P. McCaffrey, chief of the
western New York district, were being used to assure women seeking abortions a
constitutional protection. The last time he said he could remember marshals'
serving in a similar role was during the civil rights era of the 1960's.
PAGE
6
The New York Times, October 27, 1998
"This is a constitutionally protected medical procedure and there is a
rist movement trying to make it impossible," Senator Moynihan said in a
phone interview. "And they murder people and they have Web sites that list
tors who perform abortions and every so often a name is crossed off."
The funeral drew an overflow turnout that included Dr. Slepian's patients and
medical colleagues, as well as his family and friends and a sprinkling of
abortion-rights supporters from as far away as Atlanta.
A half-dozen Amherst police officers controlled traffic at the funeral and
kept reporters out, but there was no indication of a heavy police presence to
guard against a sniper.
The Slepian family asked that the funeral be private, but Glenn Edward
Murray, a friend of Dr. Slepian's and his personal lawyer, and others who
attended described it afterward.
Rabbi Michael L. Feshbach, rabbi of Dr. Slepian's synagogue, Temple Beth Am,
read a three-paragraph letter President Clinton wrote to Mrs. Slepian and her
four children, Andrew, 15, Brian, 13, Michael 10, and Philip, 7, that began with
the words: "Hillary and I were deeply saddened to learn of your husband's tragic
death."
"Violence in our society hurts us all, but few have to endure its effects so
personally," the President wrote. "This cowardly and brutal act has robbed your
family of a beloved husband and devoted father and it has robbed your community
of a skilled doctor and cherished friend. In the face of threats, taunts and
V 'ence, Barnett Slepian refused to abandon the patients who trusted him and
amilies who needed his help."
Dr. Slepian's niece, Amanda Robb, told how Dr. Slepian became like a father
to her after the death of her own father, providing financial and emotional
support even as he was struggling to build his medical career.
Before beginning his eulogy recalling Dr. Slepian's dedication, his older
brother, Jacob, an ear, nose and throat specialist in Connecticut, told a story
that highlighted his brother's dry sense of humor.
He recalled how his brother had once had a bird, perhaps a macaw. When he
learned that the bird could live to be as old as 80, he joked that he would
train the bird to deliver his eulogy. Jacob Slepian said the bird and his
brother had parted ways at some point, but he would try to do as well as the
bird would have done.
GRAPHIC: Photos: Alan Dickison with his children at services for Dr. Barnett A.
Slepian yesterday. (Michael J. Okoniewski for The New York Times) (pg. B1);
Mourners leaving services for Dr. Barnett A. Slepian yesterday. "This man was
about children,' one said. "This man was not about abortions." (Michael J.
Okoniewski for The New York Times) (pg. B7)
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
LOAD-DATE: October 27, 1998
NARAL Press Release ⑉ October 28, 1998
http://www.naral.org/publications/press/98oct/102898.html
NARAL
Publications
Promoting Reproductive Choices
PRESS RELEASES & STATEMENTS
STATEMENT OF KATE MICHELMAN
AT THE VIGIL FOR DR. SLEPIAN
October 28, 1998
I knew Dr. Slepian. I knew this remarkable man. I knew of his commitment to his
patients and of his dedication to our cause. I knew of his devotion to the
reproductive health and freedom of American women. And I knew of his
determination and courage.
Dr. Slepian was a victim of serious threats for years and he never backed down. Not
once did he think of ending his practice or abandoning the women who relied on
him SO much. Dr. Slepian believed deeply in the constitutional right of women to
choose and he rightly believed that he was a force that enabled women to exercise
that right with dignity and in safety.
A dedicated physician, a true ally in the fight for women's reproductive health, a
husband, a father, and a dear friend. Dr. Slepian will be sorely missed.
Dr. Slepian would want his passing should serve a much higher purpose. So let us
honor him with renewed commitment to the pro-choice values he so perfectly
embodied. Let us mark his passing with renewed courage to fight for women's
reproductive health and the right of women to choose - free from government
interference - free from harassment - free from intimidation - and free from
violence.
Coming on the heels of the brutal death of Matthew Shepard, the shocking murder
of Dr. Slepian reflects a deeply disturbing and increasingly dangerous trend of
intolerance, exclusion, hatred and disdain for the rule of law. Both Dr. Slepian and
Matthew Shepard were victims of those who use violence to express their
opposition to social progress. This reign of terror must be stopped.
Increasingly, anti-choice groups and their leaders are using sensationalized rhetoric
and incendiary statements to characterize abortion. They have labeled doctors as
murders, posted their names on "wanted" signs and on the Internet, and even gone so
far a to publicly justify the murder of these men.
But it is time for that to change. Those who oppose abortion must take
responsibility for their role in creating a climate where the zealous feel justified in
committing acts of violence. They must acknowledge and admit that their words
drive unrestrained factions of their movements to commit these horrific acts.
Denials and condemnations no longer suffice. They must stop referring to abortion
as murder. And they must stop referring to doctors as murderers.
These are acts of terrorism, pure and simple, and this country must condemn them
as such. Our outrage should boil over and spill into the streets. Law enforcement,
legislators, the medical community, pro-choice and anti-choice Americans alike
must rise up and strike back at the heart of these criminals - not with violence, but
with swift justice and meaningful action.
1 of 2
1/21/99 1:24 PM
NARAL Press Release - October 28, 1998
http://www.naral.org/publications/press/98oct/102898.html
Those who would do away with the Roe have become emboldened - have become
smarter - have become a very powerful force in America - with a reach that is
broader and deeper than we could ever have imagined just four years ago with the
congressional landslide election of 1994. The freedom to choose is no longer safe
and the time for action is now.
In less than two weeks we must make choices at the polls. Let bring our outrage at
these killings into the voting booth with us. Let us bring a renewed commitment to
our cause. On November 3rd, I ask you to step up to our opponents and do as they
preach - vote your own values. Dig deep into who we are as a people - into what we
want for our children - into the freedoms SO hard won, and now at risk.
If we fail to rally our people into action, then our opponents - and the murderer of
Dr. Slepian will have won. If we fail to rally to our own cause, we will have failed
ourselves - and we will fail our future.
Let us honor Dr. Slepian with action, not tears.
home
search
index
what's new
feedback
join
Copyright 1998, National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League
2 of 2
1/21/99 1:24 PM
First Lady's Speeches
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990122.htm
First Lady Hillary Rodham Clinton
Remarks at NARAL Anniversary Luncheon
Washington, D.C.
January 22, 1999
Thank you. I am honored to be here with all of you on NARAL's 30th anniversary to
celebrate the voices you have raised, the battles you have waged, and the victories won on
behalf of women around the world.
For 30 years, every step forward for women's reproductive health in America has had one
thing in common: the leadership of the people in this room. So I wanted to come this
afternoon for many reasons, but I want to start by thanking all of you for what you do every
day for the rights and health of women and families. I want to thank my dear friend,
Secretary Shalala, Nancy Rubin, former and present members of Congress, Lucky
Roosevelt and Susie Gelman for your hard work. And I particularly want to thank someone
else. I know that in her remarks, Kate spotlighted many of NARAL's countless
achievements, but I happened to notice that she left one thing out. And that is that none of it
would have been possible in these last years without her and her leadership. Whether
speaking out in the halls of Congress or organizing in communities across America, no one
understands the stakes more. No one has been more courageous, passionate and tireless in
the battle to make sure that every child is wanted, to make sure every pregnancy is planned,
to make sure that every woman is blessed with reproductive health and freedom. And Kate,
we all want to thank you for what you've done every single day. Thank you very much.
I'm also very humbled and honored to join the American College of Obstetricians and
Gynecologists, and all of you, in honoring the courageous life and work of Dr. Slepian. The
President and I, the Vice President and Tipper had the opportunity to meet Lynne Slepian
and her four sons in Buffalo the other day. I don't know how I could adequately express the
feelings that the four of us had standing there and talking with Lynne. Marilyn Buckham,
the director of the Buffalo clinic, was with her. And those four young men. I'm told that
recently Lynne, in a conversation with a friend, said how astounded she was that countless
people that she didn't know had offered to help her family. Her friend replied, "It's because
so many people admired Bart's courage and commitment." "But you know," Lynne said, "he
didn't do those things to be admired." And the friend replied, "We know. And that's one of
the reasons we admired him so much."
For his work was not the work of politics. It was the work of a community physician who
brought life into the world, and gave health and dignity to women. That was his mission,
and it must be our enduring goal.
Because we are here not only to celebrate NARAL's 30th birthday, but also to
commemorate the 26th anniversary of Roe V. Wade. We can all take heart that despite
many attempts to chip away at its guarantees, Roe is still the law of the land. We can take
heart that we have stopped the global gag rule, for now. That Title X family planning
funding increased by $12 million. And that federal health plans are now required, if they
cover prescription drugs, to also cover contraceptives.
