Extracted text

OCR Page 1 of 42
DEPARTMENT THE INI THE 174" DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY washington, D.C. SECRETARY OF THE TREASURY December 2, 1998 CLOSE HOLD MEMORANDUM FOR GENE SPERLING DIRECTOR, NATIONAL ECONOMIC COUNCIL FROM: ROBERT E. RUBIN SUBJECT: Meeting on Tax Cut Options An NEC process in coordination with Treasury staff has developed possible new tax cut options for the President's budget. NEC-DPC sub-groups (Treasury, OMB, CEQ, OVP, and various agencies) have been working on priority areas, including health, education and training, children and families, empowerment, R & D, and pensions. This meeting will focus on these new possible proposals and the context for their consideration. Treasury has a number of concerns about many of these proposals, including questions about administrability, marginal effect and social policy judgments. Moreover, as a more general matter, we face serious budgetary and analytic resource constraints. Given what the Administration is almost certainly committed to, there is little room for new proposals, especially if we decide to support a fix to the marriage penalty. In that context, we need to decide which, if any, of the new proposals to work on, bearing in mind that such effort comes at the cost of work on other high priority issues, development of possible raisers, revision of the tax baseline and issuance of regulatory guidance (which is always heavily weighted toward year-end). More generally, there is as always the broader question regarding the extent to which we should focus on simplifying the tax code versus the extent to which we should pursue other social and economic objectives at the expense of making the tax code more complex. In light of the above considerations, we believe that the NEC Principals need to focus on the following questions: Should the budget include marriage penalty relief? Should a share of tobacco receipts, if any, go to offset tax cuts?