Ask the Scholar
Document scope · 1 page
Scholar
Ask about this object, its catalog metadata, its source description, or the page inventory.
For page-specific OCR and visual context, open one of the page chats.
Scholar Source Context
Document identity
localId
55280061
label
[New Markets Tour Brainstorming Session] [2] [loose]
core
doc
dtoType
document
citationUrl
pageCount
1
Source metadata
id
55280061
sourceUrl
contentType
document
title
[New Markets Tour Brainstorming Session] [2] [loose]
citationUrl
collections
Records of the Office of Policy Development (Clinton Administration)
Lisa Green's Files
imageCount
1
hasImages
yes
source
import
hasTranscription
no
Source extras
naId
55280061
levelOfDescription
fileUnit
otherTitles
42-t-26466288-20120043S-012-012-2017
recordType
description
ocrSource
nara-archive
Single page context
seq
1
pageIndex
0
type
document
mediaId
62d30ea34d4f85f3
ocrText
08/27/99 10:20 FAX 530 792 5791
USDA NRCS CA PAZENG
101 001
Uil
FAX TO:
USDA NRCS
ATTN: Darrel Dominick
FAX: 202-720-8819
(South Bldg. Rm. 216A)
8/27/99
4 pp.
From:
Marsha Gery, California State Outreach Coordinator
USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service
530-792-5604 ph
530-792-5790 fax
RE: Multi Ethnic Center
Here is a start on some information re: the Multi-Ethnic Small Farm
and Community Development Center. I'll FedEx copies of their
quarterly reports, a San Francisco Examiner article on Black
Farmers, and a chart of our other outreach projects in CA. You
should receive these materials on Monday, Aug. 30. Hope this helps.
If you come up with any other questions, shoot them my way and I'll
do my best to find the anwers!
Marsha Gery
08
27
10.20
FAX
530
792
5791
USDA NRCS CA PAYENG
10002
Multi-Ethnic Small Farm and Community Development Center
Area Served
California Central Valley including Fresno, Madera, Stanislaus, San Joaquin, Kings. Kem
and Tulare Counties
Partners
Natural Resources Conservation Service
Rural Development
Farm Service Agency
California State University-Fresno
National Banker's Association
California Futures Institute
Central Valley Technology Center
Great Valley Center
Board of Directors
The Board is currently made up of eight minority small farmers and business persons and
meet the second Thursday of every month. Board meetings to date have averaged 90%
attendance.
Albert Smith
Chair
Small Farmer/Businessman
(also President of Black Farmers Assn.)
Powell Brannon
Vice Chair
Small Farmer/Community Activist
John Oaxaca
Farm Labor Contractor/Activist
Larry Sandoval
Secretary
Farm Superintendent
Mike Smith
Treasurer
Small Farmer
Phen Vue
President
California Highlander Cooperative
(represents 360 Southcast Asian small farmers)
Locale/Population Background
California's Central Valley is one of the most agriculturally productive areas in the world
producing 250 crops worth $13 billion each year.
Demographic Magazine recently identified the top 20 multi-ethnic cities in the nation-17 of
which are either in California or Texas. The other three are Chicago, New York and
Washington D.C. Within the top 10, four are in Central California; one of them is Fresno.
A community is considered multi-ethnic when it has at lcast two ethnic populations over
30%.
Seventy-one percent of the farms in Fresno County are operated by small farmers.
1
08
530
792
5791
USDA NRCS CA PATENG
171
The Southeast Asian community represents the fastest growing segment of small farmers in
the San Joaquin Valley. Among the 26 specialty crops and nine American fruits and
vegetables produced by Hmong, Mien and Laotian farmers, 680 acres of strawberries, 600
acres of cherry tomatoes, 750 acres of squash, 2,000 acres of green beans, 1,520 acres of
oriental vegetables and 600 acres of eggplant are cultivated.
Of the 24,660 farms in the arca, approximately 95 are operated by Black farmers.
Hispanics make up 34% of the county's population.
Project Description
The primary objective of the Multi-Ethnic Center is to create a healthy community of
historically underserved small farmers and businesses by achieving economic self-
sufficiency through coordinated public and private investment. To accomplish this vision,
the Center has developed services in four major areas: )technical assistance, 2.) access to
capital, 3.) marketing and outreach, and 4.) farmland acquisition.
The Center operates as an extended outreach tool for the USDA agencies, utilizing program
coordinators and community development specialists that have community outreach
responsibilities. Community assessments include outreach efforts that include 502/504
single family housing programs, 514/516 multifamily housing projects, business and
industry, and rural enterprise grants.
The Multi-Ethnic Center leverages outreach efforts with community-based organizations as
well as conventional financial institutions that have major community Reinvestment Act
(CRA) commitments to historically underserved rural communities.
Project Background
Congressman Calvin Dooley's office convened a planning process in early 1998 that
brought together representatives from USDA, UC Cooperative Extension, American
Farmland Trust, California State University-Fresno, and small farmers and business
persons from the Asian, African-American, and Hispanic communities. Over a series of
five meetings, the group identified the needs of traditionally underserved farmers and small
businesses currently operating in Fresno County and California Central Valley, evaluated
existing programs available, established a vision, goals, and objectives for programs to
service minority owned businesses and small farmers, and formed an advisory committee
to implement the program.
2
08 27 FAX 530 792 5791
USDA NRCS
The outcome of this planning effort was the creation of a framework (the Multi-Ethnic
Center) for carrying out the program and the establishment of a solid working relationship
between the small farm and rural communities and the agencies responsible for providing
services to them.
Monitoring Outcome
Although there are no hard statistics available at this point on the number of people served,
a database is in developmental stages. The opportunities are enormous. Relevant
economic and community development outreach includes realistic and comprehensive "real
world" measures as follows.
-Number of new, closed, or stabilized business addresses;
-Number of farm labor housing units available;
-Increases and decreases in value of locally assess tax base;
-Number of "quality" jobs created and available (measured by wages, working
environment, and benefits);
-Changes in community attitude; (measured by fewer gangs, less graffiti, home
improvements, and news articles about local development);
-Public health indicators;
-Increase and decreases in County food stamp applications;
-Quality of inventory.
The Multi-Ethnic Center will review and evaluate progress in implementing its work plan
on a quarterly basis. Based on this evaluation, the Center will submit a mid-year and an
annual report describing progress on priorities in relation to the work plan. Categories of
outcomes may include, but are not limited to:
-Building local capacity;;
-Removing barriers;
-Leveraging resources;
-Creating partnerships;
-Developing networks;
-Providing education on issues relating to agricultural practices and trends affecting
community development;
-Special initiatives and methods undertaken to overcome special challenges posed by
conditions such as remoteness, population loss, low education, agricultural land
challenges, language population diversity, physical barriers, etc.
Funding
NRCS, through an agreement with the California Association of Resource Conservation
Districts, provided $45,000 in start-up funds in FY98. Since receiving that initial funding,
the Center has leveraged it about 6 to 1.
3
SECTION
NESS
CALENDAR
2
VF
STOCKS
3
snobee.com
THE FRESNO BEE
SATURDAY, MARCH 27, 1999
THE MARKET
Dow Jones 30 Industrials
Small
farm
center
Down 14.15 points to 9,822.24
opens
Standard & Poor's 500
By JIM STEINBERG
Fresno. and the U.S. Department of
are scheduled at 4 p.m. Tuesday.
Down 7.19 points to 1,282.80
THE FRESNO BEE
Agriculture.
Speakers will include Dooley, President
The center's name is long and intim-
John Welty of Fresno State, USDA otli-
New hope and help for small and
idating: The USDA National Center for
cials and banking representatives.
"Bluntly speaking,
Nasday Composite
ethnic farmers and business owners ar-
Excellence and Multi-Ethnic Small
rives Tuesday in the central San Joa-
The only other centers of this type
minorities and women
Down 15.63 points to 2,419.17
Farm and Community Development.
quin Valley with the official opening of
operate in Kentucky, Texas, Mississippi
Its mission and reason for being are
0 small farm center in Fresno, one of
and Washington state, said Vicente Or-
simple: Ethnic and other small farmers
have not been served by
only live in the United States.
duno Jr., the center's chief administra-
and merchants deserve the same level
tive officer.
of service that larger farmers and mer-
USDA agencies. There
Experts will begin helping African-
IE NATION
American, Hispanic, Asian and other
chants receive from the USDA, other
"In many respects, this is about rural
has been flagrant
small farmers and merchants at the
federal and state agencies and lending
poverty," says Sharon Nance, a state
new venture, located at the University
institutions.
rural sociologist who works for the
"
gold fall; dollar rises
of California Center, 550 E. Shaw Ave.