But there is even more that happened this past year that we can celebrate. Because after
years of moving in the wrong direction, we are finally seeing teen pregnancies and teen
sexual activity going down. Unintended pregnancies are down. Abortions are down by a
full 12 percent. And all of this happened under a pro-choice president who has refused to
back down in his support of a woman's right to choose. A pro-choice president who respects
the strongly held views of those who act in good faith, hold a different view. And who has
worked to make good on the promise he made seven years ago to work to make abortion
safe, legal and rare. Now you know better than anyone else that this will never be, it cannot
1 of 7
6/14/2000 9:54 AM
First Lady's Speeches
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990122.htm
be, an easy issue. It will always be hard. We don't have to look any further than the events
on the Mall, the event in this room, and the gulf between them to know that emotions and
feelings will always run deep.
But all too often, generally because of the loudest voices, the American people don't hear
explained the efforts that we're engaged in to continue to work with people from all
different walks of life to make abortion safe, legal, and rare. But instead they hear what
Lawrence Tribe calls "The Clash of Absolutes.' People shouting at each other about their
differences instead of talking about and working to find what they have in common. That
doesn't mean that anyone should ever abandon his or her belief that their fundamental
convictions, and certainly, for those of us here, it means we never abandon our belief that
the fundamental human right all people have to plan their own families. And it also means
that we can never work with those who advocate violence. But there are people of good
faith on all sides of this issue, and every day that we fail to find common ground to meet
our goals of giving human rights and dignity to all people, another day goes by where a
child is born unwanted, or a woman cannot get access to proper health care, or a teenager
becomes pregnant and doesn't know what to do.
Across our country, we come to this issue as men and women, young and old, some far
beyond years when we have to worry about getting pregnant, others too young to remember
what it was like in the days before Roe V. Wade. People call themselves by different labels,
follow different political philosophies or religions, but I think it's essential that as
Americans we look for that common ground that we can all stand upon. For more than
anything, our democracy is built upon a powerful idea: that people with profound
differences and backgrounds can work together, across whatever divides them personally,
in pursuit of common goals. Because, despite our differences, there are certain core beliefs
and values that tie us together and set us apart as Americans. And it is those beliefs that can
guide us in reaching our goal of keeping abortion safe, legal and rare into the next century.
I want to talk about three of those core, fundamental American beliefs. First, as Americans,
most of us believe that the government should never be involved in the personal decision a
woman makes about whether to bring a child into this world. I know that earlier you got a
look at the new NARAL ad that will begin running Monday night. And I want to
congratulate NARAL for calling choice what it is: a fundamental American value and
freedom. So every time we hear calls from those who would do away with family planning
or limit reproductive rights, I hope we remember how fundamental our American values are
to this debate. I also hope we will hear the voices of others who have come before us. Just
imagine for a minute hearing the voices of the women who lined around the block for hours
in 1916, waiting for Margaret Sanger to open the nation's first birth control clinic in
Brooklyn. Before the police shut it down 10 days later, the clinic managed to help hundreds
of women, and they all had their stories to tell. Stories of miscarriages and dangerous and
illegal abortions, and the daily struggles to feed, clothe and shelter seven, eight, nine, ten or
even more children when there was barely enough to care for one.
Of course we know too well the human history beyond our shores is replete with examples
of inhumanity, and the abuse of power. So every time someone glibly says that we should
have a constitutional amendment banning abortion or we should criminalize abortions, I
hope we will listen to the voices of those who have been the victims of such practices. I
hope we could hear the voices of the women who have suffered, often in silence, in Nazi
Germany. For Aryan women, deemed "valuable," abortion facilities were prohibited, and
their miscarriages were investigated by the police. For Jewish women, and Gypsy men and
women in the concentration camps, they faced mass sterilizations as part of the quest to
prevent "inferior" children. And from 1942 on, when women deported as forced labor
became pregnant, their pregnancy was reported to a special S.S. officer, who tested them to
identify their race, and then he decided the outcome of their pregnancy.
Every time someone tries to eliminate access to family planning, or further curtail
2 of 7
6/14/2000 9:54 AM
First Lady's Speeches
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990122.htm
reproductive rights, I hope we'll hear voices from women in Romania. When I visited there
just a few years ago, I spoke with women about what it was like before they had democracy
-- when they were taken against their will, often, or just as it became a matter of course
once a month during their working hours. Taken to a general holding facility where they
were physically examined to determine if they were pregnant, stripping them of their
dignity.
As part of Ceausescu's campaign to increase population in Romania to 30 million, birth
control, sex education and abortions were outlawed. You could open the door of your home
and find a member of the communist youth group there to quiz you about your private life
to find out why you hadn't conceived yet. And if you failed to conceive, you were fined a
celibacy tax of up to 10 percent of your monthly salary.
I hope we will also listen to the voices coming out of China. The voices of women today
now include many who are working to ensure that their country's family planning practices
are voluntary and respectful. When I was there, I heard about what the one-child policy had
once meant for too many women.
Back in the early 1980s, your menstrual cycle and use of contraceptives could be monitored
by local authorities. If you wanted to have a child, you needed to get permission or perhaps
face punishment. And, after you'd had your one allotted child, you could be sterilized
against your will or forced to have an abortion.
Which is why in my speech in Beijing, I said that "It is a violation of human rights when
women are denied the right to plan their own families -- and that includes being forced to
have an abortion or being sterilized against their will."
I hope everyone who has ever talked about making abortion illegal or limiting access to
family planning will listen to these voices from our own history and the history of other
women around our world. More powerful than any statistic, they tell the story of two
different extremes. The government saying you cannot have children and the government
saying you must have children. Neither of which is consistent with our American sense of
fundamental justice, freedom and democracy.
That's why NARAL is right to keep asking, Who decides? And the American people have
been right to answer again and again: This difficult decision must be made by individual
women, in privacy, in consultation with her conscience, her family, her doctor, her God and
not her member of Congress.
We also must continue to say that making abortion illegal only succeeds in doing one thing
-- making it unsafe, dangerous for women. As the Guttmacher Institute study released
yesterday makes clear, even in some countries where abortion is illegal, they have abortion
rates higher than what we have here in the United States. Because even when abortion is
illegal, women who feel they need or have a right to the procedure find a way but often at
great risks to themselves. Every year around the world, almost 600,000 women die of
pregnancy related causes and 78,000 of these deaths are because of unsafe abortions.
Even in our country, we have seen what can happen when a small group of extremists tries
to accomplish through violence and intimidation what they have been unable to achieve
through the ballot box or the courts.
That brings me to the second principle that I hope continues to guide our country, and that
is this: Violence, harassment, and intimidation have no role in our health care system or in
this debate. Yes, we should respect each other's First Amendment rights to express our
views. But no one debases the values of free speech, life and religion more than terrorists
who claim to be acting in their name.
3 of 7
6/14/2000 9:54 AM
First Lady's Speeches
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi./generalspeeches/1999/19990122.htm
At Dr. Slepian's memorial, there were countless parents who came to honor him. And they
did not come alone. In their arms or by their sides were the children that he had delivered,
some of whose lives he had literally saved. They will be his lasting legacy.
But what can each of us do that would best honor his memory, and the memory of others
who have been killed? We must honor them as Dr. Wortman has done, by refusing to back
down in our efforts to make sure that doctors are trained and available to provide safe and
comprehensive health care to women all over our nation.
And we can do everything in our power to prevent violence and terrorism before it happens.
In the last 10 years, there have been seven murders, 38 bombings, 146 cases of arson, and
733 cases of vandalism. Wherever one stands on the issue of abortion, surely we should all
agree that when doctors are murdered, when clinics are bombed, splattered with acid, or set
on fire, this is not free expression. This is domestic terrorism. And it must stop.
That's why I'm pleased to announce that the President's FY 2000 budget will include $4.5
million to provide extra security to clinics at risk. And that means proper lighting, motion
detectors, closed-circuit cameras, security systems, and bullet-resistant windows.
You know, we should recognize that nothing good can come from people preaching or
practicing hate whether they do it from a street corner or from a website. And no one has
taught us this lesson better than the man whose birthday we celebrated this past Monday.
Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., in his speech about this topic 33 years ago said, "There is
scarcely anything more tragic in life than a child who is not wanted." And that brings me to
my third point.
More than anything, as Americans I think we can find common ground in the belief that all
children should be wanted and that indeed abortions should be rare.
I have met thousands and thousands of pro-choice men and women. I have never met
anyone who is pro-abortion. Being pro-choice is not being pro-abortion. Being pro-choice
is trusting the individual to make the right decision for herself and her family, and not
entrusting that decision to anyone wearing the authority of government in any regard.
Now I think we can all agree that it is a tragedy when four in 10 pregnancies worldwide are
unplanned and half of them end in abortion. Now if we want, really, to reduce these
numbers, we know we cannot achieve that goal by making abortions harder to get. We must
do it by standing up for family planning here and around the world. And I am pleased to
announce that the President's budget request for FY 2000 does just that.
He is asking for an increase of $25 million in Title X Family Planning grants -- the largest
increase in 15 years and is also asking for $25 million for the United Nations Population
Fund thereby renewing our commitment to those women around the world who rely upon
that fund for contraceptives, maternal care, and child care.
