Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 23
remmedfile 007659 THE INSTITUTE FOR ADVANCED STUDY PRINCETON, NEW JERSEY s RECORDS 1088-a SCHOOL OF HISTORICAL STUDIES May 26,1951 For Dear Dean: Pursuant to our conversation of the day before yester- day I want to add a few thoughts that occur to me in connec- tion with your coming appearance on the Hill. 1) I enclose a copy of a lecture I recently delivered at Princeton University on World War II. I think the pas- sage on pages 12 to 14 dealing with the wartime conferences and the final passage on pages 17 and 18 dealing with the limitations of war as a vehicle for the achievement of democratic objectives may contain thoughts which could possibly be useful to you. 2) With regard to contact between General MacArthur and the Department of State, I think you should know that the reason I was sent to Japan in the spring of 1948 was that the Department of State appeared to have no adequate facilities for getting information (about activities of SCAP and condi- tions in Japan) necessary for proper study of the Japanese peace treaty problem. In particular, we had difficulty finding out what had really been done about the purges and about the decentralization of industry. It looked to us as though a huge percentage of Japanese corporate wealth had been effectively nationalized under the decentralization pro- gram, and we were unable to learn where this matter really stood, how much of this wealth had been redistributed to private owners in Japan, etc. It seemed to us that the pros- pects for future stability and indigenous resistance to commu- nist pressures depended on the answers to questions of this sort, and our channels of communication with SCAP did not seem to be adequate to provide us with such information. I believe that in one of the Policy Planning Staff papers submitted to General Marshall at that time I recom- mended that he grasp the nettle involved in the problem of the State Department's relationships with General MacArthur and see whether we could not have a full-fledged diplomatic representative in Tokyo who would not be a subordinate of the General in his military command, who could report independently to the Department of State, and who could entertain relations with the Japanese Government and the other diplomatic missions in Tokyo in a manner from which the Supreme Commander was