The Fresno center follows a pro-
Natural Resources Conservation Ser-
neglect.
prices drilted lower in sluggish
A grass-roots effort pushed the ideal
longed legal fight by African-American
vice, a division of the USDA. "All the
farmers who sued the federal govern-
economic indicators support the need
Fruday.
for years, enlisted Rep. Cal Dooley, D-
ollar rose broadly Gold fell to
Hanford, both the University of Cali-
ment over access to loans.
for trying to give an opportunity for
- Dan Glickman, U.S.
Agriculture secretary
off $3.20. on the New York
forma and California State University,
A grand opening and ribbon culling
Please SCC Center, Page C2
de Exchange.
'y securities change little
YORK - Treasury securities
e changed Friday as investors
the escalating tensions in the
GAS PRICES SOAR
China
and several huge corporate bond
ICe of the benchmark 30-year
Fresno customers see
bond Tell 1/16 pount, or 63
$1,000 in face value. Its yield,
wes 111 the opposite direction,
costs jump by 30 cents a
willing
59% from 5 58% late Thursday
gallon and more.
broader market, prices of short-
hsury securities rose 1/16, while
By DENNIS POLLOCK
rate Treasury securities rose be.
2 and in point. from Thursday,
THE FRESNO DEE
Regula
to open
Bridge Telerate, a financial in-
A customer groaned at the
service.
pump prices at Bae Burton's gas
imman Brothers Daily Treasury
station in Fresno Friday. "Why
ex, reflecting price movements
SO lugh?" she asked.
with maturities of a year or
markets
Burton himself gronned as he
se 0.21 point to 1,282.90.
spilled an unintended pun while
uls at Irand culprits, signs
explaining a big part of the rea-
son: earlier shutdowns or signifi-
Country wants to cul a
ORR When it. comes to
cant cutbacks in production at
RIUE
1C books, small companies are
two major refineries in the state.
deal with U.S. for
.1 culprits. a new study reports.
"An explosion at another 1e-
ile the financial finagling is
finery ['I'hursday] is just adding
membership in 11.
damage 0
n'l. Half the
more fuel to the fire," he said.
in the h
dy wound up
bulled by prices in recent
ing their
reorganizing
SATURDAY, MARCH 27, 1999
THE FRESNO BEE
enter: Dooley credited with crucial role in project
ned from Page CI
Glickman established the latest
ment and a federal judge has is-
aucestry who have been "under-
larger farming operations and
"I think the times - consoli-
to work. If it comes in
center, in part to redress the
sued a Monday deadline for filing
served" by government and lend-
businesses 33 antagonists.
dation and concentration for
ercial agriculture, line. It
USDA's and other agencies' fail-
objections to the government's
ing agencies.
"This is beneficial for every-
lorger markets - will present
sense."
me to serve small farmers and
revised settlement proposal.
Palacios has worked with Val-
body," she said. "There is no at-
opportunities for local growers,"
CC points to small farmer
rural business owners of African-
Officials of the new Fresno
ley farmworkers for the Ford
titude of us versus the status
Kirkpatrick said. Ile mentioned
Palacios as "the energy
American, Hispanic, Asian,
center point to Dooley as playing
Foundation and has owned an
quo. I think it's high time that
"colonies" in such areas as
I that center." Palacios
American Indian and other eth-
a central role in getting it. Dool-
interpreters service, check cash-
organizations come together."
southwest and southeast Fresno,
119 president of the cen-
nic ancestry. Orduno said.
ey said Friday from Washington,
ing and travel service businesses.
The new organization is nego-
Easton and Kearney Park.
porate board Orduno
"Bluntly speaking," he said,
D.C., that recent immigrants
She farmed 22 years along Man-
tiating to buy 15 acres in Fresno
Farmers bought 20- and 40-
at other staff members in-
"minorities and women have not
who brought Lastes and farming
ning Avenue until last yeur,
for a one-stop center for farmers
acre parcels, forming n farming
l'onins Martinez, a former
been served by USDA agencies.
techniques from Southeast Asia
growing grapes, cotton, suybeans
and rural small business owners.
mosaje, he said. Many large com-
State crimmology profes.
There has been flagrant neglect
or other areas represent a model
and alfalla.
Plans call for a federal credit
mercial growers aren't interested
incation professor Robert
That's why you have the black
for "niche" market farming that
Palacios said the center's bud-
union. training and extensions
in farming such small parcels to-
of Fresno State; manage-
farmers' class-action lawsuit."
can succeed in the Valley.
get, financed through the USDA
for such groups as Future Farm-
day, and families can earn an
professor Dewey Johnson,
Years of effort to set up the
"Agriculture is an enterprise
and private donors. was submit-
ers of America and 4-H.
income by intensive, "hands-on"
r of Fresno State's Small
Fresno center coincided with the
that some of our recent immi-
ted this week at $350,000, but it
In Visalia, Greg Kirkpatrick
production of niche crops.
AS Institute: and adminis-
National Black Farmers Associa-
grants are most familiar with
could reach to $1 million or more
represented the American Farm-
"The American Farmland
assistant Terry Fleming.
tion lawsuit alleging USDA dis-
and interested in continuing, he
by year's end.
land Trust, a national organiza-
Trust is interested because these
center will serve Fresno,
emmination by denying or stall-
said They farm small plots, and
"History shows that minorities
tion dedicated to preserving
are the areas most threatened by
1, Tulare, Kings, Kern and
ing federal loans.
their smaller-scale operations
have a tougher time getting ac-
farming, in helping launch the
urban sprawl," Kirkpatrick said.
1119 counties, concentrat-
The group reached D settle-
can succeed economically if
cess to capital," she said "It has
new center.
"They are the buffer between cit-
specific objectives: techni-
ment on its $3 billion complaint
joined to niche marketing, Dool-
been very difficult getting ser-
The farmland trust has
ies and larger farms. It is impor-
islance; access to capital,
in January, and payments to
ey said. But the small farm cen-
vices of the Department of Agri-
worked about three years with
tant Lo make them economically
ting and research; and
farmers may eventually exceed
ter extends beyond ethnic groups
culture."
Hmong ropresentatives, the
viable. As the saying goes, the
nd acquisition.
$300 million. However, some of
to include other small rural
Palacios took pains emphasiz-
USDA, the two university sys-
best way to protect formland is
culture Secretary Dan
the farmers oppose the settle-
farmers and merchants of any
ing that the center doesn't view
terms and Dooley's office.
to farm it
Gas: Prices leap 30 cents or
more within weeks in Fresno
usiness calendar
Continued from Page CI
Warren Maguire, owner of
Iding Your Busi-
He said the record high pre-
Maguire's Airport Chevron,
a seminar ollered by
viously registered in the AAA
said he W85 surprised gas
ntral California chapter
survey of mostly Northern Cal-
prices had dropped as low as
Service Corps of Re-
ifornia stations was $1.60 in
they did in recent months.
recutives - 9 a.m -4
May 1996.
"I was sure we would never
IS. Small Business
Moreno said a special survey
500 gas below a dollar, even at
stration Office confer-
of prices in select cities will be
Arco," he said. "If you go back
om, 2719 N. Air Fres-
released Tuesday because of
two or three years 3go, you saw
e, Fresno. Cost: $30
the rapid climb.
oil at $20 a borrel. A little over
son. Pre-registration
Tuesday's survey will not in-
a month ago, it was barely $11.
nmended. Details:
clude Fresno, but it will include
It's around $16 now."
31, ext. 102; JoAhne
Sacrainento. San Francisco,
at 346-0380.
San Jose, Oakland, Reno, Las
A plan by the Organization
3Za Lawyers' Dinner
Vegas and Salt Lake City.
of the Petroleum Exporting
Countries to cut the world's
9 p.m.- 1:30 a.m.,
Both Moreno and Burton say
those who sell gasoline at retail
supply of oil is not yet a signifi-
Inca banquet hall,
have had no recourse as prices
cant factor in the state's price
iolumne St., Fresno.
for their deliveries have risen.
increases, said Will Woods, ex-
10 per person; $20
ecutive director of the Automo-
tents Details:
No escape from increases
tive Trade Organizations of
10.
"If a customer has a hard
California, an Irvine-based
Lime paying $2 more for a
trade group representing more
tankful of gas," Burton said,
than 2,000 gasoline retailers.
Markets
"imagine having to pay $2,000
"At. least half of our gasoline
more In two days, a 9,000-gal-
is domestically produced, and
lon load for ure went up to
some comes from
"
zuela,"
in
St
ASSOCIATED TRESS
$12,000. an increase of $2,000."