Now, I am always amazed as I was during the debates on this issue last year that those
who oppose family planning try to link family planning to increases in abortion. Now we
know that it is, on the contrary, by refusing to fund family planning programs that we force
women to fall back on abortion.
We know that contraception reduces the probability of having an abortion by 85 percent.
We know that every year, U.S. family planning programs prevent 1.2 million unintended
pregnancies and 516,000 abortions in our country alone. And we have seen the same results
the world over.
I am looking forward to my trip to the Hague in a little over, a little less, I guess now, than
two weeks, where nations will gather in anticipation of Cairo plus five, to highlight success
4 of 7
6/14/2000 9:54 AM
First Lady's Speeches
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990122.htm
stories -- and find ways of replicating them worldwide.
But I have already seen many of those success stories firsthand. As I have personally had
the opportunity to visit health centers all over the world, where family planning is
decreasing the abortion rate and helping women gain authority and dignity in their own
lives.
I remember visiting a maternity hospital in Brazil, where they had integrated family
planning and reproductive health into their maternal and health services.
I saw mothers standing in the crowded hallways, cradling their newborns, waiting for
well-baby appointments. Young women waiting for their prenatal appointments. Infants
getting immunized. I saw parents getting the information they needed to make wise choices
about planning their families. And I also saw wards of women who were there because they
had not received quality health care. Many had, however, received self-induced or
back-alley abortions.
I spoke to a number of mothers who told me that for the first time they could adequately
care for the children they had. I learned about how rates of maternal mortality and abortion
decreased because women received health care they needed in a timely fashion. And I fell
in love with the Minister of Health for the state I was visiting when he said what everyone
knows, and that is he intended to bring to poor women the same access to family planning
services that well-to-do women take for granted.
It was indeed a victory when contraceptives were included last year in health plans for
federal employees. But now, private plans should cover contraceptives as well. It is also
past time to pass a Patient's Bill of Rights so that women will not have to go through a
gatekeeper to see their OB/GYN every year. And it is time, through our community health
clinics and other facilities, to give all people access to effective family planning and, I hope
someday, universal health care.
And, if we want to decrease unintended pregnancies, abortions, welfare, and the number of
young people dropping out of school, we must continue the progress we have made on
preventing teen pregnancy. I am very pleased with the results of the National Campaign to
Prevent Teen Pregnancy, headed by Sarah Brown and enlisting many distinguished
Americans. That campaign has made teen pregnancy an issue on the front covers of teen
magazines and soap operas, and has used many imaginative ways of reaching out with
many Americans, particularly young Americans, as possible. And we've got some success
to show for this effort.
Fewer teens are having sex, getting pregnant, and having abortions, so we are getting the
word out, but there are clearly too many young people who have not yet gotten this
message. I'm always stunned when I meet with groups of young women who have babies
already, who are pregnant and perhaps attending a class I visit. They sit there with a totally
straight face and tell me that as soon as their boyfriend gets a job or gets back from the
Army, or gets out of jail, they'll be a family, and everything will work out just fine. Well,
we know better, and we have to continue to educate our young women about that reality as
well.
But we know that young women get pregnant for a whole host of reasons. Some just don't
understand why it's a bad idea, because they will, they think, have someone who is totally
there who will love them unconditionally, at least until that child becomes a toddler and
learns to say no. But that's another story. Some are coerced by older boyfriends. Some are
the victims of incest. Others can't cope with school or their family and see pregnancy and
motherhood as a way out. Whatever the reason might be, we have to try to reach every
single teenager. We're doing that in a variety of ways. We are leaving no strategy unused.
The pregnancy prevention programs include abstinence education, more after-school
5 of 7
6/14/2000 9:54 AM
First Lady's Speeches
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990122.htm
programs, efforts like Secretary Shalala's Girl Power Campaign, access to family planning,
decision-making groups any approach that we think can work.
And we are seeing that this multi-pronged strategy can give us positive results. For
example, back in 1990, Cortland, New York, had one of the highest teen pregnancy rates
around. The county's family planning clinic and Catholic Charities decided to work
together. They made the clinic free. They enlisted teens to talk to teens. They created a
place for youngsters to go every Saturday night with adult supervision. They brought in
religious leaders and businesses and they taught parents how to talk to their own children.
And they set a goal of reducing the teenage pregnancy rate by one-third by the year 2000.
Today they have almost reached that goal. As of 1996, the rates had decreased 30 percent --
the lowest in that community in 20 years.
So we know what works. We have to muster the will and build the coalitions that reach out
and include all members of a community in making it possible for not only young people,
but people of any age, to have access to the services, to be given the support they need to
make wise decisions about their sexual life so that they can prevent pregnancy and prevent
abortion.
I remember hearing about a conversation that Sarah Brown had with a teen father in Los
Angeles. As they talked about what he felt like, being a father at such a young age, at the
end of the conversation, he told Sarah that, "No adult had ever taken that much interest in
what happened to me."
Well, the truth is that we have to pay attention to young women and young men, we have to
do what we can to make it possible that they can have the equipment they need
psychologically, emotionally to withstand pressure and to make the right decisions.
One young person from Texas, when asked what parents could do to prevent their own
children from becoming pregnant said: "Don't leave us alone so much." Now, as any parent
of teenagers knows, I don't think he meant literally he wanted to spend every second with
his parents. But I do think that he was sending us in the adult community a very important
message: that we have to fill our young people's lives with meaningful activities, skills they
can obtain, a good education and just plain old-fashioned support and love. If we give them
something else in their lives to look forward to playing on a soccer team, being in a
school play, or going to college, becoming a teacher, whatever it might be then the needs
that they sometimes feel to achieve maturity early will have some tough competition.
A number of years ago, at the Baltimore Self Center, Rosalie Strett used to give pregnant
girls baby dolls to teach them to be parents. But she replaced the face of the doll with a
mirror not only so they would learn to make eye contact with their children, but so that
when they looked down, they would see themselves, and that child, in the future.
Imagine if every person looked into the mirror before sexual activity, before a pregnancy,
and asked, "Am I ready for this?" Imagine if boys and men not just girls and women --
looked into that mirror as well. Because we have to do more to reach out to young men, and
enlist them in the campaign to make abortion rare, and to make it possible for them also to
define their lives in terms other than what they imagine sexual prowess and fatherhood
being.
All of us -- citizens, parents, teachers, government officials, the media, sports figures,
religious leaders, business leaders all of us need to look in that mirror. We have to make
it our responsibility to create a new ethic of planned parenthood in this country. An ethic
where people have the tools they need to plan every pregnancy -- probably, by any
measurement, the most important event in their lives with as much care and detail as they
plan other major events.
6 of 7
6/14/2000 9:54 AM
First Lady's Speeches
http://www.whitehouse.gov/WH/EOP/Fi../generalspeeches/1999/19990122.htm
I hope we will do more than imagine. I think again of Dr. Slepian, who despite the
harassment, had the courage every day to be there for the women who relied upon him.
I think of the women who died in back-alley abortions. The women forced to bear children
in Romania or forced to abort them in China. And I think of the pioneers in our own
country before Roe V. Wade -- some in this room -- who, even when you were ridiculed,
threatened or ostracized, stood up for the right of each woman to choose. You have led us
to this day, and we are grateful for your leadership. But now we have to expand far beyond
this room, and far beyond those who are already identified an understanding that the issue
we are proposing the pro-choice issue -- is an issue with deep roots in American
democracy and human rights.
I hope that at the 50th anniversary of NARAL, the people on this podium speaking to you
and the people in the audience will be able to say that we persevered. We did not turn our
backs on our fundamental principles, but we also faced forward. That we worked with those
who were willing to work with us to end some of the divisiveness that has plagued this
issue. And we found the courage -- and the common ground -- to make it possible for future
generations to say that abortion is safe, legal and indeed, rare.
At some point in that future, where we will be able, I hope, to have built a much stronger
foundation, and created on much more common ground, we will not have to hear these
endless debates about family planning, about reproductive rights, but instead, we will all be
focused on giving to each person in our country the respect that person needs to make the
decisions all of our lives that only we can and should make. That's the kind of America that
we celebrate today. That's the kind of America we must continue to fight for. Thank you all
very much.
?
To comment on this service,
send feedback to the Web Development Team.
Read our Privacy Policy
7 of 7
6/14/2000 9:54 AM
January 21, 1999
NARAL 30th ANNIVERSARY CELEBRATION
DATE:
Friday, January 22
TIME:
1:05 pm - 1:35 pm
LOCATION:
Omni Shoreham Hotel
Washington, D.C.
FROM:
Brenda Costello and
Natasha McMahan
I.
PURPOSE
To deliver the keynote address at NARAL's 30th anniversary celebration, and to highlight
the Administration's commitment to finding common ground in order to make abortion
safe, legal, and rare.
II.
