Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 25
MEMORANDUM his THE WHITE HOUSE WASHINGTON February 1970 TO: Staff Secretary FROM: Bryce Harlow At 10: 30 a.m. on February 11, the President met in his Oval Office with Secretary Finch, the Attorney General and the undersigned to consider the school situation in Charlotte, North Carolina, resulting from the District Court desegrega- tion action. The President said that there is nothing to be gained and much to be lost by going along with the courts on this approach to school desegregation. He said that he wants to find a way for the Administration to indicate that we are separating from the majority position of the Supreme Court, stressing that he had spoken out unequivocally on these matters before the 1968 election and before the recent court decisions. The President evidenced extreme perplexity over what to do. He said that he could send the Vice President and the Secretary of Labor to the South "and so on," but he just couldn't believe in doing this. Anything within the law that we can do to "put some daylight" between the court's position and our views "is the right thing to do." The Attorney General said that all that could be done respecting the Charlotte situation would be for HEW to say that the changes ordered by the court go too far in setting up a unitary school system. He suggested that HEW take the position that the actions ordered by the court are not required by law and are contrary to good education. Then the Department of Justice could get into the case in support of the HEW position. The President interjected that HEW needs some credibility in the South, and he urged a statement critical of the Charlotte court action over the signature of Secretary Finch. Secretary Finch said that the Charlotte school board could re- quest a new plan from HEW, and then the board's appeal to the Fourth Circuit could include the HEW recommendations. The President urged that the Finch statement on this issue include the statement: "In any plans, I will not favor anything that requires school children to change schools during a school year; that includes no changes at the end of a semester while the school year is in progress."