Woods said. "It t:
to 15
A vendor sells Teletubby dolls in Sao Paulo, Brazil, as residents look fo
sources of
Guy Land ARC 884-7674 [email protected]
Lara Muldoon Treas 622-6773 [email protected] Do.
Seth Harris DOL 693-6073 Horris-Seth @ DOL.GOV
TADE SULLIVAN USDA 720-0164 TADE_SULLIVAN@ wdc, fsa.
usda.
gov
Author: Linda Lawson at ostnovp
Date:
09/15/1999 7:52 PM
Priority: Urgent
Receipt Requested
TO: Linda Darr at OSTNOV2
Subject: attached rough cut new markets ideas
Linda,
As you know, this is rough cut and needs lots of vetting. It is a
summary of the discussion. Also is below in case you don't have the
time to open the other one.
L
Potential Locations for New Markets II
Hartford, Connecticut - A city that is committed to economic
revitalization in partnership with private sector interests. A key
representative of the private sector community - Aetna Insurance -
has, through its CEO, expressed a strong interest in having the
President visit Hartford as part of this NMI tour. He was an active
participant in the first NMI trip. Hartford has been working
diligently on transportation to get welfare recipients and other low
income people to jobs and has recently received a DOT Job Access
grant.
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania - While the economic dislocations caused by
the decline of the steel and other heavy industries in this area have
been largely absorbed, there continue to be pockets of poverty and
unemployment. Surrounding communities, like Aliquippa and Homestead,
continue to be depressed, as do in town communities such as the hill
district. There is a strong corporate headquarters presence (e.g., US
Steel) and the principal US Airways hub at Pittsburgh International
Airport. These provide opportunities to develop private sector
involvement. The Pittsburgh Area Transit system is an active and
innovative transit provider.
Access to Financing DOT's innovative financing program - the
Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act (TIFIA) - -
will provide loan guarantees that leverage private sector financing
that that otherwise might not be available for some major
transportation projects. While final decisions have not yet been
made, an intermodal terminal in Miami, Florida may be one of the
recipients of a TIFIA loan. If so, Miami would be a potential new
market initiative site. This project is expected to spur job growth
for the community. Miami, is a city with diverse ethnic communities,
and a relatively high proportion of elderly Americans that includes an
Enterprise Zone.
Displaced workers in rural/natural resource/farm communities: Small
family-owned farms in America's Heartland are suffering from low
market values and rising production costs. Small communities in the
rural northwest whose economies are based natural resource industries
are prey to the same fate. Public/private partnerships are needed in
order to revitalize economic development and bring new jobs to these
locations. This could be focused on hard-hit Iowa or Nebraska rural
farm communities or coastal fishing or lumber towns.
Southwest border: Communities of poverty riddle America's southwest
border. Basic infrastructure, housing sewer, and roads are lacking.
Large immigrant communities reside in these locations. While some
border communities have benefited from increased trade, these
communities are true examples of the new markets initiative and need
investments to spur economic development and provide new jobs.
Author: Linda Lawson at ostnovp
Date:
09/15/1999 7:52 PM
Priority: Urgent
Receipt Requested
TO: Linda Darr at OSTNOV2
Subject: attached rough cut new markets ideas
Linda,
As you know, this is rough cut and needs lots of vetting. It is a
summary of the discussion. Also is below in case you don't have the
time to open the other one. L
Potential Locations for New Markets II
Hartford, Connecticut - A city that is committed to economic
revitalization in partnership with private sector interests. A key
representative of the private sector community - Aetna Insurance
has, through its CEO, expressed a strong interest in having the
President visit Hartford as part of this NMI tour. He was an active
participant in the first NMI trip. Hartford has been working
diligently on transportation to get welfare recipients and other low
income people to jobs and has recently received a DOT Job Access
grant.
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania - While the economic dislocations caused by
the decline of the steel and other heavy industries in this area have
been largely absorbed, there continue to be pockets of poverty and
unemployment. Surrounding communities, like Aliquippa and Homestead,
continue to be depressed, as do in town communities such as the hill
district. There is a strong corporate headquarters presence (e.g., US
Steel) and the principal US Airways hub at Pittsburgh International
Airport. These provide opportunities to develop private sector
involvement. The Pittsburgh Area Transit system is an active and
innovative transit provider.
Access to Financing DOT's innovative financing program - the
Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act (TIFIA)
will provide loan guarantees that leverage private sector financing
that that otherwise might not be available for some major
transportation projects. While final decisions have not yet been
made, an intermodal terminal in Miami, Florida may be one of the
recipients of a TIFIA loan. If so, Miami would be a potential new
market initiative site. This project is expected to spur job growth
for the community. Miami, is a city with diverse ethnic communities,
and a relatively high proportion of elderly Americans that includes an
Enterprise Zone.
Displaced workers in rural/natural resource/farm communities: Small
family-owned farms in America's Heartland are suffering from low
market values and rising production costs. Small communities in the
rural northwest whose economies are based natural resource industries
are prey to the same fate. Public/private partnerships are needed in
order to revitalize economic development and bring new jobs to these
locations. This could be focused on hard-hit Iowa or Nebraska rural
farm communities or coastal fishing or lumber towns.
Southwest border: Communities of poverty riddle America's southwest
border. Basic infrastructure, housing sewer, and roads are lacking.
Large immigrant communities reside in these locations. While some
border communities have benefited from increased trade, these
communities are true examples of the new markets initiative and need
investments to spur economic development and provide new jobs.
RUST Belt / NEW ongland / urban Indians /
-Julian Potter
69044
DOL. 0
- Nat'l Academy Foundation-
< X Schools w/in schools. business/ED focus. technology
^
- Romd III
- community focus /march -up
- Tribal/urban
^ tribal colleges /Amesican Indian Patnership
formal internship committment
SEATLE minneapolis.
V. formal. Bus Linc tribal
- YOUTH Offender Program. (Seattle)
GAngs
11<
Sears Tower. Minneupolis.
S
- BofA - Rmal Call CenTERS -
- NEW Scattle. tele commuting.
- Wildcar <San Antonio>
- Mills : Newark.
OTHERS NAVY STORES
- TJMax -> AJ Wright Anchun Stores
GM9
Alt/chi/Det - BosTon.current
- Rust Belt
^ Faith Based )capital/ Housing
JOBS
^ Connecting financial institutions to
the faith based community- -
Partnerships / goals
"Faith. Bused Linc"
<
Small business/access to Capital
New Market Tour Opportunities
The Welfare to Work Partnership
Mary 65571 Smith
Site: TBD
Corporate Champion: Citigroup
Theme: Expansion of Wildcat job training program
Summary: Salomon Smith Barney's successful welfare to work effort has not
yet been integrated into Citigroup's overall hiring program. The company
would announce the expansion of their partnership with Wildcat and the
launch of new training programs around the country in cities like San Antonio.
Site: Newark, NJ (Meadowlands)
Corporate Champion: Mills Corporation
Theme: Permanent, construction and entrepreneurial opportunities for
employment
Summary: Mills hopes to connect their large-scale mall developments with
existing sports centers. As with other developments around the country, Mills
plans to work with the Rockefellar Foundation, the City of Newark,
community organizations and training/employment intermediaries to develop
and implement recruitment, hiring and retention program.
Site(s): Atlanta, Chicago, and Detroit. (Currently, the program operates in
Boston, through a partnership with Morgan Memorial Goodwill.)
Corporate Champion: TJX Companies
Theme: Inner city investment
Summary: The corporation is also opening a new line of stores, A.J. Wright in
areas where large businesses have left and where the community is seeking a
major business to anchor a store. The A.J. Wright stores will be established in
numerous inner cities in the northeast.
More information to follow on all of the above examples.
attended
Don Grows - Treasury. 622
CEa. Dong almond - 55012
Condinated Octivity, Presiness
Mary 65571 Smith
Proposed New Markets Initiative Site: Minneapolis, MN
Minneapolis, MN is a promising site for a Presidential New Markets Initiative event. With
a focus on creating economic opportunities, Minneapolis is an example of large untapped
markets and newly mobilized communities. As of April 1999, over 10 businesses,
including banks, had commitments under the Welfare-to-Work Partnership. Moreover, all
of the welfare reform, economic development, job creation, education, housing, child care
and transportation issues that are prevalent on a national basis are more than evident in
Minneapolis.
The Minneapolis/St.Paul metropolitan area has the single largest urban Indian population
in the United States. The Twin Cities also account for the largest diversity of cultures per
capita for a city of their size. With this large population and great diversity, however,
comes a vast need for appropriate services and opportunities, as well as ample ingenuity
on behalf of the Indian service providers to meet the needs of their clients.
Minneapolis is a thriving center for urban Indian welfare-to-work activities. The Indian
community has been working diligently and effectively on Welfare Reform since 1996.