BACKGROUND
Overview
The event will highlight National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League's
(NARAL's) thirty-year history of advocacy on behalf of a woman's freedom to choose and
the 26th annual recognition of the landmark decision in Roe V. Wade, the Supreme Court
decision legalizing abortion. Friday's luncheon will take place at Omni Shoreham Hotel
in Washington. There will be 700-750 guests who will be from NARAL and its affiliate
organizations. In addition, the luncheon will honor the memory of Dr. Barnett Slepian, the
Buffalo physician, murdered in his home last October, along with other physicians and
health care professionals who uphold the freedom to choose despite the climate of fear and
intimidation.
National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League (NARAL)
NARAL has a grassroots network of 30 state affiliates and 500,000 members nationwide.
NARAL's work is divided among three organizations, 1) NARAL, INC., which works
through the political system to effect reproductive health policy; 2) NARAL-PAC, which
is the political action committee and driving force behind the election of many pro-choice
candidates, and 3) The NARAL Foundation, which supports the in-depth research and
legal work of the organization. Since 1969, the National Abortion and Reproductive Rights
Action League (NARAL) and its affiliates have been the leading force in the fight for
reproductive freedom in America.
Serving as the political arm of the pro-choice movement, NARAL has been involved in
several key races throughout the country to elect pro-choice candidates to Congress. While
advocating for programs that reduce unintended pregnancy and make abortion less
necessary, NARAL has pursued its mission of securing and protecting the freedom to
choose. NARAL advocates that the freedom to make personal decisions without
governmental interference is one of the most fundamental principles on which our nation
was founded. NARAL is leading the way to promote policies that will make abortion less
necessary.
NARAL's legislative efforts played a vital role in passing the Freedom of Access to Clinic
Entrances Act, which prohibits unlawful anti-choice violence and harassment that
jeopardizes access to abortion services. In addition, NARAL has been involved in recent
initiatives such as educating Americans, electing pro-choice candidates and advocates for
pro-choice legislation to secure the freedom to choose, and defending reproductive choice
from assaults by the radical right. NARAL is committed to reducing teenage pregnancy
and sexually transmitted disease. In a paper presented at the American Enterprise Institute
for Public Policy Research Conference on Teenage Sexual Activity and Contraceptive Use,
statistics revealed that between 1990 and 1995, the percentage of teen girls who had ever
had sexual intercourse declined by five percent, marking the first decline in more than 20
years, yet the rates of teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted disease among teens
remains unacceptably high.
Format
Actress Dana Delany and Penelope Ann Miller will make their remarks. Next, Kate
Michelman, President of NARAL, will make introductory remarks and introduce you.
Upon conclusion of your remarks, you have the option to work a ropeline. There will be
700-750 guests in attendance, including many members of Congress and the
Administration (list attached).
III.
PARTICIPANTS
Meet and Greet
-Kate Michelman, President, NARAL
-Susie Gelman, Co-Chair of Event
-Selwa "Lucky" Roosevelt, Co-Chair of Event
-Michael Gelman, Principal and Founder of Washington-based Accounting Firm
-Mrs. Lynn Slepian, widow of slain provider, Dr. Barnett Slepian
-Marilyn Buckham, Executive Director of the Buffalo Women's Clinic
-Vicki Saporta, Executive Director, National Abortion Federation
-Nancy Silverman, NARAL Foundation Board Member and New York Philanthropist
-Roselyne Swig, Philanthropist and Community Activist
-Candy Cox, Senior Vice President, DDB/Elgin Worldwide
-Rick Gross, NARAL Board Member, Washington Attorney, Democratic Party Fundraiser
(wife Roberta, Inspector General, NASA)
-Susan McLane, NARAL Board Member, Women's Campaign Fund
-Dana Delany, actress
-Penelope Ann Miller, actress
-Morris Wortman, M.D., OB-GYN
-Lisa Perry, New York Philanthropist
Program
-Kate Michelman, President, NARAL
-The First Lady
IV.
SEQUENCE OF EVENTS
Kate Michelman will make introductory remarks and introduces the First Lady
onto stage.
The First Lady makes remarks.
Upon conclusion the First Lady has the option to work a ropeline.
V. PRESS
Open press.
VI. REMARKS
Provided by Laura Schiller.
JAN-21-99 THU 05:17 PM
NARAL LUNCHEON - Full Program
P. 02
Friday, January 22, 1999
445
11:30 am-noon
VIP Reception
11:30 am
Harpist plays in Reception Area
11:50 am
Begin Calls for Seating
All courses pre-set on table
NOON
Voice-over intros Co-Chairs, The Honorable Selwa Lucky
Roosevelt and Susie Gelman
Co-Chairs intro Kate Michelman
12:03 pm
Kate Michelman delivers Opening Remarks
12:10 pm
vo introduces Dana Delany for
Wall of Honor segment
12:13 pm
15-minute Program Break for Luncheon
12:28 pm
Kate Michelman delivers NARAL's history retrospective
Ending with 60-second "I Believe" video
12:43 pm
vo intros Penelope Ann Miller for
Messages Segment
12:48 pm
vo intros Reverend Carlton Veazey for
Moment of Silence
12:51 pm
vo intros Dr. Ralph Hale and Dr. John Choate of ACOG,
accompanied by Kate Michelman for
Slepian Award Segment:
ACOG Remarks (5 minutes)
Award Presentation to Mrs. Slepian
1:01 pm
Kate Michelman returns to podium
Asks Dr. Wortman to stand for recognition
Kate introduces First Lady Hillary Rodham Clinton
1:10 pm
Mrs. Clinton delivers Keynote Address
1:35 pm
Kate thanks audience
JAN-21-99 THU 04:45 PM
P. 02
NARAL LUNCHEON
In Attendance:
Administration:
Katie Button, First Lady's Office
Carolyn Frederickson, White House Legislative Affairs
Roberta Gross, Inspector General, NASA
Peggy Hamburg, Assistant Secretary, HHS
Jennifer Luray, White House Women's Office
Janet Murguia, White House Legislative Affairs mur-geea
Margaret Pollack, Department of State, Bureau of Population, Refugees and Migration
Nancy Rubin, US Ambassador to the UN Human Rights Commission
Donna Shalala, Secretary of HHS
Merlanne Verveer, Chief of State, First Lady
Marcy Wilder, Deputy General Counsel, HHS (former NARAL employee)
Members of Congress:
Sen. John Chafee
Rep. Eva Clayton
Rep. Danny Davis
Rep. Eliot Engel
Rep. Sam Farr
Former Rep. Jane Harman
Rep. Alcee Hastings
Rep. Rush Holt
Former Rep. Elizabeth Holtzman
Rep. Eddie Bernice Johnson
Rep. Carolyn Cheeks Kilpatrick
Former Rep. Mike Kopetski
Former Rep. Peter Kostmayer
Rep. Tom Lantos
Rep. Juanita Millender-McDonald
Rep. Patsy Mink
Rep. Dennis Moore
Rep. Connie Morella
Sen. Patty Murray
Rep. Ed Pastor
Rep. Nancy Pelosi
Rep. Lynn Rivers
Rep. Jan Schakowsky
Former Rep. And Ambassador Jame Scheuer and Mrs. Emily Malino Scheuer
Rep. Louise Slaughter
Rep. Mike Thompson
Rep. Anthony D. Weiner (weener)
ИНЕКГ MARCHEW
JAN-21-99 THU 04:45 PM
P. 03
Rep. Lynn Woolsey
Rep. David Wu
Other Notables:
Lynn Blitzer
Esther Coopersmith
Kitty Kelley
Hon. Rosario Manolo, Deputy Foreign Minister of the Philipines
Carol Pensky
ID: :202-973-3098
JAN 22'99
4:16 No. 006 P.02
NARAL Promoting Reproductive Choices
Kate Michelman, President
National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League
Biography
Kate Michelman's commitment to personal and individual liberties is longstanding. This fact is
most evident when one examines her twelve-year tenure as the President of the National
Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League (NARAL). Her leadership is marked by an
unabiding commitment to reproductive freedom as a fundamental American value. This
commitment has earned her recognition as one of the most influential and dynamic women in
Washington, D.C., while the October 1997 edition of Vanity Fair named NARAL among the
twenty most powerful special interest groups in the nation.
Media sources frequently recognize Michelman as a leading voice in the pro-choice community.
Journalists from national newspapers, including the New York Times, the Washington Post, the
Los Angeles Times and USA Today, regularly quote her as a leading defender of reproductive
freedom. She has also appeared on network news and talk shows, including Face the Nation,
This Week With David Brinkley, Nightline, The MacNeil-Lehrer News Hour, CBS This
Morning, Crossfire, Equal Time, Fox News Sunday and PBS.
Michelman knows first-hand that abortion is a difficult human dilemma, Her tenacious spirit is
driven by the memories of her difficult struggle with the abortion decision prior to Roe V. Wade.
In 1970, she was denied the legal right to choose an abortion without the written consent of the
man who had deserted her and their three children and the approval of a hospital board of four
men. She has described this experience as a degrading, dehumanizing assault on her integrity,
dignity and very sense of self.
National Abortion
and Reproductive Rights
During the twenty-seven years since her abortion, Michelman has emerged as an
Action League
articulate and passionate defender of women's reproductive choices, conveying a
1156 15th Street, NW
message that the majority of Americans support. As a political strategist, lobbyist
Suite 700
and fundraiser, she has maintained that women must be trusted to make the
Washington, DC 20005
Phone (202) 973-3000
abortion decision within their own moral and ethical framework. This framework
Fax (202) 973-3096
structured NARAL's "Who Decides?" campaign, providing a timely and ageless
10536 Culver Boulevard
message that has motivated and sustained a strong pro-choice constituency
Suite B
throughout the 1990s.
Culver City, CA 90232
Phone (310) 559-9334
Fax (310) 204-6942
http://www.naral.org
E-Mail: [email protected]
*
ID:202-973-3098
JAN 22'99
4:16 No. 006 P.03
By shifting the focus of the abortion debate to a woman's right to make personal decisions free
from government interference, NARAL has played a central role in electoral politics, helping to
elect pro-choice candidates at the state and federal levels. Under Michelman's leadership,
NARAL has also lobbied on behalf of legislation that guarantees every woman the right to make
personal decisions regarding a full range of reproductive choices, including preventing
unintended pregnancy, bearing healthy children, and choosing legal abortion.
Michelman's background provides a broad foundation of experience to develop and articulate the
need for comprehensive reproductive health care policies. At the grassroots level, she developed
a model multi-disciplinary diagnostic treatment program for developmentally disabled preschool
children and their families. The project resulted from her work on behalf of children with special
needs in Adams County, Pennsylvania, a predominantly rural county on the fringes of
Appalachia. One of the first such projects in the United States, it has become a model program
replicated by early childhood specialists in several regions.
As an educator, Michelman has provided clinical training of medical students and residents in
child development while working as a clinical Assistant Professor in the Department of
Psychiatry at Pennsylvania State University School of Medicine. In 1994, she was selected to be
a fellow at the John F. Kennedy School of Government's Institute of Politics at Harvard
University. In addition, she served as the Executive Director of Planned Parenthood in
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. During her five-year tenure, she expanded the availability of health
services to include all aspects of reproductive health needs.
No one knows better than Kate Michelman that the right to choose is one of the most contested
American values. Victories have been hard won, and the status of reproductive freedom is
currently tenuous. Michelman, however, is a woman of vision. She is leading the efforts to
create a positive, moral, pro-choice message that elevates childbearing to a new level of
responsibility. She is also a woman of compassion, working to create a society that enables
women to participate fully as citizens, and that values women's choices, health, and safety.
2
NARAL Publications -- TEENS IN CRI...ategy to Protect Adolescent Health
http://www.naral.org/publications/teensincrisis.html
NARAL
Promoting Reproductive Choices
Publications
TEENS IN CRISIS:
A Comprehensive Strategy to Protect Adolescent Health
National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League (NARAL/The NARAL
Foundation) Kate Michelman, President
Paper presented at the American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research
Conference on Teenage Sexual Activity and Contraceptive Use: An Update May 1, 1998
Recent surveys identify several positive trends concerning teenage sexual activity and
contraceptive use. Between 1990 and 1995, the percentage of teen girls who had ever had
sexual intercourse declined by five percent - marking the first decline in more than 20
Source
years.1 In 1995, 78 percent of teen girls used contraception at first intercourse as compared
to 65 percent in 1988 and 48 percent in 1982.2 In addition, the teen pregnancy, birth and
abortion rates have been declining.3
Although these findings are notable, the U.S. continues to face an adolescent reproductive
health crisis. The rates of teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted disease (STD) and
human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infections among teens remain unacceptably high.
More teens may be using contraception at first intercourse; however, teens continue to fail
to use contraception consistently or appropriately. Moreover, the frequency of unwanted
sexual intercourse among teen girls is alarming.
In searching for solutions to this adolescent reproductive health crisis, some individuals and
groups have focused on abstinence-only education. An emphasis on abstinence-only
education is misplaced. Abstinence education is an essential part of sexuality education, but
abstinence should not be the only lesson taught. Sexuality education should teach teens to
deal with peer pressure and pressure from partners to engage in sexual activity, but teens
should also learn how to protect themselves if they do become sexually active.
Rather than focusing on abstinence-only education, the U.S. must demonstrate a national
commitment to remedying this adolescent crisis through a multi-pronged approach. Such an
approach would invest in the development of young women by valuing their lives, inspiring
them to seek better futures, enhancing self-sufficiency, preparing them for higher education,
providing job training and ensuring access to health care. We need to embark on a
campaign to increase family planning funding, improve and expand access to
contraceptives, and increase awareness of and access to emergency contraceptives. Finally,
we must launch a national effort to require comprehensive sexuality education throughout
our primary and secondary schools. This approach would protect teens by promoting
abstinence while simultaneously providing teens with the contraceptive and STD/HIV
prevention information they need to make responsible decisions if and when they become
sexually active.
I. America is Facing a Crisis in Adolescent Reproductive Health.
Despite the positive trends identified in the 1995 National Survey of Family Growth and
1995 National Survey of Adolescent Males, the U.S. continues to face a crisis in adolescent
reproductive health. Although some statistics demonstrate a decline in teen sexual activity,
1 of 11
1/21/99 1:55 PM
PAGE
12
LEVEL 1 - 7 OF 50 STORIES
Copyright 1998 The New York Times Company
The New York Times
October 26, 1998, Monday, Late Edition - Final
SECTION: Section A; Page 1; Column 6; Metropolitan Desk
LENGTH: 1148 words
HEADLINE: Beliefs Pushed Doctor to Keep Abortion Role
BYLINE: By JOSEPH BERGER
DATELINE: AMHERST, N.Y., Oct. 25
BODY:
Some of those who knew him said today that Dr. Barnett A: Slepian continued
to perform abortions in the face of death threats because he had what one friend
called "a stubborn kind of courage."
Others said he persisted not for ideological reasons but because he was
simply a conscientious doctor who wanted to practice the full range of
gynecological medicine that he had been trained in, even if that included the
procedures that many in the aggressive anti-abortion movement in western New
York equated with murder.
Having babies come into the world was his life," said Ellen Fink, a
ime friend. "But he performed abortions because he believed it was a
i's legal right to choose.'
Dr. Slepian, a 52-year-old gynecologist and obstetrician who lived in this
suburb of Buffalo, was shot fatally in the back Friday night as he stood in his
kitchen chatting with his wife, Lynne, and son Andrew. He had just returned from
synagogue where he had gone to mark the yahrzeit, or anniversary, of his
father's death.
Today, his friends, patients and relatives were heartsick at his murder, but
also fearful to speak about it because the sniper who lay in wait in the woods
behind Dr. Slepian's house and shot him with a high-powered rifle through an
undraped window was at large. Still, a few took time to talk to reporters
because, they said, they wanted to make sure the man they knew was portrayed not
as a pro-abortion zealot, but as a well-rounded doctor, father and husband.
Dr. Slepian, who as a young man was so determined to become a doctor that he
studied medicine in Spanish in Guadalajara, Mexico, when American schools would
not accept him, was a person who prized his time with his four sons: Andrew, 15;
Brian, 13; Michael, 10, and Philip, 7. He was a devoted jogger, having run a
marathon, and was, one friend said, "a health nut" who carefully watched such
demons as cholesterol and salt. He belonged to a Reform synagogue, Temple Beth
Am.
He was painfully aware that he and his family could be the target of a fierce
ent of abortions and took precautions. In the last five years, there had
PAGE
13
The New York Times, October 26, 1998
four attacks none fatal against doctors in the United States-Canadian
r region, and two abortion doctors had been killed in other parts of the
ed States. As recently as Friday morning, Dr. Slepian received a two-page
rning from the downtown Buffalo clinic where he worked, urging him to beware
niper attacks.
"Do not assume that you are safe once you are at home,' " the warning said.
"Close the drapes in your house so you are not visible from outside.'
In fact, Dr. Slepian often kept the blinds drawn at home and he called the
police whenever he received a death threat. Neighbors said there were a number
of periods when an Amherst patrol car was stationed outside Dr. Slepian's
two-story brick colonial in a well-to-do enclave here.
But he refused to change his approach to medicine, even when his friends
warned him some anti-abortion protesters would view his death as a "coup" that
would virtually eliminate poor people's access to abortion in the Buffalo area.
"He knew the risks well," said Glenn Edward Murray, who was Dr. Slepian's
lawyer and longtime friend. "We had discussed the fatal dangers he placed
himself in by continuing to perform abortions. We discussed security measures.
He was dedicated to providing women with safe and legal abortions and was
unwilling to abandon his clients because of threats."
Mr. Murray, who talked in carefully measured tones but still found himself
choked with emotion, said that Dr. Slepian, as a young intern and resident in
the Buffalo area, had been taught by mentors how dangerous and sometimes fatal
alley" abortions performed by bad practitioners or by the women themselves
be. Even as he had four children of his own, he was determined that he
perform abortions for women who needed them, no matter how poor they were.