They have formed partnerships with a large number of Indian and non-Indian businesses
and corporations, in both the public and private sectors. The American Indian Partnership,
a coalition of over 30 organizations and agencies in Hennepin County (including the 6
largest Native non-profit agencies in city), have joined together to facilitate welfare-to-work
from cultural standpoint. This model has been so successful that it is expanding to other
areas of Minnesota, as well as to other states.
The Minneapolis campus of the Native American Educational Service (NAES) Tribal
College has also been quite involved in welfare reform and opening economic
opportunities for Native students. In the past year, NAES has developed a curriculum
about welfare reform and, supported by funding from the W. K. Kellogg Foundation, have
held their first community forum about devolution and welfare reform. These community
forums, including service providers, welfare recipients, students and other members of the
community, will continue in the coming years.
In addition to efforts made in by tribal organizations in Minneapolis itself, the surrounding
region has a wealth of successful tribally-administered programs. The regional, inter-tribal
organization, the Midwest Alliance of Sovereign Tribes, represents tribes from Minnesota,
Michigan, Wisconsin, and lowa and works closely with North Dakota and South Dakota
tribes. Moreover, Minnesota is a long-standing Democratic state, with tribes supporting
and contributing resources to national and local Democratic campaigns, including
President Clinton.
MEMORANDUM
Minneapolis
To:
Maurice Jones : Treasury
Deputy Director for Policy and Programs, CDFI Fund
From:
Bill Luecht
External Affairs, CDFI Fund
Re:
Results from CDFI Fund brainstorming session on second new markets trip
Possible Themes
Continuum of Capital
(Coastal, Working Capital, BAC in FL, check with SELP)
Faith Based Community Development
(Leviticus, Mercy Loan Fund, McAuley, Faith Cmmunity, New Community, souther
credit unions)
Industries stepping up to the plate before CRA like regulations (Insurance,
Telecommunications, & Utilities)
(IFF and Alstate, DVCDLF and utilities, etc.)
Funding of facilities: child care centers, health care centers, youth centers and other
facilities)
(NFF and youth centers, PCDC and health center)
State establishing CDFI Fund like programs
(Pennsylvania, etc.)
Social conscious investing/community development venture capital
Rural Infrastructure
(RCAC, Rural LISC, etc)
Geographic Areas
New England (rural, fishing industry, agriculture)
(NHCLF, VCLF, Coastal, BCC/BCLF, Working Capital, NJCLF, CBAC, etc.)
Southern States (CDCUs)
Rust Belt (rural, manufacturing, decaying urban industrial areas)
(CLFSWP- Pittsburgh, N.E. Ventures - Ore belt, Sable, Legacy - Milwaukee)
Pacific Northwest (rural, agriculture, microenterprise development)
(Cascadia)
Rural West (infrastructure)
(RCAC, Rural LISC)
ARIEL Zwang HUD
HUD
708.0614 4839
New Markets
List of High-Possibility Sites as of 9/15/99
Site
Info Provided for First New Markets Tour
Info Received from Field Since September 10
CT. New Haven
New EZ: was designated EC in '95. Omni took over only large downtown hotel; complete rehab using
welfare-to-work trainees has resulted in 85 permanent jobs. HOPE VI awarded approx. '94 now underway;
365 units to come down. NOTE: FBI is investigating a livable cities initiative grant.
FL. Palm Beach
Issue would be dichotomy between haves and have-nots. A number of homeless projects there (Awaiting
/WPB
detailed info.)
IN. Gary
ACE Hardware.
Field reminds that Secly was there in March to announce EZ designation (with 2 neighboring cities).
Consortium of local banks established $50 million pool for Zone. Zone expects 3000 jobs created over 3
years. Also $19.8 HOPE VI award this year. Total HUD dollars !995-99: $118 million.
MA. Boston
Dudley Square.
New EZ. Field says Dudley Square still a good choice, much to look at. Adjacent neighborhood is Grove
Hall, where EZ investment is making inroads.
MI: Benton
Harbor
CDFI''
Proposed by field. "Most distressed central city in Michigan." 1998 HUD/Cornerstone Foundation Financial
Summit. BEDI grant, $1.5 million 108 loan., significant other HUD involvement. (AZ checking for private
sector involvement.)
7 Flinr
(No project identified.)
City continues to reel from plant closings. New Homeownership Zone will include 309 homes: total $50
million investment of which $2 million from HUD. Mayor has announced Buick City Task Force to
strategize attracting new business. Universities partnering in small business development.
MN, Minneapolis
New EZ. Sears Tower redevelopment for multi-use complex, Phillips Eco-Enterprise Center. EZ was critical
in developing both. More direct HUD role unclear.
NY. Buffalo
Mile-long abandoned rail corridor converted to new parkway; $7m investment included $1 from EZ and $1
from HUD. Buffalo Medical Corridor area includes medical enterprises. businesses; $9.7 million 108 loan
for 100-room hotel. LTV Steel will donate 100-350 acres for multi-year redevelopment to retain/create
5,000-8,000 jobs. Inner Harbor project will encourage recreational, cultural activities and tourism; HUD
recently announced EDI and 108 funding totaling $9.2 million in this year, which will result in 1000 new
jobs. Former GM plant was purchased by American Axle & Manufacturing, creating largest mfg employer in
Buffalo. 300 jobs created: 7 new businesses now located nearby.
NY. New York
Harlem USA: major retail complex in EZ.
200 construction jobs, plus 300 permanent.
Broadway Video: 20 jobs for EZ residents
in high-tech post-production facility.
NY. Rochester
Upper Falls Shopping Center: $3m EZ, $980,000 CDBG, more than $4m in other local and federal funds,
$2.8 m private sector. Anchor tenant is Tops supermarket that gives preference in training and hiring to
neighborhood residents: more than 120 jobs created. August '99 EDI award for Sx to German-Simonow for
renovations and upgrades of their facilities. City and HUD have executed one of the first Single Family Asset
Control Agreements in the county.
PA. McKeesport
People's Building Family Support Project:
Various HUD investments
$750k in EC funds developed complex of
30 human service agencies.
TX, Fort Worth
Minyards Grocery: outstanding project
combined public. private investment to
create 165 jobs and attract additional
businesses. First local grocery in over 20
years.
DRAFT
Peter Hamm
219.6871
Potential Sites and Cities
for a Potential New Markets Tour
U.S. Department of Labor Programs
Note: all specific sites listed are subject to further review and vetting.
NEWARK, NJ
SPORTS TEAMS - LIVABILITY - WELFARE TO WORK
Site TBD
Newark
The President and the Secretary join Nets owner Ray
Chambers, players for the New Jersey Nets and other New
Mills
York area athletes and business leaders for an announcement
of a major financial investment and partnership effort to
Cord
revitalize inner-city Newark, creating jobs for local Welfare-
to-Work clients and out-of-school youth and youthful
offenders.
Contact: Ana Ma for Ray Bramucci, DOL, 202-693-2700
DENVER, CO
OUT OF SCHOOL YOUTH
Manual High School
1700 E. 28th Street
Denver
The President/Secretary visits Manual High School, taking a
tour of the school's Technology Lab, where vocational
students will demonstrate one of the many programs and
tutorials available on computer work stations, such as a flight
has
simulator program. Joined by Mayor Wellington Webb, local
businessman Rollie Heath, additional businesses that pledge
commitments and young people from the high school and
other local out-of-school youth programs including a new
Youth Opportunity program.
Contact: Wilma Webb, 303-844-1256
Page 2
DETROIT, MI
WELFARE TO WORK, OUT OF SCHOOL YOUTH
Arbor Career Center
1500 Southfield Freeway
Detroit
The President, the Secretary and area CEOs from the big three
automakers tour this highly rated One Stop Career Center,
announcing linkages between Michigan's Welfare-to-Work
program and Detroit's new Youth Opportunity grant to major
area employers.
Contact: Willie Walker, Detroit SDA, 313-876-0674
BOSTON, MA
OUT OF SCHOOL YOUTH, MANUFACTURING
Site: TBD
The President/Secretary convene a meeting of Boston Mayor
Thomas Menino's high-energy Youth Council, made possible
by passage of the landmark Workforce Investment Act, and
area CEOs pledging jobs.
Contact: Thomas O'Brien, Boston SDA, 617-722-4300
SEATTLE, WA
OUT OF SCHOOL YOUTH, YOUTH VIOLENCE
Safe Futures Youth Center
6337 35th Avenue SW
Police
Seattle
The President/Secretary join law enforcement and business
leaders at this center, one of several possible sites that are
involved in a wide-ranging effort by Seattle to crack down on
runaway gang activity by getting young people out of gangs
and into meaningful jobs.