So in addition to a private practice he had in this leafy suburban town in
the prairie-flat countryside east of Buffalo, Dr. Slepian chose to work
regularly at a clinic in downtown Buffalo that had been singled out by
protesters and was the last of its kind in Buffalo Buffalo GYN Women's
Services. Now, that clinic has been left without a doctor.
His wife, Lynne, a trained nurse who stayed home in recent years to raise
their sons, was as resolute as he was in not letting the protesters stop her
husband from practicing medicine as he saw fit.
Dr. Slepian, a slender, wiry man with the bearded face of a scholar, was born
in Cambridge, Mass., into a lower-middle-class family of four children, each of
whom went on to considerable accomplishment as an adult. One of his two
brothers, Jacob, is also a doctor, specializing in ear, nose and throat
medicine.
Dr. Slepian, whom friends called Bart, was raised in Rochester, N.Y.,
attended college at the University of Denver in Colorado and received his
medical degree from the Autonomous University of Guadalajara. A residency at the
State University of New York at Buffalo brought him to this' area 20 years ago,
and he stayed.
Although some gynecologists will quietly perform abortions for their longtime
g patients, Dr. Slepian was one of only a few doctors in western New York
PAGE
14
The New York Times, October 26, 1998
were willing to perform abortions openly at public clinics. Nonetheless, his
ds said, he counseled women seeking abortion to consider alternatives like
cion.
n 1988, protesters taunted him outside his home on Hanukkah. When he emerged
rying a baseball bat, a clash ensued and Dr. Slepian was eventually charged
with a misdemeanor for damaging a protester's vehicle. In 1992 he again became a
target in a coordinated protest by 200 picketers from the anti-abortion group
Operation Rescue that was known as "Spring of Life."
In recent years, patients who visited him at the downtown clinic or his
private office in Amherst periodically endured shouts from picketers of "You're
murdering your babies. A longtime patient who asked that she be identified only
as Karen said that Dr. Slepian frequently apologized for the protesters'
disruptions. Still, Karen said she knew him mainly as a devoted gynecologist who
saw her through infertility treatments and delivered her daughter.
"He wasn't supposed to be there for the delivery but he came anyway and when
I asked him, 'What are you doing here,' he said, 'I wouldn't miss it for the
world.' " Similarly, she said, he went out of his way to visit another patient
when she was in the hospital for a non-gynecological ailment. "I thought I'd
come over to have donuts and coffee with you when I heard you were in the
hospital," Karen heard that he told the friend.
"He was the type of man," Karen said, "that I would put my life in his hands
and not question what he had to say. And I can't say that about all doctors."
HIC: Photos: Dr. Barnett A. Slepian was one of Buffalo's last abortion
rs. (Associated Press); Mourners left flowers and a sign yesterday at the
st, N.Y., clinic of Dr. Barnett A. Slepian, an abortion doctor who was
n Friday. (Michael J. Okoniewski for The New York Times) (pg. B10)
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
LOAD-DATE: October 26, 1998
PAGE
4
LEVEL 1 - 3 OF 50 STORIES
Copyright 1998 The New York Times Company
The New York Times
October 27, 1998, Tuesday, Late Edition - Final
SECTION: Section B; Page 1; Column 2; Metropolitan Desk
LENGTH: 1265 words
HEADLINE: Slain Physician Eulogized as Caring Man
BYLINE: By JOSEPH BERGER
DATELINE: AMHERST, N.Y., Oct. 26
BODY:
Alan Dickison went to the funeral of Dr. Barnett A. Slepian this afternoon
carrying his two towheaded children, Connor, 4, and Kelsey, 2, a boy and girl
whom Dr. Slepian had delivered.
"This man was about children," he said, brandishing the two children toward a
cluster of reporters. "This man was not about abortions."
As the Federal Bureau of Investigation announced a $100,000 reward in its
investigation of Dr. Slepian's slaying on Friday and the abortion clinic where
ad worked vowed to be open for business on Tuesday morning, Dr. Slepian was
jized today by a brother and a niece and, in a letter, from President
on as a kind and dedicated physician who did not let threats and protests
him from fulfilling what he regarded as his duty to care for women, no
matter what their needs.
Yet, among the hundreds of mourners who spilled out from a suburban funeral
home here, there were many patients like the Dickison family who resented Dr.
Slepian's description in many television and newspaper accounts as merely an
"abortion doctor." Such a depiction, they said, was feeding into the agenda of
the fierce enemies of abortion.
"They raise the stakes and then some extremist shoots him in the back in the
middle of the night," said Mr. Dickison, a registered nurse.
Dr. Slepian, he said, was a doctor who cared for women through pregnancy,
infertility, childbirth and menopause. His murder, he and other mourners said,
has deprived the Buffalo area of a doctor who brought hundreds of babies into
the world and attended to women who for medical or personal reasons could not
carry an embryo to term.
Marcia Sperduti, weeping as she walked toward the funeral home, told how
Dr. Slepian had saved her son's life by rushing to perform a Caesarean on her
when her son's umbilical cord became knotted in the womb.
"Thank God I'm not having any more children, because Dr. Slepian is not alive
to deliver them, she said.
PAGE
5
The New York Times, October 27, 1998
Dr. Slepian's coffin was taken away for burial, the F.B.I. announced it
ffering a $100,000 reward for information leading to the capture of his
er. But law enforcement officials who spoke on the condition of anonymity
id that so far, little information had been developed about the killer -- what
r she looked like or what car was used in the getaway. Ballistics tests have
yet been completed on the bullet, which was fired by a sniper with a
high-powered rifle from a wooded field behind Dr. Slepian's home.
Officials said they were theorizing that this slaying was connected to four
other sniper attacks since 1994 on doctors who performed abortions. Three
attacks took place in Canada and one in Rochester, and there were injuries,
though none of those doctors was killed. The F.B.I. and the Amherst Police
Department have spoken to Canadian investigators about Friday's shooting.
Dr. Slepian, 52, who had a private practice here, but also was the primary
doctor at the only abortion clinic in downtown Buffalo, was shot in the back on
Friday night as he stood chatting with his wife, Lynne, and 15-year-old son,
Andrew, in the kitchen of their Amherst home. The killer had fired his
high-powered rifle at an undraped window.
At a news conference, John B. Askey, the Chief of Police of Amherst, revealed
that six hours before Dr. Slepian was killed, his wife had called the police to
inform them of a fax from the National Abortion Federation warning its 350
member clinics in the United States and Canada of the possibility of impending
assaults because of the approach of Nov. 11.
The holiday, known as Veterans Day in the United States, is Remembrance Day
anada, and this day to remember war dead has been embraced by abortion
ents as a memorial day. The sniper shootings of the three Canadian doctors
he one American took place in the days leading up to Nov. 11.
Chief Askey said that Mrs. Slepian did not ask that a patrol car be stationed
at the house, and the police did not send one. Asked if he regretted not doing
so, he said: "I regret that Dr. Slepian is dead."
Officials at Buffalo GYN Womenservices, the clinic where Dr. Slepian worked
15 to 24 hours a week performing abortions for largely poor and low-wage
clients, said today that they had received offers from more than a half-dozen
doctors around the country offering to take over Dr. Slepian's duties. Melinda
Dubois, assistant director, said she expected the four-day-a week clinic, the
only abortion clinic in western New York, to resume operations on Tuesday.
"There are so many doctors that respected Bart," she said, using Dr.
Slepian's nickname, "that they'd be willing to come into this area to take care
of our patients."
At the same time, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan announced in Washington
that any doctors who volunteered to work at the clinic would receive
round-the-clock protection from the United States Marshals' Service.
The Senator said marshals, assigned by John P. McCaffrey, chief of the
western New York district, were being used to assure women seeking abortions a
constitutional protection. The last time he said he could remember marshals'
serving in a similar role was during the civil rights era of the 1960's.
PAGE
6
The New York Times, October 27, 1998
This is a constitutionally protected medical procedure and there is a
rist movement trying to make it impossible,' Senator Moynihan said in a
phone interview. "And they murder people and they have Web sites that list
ors who perform abortions and every so often a name is crossed off."
The funeral drew an overflow turnout that included Dr. Slepian's patients and
medical colleagues, as well as his family and friends and a sprinkling of
abortion-rights supporters from as far away as Atlanta.
A half-dozen Amherst police officers controlled traffic at the funeral and
kept reporters out, but there was no indication of a heavy police presence to
guard against a sniper.
The Slepian family asked that the funeral be private, but Glenn Edward
Murray, a friend of Dr. Slepian's and his personal lawyer, and others who
attended described it afterward.
Rabbi Michael L. Feshbach, rabbi of Dr. Slepian's synagogue, Temple Beth Am,
read a three-paragraph letter President Clinton wrote to Mrs. Slepian and her
four children, Andrew, 15, Brian, 13, Michael 10, and Philip, 7, that began with
the words: "Hillary and I were deeply saddened to learn of your husband's tragic
death."
"Violence in our society hurts us all, but few have to endure its effects so
personally," the President wrote. "This cowardly and brutal act has robbed your
family of a beloved husband and devoted father and it has robbed your community
of a skilled doctor and cherished friend. In the face of threats, taunts and
ence, Barnett Slepian refused to abandon the patients who trusted him and
amilies who needed his help."
Dr. Slepian's niece, Amanda Robb, told how Dr. Slepian became like a father
to her after the death of her own father, providing financial and emotional
support even as he was struggling to build his medical career.
Before beginning his eulogy recalling Dr. Slepian's dedication, his older
brother, Jacob, an ear, nose and throat specialist in Connecticut, told a story
that highlighted his brother's dry sense of humor.
He recalled how his brother had once had a bird, perhaps a macaw. When he
learned that the bird could live to be as old as 80, he joked that he would
train the bird to deliver his eulogy. Jacob Slepian said the bird and his
brother had parted ways at some point, but he would try to do as well as the
bird would have done.
GRAPHIC: Photos: Alan Dickison with his children at services for Dr. Barnett A.
Slepian yesterday. (Michael J. Okoniewski for The New York Times) (pg. B1);
Mourners leaving services for Dr. Barnett A. Slepian yesterday. "This man was
about children,' one said. "This man was not about abortions." (Michael J.
Okoniewski for The New York Times) (pg. B7)
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
LOAD-DATE: October 27, 1998
NARAL Press Release - October 28, 1998
http://www.naral.org/publications/press/98oct/102898.html
NARAL
Publications
Promoting Reproductive Choices
PRESS RELEASES & STATEMENTS
STATEMENT OF KATE MICHELMAN
AT THE VIGIL FOR DR. SLEPIAN
October 28, 1998
I knew Dr. Slepian. I knew this remarkable man. I knew of his commitment to his
patients and of his dedication to our cause. I knew of his devotion to the
reproductive health and freedom of American women. And I knew of his
determination and courage.
Dr. Slepian was a victim of serious threats for years and he never backed down. Not
once did he think of ending his practice or abandoning the women who relied on
him so much. Dr. Slepian believed deeply in the constitutional right of women to
choose and he rightly believed that he was a force that enabled women to exercise
that right with dignity and in safety.
A dedicated physician, a true ally in the fight for women's reproductive health, a
husband, a father, and a dear friend. Dr. Slepian will be sorely missed.
Dr. Slepian would want his passing should serve a much higher purpose. So let us
honor him with renewed commitment to the pro-choice values he so perfectly
embodied. Let us mark his passing with renewed courage to fight for women's
reproductive health and the right of women to choose - free from government
interference - free from harassment - free from intimidation - and free from
violence.
Coming on the heels of the brutal death of Matthew Shepard, the shocking murder
of Dr. Slepian reflects a deeply disturbing and increasingly dangerous trend of
intolerance, exclusion, hatred and disdain for the rule of law. Both Dr. Slepian and
Matthew Shepard were victims of those who use violence to express their
opposition to social progress. This reign of terror must be stopped.
Increasingly, anti-choice groups and their leaders are using sensationalized rhetoric
and incendiary statements to characterize abortion. They have labeled doctors as
murders, posted their names on "wanted" signs and on the Internet, and even gone so
far a to publicly justify the murder of these men.
But it is time for that to change. Those who oppose abortion must take
responsibility for their role in creating a climate where the zealous feel justified in
committing acts of violence. They must acknowledge and admit that their words
drive unrestrained factions of their movements to commit these horrific acts.
Denials and condemnations no longer suffice. They must stop referring to abortion
as murder. And they must stop referring to doctors as murderers.
These are acts of terrorism, pure and simple, and this country must condemn them
as such. Our outrage should boil over and spill into the streets. Law enforcement,
legislators, the medical community, pro-choice and anti-choice Americans alike
must rise up and strike back at the heart of these criminals - not with violence, but
with swift justice and meaningful action.
1 of 2
1/21/99 1:24 PM
NARAL Press Release - October 28, 1998
http://www.naral.org/publications/press/98oct/102898.html
Those who would do away with the Roe have become emboldened - have become
smarter - have become a very powerful force in America - with a reach that is
broader and deeper than we could ever have imagined just four years ago with the
congressional landslide election of 1994. The freedom to choose is no longer safe
and the time for action is now.
In less than two weeks we must make choices at the polls. Let bring our outrage at
these killings into the voting booth with us. Let us bring a renewed commitment to
our cause. On November 3rd, I ask you to step up to our opponents and do as they
preach - vote your own values. Dig deep into who we are as a people - into what we
want for our children - into the freedoms so hard won, and now at risk.
If we fail to rally our people into action, then our opponents - and the murderer of
Dr. Slepian will have won. If we fail to rally to our own cause, we will have failed
ourselves - and we will fail our future.
Let us honor Dr. Slepian with action, not tears.
home
search
index
what's new
feedback
join
Copyright 1998, National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League
2 of 2
1/21/99 1:24 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/In.univ..5=36f6200e03de0c031c8c956c628efb27
Copyright 1999 The Washington Post
The Washington Post
View Related Topics
January 23, 1999, Saturday, Final Edition
SECTION: METRO; Pg. B01
LENGTH: 918 words
HEADLINE: Roe V. Wade 26 Years Later; Abortions Protested; First Lady Pledges to Help Clinics
BYLINE: Sari Horwitz; John W. Fountain, Washington Post Staff Writers
BODY:
"Hey, hey, ho, ho! Roe v. Wade has got to go!" a pack of teenage girls chanted yesterday at the steps of
the Supreme Court. Behind them stood a 70-year-old former Marine carrying four pictures of bloody
fetuses and wearing a fifth placard. Mothers pushed toddlers in strollers, several men rode in wheelchairs
and a group of priests softly sang prayers.
Tens of thousands of protesters from across the country marched under a gray sky to voice their strong
opposition to abortion and to vow to continue the fight to reverse Roe V. Wade, the U.S. Supreme Court
decision that legalized abortion 26 years ago.
Across town at the Omni Shoreham Hotel, first lady Hillary Rodham Clinton marked the anniversary in
a different fashion. She announced that the administration will seek $ 4.5 million from Congress for
alarm systems and closed-circuit cameras at abortion clinics.
"We must work to make abortion safe, legal and rare," Clinton told the National Abortion Rights
Action League. "Violence, harassment and intimidation have no place in our health care system or in
the debate."
On the streets, protesters marched up Constitution Avenue, past the Capitol and the impeachment trial
within, to the steps of the Supreme Court, where they were met by a phalanx of police in riot gear. The
marchers waved banners showing scissors, tearful children and Jesus Christ.
"The scandals that have rocked the White House pale to near insignificance when compared to the
anti-child policies so methodically pursued by our abortion president and his administration," said Rep.
Christopher H. Smith (R-N.J.), a rally speaker.
"The execution of a partially born girl or boy by stabbing them in the back of the head and sucking their
brains out shatters the myth that abortion is somehow benign, just or compassionate," Smith said. "It is
ugly beyond words."
Police said there were no arrests or serious incidents reported during the four-hour protest, which began
at noon with a rally on the Ellipse. The U.S. Park Police no longer estimate the number of participants in
Washington marches, after controversies over official crowd counts. March organizer Nellie Gray, the
president of the March for Life Education and Defense Fund, estimated the crowd at 100,000 and
proclaimed the 26th annual march "the best we have ever had."
Gray acknowledged that there was a tense moment on stage when former representative Robert K.
Dornan (R-Calif.) was nearing the end of a passionate speech. He began to criticize the U.S. Catholic
1 of 3
7/13/2000 4:08 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/In.univ.5=36f6200e03de0c031c8c956c628efb27
bishops -- scores of whom were standing nearby -- for not doing enough to end abortion.
Gray jumped to the lectern and began to pull the microphone away from Dornan. He tried to get it back.
"No, no," Gray said, pulling it away. But Dornan retrieved the microphone, telling her he just wanted to
say goodbye to the crowd.
Instead, Dornan quoted a line from the movie "A Few Good Men": "You can't handle the truth."
Later, Gray called Dornan "one of my heroes and a dear friend" but said that "the March for Life was not
the place to publicly criticize the bishops. I could not tolerate those kinds of remarks at my microphone."
Yesterday's events an annual commemoration since the Roe V. Wade decision -- began early in the
morning inside the stately third-floor caucus room of the Russell Senate Office Building. About 300
people held a solemn memorial service for "the pre-born and their mothers and fathers."
A panel of clergymen in robes sat at the front. With them was Norma McCorvey, whose fight to get an
abortion led to the historic Roe v. Wade decision but who has since become an antiabortion crusader,
publicly apologizing for her role in the court case.
Under crystal chandeliers, there were prayers for the unborn and the sins of a nation. Participants sang
spiritual songs amid the soft symphony of a harp and violin and the lighting of "The Life Candle." The
candle flickered on the white-clothed table, in front of a quilt stitched with names given by parents to
children who died before birth.
After the memorial service, some in the crowd posed for pictures with McCorvey. One woman embraced
her.
Their eyes shut tight as they hugged, the sparse words between them barely audible. Others shook her
hand. Some said thank you.
Later at the rally, the protesters filled the Ellipse and spilled over to the Mall. In the crowd was Jeannie
French of Pittsburgh, who tightly held the hand of her son, 5-year-old Will.