Page 3
Contact: Alfred Starr, Seattle/King SDA, 206-448-0474
NEW ORLEANS, LA
OUT-OF-SCHOOL YOUTH
New Orleans Job Corps Center
3801 Hollygrove Street
New Orleans
The President/Secretary tour the Job Corps Center,
representing the federal government's most effective, long-
running program to help out-of-school and at-risk youth, with
New Orleans area business leaders. Announcements include a
new agreement linking the Job Corps system nationwide with
the Americorps program.
Contact: Jose deOlivares, Regional Job Corps, 214-767-2567
ATLANTA, GA
OUT-OF-SCHOOL YOUTH, WELFARE-TO-WORK
Bell South
5375 Chamblee Dunwoody Road
(Or other facility)
Atlanta
The President/Secretary tour a Bell South facility where youth
and former welfare recipients are at work, as Bell South
announces a major national commitment to employ at-risk
2000
youth and Welfare-to-Work participants.
Contact: Stephanie Swirsky, DOL 202-693-6006
MEMORANDUM
To:
Maurice Jones
Deputy Director for Policy and Programs, CDFI Fund
From:
Bill Luecht
External Affairs, CDFI Fund
Re:
Results from CDFI Fund brainstorming session on second new markets trip
Possible Themes
Continuum of Capital
Faith Based Community Development
Industries stepping up to the plate before CRA like regulations (Insurance,
Telecommunications, & Utilities)
Funding of facilities: child care centers, health care centers, youth centers and other
facilities)
State establishing CDFI Fund like programs
Social conscious investing/community development venture capital
Rural Infrastructure
Geographic Areas
New England
Southern States
Rust Belt
Pacific Northwest
Rural West
Lisa Green
09/15/99 06:41:13 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Elizabeth J. Potter/OVP@OVP, Carl Haacke/OPD/EOP@EOP, Jackson T. Dunn/WHO/EOP@EOP,
Kathleen K. Ahn/WHO/EOP@EOP
CC:
Jonathan A. Kaplan/OPD/EOP@EOP, Melissa G. Green/OPD/EOP@EOP
Subject: Small Groups for Tomorrow's Brainstorming Session on New Markets
brainstormingagenda.dbrainstmemotogene.ddeas for 2nd trip.do
Thank you for agreeing to help facilitate tomorrow's small groups for the Brainstorming Session on New
Markets. Each group will consist of representatives from various agencies, as well as internal White
House Staff. My expectation is that no group will have more than 2 people from the same agency.
Your role will be to
1) Be a timekeeper. Please make sure the small group ends by 11:45, which is the time on the
schedule/agenda. Realistically, you will probably run a little bit over, but please try to have eveyrone back
in the main room -- 231 no later than 12:00.
2) Track all of the ideas. By no means am I asking you to be a notetaker (in fact you may want to ask if
anyone in the group wants to be a recorder). But after the session I would like to know what all the ideas
were that came up (not just the five that get reported back to the larger group), so that I can record them.
One sentence -- verbally after the meeting -- or on paper for each idea is fine.
3) Keep any one person from hogging the floor. Please try to encourage input and participation from
everyone.
4) Collect any paper that is distributed. Some agencies will come prepared with paper on their ideas.
I've heard that a few offices have had their own internal brainstorming sessions. I want to make sure that
we get copies of any written product that folks are willing to share.
5) Encourage thinking out of the box. Please make people feel that all ideas are welcome and that
nothing is too crazy for consideration. This is meant to be a brainstorming session where
anything/everything goes.
Thanks again for agreeing to facilitate the small groups. If you have any other thoughts ideas please let
me know first thing in the morning. Also, don't forget that, in addition to being a facilitator you should
contribute your own ideas.
See you tomorrow, unless of course we are all flooded out by Floyd.
Lisa Green
09/15/99 06:50:03 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Jackson T. Dunn/WHO/EOP@EOP, Carl Haacke/OPD/EOP@EOP, Elizabeth J. Potter/OVP@OVP,
Kathleen K. Ahn/WHO/EOP@EOP
CC:
Jonathan A. Kaplan/OPD/EOP@EOP
Subject: Rooms for Tomorrow's Brainstorming Session
Just so you know ahead of time --- the groups will be as follows
Jay - Room 209
Group #1
Julian - Room 231
Group #2
Carl - Room 221
Group #3
Kathleen - Room 231
Group #4
I'm just going to have folks count off 1-2-3-4 to break up into groups. I have a list of who's coming but 1
think there may be some no shows because of tomorrow's weather, so I'm hesitant to create pre-assigned
groups.
If we end up with too many people and we need five groups, I will facilitate the fifth group. But I think it will
work best if I'm able to circulate in case there are questions or problems.
September 15, 1999
MEMORANDUM TO GENE SPERLING
FROM:
LISA GREEN
SUBJECT:
NEW MARKETS BRAINSTORMING SESSION
Background
We are holding a brainstorming session in preparation for the second trip and in effort to be more
creative and prolific with New Markets events over the next fourth months. This an informal
session designed to encourage innovative ideas for the trip or separate stand alone events.
Agenda and Format
We will open with the full interagency working group gathered in one room.
A few minutes will be spent talking about the goals of the New Markets Initiative, to
encourage private sector investment in economically distressed communities, and how we
can accomplish a great deal even without legislation.
We will emphasize the importance of thinking of the New Markets Initiative as an ongoing
effort. The brainstorming session is not just about the trip but about ways we can promote
the goals of the New Markets Initiative, through the President's use of the bully pulpit and
other efforts.
We will then ask the group to comment on what elements of the 1st trip were particularly
good and what lessons we learned that can be used to make the 2nd trip and other New
Markets events even better.
I will refer to the four M's as a way to think about events for New Markets.
Mobilization of the Private Sector - The themes that we focus on and the places we
visit must center upon the role of the private investment in helping to improve conditions
in poor communities. We want to involve the private sector and encourage them to
respond to specific challenges, revolving around certain themes or locations.
Memorable Settings - We are looking for places to visit that will be of interest and will
bring attention to the needs of distressed communities. As in the first trip, we also want
these places to illustrate the possibilities under the right conditions and given the right
tools.
Moving Stories - Accordingly, we want to be able to point to some signs of hope ---
storeis that show something good has happened in the community, preferably as a result
of a program that was created or expanded under the Clinton-Gore Administration.
Measurable Impact - Ultimately, we want companies to establish goals that can be
measured, so that we can look back in a year or more and point to concrete
accomplishments that would not have happened without the New Markets effort.
The session will then breakout into smaller groups that will be asked to come up with at least
five ideas. The small groups will be encouraged to think out of the box. The interagency
working group as also provided beforehand with the attached set of ideas to start people
thinking. A copy of that idea sheet will be provided for each the smaller groups. There is a
White House sta: f person helping to facilitate each of the small group sessions.
We will close by bringing the larger group back together and asking for reports from each of
the facilitators an comments from the entire group.
Followup
Agencies have already been asked to submit memos by Monday September 20 on ideas for both
locations and themes for the second trip. We expect that some of the ideas from this
brainstorming session will be fleshed out in more detail in these memos.
Patrik / constory Nawsal
I
AGENDA
BRAINSTORMING SESSION FOR NEW MARKETS
Room 231 Old Executive Office Building
10:30 AM - 12:30 PM
I.
Introductions il nd Overview (10:30 - 10:45 AM)
Goals for The New Markets Initiative
Review of the 1" Trip's Success
The Four Ms
Need for an Ongoing Effort
Instruct ons for Breakout Groups
II.
Breakout Groups (10:45 - 11:45)
III.
Reports and Wrap-up (11:45 -- 12:30)
Author: Linda Lawson at ostnovp
Date:
09/15/1999 7:52 PM
Priority: Urgent
Receipt Requested
TO: Linda Darr at OSTNOV2
Subject: attached rough cut new markets ideas
Linda,
As you know, this is rough cut and needs lots of vetting. It is a
summary of the discussion. Also is below in case you don't have the
time to open the other one. L
Potential Locations for New Markets II
Hartford, Connecticut - A city that is committed to economic
revitalization in partnership with private sector interests. A key
representative of the private sector community - Aetna Insurance
has, through its CEC, expressed a strong interest in having the
President visit Hartford as part of this NMI tour. He was an active
participant in the first NMI trip. Hartford has been working
diligently on transportation to get welfare recipients and other low
income people to jobs and has recently received a DOT Job Access
grant.