Will looked up at a large placard bobbing in front of him, at the picture of a bloody fetus torn into bits.
"Mommy," he said, "that's scary."
"It is scary, Will," French replied. "That's why we're here today."
French said she and her son were marching in honor of Will's twin sister, whom doctors advised French
to abort because of serious birth defects. Instead, she gave birth to the baby. The girl lived for six hours.
"She died peacefully, not violently," French said. "And we donated her heart valves to two children in
Chicago who were given the gift of life."
Shelly Sigler, right front, prays with others from Franciscan University in Steubenville, Ohio, during the
rally. Thousands of antiabortion protesters -- some with placards, some without march from the
Ellipse to Capitol Hill, marking the 26th anniversary of Roe v. Wade. KatieJane DeMonti, 8, of Stafford,
holds a sign as she prays before the start of the March for Life. She was at the protest with family and
friends.
2 of 3
7/13/2000 4:08 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/ln.univ.5=d7115a470c40d940a82ce6ba3e0220a3
Copyright 1999 Chicago Tribune Company
Chicago Tribune
View Related Topics
January 23, 1999 Saturday, NORTH SPORTS FINAL EDITION
SECTION: NEWS; Pg. 4; ZONE: N
LENGTH: 524 words
HEADLINE: FIRST LADY UNVEILS CLINIC SECURITY PLAN;
ANNOUNCEMENT COMES ON ROE ANNIVERSARY
BYLINE: Associated Press.
DATELINE: WASHINGTON
BODY:
Announcing an administration plan to counter abortion clinic violence, First Lady Hillary Rodham
Clinton said Friday that President Clinton plans to seek $4.5 million for alarm systems and
closed-circuit camera systems to protect the clinics.
Across town, meanwhile, thousands swayed, sang and prayed for the government to make abortions
illegal again.
On the 26th anniversary of Roe vs. Wade, the Supreme Court decision legalizing abortion nationwide,
Hillary Clinton told an abortion rights group of the administration's proposal, under which clinics
would buy security devices--which also include motion detectors, bulletproof windows and improved
lighting--with federal money. The money also would be used to determine which clinics were most at
risk.
She said the president will include the plan in his budget proposal for the next fiscal year, which begins
Oct. 1.
"Violence, harassment and intimidation have no place in our health-care system or in this debate," she
told members of the National Abortion Rights Action League. NARAL was celebrating its 30th
anniversary at a Washington hotel.
The first lady also saluted Dr. Barnett Slepian of Amherst, N.Y., an obstetrician shot to death by a sniper
in October in the kitchen of his home. Investigators suspect he was killed by an abortion protester.
At the NARAL meeting, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists honored Slepian's
widow, Lynn, with a plaque honoring her husband's service.
An appropriate way to honor him, Mrs. Clinton said, is to "make sure doctors are trained and available to
provide safe and comprehensive health care to women all over our nation."
"In the last 10 years, there have been seven murders, 38 bombings, 146 cases of arson and 733 cases of
vandalism" that were abortion-related, she added.
A law-enforcement official said Friday that preliminary DNA tests link a missing anti-abortion activist
to a strand of hair found near where a sniper shot and killed Slepian.
The first round of DNA tests by the FBI established a high probability that the hair came from the same
person as a hair found in a New Jersey home where James C. Kopp, a 44-year-old abortion protester,
lived last year, the official said.
1 of 2
7/13/2000 4:08 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/In.univ.5=d7115a470c40d940a82ce6ba3e0220a3
Kopp has eluded authorities since they obtained a warrant for him as a material witness in the Slepian
killing.
Clinton also emphasized the importance of making contraceptives and health counseling available to
young women and men to avoid teen pregnancies.
"After years of moving in the wrong direction, we are finally seeing teen pregnancies and teen sexual
activities going down," she said.
As the first lady spoke, hundreds of anti-abortion activists gathered on a muddy park within shouting
distance of the White House for speeches, songs, prayers and a march to the Supreme Court and the
Capitol.
This was the 26th year in a row that the group March for Life has organized a rally just south of the
White House to mark the anniversary of Roe VS. Wade.
Participants waved dozens of colorful signs--some hand-lettered, some professionally printed--with
slogans and graphic pictures of aborted fetuses.
GRAPHIC: PHOTOPHOTO: Abortion foes march to the Supreme Court Friday, the 26th anniversary
of Roe vs. Wade. Reuters photo.
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
LOAD-DATE: January 23, 1999
FOCUSTM
Search: General News;national abortion rights action league and hillary w/2
To narrow this search, please enter a word or phrase:
FOCUS
Example: House of Representatives
About LEXIS-NEXIS
Terms and Conditions
What's New
Copyright © 2000 LEXIS-NEXIS Group. All rights reserved.
2 of 2
7/13/2000 4:08 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/ln.univ.5=9d0dd934e6ff328c297990503721b89b
Copyright 1999 Associated Press
AP Online
January 22, 1999; Friday 15:10 Eastern Time
SECTION: Washington - general news
LENGTH: 691 words
HEADLINE: Clinton Seeks Abortion Clinic Funds
BYLINE: KALPANA SRINIVASAN
DATELINE: WASHINGTON
BODY:
Abortion clinics could use federal funds for alarm systems, bulletproof windows and closed-circuit
camera systems, under a White House plan to counter clinic violence.
The administration is seeking $4.5 million to enable clinics to bolster security measures and pay for
security assessments to determine which clinics are most at risk.
First lady Hillary Rodham Clinton made the announcement today in a speech to the National Abortion
Rights Action League on the 26th anniversary of the Supreme Court's landmark Roe vs. Wade ruling
that legalized abortion nationwide.
Meanwhile, thousands of anti-abortion advocates gathered on a grassy area just south of the White
House to sing, pray, wave signs and demand an end to what one speaker called "the unseemly and
aggressive persecution of children."
Rep. Christopher Smith, R-N.J., called on the crowd to fast and pray that President Clinton and Vice
President Gore take steps to make abortion illegal.
"The scandals that have rocked the White House pale to near insignificance when compared to the
anti-child policies so methodically pursued by our abortion president and his administration," Smith
said.
This was the 26th time the March for Life had organized a massive rally and march to the Supreme
Court and the Capitol on the anniversary of the Supreme Court decision.
"We are touching the hearts and minds of people more and more," said Teresa Snyder of South
Hampton, Pa.
"We must work to make abortion safe, legal and rare," Mrs. Clinton told an abortion-rights crowd in a
ballroom at the Omni Shoreham Hotel. "Violence, harassment and intimidation have no place in our
health care system or in the debate."
She saluted slain obstetrician Barnett Slepian of Amherst, N.Y., who was shot to death in October. She
suggested an appropriate way to honor him is to "make sure doctors are trained and available to provide
health care to women all over our nation."
When doctors are murdered or clinics are bombed, she said, "This is not free speech. This is domestic
terrorism and it must stop."
She emphasized the importance of providing contraceptives and health counseling to young women and
men to avoid teen pregnancies.
1 of 2
7/13/2000 4:09 PM
LEXIS®-NEXIS®
http://web.lexis-nexis.com/ln.univ..5=9d0dd934e6ff328c297990503721b89b
The money the president is seeking, to be included in the budget proposal for fiscal 2000, also would
help clinics purchase motion detectors and improved lighting, according to a senior administration
official, speaking on condition of anonymity.
"I think with the escalation of violence waged against abortion provider clinics, this is good news," said
Belle Taylor-McGhee, spokeswoman for NARAL. She stressed the need for doctors, abortion providers
and women to all have safe access to clinics, which provide a variety of health services.
"This is a good first step, and it's important that the administration is taking domestic terrorism
seriously," said Jacquelyn Lendsey, vice president of public policy for Planned Parenthood.
In November, Attorney General Janet Reno set up a national task force to prosecute and prevent attacks
and threats against abortion providers. The announcement was made a month after Slepian, an abortion
provider, was killed by a rifle shot fired into his home.
The task force plans to train local law enforcement and abortion providers in how to respond to and
prevent such attacks and establish a national database with all information on clinic violence.
A survey released Thursday by the Feminist Majority Foundation showed that in the first seven months
of 1998, 22 percent of clinics experienced one or more forms of violence.
These included blockades, invasions, bomb threats and bombings, arson threats and arsons, chemical
attacks, death threats and stalking. This was a slight decrease from 25 percent in 1997.
But the foundation's president, Eleanor Smeal, said even the current percentage of clinics that "are
battered day after day with violence is unconscionable."
The survey also found clinics that reported law enforcement response as "excellent" experienced lower
levels of violence than those that characterized local law enforcement as "poor."
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
LOAD-DATE: January 22, 1999
FOCUSTM
Search: General News;national abortion rights action league and hillary w/2
To narrow this search, please enter a word or phrase:
FOCUS
Example: House of Representatives
About LEXIS-NEXIS
Terms and Conditions
What's New
Copyright © 2000 LEXIS-NEXIS Group. All rights reserved.
2 of 2
7/13/2000 4:09 PM