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania - While the economic dislocations caused by
the decline of the steel and other heavy industries in this area have
been largely absorbed, there continue to be pockets of poverty and
unemployment. Surrounding communities, like Aliquippa and Homestead,
continue to be depressed, as do in town communities such as the hill
district. There is a strong corporate headquarters presence (e.g., US
Steel) and the principal US Airways hub at Pittsburgh International
Airport. These provide opportunities to develop private sector
involvement. The Pittsburgh Area Transit system is an active and
innovative transit provider.
Access to Financing DOT's innovative financing program - the
Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act (TIFIA)
will provide loan guarantees that leverage private sector financing
that that otherwise might not be available for some major
transportation projects. While final decisions have not yet been
made, an intermodal terminal in Miami, Florida may be one of the
recipients of a TIFEA loan. If SO, Miami would be a potential new
market initiative site. This project is expected to spur job growth
for the community. Miami, is a city with diverse ethnic communities,
and a relatively high proportion of elderly Americans that includes an
Enterprise Zone.
Displaced workers in rural/natural resource/farm communities: Small
family-owned farms ..n America's Heartland are suffering from low
market values and r.sing production costs. Small communities in the
rural northwest whose economies are based natural resource industries
are prey to the same fate. Public/private partnerships are needed in
order to revitalize economic development and bring new jobs to these
locations. This could be focused on hard-hit Iowa or Nebraska rural
farm communities or coastal fishing or lumber towns.
Southwest border: Communities of poverty riddle America's southwest
border. Basic infrastructure, housing sewer, and roads are lacking.
Large immigrant communities reside in these locations. While some
border communities have benefited from increased trade, these
communities are true examples of the new markets initiative and need
investments to spur economic development and provide new jobs.
Lisa Green
09/15/99 06 41:13 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Elizabeth J. Potter/OVP@OVP, Carl Haacke/OPD/EOP@EOP, Jackson T. Dunn/WHO/EOP@EOP,
Kathleen K. Ahn/WHO/EOP@EOP
CC:
Jonathan A. Kablan/OPD/EOP@EOP, Melissa G. Green/OPD/EOP@EOP
Subject: Small Groups for Tomorrow's Brainstorming Session on New Markets
brainstormingagenda. dbrainstmemotogene.ddea for 2nd trip.do
Thank you for agreeing to help facilitate tomorrow's small groups for the Brainstorming Session on New
Markets. Each group will consist of representatives from various agencies,as well as internal White
House Staff. My expectation is that no group will have more than 2 people from the same agency.
Your role will be to
1) Be a timekeeper. Flease make sure the small group ends by 11:45, which is the time on the
schedule/agenda. Realistically, you will probably run a little bit over, but please try to have eveyrone back
in the main room -- 231 no later than 12:00.
2) Track all of the ideas. By no means am I asking you to be a notetaker (in fact you may want to ask if
anyone in the group wants to be a recorder). But after the session I would like to know what all the ideas
were that came up (not just the five that get reported back to the larger group), so that I can record them.
One sentence -- verbal y after the meeting -- or on paper for each idea is fine.
3) Keep any one person from hogging the floor. Please try to encourage input and participation from
everyone.
4) Collect any paper that is distributed. Some agencies will come prepared with paper on their ideas.
I've heard that a few of ices have had their own internal brainstorming sessions. I want to make sure that
we get copies of any written product that folks are willing to share.
5) Encourage thinking out of the box. Please make people feel that all ideas are welcome and that
nothing is too crazy for consideration. This is meant to be a brainstorming session where
anything/everything goes.
Thanks again for agree to facilitate the small groups. If you have any other thoughts ideas please let
me know first thing in the morning. Also, don't forget that, in addition to being a facilitator you should
contribute your own ideas.
See you tomorrow, unless of course we are all flooded out by Floyd.
Lisa Green
09/15/99 06:50:03 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Jackson T. Durin/WHO/EOP@EOP, Carl Haacke/OPD/EOP@EOP, Elizabeth J. Potter/OVP@OVP,
Kathleen K. Ah n/WHO/EOP@EOP
CC:
Jonathan A. (plan/OPD/EOP@EOP
Subject: Rooms for Tom orrow's Brainstorming Session
Just so you know ahead of time --- the groups will be as follows
Jay - Room 209
Group #1
Julian - Room 231
Group #2
Carl - Room 221
Group #3
Kathleen - Room 231
Group #4
I'm just going to have folks count off 1-2-3-4 to break up into groups. I have a list of who's coming but I
think there may be some no shows because of tomorrow's weather, so I'm hesitant to create pre-assigned
groups.
If we end up with too m any people and we need five groups, I will facilitate the fifth group. But I think it will
work best if I'm able to circulate in case there are questions or problems.
September 15, 1999
MEMORANDUM TO GENE SPERLING
FROM:
LISA GREEN
SUBJECT:
NEW MARKETS BRAINSTORMING SESSION
Background
We are holding a bra instorming session in preparation for the second trip and in effort to be more
creative and prolific with New Markets events over the next fourth months. This an informal
session designed to encourage innovative ideas for the trip or separate stand alone events.
Agenda and Forma:
We will open with the full interagency working group gathered in one room.
A few minutes will be spent talking about the goals of the New Markets Initiative, to
encourage private sector investment in economically distressed communities, and how we
can accomplish a great deal even without legislation.
We will emphasi the importance of thinking of the New Markets Initiative as an ongoing
effort. The brainstorming session is not just about the trip but about ways we can promote
the goals of the New Markets Initiative, through the President's use of the bully pulpit and
other efforts.
We will then ask the group to comment on what elements of the 1st trip were particularly
good and what lessons we learned that can be used to make the 2nd trip and other New
Markets events even better.
I will refer to the four M's as a way to think about events for New Markets.
Mobilization of the Private Sector - The themes that we focus on and the places we
visit must center upon the role of the private investment in helping to improve conditions
in poor communities. We want to involve the private sector and encourage them to
respond to specific challenges, revolving around certain themes or locations.
Memorable Settings - We are looking for places to visit that will be of interest and will
bring attention to the needs of distressed communities. As in the first trip, we also want
these places o illustrate the possibilities under the right conditions and given the right
tools.
Moving Stories - Accordingly, we want to be able to point to some signs of hope
storeis that show something good has happened in the community, preferably as a result
of a program that was created or expanded under the Clinton-Gore Administration.
Measurable Impact - Ultimately, we want companies to establish goals that can be
measured, SC that we can look back in a year or more and point to concrete
accomplishnients that would not have happened without the New Markets effort.
The session will then breakout into smaller groups that will be asked to come up with at least
five ideas. The small groups will be encouraged to think out of the box. The interagency
working group was also provided beforehand with the attached set of ideas to start people
thinking. A copy of that idea sheet will be provided for each the smaller groups. There is a
White House sta T person helping to facilitate each of the small group sessions.
We will close by bringing the larger group back together and asking for reports from each of
the facilitators ar d comments from the entire group.
Followup
Agencies have already been asked to submit memos by Monday September 20 on ideas for both
locations and themes for the second trip. We expect that some of the ideas from this
brainstorming session will be fleshed out in more detail in these memos.
September 3, 199
MEMORANDUM F DR GENE SPERLING
FROM:
LISA GREEN
SUBJECT: IDEAS FOR THE SECOND NEW MARKETS TRIP
Background
Following our recent onversation, I have done some brainstorming for the next New Markets
trip. This memo outli es several ideas on how we can distinguish the second trip from the first.
The following information includes suggestions from members of the interagency working group
and White House staff. I am also planning a brainstorming session the week of September 13th
to solicit additional id as and to expand upon those summarized below.
Suggestion for an Overall Theme
The New Markets Init ative is an effort to encourage the private sector to invest in underserved
and economically dist essed areas - or what we refer to as New Markets. As part of the first
New Market tour, the President challenged corporate America to invest in poor communities
throughout the nation. The response, which was tremendous, came primarily from financial
institutions banks, insurance companies, and mortgage firms. On this second trip the
President could extend his challenge to various areas of the private sector, with a focus on
specific types of private institutions on each stop of his tour.
The second tour coul focus on the role that different segments of the economy can serve in
stimulating economic growth in New Markets.
Specific Themes
Examples of industrie ; that could be highlighted on legs of the tour include:
The Legal Community: Members of the One America Lawyer's steering committee have
already expres sed an interest in providing support or pro-bono work for investment funds
or small business activity that would result from the New Markets Initiative. The
President could be accompanied by managing partners from some of the major law firms
in the country on one leg of the trip. We could highlight existing programs (such as the
one created lo ally by the DC bar) where attorneys are working with small businesses or
investment fur ds in New Markets.
Private Universities: SBA has suggested that we identify Universities that are providing
technical assis ance to small businesses in low income communities and use them as a
model to encourage such programs across the country. We have also received a letter
from the University of Oregon, where they have such a program, that we could highlight.
On this leg of he trip, the President would be accompanied by University and College
Presidents froi 1 institutions that were making commitments to create or expand such
programs.
Faith Based Institutions: We could highlight successful faith based efforts to encourage
economic development, such as the types of programs developed by Reverend Floyd
Flake in his Queens, NY church which owns and operates several businesses in a
distressed community. The President could be accompanied by religious leaders,
announcing commitments by their institutions to create programs connected to New
Markets. There are also numerous faith-based CDFIs and Credit Unions, focussed on
New Markets, that we could highlight.
Private Foundations and Non Profits: The possibilities here are endless. One exciting
idea, would be to have some of the larger community development intermediaries (i.e.
LISC, Enterprise, Ford Foundation) create a joint program to support Community
Development Venture Capital funds. This type of collaborative program has been done
successfully in the housing/CDC arena with the National Community Development
Initiative.
Private Research Organizations and Think Tanks: There could be a commitment from
research groups to commit to provide data on New Markets. The internal interagency
working group on New Markets research and data is already exploring ways the
government might be able to work with private data companies and think tanks to provide
indicators for investment in low and moderate income communities.
Sports Teams and Organizations: We could build off of the program created by the New
Jersey Nets/New York Yankees that supports youth programs in Newark, NJ. Jeffrey
Rheinsodorf, who participated in the Rainbow/PUSH Conference, and owns the White
Sox/Chicago Bulls is another leader investing in New Markets. His organization has
developed successful supplier/vendor relationships with small minority businesses, which
could be used as a model for other sports team. Both of these organizations could be
asked to challenge other sports teams to invest in New Markets. The President could be
accompanied on this leg of the trip by team owners and athletes, which would no doubt
bring great media attention to the tour.
Pension Funds: We held a very successful meeting last week with ULLICO and the
Building and Construction Trades Department of the AFL-CIO. They are considering
making a major announcement involving their pension funds money and a new
investment vehicle based on the New Markets Initiative model that would target low and
moderate-income communities. They believe their investment would spur others to
action. The President could be accompanied by the heads of major pension funds such as
TIA-CREF, CALPERS (the California State fund) as well as the AFL-CIO.
Retailers: We could have one leg of the trip focussed specifically on retail investment
with major retailers, for example Howard Schultz from Starbucks, accompanying the
President. We could ask the National Retail Federation to take the lead on creating an
event or a program.
Manufacturers: Similarly, we could ask the Manufacturing Association to make a
commitment as an organization to support New Markets. We could seek innovative
programs and investment commitments made by large manufacturers, in particularly the
Big Three could be encouraged to announce a significant commitment to New Markets.
States and Local Governments: At some point we could turn attention to the role of the
public sector, on a local level, in creating an environment that supports private
investment in New Markets. There are several good examples of proposed State
programs that would mirror and certainly complement the New Markets Initiative. The
programs that would be far enough along to announce include a tax credit program in
California (that LISC has been very involved in developing) and a program in North
Carolina that involves numerous incentives to private investors. The President could be
accompanied by Governors and local officials, making announcements about
commitments in their cities and states. We could also invite the heads of the appropriate
associations to join us and could ask for supporting resolutions from the National
Governor's Association and the U.S. Conference of Mayors.
Summary
There are a lot of ideas here and there will probably be additional ideas coming out of our
brainstorming session. I believe it will be easier to plan and strategize for the trip if we
work with themes and then pick locations, events, and participants that are consistent
with the themes.
Time Line
If you agree with this strategy, I would like to set the following deadlines for the second
trip:
Early September
Brainstorming Session
(no later than 9/15)
Written Summaries of Ideas and Proposed Events from Agencies
Late September
Memo on Themes/Proposed Events to Gene Sperling, et. al
(no later than 9/30)
Solicitation of Commitments from Private Companies (this has
already start somewhat, but we should have as many preliminary
commitments as possible by the end of the month)
Early October
Memo to the President outlining Themes and Possible Locations
(no later than 10/15)
Decision on Locations
Late October
Advance Teams on Location
(10/20 - 10/31)
11/3 - 6
Dates on the President's schedule for 2nd New Markets trip
HUD
New Markets
List of High-Possibility Sites as of 9/15/99
Site
Info Provided for First New Markets Tour
Info Received from Field Since September 10
CT. New Haven
New EZ: was designated EC in '95. Omni took over only large downtown hotel; complete rehab using
welfare-to-work trainees has resulted in 85 permanent jobs. HOPE VI awarded approx. '94 now underway:
365 units to come down. NOTE: FBI is investigating a livable cities initiative grant.
FL. Palm Beach
Issue would be dichotomy between haves and have-nots. A number of homeless projects there. (Awaiting
/WPB
detailed info.)
IN. Gary
ACE Hardware.
Field reminds that Sec'y was there in March to announce EZ designation (with 2 neighboring cities).
Consortium of local banks established $50 million pool for Zone. Zone expects 3000 jobs created over 3
years. Also $19.8 HOPE VI award this year. Total HUD dollars 1995-99: $118 million..
MA. Boston
Dudley Square.
New EZ. Field says Dudley Square still a good choice, much to look at. Adjacent neighborhood is Grove
Hall. where EZ investment is making inroads.
MI. Benton
do
be
3
Proposed by field. "Most distressed central city in Michigan." 1998 HUD/Cornerstone Foundation Financial
Harbor
Summit. BEDI grant. $1.5 million 108 loan., significant other HUD involvement. (AZ checking for private
sector involvement.)
MI. Flint
(No project identified.)
City continues to reel from plant closings. New Homeownership Zone will include 309 homes: total $50
million investment of which $2 million from HUD. Mayor has announced Buick City Task Force to
strategize attracting new business. Universities partnering in small business development.
MN. Minneapolis
New EZ. Sears Tower redevelopment for multi-use complex, Phillips Eco-Enterprise Center. EZ was critical
in developing both. More direct HUD role unclear.
NY. Buffalo
Mile-long abandoned rail corridor converted to new parkway; $7m investment included $1 from EZ and $1
from HUD. Buffalo Medical Corridor area includes medical enterprises, businesses; $9.7 million 108 loan
for 100-room hotel. LTV Steel will donate 100-350 acres for multi-year redevelopment to retain/create
5.000-8,000 jobs. Inner Harbor project will encourage recreational, cultural activities and tourism; HUD
recently announced EDI and 108 funding totaling $9.2 million in this year, which will result in 1000 new
jobs. Former GM plant was purchased by American Axle & Manufacturing, creating largest mfg employer in
Buffalo. 300 jobs created; 7 new businesses now located nearby.
NY, New York
Harlem USA: major retail complex in EZ.
200 construction jobs, plus 300 permanent.
Broadway Video: 20 jobs for EZ residents
in high-tech post-production facility.
NY. Rochester
Upper Falls Shopping Center: $3m EZ, $980,000 CDBG, more than $4m in other local and federal funds,
$2.8 m private sector. Anchor tenant is Tops supermarket that gives preference in training and hiring to
neighborhood residents: more than 120 jobs created. August '99 EDI award for $x to German-Simonow for
renovations and upgrades of their facilities. City and HUD have executed one of the first Single Family Asset
Control Agreements in the county.
PA. McKeesport
People's Building Family Support Project:
Various HUD investments
S750k in EC funds developed complex of
30 human service agencies.
TX. Fort Worth
Minyards Grocery: outstanding project
combined public, private investment to
create 165 jobs and attract additional
businesses. First local grocery in over 20
years.
Proposed New Markets Initiative Site: Minneapolis, MN
Minneapolis, MN is a promising site for a Presidential New Markets Initiative event. With
a focus on creating economic opportunities, Minneapolis is an example of large untapped
markets and newly mobilized communities. As of April 1999, over 10 businesses,
including banks, had commitments under the Welfare-to-Work Partnership. Moreover, all
of the welfare reform, economic development, job creation, education, housing, child care
and transportation issues that are prevalent on a national basis are more than evident in
Minneapolis.
The Minneapolis/St.Paul metropolitan area has the single largest urban Indian population
in the United States. The Twin Cities also account for the largest diversity of cultures per
capita for a city of their size. With this large population and great diversity, however,
comes a vast need for appropriate services and opportunities, as well as ample ingenuity
on behalf of the Indian service providers to meet the needs of their clients.
Minneapolis is a thriving center for urban Indian welfare-to-work activities. The Indian
community has been working diligently and effectively on Welfare Reform since 1996.
They have formed partnerships with a large number of Indian and non-Indian businesses
and corporations, in both the public and private sectors. The American Indian Partnership,
a coalition of over 30 organizations and agencies in Hennepin County (including the 6
largest Native non-profit agencies in city), have joined together to facilitate welfare-to-work
from cultural standpoint. This model has been so successful that it is expanding to other
areas of Minnesota, as well as to other states.
The Minneapolis campus of the Native American Educational Service (NAES) Tribal
College has also been quite involved in welfare reform and opening economic
opportunities for Native students. In the past year, NAES has developed a curriculum
about welfare reform and, supported by funding from the W. K. Kellogg Foundation, have
held their first community forum about devolution and welfare reform. These community
forums, including service providers, welfare recipients, students and other members of the
community, will continue in the coming years.
In addition to efforts made in by tribal organizations in Minneapolis itself, the surrounding
region has a wealth of successful tribally-administered programs. The regional, inter-tribal
organization, the Midwest Alliance of Sovereign Tribes, represents tribes from Minnesota,
Michigan, Wisconsin, and lowa and works closely with North Dakota and South Dakota
tribes. Moreover, Minnesota is a long-standing Democratic state, with tribes supporting
and contributing resources to national and local Democratic campaigns, including
President Clinton.
New Market Tour Opportunities
The Welfare to Work Partnership
Site: TBD
Corporate Champion: Citigroup
Theme: Expansion of Wildcat job training program
Summary: Salomon Smith Barney's successful welfare to work effort has
not yet been integrated into Citigroup's overall hiring program. The
company would announce the expansion of their partnership with
Wildcat and the launch of new training programs around the country in
cities like San Antonio.
Site: Newark, NJ (Meadowlands)
Corporate Champion: Mills Corporation
Theme: Permanent, construction and entrepreneurial opportunities for
employment
Summary: Mills hopes to connect their large-scale mall developments
with existing sports centers. As with other developments around the
country, Mills plans to work with the Rockefellar Foundation, the City of
Newark, community organizations and training/employment
intermediaries to develop and implement recruitment, hiring and
retention program.
Site(s): Atlanta, Chicago, and Detroit. (Currently, the program operates
in Boston, through a partnership with Morgan Memorial Goodwill.)
Corporate Champion: TJX Companies
Theme: Inner city investment
Summary: The corporation is also opening a new line of stores, A.J.
Wright in areas where large businesses have left and where the community
is seeking a major business to anchor a store. The A.J. Wright stores will
be established in numerous inner cities in the northeast.
More information to follow on all of the above examples.
Record Type:
Record
To:
Lisa Green/OPD/EOP@EOP
CC:
Subject: From Barbara
Please call Barbara at 410/879-8672 regarding today's New Market meeting.
Forwarded by Barbara B. Hunt/WHO/EOP on 09/16/99 10:17 AM
[email protected]
09/16/99 10:16:22 AM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Barbara B. Hunt/WHO/EOP
CC:
Subject: raynell
The following list are Mayors that IGA has heard from that would like
consideration for the New Market tour.
Mayor Manuel Lopez
Oxnard, CA
County Commissioner Carol Roberts
Palm Beach County, FI
(Glades Rural District)
James B. King, Presidential Fellow
Trinity College
Hartford, CT
Mayor Clarence Anthone
South Bay, FL
Lisa Green
09/15/99 06:50:03 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Jackson T. Dunn/WHO/EOP@EOP, Carl Haacke/OPD/EOP@EOP. Elizabeth J. Potter/OVP@OVP,
Kathleen K. Ahn/WHO/EOP@EOP
CC:
Jonathan A. Kaplan/OPD/EOP@EOP
Subject: Rooms for Tomorrow's Brainstorming Session
Just so you know ahead of time --- the groups will be as follows
Jay - Room 209
Group #1
Julian - Room 231
Group #2
Carl - Room 221
Group #3
Kathleen - Room 231
Group #4
I'm just going to have folks count off 1-2-3-4 to break up into groups. I have a list of who's coming but I
think there may be some no shows because of tomorrow's weather, so I'm hesitant to create pre-assigned
groups.
If we end up with too many people and we need five groups, I will facilitate the fifth group. But I think it will
work best if I'm able to circulate in case there are questions or problems.
Lisa Green
09/15/99 06:41:13 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Elizabeth J. Potter/OVP@OVP, Carl Haacke/OPD/EOP@EOP, Jackson T. Dunn/WHO/EOP@EOP,
Kathleen K. Ahn/WHO/EOP@EOP
CC:
Jonathan A. Kaplan/OPD/EOP@EOP, Melissa G. Green/OPD/EOP@EOP
Subject: Small Groups for Tomorrow's Brainstorming Session on New Markets
brainstormingagenda.dbrainstmemotogene.ddeas for 2nd trip.do
Thank you for agreeing to help facilitate tomorrow's small groups for the Brainstorming Session on New
Markets. Each group will consist of representatives from various agencies, as well as internal White
House Staff. My expectation is that no group will have more than 2 people from the same agency.
Your role will be to
1) Be a timekeeper. Please make sure the small group ends by 11:45, which is the time on the
schedule/agenda. Realistically, you will probably run a little bit over, but please try to have eveyrone back
in the main room -- 231 no later than 12:00.
2) Track all of the ideas. By no means am I asking you to be a notetaker (in fact you may want to ask if
anyone in the group wants to be a recorder). But after the session I would like to know what all the ideas
were that came up (not just the five that get reported back to the larger group), so that I can record them.
One sentence -- verbally after the meeting -- or on paper for each idea is fine.
3) Keep any one person from hogging the floor. Please try to encourage input and participation from
everyone.
4) Collect any paper that is distributed. Some agencies will come prepared with paper on their ideas.
I've heard that a few offices have had their own internal brainstorming sessions. I want to make sure that
we get copies of any written product that folks are willing to share.
5) Encourage thinking out of the box. Please make people feel that all ideas are welcome and that
nothing is too crazy for consideration. This is meant to be a brainstorming session where
anything/everything goes.
Thanks again for agreeing to facilitate the small groups. If you have any other thoughts ideas please let
me know first thing in the morning. Also, don't forget that, in addition to being a facilitator you should
contribute your own ideas.
See you tomorrow, unless of course we are all flooded out by Floyd.
Anne Whitworth
Brasky mit
09/10/99 05:25:48
,
PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Lisa Green/OPD/EOP@EOP
CC:
Subject: Re: New Markets Brainstorming Session - Thursday, September 16
hopefully you meen 10:30 AM to 12:30 PM! I think both Steph and Sara Latham are going to try to make
it.
New mkts
Tyng in labor Welfare - to- Wak
Non- Universities'acommity Colleges.
HBCUS
HS Institutions
VSDA grants to Inst. fn technical
Amarican
assistance fn famers.
USDA - Socus on As.
highlight the
FLORIDA COOPERATIVE - model for Rs.
technical Assist
other pugra
Florida A+M + involvement
tangible
ARAMARK Corp.
neceases in
dollars of
100 - 200 country cooperatives accusthe
income
- approx. 4-5 - Syrs.
directly fied
- direct involvement/help fun USDA.
Excellence -
FRESNO, CA - Nat'l Center for Multi ethic
Corg. Dooley
small funer development.
- Racially direise forms community
- over 100 famer family fame
- B Bil annualy - 250 crops.
- Increase bank in
reglication
- Greatexangle of ways to Save
family fams
- -COLORADO (Dewer ) Rocky Mountain cogquative
20 &
coggerative - 15mil
mustly H spaning - salary above min wage
Sgunts team tabor, SBA.
Newark - as pinging off point fn invilvement
Francluse modement - incurity urban areas.
of sports leaders
≤
Job fans, hiving commitments.
Leaders to chain an effort committee Sleeng/Leadership
Continuing entity -- - permanez.
Universitis/Colleges UNC, UNC,Harvard
Busness schools - academic credit to
I
businesses students consultion community
Group
commitment
Teleem fine in TX - UT Austi Colleges. Austri Comming
Dell Computers
USDA technical assistance programs at
all HBCUs, Tribal, Hispare sining.
Private sector partnerships w/colleges, universities.
SBA - - Pres Econ Denely Done in Phile
Mariliz
Universal Puject companies - Gamble Mr
Urban ag. plan - urban sparant
water 2000
uvban park service /foresty
pwf,
Orban Foresty service
partnership w/Private sector, local gov't
combutting Uvban sprawl - more green, trees.
importance of uvban S foresty.
" millemium grones the planty n in
urban. centers
Treasung - Inguine into investment/pension funds
- Developmental nenture capital project - Appaladia
nd Joct.
meeting private banks fed reserve banks.
commuter & to banks to create 7-10 capital
tanks.
concrete results of 1st tour - expand- -
Appalaclua Regional Comn.
Theosuy - Minnity Bank deposits purs.
surnity, female. low-income. banks
ways to see if fed. funds can be
housed in these instituties.